Palestinians: If the occupation ends, will there be peace?

This project is made possible by donations from viewers like you.
Please donate to the project at:
* www.paypal.me/coreygilshuster
* www.gofundme.com/Ask-Project
* / askproject
.
Want to know what Israelis and Palestinians in the Middle East really think about the conflict? Ask a question and I will get answers.

[@ijjimem]

Ask them: "Why won't you lose with honour?"

[@nabeelgz3167]

This is not the Olympics

[@mot9769]

Arabs hold great honor, chivalry and respect. Which never loses.

[@williamrappaport9203]

@ijjimem, Another question would be “why are you intent on Jews not have a country like your fellow Arabs do?” Arab countries are 20+ to 1 for Jews, and Arabs in Gaza are fighting to get rid of this sliver of land for Jews.

[@hannabard5455]

The Palestinians who are willing to compromise, almost make me tearyeyed of joy. I have cared about the conflict since 2001 when I was 13 and I have no personal ties to it except the fact that it has been important for me for such a long time. I also understand the Israelis and Palestinians who are not willing to compromise, but in all conflict, compromise is necessary.

[@user-hs4dm9xq5e]

+++, the troubles(and yes, that civil war as well) in Ireland did not end with Irish independence, but at least it was an important first step and really helped. And here it's an excruciating torture to make even first 0,5 of a step. I personally feel same for Israelis who are against occupation-but the polls make my eyes wanna bleed, apparently the war camp will rule for the next couple of years.

[@honeybunny235]

yes.

[@hamzaali2310]

To compromise is to Is to give up our right, is to betray the rest of our Palestinian people in the camps and in the 48 T

[@Petal4822]

Palestine never belonged to the Palestinians. It was never stolen. Palestine - was a region that both Jewish and Arab people shared - it was always a part of other empires, never an independent country. That is why there was never a King of Palestine. The UN partitioned the land into a two states. To accommodate both the Jews and the Arabs. in 1947. The Arabs rejected their half of the partition because they wanted the two halves. In 1947 India and Pakistan managed the two state Partition of India into two independent countries. India and Pakistan were not as greedy as the Palestinian Arabs. Now that Israel exists and is not going any where it’s too late now. That would be like India demanding Pakistan back.Lol

[@ravisingh7928]

@@Petal4822 comparing india pakistan with palestine is absurd.... you're either ignorant or a liar

[@veroniques.p.8707]

"There will be peace when palestinians get ALL the land back !" If there is no Israel anymore, who will you make peace with? hamas or fatah ??

[@ailuros]

@@veroniques.p.8707 Why refuges can’t return in their homes, if land is not stolen?

[@rickytikitavi4101]

With Israel gone, they'll realize they've been sold a lie for 73 years. The lie that going back to pre-48 borders will solve all of their problems. Their "dream country" will become another Muslim brotherhood infested dictatorship in the middle-east, because for 7 decades they never envisioned any sustainable future, other than destroying Israel. And as history has proven again and again: if you build an entire collective identity on negating someone else's sovereignty - when you no longer have the big bad "OTHER" to fight against, you'll turn on each other. If it ever comes to pass, the Christian Palestinians will be the first to learn that.

[@rickytikitavi4101]

​@Oussama11 My logic is quite sound. The Arabs could have had their homes if they hadn't waged a war against the Jews when the partition plan was announced (and frankly, for 3 decades before that). They lost the war they started, along with a good portion of the lands allocated to them, and have been repeating the same mistake ever since. Well, it doesn't look like they learned anything from the past so their future is guaranteed to be a disaster as well. The entire human history is full of wars that have been fought and lost. The Arikara people were driven out of the Black Hills of North America by the Cheyenne peoples. Then the Lakota peoples arrived from Minnesota in the 18th century, drove out the Cheyenne to the west, and claimed the land as their own sacred territory. Then the gold rush happened and The US government took the Black Hills from the Lakota and European Americans from the south settled in the area. The Lakota, still bitter at their loss, will never admit that they themselves did to others what has been done to them. And even so, their life quality is immeasurably better than it would've been if it wasn't for the US. The same exact thing goes for the Palestinians. Just one example to illustrate my point is the famous Muhamad Hadid, Bella Hadid's father, who still whines about becoming a refugee from Safed at the age of 1 years old. At the same time, he boasts about his maternal grandfather who was an sheik from an Arab tribe that originated in the Hijaz, who destroyed at least 9 Druze villages and drove much of the Druze population out of the Galilee region to what is now Syria. Ask any of the remaining Druze people near Safed how they feel about the Al-Zaydani period, and trust me, they won't have kind words to offer. This is all to say that those who, instead of building a sustainable future for their children, uncompromisingly cling to an imaginary glorious life (that never existed in material reality outside of Palestinian propaganda) in the ruins of a village 40 kilometers from their current residence, where several dozen farmer families lived with no electricity connection, no sewage system and no schools, are hurting only themselves and future generations. Personally, I don't care if they repeat the same mistake for another hundred years, but what I'm saying is simply the truth, as taught to us by history.

[@rickytikitavi4101]

@Oussama11 Please don't try to sell me this BS propaganda about peaceful living with the Arabs, ok? Amin El-Husseini was supportive of the Nazi cause, and personally met with Hitler. He orchestrated the 1936-1939 riots that pushed the Brits to limit Jewish immigration to the Land of Israel (BEFORE WW2) causing many Jews to die at the hands of Nazis. One woman in the video mentions her family is from Lifta. What she forgets to mention is that the Arabs of Lifta attacked the Jewish villages nearby in 1929 and 1938 (again- BEFORE WW2). Jews had every right to live in the land of Israel, certainly no less of a right than Arabs from Arabia. The Arab nationalists rejected all Jewish claims to the land because they wanted to have a pan-Arab state in the entire middle east, and didn't agree to share. To this day Article 1 of the Palestinian National charter from 1968 states that "Palestine is the homeland of the Arab Palestinian people; it is an indivisible part of the Arab homeland, and the Palestinian people are an integral part of the Arab nation." It rejects entirely any sovereign state that isn't Arab, on ANY part of the land, as it has for more than a hundred years. Which is why Palestinians keep loosing.

[@NOTredot]

@@rickytikitavi4101 very well said!

[@maxschmidt1787]

if people dont have get peace in their hearts ... there will be no peace outside in the world ...

[@Larrypint]

That's why Palestinian arabs get brainwashed to hate in mosques,school and media

[@Larrypint]

@Oussama11 lol that's exactly the same argument you could have against many Muslim country's who conquered and ruled over many other tribes and territories and empires and nations in the exact same way by establishing Islamic laws . I understand your standpoint but that is far to biased/onesided. At the end it's about conquer and rule and a clash of cultures. The question is how to solve it my friend?

[@user-ch7hn8dd8j]

@@Larrypint kzbin.info/www/bejne/sHyrhWmQrbaEjNk

[@Larrypint]

@Oussama11 OK that sounds good in the theory but how you wanne bring Christians,orthodox jews, zionists,moderate secular Muslims,fundamental Muslims, Druzen, yesides,kurds, atheists and the Judaism,Christianity and Islam under one feudalistist system with the same laws? Should they be secular with Parlaments, parties and a modern state system or based on on one specific religious theocratic system?

[@Larrypint]

@Oussama11 that was no answer to my question. How you wanne bring all these different religions and ethnical groups under one state with one law system. What kind of law system should that be?

[@theaaronzhu]

Corey said to this woman "most refugees don't go back", Jewish people were the refugees thousands years ago, but why do them go back to Canaan today?

[@edyosed]

Jace_From_Spaaace ! Ur isn't in turkey it's in modern Iraq

[@SigalDa]

palestinian are from saudi arabia they should go back to this palce.

[@Spiritusp]

after thousands of years. only some of their descendants. with lots of luck

[@kkkk2493]

Dardahan there not from Saudi Arabia you unedecuated piece of shot go back to Europe

[@rennyskiathitis8178]

Yes, it took Jews over two thousand years to return home. In all intents and purposes that means you don't return home. So the Palestinians have 2000 years and they can return home.

[@hagitaleinikov8643]

So sad, most of them don’t accept Israel even on a meter/ inch in that land. Israel have to protect itself.

[@alijackson8630]

What About The Settlements Which is increasing day by day in the West Bank and around the Palestinian cities😂, Israel is the stronger party and does not want peace at all.This is a fact that is difficult to be peace

[@mfbj1]

@@alijackson8630 Israel offered to give it all up in 2000, 2005 and 2008. Your leaders refused it time and time again for their own clout and wealth, you’re their hostage but you just don’t see it yet.

[@VIP1G]

@UCMP6j9fbOII5VgX_mcGDL-g yeah took all the land and offered a peace of Shit

[@hagitaleinikov8643]

@@VIP1G “took all the land” - check if it’s true. Hint: it’s not.

[@VIP1G]

@@hagitaleinikov8643 i think you don't understand what sarcastic means Дебил

[@ralphgreenjr.2466]

My take from this video is peace is not possible unless Israel vacates 1948 lands, 1967 lands, and ceases to exist as a state. The Palestinians will never see any of this. The reality of this situation is there is an Israel state and there needs to be a Palestinian State with lands agreed upon peacefully, but neither side appears to give an inch. They would rather attend funerals than live in peace.

[@ef2718]

All relative, lookup: Wars and Casualties of the 20th and 21st Centuries

[@rennyskiathitis8178]

The Palestinians don't want peace, if they wanted peace they would have chose peace in 2005 when Israel compromised and gave them all of Gaza in hopes for peace. The Palestinians never wanted peace, that is why the conflict began in 1948 with the creation of Israel. The conflict exists because Israel exists. It's that simple.

[@MirroringTruth]

Always a good watch. Thanks for posting.

[@MrOpenConversations]

in reference to the 48 lands "Yes it would be required, its my hometown". if she is at least 73 i'll eat my hat. My father got out of Uruguay when he was 20. He was afraid Escobar's family was going to plea to be sent there. He didn't want to deal with drug dealers coming to his hometown and the fear associated with that. He came to the U.S. and never looked back. I would never cry about that being my home. Unless I actually grew up there and was removed by another.

[@deana777]

my grandparents were born in haifa and jaffa before 1948, when they were forcibly evicted and their land was stolen. subsequently, their children (my parents) were born as refugees. a generation later, i was born in australia and ive lived here all my life. yet, i practise palestinian culture everyday- whether it be the dialect i speak, the food i make and eat, the music i listen to, the cultural clothes i wear to events, the traditions i uphold etc. (note: i have arab friends that aren't palestinian- the culture they practise is distinctly different, affirming the uniqueness of the palestinian culture i observe. many try to lump us all as one group- thats just not true) because of this, palestine will forever be my homeland. you can't deny the cultural linkage that is very much alive.

[@messianic_scam]

not the same idiot

[@BizznessBox]

@deana777 And what about the people who were on the land before Muslims stole it?

[@malvolty4967]

respect for you and your great work !

[@bevin9736]

Ask palestinians if they know what the word "palestine" means and where it originates from?

[@Daniel-zl5cr]

He asked it already... They have no fucking idea watch?v=i_1wZSXEofE

[@huh4190]

The very word "palestine" is a Roman insult for Israel, derived from a Hebrew word, Philistine, that means invader and has nothing to do with muslim invaders of Israel. There isn't even a letter "p" in the so-called "arabic" language, which is of course stolen from Hebrew, as there is nothing muslims won't steal from Israelites!!

[@marokaisrael]

im embarrsd for the fakestinanes

[@user-rn8nn1hw1z]

they cant care less about peace. they want land and Israel to die. no yearning for peace. they're having a good life, they dont need to go to the army, if they'll do nothing wrong no one would harm them

[@guywhousesapseudonymonyout4272]

@ j senor re _it's written 4 times in the old testament, it clearly originated from jewish writings. sucks when your own history returns and fucks you hey_ There is no mention of "Palestine" in the TaNaKH, which you referred to as "Old Testament". However (1) "Pellesht" is mentioned as the territory of the Philistines, a seafaring people that likely originated from the present-day Mycenian Grecian Isles region. (2)There is no clear cultural or historical link between the Arabic-speaking non-Jews who have adopted the name "Palestinian" to describe their national identity in recent decades and the long-extinct Philistines. And (3) the term Philistines likely derives from the Semitic root "P/L/SH" which connotes a an intruder or an invader. It's odd that a group which claims indigenous status assumes a name which means they are foreign invaders, but whatever.

[@shadowfox6438]

What the hell. Hey, you wanna go back to your hometown? Well you cant because my grandparents cant. What sort of argument even is that...

[@Napoleon501ste]

Peace requires sacrefice. Look at the lands germany gave up to poland, millions of germans could never return home. But they accepted that this was thz price of peace. Peace isnt always the return to the pre war situation.

[@hazmoses1324]

@@Napoleon501ste and what is israel sacrificing for this peace?

[@warpedcomedy]

It's not her hometown it's her grandparents hometown.

[@hazmoses1324]

@@warpedcomedy so israel is not the country for the jews its the country for the ancestors of the jews

[@youtubedeletestomanyaccoun4247]

@@hazmoses1324 yea if you use that logic is shows there’s definitely a flaw. Tho the early Zionist didn’t really use refugee as an excuse but instead aggressively purchase land to return. I think the best medium is a 1 state equal for everyone solution where instead of Palestinian literally going back to their “exact house” which is mostly destroyed decades ago, israel/Palestine expands the cities like Acca Yabne vice versa so they can move back without doing exactly what happened to their own ancestors and to the ancestors of the Jews

[@JoeCiliberto]

Great work Corey, keep it up, people need to talk, to be honest, to listen to one and other and work it out.

[@avigailbc1]

Their is no one to talk to clearly Palestinians don't want peace..

[@itsytyt5192]

ממ

[@RoccosVideos]

I hope there will be peace one day but my outlook is guarded.

[@maracohen5930]

Except there are no 1967 Borders. There were Armistice Lines, post the 1948 Arab League Invasions. The Land they call "Occupied" was granted as Jewish National Home by the League of Nations at the agreement of that Organization's assignments was done in 1922. These Arabs were given TransJordan. This was what was legally done with formerly Ottoman Turkish Lands. These people are Arabs. And no, both they, and the Jews were subject Peoples of the Turks.

[@yaheladom2440]

The muslims say"will be peace when we push to jews to the sea"

[@mahmoudsarout7008]

There will be peace when the occupation state that resides on the land of Palestine ends As for that phrase that you said, its owner was Gamal Abdel Nasser, the president of Egypt in the middle of the last century, and he was a socialist communist We are not Westerners or infidels until we hold their children and women accountable for the actions of their army and mercenary government

[@truthseeker1068]

ofc why not haha

[@thehonesttruth415]

jordan is 70% palestinians, its their home, they move in and out like their home.

[@yaheladom2440]

@@thehonesttruth415 Israel for jews. Arabs for country Arabs. Palestians can Live in their countries, Siria and Jordania.

[@ailuros]

@@yaheladom2440 So Russians can be kicked out of Siberia because there more Russian land elsewhere? What a psychotic take. People want to live where they always lived and where their ancestors are buried.

[@Assaf_yosef]

.What occupation? The Arabs conquered half the world Egypt, Iran, North Africa, Syria, Lebanon, Jordan, all countries occupied by the Arabs

[@avigailbc1]

But then they can't handle their own countries so they run away to Europe, But for some reason they are not leaving Israel, I wander way..

[@omniyashafik2552]

@@avigailbc1 lol bitch we handle our countries fine. Stop killing babies first.

[@karimtit4897]

@Kamil Taibi "became arabs" Well in that logic, the land there became (back) jewish. It's not a good argument.

[@karimtit4897]

@Kamil Taibi wow, no come on. They have food, music, language. It's a more than just religion, let's be honest.

[@karimtit4897]

@Kamil Taibi Well no, they did have a country and civilzation of their own, but they were kicked out by the Romans. And look man, I'm doing PhD in math. Like we (the arabs) did invent some cool math, astronomy and philosophy in the past. But after the 14th century, our scientific output has been almost 0. Plus the jews did help us a lot, in Andalus for example, and in Bagdad, they were part of this great civilization and helped building it. And in the modern time their output in science has been really big. Just look at Einstein or John Von Neumann (my scientific heroes tbh). No it's not honest to say that like that. And like without their culture, christianism and Islam would not exist.

[@nancyjankoski5339]

Why didn't Arab leaders vote to accept the UN resolution 181? There could have been a Palestinian state 70 years ago. But the Arabs said no. Why are there people kept in refugee status for 70 years going now into the fifth and sixth generation? Because the Arab states won't accept their fellow Arab refugees who speak the same language, have the same religion and same culture into full citizenship. And the UN UNWRA have a vested interest in getting international money to keep their jobs. Most of these speakers admit what world leaders want to pretend isn't so. They don't want peace with Israel they want Israel gone. And that is just not going to happen.

[@rennyskiathitis8178]

Here's a question for Palestinians, the "occupation" of Gaza ended in 2005, why didn't the end of the occupation bring peace between Gaza and Israel?

[@marksimons8861]

They are blithely unaware of the fate of Poles in Lvov, Turks in Salonika or Armenians in Turkey.

[@user-im3fc4kb2w]

If they don't recognize Israel why should Israel recognize them simple.

[@user-im3fc4kb2w]

@Oussama11 learn history

[@user-im3fc4kb2w]

@Oussama11 nobody teach me nothing I do my own learning.

[@johnterry4201]

@Oussama11 not stolen ...voted in the United Nations.... actually most Palestinians are migrants from Arab countries like Syria, Egypt, Saudi Arabia.

[@johnterry4201]

@Oussama11 ... first ,Anyone that reply with ha ha Ha he’s a fucking moron, Second, I’m not Israel I am an American, third who gives a fuck about united nation, fourth, it’s a Jewish state they don’t have to ask permission from no one where to have settlements, you forgot that you lost the war..... losers. So get the fuck out ,or shut the fuck up, there’s two options still open for you.

[@broadcastmadnesss]

You were very rude to the Pharmacist, Corey. Classy lady.

[@TiagoSilva-ei7sd]

Mosque noise is a total lack of respect and public disturbance.

[@ef2718]

Few modern mosques where the local imam wanted to act nice with the neighbors started using a smartphone app.

[@semsemeini7905]

We the Jews of Egypt, Iraq, Syria, Libya etc can't go back. Anyway as one guy said Peace would be "temporary."

[@Agamemnon1002]

I am a supporter of the Palestinians, and their right to self determination. However, there has to be a compromise and an acceptance that at best the 1967 borders can be the solution. Besides, beyond a two state solution there needs to be a two state cooperation in terms of economic cooperation and the sharing of resources such as water. In other words, you cannot just ignore each other even if a two state solution becomes reality. Actually, with inspired leadrship on both sides and a leap of faith the mess that currently is the middle east can become a paradise.

[@rennyskiathitis8178]

Their were no 1967 borders, just armistice lines created after Israel's war of independence. Both sides actually explicitly stated that they weren't borders. The West Bank and Gaza have nothing to do with International law. They are just the lines drawn when the war of independence ended. a war the Arabs started by the way. Lets not forget that the Arabs in Palestine were offered peace and statehood and instead chose war. Over and over they have been offered peace and statehood and always choose war.

[@anna-jh7zy]

"Does there need to be peace?" well yes that's the concept behind solving a conflict...

[@yassers5970]

Why do you have to make Right of Return a condition for this question? Are you negotiating the final stages of agreement on behalf of Israeli government here?

[@yassers5970]

@@rv2167 Other than the obvious bullshit, still not relevant to the question. You are asking them if they want peace. Keep it simple and generic, and enough with your dirty ways.

[@jayavani7801]

Imagine if Indian Hindus who came from Pakistan and Bangladesh think like this there would be atleast 30 to 40 million refugees who are entitled to their homes in Pakistan,Because majority of Hindus like Palestinians didn’t accept partition at that time. I can’t wrap my head around this video !! So disappointing!! I wish there will be peace for Palestinians!!

[@gemeaux2450]

he's so argumentative with Palestinians and so biased !

[@ohadtes1]

Does peace for palestinians means Treaty of Hudaybiyyah which means a temporary cease fire? Can any palestinian here please answer that question?

[@ohadtes1]

and where does the palestinians refugees that were inside the israeli 1948 boreders go? would you invite them to live in your city or would you tell them to continue west to where they were before?

[@hazemght4654]

@@ohadtes1 I'm as a refugee, I don't want to kick all Israeli out, just let us live together and end the story. my hometown in Haifa but now I'm living in Gaza, we have more lands in the country, it's not a big deal, but the Israeli government needs only jews. there are many Immigrants jews coming from different areas in the world and Isreal accepts them and builds settlements they can do the same for Palestinian refugees, and you know they every time confirm that the number of jews must be more than Arabs(Demographically).

[@fantasticfoodcanada9373]

@@hazemght4654 we don’t trust you. Kick your Hamas terrorist and stop 🛑 kill Jew . Be peaceful people and then we might trust . Even that need time to believe to Arabs that they want peace ✌️ with Jew

[@user-ch7hn8dd8j]

@@fantasticfoodcanada9373 you guys need to be peaceful too kzbin.info/www/bejne/sHyrhWmQrbaEjNk

[@fantasticfoodcanada9373]

@@user-ch7hn8dd8j we are

[@death-aura]

Palestinians in a nutshell: "yes of course there will be peace [but there will be no israel because we will have all the lands]"

[@aeskin1]

My ancestors were ethnically cleansed from Belarus in 1941. I don't have any right to go back to my grandparents' hometown in Belarus, neither do I want to.

[@mohamedsherif8847]

Corey just because they deported your family from Russia or Ukraine which is wrong doesn't make it right for her to be deported from her home town am talking about pharmacist. what is wrong is wrong

[@mika274]

He is not saying it is not wrong. What he is saying is that it would take the use of force to get back land you were forced to leave. It is on accepting that you won't get you land back and refraining from using force to get back this land that peace can be achieved

[@shevetlevi2821]

They are hard-wired against any peace or resolution or compromise. They want nothing less than everything that they want. In the Israel-Egypt peace accords the process got hung up for quite a time over a 600 meter stretch of beach at Taba, where Israel built a $40,000,000 resort. Sinai is 15,000 square miles and they wouldn't budge over 600 meters of beach. Israel gave them Taba and the resort. The peace agreement was definitely worth it; 40 plus years of a peaceful (albeit cold peace) border but it speaks to Arab intransigence. Then there's Gaza. Unilateral withdrawal by Israel in 2005. The beaches in Gaza are beautiful. They could've had a wonderful resort economy but they made it into a rocket base and tunnel strewn sewer. I only see the status quo in my lifetime.

[@hazemhatem9701]

you are occupying the land and asking the people to be happy and grateful to return their own rights?

[@SRBOMBONICA86]

@@hazemhatem9701 still Arabs are stubborn people though

[@SRBOMBONICA86]

Absolutely,i noticed that stubbornness in Arabs a lot ha ha

[@shevetlevi2821]

@@hazemhatem9701 How can we occupy our own land? The Jewish people are the indigenous people of Israel. YOU are the foreign invaders, yet we make every effort to live next to you in peace.

[@AC-iw8wu]

​@@hazemhatem9701 Palestinian, n, pl -s = A people originating from imperialist invaders (Arabs) named after an extinct people of imperialist invaders (the Greek Philistines), by a people of imperialist invaders (Romans). Free Israel 🇮🇱

[@Ravi-ot6xj]

Never give up an inch coz they will never be satisfied. I am advocating the same in India. Muslims use peace as a pretext to grab more and more land. So never surrender.

[@SomeoneSomewhere-el3cl]

Shut it hindu

[@mdmdmd63]

Exactly. In the western world we see peace as something romantic. When he asks them they don’t even give it a close interpretation. Peace is kul il Palestine, kul il alam. Fucking brainwashed

[@Lildizzle420]

will there be peace if the occupation continues?

[@AlexHolland123]

Wow im suprised having independence wouldnt be good enough for them and they'd want violence to continue. To be honest most these answers just seem really illogical to me. Based in pride rather than what makes sense. They dont live in what is now Israel anymore. There's no need to have it all back, its just pride. Isnt a better life what matters, not vengeance. Continuing violence would just continue poor standards of life. Its kind of like if Native Americans asked to have the entire country of the United States back, that would just be ridiculous based on current context. Well, I hope a two state solution does happen. And I hope minds and hearts would change in that situation towards peace rather than needlessly continuing conflict.

[@millevenon5853]

The two sate solution is Jordan. You can never please Arabs

[@ghofranesalhi7386]

@@millevenon5853 yes you can please us by giving us our land back. ALL of it. We will keep fighting for every inch of it until the end of times. No peace on stolen land. Thats what those zionist thieves need to understand.

[@honeybunny235]

@@ghofranesalhi7386 it is NOT a stolen land, it used to be belong to the Jews until the Romans took it in year 70. and if the Palestinians want it so bad, Y didn't they made it a real state before the Jews needed it back. now, its true that the way they took it back wasn't right, but the Jews deserve to have there tiny. little state where they feel welcomed among there own people. there are 22 Arab countries, and only ONE Jewish. stop being so egoistic.

[@ghofranesalhi7386]

@@rv2167 Inbelievable. The extent to wich you guys can go to "prove " your point. You just inversed what actually happened. It is the jews who came to palestine from everywhere during the last century . The palestinians are descendants of the Canaanites who came to this land 3200 before JC. Most of these people chose to convert to islam in the 7th century. You do realize that being arab is an ethnecity while being jew is a religion. Right? The amount of endoctrination in next level. I suggest you study the history of Palestine. Please . So you don't embarass your self by spreading these blatant falshoods. Have a good life.

[@user-ch7hn8dd8j]

@@rv2167 kzbin.info/www/bejne/sHyrhWmQrbaEjNk yeah they are the insane ones

[@alissaabrahams9012]

These videos of the Palestinians are so upsetting. 50 years later and the Palestinians in the territories think the Jewish people are aggressive colonizers who dont belong in Israel. Theyve been taught to hate and dehumanize the Israelis in PLO run schools. Its all very depressing with no solution.

[@user-gf2lr6vq4m]

Did you know that if you put 100 black ants and 100 red ants in a jar, nothing will happen? But if you shake the jar hard, the ants start killing each other. The red ants consider the black ants their enemies, and the black ants consider the red ants their enemies. The true enemy is the one shaking the jar. The same thing happens in human society. So, before we attack each other, we should think about who is shaking the jar! - Kurt Vonnegut

[@84Latty]

Neither side has “compromise”in their vocabulary

[@amit0000]

not possible with Muslim.

[@ssheikh3598]

Dalito/Shudro ko marnewalo yaha maa mat chuda !! tumhari gand mar ke rakha hai Chandrashekhar Bhaiya ne !! Chamar meri jaat, Dharm se Musalman !!

[@Sk-sllk]

Palestinians are not only muslims!!!!!

[@shadowsaber3]

amit kumar Singh what about the Christians? Same huh? So you are a bigot and a disgusting jew

[@yusuufibrahim530]

Not all Palestinians are Muslim. Toilet india!

[@hexagramz5115]

@@Sk-sllk if they were all christians, we would have no conflict, that's for sure.

[@berserker912]

Lol on the same afternoon the IDF withdrew from the West Bank these guys would start shooting rockets into Israel.

[@TheJacksmith500]

The rockets are made of dirt and cardboard, not really a threat

[@josephsaff]

@@shadowsaber3 It's logical that because that's what they believe that that's what they would do. Which is exactly why they don't leave. Where is the evidence they slaughtered 'hundreds of thousands of innocents'? I don't see how this hyperbole helps anything.

[@shadowsaber3]

@@josephsaff hyperbole? Everyday on the news you walk in their homes with bulldozers and kill those who refuse to ecavuate...go to america and do that you will be killed 100 times over..wake up

[@aaronmeyer9618]

@@shadowsaber3 Have you ever been to America?

[@bernardfurst9133]

There will be peace only after one side destroys the other. And that's the truth.

[@Seanonyoutube]

Or when both sides stop believing their religious delusions.

[@ef2718]

@@Seanonyoutube The Mehdi/Messiah will come before that happens.

[@MiguelGarcia-vm9tj]

I know that you deserve the right to make sarcastic comments... but sometimes it feels really annoying. I rather just hear their honest answers, you are not going to change anybody's mind. Thanks for the effort though.

[@alinaveed6628]

7:35 I saw my country flag behind .

[@omarhellotahiri7097]

Free flag when you import haloumi cheese

[@death-aura]

wait so she's 70 years old?

[@deda9829]

"If you want me to come to more crazy places like this" lol smh

[@melinavdw342]

Yeah wtf I was thinking t he same

[@tatsumakimojo5502]

Nope....next question ?

[@eternitymelody7974]

5:30 omg he is so cute, palestinian man so hansdome

[@tubaaa333]

As I know there will never be a peace in the holly land and the arabs.

[@besogon]

there you have it. occupation has nothing to do with peace.

[@aaronmass6543]

These people should learn to accept defeat gracefully like the Germans and Japanese. Imagine what the West bank or Gaza would look like if they just accepted they lost and move on.

[@ef2718]

They are part of the majority of the ME, where minorities don't get national rights, especially Jews, who are the one single minority in the whole are that outrageously managed to escape Arab Islamic rule.

[@messianic_scam]

stupid comparison irritate me as usual how do you compare Japan or germans to Palestine !? do you see british settlers in germany or Japan kicking Japanese out of their houses or pulling road shootin as they do in hebron ! ? what's wrong with you.ppl

[@aaronmass6543]

@@messianic_scam you might want to proofread before replying or work on your English skills. You probably are not aware of this, but the Palestinian leadership, particularly The Grand Mufti of Jerusalem was a personal friend of Hitler and helped raise Muslin SS troops in the Balkans. He also pushed Hitler to gas the Jews and had the Germans won in southern Russia and Egypt, he was working with Arabs to launch a rebellion against British forces. So yes, the Palestinians have always been on the wrong side of history and one other thing - most of them are not even native to the land - they were attracted to it by the burgeoning GDP and economic development resulting from Jewish settlement in the region. Look at the Ottoman Census records pre Jewish re - immigration. Something like only 160k in the entire area, not 3M.as the Palestinians claimed.

[@messianic_scam]

@@aaronmass6543 typical cliche reply

[@messianic_scam]

@@aaronmass6543 shut it you messing with the wrong person you bogus kzbin.info/www/bejne/oGjCfX-YmtOBabc

[@chayimjakob5499]

Of course. If not for the occupation of 1967, there would be peace. Which begs the question, why did the Arabs go to war in 1948, 1956 and 1967? (No doubt, because of the occupation of 1967).

[@CastleArrow1]

False, The arabs were under occupation by the British, and the British Mandate for palestine started ever since 1918, and gave a slew of land and incited riots through the Palmach an underground army of the Yushiv. Don't try to cover up the facts of collonial expansion.

[@chayimjakob5499]

@@CastleArrow1 So, let me understand... Was it the occupation of 1967, or was it not? Or are you now claiming the Arabs are trying to destroy the Jews, because of the British occupation of 1918?

[@CastleArrow1]

@@chayimjakob5499 No I am informing you about the fact the occupation began way before 1967 and even before 1948 because the underground militas like the Palmach and others that attacked villages and routes of Palestinian villages, and it was a westren effort to colonize Palestine, and using the Jewish religion as a tool to achieve that end. And there are Mizrahi Jews you know that right? And before the illyah to Palestine they lived in all sorts of different arab and west african countries.

[@chayimjakob5499]

@@CastleArrow1 Ah... I see... So from 1967 on, the Arabs have been saying there can't be peace because of the occupation. If only the occupation would end, and Israel would give up the land the won in 1967, then we could have peace. I called b*llsh*t. The Arabs' problem with Israel is not 1967, it's Israel's existence. They (the Arabs) consider all of Israel occupied, and thus, the going back to the 1967 lines will not bring peace. And you are agreeing with me. Thank you for your honesty.

[@CastleArrow1]

@@chayimjakob5499 No I don't think you see it at all actually. You are just blaming Arabs for not lying on their backs when they get attacked and colonized, and actually trying to defend their homes. Peace can only come with accepting responsibility for the transgressions that have been done in the past. And if Isreal decides to back off East Jerusalem and all the other illegal settelments then I think there would be a good chance for peace.

[@jeunesarabes7738]

عاشت فلسطين حره مسلمه عربيه وعاصمتها القدس الشريف وعاش الشعب الفلسطيني في شتى بقاع الأرض والنصر بإذن الله لله ولرسوله وللمؤمنين وحق العوده لن ننساه 🇹🇳🇸🇩

[@il831]

فلسطينكم في احلامكم يا دواعش هاي ارض بني اسرائيل وانتو المستوطنين فيها

[@jeunesarabes7738]

IL داعش تتعالج في مستشفياتكم

[@SRBOMBONICA86]

Omg poor Palestinian Christians lol

[@ibracadabra882]

It's a conflict between 2 stubborn people. There will never be peace.

[@perrypelican9476]

No, the main issue is hamas and their selfishness. What the Palestinian people want does not matter unless they would reject Hamas and those other guys as their leaders. They need one or 2 generations of Jewish, Palestinian integration from a young age, starting with integrated schools.

[@GlowingAsteroid]

Corey is so bias it's ANNOYING! He's so defensive, it ruins all responses

[@avigailbc1]

Why don't you open up your own channel about the conflict?

[@aburyan19]

I enjoy most of your videos. One huge issue with this video, why quiz the Palestinian interviewees so intensely about the right of return and completely ignore the settlers, not balanced.

[@jbuda4263]

I agree. I’m feeling he’s becoming more biased than before.

[@Mr9mann]

@@jbuda4263 Palestine taught him well.

[@rennyskiathitis8178]

That's not how his videos work. In each video he asks one side questions. He ether asks Palestinians a question or Israelis a question. Have you not been paying attention at all?

[@Vport]

Everyone on Earth needs to return to where they were in 1948. The ultimate world peace. No exceptions.

[@SenorJoeBiden]

It is interesting how almost all of the women say there would not be peace while the men are more split 50/50. I wonder why this is. I’ve noticed something similar on the Israeli side with Israeli women’s feelings towards the conflict.

[@skeptorr]

6:40 מה שרה עושה שם???

[@Seanonyoutube]

חחחח

[@youtubedeletestomanyaccoun4247]

She essentially is saying there’s nothing wrong with taking someone’s land and house aslong as it’s not here and Palestinian. She’s just as bad as what the nakba was

[@kinster02]

No, There's was never going to be any peace over there for the foreseeable future so, don't kid yourself. REPLY

[@parthasarathyvenkatadri]

Two states would not get peace in the long term .. unless the entirety of Palestine 1948 becomes a federation with secular ideals

[@Botie2]

What a loaded question. If we gave some of the people their land back but not all, would everyone accept this?

[@aaronmeyer9618]

Why not?

[@615bla]

why is it so complex to get a straight coherent answer in some of these cases?

[@yonatanzaslaver7348]

Its just basic logic, how can you have peace with a state that you want to destroy?

[@ravila2910]

@Oussama11 you only make peace with enemies... what am i missing here?

[@ravila2910]

@Oussama11 plenty of room for everybody. god owns land not humans

[@ravila2910]

@Oussama11 no. But if there's free space next to me you're welcome.

[@abdomohamed1335]

There is a problem when the Palestinians asking to return to the homes from which they were forced out.

[@elcalich33sehead]

Let the settlers stay in the nascent state of Palestine, under the condition that they have Palestinian citizenship, and then we’ll talk about settlements.

[@meoowthunder2038]

No Palestinian should go to Jordan

[@jeunesarabes7738]

We know too well that our freedom is incomplete without the freedom of the Palestinians. Nelson Mandela

[@marksimons8861]

Sounds like South Africans' freedom is incomplete with Jacob Zuma in charge.

[@charles.neuman18]

Was there peace before 1967? Why not?

[@Mishkafofer]

Just send them John Lenon Cds and see magic happens. Just kidding.

[@Hamzaben9]

the translator is terrible.

[@daliaj9334]

There would be peace when the Palestinian refugees have their right of return! Any jew in the world can have a "birthright" of visiting his ancestral land. While any Palestinian refugee whose parents/grandparents were exiled from the 1948 territories aren't allowed to go back and live there, so he's BANNED from visiting his homeland! What kind of justice is that?!

[@g.iskandar90]

Dalia DJ Exactly!!!

[@marksimons8861]

They were, but then the bombs and murders started and in the end they got a separation barrier. A great victory for Arafat's intifada.

[@nirhakimian3204]

Anavrinn DJ There will be peace only when all Arabs go back to the hejaz. No occupation is justified so fuck off

[@superme29-19]

Dalia DJ sance bomb was made palestine just love these toys

[@user-yk8pw5ci3t]

Dalia DJ my grandfather was kicked out of Yemen Now he can’t go back

[@tekubus]

Please ask both Israelis and Palestinians, "Many people believe Hitler to have been a very bad person, while some others believe he was very great. What is your personal opinion of Hitler, and the dichotomy of that reality?" Or just ask Palestinians for obvious reasons, but I would be interested to hear the specifics of the Jewish opinion.

[@CitiesSkyGay]

Refugees have gone back to their homelands once conditions there have calmed down. Vietnam, for example, open their markets and lessened their totalitarianism after the 1980s, and the boat people voluntarily went back

[@marksimons8861]

Were they fighting a war of attrition meanwhile and bombing those left behind all the while? Had they done so I bet they would not have been made welcome.

[@Lildizzle420]

the Israeli internal security directors have spoken on this issue. an independent Palestine doesn't create a worse security situation than they have now. so there isn't any risk associated with an independent west bank but the benefits are the ending of the occupation, removing Israeli Jews from harms way, and going a long way to reduce tensions between the two peoples while also securing and protecting Israel's Jewish identity. (just my personal opinion even native American reservations have more autonomy than Palestine and the severe dependence and militarism creates a very toxic relationship between Palestinians and Israelis.)

[@Lildizzle420]

we could debate that, the defense ministers and internal Israeli security have said that keeping this territory (and also the golan heights) endangers Israeli security. you keep the west bank and golan heights, to defend against attacks for keeping the west bank and golan heights. or you give up the territories, normalize relations with these countries and there isn't anyone to defend against.

[@g.iskandar90]

Lildizzle420 I couldn't agree more with you!!!

[@Lildizzle420]

Jace_From_Spaaace ! you can't predict the future, you do what is best at the moment and at this moment Israel has never been safer, stronger, more protected than it is now. the Israeli internal security director a have said the problem is political and not a military or security issue anymore.

[@Tamir-Barkahan]

*There is no "occupation" in Gaza since 2005... Does Gaza look like a peaceful place to you?*

[@marksimons8861]

My recollection is that Hamas won the election across ALL the Palestinian territories. but Fatah refused to transition peacefully. There was a brief violent struggle, civil war if you will, resulting in Hamas taking over in Gaza and Fatah hanging on in WB. There's been tension between the two ever since. That's why, for example, WB is refusing to pay for electricity for Gaza. As far as I can make out, Hamas and Fatah have separate funding streams from various donors around the world.

[@Tamir-Barkahan]

Why do Kremlin-funded trolls like to copy-paste so much?

[@Tamir-Barkahan]

raye7 bikhra 3ala 2abrak ya trollski

[@Tamir-Barkahan]

You sound bitter, Popov.

[@Tamir-Barkahan]

Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery, Popov.

[@TrueFacts-sf4it]

both sides need some hard compromise for peace's sake

[@rennyskiathitis8178]

Israel gave the Palestinians Gaza, there you go compromise. Israel gave Egypt all of Sanai for peace. What have the Arabs ever compromised for peace? The Arabs compromise, they accept compromices from Israel in return for peace.

[@parthasarathyvenkatadri]

I don't Get why women in general are more conservative ...

[@ef2718]

Because Arab women stay at home or work near by while men have higher interaction interact with Jews.

[@elaziz2357]

7.30 Turkey

[@kevindonohue2912]

The farm where my grandmother was born was seized by the State of New York under eminent domain to build a reservoir for New York City. I currently live 15 miles away. I think it would be very difficult to find anyone who would consider me a refugee because I can't return to my grandmother's farm, or who would think not being able to do so would justify me murdering people or starting a war - yet this is what we see with the Palestinians (and that is ignoring that most left their homes in 1948 of their own free will). People living 15 miles from their old family homes say there won't be peace until they can go back - in the meantime, they still live within their original cultural, linguistic, religious and kinship groups. This is insanity.

[@tommyhaynes9157]

Well that's a little different

[@yaramay510]

They never left their homes because of their free will. Actually half of them were ethnically cleansed before may 1948

[@kevindonohue2912]

@@yaramay510 I've heard testimony from Arabs saying that most of them left at the direction of the Arab leadership. Those who stayed were granted Israeli citizenship - if Israel wanted a Jews-only state, why weren't these Arabs forced out? What you say does not hold up against reality, it makes no sense.

[@yaramay510]

@@kevindonohue2912 Most people who stayed were internally displaced. For example, Nazareth ( Jesus city) was a very small town prior to 1948 and became very large city due to the displacement and people being internally transferred. Most people who were internally displaced ( Israeli border today ) could not return to their homes 5 miles away even if they owned it until today even if they are Israeli citizens. Israel immediately sized their homes . The united nation intervened and Israelis as much as they wanted , they could not cleanse the area totally from Arabs. The united nation argued the returned of refugees who were kicked out from their homes but israel still refuse to do so or even agree to pay them compensation . Israel still until today try to ethnically cleanse the rest under different methods . I’m not sure if you know what is happening in east Jerusalem that provoked the last violence we saw recently. All what you have to look at is the dates when all the the villages were ethnically cleansed. The dates can go back to 1947, 9 months before israel decelerated its independence and before Arabs attacked. There was no way for israel to declare its independence without ethnically cleanse the natives. Israel was built in Jewish supremacy and continue until today . This land only belong to the Jews and only Jews. I’m Israeli myself and lately Jewish human rights organization in Israel declared that Israel is an apartheid state. Now we Israelis should ask ourself if we want to live in an apartheid state or not. I understand the people interviewed in the video . They are more compromising than most Israelis who think that because we are powerful and the States is supporting us, is ok to continue oppressing others!. Sorry English is not my first language

[@kevindonohue2912]

@@yaramay510 Bull crap. And what is happening in Sheikh Jarrah is that during the illegal Jordanian occupation, Jews were ethnically cleansed from east Jerusalem and Arabs were allowed to use their homes - homes which Jews had owned since 1875. The Jews are the only ones with legal claims to these homes, and the Arabs were offered the option of staying if they paid rent, which they refused to do. As far as right of return is concerned, Israel in its many peace deals has offered the right of return to Arabs actually born inside Israel, but the Palestinians demand that this right be granted to their descendants, which is unprecedented in history. And being displaced 5 miles, while remaining in the same geography, ethnic groups, language groups - that is not oppression. Look at the displacements that took place in Europe and Asia during the same period. Are you aware that almost a million Jews were forcibly displaced from Arab countries in MENA, that an area five times the size of Israel was stollen, and property worth more than what the Arabs lost in Israel? What about the right of return for these people, or reparations? Your understanding of history is incomplete, selective, and biased. And all of this could have been avoided if the Arabs had accepted the Peel Commission partition plan in 1937 or the UN partition plan in 1947 - but they refused and instead waged war.

[@mahtovu3399]

There is no such thing as palestine........

[@michaelsmullen9891]

Israel- We will give them what ever is their innermost desire!

[@jayerodriguez8213]

The pharmacist was right, it's your choice if you choose to ever go back. Your grandparents could've went back to Russia or Ukraine if they really wanted to.

[@undecodable6145]

historicly jews and muslims were living together in peace

[@marksimons8861]

That depends on your point of view. Dhimmis managed as best they could. Historically, everyone lived in peace under the Turks because the latter would ruthlessly crush any rebellion and move people around.

[@fuckingSickOfCreepyG]

I love Israel but the situation is complete madness and I don't think there is a proper solution. Imagine if someone else occupied your land with the help of foreign powers and then offered you a chunk of it back so you're cool with it.

[@ef2718]

Palestinians should get the kingdom of Palestine back and the King reinstated.

[@rennyskiathitis8178]

It wasn't Palestinian land, it was Ottoman land. Have you bothered to learn any of the history? The Paledtine included Jordan as well, did you know this?

[@rennyskiathitis8178]

You are being sarcastic obviously.

[@michaelsmullen9891]

@@ef2718It wasn't a King that they had, but an Emperor. The Emperor with no clothes!

[@lucys.l.p448]

If the West Bank did become its own state of Palestine would the Arab Israeli citizens move the Palestine or would they stay Israelis

[@jeunesarabes7738]

There's a Palestine that dwells inside all of us, a Palestine that needs to be rescued: a free Palestine where all people regardless of color, religion, or race coexist; a Palestine where the meaning of the word "occupation" is only restricted to what the dictionary says rather than those plenty of meanings and connotations of death, destruction, pain, suffering, deprivation, isolation and restrictions that Israel has injected the word with. Refaat Alareer

[@g.iskandar90]

jeunes arabes الشباب العربي 💜👏👏👏

[@SigalDa]

palestine its made up nation and made up name.

[@cloud0746]

Hmmm, Palestinians cannot go back to their homes same generation, but Israel can come and say, 3000 years ago we lived here???? very very strange.

[@miransayed]

cant they both live off each other...its too late now ask anything back.....just form a government to both state

[@morp904]

Free palestine means free levant of jews basically

[@faf20134]

Corel man try to be more neutral and coherent please! When you say to the first woman that refugees never come back don’t forget that Irsaelis are justifying the occupation and the land they took to Palestiniens saying that they were refugees during 3 thousands years that decided to come back!!! So what are you talking about😳

[@Lorenzoselas]

These people are delusional & need to learn the proper history. Old & recent history.

[@mahometwarlord7313]

The younger are palestinians the more they want the whole land before 1948. That is to say, while there is less and less people born in 1947, there is more and more people who want to go before 1948 (I don't use "come back" it will be anachronic). What is the appreciation of their current life, the uchronic claim for "come back", it's a way to disguise vacuity, except the only life motive, war to Israël. Perspectives of peace: ZERO. Sense of reality: ZERO International fair support: ZERO International handling support : iran, turkey.

[@cholponduisheeva3886]

They need study, they are clever people, not stupid. ..

[@moetama_]

Just have a 1 country 2 system model And eventually after 200 years become 1 country lol

[@Seanonyoutube]

They don’t want that either

[@Seanonyoutube]

@Oussama11 while I agree with you in principle, in practice it is too late for your proposed solution. The jews of 48 are long dead and now you’re dealing with their descendants that were born and raised in Israel and have no European citizenship. They ain’t going anywhere.

[@TheKeithvidz]

i say 2 states, one wall.

[@knishknish66]

These folks are honest, the arab refugees will never allow Israel to live in peace!

[@user-ch7hn8dd8j]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/sHyrhWmQrbaEjNk

[@michaelsmullen9891]

Piece by Piece and not Peace for Peace!