I need Water

The plaintiff says the defendant used to date her son, and she put up her own money so the defendant could get an iPhone. After the defendant and plaintiff got into a fight, the defendant stopped making payments on the loan, so the plaintiff cut off the phone. Afterward, the plaintiff claims the defendant slashed her tires in retaliation, so she’s suing for the cost of the phone and car repairs. The defendant denies that she slashed the tires, and she says the plaintiff was being petty when she cut off the phone.

[@Farrahganalii]

That girl did everything she is being accused of

[@traceyjackson4470]

Absolutely!!! All that over a child eating candy!!????🤔🤔🤔 ANY babysitter would have had the same reaction. Why is the baby eating candy in the morning ANYWAY!???

[@chuck9380]

She mad because the plaintiff called her out of her bs

[@rockobill7637]

then after all that, made another veiled threat to the woman as she was talking to Doug...she has some heavy duty problems

[@catherineeckstein2705]

Absophuckinglutely she did!

[@jlywi7171]

Facts

[@missy67]

The defendant admits she has a temper, her mother admits her daughter has always been like that and the mother says to Doug in the hallway that the plaintiff is no good? She gave your daughter a phone when she needed it and she's watching your grandchildren! The nerve of some people!

[@sandylane5498]

Amen!!!

[@loveDebbieDeb]

Say it louder for the people in the back!!….Agreed!

[@Sook995]

She had her hood friends slash those 🛞🛞🛞

[@tanyawhaley1946]

I was thinking the same thing

[@ambersouthern282]

​@@sandylane5498 🎉

[@SmilingSynic]

The clear winner in this case is the plaintiff's son, who broke up with the mentally unstable and dangerous defendant.

[@Shellygrrl2573]

I absolutely agree. You can see the devil peering through her evil eyes everytime she looks at the plaintiff. What a nut job😬

[@johnmdaniels27]

Fully agree

[@clwilson7318]

...and didnt have a child with her

[@jeremySJThompson]

Wow!!!! Facts! And thankfully he didn't have kids with her ...

[@wvrjl]

That women should not have children.

[@leisurefarm]

every time she narrows her eyes, evil seeps out

[@butterflyroho6470]

😂

[@christopherramon-reid2000]

👍👍👍

[@lenc3970]

She who? There’s multiple women

[@mememefirst]

@@lenc3970 obviously the defendant she was the only one doing it. 🙄

[@brittanyblanco7982]

😩😩😩😩

[@MGarcia_o.o]

In the hallway...she said she would've done something worse than slashing her tires Five mins before...she is fake crying saying that she would NEVER do anything like slashing tires Hello crazy 👋👋

[@Shellygrrl2573]

Crazy and evil...the plaintiff shouldn't have even helped her. I can bet a million dollars that the son told his mom not to deal with that nut job. Why put yourself in that position when your son left her?

[@Starnote16]

Then the mom defends her behavior. Wtf!!

[@skymitchells3299]

😅😅😅

[@humaneleaguelancPA]

Crying but no tears...

[@ginatse2786]

Her mom then said she now learned her lesson ????? Lol what lesson ?? Shes crazy.

[@cowgirlbebop14]

The defendant's mom is a piece of work. Stop making excuses for your daughter's nasty attitude. "She's just always been like that and Cookie knows that" is so lame.

[@kia4334]

I think the mom is afraid of the daughter. That’s why she’s saying that. I very sure she causes a lot of problems at home.

[@dearboss9136]

id like to know why she cant watch her own grandkids?

[@Nevaeh1]

The defendant definitely slashed those tires or had someone do it.

[@mrshappilymarried1]

Absolutely with those fake tears...

[@kalaniturner9404]

@@mrshappilymarried1 😊😊

[@Possumpat84]

Exactly and that mother helped the daughter 💯 %!! Mother only dislikes the plaintiff because she was a better role model to her daughter than she ever was.

[@Selfemployedmildautisticperfor]

and hmm to many facial peircings or not ??

[@Lenape_Lady]

@@Selfemployedmildautisticperfor Why do the face piercings matter??

[@inukoko2012]

The plaintiff seems like a good person and what she said at the end about the defendant & her mom spoke volume.

[@johnmdaniels27]

Definitely

[@marthapozo4881]

It was quite profound for sure!

[@catherineeckstein2705]

@jamessonatore2320bingo

[@jeremySJThompson]

The end really spoke volumes

[@jeremySJThompson]

@James Sonatore Facts!!!!!!

[@sisipruitt]

And did you hear her jump to say that it didn’t happen on the day the judge said? That’s a nervous guilty conscience. What a gem she is.

[@Possumpat84]

Yep, JM caught that too. Defendant tried to play off her slip but that recording really doomed her defense. Then dummy makes a even worse threat to Doug on camera. She’s a foolish woman.

[@michelehemlokhexwhite4310]

​@@Possumpat84 you could see the mum just about facepalm when she said that to Doug 😂

[@dillionoshea7535]

Even more so at the beginning she said “she has no proof”. An innocent person says “I didn’t do it” not “she has no proof”

[@Alivirgo8.24]

Remind me of that Judge Judy episode with dumb & dumber "there was no earpiece in it ma'am...." 😂😂

[@cbro2807]

Haha..."champagne"? Her car is silver and her mom's car is red. Not a coincidence.

[@mrshappilymarried1]

The mom has a lot of nerves but wasn't babysitting her own grandkids. The apple doesn't fall far from the tree...

[@MyGoodenessGracious]

Exactly

[@TRILLTALKTV]

the lady said the mom stop dealing with her

[@claypartridge7553]

Defendant “it wasn’t the next day, hehehe” admittance

[@glenngatlin8475]

She's taking good care of your child!!! Respect this woman.

[@cai1593]

@James Sonatore you keep going under every comment making statements like this but you’re placing all the blame on her. How is it her fault the father won’t take care of his child??? She’s doing what she can after not having help from him and you’re blaming her lol. Men are so fing stupid😂

[@justterri443]

How is she going to say the lady isn’t any good but she was good enough to watch your grandkids. The apple doesn’t fall too far from the tree.

[@Shellygrrl2573]

She's saying because she's just as trifling and evil as her daughter. She didn't watch her grandkids, she didn't get her a phone, she didn't do ANYTHING for her own daughter. Yet has the NERVE to talk about the plaintiff. She and her daughter are both scum.

[@RKeith]

"If I was going to do anything it would be way more than slashing tires".....on National TV.....smh......

[@spacecase8791]

Sheesh, the attitude on the defendant! She has some dang nerve! She seems mean AF.

[@nikkirene00]

That girl is going to end up killing someone someday. Yikes.

[@marquishoward3529]

Or god forbid, somebody gonna kill her smh

[@RissaDaBrat]

Or someone is gonna end up getting her fake tuff ass first!

[@StarMarcie]

She did it, LOL!

[@insertwittynamehere_]

Sure did lol!

[@mizzkat17]

The mom said she told her the lady was no good??? Tf? She looked out for your daughter constantly with no obligation to do so

[@d.b.2079]

Exactly!

[@keeper6458]

Exactly!

[@colleenknapp8626]

Defendant's mom just as bad as Defendant. 😮

[@Shellygrrl2573]

​@@colleenknapp8626 right! Why isn't SHE watching her grandchild? Whys isn't SHE getting her crazy daughter a phone?With the defendants fake tears. She's rotten inside and out. What an ingrate..smh..

[@Possumpat84]

The mom only dislikes the plaintiff because she knows she was a better role model than she ever was.

[@Bebe-og3bc]

I feel bad for those kids! Having a sociable unacceptable mother and grandmother!

[@Ms_O]

apple doesn't fall far from the tree

[@catherineeckstein2705]

And that’s how the trend continues….

[@jeremySJThompson]

@@catherineeckstein2705 vicious cycle

[@catherineeckstein2705]

@@jeremySJThompson truth

[@stevo9421]

We will see a familiar face one day when the defendant is on some prison show.

[@tiffanychristian1978]

Her mother is the problem too. scared of her own daughter.

[@RissaDaBrat]

Exactly

[@dataodokpa5431]

The mom of the defendant tells me everything of how that defendant was raised

[@angieelewis6619]

Lol she was no good but was steady watching YOUR GRANDSON?! That's insane 😅

[@ButtonsCasey]

She was getting paid to do it, so don't act like that makes her a Saint.

[@lukerinderknecht2982]

​@@ButtonsCasey so? That makes it even worse - if they really thought she was no good why pay her and not find someone else they can hire for the job?

[@PositivitySpeaks101]

@@lukerinderknecht2982 exactly

[@user-Tina8462]

​@@ButtonsCasey it makes her better than her own mom. Because the mom wasn't watching her kids. Her mom should have been watching the kids for free to make it easier for her daughter. My mom didn't want anyone else to watch my children. She also watched them for free if I was working.

[@paulag8843]

I don’t understand a person disrespecting the person caring for your kids. The defendant has an evil spirit 🙏🏽

[@editorshaaan]

The mum saying that lady was no good - she did a lot more for that girl than her own mum. Typical!

[@AmScram92]

She smirked when the slashing was discussed and when Milian read the police report.

[@sushimitten]

Yeah she does seem to have a bit of a temper. I believe she would slash someone’s tires in anger. It’s sad that their friendship ended though, the plaintiff seemed like a nice lady.

[@rafaeltorres2460]

They are not kids! She's 26 years old

[@sandylane5498]

The mother and daughter deserve each other.

[@shawnda8317]

that defendant needs her @zz BEAT! All that disrespect to someone who was there for you when your own parent wouldn't watch your kids - get your ENTIRE LIFE!!

[@colleenknapp8626]

❤ Thank you! Defendant is an ingrate.

[@sandylane5498]

Gurl!!! I couldn't have said it better!

[@darylroddy112]

As soon as she walked into the courtroom, I knew the defendant was guilty of everything

[@preciousjacob6108]

Wow… you’re the definition of guilty before proven innocent. The mentality that a person is going to steal once they walk into your store…. Just being sarcastic

[@Mario-ur8ti]

Same here. The narrowed beautiful eyes say it all.

[@serenaprescott681]

Oooh something about the defendant feels like the devil resides in her. Her eyes spoke volumes.

[@Shellygrrl2573]

I said the same thing! Glad the plaintiffs son left her crazy butt. She gives Jodi Arias vibes😬

[@lcam9241]

I think she just really needed glasses y'all. But she was definitely wrong for treating the woman watching her child that way.

[@TopherGrant]

The devil is fictional.

[@RissaDaBrat]

​@@TopherGrantDon't start that shit please! 🙄

[@MyGoodenessGracious]

Oh she crazy as hell😳

[@jimmiepasson2002]

“I would of done way more than slash her tires.”, she didn’t learn a thing. She’s 26 with kids acting like this….

[@rosej5029]

I'm sorry but plaintiff is foolish to let anybody let alone your son's ex girlfriend be on her phone plan. She added unnecessary trouble to her life.

[@lcam9241]

Absolutely

[@delenareed9731]

I was thinking the same thing 🤔

[@livinginamerica]

Everybody plays a fool sometimes. I hope the viewers on here have learned a lesson. I certainly have.

[@bridgetteknox8319]

I believe she is disrespectful to her own mother. Why wasn't her mother baby-sitting? She needs anger management

[@augustmoon9973]

That's ridiculous to get so mad over words. Even if the plaintiff was being disrespectful, it was true. Say sorry and be done with it. Or better yet, walk your child into the house, grab a towel, head straight to a sink, and clean your child off quickly before leaving for work. 😢

[@tamaradula1331]

People are insane. When someone is good to you , You’re to be even better to them . Unbelievable

[@LelelapoeteSpeaks]

It's beyond clear that the defendant damaged her tires; watching her mom vouch for her temper actually hurt her defense even more!

[@preciousjacob6108]

Yeah her mom partially helped her win her case…

[@artistjoh]

That woman doesn't realize that recorded words matter. The threat followed by slashed tires got her convicted whether she did it or not. Then in the hall she brazenly said she would do way more than just slash tires. Sounded like a threat to me, and if the plaintiff has any kind of problem, house fire, assault, even murder, the police will look at this and mark her as suspect #1. Words can have consequences.

[@Catlover1974]

That’s true. People can spew out threatening words, even when they don’t mean it. But they don’t stop to think that if something were to actually happen, and God forbid something happen TO the person they threatened, they would be a suspect!

[@tnicoletnicole]

The mother proves exactly why the defendant is the way that she is. Calling that plaintiff no good, when she actually took care of her grandchildren regularly, when she wouldn’t and she’s the actual grandmother??? A JOKE!!!

[@MsCassie272]

Hard to find a good sitter for your kids... who's keeping them now? The defendant is a fool!

[@maxxxcee602]

That lady was no good, says the grand mother, who clearly wasn't providing the required child care support her daughter needed. As they say the apple doesn't fall far from the tree. Threatening someone who is caring for your child, is an indication she lacks control.

[@khandiekane5509]

She definitely slash those tires

[@JAYSTXRR]

why is the defendant vibe so sinister ? 😳

[@aprilshines9521]

The defendant's eyes says it all what it really is. Convenience when needed.

[@0207khenry]

That girl full of pain.

[@probochronicles3991]

"I should've really done it then" brilliant comment....

[@chuck9380]

Mom enables the daughters behavior and the daughter should get her children’s father to watch them. She is also mad the plaintiff called her out on her child neglect.

[@lukerinderknecht2982]

I honestly worry about the safety of the defendant's kids if she can't control her temper as she seems to freely admit.

[@amira2736]

first she laughs about her car not being silver and when pressed mentions the champagne colour last, although its the cars main color. very telling

[@sunnyscott4876]

It ain't gonna end here....... More threats.

[@SmilingSynic]

If the defendant didn't slash the tires, how would she know when they were slashed?

[@charlottemarshall4451]

The planttiff said tires were slashed 2 days after argument

[@Trich-nf2zf]

@@charlottemarshall4451 but the girl could have done it the night after (1 day) but plaintiff seen it that morning 🤔🤔

[@SRFAA]

Nah, that doesn't work since she used what the plaintiff had already said earlier in the case. It's likely that she did it, but that angle doesn't work. The judge just wanted to try and get her to slip up and say when she did it.

[@buffalowill2789]

the mother saying "that lady was no good and i told her" LMFAO! that women helped your daughter out big time. but hey,now you get to watch your grand kids and pay for her phone

[@shellwilliams6306]

Respect doesn't come without being EARNED. This is the culture of our youth 😥

[@Ahhmisohornie]

Oh right, like stupid boomers aren’t disrespectful af. Get real.

[@moniqueengleman873]

I completely agree 💯 These kids have Zero respect for anyone. It drives me nuts

[@latashamichelle6657]

Very Well Said!

[@SwordHMX]

...so you disrespect everyone until they earn respect? You would earn exactly nobody's if you actually lived that way.

[@mariannecarpenter9790]

The plaintiff really is a nice human being. She has a soothing voice.

[@briasworld8]

She got that Beak of a Nose from her Momma.

[@ladye626]

Why didn’t her mom watch her kids, she’s clearly active in her life.

[@flawlessfabdiva]

She gave the baby candy that morning on the way to a sitter??

[@p1n3apple21]

Boi that smile is devious!

[@dessean1]

"The fruit does not fall far from the tree" & this mother & daughter defendant combination showed exactly that. The mother has no more honor or integrity than her daughter & this criminal duo were both responsible for slashing the plaintiff's tires without a doubt. Even in the hall when speaking to Doug the mother still couldn't behave civilly toward the plaintiff & just had to get that last plug at the in. The mother had an opportunity to show on national tv that she was a decent person/mother/human being & even remorseful toward the plaintiff for what she & her daughter had done but instead, she chose to take the "low road" & confirm to the world that she & her daughter were evil, conniving, sinister & absolutely untrustworthy individuals which was exactly what the rest of us already figured out.

[@Blueeyedjenn14]

That 26 year old is EVIL AND DANGEROUS. What she said in the post verdict interview was chilling combined with that turn around eye look at the old fella asking the follow up questions. Her mom should sleep with one eye open, heck anyone around her should.

[@TopherGrant]

That's hot asf! Crazy chicks that might stab me are my weakness! Strong women are sexy

[@bigmarv3937]

She’s a straight killer that listens to the voices in her head

[@brooklynmobley5449]

The defendant looks evil AF n the fact her mama says she's always been violent n short tempered says a lot. The plaintiff didn't say anything bad about them in the end even when the defendants had so much negative to say about her. It's a blessing the son got away from her lil crazy tail before something bad/violent really happened in the relationship

[@diva70smusic]

Ole girl walked into court looking guilty as h e l l. Then she was mean mugging the plaintiff. What an ungrateful, soulless woman.

[@sleepywillowsounds8635]

Hugs to the plaintiff, you can tell she was hurt

[@angelagray736]

"She can't hold her tongue for nothing "..she hasn't ran upon the right one yet

[@marquishoward3529]

She will eventually smh

[@ebonyadams8384]

Something is way off about the defendant . 😫 she seem crazy as heck

[@tawandapatterson5845]

The defendants mother is the reason her daughter thinks it’s ok to behave like that!!! Stating her daughter should have stayed away from the plaintiff after all she’s done. No one owes the defendant anything with her nasty demeanor!

[@nicholeknight1893]

The defendants mother is a hot mess

[@brittneyrobinson2761]

Mom was jealous of the relationship the plaintiff had with her daughter. She definitely aided in the destruction of the plaintiff's property. That was her chance to bond/support her daughter.

[@KPbouj]

I would never disrespect Mi Comadre or other older moms who were there for us when our kids were younger! If we needed to “disagree to disagree” we would and keep it moving along to strengthen our friendship and business relationship.

[@shayna2562]

that’s crazy the defendant basically admitted to slashing the tires

[@latashamichelle6657]

Saw that too. Her comment and facial expressions revealed her actions.

[@jillcabler2186]

The defendant know damn well that she cut those tires, period Some people you just can't help especially ungrateful and disrespectful ones A dog will bite the hand that feeds it She should have gotten locked up She is dangerously out of control SMH

[@justterri443]

She knows that she slash those tires because she didn’t even have anything to say after the judgment. If you really didn’t do it then you would’ve been like judge I really didn’t do it but she didn’t do any of that because she knows she’s guilty. Girl Bye 👋

[@buffalowill2789]

the stare and squint in her eyes is pure evil. that girl has problems. good thing her son got outa there when he did

[@Amy-ej2px]

She did it. In tears, she tells the judge that she's sooo hurt that the plaintiff would accuse her of slashing tires and that she'd NEVER slash tires. In the hallway, she says that if she was going to do something, it would have been more than slash tires. She's a psychopath. All of this bc she questioned why your child was sticky and had on the same clothes from the previous day and stopped watching your kid after you threatened her??

[@nicoleh.6352]

Wow, the plaintiff was there for her when it seems her own mother wasn't.. the mother in fact raised her that way, then had a nerve, to say the plaintiff knows how her mouth is... smh...a disrespectful mess, she's going to miss that extra help..

[@mrsbook5206]

That girl is evil af!! The plaintiff should be thankful that she is out of her life!!

[@PHOENIX1699]

Defendant LOOKS evil That's a kid that never got a slap while she was growing up. That's gonna get her hurt one day.

[@LowellBDennyIII]

"I should have really did it." - That commend says a lot

[@sheap3871]

Look at the defendant's mannerisms, she did it. That little spill she said at the end " I would have done way worst than slashing tires"! SMDH she did it and she needs to pay! Terrible attitude!

[@jeslyndonnell9138]

The defendant gives me evil vibes especially with the devilish eyes and grin.

[@fwb1012]

Some Caribbean peeps always thinking someone disrespecting them🙄 You are on the lady’s phone plan for heaven sakes!!!

[@ihateutube1143]

Single mommy with Chest tattoos spells GALAXY SIZE RED FLAGS!!!

[@jnicole3926]

The plaintiff, in my opinion, is a good person to surround yourself with. Reminds me of my best friend/ mentor. 20 year age difference, best advise and lessons come from her.

[@iris-nx1wt]

She must've brought that baby over filthy. If it was one little sucker she would've said at the door "oh he just made a mess I'm sorry", but she didn't, and he had on the same clothes from the day before. Maybe she had a ruff night, but she could've briefly explained to her why the baby was messy before she left him. Most folks don't go for that mess when it comes to helpless babies and kids. You changed your clothes, and you need to change theirs too.

[@DumpyDumplin]

The defendant did it for sure 😂 in the courtroom she starts crying saying “I can’t believe she thinks I slashed her tires that hurts me!” Then at the end she says “I would’ve done way more than slash her tires if it was me” 😂😂😂 nice job

[@sugarshamrock]

No good deed goes unpunished...don't put others on your phone bill for your sons girlfriend it never ends well. For someone who is babysitting for a working single mother she is ungrateful and entitled. She totally slashed the tires and can be pety.

[@daymonnin]

What a horrible vicious girl. Even at the end she’s making threats.

[@mememefirst]

That lady was better than the defendants mom and the mom had the nerve to disrespect her talking about she’s no good. Yet she provided childcare for your grandchild and a phone for your disrespectful daughter.

[@sarahrean7174]

Nooo the lady disrespect her own son

[@AVBNOW23]

Defendant: Does she realize what she’s saying on national TV???

[@fenrichvega6166]

That defendant knows she had someone slash those tires. And her mom defending her and making excuses for her about how she always been outspoken and catch attitudes and shit,those 2 are a piece of work

[@suzanneromeo390]

That girl is so ungrateful. Taking the woman's kindness for weakness.

[@WomanEvolving]

She did it! Point! Blank! Period! Them tears is a sign of guilt that she screwed up a relationship b/c of her actions. Hopefully, she’s grown up since this aired 🤷🏽‍♀️

[@user-hs1zr6mc5d]

It's clear to see why nobody helps the defendant. It's also clear to see why she is the way she is because she was raised to think she does no wrong.

[@ingerhall3265]

The defendant looked demented in the hallway. Creepy!

[@Lovely-sq8wr]

Those evil eyes 👀 Her energy spoke volumes and she told on herself about the tires

[@bongoikno4994]

These young people really don't know their place at all elders can't chastise you if needed damn I'm 42 and still humble to my elders smh yo this is the result of not beating these people born late 90s and up

[@keeper6458]

Agreed!! Same for me!! I'm 45

[@h.Freeman]

Nah... A young a hole will oneday be an old a hole. Respect is earned not a right. And I'm in my 40s. But I think she did what she is accused of

[@highlander666]

It was immediately obvious that all of the accusations against the defendant were true when she walked in; she just looks conniving 😅

[@Possumpat84]

Thought the same thing. Just her essence comes off confrontational.