Phantom Comparison - PONR Unmasking Part 2

[@PrismsofGlass]

0:00 - Title screen 0:05 - David Shannon and Gina Beck 0:29 - Earl Carpenter and Olivia Brereton 0:54 - Earl Carpenter and Katie Hall 1:18 - Marcus Lovett and Sofia Escobar 1:44 - Geronimo Rauch and Harriet Jones 2:10 - Geronimo Rauch and Lisa-Anne Wood 2:32 - Ben Lewis and Amy Manford 2:58 - David Thaxton and Kelly Mathieson 3:25 - Tim Howar and Amy Manford 3:42 - Josh Piterman and Kelly Mathieson 4:10 - Hugh Panaro and Sarah Bakker 4:36 - Paul A. Schaefer and Mary Michael Patterson 5:02 - Norm Lewis and Sierra Boggess 5:32 - Laird Mackintosh and Kaley Ann Voorhees 6:02 - Rachel Eskenazi Gold 6:23 - Ben Crawford and Ali Ewoldt 6:53 - Ben Crawford and Eryn LeCroy 7:15 - Anthony Crivello and Kristi Holden 7:54 - Tim Martin Gleason and Kelly Jeanne Grant 8:24 - Cooper Grodin and Julia Udine 8:48 - Cooper Grodin and Grace Morgan 9:15 - Chris Mann and Katie Travis 9:40 - Derrick Davis and Kaitlyn Davis 10:06 - Quentin Oliver Lee and Eva Tavares 10:28 - Derrick Davis and Jenna Burns 10:51 - Mikael Samuelson and Inger Olsson Moberg 11:17 - Peter Joback and Emmi Christensson 11:43 - Tomas Ambt Kofod and Sibylle Glosted 12:11 - Saulo Vasconcelos and Irasema Terrazas 12:39 - Saulo Vasconcelos and Kiara Sasso 13:03 - Fred Silveira and Lina Mendes 13:33 - Thiago Arancam and Darua Goes 14:00 - Thiago Arancam and Giulia Nadruz 14:28 - Simon Pryce and Ana Marina 14:54 - Alexander Lewis and Ana Marina 15:19 - Brad Little and Claire Lyon 15:47 - Brad Little and Sara Sarres 16:14 - Jonathan Roxmouth and Meghan Picerno 16:42 - Christian Muller and Lisa Antoni 17:12 - David Arnsperger and Lauri Brons 17:41 - Mathias Edenborn and Daniella Braun 18:10 - Rob Pitcher and Valerie Link 18:38 - Brent Barrett and Elizabeth Welch 19:02 - Dmitri Ermak and Tamara Kotova 19:25 - Ivan Ozhogin and Mercedesz Csampai 19:50 - Dmitri Ermak and Maria Ivleva 20:12 - Andrey Shkoldychenko and Elena Bahtiyarova 20:33 - Adrian Nour and Irina Baiant 21:26 - Marian Vojtko and Michaela Gemrotova 22:07 - Radim Schwab and Monika Sommerova 22:52 - Damian Aleksander and Paulina Janczak 23:29 - Ben Forster and Amy Manford

[@scotthamp384]

Two questions. One: why did you not name the Phantom with Rachel Gold? And two: why can you barely hear the audio of that video?

[@PrismsofGlass]

@@scotthamp384 The answer to both is because the Phantom is James Barbour.

[@gypsysmiles]

@@PrismsofGlassThank you for that.

[@Canyoufindthepresidents]

@@PrismsofGlass wait what?

[@Canyoufindthepresidents]

@@PrismsofGlass OH I SEE NOW WHY UGHHHHH

[@FruitPunch603]

Bookmarks for later! (I hope you don't mind, Prism) 2:58 - Love how Thaxton smooths the ring onto her finger instead of shoving it on. Such a delicate Phantom! Also. The sound of guttural shock hit me straight in the chest. He clearly hadn't expected his honest Christine to unmask him in front of all those people (especially given his adverse reaction the first time she did it). (Mostly bookmarking this for his sustained notes and rich tone). 4:10 - He just reminds me so much of Crawford, and-asdfghjkl. The way he sinks humbly to his knees. 😭 There's just something so soft and tender in this rendition, and it's *ripe* with humility. 5:05 - I had to. Norm’s voice is butter melting into brown sugar. 6:24 - Love a Phantom who moves his hands. Moreover, the *panic* as he shouts ‘No!’ and looks around-chef kiss. (Resonant voice. Very nice. Very good.) 7:21 - The vocal growl. The POWER. (”Bring down the chandelier!” Reminds me of that Dave Chapelle meme where he throws the water as a diversion before running off). 8:00 - I just think he’s neat. Voice pretty. 8:31 - hnng. The humility. I know it's customary for a groom to get on his knee but in your heart of hearts you know Erik was bowing before her. Love a submissive Phantom, especially given how canonically proud Erik is. 12:46 - This Phantom definitely has his tail between his legs. It's cute that he can't even look at her; he is *absolutely* begging her to carry him around in her pocket. 13:47 - Nice voice. Phantoms with warmer ranges really command my attention. 14:36 - Nice voice x2. Unassuming and pup-like. 10/10 would smooch. 15:32 - The hands. And the fact that he tried to grab her waist-! 16:15 - Everything d*mnit! Everything! ❤💐 (He has the Phantom ‘presence’ I was looking for.) 18:40 - Again, Phantom presence. (This one stirred something maternal in me and I don't know why). 19:29 - Yes. He’s tangibly wet and begging. Wet puppy Erik. Please let him in it's cold outside. 21:12 - Congratulations to Christine for not ripping off Phantom’s mask (I have no idea why she does that). 21:49 - I’d keep him as a puppy. I’d adopt him.

[@charlenekravec1461]

Interesting how many Christine's follow the stage direction of moving in to kiss the Phantom as a ruse to unmask him.

[@michellekeeling3392]

Michael Crawford and Ben Lewis are just the most heart breaking in this segment such nuances of pleading and emotion before Christine breaks their hearts. 👏👏👏👏

[@madamemaximoff9838]

23:30 Ben’s voice ❤️

[@darthneon0701]

Fun fact: Earl is also recognized for playing Javert in various productions of "Les Misérables."

[@shbo2510]

Fun fact: Water is wet

[@darthneon0701]

@@shbo2510 Are you referring to Javert's Suicide?

[@shbo2510]

@@darthneon0701 No, I am referring to the fact 99% of those watching this video know exactly who Earl Carpenter is

[@ldpadventures833]

@@shbo2510 hey that was rude

[@alysonk5853]

If you’re still doing these I’d like to request a comparison of Old Fool (he makes me laugh) but more so the part where the phantom interrupts Carlotta’s performance and makes her croak

[@xxxStellarEVExxx]

YES

[@romulusroyal6660]

0:30 no one noticed Earl wig falling off

[@alanshore17]

For a baritone, Brad hits the high notes very nicely

[@dantemaritato]

Is there a full recording of 7:18

[@LauraBwayMorris]

If you can (you don’t have to), could you please do an updated “You try my patience” comparison?

[@matthewsworld3127]

What’s With The Fire On 17:04?

[@LauraBwayMorris]

I believe that’s Piangi’s body?

[@taelenfl27_]

Wowowo, do you have more clips of this? 16:55 🤔 Christian Muller y Antoni, Austria?

[@ldpadventures833]

The resoin why they dont have all the costumes and the mask a the makeup is because its a annyversry concert so its a little bit different 16:55

[@ldpadventures833]

Oh and why is Chrisene holding a notebook lol 16:55

[@taelenfl27_]

@@ldpadventures833 oh, I understand

[@ldpadventures833]

@@taelenfl27_ yea it was hard for me to understand too

[@broadwaymike92]

Shout out to all the Christines who scream during the unmasking!!

[@taelenfl27_]

Damn, Adrian and Irina ! :0 I love the differences hehe

[@xxxStellarEVExxx]

IKR

[@lopsideddog7925]

Does anyone know if there's a "you deceived me I gave my mind blindly" comparison video?

[@PrismsofGlass]

Yeah, I made one, combining it with the Phantom's "You try my patience" line: kzbin.info/www/bejne/qIGaioR_qJ18nrc

[@lopsideddog7925]

@@PrismsofGlass ahhh thank you so much!

[@natekrieger5741]

thx for posting!!

[@TronaldTheWizard]

21:14 boy did they fuck that up

[@LauraBwayMorris]

No they unmask him during the kiss in the final lair in that production

[@taelenfl27_]

8:24-10:50 haha, literally Christine runs to the Phantom's lair before than run to Raoul 😅😂🤔

[@sourfrog21]

I thought that maybe she was trying to run offstage and then the phantom caught her but that could also be a possibility

[@1SpicyMeataball]

Haha. The new blocking was so bad. I can almost hear the Benny Hill theme.

[@LauraBwayMorris]

I like the UK tour unmasking blocking better

[@dd-zx6sd]

I wonder which Phantom and Christines do you think have the most chemistry?

[@sourfrog21]

I feel like most people would say Ramin Karimloo and Sierra Boggess

[@taelenfl27_]

7:33 wtf? :0 really I don't know how he is that🤔😅

[@alanshore17]

I do feel like Tim Martin Gleason doesn’t get enough credit for his Phantom, which was excellent!

[@cornnuts9457]

I don't quite understand what happened in the last one?

[@taelenfl27_]

In the last and one before, I don't understand too, so, the Phantom it's not unmasking in both....so, the piangi's death in the same stage 🤔, or i don't know

[@scotthamp384]

Some productions were jokes, like the Polish and Greek ones

[@LauraBwayMorris]

@@taelenfl27_ actually, at 24:00, I just noticed, he actually takes his mask off to scare people and then drops it purposely before taking Christine away

[@dantemaritato]

Ben Crawford has gotten so much better then when he started

[@alanshore17]

That’s very common, but i def agree that Ben’s Erik has evolved very nicely. I will say however that i’ve never seen a Phantom who spits as much as him the entire performance…poor Christine

[@stone1488]

did earl at 0:36 have a wig malfunction? to me it looks as if the ig was already pulled off, could it have been from Olivia pulling too hard when unveiling him?

[@LauraBwayMorris]

Yes

[@jackvanpelt9812]

Can you do a comparison of “Abandon thought” And “Our passion play”

[@jillianvicic3282]

I like brightman and Crawford better they are always sound so good and pure and sweet and perfect and professional and loving and great profession and loving pair couple for years They really good and sounded great too but amazing how I can love tonight

[@camilaalcalafarfan8820]

2:10 so intense :0

[@ldpadventures833]

Glass Prisim Can you pls upload all of the brazil PONR PLSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS

[@sameaston9587]

Time for lounge pants!

[@jillianvicic3282]

Ben foster sounded like Gerald butler from original Phantom from the movie 2008 and I Need him back at my movie again please

[@LauraBwayMorris]

The movie came out in 2004

[@evanroberts5045]

I always thought that unmasking him in public was kind of mean, he was already very self conscious about his appearance and he was always hurt by how people reacted to his real face.

[@boglitt6918]

Hell yes ❤️❤️

[@burgerking2538]

why there is not the james babour with julia udine?

[@PrismsofGlass]

Because it's in Part 1.

[@burgerking2538]

@@PrismsofGlass but why i can not find

[@PrismsofGlass]

@@burgerking2538 If he's in Part 1, then it's the video of Rachel Eskenazi-Gold, as Julia Udine is already in a video from the tour.

[@burgerking2538]

@@PrismsofGlass I said both of them in a clip

[@PrismsofGlass]

@@burgerking2538 I try not to repeat casts as much as I can. If James Barbour is in a clip with Rachel Eskenazi-Gold and Julia Udine is in a clip with Cooper Grodin, then there's no need for a clip of both of them together.

[@natekrieger5741]

Was Meghan Picerno on Broadway as well at some point?!

[@PrismsofGlass]

She's part of the current Broadway cast right now.

[@natekrieger5741]

@@PrismsofGlass Thx!!

[@taelenfl27_]

3:33 Tomas sounds how a Spanish :3

[@LauraBwayMorris]

That’s Tim Howar

[@jillianvicic3282]

I think in Greece version of Ben and Amy are always amazing together for my take to Ben sounds like Gerard indulge Amy as Christine actually like Emmy to not on the table on the ground and the floor is alot better than the table for me the two newlyweds are always doing it so good and so perfect together

[@TheMrfree1985]

who was the phantom with rachel eskenazi gold

[@PrismsofGlass]

James Barbour. If there's no name next to the Christine, it's always James Barbour.

[@finleyforevermore]

10:17

[@mariejusto423]

❤️

[@jillianvicic3282]

My favorite phantom and Christine is Michael and Sarah brightman and Gerard and emmy and Nick gardener and Jillian Reubens and eliji and kyoko and Chirs colfer and Jillian Reubens and Sean astin and Jillian Reubens norm Lewis and sierra boggese and Paul Reubens and Jillian Reubens they are my favorites people who are from the musical

[@abigailmassey2518]

Where was Gerard Butler and Emmy Rossum?

[@PrismsofGlass]

This is a comparison of the stage version, not the movies. Also, using movie clips is most likely to get my video copyright struck and blocked.

[@gloriabarberi1292]

I hate that thing of putting the benches on the table, it makes no sense at all

[@robertnail8307]

brave

[@Alison101213]

tim howar sounds like he was inspired by colm wilkinson!

[@roxanagonzalez5314]

Min 2: 00 Cristine tenía más espacio....para huir