People MTG Player Quiz Show vs 20 People

Can you tell if a Magic card is fake? How well do you know your creature types? Take this quiz & see if you can beat our MTG-Trivia endboss, Thoralf Severin!
Want to see the full list of counters in Magic (with examples)? Check:
bit.ly/43Nzr6x
_______________________________
！Opinions expressed in this video are those of the author/video creator and not necessarily Cardmarket.
➥ Buy and Sell your cards: 🛒
www.cmkt.co/v
You can find us on:
👾Twitch: / cardmarket_magic
📷 Instagram: / cardmarket_magic
📘Facebook: / cardmarketmagic
🐦Twitter: / cardmarketmagic

[@CardmarketMagic]

Want to see the full list of counters in Magic (with examples)? Check: bit.ly/43Nzr6x

[@MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM-f4x]

Side note I found an infinite combo and you need three cards but it doesn’t really work with just 3 so the first is wren and realmbreaker emblem the second is Azura lost but seeking and the third is walk the aeons your smart enough to figure out how

[@prn_Melatonin]

KI COUNTER?

[@stone5against1]

2:50 Carl: "There are many types of counters in Magic The Gathering" Me: "... Counterspell?"

[@DaTimmeh]

Can you name a counter? Every blue player:

[@chasm9557]

Croak counters and bribery counters I think would be a couple sneaky ones to remember but not say since as far as I know, they're each only on one card.

[@willsmith-qb5bn]

You could get real cheeky and do things like flying counter

[@jeromedarnell6270]

"Saproling Counte- " "You removed them all."

[@genzo454]

Ritual Counter, let's go 😂

[@TheCubicalGuy]

Neither person getting voidwalker when it was literally brought up earlier in the counters point made me so distraught lmao

[@pneu_8365]

Nerd

[@Hoologramek]

We as KZbin audience saw it, they didn't see it live XD

[@Shimatzu95]

To be fair the ULTRA zoomed in first picture is just hard to get right.

[@TheReddaredevil223]

That was not your average audience lol. They knew their stuff

[@RumpledNutskin]

Lol I got every one of these questions right. They're all easy 😂

[@TheReddaredevil223]

@@RumpledNutskin Ok we got a badass over here

[@paulh.9526]

One of them was a judge so yeah

[@RumpledNutskin]

@@paulh.9526 knowing the rules of the game doesn't mean you know everything else

[@guillaumebasch2688]

Who goes for contagion counters as your second guess lol 😂 throwing for content

[@SneoK]

seems like that audience had some fading counters on them...until only few remained :D

[@CardmarketMagic]

The next round in the tournament had started 😅

[@deutscher1a]

not just "some" One of them is a german mtg streamer, watched his early access video earlier today xD

[@CardmarketMagic]

@deutscher1a SolAris is great :) we have a video coming out with him next week!

[@deutscher1a]

@@CardmarketMagic i didnt know if i was able to say his name, its sol4r1s mtg on here ;) Glad to hear about that - ill def watch it❤️

[@rfs8194]

Love the double-reverse psychology on the centaur question! Knight is just too obvious as an answer isn't it?

[@fatefulwaffle]

We had the magic, and now we have the gathering

[@Loki-]

I got 8 points and guessed 2 away from the price at the end! 🎉❤ That's the best I've done on these since coming back to magic 2 years ago! I've learned a lot and I'm happy to be so involved in mtg. More than I've ever been. (Thanks to help from this channel!)

[@CardmarketMagic]

Hey! You've been a viewer since early in the channel :D thank you for your continued support!

[@Joebob31100]

Super proud I got the Blood Artist and Kodama's Reach questions. But I flubbed on most of the others

[@CardmarketMagic]

They were the toughest questions in my opinion 👏👏👏

[@DNGNDriver]

(Will fill this in as I watch the video) B C (hypersonic dragon was in the Guild Kit I got as a teen!) 3: N/A 4: It's an Arcane Sorcery (the only difference between it and cultivate- I jammed both in my first EDH deck) 5: Knight 6: guess @ 3 = dauthi voidwalker 7: artist name change? 8: A 9: guess @ 3 = deep analysis 10: 40 euro

[@aryst0krat]

I was hoping the counter question would go longer! That was fun

[@hoodiegal]

Oh, my god, the Blood Artist. I literally went "did he change what the artist is painting? No, there's no way he'd do that..."

[@Scrimshaw_DuBois42]

Cool idea! I got 7, but I think we had a little help on the Voidwalker art question, since the video showed the card for a brief moment second when the Counters question came up.

[@ericaschner3283]

First one of these I actually did well on. 😅 Not only the multiple choice, but got both Voidwalker and Oracle at full zoom. :D

[@evanshaner991]

On some of these questions, I swear Thoralf is throwing for content.

[@CardmarketMagic]

If he was playing for content, he would be making the game much closer :P

[@evanshaner991]

​@CardmarketMagic Are you telling me he went for -1/-2 counters before -1/-1 and *wasn't* throwing for content?

[@CardmarketMagic]

@@evanshaner991 he thought he was being clever 😅 trying to name the counters from Contagion

[@alexhaenzi]

Thoralf is such a likable character.

[@eq2lornick]

He had to throw the knight question on purpose. It's not even close either. There are like a million knights but the other two are fairly uncommon.

[@Esper_Compleat]

Lol had it exactly with the audience until the finance question where i guessed $75, which is ~ €69

[@VestigeX3]

8:13 thought sponge!!

[@pdb189]

No fair! Katarina is a ringer!

[@aLocalGuy312]

b op de eerste vraag is het nac breda logo lol

[@Voerder100]

Bring more Katharina 😊

[@hannesmayer5215]

Ihr müsst mal ein pauper kommander match machen 😂

[@lanibentz9976]

Remind me to never challenge the Italians

[@mobster24451]

Not gonna lie i only knew the first answer because i knew that was the nhl logo

[@g4greed502]

I guessed 63 for dockside... i need to play other formats

[@Reaprar]

hi sorry i just wanna say as a woman the person with blue hair in the audience was very cute thank you

[@edisonkelly2729]

will we see the yugioh channel again?

[@CardmarketMagic]

Yes :) it should be back within a month

[@Botanick13]

Hi guys, is Thorals still active as pro player?

[@JoeRae-du8iv]

Yeh!

[@vladtodorov4665]

Carl is a true showman. This man is made to present and host shows/games.

[@tzaandor]

In the immortal words of Benjamin Wheeler: Magic the Gathering.

[@suNn.K.O]

Magic: The Gathering.

[@tzaandor]

Magic the Gathering

[@claudiomonteverdi847]

tip for next time^^ You could make a quadrant on the ground to represent the answers and eliminate all the people on the wrong ones

[@jollychris1010101]

Is that the same Katarina (sorry if the spelling is wrong) who appeared in a video before? She sen t a deck in and piloted in 1 or 2 of the matches.

[@BoltTheEmolga]

Yeah that’s actually the same one

[@donhooplah]

She was very good on that episode

[@tomthemime4318]

Yep, the Gruul Shamans deck.

[@mortuc1]

Makes it feel more scripted tbh

[@SandroSegadora]

The zoomed in picture that ended up being Thoracle tripped me up so hard. I could swear on my life that it was Deep Analysis.

[@Chocolate83Bunny]

That was my guess as well

[@madelinemccaul8209]

I really thought it was Mirari

[@TheLuckySpades]

That Thoracle was great, I also got it immediately since it is the bane of my local commander scene

[@BoltTheEmolga]

The bane of every commander scene to ever exist

[@abjoern]

Probably why Thoralf didn't get it, he only plays magic

[@whaleofdarkness]

I first thought of the oldest Icy Manipulator art, but that would have been too niche.

[@JohnFromAccounting]

I am a Doomsday junkie so I immediately knew it. Same with Dauthi Voidwalker.

[@AnoraksMuseum-eu9ph]

I thought it was Deep Analysis

[@GG-dt5hh]

There in fact 2 sponges. There is also Thought Sponge. I only know this because I have an EDH deck that is exclusively just "the sea creatures that get forgotten". The deck runs sponges, nautiluses, squid, whales, etc. Basically everything Ula's temple forgets about

[@andrewb378]

What about Homarids?

[@GG-dt5hh]

@@andrewb378 Yes, but the only one in the deck is the OG Homarid, because who wouldn''t want to keep track of tide counters?

[@DoABarrelRol1l]

I love it! I really want something that at least brings the lesser forgotten of the forgotten sea creatures together. Fish, Sharks, Whales, Crabs… Quest for Ula’s distant cousin’s temple. Do you have a decklist online somewhere? I love looking at my sea bois

[@Cpipzy]

Asking for a deck list as well cause I just made an "Under the sea" commander deck on Arena with all water-themed cards haha

[@TehKorwinMikke]

Liking Myr, building a Myr deck, and checking the oracle database for all Myr paid off! I received one point.

[@stone5against1]

Wow that last question, love how they guessed so close to one another! Only thing that would have made it better is if the price had been 56.50, split in the middle haha

[@StefanodeCurtis]

I'm guy who answered the dockside question! I'll be seeing you in Amsterdam to answer more trivia questions hopefully :)

[@CardmarketMagic]

Come join! We'll be doing another qui, in the panel area on Friday :)

[@DemonaruMusic]

8:20 WALKING SPONGE...is not the only sponge in the game. Thought Sponge also exists!

[@BCfightan]

The audience mostly left by the end haha but this was still sweet, hopefully the turnout is good if you ever do it again. Liked the video to show my support

[@yoshimitsu5537]

Great video! The various gameshow episodes are still my favorite (except for Fele piloting the Treasure Cruise/Zombie Infestation deck).

[@pannina.]

my boyfriend is in this video

[@thenumberpie314]

tl;dr one of my friends had a japanese blood artist and i just discovered in this video it doesn't drain each opponent I was once playing Commander with some friends. We're all quite inexperienced, and one of my friends (let's call him Joe) casts a Blood Artist in Japanese (because it was cheaper to buy). Everyone but him was at less than 30 life, and Joe had like 10 1/1 spirit tokens and a card with "whenever you gain life, each opponent loses that much life", alongside Teysa Karlov and an Ashnod's Altar kind of effect. He sacced all of his tokens. None of us knew Japanese and were like "wait... does Blood Artist target or does it say each" and Joe was like "I think it says each". That meant we all died to his Blood Artist triggers. Seeing BA in this video as a "modified" card I thought "oh this is so easy, it's each instead of target opponent" and then seeing Carl say the error was in the art made me SO angry.

[@Tharkon]

That's Zulaport Cutthroat, but that only triggers when your own creatures die. So either it triggers for each player but you only drain one, or it triggers for only you but it drains all opponents, that's the decision you have to make, more lifegain or more lifeloss. Zulaport Cutthroat is also a lot cheaper than Blood Artist.

[@MrZambEasy]

What's magic?

[@logancalapp2426]

You have much to learn

[@SchizophrenicRuneterran]

Magic the Gathering is a card game. It's can be kinda complicated at first, but if you stick with it it's fun af and is a great way to meet new friends and socialize!

[@provoidcloak]

The gathering

[@darthwatto]

I thinks like a board game or something

[@Leuber]

For the -1/-2 counters Thoralf starts saying they are from Contagion before Carl quickly continues. However, it actually gives -2/-1 counters which is a bit less powerful, but it can still kill a Psychatog if needed in a best deck ever tournament.

[@StetsonM]

I was so close to getting all of them right. I couldn't remember a mire myr or walking sponge and I couldn't remember there being a horse logo. I still don't know where that's from loll

[@awesomeguy5451]

I got question 8 immediately, I'm quite familiar with funny mtg cards

[@dekina1198]

the fumble on contagion, LOL. i thought that part would have been WAYa lot longer. mire myr could have been the myr that taps for black. didn't know the sponge. i would have gotten 12 points. 1st wrong, 2nd, 3rd right, (2 points) 4, would have gotten way more counters then thoralf, since he failed early. (3 points) 5th right, (4 points) 6 would have gotten dauthi voidwalker on 3 points (7 points) 7: right, why are the rose pattles on the art if no rose is seen? (8 points) 8: wrong. mire myr could have been the myr that taps for black. didn't know the sponge. (8) 9, would have gotten thassas on 3 points. (11) 10: thought dockside would be around 65€ (12 points total)

[@andreww479]

Salvat/Hachette is one of my favorite sets partially bc the Set Logo is so random and for being a bunch of out of place white border cards. Also it would be a hilarious photoshop challenge to show someone a Salvat card and have them figure out what it even is

[@Repaurcas]

I love that I know many of the guessers here, met them in person in Bologna, Prag etc., sad that I wasn't there this time, but shout outs to Katharina and Jules from this Clip☺️

[@JoeDF]

Can confirm. Thoralf knows Magic.

[@victhefoxygamer_6180]

Love these little quiz/game shows. Can't wait for more. Also, cannot wait for "LESSER USED TRIBE BATTLE!" Siltai Oozes (no changelings, that's cheating) v Jund Spiders v Naya Minotaurs v Grixis Insects Just a few tribes that came to mind that I feel we don't see enough in MTG. Especially in regards to Oozes. Would love to see my goopy little Ooze lads CONSUME the competition. (I know that it was mentioned to be kept in mind, but I'm annoying and impatient c: )

[@AlienValkyrie]

I keep thinking the Price round could be even more exciting if the points were based on how much closer you are. Like, if your guess is six times further away than your opponent's, your opponent gets six points. If you guess the exact price, infinite points for you.

[@idanbhk3875]

Oh, nice! that solves the "we're discarding all previous points" problem, while still keeping the potential of gaining enough to offset any advantage. Excellent idea.

[@SmashPortal]

- I thought Blood Artist had different wording. - I thought Thassa's Oracle was Deep Analysis. - I guessed $65 for Dockside Extortionist. Everything else I got right. I'm pretty happy.

[@Tharkon]

Question 1: I though it was A, but instead of telling us that the fake one is based on a hockey logo (I assumed you just made up a fake logo), you should tell us what sets the real ones are from. A is apparently from a very obscure starter set from 2005 only released in Italy, France, Spain and the UK that wasn't even released by WotC, but by Salvat in collaboration with Hasbro. You won't find it on most lists of Magic set symbol, so I'm surprised so many people got the answer, guess they must have been from one of those four countries. B I thought was C19 but just mirror image, C I did recognize, but was never actually printed on a card, so would also be hard to recognize, I only recognized it because I digitalized my cards, it's Chronicles. D is Baldur's Gate Commander. Question 2: Thoral guessed correctly that it was Hypersonic Dragon, but that was not the question, he held up the wrong picture so he would have gotten that one wrong. So did I though, mostly because I thought Niv-Mizzet was being contained and that didn't seem like something featured on a Niv-Mizzet card. But it was actually a shield representing hexproof. Question 3: I think I'd do well in this, having looked up a list of all counters a few days ago. I'd name the keyword counters pretty early because as soon as you name one, your opponent will catch on to them, but I'd reserve Shadow because they might not think of that one. I'd stay away from the old +/1 counters for the exact reason Thoralf showed. Question 4 and 5 were pretty easy. Question 6: I knew it was a Dauthi, but I'd have to guess. The video beat me to it before I could guess a random Dauthi. Consider Dauthi Voidwalker was named earlier in the counters question it's likely I would have gone for that one as well though. Question 7 got me confused, I was thinking Blood Artist was male, and I guess that's because I play the original one. Question 8: I was with Thoralf here, but B was my second guess. C and D I knew 100% were correct. Question 9: My guess was Mirari. But guess it was more zoomed in than I thought. Question 10: I went with €50, going for a round number, I did think it was more likely higher than 50 than below so I should have guessed higher. So guess I'd have 5 points.

[@Tselel]

For the American viewers (myself included) the answer to the last question in USD is..... (spoiler shield) $68.15

[@jacobisbell9388]

I don't know why Thoralf tried to go obscure so early on the counter question. -1/-1, loyalty, various keyword counters, should all be eliminated before your opponent can use them

[@chrisjett6232]

I only got #1 because I'm familiar with hockey. The Pegasus I was completely unfamiliar with, not even heard of the set

[@dapperghastmeowregard]

Got 1 and 8 on process of elimination (1 I wasn't sure between the first two, but guessed the shield was a classic misdirect given the meme about how horny the commander sets are for jamming a shield into every expansion symbol :P)

[@toast_recon]

I'm glad the counter part ended quickly. Interesting idea for a question, but it could have taken over 10 minutes if thoralf hadn't gone for something obscure.

[@cat-astrophe8697]

They should have put me on the counter question :D I regularly play a Commander Atraxa Deck with ~45 different counters

[@danielklein5829]

surprised you didn't use the FC Bologna crest as the fake set symbol, would've blended right in

[@TheMuffinBagare]

I'm staring myself blind on a list with all set icons but I can't find what set icon A is from. (First question)

[@excalipoor]

Hmm… think the best is to pick a champion for every question. Just a suggestion.

[@mariamagda666]

This is unironically my favorite game show (ok after game changer maybe)

[@Baalsson]

I wonder that anybody pointed out that there is Sol4R1s among the people in the audience.

[@tylerduncanson2661]

Looks like Thoralf needs to play more cEDH

[@codacoder]

You could easily host a MtG "who wants to be a millionaire" :D

[@shawnosnap3462]

contagion would be gas if it gave 2 -1/-2 counters lol

[@patatop850]

Me at the third question: Flying counter Deathtouch counter First strike counter Lifelink counter Yea I played Ikoria Oh yea, hexproof counter, my beloved

[@CardmarketMagic]

I counted the keyword counters as one single answer for this question, for obvious reasons 😅

[@darklord161]

The counter round was easy since there are counters for many keywords

[@uriarte411]

Honestly the nerf on Thoralf because he doesn't play much commander. Thoracle and Dauthi are pretty easy if you end up playing against them constantly.

[@CardmarketMagic]

They are both constructed staples in Modern/pioneer

[@Flip4Crypt]

Cool to see Katarina back! The counter battle was great

[@joshmartin533]

Oh... I'm like EARLY early... 😎

[@GaleonBlazer]

I’m hating myself for not participating in this 😭😭 I knew most of the answers! But I had to leave for lunch :( next time for sure! (and I’ll be sure to stick around until the very end) ❤️ you guys rock, keep it up

[@lawtonfriedland1228]

Filibuster counters were screaming at me

[@vitulzboubinator4883]

I just beat Thralf and the audience oO

[@MunetsuguTakeno]

I though I was doing decently, I even knew that Kodama´s reach was printed in Kamigawa my favorite block, I believe its champions of Kamigawa to be more precise and it was clearly a spell of Kami therefore it had to be arcane (nice try though), Niv was easy though I didnt recalled name, I even got the card guess from first picture it its clearly a shadow card and shadow(there is only about ~23 shadow cards in black) is usually connected with black my favorite color per the art and the only "shadow hand" on a tree? is Dauthi Voidwalker...then it went to hell. I though that Blood Artis was honesty fine though I am not playing for a while so I didnt know about the new art to be fair, I ultimatly though it was Common or 1/2..well I was wrong at that. The card name? Piece of cake. Frog was printed after I rotated back in 2011~ or so, it was printed later, but one of the nasty limited card was it..2015? Brushwaggs are so rare that it had to be a bait..leving only Sponge and Mire. Considering that Myr Sire was printed and its name is pronouced rather simiiarly I though yuore banking on that so 50/50 more favoring Mire. Afterwards I derped on Oracle..I was like orb....sphere...That could be Trinishphere oh man I never was so wrong before...I should had knew because its blue and such a cheesy win card, but yeah I dont play anymore...and finally I overshoot the pirate, I though hes really powerful especially in comander...So I guessed 72.34. Considering I was 10 off It wasnt that bad, but Thoralf guessed it way better. So I guess I would be ultimatly..arround 8-9 murbles? I wasnt counting tbf.Well I think about 3 mistakes is not a bad result on a guy who quit long time ago (and even more exlucing commander).

[@iTzDritte]

I got the Blood Artist question correct at 7:25 , dunno if that’s a good thing or not

[@JohnFromAccounting]

I thought the painting was upside down, but turns out it was just the wrong painting.

[@Couldnt_Be_Bothered]

8:12 this is incorrect as there is a second sponge. Thought Sponge from Commander 2019. I think you should lose a point for blunder.

[@Arkanemacht]

1:33 what set is C?

[@cripuspl2784]

Pretty sure its Chronicles

[@ericaschner3283]

Chronicles

[@Leuber]

It is but an interesting aspect is that paper cards from Chronicles did not have this symbol (they had the symbols from the set they were reprinted from).

[@Kalenz1234]

All the keyword counters..

[@canadianbakn]

My first thought when they showed that this was a legacy European tour event was "oh man, these people are going to know magic". They didn't disappoint!

[@ApproachoftheSecondGame]

NEXT MTG TRIVIA MATCH : Thoralf vs ChatGPT

[@tciddados]

8 points (ignoring the counters one since I can't participate there), I did pretty well. Though mostly from the art questions.

[@violaknapp7904]

Nice to see Katharina again!

[@ianh1504]

When i played celestial sunmare in standard i was desperate to load my deck with horses and there were basically none

[@donniebankoebarkie7916]

Theres actually TWO sponges in magic the gathering :)

[@iansvoice1]

Lol got tripped up so bad on the Euro value of Dockside

[@Lcngopher]

Love how i knew it was the nhl shield logo in question 1 as soon as i saw it.

[@ben668]

Question 8 the sponge was from urzas legacy

[@ronaibarnabas7174]

I almost got everything right.

[@CardmarketMagic]

👏👏👏 You must really know magic :)

[@lastnamefirstname8655]

nice competition between thoralf and the community!

[@BruderSeth]

the fuck, why is this crowd so tiny? You deserve at least 100x that audience.

[@CardmarketMagic]

That is very kind of you to say :) but we were at a competitive tournament 😅 everyone was busy playing their rounds

[@allanturmaine5496]

I love game shows!

[@TheodorBuroman]

Hä you are a Yogijochannal what are you doing with this magic stuff?😅

[@justanothercommenter5835]

Did you not notice the 'CardMarket - Magic' channel name?

[@haizhouz7627]

wow that guy doesnt know magic

[@justanothercommenter5835]

3 top 8s at GPs and Mythic Champion at Barcelona.

[@lovreivancevic1170]

You should 100% invite some ygo players to try and play magic Examole teamsamuraiX his mind will be blown when he tries mono w humans and sees what a thalia can do