One of KPOP's 4th Gen Best Singers | Waleska & Efra React to aespa NINGNING in Begin Again - Toxic

[@makeitright3810]

She has such a wide range. Her voice can adapt to so many songs, I can’t wait for when she gets longer into her career and starts doing solo music.

[@zayn659]

They all look kinda same

[@mobblemaggotgutter]

She's literally the main vocalist of 4th gen. Our best baby

[@LG-er6rh]

She is the best 4th gen main vocalist indeed

[@Jeusyao_Seon]

Ningning is the best vocalist of the 4th gen in my heart.❤❤❤Thanks for your reaction💓

[@wntrbll]

imo, NINGNING voice is so fit with RnB

[@dbskmidoyo]

I think you'd love her singing "Melody". Still replaying that one over and over.

[@WiwiwiyyyY]

Up

[@DA_Ald]

Imagine at the end year stages lily Haewon Ningning and winter would have a collab (they are the top 4 vocalist in the 4gen)

[@uc6758]

This reminds me of that stage Stand Up for Love with Taeyeon, Sunye, and Davichi

[@blink_____jenniequeen6670]

I love her vocal tone and the way she controls her voice 🧡

[@danissegomez7953]

She is the best 4th gen vocal undeniably❤❤❤

[@sabiaakthar1613]

Her stage on the stage a chinese show is amazing

[@blackbottle_]

i love begin again ningning! she's just amazing, idk if you guys will react to her other performance on other shows and her duet with jay park..ugh that was fire

[@Core_delarosav]

NingNing es increíble ♥

[@inadraodwikaaudry916]

Main vocal of 4th gen ❤

[@saoirseblack6173]

I personally love her voice a lot! ❤

[@kashmeramallick612]

First 🥇 I am watching your reaction since a long time thankyou for your beautiful reactions love you both from India ❤

[@luoranmei8839]

i am waiting here for d.o.'s new album reaction ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ

[@andreamarie685]

Please react to Ningning's Always Remember Us This Way on the same program.

[@Sumin-ss8lv]

Yeeessss!!! Also I don't know if you guys already checked it out but it'd be great if guys checked the ones of Woodz. Those are some of my favorites performances of his

[@renavemsoriano2884]

Pls react to ningning and jay park (WYA)

[@gaon1709]

pls react to ningning singing melody

[@subilynnoweight2090]

I think Ningning and D.o have the same vocal coach 💯

[@tnlkb6115]

No it Winter and D.o

[@L....F]

​@@tnlkb6115 Are Ningning and Winter different teachers? Do the other girls also have different teachers?

[@tnlkb6115]

@@L....F most vocalists in the same group from sm doesnt have the same vocal coach. I don't know who it was for Ningning, but i know for sure it wasn't Yoo Young Jin. He know for barely taking students. He has been with the compagny since it creation and yet, only 3 sm idols have been know to have learned singing under him. And those 3 are Max Changmin, D.O and Winter.

[@L....F]

@@tnlkb6115 thank you for clearing my doubts

[@ccz2852]

im wondering if you guys watched the nmixx episode with lily and sullyoon since u guys mentioned loving this show..i just recommend it so much. i believe they did like 3 or 4 iconicc songs but i think adele's set fire to the rain was my favorite if u wanna watch just one.

[@ashh5075]

Thankyou for react,another cover of ningning please🙌🏼❤️

[@ShahFred]

one of the best?????? SHE IS THE BEST

[@renavemsoriano2884]

Plss react to jay park and ningning performance

[@ashh5075]

Please🙌🏼

[@朱陈呈]

Ningning❤

[@EXOL_Paris]

Please watch D.O contents!! He’s promoting a lot now for his album!!

[@guestbone03manurunge]

AESPA SAVAGE PLEASE

[@sugaspice05]

Not really related to the video, but could you guys react to V Tiny Desk Korea please?? It's right up your alley i think you'll LOVE it!!!

[@SVT_GODS_MASTERPIECE]

💛💛💛

[@trishoyo]

You need to react to ningning on lee mujin service YOU WILL LOVE IT

[@7withU]

:) I hope you both consider reacting to woodz. you can start with the live clips of drowning and ready to fight (these are the songs on the album he released this year)

[@moraeine]

Ningning Best❤❤❤

[@basilisk069]

less than 2 mins in and efra says "britney gone mental" this guy lmfaoooo

[@ybhcch]

这视频应该传到BILIBILI啊，宁宁是中国人，很多中国人喜欢她

[@fernandanahuelhual7799]

d.o and akmu rewrite the stars cover pls react to it

[@renavemsoriano2884]

Please react to ningning always remember me cover please do a rwaction

[@remembertosmile1582]

Please react to laut aa mere des by Shreya Ghoshal from bhoomi 2022❤

[@carmelalubiano]

Chat😅 na😢8i 0:34 😢🎉🏩🗾🗾

[@carmelalubiano]

8tj8 0:33 😮 0:33 🗾 0:🗾

[@carmelalubiano]

😢v8 0:32 🎉🗾🗾🏙 0:36 🌽🗾🗾🧀🥐🐩🐩

[@carmelalubiano]

😂zjj😮 0:32 😮 0:34 0:34 😮😮🏈😅

[@carmelalubiano]

J😮8j

[@jugalkishurdeka3895]

1

[@neowaffle]

Are they really reacting to NingNing? 😶‍🌫️