The Procreate Selection Tool Sucks…Heres How to Make it Better

Hope this small workaround helped you!
What workarounds do you have for procreate?
Find my brush packs and online store at ko-fi.com/kagebonito/shop
Catch my stream M-F at 11am LA time at / kagebonito
----Links----
Find all my links here: linktr.ee/kagebonito
Join the Discord: / discord
Patreon: / kagebonito
CSP Brushes: gumroad.com/kagebonito
Twitch: (M-F 11AM Los Angeles) / kagebonito
Merch:
www.redbubble.com/people/kage...
My Gear:
iPad Pro 2021 12.9in
Apple Pencil Gen 2
Apps Used: Clip Studio Paint
Parblo Tablet Stand: www.amazon.com/Parblo-Univers...

[@TheSquonk]

THANK YOU SO MUCH!!! I hate spending an hour meticulously erasing and cleaning around the lineart…

[@MrAkella33]

Why can’t procreate just update the selection tool, it’s been years!!!

[@thekaleidoscope2630]

I wish they will improve their selection tool like SAI. SAI's selection tool is the best so far.

[@charlesmarshall2614]

I ran into this problem again last week, and it has bugged me for a couple years. Well done. Yes, hopefully Procreate will give us this capability soon.

[@QuickWitit07]

I need to save this video until I remember how to do this. Thanks Boss! Steps to remeber 1. color under line art 2. make line art reference 3. select color and create mask 4. Drag in black

[@MutantAndProud]

This is one of the most helpful workarounds I've found so far as a beginner. Thank you ❤

[@beavant5]

I appreciate you so much for this. I am a beginner with procreate and have been struggling so hard with this and running into issues with other’s tutorials on this. This is the first tutorial where it actually worked for me. Thank yoooou

[@Rakuen91]

copy layer alpha lock and fill.... you welcome

[@nokillnina]

This solution is great. Thank you so much! I was struggling with the selection tool so long

[@js-1389]

For as great as procreate is it is so disappointing how bad their select and filling tools are. When I first got it it took me days to figure out the color fill (was too stubborn to look it up for a bit lol) and I wanted to give up and go back to ibispaint. Thanks for the help :)

[@TiffanyNg100]

Yeah! Jesus Christ. Jsut make a lasso fill tool. It’s not cost money, and they have money. Even IbisPaint is much better with the user interface. They suck and cost money

[@wmurd]

@@TiffanyNg100you can use bucket fill for selection. but magic wand is awful, pixels are all over. and there is no magnets for selection…

[@draskoprasnicki5783]

Procreate has been nothing but a chain of frustrations since day one, lack of tools, lack of basic anything, lack of advanced selection or pen smoothing on selection and the worst of all, lack of a blur tool, its just a overadvertised headache. For 20€ its great but with a huge list of disfuncionality it just makes me question those 20€. Thank you for sharing your the vid. :)

[@danielblodgett1]

Bro...I was just getting into this program from years of PS and CSP. Thank you so much!

[@Espenfalls]

So I was desperately trying to find a way to do just this, and you, sir, are simply amazing. Gosh this is going to save me so much time!!

[@harleyhollingsworth5981]

Thank you! Really helps when you don't want to close shapes to fill them🎉

[@esmoldt]

Great solution! Thank you!

[@dyldev0320]

That problem has been getting me for ages, hated having to be precise and/or changing my brush settings

[@paradoxoftime22]

Thank you so much😭 this really help me save a lot of time when colouring!

[@Scytheuk]

Thanks for the post, it REALLY helped me out!

[@bajeebies]

man i love sai's selection tool

[@UtaminoUta]

Ahhh thank youuuu this is very helping ❤

[@ACometsShadow]

thank you soo much for this, it worked like a dream for what i needed.

[@rocket-boyz467]

Thanks this will save me a bunch of time I used to have to select fill the zoom in to clean up the gritty edges life saver ❤

[@stephaniepolo6650]

Thank you. This was the best tip this year for me.

[@jayc6159]

Thank you so much I use Procreate everyday and run into the problem often this is so much better

[@user-zm9wh7qv7f]

Omg you are such a lifesaver. That is so much cleaner and better. I will be using this from now on

[@clear_out6474]

awesome thank you!

[@hotmonkeyfilms]

This tip works very well. Thanks

[@aussiekingofmongrels]

THANK YOU 🎉

[@gingergreenwitch6934]

Thanks a lot

[@PlainsAyu]

Its still jaggy around the inside lines if you continue coloring in with the bucket.

[@hallegarrison38]

I had this issue when I tried this, too. :( did you ever find a solution?

[@PlainsAyu]

I think there is none@@hallegarrison38

[@LBofcourse]

Very helpful. Thank you.

[@felix-xd4mx]

thank you so much bro this saves sooo much time

[@marcinchopik5743]

Thank You

[@MelikeMiyanyedi]

thanks so much

[@grownupgoth]

❤ TY!

[@mutiaradaulay3929]

Thank youuuu

[@1015SaturdayNight]

Just did a "simple" coloring page last night and had this problem!

[@dalianaferrero9110]

Liminati- ive been looking for this video for months- THANK you- no one else has mentioned this. the white line created by color fill is horrible - thanks for this creative solution!

[@costaricacardcollector3524]

Great video.. I found that if you have solid line art you won't have that issue.. A solid line verses a broken line causes that broken line look..

[@rixcerezo]

Thanks

[@ajitpandey4087]

Innovative !!! Thanks

[@Pownchao]

This is the best! THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THIS!

[@aishwarialakra9904]

This was God send ...thank you so much 😊

[@Xanderful209]

This is an amazing video thank you ❤

[@magentaking]

THANK YOU!!!!

[@tfgallego]

Thamk you so much,man.

[@fausto_giurescu]

Thank you for this tip, you're amazing ♥

[@Heyhey-gr9qc]

It’s really work, thankfully 😍

[@macychocolate]

You're a true king 👑 thank you so much

[@photozzunkhungary9010]

Thank you very much 🤗 this very very veeeeryyy useful‼️

[@snighman3131]

thank you i been having this problem

[@anastasiadrogouti2650]

WOW! Thank you for this, that's helpful!

[@liminatii]

Glad this helped!!

[@fm-mb2qm]

Wow it has helped alot thanks

[@bastianrivero]

Excellent

[@clebertoncms]

This is amazing.... Just liked it and start to follow. I relish these kind of tips

[@pedrorodriguez7122]

Ah thank you doesn’t cover the feeling I have after watching u r vid. Excellent ! Keep up the great work. 🎉

[@hiemi1508]

ohmygod! tks u so much! 🎉🎉

[@magdycomics]

It has been monthes of procreate frustration. Thanks pal

[@jenjoestar.]

Or the choice to make straight lines when selecting

[@melwilson471]

THANK YOU SO MUCH OMG! You just made my workload SO much easier with this!

[@YouKnowImOnMyPeriodYah]

You, sir, are a wizard. Holy sh!t, I needed this

[@InkRebellion]

Seems like a good solution for Pencil art, nice job. I suppose not really required if you INK your lines instead of pencil lines. thanks

[@jcmoney11111]

In CT imaging we call these 2 features erode and dilate when cutting out 3d voxels.

[@ryanartward]

Just an expand and contract tool, that's all I ask. Even Infinite Painter put that in!

[@nathanaeltendam4874]

This is great and thanks, but it would be nice if they fixed their fucking program.

[@NhlNarcos]

god bless you. all i gotta say.

[@johnminet9067]

Thank you I am amateur a hi it’s, but I am happy to learn better skils

[@boblatzer]

Great hack.

[@rex4653]

3:29 start

[@rex4653]

1. lineart on top, fill pink on below layer. 2. lineart as reference. pink layer as mask. fill mask with black. drag it as desired. 3. merge pink with mask. set as reff. done

[@giftedgrouch]

great video

[@it52957]

I'll have to give this a try. I've been having this issue for a while and I didn't know how to fix it.

[@liminatii]

Its a workaround that shouldn't HAVE to exist, but I'm glad I at least found a semi-simple solution lol

[@it52957]

@@liminatii hopefully Procreate will eventually fix this issue.

[@swimmiey]

I was using the feather option for this, and while it works it does make it blurred if you would want to turn off the line art layer for whatever reason. Will try next time if his works better for me.

[@XtianApi]

This is great

[@liminatii]

Glad you found it helpful!

[@mallowskycotl]

THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU!!!! AAAAAA 😭✨✨

[@rhea2gaming737]

Thank you so muchh for the tutorial, it has been suck for me getting used to procreate (im newbie for procreate) when im fully used to clip studio paint with bunch of useful features.. may I asked if it is possible to pick color from what’s on the current layer,, for example, I have skin color on layer 1 and its shading color as multiply mode layer on layer 2,, in csp, I have options as I can pick the shading color on the layer 2 only or the blended (displayed) color from those 2 layers, while in procreate I can only pick displayed color… I wish I have that first option on procreate as well buhuhuh thank u again!

[@nightpartyman]

thanks it's usefull

[@purpswithyou607]

How can i waste my 2 years watching clue less tutorial out there. I need someting like this!

[@patricioaravena6015]

Man, you saved my life I was about to burn the Ipad of frustation lmao. Thank you!

[@birunnn7813]

God bless you sir

[@eross21]

is it possible to take that object just selected, and move it to its own layer?

[@woodswalker88]

Autodesk Sketchpad can select by color just fine. Why did I think Procreate was going to be so much better?

[@xxdebtxcollectorxx]

Nice work around. 20 plus years ago in my marketing firm we did most of our work in Adobe Illustrator and Photoshop. I just started using procreate. I’m still looking for the clipping path. Clipping path work very well and gave you many options. Do they no longer write that into software?

[@hiiamsatan]

THANK YOU!Ive had the tablet and procreate for months and holy shit this blew my mind

[@gmnavy9]

I am glad you said this in public. It really sucks.

[@anarchohelenism]

damn dude u blew my mind

[@ChenaeLoren]

still having an issue with only part of it filling with color!anyone know why??

[@ivopedro]

April 2023, still no decent Selection tool. Thank you!

[@spookattz4171]

i owe you one

[@litchy6387]

Thank you so much bro I was having a seizure with this stupid select tool and you saved me

[@KevinPichette]

Cool beans

[@ArcaneCluster]

I'm about to stop using Procreate bc this thin white outline that keeps showing up on my selections... doesn't even seem to matter when i change the threshold either...

[@still_your_zelda]

Same. It either fills the whole canvas or leaves a white line. It’s so broken.

[@ArcaneCluster]

@@still_your_zelda ended up causing HOURS & HOURS of extra work cleaning up for a screen print tour poster project.. fuuuuu.... never again lol

[@dougiestarr3760]

take a shot everytime he says artifacts

[@Bosst213]

Sobrang pogi mo dyan bayaw ah 👌 keep it up

[@YourLocalGhostSimp]

i just woke up.. this is intresting tho, because i dont use procreate that much.

[@liminatii]

It’s definitely a feature that needs to come to the app!

[@ConcussiveCrow]

Then... I have to duplicate all my Lineart Layers and those Copies, Merge them Together in order to Painting Leave originals in a Group, Separated and one Merged all Together for Painting? Wot?

[@astaroth3123]

IKR it’s so annoying

[@resurrectonjupiter2695]

Idk how this is supposed to help when shading in specific areas

[@fantasii_ryy1965]

It didn’t work.

[@TiffanyNg100]

I had never seen and use an drawing that so clunky and no user friendly like procreate. I would rather use IbisPaint!

[@chillyourself5208]

How this app has no real instruction is pathetic underwhelming and makes it uselss without hours of learning

[@Taka_Takata]

OMG , HOURS of learning? You must give up RIGHT NOW.