Part 1: The Quran's Preservation: The Honest Truth

[@FlyingSpaghettiMonster2000]

Very interesting, from a historical perspective too. Thank you, have subscribed.

[@islamwhattheydonttellyou164]

Thanks Simon, appreciate your comments

[@reasoningtegatamuno3497]

Great video. Just subbed. Directed here by a friend who was also directed here by bro Mel of S Corner

[@islamwhattheydonttellyou164]

Thanks my friend 😊

[@PRAEDICATORVERITATIS]

Great information, presented clearly.

[@islamwhattheydonttellyou164]

👍😊

[@terminateurextra-ordinaire3925]

Great presentation as usual.

[@islamwhattheydonttellyou164]

❤👍

[@sasa_sasa_sasa230]

@@islamwhattheydonttellyou164 verse of stoning is known but verse of breastfeeding is lost

[@cdo...49283]

Just discovered your channel, it looks really good! I'm definitely gonna get the book :) Looking forward to reading it..

[@islamwhattheydonttellyou164]

Thank you, very kind of you ❤😊

[@Xgya2000]

TheRationalizer guided me here. This is a bit too deep for my limited understanding of the Qu'ran, but definitely interesting. I guess this just means I'll have to watch this multiple times.

[@markloughran3587]

Great content and truths. Directed here form a comment on Plander films. I hope you dont mind but im posting these video on my Quora channel called STANDARD ISLAMIC NARRATIVE S.I.N. keep fighting the good fight brother.

[@zahraexshiatruthseeker1]

Great and hard work! Thank you so much.

[@islamwhattheydonttellyou164]

😊❤

[@krisMcA82]

This is brilliant. I’m going to watch this whole series, so I know it like the back of my hand . Thank you 🙏🏻 very much my friend ✌🏻🤝

[@islamwhattheydonttellyou164]

Thank you for your kind comments Kris, and thank you again for the support 👍😊

[@neophilosophy1764]

This is an excellent and coherent presentation! I hope your channel grows more to expose the lie of Islam.

[@zat5176]

Are you Christian?

[@SYWTG]

Only channel ,but not the people. 😭😭😭😭

[@qandachristian7614]

@@SYWTG what's your problem exactly?

[@skeptical_citizen]

The point of these videos is to show that Islam is an extension of the other Abrahamic religions, with its own divisions and problems, like other religions.

[@xtreme6018]

🤣🤣that cant by anyone...even critric..they can only play words here to therecuz its already recognition by orientalist n UK non muslim scholar

[@atilla4352]

I remember a big attack because of the Saana manuscript which was obviously a student's scribble to memorize hadith and Qur'an. This one is more accurate and historical but my question as a European convert. Let's say it's distorted. How many similar sounding Arabic words can we distort and change accidentally?

[@islamwhattheydonttellyou164]

I have written extensively on this subject in my book, please check it out. Thanks

[@haxlwaxl997]

Hello, there is an annoying background noise. I recommend to also work on the technical quality of your Videos. The content is great though.

[@islamwhattheydonttellyou164]

Thanks for your comments

[@nezar-6889]

Awesome and educational content that needs to reach a wider audience! Unfortunately, a bit more work must be put into the quality of the video and sound. Perhaps look into a background noise removing software for starters? Cleaning up the audio makes a HUGE difference!

[@islamwhattheydonttellyou164]

Thank you Nezar for your kind comments, i have worked on my videos, my later videos sound is better, really appreciate the advice though, its true what you say, take care my friend👍

[@nezar-6889]

@@islamwhattheydonttellyou164 Anytime, good sir! I sincerely appreciate and admire anyone who exposes religion for what it truly is -- a scam!

[@islamwhattheydonttellyou164]

@@nezar-6889 👍well said

[@Ddej6627]

Great info

[@islamwhattheydonttellyou164]

👍

[@sasa_sasa_sasa230]

Little corrections, verse about stoning is known but verse about breastfeeding is lost

[@islamwhattheydonttellyou164]

Which one is the stoning verse? Can you give me chapter and verse? If you cant, thats what was meant by lost, as in its no longer in the Quran because it was lost.

[@sasa_sasa_sasa230]

@@islamwhattheydonttellyou164 you have hadith that said that in quran was written if old man and old woman fornicate ston them.

[@islamwhattheydonttellyou164]

@@sasa_sasa_sasa230 My point is its not in the Quran, the topic is on the 'Quran's Preservation', if hadith is used as evidence for a verses' existence, then the hadith also mentions the breastfeeding verse.

[@sasa_sasa_sasa230]

@@islamwhattheydonttellyou164 nope, in hadiths you don't have exact quote of verse of breastfeeding

[@islamwhattheydonttellyou164]

@@sasa_sasa_sasa230 Can you give me the exact quote for the stoning verse? I dont see a difference as the stoning ‘verse’ was something that Muhammad had stated but it was never a Quran verse as such, this is similar what I said about the breastfeeding verses (Sunan Ibn Majah 3:9:1942) and other places. What you say about the so-called stoning being a Quranic verse, "The married old man and old woman, if they commit adultery, then stone them irrevocably." The hadith literature suggests that was a saying (Hadith) rather than the actual verse, the evidence is In Musnad Aḥmad 21086 where it says Umar said "When this was revealed, I went to the Prophet and I said: Let me write it.” As Quran, because back then Muhammad forbade writing anything but Quran, Muhammad 'disliked' it being written, the hadith was graded authentic (Sahih). If it was a Quran verse, then Muhammad would have included it in the Quran and not forbidden writing it in. It sure is ambiguous because the hadith does say 'revealed', Muhammad cannot over-rule Allah, by deciding what forms Quran and what does not unless that is something Muslims are saying.

[@user-oo1tr6wo8n]

Please can you insert Arabic language?

[@islamwhattheydonttellyou164]

Thank you for your comment, this will be on my next to do list as I know Arabic, wondering if someone can assist me on this as I am working on English ones for now. I gave permission for another channel to translate my videos into Malay and Indonesian languages.

[@user-oo1tr6wo8n]

@@islamwhattheydonttellyou164 Can I ask you a question ? Do you hate Muslims? Why ? And thank you for your comment

[@islamwhattheydonttellyou164]

@@user-oo1tr6wo8n Strange question, why is anyone who points out inaccuracies or anything wrong with the religion or the people who claim to follow it automatically considered to be a hater? The answer to your question is no, in fact I love all people including Muslims thats why I want them to know the truth. Its the Muslim apologists and so-called scholars, Sheikhs so on who lie about the religion to the people who really hate Muslims because they know the truth yet hide it from the masses. Take Care

[@user-oo1tr6wo8n]

@@islamwhattheydonttellyou164 Thank you 😊

[@islamwhattheydonttellyou164]

@@user-oo1tr6wo8n youre welcome 😊