Bill and his guests continue their conversation after the show.
Пікірлер: 3 000
@josephlauzon373710 күн бұрын
Douglas Murray rules. Bill, please get him on the show more often.
@mdaddy7752 сағат бұрын
He says right-wing trash with a posh voice. That's it.
@MarkusAxunIllianus11 күн бұрын
More Douglas Murray please!
@g_47849 күн бұрын
But he's a bigot because I said so
@MarkusAxunIllianus9 күн бұрын
@@g_4784 sounds legit. Ready the pickforks.
@Gannicus0068 күн бұрын
@@g_4784 stop trolling
@g_47847 күн бұрын
@@Gannicus006 I'm parodying the people who troll
@mdaddy7752 сағат бұрын
Check your local dumpster.
@jayrosen666311 күн бұрын
So happy that Bill had Mr. Murray on his show!!!
@g_47849 күн бұрын
But have you considered that Douglas is a revisionist because he is pro-Israel and disagrees with me
@easynow74258 күн бұрын
Bill Mahers take on Palestine is the most sophmoric explanation I could ever imagine! Burr exposed Maher for the joke that he is.
@user-rx2gf4nx9e8 күн бұрын
Me too! I really love both of them!
@Youtubeisafascistcompany6 күн бұрын
Murray tells facts about Palestine nobody has the balls to say on TV..
@ingloriousraptors60105 күн бұрын
@@easynow7425eh.. how? I saw that podcast.
@annslato52105 күн бұрын
As soon as I saw Douglas Murray, I need to watch!
@pcbacklash_326112 күн бұрын
Just a note to Bill, if any of his staff read these comments: The "ball" device to which he was referring at the beginning of the segment is called a "Newton's cradle." You're welcome.
@gosselinluke11 күн бұрын
Kinda wasted on bill maher fans
@gezenews11 күн бұрын
@@gosselinluke balls? yeah
@2197201214552511 күн бұрын
His staff has Google. Theyre not going to read your comment
@evanburrows169711 күн бұрын
Of course, they read the comments. That's how they delete the ones critical of Bill.
@pikiwiki11 күн бұрын
oh thank you
@Katcornell11 күн бұрын
It's truly a delightful treat to have Doug Murray at the table.
@Drainage_Eli10 күн бұрын
Agree, wholeheartedly. He’s actually been to many places and has been able to see what’s really happening. Bruni seems to just get his information from Don Lemon or Rachel Maddow.
@lynnpaul204011 сағат бұрын
Agree 💯
@Tvaleriya8 күн бұрын
Douglas needs his own show or podcast STAT!!!! Eloquence and common sense embodied!
@jacobmatthews75243 күн бұрын
i prefer him going around on everyone elses. that way, he reaches WAY moe audiences. if he had his own, he would have just 1 audience.
@javiersds808118 сағат бұрын
He does have his own YT channel. It's called simply 'Douglas Murray'.
@jacobmatthews752410 сағат бұрын
@@javiersds8081 yes but he just posts interviews he does, it's not his own content. he did do a 10-episode history show and posted it, and he recently posted a documentary, but that's it in terms of original content. which is good in my opinion
@mdaddy7752 сағат бұрын
Needs to fix his lisp!
@mdaddy7752 сағат бұрын
@@jacobmatthews7524 Yes, the world needs to witness his propaganda and cheap insults!
@alankefauver618711 күн бұрын
Bill, Best show ever!! Just preordered your book, and bought the Murray and Bruni books
@SN-sz7kw11 күн бұрын
Really love the new calibre of guests. Fewer flame throwers & more thinkers. Who know how to have a discussion. Able to raise the consciousness of viewers with a side helping of humor.
@StroMedia11 күн бұрын
Agree. Kellyanne Conway last week was nauseating.
@Zozzo98411 күн бұрын
No there should always be people from both sides of the coin. Need more guests like her not less.
@ryanbarnes84011 күн бұрын
But why bring Murray on? Maher continues to bring these Israel cucks on his show because he's one himself. It's nauseating. Bring someone on the show who is from Palestine, or someone from Al Jazeera, or a network that is not firmly in the pocket of Israel. THAT would make for an honest debate, but Bill is afraid.
@ladym199111 күн бұрын
Again, thank goodness for no Kellyanne Conway! She’s not sane nor competent to speak along side this intelligent caliber of guests! 🤥😠
@adeletate664011 күн бұрын
Love listening to Douglas Murray
@lgoler11 күн бұрын
“It makes me glad I didn’t go”. Great fast wit with that one.
@shakypam7 күн бұрын
yeah I didn't get it. Please explain how that was witty. Talk to me like I'm 5 years old without implying I'm 5 years old
@haroldmcpeake870411 күн бұрын
I enjoyed listening to this intelligent conversation while still allowing a place for humor 😊
@weaverto10 күн бұрын
It sounded intelligent, but it was just privileged celebrities. Murray and Mahr are tedious to well researched folks.
@annaathome299511 күн бұрын
Great panel Again,good one Bill,touching on the relevant issues
@jaxonjaxoff329112 күн бұрын
You had me at Douglas Murray.
@nicebluejay12 күн бұрын
he lost me at Douglas Murray.
@afridgetoofar181812 күн бұрын
He’s got seriously sweaty pits
@jamievidd77511 күн бұрын
Truth!
@jamievidd77511 күн бұрын
@@nicebluejayyou sound lost alright.
@ktom526211 күн бұрын
He's a right-wing clown and spin-doctor.
@dubdub486212 күн бұрын
The "steel balls" are called Newton's Cradle - I looked it up because it's so spot on. One "far-side" acts - the other "far-side" reacts and everybody else takes a beating and gets nowhere!
@winnienourse549212 күн бұрын
I was raised with, "the rich get richer and the poor get poorer" implied..everybody in the middle gets hammered from both sides
@Barberdan11 күн бұрын
@@winnienourse5492 I never thought it in that way. I will now.
@callamastia11 күн бұрын
yeah that was a very accurate analogy. those 2 balls are the problem and need to be removed.
@HansDelbruck5311 күн бұрын
@@callamastia Remove two of your balls and see what happens.
@2197201214552511 күн бұрын
No it wasn't. The balls dont move. In our situation the balls are moving then tugged in the other direction. Pendulum is correct
@teresajenkins905611 күн бұрын
This is a great show and you had great guests...super bright and intelligant conversation..
@davidanderson_surrey_bc10 күн бұрын
"Intelligant"? I guess that would be a blend of "intelligent" and "elegant".
@MegaGo6811 күн бұрын
This was a terrific episode: top notch guests who brought out the best in each other and in Bill.
@RobRamseyWizardofMathematics10 күн бұрын
The guy from the NY Post was spreading propaganda, in reference to the protest on college campuses. A call for a ceasefire is not pro-hamas, or anti-Semitic, which is the disinformation that he was trying to spread. The students have been calling for humanitarian aid to starving women and child who are being terrorized by the IDF and Netanyahu. Long live the World Central Kitchen
@MrNintoku11 күн бұрын
I don't go to concerts simply because of how expensive they are.
@HaleyMary11 күн бұрын
Same! It's so much easier just to buy the cd and enjoy listening and dancing along to the music at home. Not to mention more economical. Though, I hardly ever buy cds anymore either.
@jurassicthunder11 күн бұрын
ticketmaster needs to be de-monopolized
@zackamania653411 күн бұрын
Most of my faves are dying off, save for McCartney, James Taylor et al. And my rap group dudes won’t perform together (OutKast)
@vinnym560711 күн бұрын
Ok ...
@crosslink149311 күн бұрын
Remember that Taylor Swift fans are predominantly teenage/early 20s girls, so every ticket sold to one of them results in a second ticket sold to a parent who's the 'security escort' for the evening. Great way to double your ticket sales, Ms. Swift.
@elizabethpowers754011 күн бұрын
When I was young, I went to 3-4 concerts a year. I'm glad I'm as old as I am because I could never afford it at today's prices.
@jeremiahbrewer611510 күн бұрын
I still go to concerts but now only 1-2 year. Of course the formerly legendary acts I like, like Neil Young, Robert Plant and John Mellencamp, are “vintage” now. Still pricey though.
@EasyThere10 күн бұрын
I buy the live shows and watch them at home too, then the only annoying belligerent drunk I have to deal with is me.
@elizabethpowers754010 күн бұрын
@@jeremiahbrewer6115 We're probably about the same age so I know what you mean. I go see SOME of these guys but for example as much of an Eagles fan as I am I won't go see them because they were the 1st ones I remember where the price gouging was so outrageous that I just can't forgive it. Before they got back together I did see Henley solo though.
@hopeewing55839 күн бұрын
Me too!! In the 70s ,the Doobie brothers were 15 dollars a ticket. It was packed with high school kids and on up
@TheCrappyRobot9 күн бұрын
When I was young, I never needed anyone and making love was just for fun.
@TheKindredTrucker11 күн бұрын
"How are people going to know their history if there's no statues?" ... idk, books maybe? What an insane thing to argue about. This was embarrassing to watch.
@howardhales632511 күн бұрын
When I saw Bowie in 1983 there were people who wouldn't go because the ticket prices were too high. I paid $ 20.00.
@Asto5084 күн бұрын
$60 today. Guess people weren't used to the normal prices today.
@jeffmoser403411 күн бұрын
The Arthur Ashe statue in Richmond is hilarious. He really looks like he is beating the kids.
@maryannlockwood780611 күн бұрын
I agree! I have family that live in Virginia a& they took me to see that area couple years ago. I don’t know every time I see relatively new statue of someone there’s always something really odd about it!🎾
@Zozzo98411 күн бұрын
Poc artists are Embarrassing
@Ausf11 күн бұрын
It looks like the kids are trying to get the book he's holding, and he's about to beat them down to keep the book safe.
@ITOLDUDA10 күн бұрын
This was a great panel. Usually at least one is insufferable, but both of the main guests made good points without being unlikeable.
@keep-ukraine-free5289 күн бұрын
@ITOLDUDA You said you liked "both of the guys". Didn't you see there were 3? But as usual, one (Murray) *_WAS_* insufferable.
@ITOLDUDA9 күн бұрын
@@keep-ukraine-free528 No, there were two primary panelists during the show. Did you not watch the show? 🤣
@Oxley0169 күн бұрын
@@keep-ukraine-free528 Douglas Murray is one of the greatest thinkers and speakers of our time. I can't think why you would think that about him.
@keep-ukraine-free5289 күн бұрын
@@ITOLDUDA Can't you read the title that names all 3 guests -- "Eric Schlosser, Douglas Murray, Frank Bruni"? Can't you see all 3 of them sitting near Bill? But if you still want to imagine only 2, then go ahead imagine a warped world for 🤡 yourself. Everyone else sees 3 guests. None were "regulars".
@keep-ukraine-free5289 күн бұрын
@@Oxley016 If you consider Douglas Murray to be "one of the greatest thinkers", this tells us only the level of disparity between his & your faculties (and nothing more) -- alternately it's a quite inopportune situation for you, that you've never encountered (or maybe couldn't fully assess) anyone smarter than him. I hope you take more opportunities to expose yourself to smarter people. There are many. Good luck.
@joannek62679 күн бұрын
Surprisingly odd that Schlosser never mentioned the forever chemicals we are ingesting as a result of drinking bottled water.
@BlaccTony6912 күн бұрын
When I saw Prince, The Time & Vanity 6 in 1983, I paid between $10-$15 dollars for Prince ticket. And I was on the 2nd row. Seeing Prince & his Band, Vanity, Susan, Brenda, I was so close, I didn’t know Morris Day had freckles on his face. I guess he always wore makeup on his albums. Now they pay $10K to see Taylor Swift; unbelievable.
@deborahfreedman33312 күн бұрын
The Hollywood Bowl used to offer UCLA students $2 rush tickets. I got to hear a lot of amazing artists, including the flutist Rampal (1976), for next to nothing.
@shiddykiddy-lp4dz11 күн бұрын
You saw some great Minneapolis musicians ❤
@2197201214552511 күн бұрын
@@shiddykiddy-lp4dzmsp ❤
@2197201214552511 күн бұрын
Corporate greed
@kimberlywalker397011 күн бұрын
I haven't been to a concert in over 20 years. When I saw INXS during their Kick Tour in 1988, the tickets were $17 or $18, and I had floor seats. I got a great view of Michael Hutchence and most of the band. In 1992, I saw U2's Zoo TV Tour at Arrowhead Stadium for $35 and I was kind of high in the rafters. In 1997, I saw U2's Pop Mart Tour for $60 and I was on the ground. I could barely see the band and the show was an utter disappointment. Years later, I heard their tickets were selling for as high as $200 and I said no thanks. I haven't been to a concert since. Besides, there's no one good enough to see that would make me want to part with my money these days.
@gretcheneger369011 күн бұрын
Museums, history classes, documentaries, books are places where one can learn about history and the relevance of certain people during the historical time.
@thetruthendofstory11 күн бұрын
Exactly. Don't need statues of traitors of the country to teach history
@2197201214552511 күн бұрын
These people act like someone who ignores all those things would voluntarily choose to study a statue. #weaksauce
@jeannienickel711 күн бұрын
Sadly… out of sight, out of mind. People with attention span of Tik Tok will not learn from museums or Libraries…. I feel sorry for Teachers today
@AverageJoe48311 күн бұрын
Can we remove the Lenin statue in Seattle?
@Stolat7911 күн бұрын
@@AverageJoe483private owner on private property, the Lenin statue has nothing to do with public funds or the government of Seattle.
@revtheory11 күн бұрын
Yes!! Douglas Murray, the last beacon of truth!! Awsome
@intello895310 күн бұрын
Lol saying stuff is a “beacon of truth” now? Yikes
@weaverto10 күн бұрын
Muray's take on Monument Avenue is typical low-grade bullshit from a celebrity opinion peddler. Monument Avenue was a private real-estate venture designed to capitalize on the post-reconstruction phenomenon of reasserting white power. He's a cunt for whining about no "monuments" on Monument Avenue.
@keep-ukraine-free52810 күн бұрын
@revtheory Douglas Murray's a buffoon. He embarrassed himself again. After he said his first words, all 3 others saw his racist point & denounced his words. He slivered back into his tiny box. He was smart enough to then revise his words, spinelessly.
@mdaddy7752 сағат бұрын
@@intello8953 He says things that make right-wing simpletons happy
@intello89532 сағат бұрын
@@mdaddy775 “immigrants bad, Muslims bad, woke is bad, Christianity good, well western Christianity is good even though I’m a gay atheist, the West is the greatest of all time, Zionism is good and Isreal is awesome forever” I might be oversimplifying him but that’s basically his whole thing 😂
@nuqwestr9 күн бұрын
Statues in the 1920s centered around efforts of reconciliation between the Blue and the Gray as they aged out. Various reunions and commemorations were held by both Union and Confederate veterans throughout the 1920s. These gatherings aimed to foster reconciliation and mutual respect among former adversaries, often emphasizing the shared sacrifices and experiences of soldiers on both sides.
@pandaloon60838 күн бұрын
People some to overlook or forget that it was a civil war. You don't conquer and subjugate. You don't fly over and leave. Your enemy was your neighbor, your brother, your countryman. The war being over, you now have to live with them. What makes it easier to bury a hatchet, a Seinfeld-esque "No statues for you!' approach, or a "Bury your dead, honor your heroes. Come home" approach?
@JustAMinuteYT12 күн бұрын
So many parents buy their teenage kids new cars at 16/17. It blows my mind.
@rickyiglesias538411 күн бұрын
oof. I got a $1000 used car when I was 16 and I felt insanely blessed.
@direwolf623411 күн бұрын
if it's a new car then they are financially well off .. and they have more than cars ...
@dannyfrog11 күн бұрын
I got my Dad's old worn out truck on it's 2nd engine and nearly 400K miles. He did it to teach me a lesson in appreciating nicer things when you have them. And he was right.
@denniszenanywhere11 күн бұрын
My father bought my stepsister a fancy german car at that age.
@jool779311 күн бұрын
Only rich people do that.
@jesseceballos554311 күн бұрын
You know Bill Maher has been a lot of things over the years but he's always stuck to his guns and his convictions even if you disagree with him at points. He's not trying to fuck with you. Kudos to him. I like this phase of Bill Maher. I think he is the number 1 unbiased news outlet at this point.
@carsondenny198611 күн бұрын
With those lip smacks, he’s sticking to those gums too
@SarahRLWarner11 күн бұрын
Good one
@2197201214552511 күн бұрын
Its not ideal to stick to the same viewpoints throughout your life
@timducote571311 күн бұрын
He is, has been and always will be a limousine liberal. Many people tend to seek stability as they age and that isn't found in left-wing ideology. For as long as I've watched him, he has never seemed to had an "ah ha" moment. He is an unapologetic partisan.
@MrScott1212ful11 күн бұрын
@@timducote5713 I saw him one time ask why the Dems lie, that the rich do pay more taxes than us. The liberal person he asked did not have a good answer. LOL
@parannoy11 күн бұрын
"How are people gonna know their history if there's no statues?" -- Murray "I don't know. Books?"
@ErgoProxy123457 күн бұрын
kids dont read books though. And they are the future and will fuck things up if they are not shown the past
@wasntme196710 күн бұрын
"Let's have a drink" was a very sincere and warm closing line.
@Blue-vq7vm11 күн бұрын
Never destroy history. Don't burn books.......
@xaspirate806011 күн бұрын
Or re-write history to spare feelings,,, I don't know which is worse.
@thetruthendofstory11 күн бұрын
Or ban books like they are doing in Florida Texas Arkansas Alabama, pretty much all of the old Confederacy, I wonder why?🤔
@tomy298811 күн бұрын
@@thetruthendofstory So you support the sexualization of children but offended by Huckleberry Finn, got it…
@evanburrows169711 күн бұрын
@@thetruthendofstory groomer
@thehmc11 күн бұрын
@@thetruthendofstory No books in those states have been banned. California however did ban books.
@user-bj7xs1my4p11 күн бұрын
What a great show this week. Wish it were even longer. A breath of fresh air.
@ryanbarnes84011 күн бұрын
Not really. It was just more of the same "Israel is great, Palestine sucks....anyone who supports Palestine is anti-Semitic, and Israel never does anything wrong....let's compare what Israel is doing to what Ukraine is doing...." nonsense. It's total garbage. I'd like to see Bill actually bring on someone who supports Palestine and hear their argument for why they're protesting Israel, instead of bringing on all these stooges who chalk it all up to anti-Semitism, ignorance, and being in college.... that would make for a good show.
@thomasforrisi87910 күн бұрын
Okay, I'm an elder on a fixed income. As a, " child of the 60s ", today's ticket prices and legal scalping has me reluctant to pay into an artist's retirement fund.
@SuZ39454 күн бұрын
I love Overtime! thank you for this brief moment of real thoughts!
@andrewleyden275212 күн бұрын
This is actually much better than the main show. The discussion about statues was pretty nuanced by today’s standards. It is possible to distinguish between a statue put up in another era and one put up more recently to represent very bad ideas. Concretely, there is a difference between a monument to someone like “Stonewall” Jackson put up in 1919 v. one put up in the 1860s, because obviously the person putting up the statue in 1919 is making a very specific point.
@johnlewinski635912 күн бұрын
It usually is. They used to cover more topics in the regular show
@AdamBechtol11 күн бұрын
Hmmm wish this wasn't edited so I can see your beef with Mr. Jackson ha.
@vforwombat991511 күн бұрын
not sure ANY statues if stonewall were put up in the 1860s. i can't say for sure, i know most of the confederate statues were put up a long long time after the war ended. so idk how many put up contemperaneously have survived to be an issue. in any case, the initial question was about school names, and these schools were certainly built long after the civil war, had their names changed from confederate heroes, and now have had those confederate heroes names put back on. at this point that's pure spite, and if you wanna consider it a reaction to grievance culture, ok, but it's a petty, spiteful, racist reaction.
@tonirose677611 күн бұрын
@@vforwombat9915 Agree wholeheartedly.
@xaspirate806011 күн бұрын
@@vforwombat9915 I never heard of the back and forth with confedrate named schools - if that is true it is spiteful and silly.
@DeltaElites12 күн бұрын
I remember concerts where everyone paid the same $20 for an all day concert like the US Festival in 1983 with bands like Van Halen and Ozzy. I was able to see close to 100 live bands in my teens and 20s. I've been able to afford taking my adult daughters to only 4 concerts in the last decade.
@MarvinThiessen11 күн бұрын
Back in the mid-70's, I saw the Crusaders a few rows back from the stage, center aisle, tickets were $5 each. Also saw Frank Zappa at the same venue on blue collar wages. Now it's down payment and terms. Fuhgeddaboudit.
@gd136111 күн бұрын
@@MarvinThiessen and a massive "service fee" for each ticket 🙄
@sirsurnamethefirstofhisnam798611 күн бұрын
Like virtually everything else the cost has grown faster than regular peoples incomes
@RiotNrrrdUTube11 күн бұрын
$20? I walked into the 3rd day of the 1983 US Festival right before Bowie went on and saw him Scot-free. 😊
@justken190011 күн бұрын
$20 concerts were a time when the artists made money selling their recordings. Streaming killed that revenue, so they have to make their money on tour.
@True_Heretic11 күн бұрын
How are people going to know their history if there are no statues? Heard of books, Murray?
@dukesilver207211 күн бұрын
Exactly! 💯
@megansummersides42555 күн бұрын
Lol, aren’t they trying to ban all of them too. Nice try though 😂
@True_Heretic5 күн бұрын
@@megansummersides4255 "They" have banned books. Or gotten them banned. Usually to their discredit. I wouldn't ban books personally. Even books by narcissistic, racists like Murray. Because everyone one is entitled to their opinion. Including all the people Murray wants to shut up. Another narcissistic racist, Adolf Hitler, wrote a vile book back in the day. But even that shouldn't be banned because it shows the truth of the man. Many warts and all. That book becomes all the more important when Republican senators lie and say that Hitler was a left winger, which shows that they never bothered to read his thoughts in Mein Kampf. Any books you'd ban, Megan?
@SBRLimey5 күн бұрын
You don’t need a statue commemorating a traitor. That is what museums are for.
@dawiedarling10 күн бұрын
This Bruni is marvelously on-target, bright, and brief. That sort of skill wins debates
@darylsavoie747211 күн бұрын
Freddy Mercury threw you a tambourine? That also happened to me...I was in the 6th row at Maple Leaf Gardens in Toronto, Freddy made eye contact (because I had a joint in my hand), nodded, and threw the tam right to me. I got my hand on it, but so did everyone around me....I couldn't even let go of it by this time. It finally broke into pieces, I didn't even get a small piece, just a cut on my finger from the little cymbal diigging in. But I didn't drop the joint!.
@mikemcnamara648310 күн бұрын
Lmao. Great anecdote, thanks for posting that.
@eileenhall49186 күн бұрын
@@mikemcnamara6483 I saw Freddie but alas got no tambourine. Love him still so much!
@Nailbunny270211 күн бұрын
Another amazing panel. Overtime is too short!
@billmimms11 күн бұрын
EXTEND Overtime. Are they afraid they'll run out of material? I do realize there is that risk of having one of those "panels of idiots..."... That does happen enough. I think it's WORTH the risk. EXTEND Overtime. Thank you!
@StuPedassol10 күн бұрын
@@billmimmstrue dat, yo. True dat.
@djoetma10 күн бұрын
They have done it once or twice. I remember they went for 45 minutes once on overtime. But the concept isn't to have more of a free discussion anymore. They used to chance the at.osphere a bit since it was 'the internet'. But there isn't a real difference between tv and the internet anymore.
@bakshijoon11 күн бұрын
Let’s rename all the schools and buildings named after Confederates with the names of Union Generals. I’d love to know there’s a General Sherman High School in Mississippi!
@user-vu7yt8pm4p10 күн бұрын
Better yet, let's name a school "The Battle of Vicksburg," so Mississippi doesn't forget the major battle they lost. They must learn and remember their history!
@GlennC78911 күн бұрын
Germany knows its history very well and I can promise you there's not a single statue of Hitler in a town square or anywhere else.
@pandaloon608310 күн бұрын
Question. What if there was one. What if there was one, it had been standing for 30 years and....no one cared? No rallies under it. No pro-Hitler pamphleteering under it. No fist-fights under it. What if the community's lived-history with the statute was benign or banal? Would you get rid of it? Or would the fact that the statue stood for all those years while people DIDN'T make their neighbors' lives miserable be in some way a testament to how far people have come along, how they've progressed. A challenge overcome. Such that removing the statue eliminates the reminder of the progress made. Or, again, would it have to go because Hitler was evil?
@brandongratta90409 күн бұрын
Right. The man was losing the argument the second he made a relation to statues and people knowing history. I know history because I've been schooled and lived through some events. Not because I saw a statue. Statues are a nice way to commemorate someone for something they did, not to learn history.
@Kobe292619 күн бұрын
@@brandongratta9040 This is an interesting twist - never thought of it that way! Thanks
@pandaloon60839 күн бұрын
@@brandongratta9040 Statues have a way of inspiring the learning the history in way books, lectures halls, and museums do not.
@brandongratta90409 күн бұрын
@@pandaloon6083 then make a statue for the victims not the people that caused the harm. It should be for commemoration
@RealCoolGuy11 күн бұрын
Savannah, GA did a great job of "retain & explain". They did not tear down the Confederate statues, but they did add statues of Black civil rights leaders and monuments to historical Black locations. I think it's great because I enjoyed reading the history of both and it's important to highlight negative aspects as well.
@timducote571311 күн бұрын
Modern young people don't know (or care) anything about the original civil rights leaders or about confederate Civil War leaders. The iconoclasm against statues was nothing more than mob rage.
@jimpalmer7927 күн бұрын
"Savannah, GA did a great job of 'retain & explain'. They did not tear down the Confederate statues, but they did add statues of Black civil rights leaders and monuments to historical Black locations. I think it's great because I enjoyed reading the history of both and it's important to highlight negative aspects as well." Exactly. Its called 'history' -- all of it, the good & the bad, and it has nothing to do with 'being woke'. America should treat all this stuff as a 'learning/teaching' moment; 'lord' knows Americans needs to be be better educated !!!
@moeron387911 күн бұрын
'how are people going to know their history without statues?' - I can't take you seriously after that statement. ..
@EvanJames-gm2uf11 күн бұрын
Is the statue in the room with you right now?
@CrapKerouac11 күн бұрын
It's an interesting question since Americans don't read anymore. Maybe ticktock videos of American history?
@2197201214552511 күн бұрын
@@CrapKerouacso what makes you think they're going to read a statue then
@ashleywebb273610 күн бұрын
It starts with the statues
@g_47849 күн бұрын
There's a lot of value in being able to actually see a historical figure up close, as they had looked in full scale. I feel as if there's a humanity element here that should not be undermined.
@raeannaroylance54017 күн бұрын
Came for Douglas Murray
@povertime63818 күн бұрын
Nobody in this panel has ever heard of the four olds in China, besides Douglas Murray.
@NevadaBoss12 күн бұрын
Excellent show, excellent guests, and a bang on takedown of the herd mentality of the media on New Rules. One of the strongest episodes this year. The writers (and Bill) earned their paychecks this week.
@johnlewinski635912 күн бұрын
It wasn't that great.
@utubethumbsup12 күн бұрын
@@johnlewinski6359 I agree, it was a bit boring tbh.
@johnlewinski635912 күн бұрын
Better than with Kelly Con Away
@richardthelionheart559412 күн бұрын
They've really hit their stride; this one and the last 2
@user-gv4vf7tf3k12 күн бұрын
Was wonderful that you had Douglas Murray on show Frank Bruni good as well helped .me recover from Kellyanne Conway
@DeaPeaJay11 күн бұрын
They removed Teddy Roosevelt on his horse with his two Indian guides from the entrance to the museum of natural history in New York. So cut the “celebrating slavery” crap.
@timducote571311 күн бұрын
Trump asked, "where does it stop?" and rightly predicted that statues of Washington and Jefferson would come down, too.
@darrylsheffield710210 күн бұрын
They were Slave Owners 🤣👿🤔
@joemess10 күн бұрын
Losers and traitors don't get statues. Period. End of discussion.
@RobRamseyWizardofMathematics10 күн бұрын
Should the Iraqi’s bring back the statue of Saddam Hussein?
@pandaloon608310 күн бұрын
@@joemess "Traitors" -- 18th and 19th century Americans confronted more intense feelings of divided loyalty than do today's Americans. Your friends, your neighbors, your family -- they were part of your State. The federal government was more like an abstraction. Further, if you believe (as many at the time did) that the federal government was a creation of the states via ratification - then it is easy to understand why a state announcing its secession wasn't an act of treason but merely an act of contract termination.
@annacanova7060Күн бұрын
I'm always inspired by Douglas Murray!!!
@anilz42978 күн бұрын
Bill if you or your staff read this, consider having a guest on that has contrary take on the war in Gaza to your own and interview the other side directly. I denounce the attack on October 7 and all forms of antisemitism, but I feel Doug Murray just glossed over the suffering of the civilians there.
@zealandzen11 күн бұрын
Excellent points made.
@xlDysenterylx11 күн бұрын
It's called a Newton's Cradle, Bill. 🤦🏻♂️
@NicThatOneKid11 күн бұрын
100 years later , the roaring 20’s repeats itself 🎉😮
@jimladen222 күн бұрын
Good to see Douglas Murray getting some more airtime on TV
@Mickey-199411 күн бұрын
Nobody is going to call that guy out on his bulls@@t, wage inequality and a declining middle class have nothing to do with envy or jealously. My Uncle worked as a postman with no college education and my Aunt worked part-time at a retail store. They had the money to buy a big house, own two cars and live a very good middle class life. Most of us want that life and we are not expecting to live like the rich, but we have not changed. The government and corporate greed have gotten worse. Nothing is enough for these people and wanting what the Silent Generation and Baby Boomers have is somehow unreasonable in their view.
@k.c.44235 күн бұрын
If people who want those things would behave like their grandparents, they would be more likely to get that stuff. Even now in a different economy. I work with young people and their parents and I see it happen! For example, they can go back to the values that existed in those days… waiting a little longer to start their families (like maybe after high school?), taking available jobs and not acting like McDonald’s is beneath them? Fast food is paying $20 an hour in many parts of the country nowadays! Being willing to work the starter jobs and progressing their way up the ladder while getting a skill- just one example, Union pipefitters make $120k a year, with great benefits and pension! Many school districts offer welding classes, and kids can get trained and certified right out of high school! But this requires them to… What? Not be on drugs! Not be addicted to substances, games and porn! Be willing to get off their behinds and get out of their homes! Maybe have some work ethic! Maybe getting some religion might help! If you want what grandma and grandpa had, maybe you better find out what they were doing! Do you want to know who has what grandma and grandpa had? Immigrants! Yes, even the ones who are streaming across the border! And they are working darn hard for it. I meet immigrants all the time who have been here 10 years and are buying houses. After painting homes, working in yards, cleaning, farming, doing the grunt work lazy Americans don’t want to do. They are achieving the American dream. It is still out there. If you’re waiting for America to hand it to you, guess who’s going to end up paying for it? You. And guess what it’s going to look like? Just imagine your dream house. Not that.
@Mickey-19945 күн бұрын
@@k.c.4423 That is out of touch Boomer thinking little buddy. You're allowing greedy corporations and politicians off the hook.
@Grazimoto111 күн бұрын
We don't learn our history from statues, we learn our history from BOOKS! Statues were built for WORSHIP and REVERENCE!
@silencemeviolateme607611 күн бұрын
Worship? Then none should exist on public land.
@sigalitmenashe50227 күн бұрын
Wow so many here love Douglas I thought I was the only one
@tombombaddie11 күн бұрын
3:20 How are we to remember 9/11 without a statue of bin Laden at Ground Zero? 😢
@kari818711 күн бұрын
Douglas 😊
@purpledragonfly31311 күн бұрын
You don’t need every statue out in the open. Put them in a museum and explain context. Read a book or 50 to keep up with history!
@AB-ol5uz11 күн бұрын
which demographic has the absolutely lowest attendance in Museums? That is why we need historic monuments in public.
@davidyohalem62911 күн бұрын
@@AB-ol5uz The monumental statuary removed in Richmond was not historic. It was anti-historical, enforcing the mythology of the Great Lost Cause.
@ivanvanogre-nd1sw11 күн бұрын
And these statues were a scam too. They were cheapass statues that played on these bitter old racist fools hatred to make a buck. Same with the KKK. There was ONE clothing seller that made a huge amount of money selling these fools Klanwear. The haters got ripped off. Good.
@phill7311 күн бұрын
@@davidyohalem629 Says you
@f1ref1rst6211 күн бұрын
@@phill73says the Daughters of The Confederacy. You could ya know, research for yourself. Confederate statues and altered textbooks in the south were just two examples of how the DoTC tried to establish the mythology of “the lost cause”
@imitationoflife335711 күн бұрын
Re education about our history…since statues are honoring, or celebrating the wrong people, we must learn our history not from a 5 inch plaque which does not explain much, we must read, see statues in museums, attend school. Statues here and there do not educate!!!
@Karen-dk1ec9 күн бұрын
Eric should tell the direct, blunt truth and not be worried about being sued, or don't appear on a show. I like Maher's honest reply. It has been known for decades that artificial sugars cause cancer, and acritical ingredient disrupts glucose control. Kudos to Douglas Murray as usual. Love him.
@robertgandler317711 күн бұрын
Spot on honest and hysterical as always thanks!
@skipmartin346911 күн бұрын
Zeppelin, 1977, LA Forum, second row loges, $9.95. Now its hundreds for bands I never heard of. I don't go to concerts anymore, even if I can afford it.
@mykingdomforak911 күн бұрын
I have a friend that talks about his attendance at a Led Zep concert from that time/era, and how close he was to the stage (2nd row). ❤ watching his eyes go back to the memory. ⚘️
@skipmartin346911 күн бұрын
Yes. @@mykingdomforak9 Its burned into my brain, too.
@kimberlywalker397011 күн бұрын
I wish I could've seen them, but I was born in '72 😒😒
@robgronotte111 күн бұрын
There are lots of very good bands playing in every major city for $20 or less, and you can be 10 feet away from the band.
@RiotNrrrdUTube11 күн бұрын
@skipmartin3469 Look at your ticket stub again. Mine says $9.75 - 12Loge Section 12, Row DD, Seat 6. L.A. Forum June 26th 1977
@DerDarthenFritzster11 күн бұрын
Does anyone know who won the American Revolutionary War? In 1776, New Yorkers pulled down a statue of King George, so I have no idea...
@JamesAnderson-ez2df10 күн бұрын
Mr.Murray,”Anytimg with balls, Bill I am all in!”😮😅
@Johnthedagger12 күн бұрын
I don't think I've ever seen Bill laugh as hard as he did when Murray talked about the statue of Arthur Ashe looking like he was beating a child😆 Bill hates him some rug rats
@josephblue413512 күн бұрын
Biggest laugh of the night 😂
@2197201214552511 күн бұрын
New here?
@timweaver782612 күн бұрын
Germany does not have statues of Hitler nor the Swastika everywhere and I bet they "remember their history."
@user-zv7fi8di5i12 күн бұрын
Based
@chesterlestrange772511 күн бұрын
And?
@godogs8911 күн бұрын
You need to educate yourself on how racists and antisemitic a statement you just made was. Wtf is wrong with you.
@Echo-mg5em11 күн бұрын
But there is a very distinct form of self-punishment that Germany took on in the era following WWII: there are many German cities that adopted the notoriously harsh and sometimes deliberately ugly Brutalist architecture as a visual marker.
@patrikvavro161111 күн бұрын
@@Echo-mg5emI don’t think that has anything to do with their post-war guilt complex, a lot of European cities are blighted by hideous Brutalist architecture, not just German ones
@raymondtalbot610411 күн бұрын
QUEEN! 😁 I went for $30 CDA and was in the second row. Still have the ticket and the pamphlet.
@goodtohaveinajam814811 күн бұрын
Went to a Solid Gold taping, and caught the neck half of the guitar Wendy O. Williams cut in half with a chain saw.
@deeannakim930612 күн бұрын
Love Douglas ❤❤❤❤
@andykidd9911 күн бұрын
Douglas is not exaggerating about that Arthur Ashe statue
@terri685411 күн бұрын
No, he is very much exaggerating, but it is a weird design.
@SuperiorLime11 күн бұрын
It literally is like 1/3 of what he explained he did over exaggerate
@andrewwilliams959911 күн бұрын
And made a cheap joke at its expense. Typical NY Post BS.
@davematt200211 күн бұрын
@@andrewwilliams9599oh pls
@procopiusaugustus623111 күн бұрын
The Ashe statue is ridiculous and a local joke. Placed there over the objections of his family at the insistence of the white sculptors fans.
@billyrock830511 күн бұрын
Never burn books or topple statues. 🇺🇸
@firstlast825811 күн бұрын
Gawd bless Murica 🤓 🖕
@silencemeviolateme607611 күн бұрын
@@firstlast8258amen! Where homophobic statues of MLK are allowed because life isn't simple.
@benwu798011 күн бұрын
Superb panel, and Overtime needs to be extended. The book that was mentioned to Eric in the main show, was Sapiens : A Brief History of Humankind, by Yuval Noah Harari. Bill didn't give the author or much about it, but it's one of the finest books in that field. He was on the show back in October 2022, the last show that Quentin Tarantino was on.
@Puffsdad11 күн бұрын
How do you explain history without the statues? Maybe books.
@TheDivayenta12 күн бұрын
I spent one Saturday for two concerts at the Monterey Pop Festival. Saw several of the top bands on Earth. Paid a whopping 3.50 per show.
@nuqwestr9 күн бұрын
1967, my buddy Wally Heider was on stage saving his equipment from destruction by THE WHO.
@Brian-nt1hh9 күн бұрын
Thx Bill
@jeanmckeon689911 күн бұрын
Caught his Tambourine, I'm so jelly!
@tokyodirect459411 күн бұрын
I went to Newton's Cradle High School in NJ then graduated from Benedict Arnold University. I see nothing wrong.
@rafaelmoshe11 күн бұрын
LOVE Douglas Murray. Brilliant, brave voice for today
@fredkeeler46209 күн бұрын
Regardless of one's opinion on Confederate monuments, the mountain carving in Georgia is an enormously impressive piece of art that will be left alone.
@ffvffv57096 күн бұрын
Nothing gets a bigger laugh out of Maher then the thought of a child getting beat!
@M196267711 күн бұрын
That was a great panel.
@piconano11 күн бұрын
Enjoyed this panel. Specially Douglas Murray.
@davidt39569 күн бұрын
Some people still can't admit the difference about teaching history and celebrating the worst of history
@Fu-orksGive.PEACE.achance.11 күн бұрын
I come from Liverpool Uk, we were a slave exporter, we have a slave museum, we understand it was different times, The world has changed. Our Liverpool port was built on money from the slave trade. But the UK was the FIRST country to BAN slavery.
@kadourimdou4311 күн бұрын
You don’t think the majority of the trade of goods, was were where the money came from? Saying it was from slavery is misleading and inaccurate.
@Fu-orksGive.PEACE.achance.11 күн бұрын
It was probably manufactured goods as well, but it's our history, some bits we like some bits we don't, but it's history it's there for us to learn, to accept and grow.
@jeffersonadams871110 күн бұрын
You also provided materiel support to the Confederacy during the American Civil War and allowed them to build a raider in your shipyard, which then set sail from your port and sank numerous Union vessels. You lost any right to boast about being the first country to end slavery the instant you did that.
@Fu-orksGive.PEACE.achance.10 күн бұрын
I'm not boasting , it's FACT. I'm not saying it's all good or all bad it happened, it's documented , ITS HISTORY
@user-vu7yt8pm4p10 күн бұрын
There is a difference between banning slavery and banning the slave trade. The US banned slave trade in the early 1800s, but it took another 50 years to actually ban the practice of slavery.
@westcoast_canuck192611 күн бұрын
Love Douglas Murray
@freem8son8611 күн бұрын
Statues are not how we “remember history”. We use libraries, public education and museums for that. Statues serve the purpose of veneration and glorification. Germany doesn’t have statues of Hitler, South Africa doesn’t have statues of Verwoerd.
@silencemeviolateme607611 күн бұрын
Lee is far from being Hitler. Slavery was legal in the US throughout the war. Lincoln was president of a slave nation.
@g_47849 күн бұрын
That's because those people were ruthless dictators and it's bad faith to compare them to Confederate leaders whose actions were not nearly as bad, and whose history represents sentimental significance for many southerners. It's not all about "learning history". It's about acknowledging it and learning to cope with the past.
@nuqwestr9 күн бұрын
Our civil-war was brother against brother, not the same as your examples. Hitler's Mein Kampf is still being published, a best seller in Turkey.
@billriddle921512 күн бұрын
As always Bill has to be a 100% right,so smug.
@2197201214552511 күн бұрын
He says i haven't changed like its a good thing 😅
@davidanderson_surrey_bc10 күн бұрын
Eh... not true. Bill has admitted to being wrong about something on more than one occasion. And I've often heard him make a statement that his guest immediately refuted, compelling Bill to retract or modify his position.
@blang15 күн бұрын
These $10,000 in ticket sales are probably going straight to the credit card with 23% IR.
@justsayin56099 күн бұрын
the steel balls are called Newton's Cradle, Bill. You, know the famous physicist?
@jimmieeddieschwenk311711 күн бұрын
I went to a QUEEN concert in INDY in January 1977... Standing room only.... Stood 20 feet from the stage... Great show...
@user-pu2yy8xd9x11 күн бұрын
Back hen you had to take film to get developed and wait a week for the pictures of your thumbs!
@paulcicchini142512 күн бұрын
To forget the past is to repeat it
@morbidmanmusic11 күн бұрын
No one forgets if a statue is removed...
@Simon-talks11 күн бұрын
yeah these kids must have forgotten since they want a world run by Lenin now
@andybarrett647211 күн бұрын
@@Simon-talkswrong show. Hannity is sieg heiling for you on Fox everyday and covering all Trumps crimes with bluster about gas stoves and trans phobia. Something to keep you flexing in the mirror for yourself Bro…..
@tonyattardo935011 күн бұрын
@@morbidmanmusic Yes they do, they don’t even realize it was ever there.
@wildcardartsent10 күн бұрын
@@morbidmanmusicWhich will not remove history, the way it happened.
@ld49747 күн бұрын
I'm a black man living in Richmond Virginia. Robert E. Lee was a son of Virginia who just happened to fight for his state (which was the mentality pre-Civil War). I had no issue with his statue on Monument Avenue.
@terrylarrabee380711 күн бұрын
In 1969 I attended a concert with Ike and Tina Turner, BB King, and the Rolling Stones at the Oakland Coliseum. We paid $10 and complained that the cost was outrageous. Things have changed.
@marydauby522911 күн бұрын
I remember when concert tickets were $6 or $8. When The Rolling Stones came to town everyone was outraged that tickets were $15. 😂
@DrNancyLivingCoCreatively11 күн бұрын
Loved the film!!!! Many thanks, Eric. 💙💙💙💙💙
@rLxJake2 күн бұрын
Douglas Murray is a once in a lifetime genius.
@67psychout11 күн бұрын
How will people know history without status? I guess if we still have history classes in schools they can learn it there
@synewparadigm11 күн бұрын
"Revisionist history"
@xaspirate806011 күн бұрын
True, so long as they still teach history straigh-up vs. the new re-write that places facts on back burner so as to appease a certain agenda and generally a negative undercurrent re: Founding Fathers.
@user-vu7yt8pm4p10 күн бұрын
In Ron Desantis's Florida, the history classes would just be more glorification of white ancestors who "built this country", and will mention some ethnic groups that got in the way of that.