Professional vs Beginner Recorder

[@darrencrissistotallyawesom918]

As always love that you let me know which one was the beginner and which one was the professional. It was pretty hard to tell

[@timmyc9915]

Yea honestly I couldn't tell between Lucie and Eddy who was the better one. 😊

[@lyingcat9022]

Almost no way to tell… I agree

[@azukichiu]

same i couldn't tell listening!

[@its_clean]

Big "they're the same picture" energy

[@laurelmentor404]

I couldn’t tell either. Eddy was just playing the modern interpretation of the pieces. He sounded like he was playing Schönberg

[@githerax5303]

Oh she's so sweet-hearted, she nods encouragingly when he gets *one* correct note in the middle of chaos.

[@chrisma3256]

😂😂😂

[@ankavoskuilen1725]

Yes, wasn't that great? She must be a good teacher.

[@agk0604]

firstly she created a private yt channel to roast twoset, and then she is flexing on twoset in real life. This girl is such a legend dude

[@tirtaamerta3911]

search this type of comment because I can't believe my eyes to witness that this is the same girl who roasted twosetviolin back then, what a plot twist in real life huh, LOL

[@Cookie_Comment]

yeah! years later, she’s here again!!

[@ethanma3916]

i had to do a double take cuz i was like is that the same person lol

[@jamesmihalkamusic]

This feels like that one character from season 2 returning for the finale in season 10

[@chih-fang-hsu]

Is there a link about this?

[@goldika]

I just love when they bring back some of their old formats 🤩🤣

[@edyuentt]

Respect how Lucie the professional respects Eddy's playing.

[@chrisma3256]

Indeed, had to fast forward 🙈😅

[@kaybrown4010]

The old “Nod and Smile”. 😅

[@Laura-gb1jv]

Indeed, she managed not to laugh until he started grooving to his own Telemann "interpretation". I was impressed!

[@BubboPants]

Gut-wrenching respect

[@andrewcordle2424]

😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@brothercuber3288]

This is proof that the recorder is indeed an instrument

[@Snoozy13]

Sacrilegious footage

[@arti-chan2714]

Exactly

[@oro88]

Always has been

[@pb2771]

Always has been Btw why’s the LL subreddit link gone😢

[@MattSuguisAsFondAsEverrr]

them plastic maped ones aint

[@theeclipse00]

Eddy took the "no note is wrong if you play the right rhythm" to the next level

[@rossthefiddler5890]

It's 'playing the wrong note with confidence' that matters though. 😉

[@lordneeko]

He was playing it Jazzy ~Charles Cornell

[@rossthefiddler5890]

@@lordneeko No, he was playing it 'fluffy'. In other words, he was 'fluffing it'. 😉

[@LesserMoffHootkins]

Play every note you can. At least some are bound to be right

[@midnightmoth1]

If you can play it slowly you can play it quickly

[@AngelaSealana]

Thank you for inviting Lucie! She's so talented.

[@Paloch1708]

And dedicated, she opened her new youtube account just to roast twoset. Gotta love that.

[@poonamranjan981]

​@@e2pii213Lucie Horsch

[@Paloch1708]

@@e2pii213 I think she now merged them together

[@conni8885]

What a journey - first, being in awe of her playing, then doublesided roasting and lastly a (partially) masterful collaboration. Eddy's face at her playing was a sight to behold!

[@qwyyfluut]

I always said that 1st video of them admiring Lucie was an unofficial pro vs beginner video.

[@qwyyfluut]

I hope they meet Sarah too.

[@cassiusily]

How can they not have given us a bloopers section for this! I really hope they filmed another collab with Lucie Horsch!

[@myrtillegrandesoreilles8275]

Yesss I was thinking the same!

[@mikefung9145]

@@myrtillegrandesoreilles8275Ling Ling challenge with Lucie!

[@jappyproductions4429]

All of Eddy’s playing is bloopers lmao

[@luckybarrel7829]

The whole thing was a blooper

[@yourfriendlyneighborhoodmegu]

TwoSet: The recorder is not a real instrument Lucie: Hold my recorder collection

[@chrisma3256]

Honestly the way he plays I'd have shared my kids'plastic recorder with him at most 😂😂 she's so generous I was wondering if they were a couple 😂

[@drelyka]

Gotta agree! You can actually damage a good recorder playing that way.

[@salamonthegreat]

​@@chrisma3256​ it hurts more to know that Morgan recorders are at least 30-40 years old and can go for about 6000USD. The maker has passed so no more of those will be made. The last instrument, the sopranino, is real ivory as well.

[@chrisma3256]

@@drelyka I know. We have two wooden recorders which are about 35 and 45 years old. That's why my kids have plastic Yamaha that are said to endure a dishwasher... if you want to damage a wooden recorder, give it to a 3 year old for 10 minutes... I've always liked the instrument and usually take it out at Christmas time... just didn't ever think there are so many sophisticated pieces for it and such a variety of instruments. The most I tried was the Vogelfänger from The Magic Flute

[@LaizyDaisy]

The last and most tragic one…😂😂😂😂

[@aqueelkadri8371]

1:30 I love how quickly she went from, "Ok you got it, good goo..nope you don't got it. back to awful"

[@Samuel_Loegan]

It's Lucie herself!!! Never have I seen the day where TwoSet ACTUALLY collaborated with their roaster XD

[@monkeymusic3318]

Missed the whole bass guitar thing, didn't ya?

[@Samuel_Loegan]

@@monkeymusic3318 oh...OH YEAH! Now that you mentioned it XD. What I should've said is it's the first time I see Twoset collaborated with Lucie 😅🤣

[@hammercleaver9396]

I’d say Ray Chen roasts them quite a bit too.

[@elissahunt]

​@@hammercleaver9396But Ray tries to be nice about it. 😂

[@Samuel_Loegan]

​@@hammercleaver9396 really? He roasts them too? XD

[@maurmi]

I love Lucie Horsch! She inspired our ensemble to perform the recorder arrangement of The Arrival of the Queen of Sheba just last week!❤

[@joshuachen8467]

Eddy's playing is still less cursed than Brett's Lofi

[@KarunaMurti]

I dunno, Brett's lofi is good for noise background when you want to concentrate on something.

[@mystamusica8571]

The way that Eddie actually tried to replicate her fingerings was so funny 😂😂 Also i love the sound of the voiceflute (3:20) it’s so enchanting

[@natasale1638]

Wow! This is by far the most beautiful play of a recorder i've ever seen! The one on the left was alright I guess... but on the the right it gets me everytime! Those pieces literally strike every emotion with it's upright elegance that I think I almost shed a tear by how mystical that performance was

[@burgundy.v]

I love how she pulls out a new recorder for every piece

[@CalixtoPrimeiro]

She has to. A recorder will start to sound hoarse after about 15 minutes of playing due to the humidity of your breath soaking into the wood. After being played for a while, a (wooden) recorder has to dry before you can play it again.

[@sabrinalauenstein]

That depends on the recorder and the conditions (humidity, temperature). If the Recorder ist played in well (and I think all her recorders are), you can play up to an hour or even longer. I think she wanted to show the spectrum of recorders and their different sound colours.

[@johnnymo4000]

Never thought the recorder could sound that majestic, wow.

[@hannahoberry8383]

Just to clarify, were you referring to Lucie or Eddie?

[@johnnymo4000]

@@hannahoberry8383 I wasn't being sarcastic I meant Lucie 🤣

[@Eve_Glitch]

Yeah, that was what I was thinking! I've played the recorder when I was 9, but I never thought that it can be *this* melodic!

[@_rstcm]

YAAAAAAAAASSSSS!!!! Recorder gang finally showing violinists who's boss! Loving these pro bs beginner videos. U guys should do a pro vs beginner on the violin with everyone else....that would be fun!

[@M_SC]

You mean with other instruments? They have done like every other instrument already

[@_rstcm]

@@M_SC In case u didn't understand, I mean...Brett and eddy will play the violin pieces....and the pros of the other instruments will try and play them....on the violin.

[@hannahblind]

Yessss

[@rayati2284]

IT'S HER, IT'S HEEEEEERRRRRRRRRRRRRR!!!!! (anyone else from the OGs here??) (for those that don't know, the professional, Lucie, first appeared in an older TwoSet video, when they reacted to her playing Vivaldi's Flautino Concerto. A few years later, she did a reaction/roast video in response to their "violin VS recorder" video, to which they also reacted.)

[@mystamusica8571]

I recognize her from when the recorder gang counter-roasted two set 😂

[@M_SC]

I didn’t see all of them so ty I will find them

[@iriswong888]

Okay 3 things: 1. Love that you've brought back this OG series of pro vs. beginner after SO many years 2. Love that you actually did a collab with Lucie Horsch after you guys reviewing each other throughout the years 🤍 3. When's the navy sweater vest dropping and will it be coming back in the original beige color too? 😂 PS: Hope you recover from your fever soon, Eddy! Rest well after this world tour 1st leg 🥰

[@WeilunP]

Eddy's playing in general: decent start, chaotic middle part, elegant ending😂 Glad to see this OG series again!! Especially it's about the recorder, an instrument they once roasted and then get roasted in return by her lol Epic Collaboration! Also I wonder how many types of recorders are there? Is it like, once you know how to play one type of recorder, you can play the rest?

[@jeanniwiese3462]

There are 5 main different recorders that vary in sizes but they switch between being in C and being in F. Therefore the recorders like the sopranino, Alto and Bass are played with the same fingering but to achieve the same notes different fingerings are used on the soprano, tenor. They all read in the soprano key but obviosly the timbre of each one is different, so yes you can technically play all of them if you can play (for example) the sopranino (in F) and soprano (in C) but each one has a very different feel to it, so each one is kind of like a "new instrument". Hope this helps😊

[@chrisma3256]

​@@jeanniwiese3462thank you! I learned a bit when my big sis switched to flute, but never knew there were so many kinds...

[@jytte47]

@@jeanniwiese3462 One of my friends plays the contre bass recorder. It is quite surprising :o)

[@londongael414]

@@jeanniwiese3462 Very helpful. As a non-muso, I am fascinated that some instrumentalists are expected to play every instrument in that family, while others are not. Imagine if violinists were expected to be able to play viola, cello, double bass etc. to concert level.

[@salamonthegreat]

@@londongael414 Though note for recorder, although you do have to adjust, it is much easier to switch between different sizes of a recorder than say a violin to a cello or a bass.

[@setonix850]

I love the looks of attentiiveness, encouragement, amazement and amusement on Lucie's face at Eddy's playing. Absolutely priceless. And Bravi to Lucie !

[@justary_97]

“Twoset brought back their OG series” - _Everyone cheered_ 🥹🫶

[@myrtillegrandesoreilles8275]

Literally the collab I've been waiting for since I first started watching TwoSet a bunch of years ago. Lucie Horsch forever !!! ❤❤❤😂

[@gianellab.4953]

The recorder is one of these instruments family and neighbors have to be brave enough to let kids practice enough to get good. My parents only gave me three options: piano, classical guitar or harp. They said 'I'm not about to have my eardrums destroyed by a violin, a trumpet or any other loud instrument'. When we had to learn recorder at school, they told me not to practice at home haha Kuddos to Lucie's family for being supportive enough to get her where she is!

[@drelyka]

I just watched the finals at Open Recorder Days Amsterdam (ORDA). The young performers absolutely killed it. And by young I mean 9, playing Vivaldi and the like. The Suzuki system gives recorder kids the same leg up as violin. They have really good tone from a very young age.

[@stephielulu9096]

Lucie's family is very musical ♩♪♩♬ ♬♩♪♩

[@aragorn1780]

I play tin whistles and my (live-in) gf has sensory issues so I'm very restricted when I can practice sadly... but yes a few years of practice takes you a LONG long way! XD

[@Vykk_Draygo]

Pianos are loud though. My wife is a pianist, so I would know. 🤣

[@gianellab.4953]

@@Vykk_Draygo I mean, my parents bought a digital piano so I could control the volume and if necessary, play with a headset haha

[@emmathompson2240]

This collaboration has been years in the making since Lucie’s first savage clap back to Eddy’s IntErEtiNg interpretation of the recorder. Absolute legend!! Lucie is an amazing musician and a savage queen 👑💕

[@hoveringhedgehogs4169]

I just did my grade 7 recorder exam 2 days ago and knowing that I can genuinely play 2 of these pieces makes me feel so much better about myself. Love Lucie, she is such an icon.

[@ianj1698]

Lucie Horsch is an amazing recorder player. Honestly some of the most beautiful music ever written was for recorders. Long may they be played professionally! 🎼🎵🎶

[@Paloch1708]

From being roasted by her now I’m so surprised and happy that now we have a professional recorder video

[@sofiaspiano7892]

As an intermediate recorder player Eddy's playing is better than most beginners

[@karlmortoniv2951]

He probably does a lot of prep to sound bad that good. If you see what I mean? The sentence got away from me.

[@sofiaspiano7892]

@@karlmortoniv2951 yeah :) When I was a beginner I sounded worse than Eddy

[@londongael414]

@@karlmortoniv2951 It's a great sentence.

[@VarshaA-w7g]

That smile on the professional player's face is eerily like my piano instructor's when I play, and Eddy just looks awkward (but awed) when she plays

[@regiroll2808]

My ears have been blessed by eddy’s virtuosic playing

[@rosegranger2872]

That was the payback to the not so nice sounding playing by Lucie😂

[@hawkins347]

Brett's gonna sample it for his next lo-fi.

[@Ottonormalverbraucher2525]

You notice that his perfect pitch gets so overpowerd. That he can stack all those notes, while she has to play them one by one. A true master polyphonic. Such complex harmonies and adventures he sends the notes to. Just to to show his experience and inspiration of Kabuki, Noh and bunraku at the end. Resulting in us asking "yooo, what might be the story of our life." Others might say "well he's not trained." Come on first of all he plays violin not viola. Secondly he prais to ling ling Lastly you underestimated his Master mind. In contrast. Her angelic ambochure (I'm not sure how it's spelled), her sweet and delicate tone telling of peace and wisdom. So what do you think wins?

[@segala7853]

ottonormalverbraucher5215 kicked out of youtube comment club for worst comment in youtube history

[@Ottonormalverbraucher2525]

@@segala7853 common that was no hate.... oh wait I think you do the samething I did here.

[@stephenbeck7222]

Embouchure

[@Ottonormalverbraucher2525]

@@stephenbeck7222 thanks.

[@jodietypn]

I swear when Lucie plays I thought the video was sped up 😅 she’s so good. And love how Eddy tried to learn her fingering at the beginning of each piece then gave up then decided to enjoy anyway 😂

[@elsaclf]

Yayyy Eddy and Lucie! Perfect combination, and as a recorder player and pianist I'm glad you're making people realise it's a legit instrument :)

[@toramenor]

When she started the really fast one: Eddy's jaw dropped. When Eddie started doing it, she looked at him, then towards the camera and it was like she said "bless him, he's trying" 😂

[@user-0917fckvjjigk]

Thankyou for bringing back the old format!! Beginner-Professional series was always my favourite

[@rubenacevedoacevedo3124]

I laughed my left lung when Lucie turned to the camera at 2:22.

[@mukilnarayanan]

Thank you for inviting Lucie! From roasting recorders to playing recorders (albeit learning), this is a well-deserved playing! Hoping for greater videos with Lucie!

[@AdamFaruqi]

I saw Lucie perform back in 2016 when she was like maybe 17 years old, and she was already a master then. Blew me away with her performance. Lovely to see you guys collaborating.

[@PVHSRecorderClub-cl4os]

As a recorder player I know indeed that recorder is a very underrated instrument and it’s fun to play. Also I can see Luice dying inside when Eddie plays

[@amclp1830]

So nice to see this collab! I once requested this in one of TwoSet's surveys and I am so happy that it came true 😊

[@Madshadowgolem]

I think a proper Recorder and Violin(s?) duet would be amazing. So great to see and hear Lucie!

[@yanneldor]

the roasts on the recorder players boomeranged so fast XD. no joke, eddy is pretty good considering he never had proper recorder training

[@barbarallanas1394]

I love how she is actually impress in some pieces eddy play, but in others is just “wtf is he doing” She is AmaZInG❤❤❤❤

[@wishingonthemoon1]

Love seeing Lucien on the channel! And like bringing an old format back. Her standing respectfully and nodding encouragingly while Eddy plays makes this so much more hilarious. 😂

[@laurelmentor404]

I had no idea that Eddy could turn every piece into Pierrot Lunaire by Schönberg. Also, Lucie is like the Paganini of the recorder.

[@ducks5377]

the way lucie looks like she is trying to hold back tears while eddy is playing 😭😭😭

[@_evangeline8011]

Lucie's face throughout the video: 😁😄😃😀😅🙂🥲

[@BassFunMusic]

Brilliant video! I can't get enough of your channel. ❤

[@sampolinad]

Sounded like birds chirping and water drops cascading and drizzling in a brook! Beautiful pieces!

[@hiiexist479]

WE GETTING OUT OF THE BAND HALL WITH THIS ONE 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@anakareninagarcia6379]

Lovely collab!! Lucie Horsch is such an inspiration! I really understand Eddie’s pain when he tried to play the lowest note on the voiceflute using his leg hahaha that happened to me the first time I tried it after watching Sarah Jeffery do it 😂

[@ankavoskuilen1725]

It is difficult. You can lose a tooth or two. Almost speaking from experience.

[@anakareninagarcia6379]

@@ankavoskuilen1725 wow thank you for the heads up, I’ll be more careful (I’m a beginner learning the alto recorder). I hope you’re well, sounds like you had a hard time

[@lyonwgffan_5568]

Brett and Eddy change my life. Like 1,5 years ago I was a bored student with zero knowledge in music AND CLASSICAL music, at the time i discovered a instrument, the clarinet, i started to study clarinet and classical music at the conservatory, and i started watching twoset videos, i started like classical music and THE VIOLIN, i love this instrument so much that in september 2023 finally i start taking violin lessons!!! I’m so happy thank Brett and Eddy for change my life❤ (Sorry for english errors i’m italian😅)

[@sofiaspiano7892]

Your English is perfect! Better than most native speakers

[@lyonwgffan_5568]

@@sofiaspiano7892 Thank you!

[@sofiaspiano7892]

@@lyonwgffan_5568 You're not the only one I see so many comments by non native english speakers and their grammar is perfect

[@lyonwgffan_5568]

@@sofiaspiano7892i subscribed to your channel! Amazing videos

[@sofiaspiano7892]

@@lyonwgffan_5568 thank you! I've been told that the camera quality is bad so thank you

[@funnybunny4079]

Loved it, I’ve been waiting for a video like this for very long, thank you

[@cycoekiller119]

full circle in terms of format and also roasts w lucie haha. i hope there are more collabs w her, shes so sweet and incredibly skilled

[@aurelliajacindakusumo]

They both have good expressions for each other 🤣. Also this is so great to see them bringing back their old concept! So refreshing!

[@marcosallegueallegue4056]

Both are so sweet! Love you Eddy and Lucie❤❤❤

[@somebody9033]

Totally irrelevant but how on earth is Lucie's sound just so full and resonant

[@cornellk]

Practice! 🙂

[@peterfireflylund]

Very, very good breath control.

[@itznoxy7193]

Me trying to sleep The birds outside my window at 4 am: 3:07

[@lienlee7654]

I am impressed that Eddy can actually make decent sound out for being a beginner. Nice collaboration!

[@ComputerDude2600]

As a recorder player this gives me so much joy. Thank you

[@lemongreed7916]

I recently unearthed my old dusty recorder and started playing it for fun, and not that many people seem to be at all interested in it, so this video is quite inspirational

[@lizziesmusicmaking]

This was a lot of fun. Lucie certainly wasn't going easy on Eddie with regard to repertoire! Some of those are on my list of things I want to learn, but I'm not good enough to play yet, like the Vivaldi. Others I could probably play, given the music and time to work on them. Eddie's tone on the low notes at the beginning of pieces is actually quite good, very good for a beginner. Of course, the stuff in the middle involves a lot of randomly waving fingers around and squeaking, which is hilarious to watch. Their faces are also fun to watch, especially Eddie's when she started in on that Vivaldi concerto. Mouth hanging open... Anyway, nice video guys. Enjoyed it.

[@mystamusica8571]

Eddie’s face at 1:58 is so golden 😂😂

[@sunshine8338]

Ayo loving this old style episode of Twoset :)

[@victorhugo1819]

Lucie is such a recorder legend, I love her 😍 love the recorder as well 💙

[@ioanab7076]

The looks on their faces are priceless !! And I'm so glad to see this collab happen too.

[@YozhikvTumane]

Whenever Lucie plays the recorder my heart melts ❤

[@2svil]

Thank you for your patience and courage to teach Eddy the recorder Lucie 😍. Better to practice Eddy🤭 but first I hope you make a swift and speedy recovery from the flu Eddy 🥺❤

[@mypianoschat9475]

The legendary Lucie Horsch

[@Azureyy]

So glad that you are bringing this series back

[@Nora-kd4iw]

I love Twoset Violin they are such an inspiration and everytime I watch their videos I'm inspired to go practice! LOL

[@thefloor5311]

another one of these videos? yall are amazing, also I've been having so many recorder videos recently.

[@true05angel]

My dog was fascinated by Eddy's "renditions". She had to stop eating to come listen! 😂😂

[@ankavoskuilen1725]

She thought some dog had puppies, I suppose.

[@eiralinnea]

Lucie's amazing recorder playing is indistinguishable from magic, it's so great ❤

[@rusballerina8058]

I love how Eddy makes up for his beginner-ness by adding those important arm flails and dramatic movements

[@megaturtle23]

Awesome video! Everyone on this channel has some real talent

[@TwoSetViolinEdits]

4:15 Eddy’s smile is so cute! Also, I kinda miss Brett now and NEED him in the next vid. Twoset. Not Oneset. I need BOTH the boys in each vid

[@Horscht2001]

Nice collab, Lucie is incredible!!

[@chilitofu3512]

wasnt that the person who decided to make a response on the violin vs recorder video?

[@Davidescilio3]

Yessss she's backk

[@lenochod6]

I was dying to see this legend again and my wish is fulfilled. Lucie Horsch is the best and I love her playing so much.

[@PanchamiBhatG]

Couldn't differentiate between beginner and professional thanks a lot for mentioning it

[@R0bilicious]

1:17 You can see the exact moment when Eddie gives up on trying to follow the fingerings.

[@blytheanneliese5408]

Keep working at it Lucie, maybe one day you'll be able to reach Eddy's level of recorder mastery.

[@leonzapffe5848]

Can we just acknowledge how insanely good Lucie was at playing the recorder? god DAMN

[@arti-chan2714]

I'm a recorder player too and I must admit it's harder and of course more beautiful than you think 🌷✨🤪

[@clara_c930]

Have been waiting for beginner vs professional video to come back! Lucie is an amazing player and Eddy too (in his mimicry skill 😂) Thank you for keep making fun videos during your busy tour schedule!

[@aidannodomm]

Petition to change the name Recorder to Kektryp 👇🏻

[@Hysteriassaintssoul]

We can all agree that Eddy’s recorder playing is truly sacrilegious

[@chansolpark6860]

yay the recorder girl is back!

[@villain1369]

Thanks for always writing professional and beginner, I would have gotten so confused without it beeing blended in.

[@ambergreymorning1637]

Saving this video to show to my 4th graders during our recorder unit next spring!

[@gustafbstrom]

I love Eddy's interpretations of these masterpieces and look forward for the tickets.

[@veritaseulerprogramation673]

Years later, here they are

[@linglingss_-]

yay were bringing these back!

[@joshua-we9xr]

His face at 2:30 is legit everything 😅

[@yasdnilknarf1885]

Hey let's not forget, even without the talent, she is ludicrously gorgeous.