Psychologist Reacts to Andrew Tate on DEPRESSION

[@chris4charity191]

I was on antidepressants for 9 years....I was diagnosed with all those labels by a psychiatrist. I was having 8-15 panic attacks per DAY! and after coming off meds for 6 months, I thought I would have to go back on because I was struggling. After listening to Andrew speak, those attacks stopped that day. I got angry at my situation and my anxiety disappeared. I noticed a shift in my thinking and internal voice and now months later, I'm in better shape, clearer mind and have opportunities like I've never had before. Hes right...men shouldn't talk about their feelings. They need to be empowered to get the F back out there and work for yourself because no one cares about you! Good luck.

[@chris4charity191]

Also, being told you have depression for life is real....Dysthymiais a label I was given and it's low moods for the rest of your life with bouts of deeper depression. RIDICULOUS! Get off the pills and fix your life. Anxiety is being in your thoughts too much without control. Depression is the feeling you've lost control of your real world life. Faith and hard work will pay off!

[@j-greggo_laaa3736]

@@chris4charity191so much respect for you bro well done 👍

[@JeBeEeYT]

Jesus Christ Loves You and He died on The Cross and rose again 3 days later for yours and everyone's Sins. ✝️❤️ Here is my Testimony: I use to to Very very depressed and anxious and Suicidal for 2 - 3 years from 2019 - 2022. I would get anxiety attacks almost every week. I was sleep deprived because of the anxiety attacks. So I was failing school. Then one day I seen a Christian KZbin video in my Recommended I watched it and I saw more and more Christian videos Recommended to me. And One Day I gave my Life To Jesus Christ and all my Depression, Suicidal thoughts and actions and anxiety Went away Immediately. I Started balling my Eyes out Because I felt the Love of God. And I have not been depressed, suicidal and had anxiety ever since and the was 1 1/2 years ago. I can do all things through Christ who strengthens me. Philippians 4:13 (NKJV) For I know the thoughts that I think toward you, says the Lord, thoughts of peace and not of evil, to give you a future and a hope. Jeremiah 29:11 (NKJV) For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting life. John 3:16 (KJV) Jesus saith unto him, I am the way, the truth, and the life: no man cometh unto the Father, but by me. John 14:6 (KJV)

[@10colej]

Thank you. This doctors a fucking joke lmao they profit off ur misery dont become a lifelong patient for them

[@leftthatbehind6090]

Except saying “you got to take action” what ground breaking thing did he say? Talking about your feelings alone isn’t going to help anybody but it can be beneficial for both genders. I think there are a lot of bad therapist out there I don’t think it’s bad as a whole

[@johnk7025]

Tate saved my life. If there wasn't for some silly Tate youtube short to discover him my mind would have turned into a potato from all the brain-disentangling panic attacks I used to have. It seems nobody else can help you fix those problems, nowadays, only make them worse. From my experience, psychologists are too passive, they are scared to upset you even a tiny bit, they just hear you blah blah and schedule new appointments.

[@justinthomas7554]

If you recover, they will be jobless 😂

[@johnk7025]

It's just another business. Appointments with psychologists is a new thing, after like 1980s it became mainstream. I think it is better to treat emotions with logic instead of with more emotions, because otherwise you end up in a vicious cycle resulting in more appointments.@@justinthomas7554

[@leftthatbehind6090]

Im curious what exactly was it that he said and what you did that helped you? I feel that you really need to try really hard and cherrypick to find anything good that that man has said lol.

[@AdanKownacki]

Wow so you weren't depressed, you had panic attacks. That's very diffrent from depression. Depression is emptiness and lack of will to live and listening to a bald head talking about Buggati's when nothing brings you joy in life wont fix anything.

[@redpanda2023]

🙄🙄🙄​@@AdanKownacki

[@DJ_RIGGERZ]

From what I’ve experienced with my friends, most doctors in the UK are exactly how Andrew describes, and are certainly not like you. People go to the doctor with depression, the doctor instantly puts them on pills that just numb their mind and then that’s the end of it. The support they get is terrible. Andrew certainly knows what he’s talking about.

[@test1122lol]

"diagnosis means don't have control over it", that's not what Andrew meant, he meant that accepting a diagnosis takes power away by giving you something else to blame other than your mind, because your own mind is the only thing you can control.

[@MarcoSanderCoaching]

But as a Therapist it is your task to not only communicate the diagnosis but also explain what this means properly.

[@anime108amv2]

The issue is that many psychiatrists make it seem to their patients that they have a condition which they have no control over and therefore the patient ends up in a deeper depression. If qualified doctorls came out today and said that depression is taking accountability and changing your life, I am certain that 99% of people with gullible minds would come out of their depression. However I agree to what you said in the video, people who have cancer and depressed because of it would require a different help compared to people who can actively change their environment and life. @@MarcoSanderCoaching

[@Brandon-vd7er]

@@MarcoSanderCoaching I believe you are coming from a good place, But the reality is that People in the medical industry LOVE to tell you can't do anything about something such as depression for example and then shove pills down your throat. THAT is the reality.

[@Ivanzter]

@@MarcoSanderCoachingI disagree with you, the most powerful weapon is the human mind. If one takes over the human mind full it with powerful positive affirmations things will change.

[@drellz9361]

So how about those who have a chemical imbalance

[@RichObiQuan]

Listening to influencers may be tricky but Andrew tate is a very rational logical man that resonates with my beliefs even prior to knowing him. You have to take everything with a grain of salt but the majority of things he says do make logical sense. When you ask people if they like the man they cannot fully tell you why they dislike him and they can’t prove the wrong doings he has done. Most people like to bathe themselves in delusion and blindly follow other people especially this woke culture. It’s sad.

[@leftthatbehind6090]

I dislike him because he is a misogynist

[@pinpointshooter6074]

Andrew tate is shutting this psychiatrist "Fake depression savers" job 😂😂😂

[@grimamir2492]

Stop

[@TommyVercetti-xp4xy]

Bro 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@10colej]

Facts these doctors dont make money if nobody’s depressed😂😂🤷‍♂️

[@dragonsolo3744]

@@10colej JACKPOT

[@OnSludge]

“Stay depressed.. stay depressed… stay depressed….” 😵‍💫🔮

[@xkgabriel3815]

overconfidence is important for extreme sucess

[@KurtDillan]

Such an emotionally balanced Psychologist. Would love to be your client...

[@turghanhollow7197]

Andrew is stating that yes people feel depressed but a competent person has to drive on, contend with it and move on with your life, all these diagnosis and plan of care for medications is an industry..... Mr. Tate is correct. watch a John Wayne movie ya sallys

[@DrPITV]

Im assuming you’re from a European country my friend. I’m a respected clinical researcher in the UK and i specialise in chronic disease prevention and wellbeing via lifestyle change. 2:15 actually most UK and US general practitioners use language as if depression is a communicable disease eg you catch it or it just happens. Or you’re born with a chemical imbalance. Often using language that’s more like breaking bad news. Then quickly follow up by recommending SSRIs. Why? Not really their fault. But funding. 15:25 . Here, general practice is assessed by the QUAF, and one metric is the number of prescriptions (or similar measure) So this determines how much funding the government gives a doctors surgery. Hence, they have a motivation to prescribe drugs and the mental health crisis is the perfect tool to throw anti depressants at patients. Even I’ve been recommended them, when my DOG died, but I answered by saying “sorry, with respect I like my libido far too much to consider that option”. None of the very helpful advice you followed with is accessible to patients in the UK and US unless they can pay and find a good psychotherapist. Just finding a good one is hard. The price also excludes the people who desperately need it. 6:53 actually it’s because he’s lived in the UK and US. In the NHS, there are no ‘systemic psychologists’. You’re lucky to access talking therapy. 13:05 proven science? Says the former newspaper editor, and now ‘talks show host’? 8:05 again. I have had that said to me - and I’m a clinical researcher and the doctor knew I had worked with world leading experts in mental health focused on non oharma treatment options. 13:13 or are they verbose/glib? 😊 12:38 read the Lancet series on Physical activity for 50 years of science which supports this. We now move so little, it’s statistically as harmful to society as smoking. Physical inactivity is the pandemic we need to worry about. We move so little is thee third biggest risk factor for chronic disease. 14:05 many of the public do. Few people could tell you the difference between a counsellor or therapist. Again, this is due to lack of resources meaning doctors are rewarded for sending patients away with a script. remember our freeUK healthcare has been something world leading and a reliable British institution for decades. Patients would my grandparents age would consider their GP like gods. But we’ve been watching our precious NHS crumble for nearly 20 years. And now, doctors have ten min slots to identify symptoms, after a treatment plan and they’re told to only address one problem in an appointment. So taking an interdisciplinary approach is impossible. 15:25 again. Our healthcare services reinforce that learned helplessness. The UK and US are worst. Other European countries, after meeting hundreds of clinicians at conferences, have a different attitude. Preventative medicine is underfunded. Over 70% of deaths are caused by diseases resulting from unhealthy lifestyles. And it’s only getting worse. My fight, and a minority of other researchers, is to change this. This is not a defence of Tate or a disagreement with you my good man. In fact we lean toward a similar perspective of health. However, since he’s not a clinician he can’t express these things clinically. So, respectfully, I thought I’d chime in 👍🏼

[@JoeL-xk6bo]

"who said that?" so many people say that. for starters, everybody who actually claims depression is an actual disease.

[@The_UnknownEntity]

Exactly, Andrew wasn't only answering peirs questions he was referring to all the common arguments made by the so called clinically depressed persons. It really annoyed me whenever this guy said " who said that"

[@leftthatbehind6090]

For some people its an actual disease but most of us its situational

[@Colorista496]

Listen guys I am suffering from bipolar disorder type 2.. Andrew tate literally saving my life.. i am off my meds.. because these meds wont cure they can only control and i have to take this medicine lifelong ..FUCK THAT.. i am taking accupuncture treatement and its helping me very much

[@bhalindersingh765]

Hope you recovered😢

[@bakachan3601]

They're talking about two different things. What Piers Morgan means by clinical depression is a disease that perfectly healthy people get that makes them feel that way. Not as a natural normal way of feeling in response to environmental factors And yes here in the United States doctors because of whatever reason push this idea that depression is a disease that you contract as a healthy person that makes you feel those feelings and that you need antidepressants to remedy that

[@Mike1-]

Not every therapist is as good as you there are doctors that will tell you what Andrew it’s saying . I like this reaction 👍🏽

[@corygall2340]

Blaming depression of the masses on individual responsibility neglects the idea that the society/ culture isn't fundamentally broken somehow. I remember Tate said people in the third world experience less depression and to that I would agree a culture that doesn't treat you like an expendable machine that should fall in line would probably manifest as a less depressing experience of life.

[@roman_air]

Isn’t there situational and biochemical depression? My psychiatrist recently told me that there isn’t any medication left to try to fix my depression. Needless to say, it was disheartening.

[@MarcoSanderCoaching]

Did you try Psychotherapy?

[@roman_air]

@@MarcoSanderCoaching Yes, since my adolescence… The technique i am favoring is DBT…

[@SeanBlackAuthor]

I think reactive depression can be a very real thing. I suffered it after the amputation of my leg when I was seventeen. I suspect it was biochemical in nature, because I was dealing extremely well for a period and then BOOM, it was like someone hit my brain with a hammer. At the same time I agree with Marco that oftentimes 'labels' are not helpful because people assume them as an identity.

[@princealmighty5391]

WHAT THE FUCK!!!! QUICKLY CHANGE YOUR PSYCHARITIST

[@denisiorga7368]

Are you homeless? did your child die? do you have cancer? If you don't have this 3 problems you don't have any problem and you have a FAKE depresion! Look at the people in Gaza who don't have food and they are bombed DAILY by Israel army, they don't have depresion!

[@CharlieTangoLaw]

people always blame their "clinically diagnosed depression" when they don't want to do something and emotional incapacity to not be a burden. "oh because I'm clinically diagnosed with depression, I can't do this I can't do that I'm feeling this I'm feeling that, and I don't have any control of anything that I'm feeling and about to do. that is how I sum up all BS people near me blaming everything to a disease they catch from the sky.

[@antwanbonifas7710]

Gotta agree with Andrew. At this point shit just be damage control on the other end. And yes doctors do have this mindset of saying you can't get better unless you take this. Anymore you go to jail you really don't even have rights to say no really to services and plus these services don't help you from my personal experience and things I've witnessed majority of ppl do not get better it's all the same shit. Those services being anything to do with alcohol, anger management ect things I've also attended. What have we seen in the court rooms to the actual jails. They'll threaten you in a court room making harsher sentencing "unless" you go to these treatment programs and they'll even have these treatment organizers show up to the jails where even the guards will become aggressive in making you attend something you don't wanna attend.....

[@user-pl9yq3fc8u]

Great takes, I hope this video reaches more people ignore the toxicity in the comment section

[@KurtDillan]

agreed

[@Mike1-]

Tate is a very inspiration person to listen to . I feel like if you watch more of his videos you would understand his in’s set more clearly .

[@Proposal12]

Depression is the overall term of it. There´s different types of it, which isn´t being addressed and hugely overlooked by both. Depression levels: 1. Severe depression /suicidal 2. Deep depression 3. mild 4 seasonal Now tell someone who has number 1 and 2 , what tate just said and see how that works out. You simply can´t tell someone to hit the gym and it´s "cured".... With mild/seasonal this would more likely work. Depression also isn´t an isolated diagnosis, you can also have extreme anxiety correlated with that. But just tell them to take control... "Clinical depression is a common and serious medical illness that can be effectively treated. The risk of clinical depression is often higher in individuals with serious medical illnesses, such as heart disease, stroke, cancer, and diabetes" - According to tate, go hit the gym and all those issues will go away since you worked on them...Doesn´t work that way, no matter how you try to twist it. People with severe depression, feel so helpless and empty inside that it doesn´t matter what someone says, since it´s a state of mind. And by simply giving someone an anti depressant pill saying here you go and you´ll feel better in 6 weeks, doesn´t work either. Every mass shootings in the US were done by people on anti depressants.... You can fact check everythng i´ve just said and see how full of shit tate actually is, since he hasn´t learned about it or cares to. Tate is very higly narcisstic "control" "power" " self admiration" "Image" "manipulative" etc....

[@DwightKnipschild]

Omg i remembered when we talked in maastricht! Love to see you are making content!

[@MarcoSanderCoaching]

haha remember you, too! Shoot me a DM on IG, I´ll be back in Maastricht in a couple of weeks.

[@ecoffey71]

Depression is genetic?dude are you serious?

[@misfitm1457]

Feeling depressed and actual depression aren't the same thing. I am SICK of people saying about 'labels' ... it is a diagnosis and not a label, if someone has any physical condition you say the diagnosis, not that you won't label them. Having a diagnosis helps people to get help and support and to understand the problem. A diagnosis is empowering. Tate's never been smart, if he doesn't believe depression is an illness who knows what to think ... he'll probably have time to get depressed in jail. Depression can absolutely be cured!

[@Si4koTushxD]

Tate is right and wrong, depending on difference in cognition and brain structure, resilient people can indeed bounce off with the way of thinking he has. Indeed it can help you fight back, but at the same time, there are those that cannot. As you have explained, depression can play on your insecurities, depression plunges you into darkness where you literally cannot feel good about anything that you do. Depression can also hit in another way where it drains your vitality, making you see that everything is pointless in life, which inherently it is, until our personality or needs perhaps give it value. It's a very dangerous take and worst of all, it seems so real that no amount of talk can make you change your view. When I had it, it seemed like nobody loved me and given that love is something I want and crave, if I can't get it and I am not getting it, it became quite real to me that it's impossible to achieve it, because the voice was telling me that it truly is like that. There is also the take where you are greatly disappointed with life in general and how things work. Andrew Tate's words made me reflect, but they do not give me the tools to fight back. It's quite easy to say get better, but it's not so easy to describe how and this is exactly what's the problem with how Andrew Tate suggests it should be dealt with. He has the key, but for people like him, depression cannot be viewed upon as one key opens all doors. Don't get me wrong, but should women get a 6 pack and get a fix that way? There was a very real explanation online on depression that it's basically draining your vitality and energy, if you have no energy and will to live, do you think you will push to the gym and the 6 pack? What if that is not an option and even worse, what if that doesn't fix you, because you don't value your body that much? What if the pillar that supports you is your intellect? In that same explanation there were cases where people were fixing their depression by doing simple tasks, but there were also extremely wealthy, successful people that lose purpose and have no road to walk on.

[@rahuld.2015]

Even the psychologists look like they are Tate's side. So wtf is wrong with Piers Morgan, why tf are people hating Andrew. Its insane how people can hate someone so much

[@Omakhara]

The reason Tate so heavily disagrees with the medical "term" is because alooooot of people nowadays just tell you "i have x, y, z, better learn to deal with it" basically and even if these labels may apply, the correct course of action doesnt change regardless of issue really. And dont even get me started on how most people are just put under drugs in many cases rather than actually changing their life. He is also talking way more about contemporary culture around mental health than psychotherapist and their treatments

[@christianflores1339]

I like Andrew's theory

[@SeanBlackAuthor]

Andrew Tate has some really good insights in some areas. How he talks about women is pretty revolting, and he seems to be extremely naive when it comes to describing things he claims to have done, which he then backpedals on. There's a little bit of Alex Jones 'I was playing a character' syndrome. Also, if you constantly have to talk about your wealth, that comes off as insecure. Extremely wealthy people either keep their mouth shut, or play it down, because flaunting wealth carries serious risk.

[@vee5315]

Love this.

[@antwanbonifas7710]

Last thing I will add is one side is extremely offended. One is not. Why is it such a big deal if a person wants to fix their life problems a more natural way without forms of medication and isn't that a better solution? The correct ways in our minds and isn't that a better long term solution? It all makes sense why one side is so threatened and offended. It hurts their pockets and makes em look like the villans which of course they are. I'm seeing the long term affects of my own mother being on medications. Hand tremors, poor cordination especially driving, very heavy forgetfulness ect and the doctors tend not to care when she'll request to have changes made. Had she done things more naturally it wouldn't be like this. Her mind also being altered. I mean she struggles financially and says always how she wants to go on vacations yet she'll play pull tabs and buy bowls out. Her whole mind is altered, conflicted and confused and might as well be gone because of it.

[@BenyOh]

great analysis , thank you!

[@MarcoSanderCoaching]

you are welcome, BenyOh!

[@ecoffey71]

Sorry dude your wrong.i had therapist telling me I was clinically depressed and loading me up on drugs.Im 52 and I've been through this.Clinical depression is bs.One day I woke up and said enough.in the last 20 years I've gotten really depressed may 3 times tops.After a day of feeling sorry for myself I would say to myself this is enough and snapped out of it

[@jaydunna2645]

Whats a german psychologist? Is it a specialization? how long does it take to become one?

[@rahuld.2015]

Please tell this to Piers Morgan (the interviewer)

[@kirakeynow]

Psychologists will always say Tate is not right because if Tate is right they would lose their jobs ;)

[@user-jh7cq3ct6u]

People need to stop calling everything that's stressful a depression. Situational depression is just stress. Stress over a current financial situation, unknown job or relationship status (insecurity) or loas of a loved one (understandable). But if you don't know about clinical depression, because you don't believe in it, therefore you push that idea away, then don't talk about it. Tate should ONLY be talking about situational "stress" not talking or denying clinical depression.

[@GuyVivet]

Yeah, take responsability that was it, all this time

[@tomk2926]

Being a “psychologist” does not give you any credibility for several reasons: 1) all you did to become a “psychologist” is read a bunch of opinions by mental ill people like Frued - a cocaine addict who wanted to bang his mother and sexualizes children. 2) psychology is NOT a science. Its purely opinionated. There is NO blood test or repeatable controlled experiment you can conduct to accuractly diagnose anyone with a mental condition. The mental conditions themselves are completely made up opinions and groupthink. 3) your world view comes from the opinions of western psychologists. If you study other cultures they have completely different beliefs about mental issues. Since psychology is not a science, there is no way to provide which culture is correct. Finally, you yourself look like you have an eating disorder. You are severely under weight. What’s up with that? Did your mother criticize you a lot as a kid, leading to self hatred and low self esteem, and now you sabotage yourself?

[@vishwapsengar7340]

Woah

[@ryoshusuke2108]

Of course psychologists have to defend their line of work. Without their beloved patients they are worthless.

[@johnk7025]

Yep. It's just another business. Appointments with psychologists is a new thing, after like 1980s it became mainstream. I think it is better to treat emotions with logic, not with more emotions, you end up in a vicious cycle resulting in more appointments.

[@NerdAlert42]

​@@johnk7025psychologists teach you how to manage it and cope with it. And hopefully, overcome it. Sometimes they do use emotions, but sometimes it is logical, like helping you build habits of making lists of smaller goals to make a big task easier

[@publiqueennemy7183]

stop encouraging people to be depressed and lazy.

[@NerdAlert42]

Stop telling suicidal people to be happy and that it's all in their head. Depression is a hormonal imbalance (and I mean clinical depression, not self diagnosed or "I feel depressed today") I want to be able to do everything I used to, but the effort it takes to do anything is monumental. My 50% effort is your 10%. I jog, I try to meditate, even, but it doesn't work. Dopamine levels are fucked. But tell me again how I'm lazy for being unable to consistently put 5 times the effort into every day 😊

[@universalnihi8374]

@@NerdAlert42I bet you live in the US, UK, Canada, or a western country. SMH

[@asurp7173]

​@@NerdAlert42i respect myself and i would never get myself to state of depression

[@osamat4284]

Marco looks like a depressed guy

[@ecoffey71]

No,depression is situational

[@ShivamGupta-wm9xh]

ANDREW TATE LITE

[@shahrilmohd7829]

Andrew himself is a psychiatrist...

[@Benbooka88]

Depression is not real .... There's no .... They controlled you by a lot of thing

[@rafaelzoiodoido9849]

he looks like a geek

[@OneTheBlue]

Your mom looks like a geek.

[@unboxing_girl.]

Neeeeeeeeerd

[@OneTheBlue]

Your mom's a nerd.

[@NerdAlert42]

Tater tot lol

[@ojcolombiano4491]

You sound depress

[@danyweedgrower8985]

the fact that a lot of people wakes up when somebody say certain things is normal that they inspire you.like i can say music saved my life...weed saved my life..and here people yelling like mf because they dont know shxii..depression is real and can be fixed wih help...certainly you dont have cured people from depression ahah magic tate ahahah i cured people ahahah thats a quite a statement here...