Phoenixes vs Turtles vs Goats vs Aurochs | Creature Tribal Commander with

[@CardmarketMagic]

Find all four decklists here: bit.ly/3Zml99N

[@kamikirbits7708]

My friend is really disappointed with the goat deck since you didn't play any actual goat creatures. Like if you don't want to play all the meh ones at least play pathbreaker Ibex

[@CardmarketMagic]

@Kami Kirbits Remy said in the beginning of the video that he's here to make goat tokens. Your friend seems to have misunderstood Remy's objective :)

[@kamikirbits7708]

@@CardmarketMagic That reasoning is horrible. To get a tribe and then play 0 creatures from that tribe is lame. It's not a goat deck rather it's a fog token deck that just happens to make goats. The others all played creatures from their tribe even if they were bad

[@MrSaverio97]

@@kamikirbits7708 look out it's the tribal deck police

[@kamikirbits7708]

@@MrSaverio97 You're goddamn right we are

[@taken_over3416]

It wouldn’t be a card market commander video without Thoralf getting out to an early lead only to be immediately 3v1d

[@vajrayana9405]

No joke, that sol ring is glued to his hand fr

[@Kiyen9001]

To be fair, Remy never actually did anything to Thoralf, so it was more of a 2v1v1.

[@marcuswillbrandt5901]

Well, he was the only one playing a real deck

[@Kokuswolf]

@@Kiyen9001 It was actual 2v1 and some goats graze around, which became suddenly strong. This is what happens when they are overfed.

[@LordSathar]

It's almost like he flamed out.

[@Pikana]

I hope there will be more of these Randomly Selected Creature Tribal videos. It was hilarious watching everyone try to make them work.

[@daem0nfaust]

I second this!

[@neoneanderthal2658]

My vote goes there too. Cardmarket don't do enough commander.

[@Sami_Ljimari]

too bad it was not really random as they were just playing pre-made mp4 videos for their "random rolls" on the tribes XD

[@minininja2792]

​@@daem0nfaust i third this

[@logancalapp2426]

@@minininja2792 i fourth this

[@matthewpopow6647]

Thoralf: what are the cards in your hand even doing!? Remy: thats a great question... Moving on...

[@dylanumino1705]

remy truly did play everything, inclusing mono goat fog

[@CityState_of_Valletta]

song needs to be updated now

[@Dexsting]

Remy right away with a gem, "they didn't beat shredder with a bunch of hamsters".

[@jackeea_]

In one corner: a £0.11 forgettable uncommon In the other: *Atraxa*

[@Generic42]

She’s the G.O.A.T.!

[@collinbeal]

Hey Moritte is cool af. I love how he used it to make Reflections of Reflections of Littjara. I know Orvar is a flashier shapeshifter commander from Kaldheim, but Moritte was a good choice for his deck. But yeah if Remy didn't have the Goat of Arms and survived another turn or 2, he probably would've started popping off with the combo of Atraxa and Felidar's Retreat.

[@fionathegayesttiefling9867]

Thoralf knowing the pain of every commander player who pops off just a bit too early and Remy knowing the joy of every comic relief commander player who mops up the remains

[@Nighterfighter1771]

I wish you guys could do more stuff with MTGRemy! I know it's hard to coordinate with people in the US like that, but you all seemed to have a great time working together. Great channel, us viewers can tell you really enjoy making these videos. (Or you're great actors!)

[@CardmarketMagic]

Having Remy over was truly a blast. He's so funny! We might invite him again over in the future, but we already have some great guests lined up this year that I hope you will enjoy :)

[@SwedeRacerDC]

There's 13 actual goats and they're all Naya. I could see adding black for woe strider. Maybe go 5 color morophon

[@ReederMG]

Remy dropping that Goat of Arms at the end was legend. I kept saying to myself that he needs Coat of Arms, but I didn't think he'd be crazy enough to put it in his deck when everyone else was also playing tribal. He was a real mad genius there.

[@dess8815]

He did say he plays fogs so all he would need is to have someone swing out fog the attack drop the coat and ggs

[@TheGeopigMan]

Left the Gate Watch and built his own Goat Watch 😂

[@Wabiman70]

42:15 the Altered Ego is already in the battlefield as a Bull Aurochs, so the Glasspool Mimic will enters as a Bull Aurochs, Altered Ego only have the ability to enters as a copy of something when is not in play

[@MunchKING]

That's what I thought. I came down here to post that.

[@rustyanvile]

Usually you ignore all effects when copying something so it's an understandable mistake

[@Gabriel64468]

And shouln't both have been copied twice? Or am I missing something that stops them from being copied?

[@MunchKING]

@@Gabriel64468 Altered Ego was a Bull Aurochs. So when he tries to copy it, Glasspool Mimic will see the card he's choosing as Bull Aurochs. However he had Glasswork Mimic come into play as an unaltered Altered Ego so he could clone the Phoenix.

[@2LettersSho]

Look, Jamin may not read the cards or follow the rules sometimes but it doesn't ruin the content or anything so I'm fine with it :D

[@yangerdanger7744]

I'm a turtle, I'm a phoenix, I'm an auroch, I'm a angel, i'm a goat...

[@KleineKassiopeia]

I'm a sinner, I'm a saint

[@roxanaspiridon1912]

Changelings are everything! 🎶🎤🎶

[@evanmaunders5688]

I’m a laborer by day, I piss away me pay

[@Loki-]

Funnily enough, I just watched that video today then I see this one!

[@nyeakz]

now ill watch that music video again

[@tonythepokemonguy751]

Remy’s cards clearly was talking and singing to him. He had an advantage no one else had

[@stainawarjar]

They had to cut the singing cards part from the video. It was originally 12 hours long.

[@breath4255]

We really, really, really need a goat commander! I've always theorycrafted one, but had to settle for satyrs because of how little goat support there is!

[@jimbeam7636]

Satyr with goat support ?

[@Matyanson]

What about Zedruu?

[@skyguytomas9615]

For some arcane reason Zedru is a Minotaur.

[@thawk75]

To set it apart as a leader of goats it should definitely have an improved stat line, I suggest 0/2. My suggestion for the ability is to tap it and 5 other goats you control to turn any plains into a wastes

[@ave_maria323]

Goat and satyrs maybe a fun deck

[@PraetorianCuber]

UNFORTUNATELY the like button enters in tapped, love these commander games guys, thanks for the content!

[@Kokuswolf]

So today I learned, the true enemy for phoenixes are a coalition of distracting goats, pre trampling auerochs copies and - when they finally arrive - overrunning turtles. No phoenix will ressurect after that.

[@CardmarketMagic]

It's wild how nature does that

[@_The_Rumbling]

Jamin played myriad landscape untapped at 9:10 and activates it in the same turn cycle at 12:34

[@MtendoTheSkunk]

I noticed that too. What a cheater lol

[@k0enigsfalter]

I mean. I guess he didnt know it. If he had it beforehand woule make no diffrence he should have played it earlier. If he just drew it than well...

[@Kaspar502]

King of Games moment

[@zacharyleblanc6514]

I got so outraged. I'm glad someone noticed.

[@thevp_ssb.]

19:25 Judge! Carl couldn't float a mana when playing Jungle Basin, as it needs to return an untapped Forest to hand.

[@CardmarketMagic]

Wow that card is even worse than I thought 😅

[@thevp_ssb.]

​@@CardmarketMagic I was playing it in Ashaya for a while, but then I realized how bad it was. Lol.

[@Wabiman70]

@@thevp_ssb. I once saw someone play it in an Ashaya to bounce his Avenger of Zendikar and it blow my mind, but I don't play mono green so I don't know how good or bad could it be in general

[@thevp_ssb.]

@@Wabiman70 it still provides decent utility, but even Guildless Commons is arguably better, as even though it is strictly two colorless mana, it at least isn't as strict with it's bounce requirement.

[@milanmach2379]

I was hoping the whole time someone would be crazy enough to drop a Goat of Arms and was definitely not disappointed when it happened!

[@LeonLayer]

Who but Remy would play a ... GOAT of arms?

[@Emeraldraven777]

Should've pledged an oath to the Goatwatch.

[@madsandersen2740]

When you copy a permanent that is copying a different permanent, it will take on the characteristics of the originally copied permanent, so Jamin would have continued to make more aurochs with Glasspool Mimic instead of copying Toffels commander. Another note is that if you somehow manage to get a clone on the battlefield without it copying something else, any permanent that enters as a copy of that clone, will just be a 0/0, the Clone's replacement effect will not take place.

[@namedelemental]

I'm not convinced on the cloning a clone ruling there. A clone's copy effect is a replacement effect and a replacement effect can cause an unrelated replacement to apply to an event it wouldn't have (or cause a replacement effect. The rulings for Clone on the gatherer specifically state that "as [this creature] enters the battlefield" and "[this creature] enters the battlefield with" abilities still work which are also replacement effects, so there's no reason that you couldn't say clone a blank Quicksilver Gargantuan and then copy what you actually want but as a 7/7 this time.

[@Barracius]

So clearly on the last turn, Carl and Jamin truly became the men who stare at goats.

[@Tompaguden420]

Can't belive Springjack Pasture isn't banned already due to this power, GG! Looking forward to the Brushwagg, Noggle, Homarid and the Beeble faceoff ^^

[@markbrierley6367]

It's a staple in my group hug deck

[@whaleofdarkness]

Fallen Empires tribes would be fun: Homarids vs. fungi vs. orcs vs. thrulls.

[@emilysmith2965]

Thrull tribal seems pretty good, actually. Not like, GOOD like Elves but better than a lot of weird tribes

[@drakegrandx5914]

God, homarids...

[@kevinhulvey7018]

Carl: "It's not a turtle, but, uhhh..." Remy: "Eh, same section of the zoo!" 🤣 Master of comedy, this guy.

[@RibusPQR]

Jamin's timing on reminding Remy that his enchantment enters tapped was so perfect.

[@narkfly]

Way to go, Remy! This highlights both the importance of piloting an underwhelming deck and the strategically correct way to play Coat of Arms with an established board presence for a massive alpha strike. Also highlights leaving blockers for the crack back and respect for the fog effects. I'll bet Remy's full grip had another couple in there... which means his deck had a solid plan to win with his goats. Very impressive.

[@ringoderbar1522]

Love this video! Obviously, one creature type was much stronger than the other. Some noteable things: - Myriad Landscape enters the battlefield tapped - Jungle Basin needs to bounce an UNtapped land. So Carl can't float mana with the returned Forest - Regarding Thoralf's Miracle Turn: Howling Mine and Braids trigger at the same time, but because of active and inactive player, Thoralf would draw the Howling Mine-Draw before he gets the mana from Braids. As he activated the Deck of Many Things in response of the Howling Mine trigger, there was no way (I think) to pay the black Miracle card with the Braids mana, because there was none yet. And Thoralf wouldn't have been able to cast Fervent Mastery. - If you clone a clone, the new clone will become what the clone on board cloned. In this case, Jamin cloned an Altered Ego with an Glasspool Mimic, the Mimic clones whatever Altered Ego cloned before (the Auroch, if I am not mistaken)

[@Dracomandriuthus]

You actually DONT trigger Mine and Braids att the same time. Braids is upkeep, mine is draw step

[@MediumChungus223]

See this is why I don't like backseat rules needs on MTG videos: You're wrong. Braids triggers on upkeep, howling mine triggers on draw step.

[@ringoderbar1522]

@@MediumChungus223 That is correct. My mistake

[@11Evalone]

The black miracle was also off of drawing two from "Deck of Many Things" which he activated during upkeep.

[@hansolo8080]

Remy just sitting there, smiling THE ENTIRE TIME like a happy child, makes this video. Thanks for uploading. Just discovered this channel.

[@TheChemiker1966]

9:11 Judge! Jamens Landscape hätte getappt ins Spiel kommen müssen. So war er leider auch eigentlich nicht in der Lage es am Ende von Remy‘s Zug zu opfern. 😢

[@thevp_ssb.]

19:25 Judge! Carl couldn't float a mana when playing Jungle Basin, as it needs to return an untapped Forest to hand.

[@TheGoldenkill]

@@thevp_ssb. Judge! Flamewake Phoenix entered before declaring attackers with haste and has attacks each turn if able but didn't! Or is that wrong?

[@QuixoticCowboy]

44:04 Judge, the lotus field came in untapped and Carl used it to cast something which should not work due to his commander

[@CardmarketMagic]

The lotus field comes in untapped because of my commander :) that wasn't a misdplay. The jungle bassin thing though is true. I could imagine that card was actually that bad 😅

[@Rueler18]

​@@CardmarketMagici think he was talking about the myriad landscape turn 3

[@samuelwalls7029]

More people need to find out you all exist, definitely my favorite MTG channel ❤

[@CardmarketMagic]

That is so kind of you to say! :D

[@Doomblaaade]

​@@CardmarketMagic bro didn't have his Myriad Landscape come into play tapped big cheats.

[@CardmarketMagic]

@The Phorgotten One you should really avoid using the word "cheat" in cases like this as it really looks like you are accusing someone of being devious to get an advantage. Jamin in this case simply did not realize that Myriad Landscape enters tapped, and we all missed it as well :) luckily, none of us cares because the point of commander is to have fun, which we did plentifully

[@Doomblaaade]

@@CardmarketMagic good on you guys. Personally wouldve called him on it. Otherwise I thought the game was fun (even for us not playing)

[@JNB6037]

19:24 be careful with the old bounce lands, Carl wouldn’t have been able to float the green mana because then it would be a tapped forest and therefore unable to be returned

[@CardmarketMagic]

You are correct 😅 I did not expect that land to be that bad

[@MrRolhand]

19:23 jungle basin: when jungle basin enters the battlefield, sacrifice it unless you return an untapped Forest you control to its owners hand. carl: "i float 1 green mana."so the forrest is not untapped. soo....sacrifice the jungle basin then.

[@The_spacemonkey]

This was amazing. We need more of this. Random jank that ends up being both way more powerful and way more entertaining than expected.🤣

[@FelixGellen]

This is the absolute pinnacle of... everything. Laughed so much, thank you guys

[@timothygadd751]

getting to watch Remy play commander really made my week. please get him on for as much content as possible. I think the video was well produced and not over produced. The choice of decks was interesting.

[@faefeatherweight]

This was so fun!!! I was glued to my screen, you all have such great personalities and chemistry, and I absolutely loved watching MtGRemy playing his deck, there, just vibing. And the quips were hilarious! Also, perfect ending to that video. Thank you!

[@CardmarketMagic]

I'm happy you enjoyed it :) thank you for the kind comment!

[@96Logan]

I want one of those Myriad Landscapes. Mine always seem enter tapped for some reason 😂

[@Marhathor]

I love how he somehow managed. Absolute madlad. No power. Minimal toughness. Obliterated everyone.

[@Joescotterpuss]

"Maybe those cards will let you get ahead." Gotta love Remy

[@GunbladeKnight]

19:28 Carl couldn't float a green unless he wanted to sacrifice the land he just played. Each of those lands (there's one for each color) specify that you must return an untapped land of the basic land type or sacrifice it. This means that he couldn't tap it for mana and return it per the effect of the land.

[@alexvoigt2154]

Please do more of these tribal commander videos, this was amazing. Love the channel and keep it up! Thoralf sounds identical to what a phoenix would sound like 100%.

[@Varler_]

That was a fun game! It was cool seeing how everyone made their (mostly) jank themes work! The Shapeshifters copying Reflections and Aurocs was super neat.

[@germanyjones2700]

Goodness remy is too much fun! And the German boys are wonderfully fun! Had so much fun thanks gents!

[@CardmarketMagic]

Happy you enjoyed! :D we loved having Remy over he's so funny

[@Narakiomal]

More Commander chaos with the boys🎉🎉🎉! Heck yeah.

[@oygemprime3864]

Let's go, more commander games!!! Love these, keep them coming!

[@intalekt]

Fantastic stuff! Keep it up, y'all! I thought it was a really entertaining battle. Remy's last-second fog and massive pump was completely unexpected, but so cool to see :)

[@CardmarketMagic]

We didn't know Remy was playing so many fogs. We were all so puzzled as to what all the cards he was not casting in his hand would to 😅 it was quite a surprise

[@DKforever24]

Jamin cheated at 9:10 when he played his Myriad Landscape untapped when it ETBs tapped. This meant that he should not have been able to crack it at the end of Remy's turn at 12:31. Carl cheated at 19:25. Jungle Basin requires an untapped Forest to be returned to his hand, but he tapped his only Forest in response to the ETB trigger, so Jungle Basin should have sacrificed itself since there were no legal Forests to bounce.

[@Thecalebpoe]

I couldn't be happier with the outcome of this game. Remmy is the G.O.A.T.

[@godsiresfollower7987]

To clarify something about the 42ish minute, the copy value of a card is what is printed on a card UNLESS that card entered the battlefield as something else: the altered ego was an auroch and its copy value was that of the auroch it chosed, So the glasspool mimic do not enter as a altered ego to then change into anything but would be the same thing altered ego selected to be when it entered.

[@pellevin]

19:24 When Carl floats the mana from the forest to play Sol Ring, doesn't that mean his forest is no longer untapped, and the Jungle Basin has to be sacrificed?

[@AwkwardDreamer]

This was a super fun watch! Thank you! I shall add my rule catch (I won't bother repeating the others that have already been stated :P) 32:23 Jamin's Aurochs should have gotten +5/+0 instead of +6/+0 (cause it's each OTHER Auroch) which was a net difference of 3 life which would have (potentially) kept Thoralf in game another turn :P Unless I missed something of course Thank you again for taking the time to play and put it up for us to all watch (and nitpick :>) Mistakes happen, not the end of the world, just glad y'all had fun! Was rooting for goats (and Aurochs) just because of the low tribe support! I'm definitely excited/interested in seeing more games with similar themes and can't wait to see what y'all come up with :D

[@b-man341]

This was one of the funniest commander videos I’ve ever watched😂

[@thevp_ssb.]

Wow, that was a lot of fun. Certainly as unexpected winner, but very fun!

[@yabi333]

PLEASE make more of these lol, it's an imaginative and interesting concept

[@pietrociompi5883]

Goats and fogs must be my new favourite theme ever for a commander deck

[@siradzki5905]

Please make a part 2!! This is probably my favorite episode :)

[@ConstanceMists]

Felidar Retreat + Anointed Procession = GGs. Gameplay was awesome, we need more unique tribal commanders!

[@vectorstrike]

There's only one thing to say about this game: "All creatures in nature must live together in balance. But I can't help cheering for the little turtles!"

[@yellowmaster52]

But unfortunately, they enter tapped.

[@vectorstrike]

@@yellowmaster52 it's to make it more dramatic when they finally make it to the water

[@ElGrandeFatso]

Turned out exactly as I expected for Thoralf, his deck was obviously just so much better than the others, they just had to gang up on him haha, poor Thoralf.

[@ericdevey7520]

I love these creative commander deckbuilding challenges. It's something I'd love to do with my own playgroup. And this video just goes to show that you don't need the best deck at the table to win the game.

[@tirnan14]

Amazing gameplay. Truly a G.O.A.T. of arms if there ever was one

[@jaydub5515]

Hey Jamin, that Myriad Landscape should have came into play tapped

[@GothamKnight-hsw4vx526430]

Way to go Remy! You the GOAT! hahah, fun episode guys please do more!!

[@JJW410]

20:13 - 20:20 is the most indecipherable attempt at a full sentence I've ever heard in my life.

[@jasonmorley9217]

Remy and his Goat of Arms... Love it.

[@TheWhmaxwell]

Thanks for getting Remy to visit, it was a fun one.

[@vinwonsenobi]

34:41 the rampant growth Island should have come into play untapped due to Archelos

[@ohfish9499]

Love the commander content, these are always so fun with a super jank theme. Really captures the spirit of the commander format imo.

[@nathanielreichley4640]

Thoralf excellent Futurama reference! "With Blackjack and phoenixes"

[@fabianmikenda9476]

I love goat tribal! My friend recently told me about one opponent he played in a modern RCQ that traveled 4 hours to play a goat modern deck lmao

[@CardmarketMagic]

What a brave person! Do you know if they did well with the deck?

[@Aaackermann]

Now you know how much Atraxas is the GOAT! He doesn't have to be cast to win a game!

[@Penguirrel]

19:27 Carl, you cannot float a green from the forest because the Jungle Basin requires it to be returned untapped.

[@CardmarketMagic]

I know now 😅 but at the time, I just assumed that it was like the other bounce lands, I didn't realize it was so bad

[@TheFroperator]

Am I the only one that noticed Jamin put his Myriad Landscape into play untapped while it's supposed to be entering tapped?

[@DerickTheHeroV2]

19:20 Carl did an illegal move by floating the forest for mana. Jungle Basin specifies that the forest must be untapped. It's a strictly worse bounce land than normal bounce lands (but it's mono-color playable I guess.) He tapped that into a sol ring into a 4 drop. He should have just played the Sol Ring and not played the other card.

[@CardmarketMagic]

You are correct! I assumed it was just like every other bounce land but worse (because of colorless) and skimmed over the text, I did not realize it was that horrible 😅

[@DerickTheHeroV2]

@@CardmarketMagic Someday I'm going to blow up on my main channel, this is an alt account where I never make content, and I'm going to beg you guys to let me play a match on camera. Be ready for it, someday.

[@CardmarketMagic]

@@DerickTheHeroV2 if your channel ever gets big enough for us to justify flying you out for content to our bosses, then we would love to have you over!

[@WindchaserX]

This was fun. Sadly didn't get to see Remy cast many spells, but he did a sneaky win! Meanwhile, I really like each of the other 3 decks, especially the Phoenix seems really fun!

[@jordangroblewsky2087]

Thoralf: This Howling Mine will help me draw into my engine to get a lot of value and play phoenixes. Jamin: I just wanna draw my aurochs.

[@ChristopherLaHaise]

49:00 I've been thinking of this card ALL GAME. To see it pop out and into play? YAS!

[@lukeneslen3412]

The aurochs should have been 7/1’s. The +1/+0 ability did not see itself, but only the other five. Thoralf would have lived one more turn

[@vinterbjork4128]

That was amazing, Remy truly are the GOAT!

[@nilrem3]

I actually laughed out loud at “UNFORTUNATELY”, this is great stuff!

[@nilrem3]

pretty sure this is a scam lol

[@josephg2332]

Loving the Sven sleeves from Remy!

[@owie34]

Just wanted to say that this was a hilarious concept and video, and that I love Remy, what a KZbin OG, even before his magic videos i was watching "Hummus: The Rap" like 15 years ago!!!! I can still do all the lyrics :)

[@dantelarka6112]

Jamin: holds up sublime epiphany. Also jamin: doesn't counter toralfs spells

[@RedRamDRA]

Great game, I actually laughed a few times! :D Remy is always good fun!

[@jesse8654]

Not only can he make amazing parodies, but he's got game too! Way to go Remy!!!

[@aprofessionalcitizen9030]

Very happy to see my man Remy in the mix!

[@aleistermorrison3678]

Why is Remy the funniest person, his jokes either hit crazy hard, or they're so bad and cringy they make you laugh anyways😂

[@insidious]

I had a bunch of Aurochs from drafting Coldsnap on MTGO and decided to make a deck with them. I played Ardent Plea, which was always a sincere prayer for a cow and always granted.

[@RodrigoCML7]

In this episode of CommaderMarket: Thoralf insists on the archenemy life Carl keeps time walking, himself Remy shows why Atraxa is the GOAT Jamin is happy to be there

[@KosheiDeathless]

That was the best commander match i ever saw. Also the best ending. Gz.

[@AlexAndrews]

Just been watching the Tabletop Jocks where Joe goes back on another deal and Cassius throws a legit strop. Even the Prof couldn't stop me turning off. This is just so much healthier and is a blast to watch. Massive fan of both sets of collaborators. MTG Remy's parody of 'The way' is one of my most listened to tunes at the moment.

[@bonnietriplett5329]

Just curious Why would prof turn you off?

[@pathtracker4944]

I love the concept!!! Could you do another one please ??? It is so fun discovering new tribes, new tribal cards, and this video made me want to make a turtle tribal!

[@Aaackermann]

Jamens "Myriad Landscapes" should have entered the battlefield tapped! ;-)

[@houligan5254]

The three 8-1 tramples out of nowhere were hilarious

[@InquisitorSinCross]

Wow, Carl whiffed on that ninjutsu hard

[@aggedon7483]

This was a lot of fun to watch and looked like it was a lot of fun to make!

[@z-mashupz8069]

Would love to see more commander content from Cardmarket, I don't follow most format's so most of the gameplay just doesn't catch my eye but I'm always down to see some EDH.

[@danielbaker5365]

28:45 he reanimated a Phoenix that says it must attack when able, has haste, but then forgets to attack with it? Or what am I missing there.

[@KevinAllen619]

Being the threat n commander is the scariest part of commander. Gg's everyone, congrats Remy

[@Ricardo-zo1ti]

Great game, great theme and great people playing it!