What Would Happen If Luffy Was Evil?

[@RCarteras]

Luffy didn't want Chopper because he was a doctor. Actually he didn't even know it untill Chopper was on the ship. He only wanted Chopper because of his cool power with 7 transformations (btw Sanji didn't knew it either, he wanted Chopper as "emergency food"😂)

[@csmileyxd7356]

Technically they would stop at thriller bark so all-in-all a lot of it ify even if it's a what-if

[@RCarteras]

@@csmileyxd7356 sorry, I didn't understand your answer😅

[@okachobe1]

Also chopper would have refused to go with Luffy if asked. Luffy wouldn't have had a choice.

[@csmileyxd7356]

Sorry I will send you a right in this shouldn't be a long what if these cuz consistent things were added to where Luffy would have died for the sake of them getting to a certain part of story

[@Nexusplays123]

Puffy tho probably would still get chopper because nami would tell him about chopper’s abilities and also because chopper is strong

[@alexiroussos8134]

If Luffy was ever evil I don’t think Shanks would rush to take the Straw Hat back from him. Rather he would try his absolute best to set Luffy on the right path again

[@Quiet_fire]

Ya

[@NonVeganMaster]

yaaaaa

[@faridawadh7054]

If luffy was evil Luffy: I hate meat and love vegetables

[@isauldron4337]

Luffy being evil exists it's called blackbeard

[@lordsnowyiv]

@@faridawadh7054nahhhh bro would be unstoppable

[@mynamedontmatter4796]

if sanji saw how he treats nami i dont think he'lljoin the crew while nami would more than likely not join since he would see luffy as just another pirate group

[@nabilonso]

Still tho, Nami would probably see something in Luffy and would semi-wholeheartedly join anyway.

[@yourdad5799]

@@nabilonso That relationship sounds toxic as hell

[@Kirito-cr9ix]

If nami didn't join sanji would

[@user35910]

@@yourdad5799 fr

[@SheezyBites]

@@Kirito-cr9ix Is Usopp didn't join they wouldn't even hear about the Baratie.

[@GAMERYT-anime_brawlstars]

I liked the idea of luffy being evil at the start i was a little sad but the end made me smile again

[@yolkieeggy]

Opposite for me just the end made me tear when said that luffy bonds with his crew

[@psich1c548]

I think you’ve glossed over one major part. Aokiji definitely kills luffy because the only reason he let him live was because he knew he was a good person and that he had helped deal with crocodile which in this story line doesn’t happen. I think this story’s timeline 100% ends at luffy getting smashed by Aokiji. And if somehow you say that they escape or Aokiji let’s them free, Kuma 100% claps luffy and his crew at Thriller Bark.

[@lundoren5240]

Nah he wouldn’t kill garp grandson.

[@justsomekid2678]

garp would kill luffy himself @@lundoren5240

[@MonkeyD.Gerald]

Also i think he forgot to consider ussop's role in thriller bark.The straw hats would have been helpless against persona's powers and with no ussop they just lose there.

[@Sun_God_Sanji]

@@MonkeyD.Gerald but they had haki

[@zombieauthorfrankenstien]

Okay but it was really surprising when he said that Luffy would fight against Shanks for the straw hat... No matter how evil or power-hungry Luffy is, the only reason he holds the straw hat is so that he can give it back to Shanks, right? He might act spoiled saying that he wants to give the hat back himself but probably wouldn't fight his mentor over it...

[@LavaCreeperPeople]

idek whats going on. im used to dragon ball what ifs lol

[@leandromercado6109]

@@LavaCreeperPeople then why are you watching this?

[@soproductions2340]

Yeah, but in this version he basically went crazy

[@RedoxRay123]

I always theorerised that at the end when shanks asks for it back he gives a wide luffy smile and says “no thanks I’ve gotten quite attached to it” something surprising everyone but shanks and he would fight him for it or Davey back fight for it at least which makes sense I mean what if red hair shanks was bald luffys would lose his literal identity as a pirate and even if he gets a new one it would never be the same as the one he’s carried for so long

[@LavaCreeperPeople]

@@leandromercado6109 because the title and thumbnail is interesting

[@Bahamut-ie3tk]

Video idea. What if all of the major characters that are Marines became pirates instead? What do you think their bounties would be if they had the same Devil Fruit and training. And do you think they form their own crew or join someone else's. If they are joining someone else's crew, which crew do you think they would join?

[@claymerpepwheeler7940]

Not sure if it was O'Hara but I know there was a video about what if Akainu was the main character and was a pirate

[@freddybabu5698]

While everyone is making serious videos about new chapter... This guy is making useless videos what if luffy is marine.. What if luffy is female... Dude stop this 💩... Dont be the worst utuber here... Make theories about new chapters buddy..

[@tontenkiller4864]

@@claymerpepwheeler7940 akainu one taps the verse😂

[@tunisino35]

@@tontenkiller4864 akainu doesn’t one tap the verse, of course this is assuming he fights the same enemies as luffy, kaido is stronger than akainu

[@tontenkiller4864]

@@tunisino35 kaido is stronger than akainu 🤓 bro if akainu fought kaido he will turn kaido into his donut collections😂

[@Amir-u5k1z]

You forgot about Perona, since she use a negative fruit, maybe she could defeat whole crew, because at that time there was no Usopp in the team

[@DarkClawEnt]

Random Joe has even less self worth

[@csmileyxd7356]

No you are very correct Perona would have beaten everyone if Usopp Never joined there's no way to get past that literally he knows he's the only one that can fight her

[@DurgaShrestha7]

But luffy could just speedblitze her before she use her ability

[@eggboy178]

@@DurgaShrestha7 yep. Current Luffy is very merciful. The Luffy here would be incredibly harsh in his attacks, not holding back at all.

[@sandyyyyyyyyyyy77]

Due to plot armor they would do something

[@unknowncreature8118]

I love your creativity and overall channel I was searching for what if Luffy then I saw ohara and I'm stuck to ur channel keep it up❤

[@nathankent2631]

“The chilli fruit user has come to take back robin”🤣 great one

[@humanN14]

Very good video but I think that Kaya would still give the boat to the straw hats as he saved her and her village, on top of that in the anime/manga they give the boat to the straw hats BEFORE they even invite Ussop to the team. So I think your only mistake is that he doesn’t have a boat to start with.

[@Perfection-given-form]

I just thought about how scary an evil nika fruit user would be. Because the whole idea is that they “ring the bells of freedom” and no matter what way you look at it if the one who does that has an evil demeanour or intentions would be absolutely terrifying. Because if you say that the evilness is seen as freedom by the people who are freed by nika in the regular series (or feel freed by it) then luffy basically has an army of people who have a warped perception of good and bad and see his evil actions as justice. And if you say that nobody feels freed then that means that freedom is basically erased until someone else eats the fruit. And if the outrageous power of the nika fruit is used for evil then the one piece world would be thrown into absolute shambles until a massive revolution of basically every strong character in the series (especially if that user has more advanced fruit and/or haki usage than luffy) manages to overpower them.

[@SherlockHolmesb-kp4ru]

They won't manage to overpower an evil Nika ,it would simply be the end .If he just takes IMU's place in the empty throne instead .He would be the embodiment of freedom in a way , he's the most free person on the planet whilst taking away the freedoms of all

[@SheezyBites]

Finding Baratie happened because Usopp shot a rock, without him they wouldn't go to Baratie, Sanji wouldn't join and Zolo wouldn't Fight Mihawk; they'd probably have more treasure too, so I think they'd skip straight to Arlong Park navigated by Nami in their stolen ship, and the betrayal would probably be done at sea with Nami making some kind of signal to Arlong... That said, I think the fight would go quite differently because this is a different Luffy, and he doesn't have the same sort of philosophical difference with Kuro, so I think Arlong Park will see Nami betray them and the seamen having an advantage at sea, but the monster trio of Luffy, a fully fit Zoro and Kuro taking them on at the park itself; Kuro probably being able to navigate and is a former butler so should know how to cook pretty well, and I think they end up winning the fight even more resoundingly because Zoro isn't injured and Luffy isn't going to be as enamored by a pinwheel to get his feet stuck in the ground and get thrown in the sea; although Chuu doesn't get a matchup so will probably provide annoying covering fire I don't think it'll make enough of a difference. Without the Baratie side quest they get to Loguetown earlier though, which could mean they miss the lucky meet up with Dragon, but they might still meet up with a super smooth skinned Alvida and could let her join the crew, maybe she can take over the Kitchen duties and is slippy enough they might be able to get away if she joins Luffy's crew instead of Buggy's. In the grand line though we get some fun, Crocus might teach him of Haki but I see no reason he'd teach them how to harness it, but when he drops the log pose Crocus gave him Kuro is there to catch it, and importantly not Vivi's replacement because she's not there yet. They have a 6 in 7 chance of never going to whiskey peak because Crocus' log pose is set to a completely different path; but we assume the 1/7 because elsewise we're at an absolute impasse with no idea how the story could possibly go from here on out. Here Zoro defeats 100 bounty hunters, but Luffy probably doesn't fight him because the people there were weak, and so they travel on to the next island without hearing about Alabasta or anything going on with Baroque Works. Vivi doesn't get them to take her to Whiskey Peak, but does probably get there herself with her plan to meet up with Igaram, but, umm... he dead. Vivi gets caught by Mr. 5 and Miss Valentine, and project Utopia goes on to be a roaring success until the point where Robin either dies lying about whats on the Ponyglyph or (more likely in this scenario with a full plan going perfectly thanks to Mr 3 and Miss Golden Week's involvement and of course no destruction of Rainbase (and Smoker, Tashigi and Hina being nowhere near because Mister 3 never gets sent to take out the people who know Crocodile's secret) has to give up the information that Pluton is on Wano and Crocodile just took the throne of a country without the weapon, which is probably going to end real bad for him. But that's not the Strawhat's journey, because that ends up in this admittedly 1 in 7 chance with them landing on Little Garden and having to stay there for a year, but thankfully we have a strength focused Luffy here, as well as Zoro, Kuro and Alvida of course who can hunt dinosaurs pretty well to keep them alive for the whole year they have to stay there for the log to set where they get to make friends with two powerful giants who know Haki, a thing Luffy wants to learn and knows the concept of, and thankfully they love fighting which Luffy also loves. This is the year long training arc, where Luffy, Zoro, Kuro and Alvida learn how to use Haki, but from this point on the world is so radically changed, Wapol took back over Drum Kingdom and never discovered Wapometal, there was a war with Crocodile that went down, Robin was likely captured and executed, Deathpeia happened and the island of Skypeia fell to the blue sea, Enel's Vassals weren't defeated and went to the moon (where they might have suffocated, who knows the physics of the moon in one piece?), CP-9 probably eventually found the blueprints for Pluton, The Supernovas didn't fight the Pacifistas, Moria made his zombie army and might have even gotten an even better shadow at Marineford to put into Oars, Jinbei and Boa weren't warlords anymore and probably both got killed, Blackbeard was probably killed or captured by Magellan who wouldn't have a second escape to worry about... the world would be radically different, and honestly a lot more chaotic. And in the middle of the real world One Piece time skip the alt Strawhats now knowing Haki and being way stronger and full of dinosaur meat... Or possibly they're dead of the five day disease... Alvida is probably too slippery to get bit, but Zoro does like going shirtless when training, and Luffy's legs are always exposed so they are both highly susceptible to getting it... At least if they die of 5-day disease we know how their journey goes.

[@lilyfields3748]

People are really bored…

[@akxay]

Am I forgetting something? Cuz I thought Luffy and Zoro both said before that they literally don’t get sick. Ever. Didn’t Zoro eat poisoned food and still came back fine

[@lilyfields3748]

@@akxay that’s what I was thinking-

[@SheezyBites]

@@akxay They said they never got sick in a joke scene, that does not mean they can't, until we meet doc. Q in a serious confrontation we won't know. Both have been shown as vulnerable to poisons with Zoro's fear of Nola's bite and obviously Magellan and mental health disorders against Perona so how they would react to a serious disease is yet unknown. That said I did write the one year time skip first and then wrote a possible alternative to the year time skip, so kinda weird to bring it up like it's the crux of an argument.

[@akxay]

@@SheezyBites I……brought it up cuz thats the part I had a question about? I didn’t know I had to find the main idea of your fanfic and write you a synopsis.

[@Dans..channel]

17:58 I like to think Luffy in this situation would have a emotional break down and say something like "you told me I was too weak to join you so I became stronger and became I great I got more powerful so why am I not suited to wear the strawhat"

[@billcutting2681]

Realistically even if he was evil he's able to recruit all of the straw hats there's certainly a bit of willpower in a captain let alone a conqueror asking you to join their crew seems more like an order than a request and it takes will to say no none of them have that will especially Chopper especially early Chopper Frankie would be the closest to saying no but ultimately still has to leave so he has to go with them so does Robin and so does Brooke

[@unknowncreature8118]

For writing so much and explaining it therie I give h a like

[@FrarmerFrank]

Everyone feels indebted to Luffy for saving them,their love ones,town,country,Kingdom........and Luffy's Conquors plays a role in presuation

[@zero1188]

Most straw hats werent good guys when luffy met them. Wouldnt be hard to recruit them. Luffy changed them to be good

[@someoneelse3456]

Zoro is a conqueror too. But he would join anyway since aligned goals

[@billcutting2681]

I'm happy to see you all have great reading comprehension too. One piece is awesome

[@roro803r]

I love these what if videos. Always fun to watch while waiting on new chapter to come out.

[@Datduuudeee]

Chaps out

[@powaaEDITS]

There will still be Going Merry because the usopp island gave luffy the ship for helping them defeat butler man and saving the island and Usopp didnt even know he was invited so yeah. DingDong Head. XD

[@elpeacecarter]

I like this version of a story. We need more Stories where the main character is not a Saint and kind hearted. Something like Code Geass or death Note.

[@csmileyxd7356]

Yeah but it's very flawed especially at thriller bark

[@arandomguy1226]

Luffy is no weaker to swords than an average person right?

[@niteeshj1097]

yes finally someone understands.

[@monkeyluffy4521]

yah people mostly misunderstand luffy not being resistance against sword for a weakness, but the fact is everyone with out haki is weak to a sword slash except bigmom and kaido, like if u use the same sword attack on luffy zoro and shanks all of them are gonna be affected equally , and if haki used it depends on whose haki is stronger

[@dogs_r_cool]

It is a weakness tho, when he stretches he has more area on his body so he’s more vulnerable to sword attacks as they can slash him with more ease because he has larger area on his body

[@niteeshj1097]

@@dogs_r_cool so are you saying you are resistant to it?

[@just_a_funni_guy3085]

No he is not,but while he can tank normal blows easily,he can't tank swords,but like,he does not take more damage to swords.

[@default.editzs]

You forgot at fishman island, Usopp was the reason that Chew was not there to help Arlong. You also forgot about Perona probably overpowering the whole crew since there is no Usopp there.

[@lemonl0re588]

No one: Evil luffy: I hate meat

[@intellectualuser7856]

Keep this up with this kind of content its entertaining and cool

[@reversalpurple]

Shanks will finally be able to kill him without feeling bad

[@reversalpurple]

Ehhhh it didn't happen

[@frelixr]

Hey Ohara, I rlly love ur vids and ur content. They honestly make my day. Keep it up 😁

[@jakehutson6158]

6:59. YOU DO NOT KILL CLOWN. CLOWN KILLS YOU!!!

[@RayAkuma]

Depends on when he starts to be evil. If we go waaaay back to small kid Luffy before meeting ace or sabo he'd probably join with those riff raff pirates, Betraying Ace and Sabo which would make one piece extremely different. In so many ways in fact the story would probably barely be recognizable.

[@lundoren5240]

Just cause he evil doesn’t mean he doesn’t have honor look at current kaido. Kaido cares for his named crew members and wants honor in his fights.

[@ik_0251]

I just love how many times this man has changed the thumbnail

[@jamestitus472]

I feel like if he's the same guy, but power hungry, that doesn't make him a total idiot. I don't see him taking on Rayleigh, or being so obstinate. He can just protest that Shenks told him to become strong, which is what he's been doing. I still think there's a version of these events where Luffy gets to Amazom Lily, into Impel Down, etc. Boa and even ID prisoners onto the crew.

[@lundoren5240]

Yea the story shouldn’t be that different. Luffy just doesn’t care about innocent people as much and kills those who go against him. But he’d still be honorable and fight for his crew. And he still has the same dream as Roger.

[@Aaroncito]

3:39 NAH! They got zoro 😂

[@JohnDMoni]

This evil Luffy arc could turn into a redemption story of someone who was misguided, like Blackbeard. Instead of Red Hair Shank defeat him it would be Luffy. Losing everything to Luffy, Blackbeard might learn the error of his way to go back and make amends for what he did.

[@Coda3010]

Im the first one to comment since 2 days ago lol also nice vid (tbh all of your videos are good)

[@stephencox8723]

garp would have put an end to luffy's evil shenanigans with the swiftness. remember how he pulled up on luffy at water 7? dragon gets a pass because garp hates celestial dragons as much as his son so the enemy of his enemy is technically his friend. (idk how garp can hate celestial dragons like that and then have a son named dragon wtf kinda bs is that? i see why dragon started a revolution he almost had a duty to rectify his namesake)

[@bahmot9501]

I gotta say you're probably the best One Piece What-If'er out there ... granted that's on the account of there being relatively few but you're still the best out of the ones that do exist !

[@bqw2094]

Aw man , why did you change the thumbnail, it was so beautiful. Well i would love a story about a dark luffy , that turns on his crew , and the strawhats have to fight to get their captain back , but by the time they get him back he is a drastically changed person , probably no longer wants to be the king of the pirates . Somebody please make a fanfic of this

[@djperezestrella]

Dude, this is amazing! Oda should really do a movie "brightburn" style!!!!

[@chrisgrad9004]

Thank God evil Luffy had a redemption arc 😂 or else I would feel so depressed.

[@Diggelana]

LOVE YOUR VIDEOS!!

[@Noname-md6lc]

If luffy was a bad guy then I would be watching the whole series again.

[@aziolp]

Yeah same

[@-SCRATXH-]

Yea what if he hade a throne and an eyepatch and metal arm and tortured everyone after he conquered everything while laughing

[@royal8286]

Das beste Video zu diesem Format bis jetzt :)

[@b0llzacx660]

Luffy would not be able to do all this with the nika fruit because the will of the fruit will ultimately oppose his actions and zoans are said to have a stronger will of their own

[@johnnypollack3243]

Love the video and keep up the great work ohara

[@Zoro_king_of_lost]

Fun fact luffy actually don’t have weakness and sword are everyone weakness and luffy with nika fruit can make water rubber

[@zard5930]

Shanks for watching... That one did mental damage. Good work!

[@nthntochere]

I know it would require a incredibly huge amount of work but just as an idea (maybe for a special or something like it) I think this series would be really fitting for an interactive video, where the viewer is able to decide which way the scenario goes on since there are a lot of different outcomes of them. Just as an idea.

[@samuraitadpole5459]

That's definitely a crap ton of work

[@paulallred2340]

I have a really good idea for the end, maybe a option 4? This is how it would play out. This is like option 3 but instead of just joining straight away he starts screaming at shanks saying its his fault for luffy being this way because at the start shanks told luffy he wasnt strong enough to join his crew which he starts using conquerers haki again but this time slowly becomes more weaker as he mumbles the name ace over and over again until he collapses and starts crying. Shanks takes pity out of this as rescues luffy anway and lets him join the crew which when he changes he throws the straw hat to him.

[@Nr4747]

Interesting video. The one fatal flaw with your theory, imho, is this one: How would Luffy know that Crocus was part of Roger's crew and that Crocus knows Haki after just having reached Reverse Mountain ? How would Luffy even know what Haki is at that point ?

[@okachobe1]

And then him and his crew suddenly know armament and observation haki? This story was jank

[@TheVeryFirstYapper]

Well, he could have asked "how do I defeat a guy with pure Smoke powers?" Crocos is old, therefore he could have some experience and maybe he would have Luffy said something like "with Haki" , something that could interest Luffy and demands crocos to teach him that.

[@Nr4747]

@@TheVeryFirstYapper True, but that's unlike Luffy. He usually doesn't seek out mentorship on his own.

[@FrogPancake]

Plot twist, random Joe is Gol. D. Roger reincarnated, helping the next pirate king on his journey.

[@genens8490]

What the hell do you mean "No Usopp No Merry" They get the ship for saving the town from the pirates not for inviting Usopp to the crew???

[@star-rock6466]

I mean, true, I think he forgot about that. But tbh, the merry would have probably been destroyed at skipea without usopp

[@niteeshj1097]

kaya only gave the ship because of usopp.

[@DoIT4Me]

6:10 I would’ve preferred this scenario Luffy gives Nami a choice : 1- if she joins him then he will leave the village in peace and forgive her 2- if she refuses to join him he will destroy the village and kill everyone including her That would really make luffy evil and would cause a rift between Sanji and Luffy which will result in a fight between them ending with Luffy or Zoro killing Sanji Crocodile would never work under anyone, he prefers to be in charge so I think that he will get killed by Luffy for refusing to join his crew

[@jessehansley7145]

Jesus loves ya

[@princesammigkandit5888]

Bro nice video you are actually one of the most underrated one oiece youtubers 🗿🍷

[@snowyvr3728]

One of the best ones yet

[@kennethtumines2447]

"What if Luffy has same attitude as Kidd" there fixed it 😂

[@monkey_d_shakeel]

Best Ohara thumbnail l have ever seen

[@Originalskiff]

I had a feeling that the original thumbnail for the video wouldn't be popular with the algorithm. Love your content bro

[@jamestitus472]

He'd still take Chopper. Luffy didn't know Chopper was a doctor when he invited him onto the crew. He just thought Chopper was cool and interesting. Same would happen here, obviously.

[@linkin420]

Did Ohara just put Dr.Simi asa representation of a random doctor, now that is hilarious lol

[@sirog7116]

Ohara totally forgot he added Crocodile to the crew.

[@_.Roberto00]

Not u adding Dr.Simi as the crew's doctor 💀goated

[@vyomcodm2052]

Bro please make a video on chapter 1081

[@krealyesitisbeta5642]

Wapol: "There ARE NO OTHER DOCTORS." Random Joe: "Alright square up-"

[@lilchubb4919]

Hey random joe shmoe keep up the good work

[@yous9143]

Barbe noire luffy un des combats que j'attends le plus

[@Bruh89847]

20:43 And Crocodile

[@Dylan-Frost]

I feel like things would've gone awry as early as Alabasta. There's no Usopp or Chopper to take out Mr 4's pair, and no Usopp to make Nami her climate baton, so she doesn't have a very good fighting chance, either. (In case this was already mentioned in the video I didn't watch the whole thing because I'm still in Skypiea)

[@captainrex6669]

Video idea: what if the straw hats went to go see luffy after the battle at marineford???

[@K_dawgerr]

Here is one thing I think you missed is Garp, he would not stand by as Luffy fights shanks especially after he just lost ace

[@canna5251]

This can basically be Rocks pirates story on how they were formed lmao this is so good

[@MonkeyD_Joel]

yo all the blue lock clips are fire

[@kikolizo]

Dr. Simi went from being thrown in concerts to be in Luffy's crew. Daaaaaaaamn

[@Blackmanyt04]

So far you’ve given one of the best, purely objective opinions about this debate that I’ve ever seen. I do feel like the fan base slanders Mihawk heavily.

[@sunaraasis7024]

Lesssgo ohara 1 M sooon ❤️

[@l7aj_galliard]

1- In fact, the main reason why Luffy is kind and does not kill his enemies it is because Shanks sacrificed his arm to save him from the sea monster. If he hadn't done that, Luffy would have been evil and perhaps more evil than what you described in the video. 2- Perhaps if Luffy was evil, He wouldn't have left that island empty-handed, he might force him to join the crew, but also he would enslave him as Alvida did with Koby. It is also undeniable how important the role Usopp played in helping the crew, even if it was weak, but his luck and skills in maintenance and design of things benefited the crew through his whole journey.

[@-SCRATXH-]

Then everyone would steal his eye n arm and he’d destroy everything and have an eyepatch and metal arm and laugh in his throne as everyone suffers and have red hair n black eyebrows

[@perayeshbasnet]

Very nice video it was fun to watch

[@vailingbow1068]

Nah, I thin they'd still get the Merry. Kaya didn't give the Merry cause of Usopp, she gave it as thanks. Also, I don't think Robin would join because when Crocodile betrayed her, she gave up. But Luffy gave back her will to live. She decided to go with Luffy because he was different. Her seeing Luffy as anyone else wouldn't make her want to live any longer than she already did at the end with Crocodile. But if Luffy defeats her before her will is shattered, then I guess she would join. I also don't see Robin sacrificing herself for the crew if she views them as a means to an end. Unless Luffy's actions of protecting her from Aokiji moved her enough. Also, I don't see Franky joining as he saw that Luffy wasn't just some pirate wanting to pillage, much less make a ship for them. Although mostly I agree things wouldn't change too much until Sabaody, but I think there's also an argument to be made that Luffy's loss to Rayleigh could set him straight if his loss was big enough. But I agree ultimately, Luffy will buckle at either Rayleigh or Shanks' strength and start reforming his bonds with his crew as they were going to from the beginning.

[@ElectroLugia]

Omg best one on the crew random Joe

[@branislavristic6559]

The thumbnail is top tier🥶

[@mashal4826]

These if scenarios videos are currently my fav series from you

[@elemomnialpha]

Ohara not removing Ussop from a What if Challenge: Impossible

[@vatsalgondrala5402]

The thumbnail is so good

[@abbyjo75]

Well done, Manu. Well done, indeed. I was thoroughly engaged, engulfed in the story lines, and entertained.

[@chiaoutzu7732]

Luffys breakdown in front of shanks at marineford would have been something mighty powerful

[@luffytby9679]

I love your vids :)

[@AverageGodzillaEnjoyer69]

Luffy with kaidos devil fruit and suit looks fire

[@MrEazye7]

Would really like to see a evil luffy that still awakens god mode and just destroys everyone on marine island

[@levraisaturo]

J'aime le concept maïs je crois que l'introduction du haki est trop tôt et sans oublier ça prend du temps pour l'éveil et pouvoir l'utiliser

[@gnome5057]

crocodile being recruited by evil Luffy then never mentioned again is just so funny

[@johnyd.productions]

I love the thumbnail already. Please don't change it.🙏

[@jaedon7649]

i wonder y u do…

[@johnyd.productions]

@@jaedon7649 is that sarcasm?

[@bqw2094]

Ohara should not have changed it , that was a beautiful thumbnail

[@NatsuIsAQT]

Dude you should do a vid on "what if luffy had awakened his form from the start of his story" ,and its like when luffy ate his fruit shanks didn't lie abt his devil fruit and told him what it actually was

[@eliaspanayi3465]

I bet luffy would make the other members of the crew learn to fight so its not just the monster trio. Also he would likely learn the gears and learn to awaken his devil fruit much earlier since in the Canon of the manga it was Because he realised he needs to protect his friends but in this scenario he had desired to get stronger from the beginning

[@lavignebui906]

wow, Luffy sure did get alot of LOVE after this video

[@teemupuumalainen3051]

If they would have stopped at Crocus resort to learn haki, it would have taken at least months for them to learn basics if not more. During this time Crocodile would have succeeded in coup and Straw hats wouldn't have helped Vivi and met Crocodile or Nico. Also Crocus would have probably healed Vivi so they didn't have point to go too deep in Drum island. If they popped at the shore they would have just killed those who denied their access. Also what would have happened in Little Garden? Would Luffy have befriended them both alone without Ussop and them helping Straw hat with Island Eater? Not likely.

[@RyeArts]

I love these guidelines

[@Lugge1999]

"Pirates are criminals who threaten the peace of our world. Absolute Justice must be upheld, and those who defy the law will face the full force of the Marines. Luffy is no exception." - ChatGPT version of Akainu

[@Da_Bludster]

bros videos are my random one piece thoughts at night.

[@mertbilge1412]

4:21 GOD USOPP WHY???

[@medoahmed6229]

Love your content

[@erozionzeall6371]

That thumbnail is wild.

[@randomclips1232]

Actually Usopp did actually still become a real pirate, if you notice closely, he says he will set off to a ship alone to become a real pirate (he says that to his crew or shall i say wannabe crew of kids) but then Luffy invited Usopp to his crew so Usopp either way would still become a real pirate

[@Jacfar242]

I love ur what ifs