A Car Catastrophe

The plaintiff parked his car at the defendant’s garage and was quoted one price, but when he returned to get his car, he was charged for much more than initially told. He’s suing for breach of contract. The defendant argues the plaintiff picked up his car two days late, which is why he’s being charged more money.
26-407

[@anthonynelson1187]

Scary to think there are grown people like the plaintiff living amongst us

[@Micknkeithable]

The entire RepubliCon Party behaves like the plaintiff

[@user-vd5ii4eo7u]

​@@MicknkeithableI guarantee Mr Puerto Rico is a democry

[@blacklesbiansociety9124]

😊😊😊😊😊😊

[@antdogg5041]

It’s terrifying! And he still believes he’s right smfh

[@KA-ey9sc]

@@user-vd5ii4eo7u found the bigot who doesn’t realize MANY Puerto Ricans adore Trump bc they are self-hating. They have the American dream and don’t want any of the kinsman to have it. ~ Signed, A Puerto Rican

[@Lauren80s]

Only thing missing was JM saying “all of us other mere mortals have to pay for extra days” 😂

[@AC081361]

The plaintiffs lack of comprehension is astonishing 😳

[@angelmercy5261]

It’s amazing these type of people exist.

[@robertschaaf7192]

I’m listening to him and he does seem confused.

[@essie2459]

He comprehends….he’s just bullheaded

[@frankgiuliano380]

This is why we had to move from NYC.. these people are so un-educated.

[@aprilpinketon2567]

No, the audacity of his entitled-ness! He comprehended just fine. He just wants what he wants! The company don’t owe you to cut you a break on your tardiness. They offer you a day back and you say more! Please! Just a jerk!

[@Catloudan]

Sue Jet Blue for what?? They can't control weather. The Plaintiffs are so ignorant!

[@johnmdaniels27]

I laughed even she asked that

[@The_Snowowl]

Right, that’s why travel insurance exists. I’m not sure about parking but they reimburse for other expenses like hotels, food, etc if your flight is delayed or cancelled.

[@M2161]

Even then, when you accept terms and conditions. You cannot sue the airline, any legal action must be done in mediation. The plaintiffs don’t understand the concept of eating your costs.

[@themrs.1200]

@@M2161 One can definitely sue airlines or travel companies. It happens quite often.

[@M2161]

@@themrs.1200 you can try to sue but it will go straight to mediation. Most of settlements aren’t ever brought before a judge unless gross negligence was actually involved, and those usually end up being class action suits.

[@michaelwolff1694]

Wow.... that plaintiff seems, to me, to be right out of the Twilight Zone.... I find it scary that someone can think the way he does and still get a drivers' license.

[@BrandonRoss1]

Seriously. And the idea that a person like that can just file a lawsuit and waste everybody's time and resources because they refuse to listen and accept how wrong they are... it's just sad.

[@user-vd5ii4eo7u]

That's what happens when you're a spoiled brat!

[@pammers5588]

The plaintiff is very pig headed and self righteous. I would not want to have to be around this guy. Hopefully what Judge Milian told him syncs in. He sorely needs a reality check.

[@ftngie]

Not the girlfriend asking should we sue the airline for the delay 😂

[@themrs.1200]

Likeeee, she will be holding someone responsible other than her man, her man, her man. 😂😂

[@essie2459]

Judge Milian had patience today….because I would’ve explained this to the Plaintiff ONE time and ONE Time only!! If he didn’t get it after that….too bad.

[@bluesoda404]

completely off subject.. love your name lol. is that really your name?

[@juliecranford534]

I agree about her patience today! I think maybe she was just so fascinated by his stubbornness that she was trying to see if he really didn’t get it or where he was actually coming from. Plus she was curious about the girlfriend because there’s no way two people could think this ridiculous way. Judge MM wanted to know if she was simply going along to get along. At least that’s my take.

[@scooneil]

I don't know how much of it was patience, haha. A case this open and shut would take about 30 seconds to resolve. Gotta drag it out a bit to make an episode out of it, particularly with a plaintiff this "entertaining."

[@juliecranford534]

@@scooneil Ahhh! Great point!! Whatever it was-I enjoyed trying to follow his logic, especially since I knew justice would prevail! Haha!

[@352kahealani]

She had time 😂 Judge Judy would have this shit

[@elisol2]

Waste of the Judge’s time, but entertaining for us 😂

[@marcusgerald5451]

Agreed.

[@bjohnson1149]

I'd be embarrassed to be the plaintiff and appear so foolish on national TV.

[@kristineo2926]

He is too stupid to be enbarrassed.

[@theburntoutlighter1084]

Loved judge Judy and old school dr phil BUT HELL NO FOR EVEN REMOTELY GOING OR EVEN being apart of THE IN THE AUDIENCE. My double chins would know that something was up. And no Oprah for her wishlist... Bees.

[@keiariabailey8739]

The way the judge was explaining it to them like a math question that’s on a 3rd graders homework 😂😂

[@pammers5588]

I know and he still didn’t get it

[@inthemouthofmadness5910]

The plaintiff is the type of person that wants everything handed to him on a silver platter. Nothing will ever be good enough for him.

[@exlesoes]

I think he had the idea and ran when it when he should have let it go... especially if/since he did get the $37 back?

[@merrymaid2890]

What a horrible man. I hope she has left him. I pretty sure he always has to have the last word. Especially at home. And that he’s gaslighting her.

[@shanewoods2519]

I can't understand how she was with him for 3 years anyway

[@robertschaaf7192]

That may be true but you’re really making assumptions there.

[@BobBlumenfeld]

This was an attempted power play by the plaintiff. Getting his money back wasn't enough for him; he wanted to punish the defendant. I'm surprised he didn't sue for triple damages (I know, there weren't any real damages, but he seems to think he can arbitrarily demand twice what he paid, so ...)

[@Mishel33020]

He's feelings were hurt when they kept hanging up on him, and he was gonna show them!!! How dare they hang up on him? That's why he filed a suit. He needs to get ahold of his temper, get a grip, and grow up.

[@JamieM470]

@@Mishel33020 Yep, and I can see exactly why they hung up on him. If he was trying to talk over the judge on national tv non-stop with his illogical nonsense and anger at the defendant over his own actions, and trying to explain simple logic to him is like beating your head on a wall, how did he act on the phone? 🤯

[@sonicpharmacist]

“Yeah you are pig-headed.” Doug is SAVAGE!

[@sarahrean7174]

😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@carliemichelle3110]

I love the defendant’s laugh when she asks, “do you really think you need to say something?” 😂

[@WarGrowlmon18]

He should've just taken the 37 bucks!!!🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤷‍♂️🤷‍♂️🤷‍♂️🤣🤣🤣

[@danedookie5478]

Hes probably going to sue his girlfriend for agreeing with the judge.

[@jalice444]

😂😂

[@moparmadness0180]

She didn't really agree. He said in in the closing interview, she just agreed to end the case and move on. She knew at that point they lost the case and there was no point arguing with the judge. She was completely on board with him.

[@DonziGT230]

I would have countersued. The plaintiff's suit was a textbook example of a frivolous lawsuit.

[@SimplyNina1]

I appreciate watching judge Milan over judge Mathis. She rules the way it should be legally while schooling you on the actual law.

[@lulusgm1]

I love them both but Mathis Gets annoying when he rolls off of his own emotions

[@SimplyNina1]

@@lulusgm1 yeah that's why I couldn't take it anymore. The rulings be very wrong, then the defendant will say something crazy at the end and shows they owed the person 🤦🏾‍♀️ a mess

[@DaisyA-04]

She is my favourite judge by far!

[@Mishel33020]

Yeah, I had to stop watching him because he's so condescending. When you're judge, you're supposed to be in partial. And he clearly was not.

[@FloChee]

Mathis rules by emotion not the law.

[@SimplyNina1]

The plaintiff didn't get it. He messed up and want them to pay for his mistake 🤦🏾‍♀️

[@JohnSmith-gu3ub]

These people are like, "I got wet when it rained. Who do I sue about it?"

[@PoodleHead2005]

I’m surprised Judge Milian didn’t kick out the plaintiff when he tried to talk over her too much. 😄

[@shanewoods2519]

Judge Judy sure would have

[@anthonynelson1187]

This show is for entertainment.. she knows what she's doing

[@jennygiallanza4524]

Plaintiff: I want to speak with the manager! A total Karen

[@inukoko2012]

They should’ve just did a extra day anyway just because sometimes flights are delayed. You can’t assume your flight will always be on time.

[@jasonmccann8023]

Right I always do another day

[@Tony_417]

Omg the plaintiffs are beyond stupid and entitled. These clowns had no business bringing this case. I can’t believe they even paid the filing fee to bring the case to court.

[@elisol2]

Exactly! They lost more than what they wanted 🥴. If I was the defendant, I would’ve counter sued for waste of time or something

[@Nevaeh1]

he should have just took the $37

[@8thhousealchemist600]

Plantiff purposely makes life difficult for himself and everyone who has to interact with him.

[@pammers5588]

He’s one of the types of personalities that I steer clear of

[@mr.carson2]

The entitlement attitude of the plaintiff is unbelievable!

[@LC05]

Defendants: "It isn't our fault that we were late!" Me: So is it the parking lot manager's fault then?

[@coleenlawrence9809]

It was getting super painful how long this plaintiff silliness mindset was being displayed... I was so happy when the gavel came down! :-)

[@markbrandon7359]

I wish this had been Judge Judy's case.

[@cflournoy1529]

“You’re an IDIOT!!!” In my best Judge Judy voice😂😂😂

[@ashleyschellinger6052]

It would have lasted all of 2mins if that if Judy took it lol she wouldn’t have even let him talk hahahah

[@jeniferburton5235]

This is the stupidest lawsuit ever!! They're suing for $37? Court costs are more than that. How ridiculous! I feel the judge's frustration in this case.

[@TeacherTonya13]

Plaintiff is purposely aggravating just to get everyone to give up & let him have his way

[@minhduong1484]

This is great case of "Never interrupt your enemy when they are making a mistake." The defendant didn't have to do much other than answer simple questions from the judge.

[@16MedicRN]

This is just... nevermind, I really don't have words 😂

[@charlesesowersjr1436]

I would hang up on this guy myself every time I wouldn't even let him get a word in nobody called back I block his number He's insane

[@porridgesilt]

Plaintiff left his brain on vacation in Puerto Rico. 🥴

[@jgs2277]

What an absolute jerk . And his sweet girlfriend is going to put up with his BS for years... Only to break up with him and return to the dating field all damaged and emotionally crippled. 😕

[@KPbouj]

Nah they seem to be cut from the same cloth. This is probably the couple who billed their RSVPs for not attending their wedding. 😅

[@prettyricky9147]

Wow 😂

[@buzzworthyblvd]

She's already damaged. Her attitude with the judge was rude

[@newsflash7609]

Definitely not sweet. She's clearly one of those people that turns her problem into other people's problems. The parking garage isn't responsible for their delay. She can take it up with the airline (good luck with that), but she can't seem to wrap her head around why it isn't the garage's problem.

[@themrs.1200]

I see two people who have the same attitude. No sweetness to be found.

[@MAMiiGOTkUSH]

Plaintiff is ridiculous

[@they-live1]

Plaintiffs are delusional and trying to scam the parking area, they have no leg to stand on. The document clearly states the date. 😂

[@KeelyB2318]

I wonder how the plaintiff has made it this far in life.

[@qveensirah8242]

Doug is hilarious 😭✋🏾

[@marcusredwine9918]

He said “I just don’t think you get it” 😂

[@SevenTailedWolf72]

The plaintiff had Disney Villain eyebrows. I love it! 😆

[@grantboi116]

What a head case he really needs to get a hobby. I guarantee this is not his first lawsuit

[@tjneverdefeated4394]

Whew the plaintiff really wasted the court’s time today!! But we are thoroughly entertained as a result. 🤷🏾‍♀️

[@irideaunicorn1620]

Ive been towed from my apartments and had to pay $232. He meeds to shut up and sit down

[@Ellie80681]

He broke the contract when he was late. Suing doesn’t always mean you are right. 😂

[@lashundavis156]

He is crazy😂😂😂his girlfriend is too

[@bhornannawindeedeigh5007]

🚨 Man-child alert: Plaintiff refuses to take responsibility for his actions. Tip of the Day #1 - Do Your Due Diligence Before You Sign On Any Dotted Line Tip of the Day #2 - Pay Your Parking Fees

[@michellet7013]

i deal with this customer type at least 2x per month. They don't read the contract and don't get how rentals work 😂

[@krystalericalewis]

Judge Milian - "Because you're crazy" 😂😂😂😂😂

[@msfranklin2650]

LAWD HELL THE PLAINTIFFS THERE'S ABSOLUTELY SOMETHING WRG W/ THEM BOTH TOTALLY IN THE WRG THEN THE ORDACITY TO SUE FOR DOUBLE HILARIOUS BUT SHE'S STANDING BY HER MAN EMBARRASSING. THE DEFENDANT WAS REALLY NICE & WAS WILLING TO GIVE HIM BK $37 SHOULD'VE TAKEN IT WHAT IDIOTS

[@0LadyV0]

Run lady. The man doubles down when he's wrong.

[@belindarsmith85]

Working in the retention department in customer service I see this all the time! An entitlement from an individual who is completely in the wrong but want you to bend over backwards and handle their request. It’s sad how many people actually think like this plaintiff and just don’t get it!

[@makiarobinson8903]

He wanted some TV time........he's CRAZY.

[@kristinkinzel9438]

The plaintiff needs to be put on some sort of watch list lmao what the hell

[@MrCharlesEldredge]

As bad as corporate customer service is these days this guy was certainly pig headed not to take the $40 offered.

[@lindaalvarez8855]

This case was a big joke! The Plaintiff didn't get it! Calling the Plaintiff "pig-headed", was perfect!

[@devinprasad3449]

Never seen the judge keep a litigant the entire case when they act like the plaintiff did.

[@ronhilscochrane3870]

Unbelievable ignorance is bliss…

[@AnikaBren]

Some one that stresses themselves this much over $37 is going to have a stroke at an early age.

[@ThejOH007]

“We were delayed in Puerto Rico” I’m sorry how is that an excuse?😭

[@sashabenoit1518]

Even IF he didn't mess up the dates and they were held up by their flight or whatever that made them late, that's NOT the car places problem!!! Their services were still used, so they get paid for ALL of it! I don't understand how he doesn't get it... Oof. 🤦‍♀️

[@joviamckibben6030]

This case pissed me off cos dude made a conscious choice to MISUNDERSTAND! He was late and was charged appropriately! He’s an idiot and his woman is too! End of story!

[@marilynwillett804]

Jan. 8 the day the king of Rock & Roll came into the world.

[@KSakamoto]

How have these people gotten to this point in life? Amazing. How do you make it to their ages thinking this is how life works

[@SmilingSynic]

Referring to the plaintiff as "pig-headed" is an insult to our pot bellied friends.

[@JinaChantil]

I would love to see him try and sue Jet Blue 😂😂😂

[@billsurley9264]

"because your crazy" .................................. lol EXACTLY!!

[@corporateraider77]

The entitlement is disgusting

[@johnsradios484]

This was a free trip to Florida !

[@christopherramon-reid2000]

Exactly

[@RacieRain]

I hope he didn't have to pay for parking.

[@balkb8297]

These plaintiffs feel very entitled and they feel by speaking loud will get them what they want.

[@rebeccahiggins2369]

WOW! How can anybody be that numb?

[@moparmadness0180]

Guy literally said his flight was for the 8th in the beginning. Just like he told the salesperson. Only this time for court he followed up with when his flight would arrive... Why would the business care when your flight takes off? Unnecessary information. These kind of people are the ones that take advantage of "the customer is always right". He hollers until people are annoyed enough to pay them to go away.

[@tiffanyfoxy212]

The customer is not always right.

[@lionelluva]

Not only are the Plaintiffs incompetent, they're rude. I would've dismissed this case the first time I explained.

[@1967davethewave]

OMG, the plaintiff thinks he's in the right if he just sticks to his guns. In truth he just looks ignorant. I feel sorry for him and his girlfriend.

[@barbaraness4507]

I have found that some people believe if they raise enough of a fuss people will give them their way. This man didn’t want justice, but instead he wanted a free ride!

[@stephh.2135]

WOW. Just wow.

[@ChelNoelle]

The defendant was super nice! He should have counter sued for time wasted.

[@janicester]

Lady...you're dating a professional victim. Good Luck with that one!

[@pammers5588]

Exactly

[@mclaybry]

In all my years of watching TPC I have never seen such a completely stupid Plaintiff as this guy. The kicker to the whole situation is that the Defendant offered to reimburse the Plaintiff before the Plaintiff got greedy and ignorant. Know the law, people.

[@christianakalaitzi1645]

This man is overly aggressive! I bet an argument with this guy takes DAYS! He DOES NOT LISTEN!!

[@Chris-ho6uf]

This is a case when there should be a penalty for filing a frivolous lawsuit.

[@JamesBrown-nr8or]

Hispanics be reallllyyyy hard headed 😂😂😂😂

[@clovermccombs8597]

Oh you don't even know the half of it... Makes a lot sense why my moms side is so damn stubborn.

[@sashabenoit1518]

Head strong... He's wound too tight! YIKES. 😬

[@1993rufus]

The nerve of the platiff!!! You can tell he planned this, he wants money back since he probably spent what he didn't have. 😂😂😂 Thank goodness JM saw right through him!!!!

[@vidamccurdy9764]

Full blown 100% narcissist,period.always has to be right,refusing to be accountable for his mistakes.guarantee he will continue this behavior till he passes awa y

[@ivonned32]

That lady dating the plaintiff should RUN as fast as she can in the opposite direction of that man!!!!😢

[@dermainedibbins9157]

Judge Judy would have called him an idiot and rightfully so 🤣🤣.

[@stratfordbaby]

Your damages are $80 if they are $40x2. Not $300. What a scammer.

[@Flightcontrol96]

Guys it makes perfect sense. His flight was delayed so the garage needs to let him park for free.

[@rashondadani]

This was a good laugh. I hope he watches himself and a lightbulb goes off

[@VampyAnji]

The Plaintiff is bonkers 😂

[@boomer891]

The plaintiff does not get it. So frustrating

[@donniee.2238]

I've seen some ridiculous things here. This one is way out there. That gf better be alert

[@G-PAT]

Somebody was sleeping during math class 🤪🤣😂😅🤣😂😅😆

[@taurus2600]

If standing by my man regardless was a person 😂

[@jelandusn]

When her accent comes out strong you know you’re wrong. 😂

[@justinmccullough3381]

She don’t never let no one finish talking. She always cut people off

[@kayangvue30]

I'm surprised jm didn't yell at the plaintiff. What a narcissistic jerk! His gf probably lets him get away with everything. Toxic at its best!