Classical Composer reacts to BAND-MAID: THRILL & SHOW THEM (featuring The Warning) | Episode 872

[@Doug.Helvering]

*** Get 40% Off Site-Wide at www.starzycreations.com/doug - Discount Code: DailyDoug40 ***

[@gerardcote8391]

I'm Japan they have a term called Visual Kei...the idea is you have a Visual concept and base your performance and songs based on that image....Band Maid is Visual Kei... Do Versailles Faith and Decision live with English Subtitles... this massive song is mind-blowing bowing.

[@gerardcote8391]

The Warning stated as a pre teen group on KZbin and built a huge following on line so when they put out their first songs of their own they had a massive audience waiting.

[@knavekid]

Both Band-Maid and The Warning are amazing bands. Many fans of both, while loving this collaboration, feel that this song is not truly representative of either band's signature sound. I highly encourage you to explore songs from both bands. You won't be disappointed!

[@Jordan-Ramses]

Love both bands. The collab didn't work imo. I'd rather see The Warning collab with a band that brings something they don't have. Like Atarashii Gakko or Babymetal for dancing. Or Creepy Nuts for rap. Just as an example. Or have Kikuo write them a song. I think maybe Band-Maid shouldn't collab. They kinda have their own thing.

[@scottmcgregor4829]

As much of a maniac that I am, I also love the warning, I am not a fan of them together. Just because they are two wonderful bands, i don't think two amazing bands , I don't think that it means twice amazingness together. Iam not a fan of Band Maid being The warnings backup Band. I would have rather had a first time reaction to From Now On or one of BandMaids instrumental pieces, especially for a classical composer.

[@scottmcgregor4829]

​@@Jordan-RamsesI agree with your points about both bands . Colabs maybe fun for the bands, to my ears ,with these kinds of Colabs both ands sacrifice their individual nuances that mak them unique.

[@UltraHD.7]

​@@Jordan-RamsesIt's a damn awesome song from 2 bands that adore each other, not only some management "construct". If people like you still don't get that and keep complaining you can't be helped. Atarashi Gakko, Babymetal, RAP! my ass!

[@Jordan-Ramses]

@@UltraHD.7 I humbly apologize for liking more than one kind of music. Please forgive me.

[@tomcatt2]

Finally, FINALLY you get a taste of The Warning ! A bottomless rabbit hole of pure Rock of epic proportions !

[@oldmanyeni1663]

I am a jazz and classical woodwind player, and I have fallen in love with both of these bands. I think this collab is great, even if it is not exactly what either band does best. I am pretty convinced that the future of rock is female. If these two bands are where music is going, then I am all in. • The lyrics are a really strong empowering message IMHO • I like that they did not try to do too much, which on one hand makes the music a bit less complex than either band’s other offerings, but it makes it that 8 players can play it and make it clean. It would be really easy to make a big'ol hot mess of this if they all tried to do too much. • The trade-offs really point out to me that each of the instrumentalists are so individually skilled and approach their parts in slightly different ways. No winners or losers. No battle. Just a lovely 4 or 8 beat display of the variety of approaches and talents for a solo section. • It is nice and compact at 3:21. I have seen plenty of collabs over the years which turn into rambling oeuvres that don't go anywhere musically. This one just feels nice and tidy to me. Since this is your first time with The Warning let me extend The Warning Army's welcome to what we believe is the future of rock & roll - The Warning - Three sisters from Monterey Mexico who started playing together when they were children and who have now been making great hard music for more than a decade. With four studio albums, several live concert videos, we think there is plenty of material for you to choose from. They were independent for the first two albums (Kickstarter and crowd-funded), but are now signed to Lava/Republic records. This three-piece is: Daniela (Dany, 24yo, guitar) Paulina (Pau, as in POW-er, 22yo, drums) Alejandra (Ale, pronounced AH-lay, 19yo, bass) All three sisters sing, and all are classically trained on piano. The Warning have a sound that is both new and familiar. It is certainly hard rock, but clearly influenced by their love of classic rock, metal, punk, K-pop, indie, grunge, funk, and many other genres including classical music. But they have taken those influences and forged a sound that is uniquely their own, and you know that it is them. At the same time simple and complex. What does it sound like to me? Refreshing. A sound that has caught my ear and made me interested in rock again after 25+ years of the same old playlist. While together their combined ages are about the same as many of us fans, their musical maturity is exceptionally high. Need another suggestion? From The Warning’s KZbin page you might choose from: - Disciple, Hell You Call a Dream, Z, Dust to Dust/Dull Knives, or Choke or anything else from their 2023 Pepsi Center Live performance - MORE or EVOLVE from the MTV VMAs - S!CK or Automatic Sun live studio performances from either MTV Push or Jimmy Kimmel - The official music video for their new releases Six Feet Deep, S!CK or Que Mas Quieras (in Spanish) - The official music video for XXI CENTURY BLOOD - SURVIVE from their 2017 TedX talk There are really no bad choices. They are something special live-I think it is their super power. Their energy, charisma, and musicality really shine when in front of an audience. In the past two years I have flown >20k miles all over North America, Mexico, UK, and Ireland. Can’t wait for the chance to travel and see them again. The only other band I have traveled for like this in more than 45 years of concert going was Rush.

[@waxonzonesoap3617]

❤✅

[@Hans_Reese]

Great write-up! 🤘🏻😎🤘🏻

[@st.croix5835]

Band=Maid and The Warning are two of the best non-grey -haired bands in the world. I absolutely love both. Kanami from Band-Maid, who wrote Show Them, said she was trying to write a song that took both bands into different territory from what they normally do.

[@satorimystic]

'The Warning' is going to give you a thrill, I guarantee. Their story, from children to rock stars, is an absolutely amazing journey. Their songwriting, musicianship, professionalism, talents, passion, charisma, and their extraordinary sibling dynamic, all blend their magic to make these young women a phenomenon that's going to rock the planet. Their interpolation of 'Enter Sandman' may be the best 'cover' of an epic rock song, ever!! Their entire discography, to date, is immaculately conceived! Heed 'The Warning'!! "The Best Hard Rock Power Trio of the 21st Century."🦉🤟⚡🍩👍⚠⚡💥

[@wrinkledm]

Pun intended, but Band Maid gives you "Thrill"... :)

[@Davey-Boyd]

"Thrill" isn't really their biggest hit, it's just their first MV so has more views as it's the oldest. It did go viral though and saved the band from being dumped by their first label. The best hard rock band I have heard in my 58 years on this planet. While they don't class themselves as a metal band, they don't stick to any one genre and often mix genres in songs. They are extremely diverse and have an extensive back catalogue featuring Punk, Pop-Punk, Hard-Rock, Classic Rock, Metal, Prog, Blues, Jazz, Groove, Rap etc. From face melting 220 bpm punk-prog mayhem to ballads, instrumentals to acoustics they do it all. They can make you headbang, they can make you pogo, they can make you cry like a baby. They are also five of the nicest people in music, without a shred of ego. They are funny and fun and world class musicians to boot. They are currently into their 12th year with the original line up. And they are the best live band I have ever witnessed!

[@tasminoben686]

❤😂 P. O!

[@gaefferson1]

Thrill is their best to me ,love it

[@Phelper99]

Agree.... would not have gone with "Thrill" as the introduction to the band. Would have rather suggested "Real Existence" as the introduction.

[@tinyhato]

Thanks for the Band-Maid reaction. To get a taste of who they are now, I'd like to recommend their instrumental "From Now On".

[@VladimirChupin]

Yes, "from now on" would be interesting to listen to. But as I was watching this reaction, I actually thought about Protect You. I think, compositional-wise, it would be more interesting. "from now on" is also interesting, though. Well, anything from Kanami in the last five years is a master class in composition 🙂

[@simondodd918]

I’m a big fan of The Warning and this collaboration massively turned me on to the Maids.

[@Olkam-w5u]

I would highly recommend getting to know Band-Maid live, this is a band that is even stronger live than on record: 1) BAND-MAID / HATE? (Official Live Video) 2) BAND-MAID / Unleash!!!!! (Official Live Video)

[@ontaka5997]

They are absolutely great live. Another recommendation 3) BAND-MAID / Domination (Official Live Video)

[@VladimirChupin]

@@ontaka5997 Compositional-wise, DOMINATION studio version (with its official MV) would also be great. How Kanami put it all together, and how the Maids implemented it, is amazing. It's a prog metal, really. Although I would be interested to hear what he says about the more recent creations, i.e., the songs from Unseen World, Unleash, or Epic Narratives. "Forbidden Tale" is the most recent and the most amazing song, which will definitely go down through centuries as BAND-MAID's unforgettable legacy.

[@V.F.D.DaleSalvador]

Band-Maid is amazing. The live versions of Domination and One And Only are my favorites. Domination especially cause everyone got a solo. Both had extended parts as well, both are super catchy as well. They have so many different styles of rock/metal they experiment with.

[@septimusseverus7237]

As a classical composer, you should appreciate Band-Maid songs such as "From now on" (instrumental) and "Giovanni" (both instrumental and with lyrics versions).

[@gazzeruk]

At long last. I can die a happy man. Your journey has just begun. You have discovered one of the best rock bands playing. My advice is always go for the live recordings

[@thontor]

Funny this could be said for either band

[@satorimystic]

Heed 'The Warning'!! "The Best Hard Rock Power Trio of the 21st Century."🦉🤟⚡🍩👍⚠⚡💥 'The Warning' KZbin Playlist by Satori has over 1,600+ videos of 'The Warning'!! LIVE! performances, Interviews, Reactions, Tears! ... and 'MORE' :P Link: kzbin.info/aero/PL24jw_18N_TZiAFbRHEFVB6PIhV0mU-Tx&si=RXa9xsXdPnolPDIh

[@stevehall5128]

​@@thontorMy thoughts exactly.

[@Grap3_S0da]

Omg you are finally doing band-maid!

[@jeffersoncosgrove1910]

Right? I'd been suggesting them on Discord for awhile.

[@dylanhamilton7190]

Oooooo, I really hope this means you check out more from Band-Maid soon. They are so good!

[@satorimystic]

Not the best intro to 'The Warning' ... but, you'll bee Warned soon enough, now that you finally got a taste. Enjoy ... I'll look forward to your review of their songwriting, song structure, etc ... awaiting anxiously. Heed 'The Warning'!! "The Best Hard Rock Power Trio of the 21st Century."🦉🤟⚡🍩👍⚠⚡💥 'The Warning' KZbin Playlist by Satori has over 1,600+ videos of 'The Warning'!! LIVE! performances, Interviews, Reactions, Tears! ... and 'MORE' :P Link: kzbin.info/aero/PL24jw_18N_TZiAFbRHEFVB6PIhV0mU-Tx&si=RXa9xsXdPnolPDIh

[@TheMaxzinc]

I've seen the ladies twice now on their last 2 US tours....they are a great group to see live and love their fans. One of the happiest groups out there.

[@sweetmandolynsurbanfarm7188]

The Warning have definitely revived Rock to a new level. They are unlike any band I've seen since the 70s. They are truly incredible ❤⚡️🤘

[@kyles5513]

They sound like a lot of other mainstream rock bands.

[@sweetmandolynsurbanfarm7188]

​@kyles5513 If you're talking about their music, then you've probably not heard much, if at all. I, on the other hand, was talking about them as human beings.❤

[@KabukiKid]

@@sweetmandolynsurbanfarm7188 Indeed... they are not just great performers and artists, they seem to genuinely be sweet individuals.

[@interstellardave]

@@kyles5513I’m not sure about that but, if true, they’re still better than any of those bands they “sound like”. Just like Band Maid is better than the numerous bands that reactors mention when certain things remind them of those bands. Both of these bands are way better than the sum of their parts… or what surface impressions they give off.

[@thontor]

Should you wish to react to some of The Warning's original music, I highly recommend checking out the videos from their 2023 10th anniversary concert in Mexico City. Just start with the opening song, "Disciple." BAND-MAID and The Warning first met at the Aftershock Festival in 2022, and that initial connection really sparked the idea for collaboration. When The Warning traveled to Japan in June, they dove into working on their song "Show Them." KANAMI from BAND-MAID had created a demo, and they engaged in a creative back-and-forth, sharing ideas and refining the song together. They focused on themes of female empowerment and collaboration, making sure to incorporate elements that resonated with both bands. Working face-to-face helped them navigate cultural differences and fine-tune the lyrics until they felt the song captured their collective vision. The energy was palpable, especially when they performed "Show Them" live in Tokyo. Fans were thrilled to see both bands on stage, celebrating this powerful collaboration. There’s also an excellent vlog on The Warning's channel that shows their meeting in Japan and the behind-the-scenes work on the song. It really captures the excitement and camaraderie between the bands during the process.

[@XenosKB]

Definitely will need to check out more Band-Maid. I think as a composer you will be very impressed with Kanami’s compositions. Check out Blooming or their latest video Forbidden Tale to see how they’ve evolved since Thrill!

[@artomatt]

I was thinking of recommending those two songs also. It's only unfortunate that they don't have live versions on their channel, 'cause I'd like Doug to see how good they are live.

[@philbrowning1187]

Great stuff Doug! I’ve been hoping for a long time that you’d feature Band-Maid, who I’m utterly obsessed with. I would suggest you try a live performance next time, that will definitely blow your mind. I’m a Rush, Yes, Punk Floyd fan, but these girls have taken me like a whirl wind.

[@jeffersoncosgrove1910]

BAND MAID!!! Finally. We thought our requests would forever be shot down by The Don, but it looks like something made it though.

[@bobespirit2112]

Now maybe we can finally get Elizabeth of The Charismatic Voice to checkout the Maids…!! 🤷🏻‍♂️🙏😀

[@jeffersoncosgrove1910]

Yes. ​@@bobespirit2112

[@nussekuddenxxx6564]

"Trill" was their first video ever and not written by them. The first one they wrote themselves is a masterpiece called "Alone". After that, their label had objection to let them compose and arrange everything. "Show Them" is an extremely simple song for both bands, but that was the point. They had not much time before recording it and play it live. Now you MUST try their latest video "Forbidden Tail", where they give other band a lesson in how to write a song. Kanami, who write almost all their songs, only listened to classic music when she grew up. You can hear that in their instrumental "From Now On".

[@tehawfulestface1337]

The three sisters that make up The Warning were all classically trained when they were still tiny little kids. They went viral when they were 9, 12 and 14 years old, when they did a cover of Metallica’s Enter Sandman for their grandparents. Seen by over 22 million which included Metallica themselves. As grown ups and veterans of live performances, Metallica invited The Warning to rework Enter Sandman with Canadian singer Alessia Cara for the Blacklist album. At the concert at the Pepsi Center The Warning have looked back at their classical training and have reworked Enter Sandman further. They performed Enter Sandman accompanied by the string section of an orchestra.

[@JehanLSZABO]

You just opemn the door to one of the most creative, talented and fun band today. Band Maid ranges from old classic rock with Manners to very fast pace anime OFT, Shamble and Protect You. Don't hesitate to listen for the instrumental to grasp the extend of their skills.

[@Big_Al_63]

You want a current example of what BAND-MAID does......Forbidden Tale.

[@RogerChance5309]

Band Maid! 🍺😁🤘🏻🕊️

[@barrycounts490]

I requested Band-Maid to Doug over two years ago but it wasn't Thrill 😎🍺✌

[@bandmaidfanATL]

Since you are a classical composer, I suggest "From Now On." It is an instrumental, and is basically a Requiem. Secondly, for a really interesting composition, try "Black Hole." And their newest song and video, "Forbidden Tale" is a really nice composition.

[@josephbel7532]

The Warning, considered by many to be the best three-piece rock band today.

[@stevehall5128]

And MV-wise, I think it's cool that the "guest" band gets highlighted with the glamour non-performance shots. Like, the 'Maids are encouraging their fans to get to know the Warning too 😊

[@philproffitt8363]

Yeah, the outside shots welcoming them to Tokyo are nice 👍

[@jasonremy1627]

These two bands are amazing and you've GOT to check out the Warning by themselves. I recommend "Hell You Call A Dream". The live version from the Pepsi Center is the best one.

[@tomcatt2]

The Warning ….Dany 24, Paulina 21 and Ale 19 are a phenomenal band and incredible live show .They have been playing together for 10 years and went viral playing a cover of Enter Sandman when Ale was 8. ! ( Even Metallica noticed and commented) They even invited them to do a full remake of the song for their 30th anniversary Blacklist album which is a video ( or live version) you must see. I’m 68 years old and I have seen them all. They broke me out of my classic rock bubble and I can honestly say ( and I don’t make this comment lightly) they are one of my 3 top bands…ever ! 4 albums and not a bad song on them. That just doesn’t happen. I understand you can’t react to everything but if nothing else look into thier history and thier journey on your own . It is fascinating. Enjoy the ride.

[@scottbradley6953]

Hiya 👋 Paulina is 22! ❤ 💖🐺

[@tomcatt2]

@ yes… realized it after I sent it but ( might’ve been 21 during this performance?!?) lol

[@ArtCatramboneJr]

Yep I’m 65 and the Warning is one of my favorite bands!!!! But I could put a list of at least 10 new bands I’m into now. A lot of really good music out there….."🎶😎🎼

[@charleswharmbyiii8401]

Now you must react to the Warning's performance at the 2023 MTV VMAs of the song "Evolve." By the way, i saw these two bands oerform this in Tokyo. The song is fine as is.

[@davidgilman3230]

Thanks for the reaction Doug. I think you are one of the few reactors who can break down Band Maid's BLACKHOLE without having your brain explode.

[@johnfridye]

I personally liked that that they had short sections that focused on the 2 bass players, the 2 guitarists, the 2 drummers, and finally the 2 vocalists. everyone had their moments to shine.

[@jeffersoncosgrove1910]

You mentioned a coda. Many Band Maid songs do have a coda, even a lyrical one. This was just an exception.

[@stevehall5128]

Shoot, in "Forbidden Tale" the coda's coda has a coda.

[@jin30-573]

🔥BAND-MAID🔥 リアクションありがとうございます🕊日本からご挨拶🤘

[@ricklagasca8196]

Sub'd for The Warning reactions. Playing live is their Super Power

[@sb859]

FINALLY! You can enjoy The Warning, and The Warning Army will invade your channel! Evolve, live at MTV awards, then Dust To Dust/Dull Knives, live at Pepsi Center. I’ve been waiting for this for SO long! These ladies are Unicorns. Welcome to the Hottest band on the planet, Doug.

[@Robertsmith-dy3sh]

So happy you finally got a taste of The Warning! I hope you continue down their amazing rabbit hole, you will not be disappointed!

[@matthew-1710]

bandmaid is a name I haven't heard in a long long time, glad to see they're still around

[@crabuki1273]

They've just kept getting better, honestly.

[@bobespirit2112]

Oh, they are nothing like they used to be - except more and more awesome. They’ve grown incredibly as musicians. They did actually play Lalapalooza in 2023. You really must check out their more recent works. I’m confident you’ll be blown away.

[@Ytf2024]

Living under a rock?

[@matthew-1710]

@@Ytf2024 Me?

[@hoges412]

Hi Doug, to see how far Band-Maid have come in 10 years, please check out a live performance from their 10th anniversary show at Yokohama Arena in late 2023. There are good quality recordings on their official channel, try Don't You Tell Me or Hate? for a showcase performance. The collab with The Warning was a nice treat for fans of both bands, but it's worth checking out Band-Maid in their own right now they are on top of their game, and especially their epic live performances. Cheers from Australia. 🇦🇺

[@riri9195]

I've been watching your channel for 2 years, and was eagerly awaiting this moment! Next, i would suggest Forbidden Tale, their latest MV, and From Now On, an instrumental which also has an MV. I recommend this because you're a composer, and these 2 are arguably their best compositions!

[@greylocke100]

Doug, I suggest when you dive deeper into Band-Maid's discography, you choose 2 songs, one old, one new and listen and compare them. Their first 3 releases with 1 exception were not written by them. It took that one exception, "Alone" performing well, for them to take over the writing, arranging and producing of their music. In fact, they recently have also taken over their own management, become as independent as possible other than the record label. They have done this so that they can control their music, their image, and be more in control of their PR, versus a management company trying to "Steer" the Ladies where they did NOT want to go. They have on occasion used outside writers, but the vast majority of their songs from their album "Just Bring It"" on have been written almost exclusively by them. Kanami Tono, the lead guitarist is the Primary composer, and Miku Kobato is the Primary Lyricist, although Saiki Atsumi has written lyrics for several songs now. Kanami will write and create a Demo, she will then send to MISA and Akane for them to work in their parts, which they send back to Kanami to mix together. Miku and Saiki will then work on lyrics, and the ones that fit the best will be chosen. And if you would like to hear an example of a Band-Maid song where the unfinished Demo was used for the final product, their song "The Dragon Cries", is such a song. Tony Visconti approached the Ladies of Band-Maid, wanting to work on a song with them. Kanami sent over a rough demo she had been working on, and Tony used it as it was. Kanami asked if she could finish it, but Tony reportedly said, it was finished, and then using lyrics by Tom Kenney, Saiki and Miku traveled to New York and spent several days in the studio recording their vocals. Tony said afterward that both Saiki and Miku sang for 8+ hours a day and never had any issues. Saying all that though. Many of us Band-Maid fans, or "Maidiacs" as we refer to ourselves as, feel that the song on the album is too overly compressed, and many of us prefer the live version from their Line Cube Shibuya performance in February 2020. It just sounds so much better.

[@DougguoD]

Oh on Alone being their break out song written by Kamami - from the internet (well KZbin, here) I'd heard it was this 1st one played, Thrill 👀

[@normanweaver7935]

@@DougguoD Thrill was their 'breakout' song in that the band wasn't getting much traction at home. It's a B-side, written by a hired gun, and was chosen to be their first MV by the band over the single that the label wanted (a very different song, stylistically). The video was shared on a facebook page and got the kind of response any fledgling band would dream of. This actually saved the band from being dropped by the label. Alone was the first song, among many that Kanami wrote and submitted for approval, that actually got the green light from the label. As Greylocke writes above, they've had control of their own direction since then

[@DougguoD]

@@normanweaver7935 Yeah, did watch a doc saying MISA almost quit, and this song Thrill did save them. Looking, I see Kentarō Akutsu wrote the song Thrill.

[@RA57727]

Doug, thank you sir for your comments and reaction to Band-Maid with their friends The Warning. Interesting thing about both bands. They are classically trained musicians. The lead guitarist for Band-Maid Kanami Tono (musical composer for Band-Maid) is a classically trained pianist and listened to only classical music growing up and was influenced by Chopin. You’ll find that both Band-Maid and The Warning have a large and active fan base who are very supportive. I’ve twisted your ear long enough thank you again I’ve been looking forward to this day.

[@donpark8316]

Love The Warning, watching them grow up and hearing their progression in their art was a pretty inspirational thing to witness. I think my favorite from The Warning is the song "When I'm Alone". I think Daniella wrote the song when she was just 17 and gives such a real insight to the illness of depression. Both Band-Maid and the Warning are incredible in their live shows. Check out both bands live performances.

[@ArcaneWolf9]

HATE? (Official Live Video) is a banger from their 10 year anniversary show. Non-stop energy and a rousing bass / guitar duel that works perfectly in a song about a relationship full of conflict and dissatisfaction.

[@pulp-tx6lq]

This is very old Band Maid. I would love for you to listen a newer solo MV of theirs, such as Forbidden tale or Protect you. They are an incredible band. Rock on 🤘

[@atlasisshrugging]

Thanks so much for delving into Band-Maid! You'll really enjoy their music from a composer's perspective; unique and complex for this style of rock. (By the way, thanks also for introducing me to Laphroaig single malt scotch. I FINALLY picked up a bottle of 10 year about a month ago. Aaaand then a bottle of Ardbeg last week because, apparently, Islay single malt Scotch is my thing.) 😁🥃

[@k3w1b3an5]

Thank you for reacting to Band-Maid. Saw them live twice last year on their US tour.

[@remembertomorrow6737]

You will love The Warning. What a journey they are.

[@ku1965view]

Glad you discovered and enjoyed these bands. I’m looking forward to more reactions to them both. 🤘🤘🤘🔥🔥🔥

[@Parker--]

You haven’t experienced Band-Maid until you’ve heard what they do live. I highly suggest HATE and Domination official live (not the mv). Those really show their best talents. I’d say these are some of their simplest songs, but don’t worry, their pop sensibilities persist through all their songs. Best band this short century. After over a decade of cynicism towards new music they made me love music again in 2021. Keep listening, you’ll learn your favorite will be the last song you heard.

[@WilliamCoyle-ll6bq]

Yes live is the way to view these maids

[@philproffitt8363]

​@@WilliamCoyle-ll6bqMaids naturally live to serve 👌🥳😁🤘

[@stevemeddaugh2003]

So glad to FINALLY see The Warning on your channel! I've waited a long time for you to check them out. I hope you will listen to more of them - it's a deep rabbit hole but the great part is, you can pick pretty much any song to react to and it will be a winner. TWA (The Warning Army) will tell you live performances are better and with only a couple exceptions, I'd say that's true. Also, they are more of a straight-up rock band than metal (ie you don't have to save them just for Metal Monday 😎). You have finally been warned!

[@daicullinane7746]

Doug, how about checking out Puzzle by Band-Maid.

[@MichaelRees1969]

​​Will be intrested to see what you think of Forbidden Tale by band maid their latest video loads of switches in it. And The warnings version of enter sandman

[@TomClark-Futoura]

There's so much that can be said about The Warning and their massive impact on the international music scene. But since you are learning more about the Maids, here's my intro blurb for those who may be new to Band-Maid: Welcome, Doug. You are embarking on (along with many others - over 210 million views just on their official YT channel, plus over 40 million reactor plays!) an awesome, progressive, hard-rock journey with 5 incredible women. BAND-MAID’s songs and sound beat with the heart and soul of all rockers. But you’ll also hear heavy influences of Prog, Punk, Metal and Pop, with nice touches of Blues, Jazz, Funk and Grunge. Sometimes they use multiple genres within the same song. Their Composition, Execution, Joy of Playing, Consistency (144 songs), Uniqueness, Charisma, Charm and, oh yeah, Cuteness factor, position them as becoming the hard rock Beatles of our time! In other words, they’re destined for mega-stardom. Each member's personalities are super interesting and their musicianship among the best. Their writing, arrangements and overall sound, especially guitar tones and drums, are kick-ass! Having seen them LIVE, I can honestly say their performance, sound, stage appearance, and band synergy is off-the-rails spectacular! Band-Maid is the only band in decades where I love nearly EVERY song they’ve done. I have over 80 favorites! "Thrill" (2014) is a great place to start: kzbin.info/www/bejne/i5XWaJppgpJnorM Their songs from albums Unleash, Unseen World, Conqueror, World Domination, Just Bring It, Brand New Maid, and New Beginning drive even more - Hate?, Shambles, Influencer, Warning, No God, Different, Black Hole, Rinne, Blooming, Moratorium, Domination, Clang, Dice, Spirit, Don’t You Tell Me, Turn Me On, Fate, Play, You, Hide-And-Seek, Secret My Lips, Puzzle, Choose Me, I Can’t Live Without You, and on and on. But don’t miss out on their powerful, beautifully written, mid-tempo songs like Daydreaming, The One, Bestie, About Us, Memorable, Anemone, Endless Story, PAGE, At The Drop Of A Hat, Mirage and Smile... or more punky like After Life, Don’t Let Me Down and Screaming… or funky like Bubble… or bluesy like Manners and The Dragon Cries… or poppy like Start Over… or a bit jazzy like Wonderland… or progressive like No God, Giovanni, and Black Hole… or cultural like the Band-Maiko series… or instrumentals like From Now On, Don’t Be Long, Onset, Without Holding Back and Going Nuts… or their many acoustic versions like Catharsis and Sayonakidori... and last but not least, their Anime hits (AniMaid) like Protect You, Sense, Different, Glory and Unleash!!!!! (from their own Anime MV (series?)): kzbin.info/www/bejne/bX2lkHiGiJlrfqc) And many songs are represented with over 50 well produced music videos. kzbin.info Most performances should be experienced from their LIVE audience & online OKYUJI concerts:  2023 Yokohama 10th Year Anniversary Concert “Endless Story” kzbin.info/www/bejne/kJKUqmCIh7uXbZI  ONLINE OKYU-JI (Feb. 11, 2021) “No God” kzbin.info/www/bejne/pHLHiKF_h896l80  Tokyo's LINE CUBE SHIBUYA (February 14, 2020) “Domination” kzbin.info/www/bejne/h5PcgnaAo5ulj8k  ZEPP 2018 “Real Existence” kzbin.info/www/bejne/Y6K0n35_gbdoq5I  Shinkiba Studio Coast 2017 and other full concerts are on bandmaidprime.tokyo, bili, and official Band-Maid’s DVD/BD/CD. And some of the better quality fan videos are excellent.  Shot by Pat McKee from their 2023 US tour concert in Detroit: kzbin.info/www/bejne/epjbhmCDi8-nl5I  See the Maids 2023 Rockville Festival’s short-set perfection performance: kzbin.info/www/bejne/rJu9nIGbpKygnsU  Great photo collage with older classic songs from P in D: www.youtube.com/@PinD-PANIC If you like Band-Maid, make sure to support them by purchasing some concert tickets, live streams, CD, DVD/BD & merch, etc. bandmaid.tokyo Like most Band-Maid songs, I like them from the get-go but really start to appreciate them after more hearings and seeing their LIVE videos. I'll go back and see an older song like YOLO, Order, Shake That, Freezer, Don’t Let Me Down, Before Yesterday, Real Existence, Non Fiction Days and Alone, etc. and realize there's no band that can consistently construct and play like Band-Maid. For fun, check out:  "Mega Band-Maid Mix" by DJ Ray of some of their earlier stuff: facebook.com/djrayboston/videos/1004709499579009  Band-Maid MIDI covers: www.youtube.com/@DeanF_MIDI  Reimagined compositions of Band-Maid songs: www.youtube.com/@fxdxmusic Band-Maid Members: Saiki Atsumi (Sy-i-Key or Psyche) “StarQueen" - Lead vocals, arrangements and melodies. At 30 and the youngest, “Sensei” (Teacher) as band members call her, has the last word on many musical decisions. High-heels or sneakers, Sai-chan’s smile melts away her sometimes perceived, coldish persona. Saiki’s powerhouse performances, charisma, and voice focus the experience that’s driven her to the top echelon of hard rock frontwomen... or frontmen! Miku Kobato (Me-Ku) "Small Pigeon" - Rhythm guitar, vocals, lyricist, 33 years old. “Koba”, as Saiki calls her, is the Band founder and a firecracker MC & PR SpokesPigeon, po! Her “Magic Spell Time” charm and energy ignite the room. Kuruppo! No, no, no… KURUPPO!! Kanami Tono (Ka-Na-Me) “Princess” - Lead guitar, keyboards, 33 years old, is a prolific writer of most Band-Maid material. Kanami (translates “Song Wave”) is a possessed riff-slayer who’s so damn adorable it hurts. The only thing you want from Mincho is more! Akane Hirose (A-Ka-Nay) "Gorilla" - Drums, 33 years old, band energizer & co-clown with MISA. Achi’s talents include massive consumption of noodles and bananas, of course, (even during performance!) while revolutionizing rock drumming with relentless drive, dynamics and the kick. This “DrumZilla” is the Party! MISA (Me-Sa) "Barefoot Assassin" - Bass, 32 years old. An alluring free spirit driving her 5-string to rapturous low-ends while pulling off surprising counter leads with Kanami, off-stage MISA is the band’s goofball ballerina. Sometimes seen as the Mysterious One because she lets her instrument do the talking, the Assassin literally kills it… every note... uniting Band-Maid’s world-class rhythm section. A slug of JB, a slight grin, and let the slappin’ begin… MISA! MISA! MISA! Maidiacs (Maid-e-acts) - Band-Maid’s crazed yet supportive, knowledgeable and loyal Super Fans. [BAND-MAID NEWS]  BAND-MAID PRIME - Special Video Distribution Website. Along with nearly 50 great play-through’s by each member, concerts and skits, Band-Maid management / label(s) have included the Acoustic Christmas 2021, ZEPP 2018 and Shinkiba Studio Coast 2017 concerts! Fans can now see more than 50 great live performances with awesome audio, etc. like Fate, I Can't Live Without You and the great MISA / Kanami exchange in Don't You Tell Me. Those concerts are two of the best produced & performed concerts ever recorded, IMO. bandmaidprime.tokyo  The Maids SOLD OUT 2023 US & Mexico tour wrapped up and was a fantastic success. And so many great live fancams to watch! Their playing and antics were as fresh and fun to experience from first show to last. BRAVO Band-Maid!!!!! In addition, their Japan tour finished up with 13 concerts. Their 10th Anniversary Tour concluded at Japan’s 17,000 seat Yokohama Arena on Nov. 26, 2023 and in Hong Kong Dec. 21! And their latest 10TH ANNIVERSARY TOUR SPIN OFF concert at KT ZEPP YOKOHAMA on February 22, 2024, where they played songs not performed at the 10th anniversary tour final at Yokohama Arena, was SOLD OUT, as usual!  📢 Recent Announcements 📢 -- The Warning, a world-famous band from Mexico, and BAND-MAID recently completed their amazing 2-man, collab concert in Japan with the introduction of their new song and OMV, “Show Them.” -- BAND-MAID released a new OMV, "Forbidden Tales," from their new album "Epic Narratives" that dropped Sept. 25, 2024. It contains 14 songs: Memorable, Shambles, Bestie, Protect You, SHOW THEM (BAND-MAID with The Warning), Toi et Moi, Magie, Forbidden Tale, Go Easy, Brightest Star, The One, Letters To You, TAMAYA!, and Get To The Top. Order now at CDJapan for bonuses. [OKYUJI] Nov. 25 BAND-MAID ZEPP TOUR 2024 TOKYO　Ticket Lottery Advance until Aug 12 Nov. 26 BAND-MAID ZEPP TOUR 2024 TOKYO　Ticket Lottery Advance until Aug 12 The Maids are one of the hardest working supergroups in the business! Their music, their sound, each of the Maids, and the love that permeates their live events is an experience not to be missed. Hope you can catch them LIVE!

[@artomatt]

I'm so happy you got around to Band-Maid (and the Warning)! Personally, I don't put either of these two songs in my top 75 B-M songs. Both songs are kind of on the simple side for the group. Both bands really excel in songwriting, though I don't think of either as "metal". Do more reactions to both, please. You won't be disappointed! It may interest you to know that Kanami Tono, Band-Maid's primary composer (as opposed to lyrics writer) studied classical piano and listened mostly to classical music before she took up electric guitar in high school. Early on, Band-Maids songs were written by outside songwriters, but once Kanami developed her writing chops to the satisfaction of their management company, she was off to the races and has become my favorite rock song composer of the last 40 years. Please listen to Band-Maid's "No God", official live version.

[@mikew1991YJ]

The Warning!! 🔥 🤘 and Band-Maid!! 🔥🤘

[@christophersimpson9245]

Doug, you have to delve deep into The Warning who are taking the world by storm and are one of the best live bands I`ve ever seen in all my 50 years of watching live music, they just had a number one album in the UK with their fourth album Keep Me Fed.

[@AncientGranules]

Glad you did The Warning as well, I love them!

[@massimilianovincioni1153]

First off, I’ve been following your channel nearly from the start, and I absolutely love what you do. I’ve been looking forward to this moment for so long. I’m 53, and I’ve been a rock music fan since I was 8. My first album? The Wall by Pink Floyd-an amazing introduction to a lifelong journey with music. Pink Floyd has always been a favorite, but in 1987, I discovered RUSH, and they became my band, the one that shaped my coming of age. When RUSH retired, it left a real emptiness. Then, something unexpected happened: I fell in love, as never before, with BAND-MAID. Their music is now a daily part of my life; it just makes everything better. Interestingly, I’ve found that most BAND-MAID fans are also RUSH fans. What could three Canadians and five women from Japan possibly have in common? Both bands have built their success with integrity, just as RUSH did. RUSH’s connection with fans was always profound. They constantly pushed themselves as musicians and consistently delivered electrifying performances. BAND-MAID embodies that same spirit. Both bands respect their fans deeply, yet they remain committed to making music for themselves, not simply catering to expectations. True artistry, after all, comes from personal expression-not from trying to please an audience. And in both bands, you see a refreshing lack of ego or showboating; they’re friends who genuinely enjoy making music together. Yes, BAND-MAID filled that hole in my heart. As for song recommendations, it’s hard to choose. BAND-MAID isn’t exactly metal, nor pure hard rock. Especially in their recent material, they blend so many styles, creating a genre that’s uniquely theirs. It’s fresh but still honors rock’s roots. And live, they’re something else-just like RUSH. How many good songs do they have? In their last two tours, they played a total of 70 different songs. When’s the last time you saw another band do that? At one of their recent shows, they performed their entire new album live-14 songs in one go. Incredible. Here are my top recommendations to get you hooked: "Puzzle" (live) "Forbidden Tale" (MV) "Hate?" (live) "From Now On" (MV) "Daydreaming" (MV) "Manners/Black Hole" (live) Much love and respect from Roma, Italia. Ps The Warning are one of my favourites at the moment as well. They are well worthy of an extended check.

[@CutlassSupreme455]

Thanks for this one! So many suggestions for both bands!

[@MTH58]

Thanks for reacting to both Bands. Here’s a few notable things about the Ladies of The Warning. 19 year old Alejandra is a Featured Artist for Spector Bass. And has her own Signature Bass. 22 year old Paulina ( Pau = POW) is both a Sabian and DW Drums Artist, Winner of Drumeo’s Best Rock Drummer 2023 Award. Winner of the Best Up and Coming Drummer Award from Modern Drummer Magazine, And Included in Forbes Magazine’s list of the 100 “ Most Powerful” Women in Mexico. 24 year old Daniella has been personally gifted Custom guitars from two of her Idols, Lzzy Hale of Halestorm and Matt Bellamy of Muse. Though they were independent for years, they have now become the 1st Latin American Rock Band to sign with a major US Label ( Lava/Republic). Their Spanish song “ Que Mas Quieres” is up for a Latin Grammy next week and they are performing at the European MTV Video Music Awards in Manchester on Nov 15th. Not bad for 19-24 year olds!!

[@toxeus_sbor]

Great reaction! Thanks for checking out our ladies! You really should pay attention to both bands. They are definitely worth it. These 2 songs are not really representative of Band-Maid. Their music is usually more complex, energetic and progressive. I hope you will continue to explore these bands. Peace! 🤘

[@vdctube8966]

Kanami (Band Maid guitarist) is a genious composer, but you haven't seen anything yet because Thrill is an early song from the band, which is the era where someone else wrote it. As for Show them, even though the band wrote it themselves, it was a composition that balanced the music between the two bands. I'm glad that you will continue to follow Band Maid. I recommend that the next song should be Forbidden Tale, where you will clearly see the band's songwriting skills.

[@jan-ovepedersen5764]

I'm happy to see you feature Band-Maid. I hope you will contine to do so going forward. Band-Maid have released more then 100 original songs composed by themselves. I've seen them play live 4 times, and they are just amazing in any way. You may react to anything from their 11 year career so far. I would suggest that you react to Forbidden Tale from their latest album Epic Narratives. From Now On from (instrumental) the EP Unleashed. Manners from the album Unseen World. Wonderland from the album Conqueror. I can't live without you from the album World Domination, just to name a few. I subscribed to your channel as well, your reaction videos are great, I've seen a lot of them over the years 🙂You said it, MISA in Band-Maid plays solo on her bass, many Band-Maid songs feature bass solos 🙂

[@jan-ovepedersen5764]

Another thing with Band-Maid is the variety of styles they blend into their base hardrock/metal music. Because of that their music is always fresh and interesting to listen to. Kanami Tono, the guitar player, is a genius composter in IMHO, she plays the piano as well which may be the reason she compose music the way she does.

[@Grap3_S0da]

Also Doug I hope you do more because they have so many good songs. Also as I'm sure other Maidiacs will tell you their lives are actually better than their recorded works.

[@knavekid]

I caution you that if you contemplate reacting to The Warning's most popular song on KZbin, it is from 10 years ago when they played a cover of Metallica's Enter Sandman at 14, 12, and 9 years old. While a worthwhile look at their origin, a better first reaction would be something from their more recent Pepsi Center CDMX concert. I'm sure "The Warning Army" will make several great song recommendations!

[@MrDportjoe]

The closing bass is from the Warning song Survive.

[@stephenriggs8177]

In some regards, I'd say you've yet to hear a Band-Maid song. Thrill was written before the ladies realized that they could write their own material. (Miku does most of the vocals, now, though Saiki sometimes writes them, too. Kanami does the music and arrangements, with input from the other instrumentalists.) Miku and Kanami wrote this one in collaboration with The Warning, whom they had met stateside, at a U.S. festival. They got together when The Warning was touring Japan, ate lots of food, and created this song. Kanami intentionally wrote it a bit high for both vocalists. She's like a teacher who's always looking to push her students to new heights. They debuted it at a concert they performed together. In fact, most of us heard the live version before hearing the album version. The Warning are pretty much native English speakers, as well as speaking Spanish and French, so they helped Saiki with her pronunciations. (Miku and Kanami are dedicated English students, but they can still be tough to understand, sometimes.) Both bands are fabulous, and I'm shocked you've never reacted to either, before. The Warning is straight, in your face, rock, whereas Band-Maid is a bit more technical and nuanced. Both have a keen focus on melody.

[@spaceknave]

If you’re concentrating on composition, you’ll love The Warning. They’ve been composing incredible songs since they were kids.

[@dougel4709]

We need to get him to do the entire QOTMS!! ⚡🤘😛🤘⚡

[@spaceknave]

@@dougel4709Doug is not likely to ever return to The Warning. He has never shown any interest and is just too busy.

[@sebrina8057]

I've been waiting for you to discover The Warning! Strap on your helmet, this rabbit hole is deep!

[@jjo154]

On "Show Them", Kanami wrote it to push both Saiki and Dany into a higher register than both were used to. Saiki called her a sadist for doing so. 😆 Glad you enjoyed both songs, but you really need to check out live songs from both bands.

[@jamie4993]

This is a pleasant surprise! And something to look forward to, the rabbit hole of talented Japanese bands is vaaaaasttttt. Should you choose to meander down it in the future.

[@johnnymiller3684]

As a composer, you might really appreciate and enjoy much of The Warning's catalog, particularly some of their older stuff (when they were teenagers). Their music and lyric writing is second to none. I'm not a composer, but I am a percussion and vocal major, and I can tell you that their music has a lot of cool twists and turns to it. Fun stuff!

[@gorddunbar7453]

For "Show Them," both lead singers were an octave above where they usually sing in order to match their styles better - and to bring a edgier sound. This collab took place over the internet and they only had a week to pull it together for their one and only public performance and the video - all through translators. Nevertheless, both bands like and enjoy each other.

[@Janokins]

After a long day, this is just what I needed :D You've gotta check out some of The Warning's solo songs, but massive respect to whoever mixed Show Them, that can't have been easy

[@HyperArcadeSystems]

The warning came to Japan to collab for this song and banged it out in about a weeks time.

[@kennylingus4595]

You MUST react to as many The Warning videos as you can. I promise you won't be disappointed - I found this band 9 months ago and have listened to nothing else since. I am a huge Rush and Ronnie James Dio fan, and in this short time these young ladies now accompany them as part of my top three artists of all time. They are amazing!!!

[@dougel4709]

totally agree!! ⚡🤘😛🤘⚡

[@davidtooke5964]

Definitely check out the Warning.

[@mickyhierro3901]

They are rock and roll guardian angels and the best hard rock band on this planet🤘Keep an eye on them!!

[@construccionyavancesadecvc5554]

in the case of the Warning band you're barely scratching the surface of 11 years of authentic pure rock and incredible lyrical and musical talent, you'll be surprised. Personally, what surprises me most about these girls (the warning) is the lyrics of their songs, since they were kids doing it, their presence, their live performance and their ability to play many instruments is the envelope of what is truly valuable about these girls. And this is said by someone who has been listening music of all kinds for many, many, many years.

[@figuerio1]

!!!GOODISM¡¡¡ BAND-MAID + The Warning is 100% ‍‍🔥 !!!🎵Ole Ole Ole Oleeee Warning/BAND-MAID🎵¡¡¡. Greetings from Argentina.

[@wilmac1]

Welcome to Band-Maid! You won’t be disappointed. Thrill is one of my favorites!

[@sweetmandolynsurbanfarm7188]

Show them was only supposed to be a collaboration video period. The Warning went to Toyko for a few days to do a quick tour with them and just have fun with exposure in Japan with their new friends from Band-Maid.

[@thomasalbrecht5914]

The little bass figure in the end is a little bow on behalf of Misa to her fellow bass player Ale. Alejandra wrote this bass line for an early Warning song when she was around 13 years old (yes, The Warning started early, they went viral with a Metallica cover when they were 14, 12 and 9, and the year after, they were writing their own music, and their second album was already a concept album. Just so you know you need to do more of The Warning, too). “Show them” was a 50-50 collab, but Kanami, who writes Band-Maids songs, had first serve.

[@TlanImass]

Oh mate… you’re a classical composer? Have to listen to Band-Maid Instrumentals and Progressive songs is my suggestion. From Now On has a music video and Giovanni has an album version (w/ vocals) and an Instrumental version.

[@p.ayebasco6645]

Have been waiting for this one to come!

[@zodak9999b]

I highly recommend live videos of either of these two great bands. Both have plenty on their official channels.

[@ontaka5997]

BAND-MAID is absolutely great live. If you ever happen to react or just listen to their music again, I recommend "BAND-MAID / HATE? (Official Live Video)", and BAND-MAID / DOMINATION (Official Live Video).

[@flugelhornoldman1362]

Welcome & thanks from Japan 有難う💛。I witnessed the live debut of "Show Them" 😍 that was played together (once and only to date) as the encore & finale of the special concert by Band-Maid & The Warning on June 12 in Tokyo . My seat was located on the 2nd floor but in the center meaning in front of the two drummers. I was in bliss! It looked to me that Paulina and Akane literally and happily competed like a duel to see which drummer can kick harder enough to break their bass drum in the joint performance. 🤣 Band-Maid is one of the best bands in our country, especially in live performance. We say "Japan is the country obsessed by Rock Music". The history is very long and the obsession started in 1966 when Beatles visited Japan and held 5 concerts at Budokan. Speaking of hard rock / heavy metal music, a number of bands started to come to Japan since as early as 1970s : Led Zeppelin / Grand Funk Railroad (1971), Deep Purple (1972), Queen (1975), Kiss (1977), Cheap Trick / Van Halen / Scorpions (1978), Judas Priest (1978/79) and so on. Now, any type of rock can be enjoyed here, especially by many all-female or women-fronted bands. They are daughters of American / European rock, for sure. (Many are grand-daughters in terms of age.) Uh-oh, we also say "Japan is the country obsessed by Jazz". It had started earlier than rock 😄

[@chrisegbertky]

The ending bass tag is a homage by MISA of a bass phrase by Ale' of The Warning. Both bands have been fans of each other for years. BANDMAID is the greatest proper rock and roll band of the 21st century IMHO. It's a crazy statement. Was Mozart the world's greatest composer of his era? He'll yeah! The farther we get away from that time the more clearly we see the immensity of his talent. Few would argue with the above assessment. Everytime I write "IMHO" after BandMaid is the greatest proper rock and roll band of the 21st century I feel like a liar. IMHO my ass! IMHO water is wet. BandMaid rules right now. 66 years old here. The future will prove us right.

[@rgbenge7580]

Two bands that have really blew me away are The Warning and Jinjer. Very different, but both have three instruments and use lots of vocals (very different styles) to create texture and fullness. The Warning are more traditional rock but are surprisingly sophisticated in their compositions. Pau, the drummer, is their creative driver and has been writing amazing songs since she was something like 12 or 13. Please go down this rabbit-hole, you won't be dissapointed.

[@glenkelley6799]

Great reaction and while Thrill is their first MV it is also the song that saved the band, it went viral on FB and garnered 1 million views in 12 days. It's also an indication of the direction the band wanted to move in. Thrill was provided by their label and it wasn't until 2016 (with the song "Alone") that they were allowed to use their own compositions, and since that point almost all the songs are written by the band. The collaboration with "The Warning" was a song that is not representative of either band, but something different for each band. Thanks for reacting to and commenting on both songs. Both Band-Maid and The Warning are great bands (I'm more of Band-Maid fan). Hope to see more in the future.

[@paulread4886]

Band Maid live 2020 version of Domination live ,and also Hate? live, which is best way to see Band Maid.

[@Molurus73]

Hi Doug, I have been a big fan of your channel for years. But I'm also a many years fan of The Warning. I'm so glad you've found them! Do more reviews of them, especially their live performances. You won't regret it!

[@wrinkledm]

I've seen both live, and both are excellent bands for sure. Until this past year, the only live repeat act I've seen live was Sir Paul McCartney (twice). I never dreamed I'd find myself twice this year flying to Japan to see Band Maid in concert and I had no regrets about doing so. Six Maid shows now in total, and I suspect before I reach the age where I can't travel anymore, I will have seen them dozens more times. With a little luck, we will have another US tour again next year. ;) No dis-respect to Sir Paul, U2, Fleetwook Mac, The Warning, and the many other bands I've seen live, The Maids live shows have been nothing short of amazing...

[@Thebluewitchthatblew]

What a welcome suprise. Band-maid is just so groovy.