Barstool Pizza Review - Coniglio's Old Fashioned (Morristown, NJ)

Dave finally makes his way to Coniglio's, owned by his friend world famous pizza maker Nino Coniglio, and is taken on a whirlwind tour of the massive operation.
Download The One Bite App to see more and review your favorite pizza joints: onebite.app/do...
Follow on Instagram: / stoolpresidente
Follow on Twitter: / stoolpresidente
Check out Barstool Sports for more: www.barstoolspo...
Follow Barstool Sports here:
Facebook: / barstoolsports
Twitter: / barstoolsports
Instagram: / barstoolsports

[@LookSpec]

"you want some 1920's coke?" prez's eyes light up

[@tonygallo2361]

lololol

[@CalebWilliams2030]

O boy, does anyone have a time machine. Idk if it existed back then . If so what $20 an eight ball.

[@TheOriginalCameron]

$4 ​@@CalebWilliams2030

[@M1Simulator]

@@CalebWilliams2030 do you have any idea how much 20 dollars would actually buy you in the 1920's

[@Ptilt]

Fuck yea I ain't done coke in 27 years hate coke a cola.... I would totally jump at the chance to try a 1920's coke with coke in it.

[@micahlouis6990]

That guy is a legend. One of the all time best Barstool Pizza Review characters of all time. Gotta respect the hustle of someone who works like that dude does. So glad we got to see this.

[@richieesco]

He was on a diff review years ago in Manhattan right? What was the name of that spot?

[@the1der]

He's the modern, "if you build it they will come."

[@timhensley3695]

Its definitely my favorite review

[@MoonmanSpacejam]

This guy shows Dave his heart and soul, all his fresh and special ingredients and he says; Why dont you do New Haven 🤣

[@irishmossdubwise]

I swear

[@willlazenby1050]

I mean Dave's not wrong. With all those ovens he could offer more of a New Haven style pizza at least as an option.

[@RobGoldy]

He had a pretty good response. He's not an expert at making new haven yet and doesn't wan't to pretend like he is.

[@MoonmanSpacejam]

@@willlazenby1050 why though? There are plenty of other styles than New Haven? Pizza is about the personal experience you receive from the maker. If you want that style, then go to New Haven. I love a thick, meaty doughy pizza!!! If everyone did New Haven, then what the fuck would the pizza experience even be?!!!!

[@MoonmanSpacejam]

@@RobGoldy or, he's good at doing what he does best and doesn't need to conform to one style that "Dave" thinks is the best

[@petermorris8923]

1 of the best guys he's had on the show. Passionate, hardworking, and not afraid to go the extra mile.

[@mt1118A1]

Reminds me of Danny from Angelo's in Philly

[@jimsonjohnson3761]

People don't understand the time and perfectionism it takes to do what that guy has done. They might just look at him and how he talks and not give him his credence. It's tough to run a business it's even tougher to run a really good one. Hats off to Nino.

[@joeyespo7]

Well said 👏🏽

[@theboringchannel2027]

true and all, but he makes a floppy average looking pie that would earn a 7.0 at any other pizzeria.

[@MoonmanSpacejam]

Especially how much he has grown, I fell like he's giving less time for his fans and the business, just to turn out videos. I get it... Its just sad to see that happening

[@willmaud2359]

@@theboringchannel2027 Imagine thinking you can tell how good food is based only on how it looks. Flavor is what's most important, not Dave's fixation on crispiness.

[@scottulrich2725]

I ran a Michelin starred restaurant -- this guy would be perfect. Love what he does.

[@jaredwarner2451]

I’m rooting for that guy. Any business owner that watches that whole video knows how hard it is to pull of what he’s doing. We need more people like him.

[@Vertigo963]

OK, but his lengthy, annoying presence in this video obviously biased the review.

[@DzekoVelez]

Seriously. Him having that large of a menu and so many things going on at once while being the sole owner is extremely hard.

[@jaredwarner2451]

Plus all the bread, the soda fountain… crazy. Hope he gets good help. If he does he could grow it and expand… if he doesn’t he’ll die of a heart attack.

[@melaniecarroll2538]

A genius who’s quality oriented and super integral. That’s what would make America great again… more people like him!

[@mondoenterprises6710]

Coniglio is playing the long game. It's nice to see someone put their heart and soul into a place like him.

[@nilcesoares9708]

Exactly -- his delivery might be over the top, but you can tell that Nino really knows what he's talking about + is super creative ... those are the keys to success + longevity

[@OllieRamone]

@@nilcesoares9708And he knows his pizza history. Listen to the old podcast he used to do.

[@samryan7954]

Bullshit! He's a drug addict......

[@metromusic5725]

STFU bot - who talks like this?

[@andrewshort2243]

no kidding.... imagine the debt to buy all that equipment! He def can't sleep!

[@Br34kdown]

Nino taking him through every back door like goodfellas had me dying

[@RonnieJamesOsbourne]

Owner: **Passionately spills his guts.** Dave: When do we get to eat the pizza? 😂

[@Year_Of_The_Cat]

Pitza pitza Ciao scusi 🤌

[@sonicmoj1]

This owner is something else. I love this owner. No bullshit and he does everything the long way. Great work!!

[@jameschenard1386]

“I’ll take a 1920’s Coke “😂😂😂 Dave hoping for the original recipe 🤣🤣🤣

[@slowprodigy]

And here we have the Knights of Columbus clubhouse. Founded in 1882, our fraternal organization has sought to strengthen family and community through charity and traditional Catholic values. It is an honor for a non-member to be allowed here. Dave: "You guys don't have TV?"

[@SenatorSimon02]

Shoutout to you for this one. Charity, unity, fraternity, & patriotism my brother!!

[@jesusthroughmary]

​@@SenatorSimon02amen

[@Azzury.]

@@SenatorSimon02Deus Vult

[@bmaychangeyourlife3542]

3rd degree Knight here, brothers.

[@jesusthroughmary]

@@bmaychangeyourlife3542 4th degree here

[@Woozlewuzzleable]

They casually dropped a movie.

[@conniedurgin164]

Yeah ... Good Fellas (especially at the end of the review)

[@Woozlewuzzleable]

@@conniedurgin164 He was probably an extra in the Sopranos.

[@takeyourtime3328]

The dude looks like Hitler. I am sorry lol

[@metromusic5725]

They casually dropped an infomercial

[@NotAnonymousNo80014]

It's called a biopic.

[@emrosesig]

This video perfectly encapsulates Nino. He has more passion in his thumb than most have in their whole body. He's rough around the edges, by societies standards, but is super kind and generous. He'll talk your ear off, but you'll learn so much from him and walk away feeling great. It's a pleasure knowing him.

[@MikeFields83]

I swear these two could be brothers 😂 they talk the same, same language, same cussing etc I love it!

[@sonicmoj1]

Exactly. Portnoy twins!

[@garyny4073]

Mike - he wants dave to help him get a u tube or tv show contract 😅😊👍

[@Xiaolongbaokid16]

Dave looking for a TV in a Knight of the Columbus frat house is so f-cking funny, man. 😂😂😂 The dude was like, “non members isn’t even allowed in here, and it’s a sacred place for us, and you’re in here looking for a fucking TV.” 😂

[@ESalty6969]

That shit was wild afff wasn't it?? Lol

[@adampryor4662]

One bite short film, everybody knows Dave is making up for those 2 minute reviews

[@Doomsquad99]

I was just about to say that!

[@Win7ermu7e]

When Paul Giamatti makes you a pizza you make a movie about it.

[@adampryor4662]

@@Win7ermu7e for real

[@fireside9503]

I dig it

[@metromusic5725]

One bit commercial

[@MEGACAMZ]

I'm not from America, and I likely will never go to this pizza place, but it is amazing to see someone so passionate about their craft and put so much thought and effort into it, such care into the ingredients and the product their serving. Impressive stuff.

[@ImStuckInStockton]

Some Italian guy in the 18th century: 0:27

[@ApexHC]

LMAO

[@willvr4]

Have you been to the South Shore of Long Island? These people still exist haha

[@indridcold777]

TOP COMMENT LMFAO

[@sethdanielw]

😂😂😂

[@thegreatgooch1]

I don't get it??😢

[@RamblinAround]

Those people are so cool, it's impossible not to like them. Such positive energy. Pizza looked great too!

[@leevy6753]

There is nothing better than a person who has a passion for doing what they love and loving what they do.

[@ItaThe3rd]

This is the best promotion ever for Nino's place! It looks like they've put their soul into the business. Great review

[@Blitz_Steve]

13 minute review.. you know it's gonna be a special one today 🔥🔥

[@mikem1457]

Everyone knows the rules

[@lumpydavidg2201]

I had a cousin like this when we were kids. He had us running to every room excited to show me all his toys and favorite hiding places. 😂😂

[@rg20322]

Holy Sh**! What a review - this guy is nuts and must be rich to keep buying all this expensive equipment but knows how to use it for the business. Awesome!

[@95thousandroses]

lol, no one who owns and personally operates a restaurant is rich.

[@allshoulders9624]

@@95thousandrosesyou need different friends then.

[@dgan2304]

@@95thousandroses If you have multiple restaurants you are rich lol

[@andresm1704]

@@95thousandroses Lmao i think someone who owns 7 pizza shops is doing well.

[@carsondenny1986]

@@95thousandroses it’s rare, but yes. In case like this, though, the person owns MULTIPLE restaurants.

[@vand.8081]

Instant classic review. Nino is a rare Jewel. He deserves all of the success for what he's doing.

[@Ryoufriggingserious]

I can imagine those two in business together. Constantly arguing 😂

[@lancefromohio]

Orange County Choppers but instead of throwing chairs they're they're throwing pies.

[@theboringchannel2027]

@@lancefromohio OCC went bankrupt and their bikes all sucked as stated by many of the owners.

[@lancefromohio]

@@theboringchannel2027 yeah. but they got that meme of them throwing chairs. so. that was the point dingus.

[@LayDurafe]

One of the greatest reviews. These two could be brothers. Nino, what a character. Dave too, true man of the people. Phenomenal showing.

[@GiraffeFeatures]

Dave finally found someone more coked up than himself, no wonder they considered entering a business together.

[@slayerhuh404]

seriously, I got sensory overload from watching this video!

[@knowfacey]

Hey, Tex! Are you mayor of Bandera yet?

[@richardcorsillo9819]

That's how many Italian Americans are...believe me, whether it is plumbing, golf, trucking or making pizza, they are boisterous loving you, busting balls, having fun, while still getting the job done

[@auchlowtrus9300]

"Coke don't change"

[@the.villan]

@@richardcorsillo9819 At what point do you become just American?

[@crunchyblack2224]

Love this guy. Well done Dave and thanks for showing us around. He is truly passionate about what he does and it shows.

[@KansasCowpoke]

What a character, dude loves doing it all, bread, pizza, pasta, gelato, craft sodas😂

[@grahamh3915]

The whole bit with the affogato had me cracking up hahaha

[@jordant.teeterson3100]

That tour at the end was legendary

[@kurtkensson2059]

Easily my favorite review yet. That couple is classic NJ. They deserve all the rewards from their obviously very hard, and passionate work.

[@fireside9503]

This guys puts love in his pizza, and what he does. You can’t ask for anything more. Respect.

[@ksrini813]

Dave congratulations for doing this for more than 10 years with the same enthusiasm even if you are financially free. You have become passionate about this. Keep going......

[@Beau_T_McBoatface]

Dude is livin his best life.

[@samhavholm]

By far, your best pizza review yet! I enjoyed how personal you can become with your friends! thank you...

[@kamiljay2697]

That video perfect portrait nj, chaos lmao

[@jmason61]

I grew up 10 minutes from the place, these are the people going down to Asbury Park to watch old punk bands when they can get maybe a late night to party

[@Dan_Bender]

So much for ever getting to visit that place!!!! The wait times are going to be off the charts!

[@joeyz3217]

DP, I know you’re a busy guy but I really enjoy the lengthy-er videos with you bantering and showing the shop etc… I hope there is more of this in future vids! God bless my guy

[@pelangos]

Really love the longer episodes like this one. This guy is a pizza legend!!

[@Studiovette]

I think he really wanted to give it a 7.3, no crunch at all.

[@GNXperimental]

Yep

[@jh7178]

Floppy mess

[@anthonyf2982]

I think you’re right. He was under a lot of pressure to give the guy a great score.

[@victormalgieri7733]

Absolutely correct no crisp at all not even the crust 7.3 all day.

[@ultimate1x1]

yup, i said 7.4 before I started reading the comments.

[@BULLY_FINGER]

Dude seems excited about the process, the machinery and the whole pizza game. Super legit.

[@UnreleasedLofi]

When you see a review 10+ minutes you drop EVERYTHING and watch immediately

[@bryanb5413]

I love this guy! Dave, you have been holding out on us. Thanks for sharing...

[@sappo504]

Not sure that pizza makes the 8's without the personal relationship... but I like that guy and his establishment seems very cool... I'd go in a heartbeat.

[@Thetache]

No crisp and no mention of the horrendous flop that he was holding up with a contortionist grip so yeah would have been a 7.1 without the Buddy Boost

[@Xsi9mm]

Nah the pizza is some of the best in Northern NJ. I've lived here all my life and I'm a local. It should have been rated higher, frankly.

[@Thetache]

@@Xsi9mm Not the point, personal preference is up to you BUT Dave is all about the crisp and he hates the flop so on his ratings that would never have got near an 8 on the lack of crisp and the flop. Go back and check his other reviews

[@Xsi9mm]

​@@ThetacheI've been watching these reviews since the beginning. It may not have been what Dave likes but In the broad spectrum of Pizza this stuff is some of the best in Northern NJ

[@Thetache]

@@Xsi9mm So in essence you agree with what I said, you subjectively like it but Dave gave him a big Buddy Boost as the pizza was in the low 7s on Daves scale based on all his previous reviews, like I said I am not arguing the quality of the pizza I am stating an opinion based on evidence of Dave low scoring floppy pizza when it isnt his mates or someone he feels sorry for. Daves scale is the least reliable on the internet.

[@scottulrich2725]

Holy God! I wish there was a Nino in my town. Dude is spectactular. His passion for what he does is awesome.

[@stephenlandreville6599]

Who else could watch a weekly hour long episode with these 2?

[@alainlalonde]

Hand raised!

[@fireside9503]

30 min should do

[@FyCMystery]

When's the pilot episode?

[@stephenlandreville6599]

This was it

[@kingstoler]

Im good

[@Xiaolongbaokid16]

That is arguably the best review he’s ever done. They made a film in 13 minutes. 😂

[@scottgodkin781]

Dave terrified to give it a 7.4 everybody knows the rules

[@petecabrina]

He even said its an eight even before eating it, because of the reputation and build up and pressure 😂

[@Redvinetv]

One bite, 2 bumps (one for Dave & one for the owner), everybody knows the rules!

[@j.j.5844]

😂

[@j.j.5844]

😂

[@thebigmoo]

One of the greatest reviews of all time, and I've seen them all!!

[@triplebbb291]

Definition of a character. Love it!

[@NookBoo]

That guy is LIVING his dream. So much respect, has to be an absolutely amazing feeling knowing that. You can tell he's full of life for making it all happen. Kudos to that man, hope I can try some pie one day.

[@yehweoutherelopez6405]

Over 10 minutes instant classic.

[@geromejohnnygranada]

Im currrently on a streak of calling the score that dave scores as i watch the videos in real time. IM A FREAKING MAGICIAN

[@theboringchannel2027]

if you called that pie an 8.3, you know nothing about pizza. its a 7 at best at any other pizzeria that is not owned by daves best buddy. the floppy and sloppy pie is obviously not an 8.3 Go find another review where flop scores 8 or higher, will be waiting.

[@geromejohnnygranada]

@@theboringchannel2027 bahahaha this is low tier bait. But I'll entertain you anyway. I said I call the score that Dave scores. It has nothing to do with the pizza. It only has to do with guessing what Dave is thinking. Who gives a rats ass about the pizza. Oh you do, you pizza snob. Pizza snob pizza snob!

[@adamj8721]

Instant classic! 😂 pizza looked awesome too. Nino has a heart of gold but that may be the most exhausting guy to be around, god bless Dave for even thinking about a business together lol

[@joseperez8774]

This guy ,place, people, business is fucking awesome.... What a review.. 🔥🔥🔥.... This guy is a warrior everyday

[@TheLazyLabrador]

Skyrocketing into the top three greatest reviews of all time.

[@jakeyell]

"... Coke don't change; don't fuck with Coke..." Words to live by.

[@brooke8567]

It's got fentanyl now

[@Animator605]

Even Mrs. Roper was getting in on the picture action! 9:45

[@smsmoof8128]

LOL

[@philm2217]

Yeah wtf was that!? Lmao it looks exactly like her

[@davebulloch1912]

Easily one of the best all time reviews. Nino is a complete beast of an owner operator. I’m ready to hop a plane to NJ!

[@robmills7611]

He got the old buddies boost! Everyone knows the rules

[@BigBoomerDave]

I love seeing this much passion from Pizza makers! Awesome

[@Plague_Doc22]

This is my favorite review of all time. It was just awesome stuff on top of awesome stuff. And Nino seems like a really good dude with a nice gal.

[@Jonetsou]

11:24 I thought review was going to be over but it just got better 😂

[@avalon449]

Plain cheese had major flop, 7.8 tops. Dave jumped the shark, again, today.

[@theboringchannel2027]

6.8 - 7.1 at any other pizzeria. 8.3 was the friend score

[@mrgeriatric]

That was an inflated "buddy" score for sure

[@z3ro7o]

@@theboringchannel2027 7.1 you watching on a iphone 3gs? gtfo

[@the_white_al_borland]

Yeah nah we all know this is as a family bag

[@zburkst2928]

unreal flop that's why the guy ran back inside 🤣

[@Food_travel_auto_fun_89]

Man, looking at this kind of video really makes me wanna visit the US and go around all these kinds of restaurants, the vibe, food, and customers must be amazing!

[@anthonyf2982]

Dave just boosted that owner’s business with that score.

[@theboringchannel2027]

thats why he gave a 7.1 floppy pie an 8.3 to boost his buddies business.

[@Xsi9mm]

This guy has been the most popular pizza place in Morristown way before Dave showed up. The pizza is pretty great and easily in the 8s

[@jonathanhawthorne1821]

World needs more people like this that are so passionate about what they do

[@MattyStavvy]

What a whirlwind of a review and cool history lesson of this spot, everybody knows the rules!

[@MarkHarper-ek8ss]

It was it was Overkill filled with narcissists

[@lawrenceluebbert21]

He has his heart and soul into his work I love it.

[@donnat2062]

No way thats a legit 8.3. If he didnt know the guy it would of been a football pizza 7.4

[@nundulan]

Lmao it looks nothing like a football pie, are you smoked out?

[@lawrenceshdow]

It is amazing pizza. At least their normal ones. The one Dave doesn't like as much of course. Super flavorful and it just tastes like high quality ingredients.

[@nundulan]

@@lawrenceshdow next time I make it to the Tri-State Area I'm def stopping here

[@theboringchannel2027]

@@nundulan many better places to go to, this place is mid at best. real score on that pie is 6.8-7.0 8.3 is a joke score for a floppy average pie.

[@nundulan]

@@theboringchannel2027 I don't care about your opinion

[@timremaly1826]

I love to hear you review pie all over the place. Growing up in New Haven County Ct we took for granted what A pits is. Glad you came around and gave it a try. I gotta get the pizza map you need to share with us. So when I leave town we can eat. You da man!

[@mrxager18]

I busted my balls at the pizza shop this morning, food truck and all. I blaze a bowl to relax and throw on KZbin...they throw me a pizza video right off the bat! Of course, I watched it. Damn you pizza.

[@peaceful671]

Brilliant,here is a fellow who is doing it right,with passion for his business and customers...

[@willdogsdroid]

Automatic + .5 points for being established friends. Real Score (Indicated by flop) is 7.8

[@ImaplanetJupiteeeerr]

7.8 might even be stretching it by a long shot, could be evem 7.3 due to the floppy stuff it was.

[@theboringchannel2027]

@@ImaplanetJupiteeeerr 6.8 to 7.1 anywhere else

[@garyny4073]

Dave being led by the guy through the back alley stedicam shot style like goodfellas is priceless , dave a 100,000,000 man wondering if he was gonna be taken out jersy style 😊😊😅😅

[@morganneher8643]

Respect to this man and his crew for how hard they work, that is a CRAZY big operation 😮 Industry people will appreciate how well he set all that up, to do that many items fresh from scratch is incredible 🙏🏻

[@mef536]

Magic review ! Thanks. Really enjoyed it.

[@ChicoandPoppyFoodReviews]

Yes..!!

[@ruhyen]

Hell yeah, Nino reviews are great

[@Ecksplisit]

Unbelievable spot and an unbelievable vibe emanating from the owner. What a packed review. All the best to the guy.

[@joejudge9629]

That wasn't an 8 he was bullshittin

[@Sonnie125]

“ Dave , You want some 1920s Coke “ …. Hell Yeah and give me a straw 😉

[@95thousandroses]

with that flop it would be a 7.8 anywhere else. Dave tryin hide it by supporting it with the finger trick.

[@mattyp6908]

Dave really out here meeting and talking to Father Pizza and just asking where his pie at 😭

[@johnnymidas5879]

THAT GUY IS AWESOME ❤

[@jamesrivera6068]

He was walking him around like the scene from Goodfellas when they were entering the Copacabana.😂

[@hoddtoward]

13 minute pizza review, everybody knows he's gonna explore the whole place get get samples shoved at him left and right

[@jonathanman7751]

Those ovens are sick! That dude def loves what he is doing and really went over the top with the restaurant and all the equipment that's epic!!!

[@11d7th]

Damnit, I like these damn posts! 6:54 Nice flop rescue there. I take back all the bad things I said about you, Davey...except that none thing…but everything else, yes. Well, damn…meh….suspect score, but it’s a warmhearted video, so… 👍

[@sarahruth1417]

5:09 "When do we get to eat the pizza? "...."Ehhh, I dunno, one day." 😂😅😂 The dynamic between these 2, hilarious. Dave's so annoyed by the end, but in a good way 😂

[@biggpanch]

I love this guy!

[@ChicoandPoppyFoodReviews]

Yes..!!

[@RickieBobbie0721]

Dave, you are man of the people! That’s why you’re EL PRESIDENTE!

[@diegovoglino8443]

No way is that even close to an 8.3. Playing favorites here! Everybody knows Dave broke the rules.

[@markl4798]

exactly. didn't even mention the obvious flop.

[@Xsi9mm]

It's pretty great pizza, easily the best in Morris county

[@Bob-qh2hy]

That guy is amazing. The shop is amazing. Thanks Dave.

[@elinblackburn7345]

note: pizza is illegal in china

[@mcscotty325]

Fact: China invented the greatest pizza in history. The Durian Pizza.

[@Oldskoolraver-OG]

These two need a cooking show together they could disagree bout anything haha can tell he's a local wise guy character . Legend

[@M21655]

That’s a 7.8 pizza

[@mrgeriatric]

with flop and no crunch at all, even on the crust, I would have guessed even lower

[@ChicoandPoppyFoodReviews]

Yes..!!