One Piece Islands | LIVE!

Don't let the tier list fool you, we're not ranking One Piece islands based on what's "best" we're picking where we want to live, where we want to vacation, where we'll only visit once, and the islands we're going to pass on. We're deciding this together so be ready to give your reasons why!

[@couldntcareless7884]

Merphy about Drum island: pass, they barely have a doctor. Also Merphy: home on Little Garden.

[@cptKamina]

I really love Merphy in this fan community. By far the best and most insightful person to talk about this great story!

[@arenkai]

Merph: We all decide together, and it's after the dictators are gone so it's cool :D Also Merph: Y'all are crazy, I'm the dictator now.

[@in-craig-ible6160]

Glad to see Merphy embracing the "Geography is Everything!" mantra.

[@AuthorTrentonNezzy]

“Yay for freedom, but it’s also kind of boring now” lol amazing

[@Osamalrahamneh]

That was fun

[@Chatedh]

am so very sad Kamabakka Queendom wasn't an option

[@bravingbrivatebrian]

Hee haw!!

[@bravingbrivatebrian]

​@@Omegateck16 you dont have to go through impel down

[@Zerigala1028]

​@@Omegateck16Kamabakka is Ivankov's island, where Sanji got sent, and the Revolutionary Army's homebase.

[@Chatedh]

@@Omegateck16 You are thinking of level 5.5 New Kamma land. A different place

[@Chatedh]

@@bravingbrivatebrian HEE HAWW!!!

[@Zerigala1028]

59:06 for Pen Island

[@curtishammer748]

Statistically, only about half of us would be interested in Pen Island. The other half would give it a... Hard pass

[@camelkingclarith]

thank you so much for your insight

[@ratiuvictor9533]

The best island is Fishman Island. Is the only on that will still be around in a couple of years

[@peanutbutter447]

Loguetown and Whisky Peak should have been on the tier list.

[@curtishammer748]

Lougetown would be visit once, just to see the platform. Whiskey Peak would be pass.

[@LiorTamir]

Whole cake island... You underestimate people's love for sugar. And chocolate! CHOCOLATE!!!!

[@rf7182]

Diabetes

[@notrixamoris3318]

I love jurassic park so little garden also culinary island look amazing too...

[@sabrinasspellbookspens5136]

Home: Zou (Talking animals, mysterious giant elephant, and the locals would literally die before handing you to the enemy.) Vacation: Little Garden(pack bug repellent), Water 7 (island boat), Fish-Man Island (Hi Jinbe), Whole Cake Island (they've got food other than sweets too), Elbef (my almost home) Visit Once: Ohara (I'm running as soon as the warships come), Drum Island (I've always wanted to visit Canada once), Jaya (why not, there's treasure in the sea around it that you can dive for), Skypiea(someone hold me on the way up), Sabaody Archipelago (to have a drink with Rayleigh), Dressrosa (They're still cleaning up but at least the fighters in the colosseum are volunteers now instead of prisoners), Wano (the borders are still technically closed...so gotta sneak), Egghead (I'll probably get bored quick though) Pass: Island of Strange Animals (boring), Long Ring Long Land (boring), Arabasta (I can't with the desert.), Impel Down (I'd rather go to Enies Lobby), Amazon Lily (They're great warriors, but they're a bit arrogant), Thriller Bark (absolutely not), Punk Hazard, Moon (space is terrifying)

[@thedizzytuna]

Dressrosa is Spain with a roman colliseum its gorgeous and cyktured and has great food and people its definitely at minimum a vacation spot

[@camronk1356]

I would have home for water 7 so I can meet jaden Yuki ❤️

[@misskulik5877]

Whole cake is most delicious island love it😊❤

[@atjatkatkaktark]

I mean presuming its post strawhat visit my 1st choice would be Dressrosa, its full of beautiful passionate women and with the restoration of King Riku a ruler so beloved his entire nation gave their life savings without needing an explanation. The only other Kingdom's we've seen left with rulers anywhere near as caring are a desert, an ice cube and Wano which would be my second choice losing points for still presumably being quite heavily polluted.

[@cjsdizzy]

Wish I caught this live but it made opening at work today so so much better. Love ya merph🤘

[@NataliaRivera-s8u]

That was my first livestream and it was a blast! Thanks so much for the fun vibes! Also Impel Down and Kammabakka Kingdom were robbed

[@MegaSherlockian]

Skypeia. The exchange rate is off the chain. A piece of rubber band will get me a mansion up there.

[@aidanklobuchar1798]

I'd love to visit Zou, but as someone with animal fur allergies, it'd actually be horrible. Water 7 is like the one functional democracy we've seen in One Piece, so even despite the Aqua Laguna, probably the safest home base.

[@thedizzytuna]

This is my very wild called shot take mixed with a personal theory but long ring long land has to be a visit once because im convinced the entrance to laughtale lies in the center of that island during aqua lagoona

[@niikolo_x]

We need a photoshop of Merphy riding a Dinosaur, lets make it happen.

[@aziz.s3]

I like you so much Merphy and you always deliver top notch content. This livestream wasn’t your best unfortunately 😅

[@brian102024]

I'd probably vacation on zou for some garchu #NotAFurry

[@ffbear8078]

Men can't visit Amazon Lily... Luffy and Rayleigh: Allow us to introduce ourselves

[@onbedoeldekut1515]

Do you think the red line could previously have been in a sort of close stationary orbit around the planet, like Saturn's rings but just above the planet instead of in orbit, and whole. Maybe something happened which caused it to fall down, out of alignment with the natural magnetic field, with its mass causing waters everywhere to rise, like Archimedes' crown but on a much larger scale? I always thought Long Ring Long Land was a sneaky nod to Archimedes, and that it had some correlating underlying factor in things.

[@rf7182]

Water 7 home? What if my smartphone drop to the river.....??? Aahhhh

[@seretseandrews5980]

Thriller bark is a island turned in to a ship

[@ratiuvictor9533]

No Marineford. It's so clean and fun.

[@curtishammer748]

Just sayin... Disease-carrying ticks

[@dimitrisgial7804]

59:52 Fun fact: this senntnce has two meanings.

[@TerminusTartaros]

For me Wano would be home. A safe country because WG can't easily go up there. But mostly because there is onsen! And we could maybe uncover pluton and blow up some islands. Sabaody would be a visit once. We could buy some mermaids for you Merphy. Dressrosa and Egghead is vacation.

[@sethuh31]

I’m all for living in elbaf tbh as long as they don’t have giant insects

[@snagglesnorf]

Ah yes right let‘s set up a vacation in a jungle island with a bunch of dinosaurs and diseases and no civilization and not in a cool place like whole cake island or egghead. C‘mooooon maaaaan……. I mean how would we even spend vacation there without any houses there? Anyway I wasn‘t there but this was a great stream watched it all the way through this was a fun time!

[@thedizzytuna]

I would likely pass but i could definitely see a strong argument for taking Morleys tunnel and visiting level 4.5 once for a hella fire LGBT party night

[@gntyh]

how did little garden make it to Vacation

[@connorc948]

Saboady has an amusement park and Fishman Island is prophesied to be destroyed. Plus the people who live in Fishman Island dream of living in Saboady to the point of risking enslavement just to go to the surface to view it.

[@emeldy2687]

If you're visiting Fishman Island at all, then you'd have to pass through saboady anyways.

[@adamm6290]

Only 2 minutes into the video but now the Puerto Rico has been mentioned I need to know where it goes on the Island Tier List

[@adamm6290]

I am now 4 minutes in and she does confirm she would put it in the vacation tier lol

[@adamm6290]

I am now 10 minutes in, Merphy how were you going to pass on an island for not having a lot of doctors and then immediately declare that the island with 0 doctors where nami got a disease that almost killed her would be your home?

[@adamm6290]

I’m 21 minutes in now shoutout to the guy who said he wanted to smash water 7

[@camelkingclarith]

I just want to marry Kiku

[@jannecapelle_art]

why would i choose to live on a prehistoric islands with animals that will kill me or a weird little city on the back of an elephant that FLOODS regularly, a desert or underwater when i could literally live in a cooler version of venice with world-class infrastructure (HORSE FISH THAT CARRY YOU AROUND, a whole ass sea-train that can quickly get me to other islands) a booming economy, jobs and a nice, temperate climate!!!! the way theyre going on over there, they might have high-speed internet soon!!! and yeah theres a yearly aqua laguna however, soon itll be a floating island anyway and also they have a very solid evacuation protocol there, its fine!!

[@leodogg468]

What if bottom tier is can’t go to this island disease

[@Moody.Smiruai]

Alabasta is vacation easy , water 7 is probably very smelly. All the trash , wrekage and sea. Whole cake aint bad. Zou is good home contender. So is fishman Island.

[@Chatedh]

@@Moody.Smiruai to be fair, all of these places would somewhat stink of the sea xD

[@Astro2024]

​@@Chatedh Dressrosa is pretty elevated. That's my top 1. Oh, and Skypeia

[@lazylonewolf]

Is Laboon an island

[@rcookie5128]

10:06 DIE OR DIE(?)NO(!)

[@Omegateck16]

Im not gona lie im suprised about Saboady. Yes it has slavery, but I'm a normal human so i wont get sold off, Ill stay away from Groove 1 and just shop around in my bubble car and have fun in the amusement park away from it. Am I crazy?

[@Zerigala1028]

Yes, if you know slavery is legal there LMAO

[@platonismisoop2152]

My guy if you aren’t killed by the myriad of pirates, slavers, and other assorted criminals that call Sabaody their home, you're probably getting shot to death by a world noble because just for being in the wrong place at the wrong time.

[@Omegateck16]

@@platonismisoop2152 If merphy gets to have little garden i get my sabody i guess lol

[@curtishammer748]

Fair enough, but if you have any mink, mermaid, fishman, giant, or tontatta friends, they probably wouldn't be able to come visit you

[@couldntcareless7884]

There are also slaver gangs that may decide to kidnap you and sell you. It may be illegal, but I doubt they care.