Pink Floyd - You've Got To Be Crazy (Early version of Dogs) - Immersion Box

[@FossilisedFishooks]

It's hearing this that makes you realise what a huge loss it is that none of Pink Floyd's major 1970s tours were professionally recorded or filmed.

[@floydnut5908]

Yea, this wembly one is about it

[@SuckMyJohnson]

This sounds professionally recorded to me…but I know nothing

[@blainebaxter7684]

@Grau Zone Roger says he metaphorically has the footage under his bed locked in a chest, well he did for the wall footage so im assuming that goes for any other concert footage. Prolly hasnt been realised due to the current fued between him and david and prolly wont be realised till one of them passes on which is a shame :/

[@williemammoth11]

Which they themselves realized way too late was in part at their own hand, unfortunately for all of us.

[@yourlocalryan]

@@grauzone2866could’ve just been a well setup bootleg operation

[@thunderdrums6551]

This song should be 74 minutes long

[@milkywayexplorer942]

Yes but does not fit a LP !

[@matsreinderink4994]

more like 74 years long

[@danielmeijer4255]

More like 74 centuries long. Oh wait. I wont live long enough to hear the end...

[@patrickrasmussen2666]

@@danielmeijer4255 That's the idea :)

[@creeperhun7er332]

I love for pink Floyd so I could do 740 years

[@deadringer28]

Imagine going to a concert and the first hour is made up of songs you never heard before and your mind is completely blown. Then, after that, you get to hear all the songs you came to the venue to hear. Let's call that Pink Floyd

[@nateds7326]

The songs were this, raving and drooling and a blue print of shine on you crazy diamond right?

[@deadringer28]

@@nateds7326 It was Shine On, Raving and Drooling (Sheep), and then You Gotta Be Crazy (Dogs), for the first hour. Then they played Dark Side of the Moon start to finish and ended with Echoes. If time travel is possible I choose to be here forever.

[@jimo7593]

The other thing few knew about Floyd is they'd typically come back out after the house lights came on and a good portion of ppl left and play a couple tunes, leave, house lights come back on, wait, they'd come out again and repeat. They'd do this about 3 or 4 times at some venues.

[@jfstock25]

@@deadringer28 when I saw them in 1975 it was Have a Cigar, You Gotta Be Crazy, Raving and Drooling, and Shine on to complete the first set. Intermission, then all of Dark Side of the Moon. Another intermission. And then closed with Echoes as their encore. Well worth the $8. 50 for the ticket.

[@deadringer28]

@@jfstock25 I have never seen dave or Rick (God rest his soul) live. I have seen Roger a few times and was very lucky to see Nick and Rog together on the SFOS tour in NYC. If there was a time machine that would bring us all back to that 1975 show, the price to pay would be unlimited. I am glad you enjoyed it.

[@kyokogodai-ir6hy]

Richard Wright, in this recording, showing why he was so important to the band. Amazing!!

[@EnosEverything]

I was at this concert at the Empire Pool and it was terrific... paid less than two quid for a ticket... They did this song which became Dogs and it eventually turned up on Animals and two other new songs one of which ended up on Wish You Were Here - Shine On Y.C.D. ..The other was called Raving And Drooling which was later changed to Sheep - like this track it was developed further and ended up on Animals . ... The programme which I still have, was in the form of a comic... Fabulous days back then....I'm 65 now and still adore music .

[@mikegoldstone6832]

Dude, I was 15 at the time and was there....just wish I had kept the programme but it got lost in a house move. Echoes was the extended finale....

[@desmondmangan3166]

What an epic show that must have been

[@hiramhiram872]

EnosEverything that’s amazing. I’ll bet you’ve been to some good shows. I’m only 31 and I get so envious hearing stories like yours.

[@Rich6Brew]

I was also at the gig, but sat in the expensive seats at £2.40 a ticket. I, too, still have the programme, bought at the princely sum of 15p.

[@davidgardiner4620]

Enos you are right man

[@Jebusisabasser]

When Roger comes in with "and when you lose control" I get goosebumps all over.

[@churchdog]

Same

[@234cheech]

you rep the harvest you have sowin

[@dx1450]

I'm glad they kept this part for "Dogs."

[@failed_little_girl]

And as the fear grows, the bad blood slows and turns to stone And it's too late to lose the weight you used to need to throw around So have a good drown, as you go down, all alone (me there for the goosebumps) Dragged down by the stone

[@bengszy8124]

It's like watching a film by Kubrick or Tarkovsky, it reveals itself so slowly but you're enjoying every second of it.

[@vincentzito3933]

Primal...

[@Oioiou73]

God yesss

[@Erikf_r]

Or Bergman

[@rotunda_]

It seriously sucks that pf never made the music for space odyssey, it would've been awesome

[@philipkingsley5304]

i know what you mean, what I love in art is when the artist takes you into their space and lets you stay a while

[@MrBlueSky474]

And just when you thought you'd heard everything by your favourite band, someone posts a gem like this. This is Awesome! thank you so much.

[@THEbadlnb]

I am right with you MrBlueSky474. I dig your avatar. I drew mine in AutoCAD.

[@TrevBoyThe2nd]

MrBlueSky474 Dogs will always be my favorite but this version is pretty darn good.

[@stewartmcmurry2452]

@@TrevBoyThe2nd yup love Dogs,but this is it's ancestor.

[@papas_lapas]

Just beautiful.

[@BitcoinMotorist]

Have you heard Pigs on the Wing with the guitar solo?

[@cuerollen]

Honestly, this is great- but for me, "Dogs" is a masterpiece.

[@krypto_9872]

this is the start of the masterpiece

[@waynzy6942]

Honest af

[@dvd11811]

Can you name anything between DSOTM and The Wall that was not a masterpiece? About 30 years ago a friend of a friend, who played guitar professionally, said David Gilmour was a "good" guitar player, very technically sound. I just shook my head and walked away. David Gilmour is a GUITAR GOD ... !!! Every note he plays, every chord he bends is brilliant, and not just intellectually, but spiritually as well. While George's guitar "Gently Weeps", David's makes me gently weep ...

[@mcpure9083]

David - Knowbrains even David himself said he didn’t care much for the wall and that there were a few good songs. He’s right

[@dvd11811]

@@mcpure9083 And yet his guitar work on Comfortably Numb is hailed by many as his best work. I think it was more the rift between David and Roger that soured David on The Wall.

[@fbsis]

After 29 year, i´m discovering a new pink floyd song... it is amazing!

[@mrpokemon8778]

Division bell is only 20 this year

[@JeffSense]

+Felipe Fernandes they also have a new album out... The Endless River

[@jordankelsomusic]

Animals is one of my favorite albums! Absolutely amazing!

[@cooper25ism]

mrpokemon8778 division bell is #1

[@mostafaamarof8944]

Me too, but after 42 years of listning to floyd.....

[@ficacar99]

This band for sure has something that many others lack. We can't say exactly what it is but I think it's that strange thing called soul.

[@tlaloc9624]

Very True

[@martinbowden9347]

That so few bands and people seem to have these days..

[@234cheech]

yea its magic

[@BrunoNeureiter]

I think it's called guitars + organ

[@vanessabean4233]

Yes indeed

[@mamasb0y463]

Imagine seeing this live front row, peaking on your LSD trip, my goodness my life would be complete.

[@paulnolan4971]

^^^^

[@guy_in_the_moon]

pure bliss I could die peacefully

[@thinginground5179]

ive got better things to do on lsd

[@matthewjones553]

I can tell you from experience the way they set everything up it's like being the show I was opened up they reached a part of me that I had never seen to be at the focal point of quadrophonics

[@garycollins1545]

Pink Floyd works in progress is better than any other bands finished product. Damn!!!

[@martygrooves]

Exactly

[@jackemin2988]

Ooooooohh maaaaannn

[@hiramhiram872]

Gary Collins Tool comes in a close second.

[@vayres7512]

Nailed it, man

[@itsgottocomeoutsomehow108]

Holy fuck, that's a spot on statement 👌😘👌

[@ormanay]

Never heard this version. Im 54 and a big Floyd fan. Thanks for this treat.

[@michaelmoceri6469]

They played this song live for 2 years before rewriting it and releasing "Dogs" on "Animals" in 1977. Live in Long Island, New York 1975 is a great recording. 🎶

[@CharlieWebb-bp8ll]

Waterfence @ Walking Dunes

[@vincestapels2022]

I know its nothing new to say in this comment section... but Dogs and You've got to be crazy are special pieces of art that mean so much to me. It helped build my understanding of music and still remains my favorites. I pray that Roger or Dave or Nick will really try to find any mastertracks or tapes of these concerts and remaster them... There are different versions of this song with one being Richard Wright seriously playing some melancholy notes. ❤love music

[@sergekannon9048]

Yeah, man! Dogs is by very far my favorite piece of modern music.

[@moisa123]

Gotta love the youtube. This kind of thing was so f*cking rare to find some years ago...

[@ww9718]

Moisés Pol Teixeira I see this was posted 7 years ago and I’m like damn I wonder how they found obscure music back in 2008. This was posted in 2013 ish and that’s so crazy

[@gregpoore2757]

It's awesome and on disc 2 of the Experience Edition remaster of Wish You Were Here.

[@234cheech]

only if you were not into bootlegs had this on tape 30 years ago

[@ssphil2001]

Wow. This version is really dreamy. Love it.

[@davevrox3023]

Yes yeah production is key but this was BETTER

[@jesuschrist6191]

Weird how they sing about cancer and the age 65 when Richard died of cancer at the age of 65

[@cristianandresgonzalezgonz3812]

Muy buena canción de la lleva🤔

[@mclovinpo]

Sad shit

[@fallout3freak360]

and now Eddie Van Halen

[@s7evens4]

In "Point me at the sky" they sang "[...] And if you survive 'til 2005", that year was their last concert, at Live 8. 1 year after, Syd died

[@hauntedbylight]

Yea super weird how a common disease kills someone

[@TheAskald]

I love this version. I still prefer Dogs, but You Gotta Be Crazy is so gentle, chill and sensible. Waters vocals are much more vulnerable and touching. Dogs, while conserving all the melancholy and melody, is a lot harsher and colder.

[@Therealderry433]

The first person I've agreed with on reading comments on you tube about floyd.proceeds to faint.

[@shreddykrueger2408]

Agreed i love both versions dogs is just more in your face

[@dx1450]

I like this version because the lyrics are so manic & quick it's like a metaphor for how life can be hectic and crazy sometimes. But then the guitar interludes kind of slow down & mellow out the song, just like how sometimes we need to take a break from the stress of life and just mellow out.

[@markkeith9055]

Water's really is a good bassist.

[@manuelbm26]

Hell yes!

[@nataliaibarrabermudez906]

I think in this album Gilmour play the bass too!

[@mrjacob0101]

Roger plays bass on Dogs, acoustic guitar and rhythm guitar David plays in the rest.

[@JuanZepp]

but in this live track is waters playing bass xd

[@PinkFloydBootlegs]

Juan Cruz Aldaya Some of the 1977 live versions of Dogs has Roger playing the guitar, along with Gilmour. He also plays guitar on Sheep (live) and Pigs Three Different Ones.

[@magnusgilberg775]

"Trained not to spit in the fan". Guess Roger didn't practice enough, although he had a valid reason to do it.

[@montag4516]

Haha, good catch.

[@sex6cult9revolution]

In all fairness, he didn't spit IN the fan. Rather, he spit ON him. HAHA

[@anycolouryoulike8567]

@@sex6cult9revolution hahahahah good one

[@saintroddy]

Go on Rog, spit on him!

[@marcmartinez4140]

@@saintroddy This comment is underrated lmao

[@mikeyaaaay]

How many musicians/artists would perform songs that haven't been released yet these days? Pink Floyd will always remain undefeated

[@kodredcud]

I was NOT prepared for that PIERCING solo oh wow. Struck me directly in the soul with absolutely full force, because I was not bracing myself as I usually do when I hear David Gilmour play the guitar....

[@clisk35]

gilmour is the freaking best..his solos are legendary .

[@edward4840]

KodredCud I think the point was that Gilmour's soft vocals and the slow tempo eases you into a softer sound, then the guitar starts up and really catches you off guard

[@EchoesonMars]

Pink Floyd was at their best at this time, shame they were fighting like crazy

[@harveyvid]

A lot of times, the fighting produces masterpieces. Floyd, Fleetwood Mac, the Beatles, and I'm sure there's more.Their best work was developed when they were at each others throats.

[@eldenboi8354]

harveyvid Unfortunately youre right about that

[@BrainPolice5]

Don't forget Yes. They fought in completely opposite directions to create their masterpieces too. Sometimes that's what it takes for real group creativity.

[@eldenboi8354]

BrainPolice5 Yes isnt pink floyd fleetwood mac or the beatles though and they dont come close really

[@ubergrendle]

Waters & Gilmour are the Gilbert & Sullivan of Rock'n'Roll.

[@FrostyCranmer]

There's so many great bands, songs, and musicians, yet I'm only drawn to PINK FLOYD 24/7/365

[@Luka.Harutyunyan]

Maybe now you need a Tool?

[@nmol9733]

Glad to know I'm not the only one with this.

[@maxsaviano3586]

Yep. Pink Floyd and Tool is the only music that’s 24/7/365 for me too

[@JaydenMereles3]

Tool and Pink Floyd are the greatest ever!

[@aidank2108]

Imagine hearing this classic song before it even came out.

[@gonzbry7272]

So the Floyd were masters of rap too

[@Therealderry433]

Does it sound like they were

[@Therealderry433]

@@mescalormavideos7767 what,raped?

[@metalfingerz4203]

I feel hating on rap music

[@user2j3ycg4df]

@@mescalormavideos7767 :)

[@isthiswherewecamein6130]

Why not!? Right? I mean they were so far ahead of their time a 10 other areas of their music, why not be THE ACTUAL ORIGINAL O.G's? Lol. God they're like Mozart, it's just timeless! And I've been a fan for nearly 35 years!!! I'm still on here trying to find underground shit that I've never heard!!! I HIGHLY doubt in 35 years people are going to be trying to dig up Kanya's old underground, pre-release, let's just get on stage and rock it out and see how it sounds before we've even been in the studio for it!!! (Or maybe I'm just under rating Mr. West genius? lol?) But God this is just GREAT music.

[@KnottsBear-yTalesPreserved]

I love that this song evolved into Dogs. Its an interesting early look into what will become an iconic Pink Floyd track

[@TheCortymast]

May I present to you: Pinks Floyds "Dogs" from the Album "Wish You Were Here"

[@andrewchen9097]

Followed by sheep from the double album wish you were here

[@cornonthekobi]

Well this did come with a deluxe edition of WYWH

[@dizzee6089]

@@cornonthekobi you serious?

[@AndyAction]

This was the Wish You Were Here tour.

[@OfSoundNFury]

@@AndyAction this was 74 so it must have been Dark Side tour. WYWH a year after

[@mortalkombatgal2]

This should be called "Puppies".

[@dirker4blood391]

No.

[@buriedinblack3424]

Good one.

[@merlowbarret3533]

No

[@bellcau]

Yes

[@eoterror245]

Maybe

[@maximiliankuntner1720]

Oh wow! I'v never heard Waters singing that perfectly! Absolutely amazing!

[@Iracord]

Yeah! In NJ in '75 he sang it very miserably "turns to stone" was Kanye bad!

[@Swizzenator]

I heard he had the beta autotune software.

[@j1g2c3000]

6 people have got to be crazy

[@werdgerl]

Now it's 14 crazy mofos. They must be voting for Hilary!

[@mcbeth4818]

+werdgerl sharad they are!

[@mcbeth4818]

+werdgerl sorry for type error...I meant to say--charade they are!

[@markcoutts7750]

To the 15 who thumbed down....WTF !!! They really must have misread... or not paying attention... They probably don't have a clue what a masterpiece is. ???? You knew it was a Pink Floyd song before clicking FFS ???? I guess everyone has a right to be their own critic, RIGHT ? If I go insane, please don't put your wires in my brain !!! Pink Floyd, still first in Space 😎 MacDogG67. Canada.

[@LimerickOfficial]

now 31 people are crazy

[@DanSheffieldMusic]

Why, why, why? Why didn't they do this version of the coda on the recording? "Dogs" from Animals is a godlike masterpiece of a recording, but after hearing the coda in this version, with Roger desperately singing the main while Dave and Rick harmonize in the round over those huge, conflicted chords which anchor so much of the raw feeling of the song, and Nick slowly, SLOWLY ramps up the tension, adding just a touch of the next big drum fill to each oncoming bar in almost bulletproof time until it's an avalanche that seems to go on forever, I can't help but feel gipped by the coda the studio recording. Yeah, that's right. I'm a grown man sitting here fucking crying to a semi-obscure Pink Floyd live recording. Wanna fight about it?

[@btwtrademe]

+Dan Sheffield To be fair the album version fit with the rest of the songs much better, and I'm sure that's why they changed it. This is kinda what the song would have sounded like if it was released on wish you were here

[@markcoutts7750]

Hey you ! EH ! I couldn't have said that any better ! 👍👍 MacDogG67. Canada.

[@montharee]

Magic? Sure. G

[@papas_lapas]

Allatoona Dan I feel you man, having only heard this version for the first time a week ago its been on constant replay every day and while its not being played the melodies are going over and over in my head 24/7. Pure bliss, shame its not hours long. Also discovered the opening suite to Atom heart mother after having a bizare adversion to it for some reason, what a piece.

[@richf8972]

Allatoona Dan love Floyd I'm 59yrs old, saw them in the 70s, 80s 90s had and have countless "live recordings" of them, one was of them in March 1922 in my home town of Waterbury Connecticut. They played the Waterbury Palace. The whole Dark side of the moon, it was called Eclipsed, played live before it was made a studio album. Then renamed Dark side of the moon. They did Echoes in its full length, Saucer full of secrets, Careful with that ax Eugene, and a few more long tracks.great bootleg double disc.

[@batalumagic]

Lyrics: The lyrics to this GREAT and incredible song after a bit of correction: You gotta be crazy, you gotta be mean You gotta keep your shoes and your car clean You gotta keep climbing, you gotta keep fit You gotta keep drinking, you gotta eat shit You gotta be smug to be a big shot You gotta eat meat to stay at the top You gotta be trusted, gotta tell lies You gotta be able to narrow your eyes You gotta believe they've gotta believe you You gotta appear easy to see through Gotta be sure you look good on the TV Gotta resemble a human being You gotta keep one eye over your shoulder Gonna get harder as you get older Gotta fly south and hide in the sand Gotta forget that you're gonna get cancer And when you lose control You'll reap the harvest you have sown And as the fear grows The bad blood slows and turns to stone And it's too late to lose the weight You used to need to throw around So have a good drown As you go down Alone Dragged down by the stone Gotta be sure, you gotta be quick Gotta divide the tame from the sick Gotta keep some of us docile and fit You gotta keep everyone buying this shit You gotta get you started early Processed by the time you're thirty Work like fuck 'till you're sixty five And then your time's your own until you die I gotta admit to a lot of confusion Pain in the head is the child of collusion Gotta resist the creeping malaise You gotta believe in the way you get out of the maze But you, you just keep on pretending You can tell a sucker from a friend But you still raise the knife to Stranger, lover, friend and foe alike Who was born in a house full of pain Who was sent out to play on his own Who was raised on a diet of shame Who was trained not to spit in the fan Who was told what to do by the man Who was broken by trained personnel Who was fitted with bridle and bit Who was given a seat in the stand Who was forcing his way to the rails Who was offered a place on the board Who was only a stranger at home Who was ground down in the end Who was found dead on the phone Who was dragged down by the stone Footnote: Every time i listen to this i imagine dreaming pink with thousands upon thousands of other people. And.. the.. feeling is... Amazing.

[@galihprasojo40]

And.. the feeling is.. amazing

[@bt9704]

Is this the version that Gilmour said just had way to many words, so they turned it into dogs?

[@kevstaa7121]

Gods work! We appreciate you! Cheers man

[@orionnentity2260]

b t yes, not because it had too many words but because it was hard to play + sing

[@andyj482]

These lyrics and vocal melody are waaaay better than the Animals version.

[@proinsulationjnclocklear5899]

1977 Miami baseball arena.. Haven't heard this version since that night ,my first concert,My search for this illusive gem has concluded.

[@tristancata9146]

proinsulationjnc locklear what a great time to be in Miami

[@The_darkside_of]

This version has such a different feel to it, specially the starting chords... as fellow guitar players would know, the starting chord is different from dogs - takes the songs on a completely different journey but winds back to the same as dogs -great version

[@ProvencalLeGallois]

That's the exact same chords but the tuning is different though

[@The_darkside_of]

In the album version, the opening chord is Dm9 - this version, David uses a Bsus4

[@ProvencalLeGallois]

enzo2enzo2enzo It is definitely Em9 for the opening chord. But Bsus4 notes are also in Em9 (B, E & F#), you were not that far from the truth actually

[@The_darkside_of]

so u dont think a Dm9 for the opening chord? haha very tricky- ur right the Bsus4 are also in Em9

[@ProvencalLeGallois]

enzo2enzo2enzo In standard tuning, the chord progression for this version is: Em9 (022032), Cadd4 (x33010), Bsus2/4 (xx4420) and Bbsus2(addB4) (xx3310). And if you tune your guitar in D tuning, you got the studio version :)

[@pnkflyd66]

I can’t stop listening to this version.

[@jackemin2988]

Oooooooohhh maaaan , because you know what the art is

[@Rebecca-pr4zp]

The golden years of Pink Floyd, the seventies, this performance is perfect 🙏

[@jerryhoward8133]

Really fantastic on so many levels, Gilmour’s guitar work is beyond Ethereal and God rest his soul Richard Wright is so creative and in sync with the vibe. I love to listen to this thru good buds after smoking some really good bud, I got issues.

[@alwantamalus3709]

Shame this concert wasn't filmed. What a great moment of music.

[@MarvelousLXVII]

Lol they would have just been standing there playing it knowing Pink Floyd.

[@iPig]

Gilmour's work on this track is just something else. So simple and so perfect.

[@opalmike1]

So thankful my 13 yo son loves Pink Floyd. When he heard this he immediately was like DOGS!!!!! but then listened carefully and said he likes this better because it was him feel different. BLEW MY MIND.

[@justinmiller5280]

That bass line that Roger slips in to this song from about 5:20 on is so sick...took me a few listens to notice it, but now I can't stop!

[@hiterss]

isn't that Snowy? I believe he plays bass on this song, and roger plays the acoustic guitar

[@anycolouryoulike8567]

@@hiterss Roger played the Bass not the acoustic guitar. David played "his acoustic parts on an electric guitar making it easy to switch between lead and rhythm". Snowy White didn't play on Dogs, he played bass on Pigs (Three different ones). Roger played Rhythm Electric Guitar on Sheep and Pigs. David played lead on Pigs, bass on sheep and lead AND rhythm on Dogs. Sorry for the long comment.

[@hiterss]

@@anycolouryoulike8567 no need to apologise , actually thanks for the info

[@wompus6570]

@@anycolouryoulike8567 Snowy didn't play bass on Pigs, David did.

[@anycolouryoulike8567]

@@wompus6570 I meant _live_ , David played Bass on Pigs (3 different ones) in the _studio version_ , in the live tour David played lead guitar and Snowy White was on bass and Roger on Rhythm.

[@thejohnsweeney]

This is what Dogs sounds like in my head when I haven’t heard it in a while

[@mikespersonalstuff]

Dogs is probably my favorite PF song. But I’m hearing this for the first time? What rock have I been living under for the last 40 years?! Loving this, btw. Thanks for uploading!!

[@OysterBoyo]

You mean "what stone"

[@BubbaZen10]

I feel the same way man. All of this stuff from my old favorite bands keeps just magically appearing on here!

[@nacksha]

STONE STONE STONE STONE STONE STONE

[@KormitTheFrag]

@@BubbaZen10 And The Later Years popping up now as well

[@BubbaZen10]

@@KormitTheFrag Yeah, for real. All kinds of good stuff! I know a lot of purists didn't like them, but i loved momentary lapse and division bell too. Maybe not quite as much, but still pretty great.

[@gary-songwriter]

This is a time capsule of how great bands used to craft fantastic songs. The finished song on Animals is clearly better but it only became so because the band had the opportunity to play it live over and over again. And David had time to tell Roger that his part had too many words for him to sign. And Roger had time to go back and rewrite the lyrics to better serve David. That couldn't happen nowadays. Everyone has a camera phone. Every performance is videoed by multiple fans. And posted on KZbin days later. So the days of bands trying out new material live before recording it are over now. And material will be started and completed in studio. And gems like the finished song, Dogs from Animals, will not happen. Dark Side was only as tight as it was because Floyd had played it for months beforehand. But that was from another time. Happily, for us, the joy is that we have both versions of this great song to listen to. Fans of current bands will not have that luxury.

[@jjackomin]

If someone listens to this and remains unmoved by it then they will never understand why we love Floyd so much.

[@roystonszweda1585]

Is this line: "You gotta keep everyone BUYING this shit?" ha ha Roger... you said it and we did... a nice birthday present all those years ago, really cheered me up!

[@arteml8897]

I know the band is going absolute 100 %, but even though he's not carrying this song alone - you can really appreciate how good a bass player Roger is on this track. Not just performance but it seems every note is crafted and engineered and he plays it to perfection. Some other dude pointed out also the avalanche that Nick Mason stirs up. What a fantastic piece this really is.

[@nyomanwijaya5849]

Still in 2018. All sound from the bass, the guitar, the drum, the keyboard, the vocal as well and they never fade away and never disappear. Make you want to listen again and again

[@rifkyr76]

Wih dari indo nih

[@nyomanwijaya5849]

@@rifkyr76 yup, salam sebagai sebagai penikmat Pink Floyd

[@_lowered.p7b]

I need this one on spotify 😭

[@ege1993]

this version is fucking amazing. wow

[@stephenmello6598]

I'm 56 yrs old and have loved pink floyd since I was a kid and I've never heard this before now. I Love It!!

[@baileyderose7776]

one day they'll put this version on streaming services and that will be a good day for humanity

[@guy_in_the_moon]

one day

[@dx1450]

I recorded the audio from this video and turned it into an .mp3. Shh, don't tell anyone.

[@jackemin2988]

The fluctuations, i mean the up and downs in this MASTERPIECE is just fucking killing me.

[@JohnnyPaton]

Enjoyed this version. it's much more "Floydian" than the later version, before Roger's vitriol changed the musicality of Pink Floyd. Feels more akin to the Meddle/Dark Side/WYWH era than Animals and The Wall especially the slower tempo guitar solos.

[@sacredgeometrymusic3290]

instead of wish you were here I red YHWH, lol

[@altairsp]

Actually Gilmour asked to change the lyrics, because it was a piece very hard to sing and play at the same time.

[@sacredgeometrymusic3290]

@@altairsp intersting, thank you!!

[@OsbalDoee]

Comfortably numb has a slow tempo too and guitar solo of dogs too, actually this version his tempo is faster

[@mt_vu_rx_jukeboxhero]

A tribute to the Who that was Ground down in pretend and was found more than twice in a device. 🐒🐨🐴🐆🐅🐈🐕🐕🐕🐺🐱🐮🐷🐗🐄🐃🐂🐘🐭🐓🐔🐹🐰🐇🐪🐫🐑🐏🐼🐻💬

[@robm9999]

Floyd, getting me through another day in this life. Honestly I don’t know what I’d do without them.

[@rbtyson399]

I keep going back to this. It's fun to listen to Dave playing and singing so uptempo. Seems like he's having to work pretty hard to get all the words out and keep that funky strumming pattern going. Brilliant.

[@MrSodium271]

Best Band Ever

[@clisk35]

damn right ..

[@Syd4510]

I saw this live, all those centuries ago. Wonderful Floyd, and Rick Wright was one of my favourite ever musicians - he had such a great imagination, he was like Syd in terms of musical creativity and unique imagination.

[@raptorlewis273]

I almost love this more than the finalized version and that says a crap ton because Dogs is a freaking masterpiece❤❤❤❤

[@Diegomanriquez91]

"And when you loose control you'll reap the harvest you have sown and as the fear grows the bad blood slows and turns to stone. And its too late to loose the weight you used to need to throw around so have a good drown as you go down all alone dragged down by the stone"

[@wulfB]

roger waters deserves his own nobel prize for these lyrics man

[@minners71]

It's lose not loose. Roger would not like that.

[@ethanbanta4714]

Stone Stone Stone Stone Stone Stone Stone Stone Stone Stone Stone Stone Stone Stone Stone Stone Stone Stone Stone Stone Stone Stone Stone Stone Stone Stone.

[@BubbaZen10]

I feel that too late to lose the weight bit more an' more all the time.

[@BubbaZen10]

@@minners71 He does seem like he'd be a bit of a grammar nazi, don't he then?

[@HaykMartirosyan]

Amazing version, I have impression that discover Pink Floyd after listening them for 30 years. That's great that they've published all this stuff... for long you live and high you fly!!!

[@Drew-jy7dl]

Hayk Martirosyan and bongs you'll rip, and beers you'll buy

[@MrSodium271]

Distribute Floyd Songs Everywhere so it lives on till the end of time. (i think they gonna live anyway)!

[@SirAntoniousBlock]

Yep, drop 'em instead of bombs.

[@WhySoSquid]

"You're never gonna die...they're gonna love you." 👌

[@eddiebazan6411]

Possibly my favorite Floyd recording.thanks guys.

[@sheilasams9515]

I LOVE Roger's Bass on This ✌👍🌹❣💜🎼🎸🎶☮☯️🎛🎙

[@anycolouryoulike8567]

2:35

[@DRomitto]

It's the bass for me, that haunting sound is practically invisible in the final version. The faster vocals are great too.

[@sisir9639]

6:43 that guitar is like the most majestic lightning ever sent down straight from the heavens

[@kentnottingham9635]

I actually laid back with headphones on and listened to a Pink Floyd song!!! Loved it and love knowing where DOGS came from!

[@heliora666]

incredible version love it so much, best guitar work by Gilmour nobody sounds this good live in concert 1973 this is sick

[@TheTwtebrd]

Love the ending in this version, am so stuck on Pink Floyd music and David Gilmour! Come back to California Sir David!!!!! Such a wonderful experience seeing you in March!!!

[@AlobytesOgniddove]

Gilmour's Rap!! ^^ =P

[@diegoholguin8019]

Alobytes Whitestone lmao

[@cannonball666]

Yo, wassup, Dog. It's Heavy G

[@evelyngrace8001]

Wussup nIGGA it’s ya boi d g

[@ethnicleanserberg7975]

He actually said that it was quite hard for him to sing the lyrics here.

[@davejones1811]

Had this on a bootleg along with Ravin' and Drooling and Shine on you crazy diamond. It's great to hear it again and such good quality sound. I'm back at Knebworth once again!!! Thanks for uploading!!!!

[@majman92]

What?! I love hearing rough versions of songs before they got to the album. Dogs is in my top 3 Pink Floyd songs, so this is quite a treat. Thank you!

[@FrostyCranmer]

It’s disappointing that Shine on You Crazy Diamond and Raving & Drooling are finally on iTunes from this 1974 concert, BUT You Gotta Be Crazy doesn’t appear to be available :(

[@asloii_1749]

I agree

[@fletches4084]

search out the "cruel but fair" concert on youtube.

[@pbr6430]

30 people are indeed crazy. This performance is a masterpiece. Need proof? Dave's guitar at 4:10. If that doesn't move you, then you need help.

[@marijanbrkic4875]

Listening to Dogs in 1974 - They were literally before their time!

[@JezuzIsLord]

I love this more than the album version...Gilmour shows why he is a rock god in this version.

[@ChrisGarmon]

I hear a whole lot of "Embryo" in here. The bass and guitar sound especially during Gilmour's first solo are very close to the stellar BBC live versions they played around 70/71.

[@maxsaviano3586]

Good connection

[@FrankyboyFloyd]

OMFG!!!! Thank you so much for this!!... Like a new Pink floyd song after all these years! There will never be a sound, a guitar, a band like this again... never!

[@mrbeatmaster61]

Incredible make wish there was an album cover to study like I use to do back in the 70s🎹🎹🎹🎹🎹

[@isthiswherewecamein6130]

I know this is gonna sound corny as all hell, but when you are laying in bed with the ear buds in, and you close your eyes, this music kinda magically transports you in your mind to another dimension, in the visual T.V. in the mind. Flying next to supernovas, out through the beauty of the milky way, past beautiful planets of Emerald Green, then ones so blue and Icie they look like giant diamonds, next onto a volcanic planets of exploding fire.. !!! Then the song ends and you literally feel like you've had a 15 minutes vacation from life and reality!!! God, a part of me wishes EVERYONE got what I'm talking about, BUT, I'm glad only Floyd fans can get what I'm saying, even if it doesn't have the same effect on different ones or all of us, but as Floyd fans we can each understand that almost indescribable and moving feeling WE GET from hearing the GENIUS that is PINK FLOYD!!!!

[@franciscoaragao5398]

Frog Stillwagon yes, yes, yes

[@GOOCHIElicker]

Its crazy even without psychedelics it has such a profound touching spiritual power to this song and the band. With psychedelics it is just so damn amazing my first time listening to pink floyd on mushrooms was so amazing insane closed eyed visions flowers growing and dying and being reborn again beautiful play of colors dancing around to the music and you feel IT and everything and the one.

[@gonzbry7272]

You're right that sounded corny as hell

[@tommeagher8058]

I think your subliminally thinking of the movie, "live at Pompeii ". The part on "echoes ."

[@wendynoto4726]

HALLELUYAH

[@robertobell1202]

Brano stupendo!!! Che melodia e che atmosfera magica.... Da quando ho scoperto questa versione è la mia preferita....

[@canbebekoglu590]

You see Gilmour at his peak as a guitarist here

[@Craigevansagain]

Never let The Man tell you what to do is the key lesson from this awesome Pink Floyd music.

[@nicklewis1882]

4:10 we know what to expect now, but I love to imagine the audience here listening to this for the first time, thinking the song is winding down to its conclusion. Then they're hit by this fantastic haunting Gilmour riff, and guess what, folks: this song has hardly just begun!

[@shirtshine73blitz]

I saw them do this at the LA Sports Arena in 74. They also did a song called Raving and Drooling.

[@Xenotypic]

lucky

[@davidblondin8447]

dam masterpiece. I want to hear this whole concert. Sounds like a real good recording.

[@julianm9876]

I believe it comes from the "getting better all the time" tour. You have a playlist on YT, but not with this one idk why

[@istinapravda7956]

Gilmour guitar is hitting strait to heart

[@alph1057]

I can’t believe that this is the first time that I’ve heard this, and I’ve been a loyal fan of theirs since 1978

[@MuktadirAlam]

This is so much better than the actual 'dogs' version. Currently my life's theme song..

[@NelsonRealTime]

Listening to this while watching the Aurora Boreales would be amazing.

[@juanrob7]

Aurora Borealis?! At this Time of Year, At this time of Day, In this part of the country, Localized entirely within your Kitchen!?

[@kevinthetruckdriver353]

*Perfect for an incoming garden variety thunderstorm still miles away at night sitting in a car.* Played the Star Wars theme (single 45 version of the orchestra version of A New Hope) and it matched the lightening. *It was cool.*

[@oscar.berry_dorkus]

This song was an unforgettable luncheon

[@captainmoondog1947]

What? But how? If the lyrics it's so sad

[@charlesweeks5027]

Pink is special , not even all the others from this era have that mystical magic.

[@davidstewart4780]

9:20 That guitar is so beautiful all by itself. So much editing, so many decisions they had to make in re-writing and finalizing. This is a real tribute to their brilliant abilities!

[@thecannetwork7559]

This is sonically a most beautiful version

[@olivierrossel6080]

Unbelievable how this song is played in a much softer manner, w.r.t the version in the Animals album.

[@michaelward266]

Got a bootleg album from 1974 tour with this and Raving & drooling

[@deadringer28]

Imagine hearing a song 3 years earlier than it was released and having your mind blown

[@jerryhoward8133]

Love the words, love the music, amazing song. RIP Mr Wright you were a legend.

[@LongSinceDead1]

It’s literally an early version of Dogs. It’s pretty clear since it’s mostly the same structurally lol. Still, this one has a much more psychedelic atmosphere that I really love.