Partition, Kashmir, and the Future of Pakistan-India Relations Ft. Mosharraf Zaidi | EP183

In today’s podcast, we are joined by Mr. Mosharraf Zaidi as we delve into a range of critical topics. We explore the partition, Jinnah’s ideology, and the geostrategic importance of Kashmir, Afghanistan and India-Pakistan relations.
The discussion also covers the problematic decision-making by the Pakistani elite and the exclusion of the younger generation (ages 30 to 35) from key roles. We emphasize the need for forward-thinking leadership to shape Pakistan's future, especially concerning trade relations and economic stability.
Join us for this insightful conversation on the past, present, and future of Pakistan-India relations and the imperative for youthful leadership in shaping Pakistan's future.
#indiapakistanrelations #pakistanyouth #howdoesitwork
00:00 Highlights
01:30 Should we celebrate Jinnah?
06:00 Jinnah's vision for Pakistan
12:00 These old politicians will not decide our future
16:00 Young generation's dilemma and thoughts about Pakistan
20:47 Kashmir, Gaza, and Ukraine
21:47 Jinnah's vision and Hindu-Muslim unity
23:00 Enjoy freedom vs Maintain freedom
25:20 Ishaq Dar statement of Pakistan India Trade
33:36 Nobody has done anything dramatic like Malik Riaz
36:00 Asad Umar's era was also not better than Dar's
44:00 Pakistan has no young leadership
50:00 Without national security, Pakistan is nothing
55:00 The Pakistani elite and 5th generation warfare
Don’t forget to subscribe and press the bell icon to catch on to some amazing conversations coming your way every week!
Keep up with our podcast:
Facebook: / howdoesitwork.podcast
Insta: / howdoesitwork.podcast
Tiktok: vt.tiktok.com/ZSRYSy1K1/
Follow Shayan Mahmud:
INSTA: / shayanmahmud__
FB: profile.php?...
Linkedin: / shayan-mahmud
Follow ProPakistani:
Facebook: / propakistani
Insta: / pro_pakistani
Twitter: / propakistanipk
LinkedIn: / prop. .
You can also audio stream our podcast here:
Google Podcast: bit.ly/3z6AGPi
Apple Podcast: apple.co/3b9GQGu
Spotify: spoti.fi/3OFNm5H

[@prathipgowda]

Knowledge 0% accent 100% 😂

[@zigzoog123]

dumb as a box of rocks 😂😂

[@redheadin]

Pakistani English ko hi knowledge samajte hai Bhai for them we Indian are uneducated every podcast mai modi ko gali denge Kashmir Mai freedom nahi hai bolenge khatam😂

[@abhishekarya5685]

😂😂

[@Mukesh_Devrari]

He is really a fool😂.

[@Maithili_V]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@anshulthakur8296]

If he is considered an intellectual in Pakistan. I can understand why Pakistan is a failed state.

[@sanamir160]

We Indian kashmiri muslim don't want to any relation with Pakistan Jay hind vandematram 🇮🇳

[@rockykhan6338]

ramu make id with real name im saying this being myself from india mumbai

[@aatmaDipoBhava]

​@@rockykhan6338 you are not indian by choice you are by chance indian passport holder bcoz True Indian muslim sees beyond religion and loves nation

[@silenthill1035]

You are lying.

[@abhishekarya5685]

@@rockykhan6338kya tuzhe yeh nahi lagta ki tu Kashmir ko alag manta hai ? Tu Muslim hai aur terse yeh jawab milna normal hai but fir bhi dil nahi manta ki India Muslim Kashmir ko India ka nahi mante .. Shame on you, religion ko g**nd me dal lo, think about nation first

[@rajvanshsingh6588]

K​@@rockykhan6338

[@BlackSabbath10019]

We Indians thank JInnah even more than Pakistanis for creating Pakistan. If India wasn't partitioned, the parts which are Pakistan today, would've been a HUGE obstacle in India's progress. THANK YOU JINNAH!!

[@atokimruk937]

Hold on to the thank you. The pork liv8ng Jenna failed to do his job. He did not get every Muslim out of India and into Pakistan. He should have given fire orders to his successors before he croaked that they must get every Muslim out of India by 1949. Then I could have gotten him a posthumous Emmy for some useless speech he might have made. I have connections with the Emmy board. Alas, he failed...

[@Hindutavalover]

But still we have 24 crore illigally Pakistani citizens in India

[@Guessswhosback]

This was Universe way of saying to Bharat- “Buckle up, We goin’ for hell of a ride”

[@avinashmishra7735]

@@Hindutavalover Jinnah was so "careful" of the weak Muslims of Hindu majority areas that he clearly asked them to not leave India entirely and let it become Hindu Nation. He was such a bigot that he proposed 2 Nation Theory, brought it into action but opposed complete population exchange to make sure India remains JOINT ACCOUNT (Dar-Al-Harb) of Hindus and Muslims and Pakistan becomes PEROSNAL ACCOUNT of Muslims. He was such a cunning man to ask for partition of India beacuse the Indian subcontinent as a whole was Hindu majority but didn't want partition of Punjab and Bangladesh because those provinces were Muslim majority. He also made a deal with Christians of Punjab to support the creation of Pakistan in the name oF Abrahmic brotherhood but never gave them equal position in the society. Infact he deliberately disallowed many Hindus and Christians to cross the border and come to India because he thought he would use them for bargaining with India and also use them for sanitary workers. He was such a pedophile that he ran away with the daughter of his Parsi friend and converted her to Islam but was not happy to see his own daughter marry a Parsi. He was such a "freedom fighter" that he was never even jailed for an hour by the Britishers. He in fact made the deal with the Britishers of making Pakistan the part of the so called common wealth. He was such an intellectual that he never wrote anything about how to exactly run Pakistan. He was such a deceiver that he made all kinds of false promises to all kinds of Muslims just to pave the way for the disintegration of India. He was such a corrupt and racist that he wanted his private house in Mumbai to not be overtaken by the Govt of India, rather rented to some white men. He was so jealous of the Nehru-Edwina relationship that he even directly asked Mountbatten about it. He was such a hindu hater that he even visited Dalit leaders of that time like Ambedkar and Periyar to further break up India. He was such a MADHARCHOD that he even asked Brithsers to give India in the hands of Muslims because according to him "Brishers took it from Mughals". I can write on and on and on....Only Hindutva can show the world how to deal Islam with Mutual-Respect

[@BlackSabbath10019]

@@Hindutavalover -- No, Indian Muslims are our own Indian brothers & sisters. That's the MAIN difference between India & Pakistan. If we start treating our Muslims the way they treat their Hindus & other minorities, there won't be any difference between us & them.

[@sidharathjain3091]

Madness on Steroids!

[@zigzoog123]

sometimes learn or atleast attempt to say a word or two that is true. It was like listening to fiction 😂😂😂😂😂

[@sewaligoswami781]

Exactly

[@PoliticalSeer-ii3wh]

It's Great How the Stockholm Syndrome has gone so Far As To Call It a Privilege to be a Pakistani under the Feet of Pakistan Army

[@goodsong_views]

he's in US

[@venkataramanasrivatsasa6470]

Sir, he claims as liberal as Jinnah. Certainly he is. Jinnah couldn't compete with the new star emerged from South Africa, Gandhi. He withdrew to his practice in England only to return after seeing a chance by getting rid of his so called image of muslim Hindu unity. Funnily this championship title was put by none other than Gandhi. Jinnah couldn't better over the leaders like Gandi, Nehru, Patel and Netaji who were leaders of masses due to their sacrifices over comforts and cash. All these people adore jinnah because they think they can't compete with Hindus, which proved wrong. Muslims like Azeemji Premji and many more top diplomats, players, artists and civil servants proved them wrong.

[@chaitanya9229]

If jinnah was ambassador of hindu muslim unity than modi is a maulana. 😂

[@abhijeetm29]

Modi is maulana though. Maulana Narendruddin Pasmandadas Modi.

[@zigzoog123]

😂😂😂

[@themyself1212]

😂😂😂

[@silenthill1035]

Mohammad Ali Jinnah WAS a champion of Hindu-Muslim unity BEFORE he realized that Hindu majority will crush Muslim minority's demands, culture, heritage, economy, etc. That bleak assessment turned out to be true.

[@chaitanya9229]

​@@silenthill1035😂

[@snathan3198]

Hafeez Syed with a jacket and an accent!

[@mayan5600]

Yeah. Jinnah was such a symbol of hindu muslim unity that he divided the nation into three parts on the name of religion. I think Subhash Chandra Bose was the example of not of only hindu muslim, but if other religion unity too . Everyone uses to love him and he used to treat everyone like a family in Azad hind fauj. There was more muslim who used to fight for him.

[@zigzoog123]

jinnah 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@silenthill1035]

Mohammad Ali Jinnah WAS a champion of Hindu-Muslim unity BEFORE he realized that Hindu majority will crush Muslim minority's demands, culture, heritage, economy, etc. That bleak assessment turned out to be true.

[@WRATH19]

​​@@silenthill1035Indian Hindus ne kisi bhi minorities ko crush nehi Kia ulta .... minorities ki number and percentage dono bare....par paxtan ne apne minorities ko jamke crush Kia .....shame on you 🤬

[@silenthill1035]

@@WRATH19 Read the Sachar Committee report regarding just the economic marginalization of Muslims in India.

[@rajvanshsingh8165]

​@@silenthill1035ek baap ke aulad ha to data published kar Indian Hindus in pakistan and Bangladesh aur muslims population percentage...agar difference nahi dekha to 2 baap ke aulad

[@MysticSage-hg3jh]

If You Keep Saying ''Kashmir Kashmir'' Your Situation Will Only Keep Worsening You Guys Don't Learn ...

[@akhtrzaman4955]

Your situation isn't fantastic on Kashmir either. You're actually stuck in the worst now living on propaganda after article 370 😂

[@srijandatta287]

@@akhtrzaman4955 Really, how many protests are going on in pakistan right now?? Links to videos??

[@akhtrzaman4955]

@@srijandatta287 Where are internet shutdowns in Endia rite now? If u r asking about Azad Kashmir no one was blinded like cprf hitting pellets in the eyes of IOK Kashmiris.

[@akhtrzaman4955]

@@srijandatta287 Why r u concerned about Pakistan 🤣? Your politicians raping women, corporates putting harmful chemicals in your food, Hindu Muslim, Hindu khatre main on WhatsApp, not going on 🤣

[@srijandatta287]

​@@akhtrzaman4955 No Internet shutdown right now. Pelts were used and shall be used again if unrest prevails. Simple. You guys just simply k|!! instead. 3 people by rangers on 13th may. A lot more is present, were that came from. Maleeha lodhi in the UN showed a picture claiming to be kashmiri later found to be palestianian. BBC published that news. POK is a $hithole and that's me being polite compared to our J&K. Stop the w@taboutary and answer the questions I actually asked!!

[@rohitwalmiki271]

Indians don't even think of pakistan nowdays 😂😅

[@TonyStark-mm6qy]

We NEVER EVER thought about them 😂

[@AnujKumar-wj3ju]

Jinnah was champion of Hindu Muslim unity. 😂 🤣 It's like saying butcher's are ambassador for non violence. 😂 🤣 😂

[@silenthill1035]

Mohammad Ali Jinnah WAS a champion of Hindu-Muslim unity BEFORE he realized that Hindu majority will crush Muslim minority's demands, culture, heritage, economy, etc. That bleak assessment turned out to be true.

[@avinashmishra7735]

@@silenthill1035 Jinnah was so "careful" of the weak Muslims of Hindu majority areas that he clearly asked them to not leave India entirely and let it become Hindu Nation. He was such a bigot that he proposed 2 Nation Theory, brought it into action but opposed complete population exchange to make sure India remains JOINT ACCOUNT (Dar-Al-Harb) of Hindus and Muslims and Pakistan becomes PEROSNAL ACCOUNT of Muslims. He was such a cunning man to ask for partition of India beacuse the Indian subcontinent as a whole was Hindu majority but didn't want partition of Punjab and Bangladesh because those provinces were Muslim majority. He also made a deal with Christians of Punjab to support the creation of Pakistan in the name oF Abrahmic brotherhood but never gave them equal position in the society. Infact he deliberately disallowed many Hindus and Christians to cross the border and come to India because he thought he would use them for bargaining with India and also use them for sanitary workers. He was such a pedophile that he ran away with the daughter of his Parsi friend and converted her to Islam but was not happy to see his own daughter marry a Parsi. He was such a "freedom fighter" that he was never even jailed for an hour by the Britishers. He in fact made the deal with the Britishers of making Pakistan the part of the so called common wealth. He was such an intellectual that he never wrote anything about how to exactly run Pakistan. He was such a deceiver that he made all kinds of false promises to all kinds of Muslims just to pave the way for the disintegration of India. He was such a corrupt and racist that he wanted his private house in Mumbai to not be overtaken by the Govt of India, rather rented to some white men. He was so jealous of the Nehru-Edwina relationship that he even directly asked Mountbatten about it. He was such a hindu hater that he even visited Dalit leaders of that time like Ambedkar and Periyar to further break up India. He was such a MADHARCHOD that he even asked Brithsers to give India in the hands of Muslims because according to him "Brishers took it from Mughals". I can write on and on and on....Only Hindutva can show the world how to deal Islam with Mutual-Respect

[@filmwood7979]

​@@silenthill1035 in reality , all the things you mentioned, were done by majority muslims with minority Hindus in Pakistan & Bangladesh. That bleak statement turned out to be true in both countries, while in majority hindu Bharat these muslims grew in number. Pakistan are bhikharis for a reason 😂

[@APEXMACHCORPORATION]

All troubled Indian Muslims should settle in Pakistan as per Mr. Zaidi. Such enlightened podcast.

[@w.a.4972]

When did he say that? I missed that

[@APEXMACHCORPORATION]

He said it in last part of podcast, will checl and post

[@PanakaluPoonakam]

Absolutely and I agree. They should have gone to Pakistan after partition. They are living in India illegally.

[@bharatchoudhary540]

He is a typical Urdu belt Muslim .. very hateful in his heart .. Punjabis and Sindhis aren't by nature so hateful of other people .. these urduwalas have made them also bitter over the period of last 70-80 years (including the years just before the partition).

[@bharatchoudhary540]

@@curio78 I know what you are thinking .. yes they too have become hateful of others now .. but they weren't like this always .. they were trained to hate by these urduwalas only beginning from 1940 onwards.

[@sunilamarwaha3053]

Wrong. Punjabi on either side have more hate ghan others.

[@ManabDasiammanab]

Poonjabis are always radical. LoL. Sindhis are more liberal.

[@eliotanderson6554]

Ok so butcher of Calcutta- jinnah (direct action day) 20000 hindus killed was the person known for unity what is this two nation theory ut means we cant live together nothing more 😂😂😂. Justifying partition medivial mindset and backward ideas is so stupid 😂😂

[@Maithili_V]

Jinnah left 20 crore pakistanis in India. They are your citizens please invite them. 🪷✌️

[@seanchris5781]

they been livuing there for thousands of years just like you. who made u a king shit landlord of that area. there is a minority of indians who think like u and when you come as a minority in usa and work in gas stations for minimum wage than ur mind comes down to earth.

[@BharatiyaVaasi]

After listening to Mosharraf’s ignorant and dangerous thoughts, I remembered a quote “Nothing in all the world is more dangerous than sincere ignorance and conscientious stupidity.”

[@offred6013]

Zinnah nd Unity 😂😂😂 Kya foonktA hai bey ?

[@zigzoog123]

phook phook ke dimaag dhuen mai ud gaya

[@HOG1070]

But maal 1 number hoga.... result of the maal is evident here 😂😂😂😂

[@MysticSage-hg3jh]

Stopping Trade From India is not About Article 370 or Kashmir It is About the Business Interest of Pakistani Businessmen at the Cost 250 Million Pakistanis

[@APEXMACHCORPORATION]

I think Mr. Zaidi should read Abdul gaffar khan (Frontier gandhis) Views on pakistan formation.

[@Agnostic-1]

Thoda mistake ho Gaya bhaiya frontier Gandhi is Khan Abdul Gaffar Khan (popular as'bacha Khan' in Pakistan) india's first foreigner 'Bharat Ratna' receiver ❤

[@APEXMACHCORPORATION]

@@Agnostic-1 thank u corrected

[@zigzoog123]

zaidi is delusional, there is no hope for him

[@APEXMACHCORPORATION]

In fact, it was jinnah who started first official violence on partition via direct action day in kolkata (calcutta) at least 20000 Hindus were killed in one day, it was later that Hindus and much later Sikhs was started responding tit for tat (which pakistani media only conveniently talks about), today Muslims being divided in sub continent has only reduced Muslims power in world affairs.

[@bhavinsampat590]

They don't loke logic. They love delusional theory.

[@APEXMACHCORPORATION]

@@bhavinsampat590 there's a book on pakistan by that name.

[@APEXMACHCORPORATION]

Book is magnificent delusions

[@silenthill1035]

Mohammad Ali Jinnah WAS a champion of Hindu-Muslim unity BEFORE he realized that Hindu majority will crush Muslim minority's demands, culture, heritage, economy, etc. That bleak assessment turned out to be true.

[@APEXMACHCORPORATION]

@@silenthill1035 It does not justify inciting violence, as I informed not only 20000 Hindus where killed but first train of dead bodies and reports of entire sikh villages routed came then Sikhs and Hindus did tit for tat, so it is Jinnah who created mess that is Partition , you can't justify his hindu Muslim unity as it carries zero value in front of what he committed.

[@sanamir160]

Narendra Modi official father of Pakistan 😎💪😈

[@Kenol881]

Not modi it is IMF

[@suman902]

Wrong , it's China. Pakistan has multiple baps it seems. Needs a DNA test.

[@silenthill1035]

Do you know who was your father ?

[@boss-33]

​@@silenthill1035 we know our father's name , do you know your grandfather's name ? Ask your father.but i am sure It will RAMU,MAHENDRA,SURENDRA ,SURESH ,MAHESH ,.. 95% pakistani converted Talked like arab😂😂😂😂 Cheema ,chaudhary,rajput, gujar,bhat,jatt,shah, malik These all yours grandfather surname 😂😂😂😂

[@silenthill1035]

@@boss-33 It doesn't matter whether someone is converted or not. If you converted to Islam today, you'll be just as precious to me as any other Muslim. That was not the point at all. What do you know mean by "We" though? Does every Indian knows their father's name ?

[@Takecare55]

I agree, jinnah should be given Bharat Ratna 👍

[@atokimruk937]

Are you crazy ? NO. BUT Iff he had done is job properly and fully by getting every Muslim out of present day Bharath and into the two pakistans of 1947, then maybe a Padmashri.

[@Takecare55]

@@atokimruk937 Jinnah bought us some time by reducing Ms to minority to get our house in order. Also it wasn't the job of jinnah to get Ms out, his job was to create a safeland of Muslims, it was our collective failure when Gandhi was convincing Ms to stay and denying Hs of the land

[@TonyStark-mm6qy]

​@@Takecare55 Gandhi MF - Coming from a Tamilan 🙂

[@LunarMonarch-bc5eh]

​@@atokimruk937He should be given as he took a lot of garbage with him

[@AnujKumar-wj3ju]

The Man is greatest Scholar from Labbaik Ya Rasool Allah University. 😂 🤣 😂 Indian must promote these kind of guy they're biggest asset of India in pak. 😂 His ideas is making sure pakistan will continue in dol drum 🥁. 😂 🤣 😂

[@rajvanshsingh8165]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@anilganjoo8401]

Mental Wreck.😢😢😢😢😢

[@user-sx4mq6zn9o]

From India my reading of the situation is until and unless Pak Army goes to Barrack, no normal relationship is possible between India and Pakistan. Pak Army's existance is dependent on Dushmani with India. Pak Army has to create a security state for unconstitutional control over Pakistan. India has taken right policy. Just ignore Pakistan. Let Pakistan live happily.

[@Agnostic-1]

Mera Dil ki baat aapne bata dia❤❤❤ Pakistani aap apne khush raho,hum indian apne main, no need for relationship between india - pakistan. God bless you pakistani from my heart 😀

[@abhimanyukumar2587]

I love these Pakistani fake accent

[@indianavijay]

Oh, what a glorious ode to freedom! Here's this fine individual, extolling the virtues of liberty in Pakistan, while delicately sidestepping the inconvenient truth that his Baloch sister's brothers mysteriously disappeared, courtesy of the Pak Army or ISI. Clearly, freedom reigns supreme! Haha...

[@zigzoog123]

haven’t seen this much crap coming out of somebody’s mouth

[@Rocky_919]

the guest is a threat to kapil sharma 😅😅

[@iluabhibhat]

Pakistani must follow him to the last word and become the leader of Muslim world

[@zigzoog123]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@avinashmishra7735]

This joker will be the first one to reject anything like CAA-equivalent in Pakistan

[@chaitanya9229]

He Is the next zaid Hamid 😂

[@harendrapsingh2301]

At the outset, let it be clear that speaking in Americanised accent doesn't make one a wise person ! Mr Jinha was a beef eating n wine drinking British Agent He eloped with teenage daughter of his Parsi mentor and was enjoying life London. He was roped in by british secret service from there and put on the job of creating a buffer state between Russian empire and british empire. It is because of this reason that he commands no respect any where in the world but in Pakistan !!

[@monikaiyer4353]

Why you want to deal with India...wanted a separate country so now enjoy 😂

[@user-sx4mq6zn9o]

The guest perhaps most of the life spent time in Europe.😂 Ignorant about ground realities.

[@InterstellarRanger]

He is mocking other Pakistanis with an accent while he himself puts on a fake accent - Story of Pakistani society in a nutshell

[@SaurabhYadav-md2ez]

boot polish

[@TanujAbhayKhanna]

IMF iski accent se khush hoke har baar pakistani kashkol main bailout khairaat de deta hai.

[@shainpv]

Thank Jinnah for getting these zombies away from Bharat.

[@romeshsharma4305]

When questioned about the constitution of Pakistan in 1947 ,Jinnah replied that this had been written 1400 years ago in the form Quran .Before partition of India he had said that give me Pakistan or I would dismember India in so many pieces. Off course Jinnah waa the best human being this world every had.

[@jai4096]

If i am not wrong Jinah's Sister was called traitor and was under house arrest till she died. If Jinah's sister suffered in Pakistan then I guess what Jinah thought or said for minority hardly matters.

[@APEXMACHCORPORATION]

Imagine onions at PKR 300 - 250 Per kg & India ke saath trade mat karo as per Mr. Zaidi, it seems he is pure elite.

[@zigzoog123]

you want trade, we don’t want anything to do with you, for us you don’t even exist

[@APEXMACHCORPORATION]

I am just pointing out audacity of Mr. Zaidi.

[@AF-yq9es]

Jinna ran away with his friend's daughter who was 15 years old. The girls father trusted him and let him into his home. This is a fact.

[@praveerkrishnatiwari1383]

Pok is nightmare for Pakistan army they go to 1971 recent condition 54kill on open fire by Pakistani

[@GuzzarAwan]

What does this guy talks he even wudnt able to understand . He talks in two different poles in same sentence 😂😂😂

[@manojthaker3678]

Wise talk. Nonsense. Pipe dream. Talk India Pakistan wall. Now point of no return. Discuss how high ? 🤣

[@noobanimation8503]

English nhi ata to bolta kyu hai

[@w.a.4972]

"new delhi doesn't trust Pakistan". Give the "why" a thought. Mumbai, Kargil... Unfortunately there is a list starting in 1965 and earlier... Yes India doesn't trust Pakistan. If that slate could be wiped clean and there were believable assurances for the future, there is a future... There is a Lot of goodwill for the people of Pakistan among the Indians of all religions.

[@zigzoog123]

we don’t trust liars

[@hkpandey1]

No, there is not a lot of goodwill for Pakistanis (of Pakistan or Bharat)... don't delude yourself (and them) by saying that...a lot of tolerance and maybe, even acceptance , yes...goodwill, no... Now most Bharatiyas are well aware of the poison and contempt that they have been forced-fed through their religious ideology and clergy against non-believers/ kafirs in general and Bharat/ Hindus in particular... and the ultimate plans that their religion obligates them to nuture for kafirs and kafir societies... The young generation of Bharat has no real connection or sentimental feelings of connection with Pakistan.... they're apathetic to this eastern neighbour and see them more as an impediment and nuisance than as an entity to know more about and befriend... that's the broader truth...

[@APEXMACHCORPORATION]

Jinnah is best person for hindu Muslim unity, tells more about knowledge of Mr. Zaidi. 😵 There should be permanent enemity with India, India created breakup that made Pakistan, I have never heard such enlightened podcast 😑

[@silenthill1035]

Mohammad Ali Jinnah WAS a champion of Hindu-Muslim unity BEFORE he realized that Hindu majority will crush Muslim minority's demands, culture, heritage, economy, etc. That bleak assessment turned out to be true.

[@APEXMACHCORPORATION]

@@silenthill1035 Oh, if true, then how strong Pakistan is economically to protect Muslims (oops they can't talk about gaza openly) , maybe if bangladesh was with Pakistan economically it would not be in this mess today , but yes pak. Unofficially killed a million bengali Muslims, culturally (oops 90% mughal sites are in India still standing), ever seen Muslims in India in forbes 500 (Azim Premji ), please don't go by your media reports, yes, there are issues but they are blown way out of proportion by your media, even Indian Muslims have commented to Pakistanis about this in social media, rather even bleaker is the inter community Muslim fights in Pakistan (deobandi vs barelvi bombings ), sunni vs Shia, ahemadiyyas is banned etc.

[@silenthill1035]

@@APEXMACHCORPORATION Sachar Committee Report is Indian Government report, not Pakistani media report. Those are undisputed facts, not mere words which someone said. The numbers of Bengalis killed by Pakistan army are not correct. Read the research by Sharmila Bose in her book Dead Reckoning. She is an Indian as well. As far as Palestine is concerned, Palestinians will win regardless of what Pakistan does.

[@APEXMACHCORPORATION]

@@silenthill1035 regarding number of bengalis killed it is certainly a genocide and a high numbers, it remains muddled because no one cares for bangladesh back then US President called it Basket Case, US and China both hid actual news of genocide and ignored it on world forum, the figure I believe is around 2 - 2.4 million at least, with highest estimate 3 million plus, mostly Hindus where killed and then Muslims, point being Muslims were not protected by formation of Pakistan.

[@avinashmishra7735]

@@silenthill1035 Jinnah was so "careful" of the weak Muslims of Hindu majority areas that he clearly asked them to not leave India entirely and let it become Hindu Nation. He was such a bigot that he proposed 2 Nation Theory, brought it into action but opposed complete population exchange to make sure India remains JOINT ACCOUNT (Dar-Al-Harb) of Hindus and Muslims and Pakistan becomes PEROSNAL ACCOUNT of Muslims. He was such a cunning man to ask for partition of India beacuse the Indian subcontinent as a whole was Hindu majority but didn't want partition of Punjab and Bangladesh because those provinces were Muslim majority. He also made a deal with Christians of Punjab to support the creation of Pakistan in the name oF Abrahmic brotherhood but never gave them equal position in the society. Infact he deliberately disallowed many Hindus and Christians to cross the border and come to India because he thought he would use them for bargaining with India and also use them for sanitary workers. He was such a pedophile that he ran away with the daughter of his Parsi friend and converted her to Islam but was not happy to see his own daughter marry a Parsi. He was such a "freedom fighter" that he was never even jailed for an hour by the Britishers. He in fact made the deal with the Britishers of making Pakistan the part of the so called common wealth. He was such an intellectual that he never wrote anything about how to exactly run Pakistan. He was such a deceiver that he made all kinds of false promises to all kinds of Muslims just to pave the way for the disintegration of India. He was such a corrupt and racist that he wanted his private house in Mumbai to not be overtaken by the Govt of India, rather rented to some white men. He was so jealous of the Nehru-Edwina relationship that he even directly asked Mountbatten about it. He was such a hindu hater that he even visited Dalit leaders of that time like Ambedkar and Periyar to further break up India. He was such a MADHARCHOD that he even asked Brithsers to give India in the hands of Muslims because according to him "Brishers took it from Mughals". I can write on and on and on....Only Hindutva can show the world how to deal Islam with Mutual-Respect

[@ashokshukla3969]

The oversized pak army won every election and lost every war

[@aniljuyal9884]

who stopped trade btwn India and Pak ?

[@ruchinkumar8358]

Indian subcontinent is naturally designed in a way that no part if separated can survive or flourish, same thing is happening to 4 provinces forming present Pakistan

[@nitishkumar-kc5hv]

bechara shia muslim hai sunni pakistan me extra prove krna padata haI

[@silenthill1035]

Fake news.

[@baazinews1027]

Brother it's a Result of Indian Policies ( Both Positive and Negative ) that Young People Don't want to Be Pakistani Anymore The Positive Policies Being - 1. Growing our GDP , 2. Growing Our Forex Reserves, 3. Curbing on Corruption and Black Money, 4. Growing International Influence through Dr. Jaishankar, 5. Building Trust and a Favourable Business Environment In India Negative Policies ( from Pak Perspective ) Being - 1. Not talking to Pakistan, 2. Not Allowing Pakistani Artists in India, 3. Not Restarting India-Pakistan Cricket, 4. New Fifth Generation War as You said ( in response to Pakistan Continuing its Policy of Terror, and thinking that there would be no consequences ), 5. So listen bro I'm a BJP supporter from India, and we don't Hate you. But that doesn't mean you get a Free Hand to impose your ideology on us or Send State Sponsored Bad Actors to India or using your ISI Mafia network for destabilizing Activities. Now that you're getting a Pushback you all are crying. If you would have never messed with us in the 1st place, we could be living together epacefully and 100 % Pakistan would never have to go to IMF and would have sufficient Forex Reserves. So I would change the 1st sentence of my Comment and say that, It's Actually the Result of the Policies undertaken by your Oversmart Elite which has led young Pakistanis to not want to call themselves as Pakistanis.

[@zigzoog123]

kyon itna mirchi laagate ho 🔥😂

[@baazinews1027]

I will add 1 more point which is, That we Indians are now friends with Arab Sheikhs which makes Sunni Pakistani Muzlims Feel Sad That Their Abbus Cheated on them With Indians 😂

[@baazinews1027]

@@zigzoog123 Aise Hee Mazaa Aata Hai 🤗

[@gunjanagrawal8195]

In Pakistan if you have good English accent then u can become foreign minister too...

[@goodsong_views]

Find someone who is so disillusioned by you as he is by Jinnah!

[@AN_SINHA]

The ability to do doublespeak when he said jinnah is for unity is surprising

[@AF-yq9es]

Kashmir is an integral part of India.

[@rickiek]

Get better guests please. I didn’t understand anything he was trying to say.

[@ravisankargollakota3888]

I like Jinna. He separated scrap from India.

[@kashifLala97]

If QEA Jinnah was biggest champion of Muslim- Hindu cause then Mr. Zaidi is best spinner in Pakistan and deserves a place in pk squad for WT20. I am glad that zaidi could bravely speak for our baloch sister but i can say for sure that he won't be able to speak about Young Pakistani boy who died in Sydney knife attack while saving lives of many women and children and gave us rare Pakistani hero in western countries just because he was born into Ahmediyya Muslim community.

[@pankajsrivastava7203]

This ganja is living with partition hatred

[@rajkhosla8513]

What's happening in kashmir.... What's happening ??? KASHMIR OBSESSION KASHMIR OBSESSION KASHMIR OBSESSION

[@vijaybhatia2686]

No doubt the partition of india in 1947 was agonizing heart-wrenching and costly in lives snd material.But in retrospect it was the for the best for the formationof present day India.

[@gnxtpankaj]

Guest is from Dilulu area of Islamabad 😅

[@user-sx4mq6zn9o]

Brother, you are in a confusion to compare Gaza with Kashmir . Given an opportunity, whole POK would like to join with Indian Kashmir.

[@user-sx4mq6zn9o]

Pakistan stopped trade and withdrew High Commissioner from India. What urgency India has to start trade with Pakistan ?

[@venkataramanasrivatsasa6470]

Jinnah, a chameleon not a champion of unity. He was just a stooge of the British, who saw in him a deal breaker in the partition. His direct action day call annihilated lakhs of lives and an eternal hatred between the newly formed countries. He refused to interfere and give a stop call to the violent mobs in Pakistan who were killing Sikhs and Hindus unlike Gandhi who toured the affected areas without chappals and without security putting his life in danger for the sake of muslims. Jinnah was relaxing with a cigar and a glass of wine in his hand chewing piece of ham, as usual. He never went to jail and was always enjoying his life like the guest and talking about an elusive country formed on the basis of hatred.

[@anilganjoo8401]

Zip Off Talibani😮😮😮😮

[@romeshsharma4305]

Jinnah was a blessing in disguise for the then Bharat, who took so many radical Muslims in Pakistan. Otherwise India at present would have been in turmoil. Bangladesh should also treat Jinnah as father of their nation because in 1948 he said in Dhaka that only Urdu will be the national language of entire Pakistan. I have lived with Indian Bengali for 5 years from where I came to know that they love their culture ( including their language) more than their religion. And so Jinnah cultivated the desire of break up of that Pakistan in 1948 ,and 1971 he succeeded although after his demise.

[@ashvinn15]

🤣 this guy was policy advisor for Pakistan Govt , india is truly blessed

[@YS27122]

Knowledge 0% Wisdom 0% Intellect 0% Comprehensive analysis 0% Lahori churan 100%✅ Madarssachhap analysis 100%✅ Attitude 100%✅ Fake accent 100%✅

[@akshay_wakodikar]

Absolutely

[@siddharthatalukdar4227]

Thank You Jinnah, for taking so called intellectuals like Zaidi. I agree with him to make Pakistan spend more on military and not on health, infrastructure, education, sports

[@chevellesome]

Just because INDIA is more capable in terms of capital, technology, military and ability, India is a threat to existence to Pak? India Pak ko threat soch skta h because all wars were first started by by Pakistan. Also, India has no first use nuclear weapons policies while Pakistan doesn't. Considering the war kargil war initiated just after historic talk between PM Vajpayee and PM Nawaj for Kasmir resolution, considering the financing and strategic aid or training provided in the sovereign space of state of Pak for attack in Indian territories, considering no action taken against likes of Hafiz saed, India had always retaliated as response but never applied pro active approach. Now India uses aggresive policies and talks will have little space for Pak. But still, it's better than no deal considering future aspects for the nation. China will act to secure mortgages given by Pak for their investment in cpec in future, China took part of Pak occupied kasmir and no one in Pak resisted, even Saudis will buy pak's public entities to call it investment but business with India was never been like this.

[@aniketranade]

Hes like an extremely articulate version of Zaid Hamid 😃

[@bambamkumarjha8120]

He is leberal and conservative 🤣🤣 like Islam promote democracy 🤣🤣

[@fanthony]

Definition of delulu that a slick accent cannot cover up.

[@user-sx4mq6zn9o]

What does India gain by trading with Pakistan ?? India will look ther way as long as cross border terrorism is continued by ISI and Pak Army on Indian soil.

[@chidambardeshpande1716]

Goodwill of Pakistani is most important and actual rulers may not be interested for business. They may feel Indians are enemies by birth.

[@GuzzarAwan]

I frm india think that Jinnah loved india very much. Bcoz he kept his lovely porpeorty in mumbai as it is to return later. But before that he tried to seperate the garbage from india into seperate land called pakistan. Though its sad that he died before he cud return to india again

[@zammerudjaffery3263]

PARTITION NOT BE DONE BY PERPOTIONLY WE LEFT 4 CRORE MUSLIM IN INDIA ,SHOULD NOT APPLY TWO NATION THEORY ON INDIAN MUSLIM ISLAM IS NOT BINDING FORCE CONUTRY CREATE BY CULTURE

[@user-sx4mq6zn9o]

Selection of guest was not good . Boring.

[@HarshPatel-yh7cq]

I am scared if there is cross boarder movement ever with Pakistan. We need strong boarder to keep them out

[@gnxtpankaj]

Fair conversation with who?? PM, ISI, Taliban, Army or civil society.. Pakistanis are always looking outward for all the problems.

[@TanujAbhayKhanna]

@26:35 If there is a willing partner in India.....blah accent blah blah accent blah blah accent blah. We remember what you did to Today's darlings of pakistan Vajpayee and Manmohan. Kargil, IC814, Parliament, 26/11. But accent achha tha!!

[@aksh5217]

Frto jinnah ko pakistan ko islamic nation nahi banna tha secular rkhna tha 😂 itni unity thi to sikkho ko kyu bhagya ?

[@mr___swag925]

15:58 pak studies totally jhutt 😅😅😅😅pak studies reading karke Pakistani apane apa ko intellectual samajhate he😂😂😂

[@AshutoshTripathi-ug9qm]

“Jinnah was the greatest champion for Hindu muslim unity,,,Ye Pak studies Mai hai, Esko deny Nagi kar Saket” . 😅😅😅 can’t deny “Pakistan studies” An oxymoron if there was any . With this kind of so called intellectuals calling their own country a valuable plot of land there no need look for enemies outside.

[@devshetty7465]

Wgat does this fellow feed his brain?

[@astv6491]

How dare these so called intellectuals compare Gaza with Kashmir…….🤬

[@w.a.4972]

"Dominant political lifeblood" of India. 😂 Despite all you hear in the vested media against Modi, it is ridiculous ridiculous that you believe this. Pity. You otherwise sounded like a well read person. I'm not a Modi fan. He had little finesse, but this media hype isn't true, sir!

[@vherlekar]

At 7:55 - he says he made mistake of "200 vs 300 Years"...the REAL mistake shud be "Years vs WEEKS" 👆 (ask ex-PM Imran Khan) 😁😁

[@VinodhKumar1989]

It is Pakistan which broke trade relationships with India(after removal of Art 370), and now you expect India to extend the olive branch? For the long term, even after Modi became the PM, India gave Pakistan the most favoured nation status. Modi travelled to Sharif's granddaughter's wedding. What did India get in return? Pakistan stalled every development talks in SAARC meetings. India proposed a common highway for SAARC countries and Pakistan vetoed it. This led to India abandoning SAARC and instead focus on BIMSTEC. And again you come here and talk about India not cooperating for trade. Seriously?

[@vijaybhatia2686]

BTW what was the genius of Zia who was a fanatic, intrduced the blasphemy and Sharia laws in Pakistan to bolster his regime?

[@vaisagar]

Jinah Vision was just to create his majesty.. he did that and died because of his Aiashi.. why interviewer is showing accent? Very bad interview..

[@VictimHood-qv1hx]

Pakistan should now focus on Red Fort in NewDelhi as the new capital

[@nishu413]

Noone fights in india for credit for breaking Pakistan. That credit is always to Indira Gandhi, field marshal sam manekshaw and their team. I believe even BJP believes it.

[@NikhileshSurve]

11:28 You can at least start by learning Punjabi, Seraiki, Sindhi & Balochi in school. They too have rich culture.

[@VivekD-td5xc]

This guy praises Jinnah for creating Pakistan to protect muslims of the sub-continent from hindu majoritarianism. By the same yardstick, even the Baloch people should be allowed to escape Punjabi majoritarianism in Pakistan and be an independent nation.

[@bhaveshpatel7042]

Whiich Muslims? What about Bangladesh? What about secular Muslims stayed back in India. This ZAIDI guy does not know history.

[@umangdesai4136]

51:48 - not PYUTIN.. his name is PUT-In.. put in..!!

[@chidambardeshpande1716]

Hard work with great devotion is a must for a generation and true to God, like Japanese.

[@vijaybhatia2686]

This Zaidi fellow was touting and justifying the need for Pakistan to have its inordinately huge defense forces who incidentally havenever won a war. He should know that the reason Bangladesh has spearheaded ahead of Pakistan in leaps and bounds and even India to a much lesser degree in its GDP is that it has hardly any defense expenditures worth the name.