[REACTION!!] Old Rock Radio DJ REACTS to NIGHTWISH ft. "HIGH HOPES" (live)

[@RGP0503]

Hello Eric. First off, I was touched by your relating the wonderful story of your dear wife. I fully understand the emotions when listening to songs that you both enjoyed so much. My sincere condolences. I am the North American executive producer for Nightwish and looking after their May, 2020 tour of this continent. This band is more than a band really. It is a group of friends who play to have fun on stage and off. I, along with Floor, Marko, and others regularly watch the reactions to their songs. A note of interest on this song is that it was never meant to be a cover. You completely nailed that. It was a tribute. Marko, along with Tuomas and Emppu, put this together in one week in the Finland studio. I am sending this to Floor and Marko as this is the absolute best review of this song that I have seen. Your detail is remarkable. And, do not be concerned about Marko. He is doing great. Be assured that we will be subscribing and watching any Nightwish reviews that you may wish to offer in the future. I wish you all the best. Take care, Robert.

[@TheWyldesidewithEricClark]

Thank you Robert, for the kind words and the compliment. I am humbled, truly, by this. Having spent 30 years in a padded room talking to myself, I'm always a bit surprised when I'm noticed, my ego aside. I know music is important to everyone, but Rock and Roll has literally been my life and I'm shocked to this day I was blessed enough to be at least "Rock Star Adjacent" and experience what I have. This is something new and wonderful and like I said in my previous reaction to their video, I'm sorry as a Program Director we are so hamstrung to where we can't promote artists like this on our own to our listeners. I have opinions about the US Music industry and very few of them are positive. On top of me working 30 years in Active Rock, my late wife was an attorney for ASCAP, so I have some added insight to the Machine. You thank me for my reaction, but I thank you for helping show the world these wonderful artists. If there is ever anything I can do to help further their reach, just ask. The community has come out in full force and have been nothing but awesome and warm. I can only hope I can provide something for them that is comparable. My email is on my page and you can reach out on any SM to have direct contact with me. And if you're ever in Nashville, beer's on me! Cheers! Eric

[@siddni_]

Please, say Hi for Marko and Floor! This is my favorite Nightwish song along with Song of Myself and 7 days to the wolves. Saw Nightwish last summer and Marko last month both here in Oulu, so I guess this is not too shabby place to live😁

[@pdutchie4924]

Very good to hear that Marko is doing great, thank you for that. This is such a beautiful tribute he did back then.

[@helli0n824]

wow again i am speechless again

[@moniquevanaken2638]

Hello Robert! WOW...this is the best comment to the best reaction ever!! Very touching and with great empathy! Well done sir! I'm glad to hear that Marko is doing fine....he deserves it! Please could you pass on my congratulations to Marko with his birthday? Thank you!

[@gabriel.bardac]

Wow, Eric. I didn't expect it to be such an emotional reaction. I understand and respect your pain, and I am glad that you find in yourself the strength to move on. Let me point out that many of us Nightwish fans have "clashed" with their music at critical times in our lives, and with their help we have found the strength to move on. And here's a paradox: I'm convinced that Nightwish members only set out to express themselves, not to be the "spokespersons" for the feelings of others. Such a thing cannot be interpreted, for them it is not a role, they actually live this, and this is felt. Thank you for helping me crystallize these ideas through your comment. Know that I am just an ordinary 54-year-old man who works from 9 to 18 and I have a passion for Nightwish, because for me it is a really meaningful phenomenon in this life. I don't lead armies. Your thanks flatter me, but my greatest satisfaction is not this, but to see people like you discover the diamonds and pearls of beauty of Nightwish music, which caresses the soul. Obviously, a new subscriber here. I look forward to your next steps in discovering this treasure :)

[@martine3293]

Well said 🤍

[@lieven2292]

Indeed. Besides obviously their music, it is them being real that attracts me to them. They ARE! These are not posers. And if they are, than they are extremely good actors and they make me a fool. I go with the first. Thank you Mr Bardac for being omni-present. You have become a certainty in my journey here...

[@572Btriode]

Thoughtfully said Gabriel, and your English is excellent and concise. To be applauded, and thank you for the work helping and guiding reactors with a NW introduction. Vă mulțumesc foarte mult într-adevăr.

[@TheWyldesidewithEricClark]

Like I said, you land in my town, you want for nothing. We'll sit on my porch, listen to metal, and watch the world go by while sippin some good Southern Sweet Tea. And I have your back in a bar fight...just sayin'... Cheers! Eric.

[@kezca]

Well said Gab

[@juhagabrieltakkinen1131]

Tuomas himself has also said that this was a Tribute, not a cover. And Floyd was a major influence to the band. Heartfelt reaction my good sir.

[@TheWyldesidewithEricClark]

Thank you for the kindness and comment. Cheers from Nashville! Eric

[@Amaranthos2]

Well now This whole thing is quickly shaping up to be the most wholesome and natural Nightwish journey on the internet

[@TheWyldesidewithEricClark]

That made me laugh out loud and scare my cat. Cheers! Eric

[@Kristina-jf4hd]

Pink Floyd is my favorite band and David Gilmour is my favorite guitarist. I also love Nightwish; they are on my list of favorites. But as such a huge Floyd fan, I refused to listen to this tribute for a very long time. And once I did, I was blown away. I can say, for me personally, this is the only cover/tribute that I approve of (except maybe Aussie Floyd). Marko was simply fantastic. Let me just say that I thought Emppu did a phenomenal job on the guitar. Too many people think that Gilmour is easy to recreate because he’s not out there shredding on every single. But it’s very difficult for people to be able to do Gilmour justice. Empuu is one; and a TikTok guitarist is another. Jukka and Tuomas were great as well. They always feel like a tight band but on this I felt the emotion pouring out of all 4 of them. It was very emotional. Condolences to you. It’s not the same but I lost my dad 4 months ago and it’s tearing me up. I’ve only watched a few of your Nightwish reactions so far (I’m late to the party, sorry) but you have an uncanny ability to really understand them as a band and Tuomas as a composer rather than just a song writer. You 💯 gained a new subscriber! Thank you.

[@richardgoddard37]

As a massive fan of both bands I feel lucky to live in a world where both versions exist. I'm loving your reactions so far - you've only seen the very tip of the Nightwish iceberg.

[@Ounouh]

There are covers, and then there are Tributes. Nightwish didn't do a cover. Thanks for the great insight and reaction.

[@mpainter22]

When you realise that you didn't have this band in your life and now you do, when you realise that this was outthere 17 years ago and you realise that you NEEDED to discover this band. The journey will be brighter but it will also be ALOT darker, I hope you are ready for what you are going to experience.

[@atlantis315]

this was recorded the night, they, as a band, decided to part ways with Tarja. They all knew it. They were all hurting. And you can feel it in this performance.

[@lknowledge]

Oh after the news hit the media you could link all the looks between members and how they looked at Tarja, the weird feeling and dynamics of the show. It was an epic show... but after knowing whats going on... oh man.

[@billattercliffe8655]

Marko has had his own demons to deal with and that is why this was such an incredible rendition. These songs can't be comprehended or delivered without having lived with some pain.

[@eviljeep]

Nightwish in one word for me.. Emotion. Never cry this much for a music band. TX for taking the Nightwish journey! 🤟

[@korvkioskshelvete]

This is not a reaction. This is a tribute. I got chills. Great job!

[@danielletoscano4509]

My condolences on the loss of your life partner. I understand completely. I’m glad you chose this gem to react to. I’m absolutely enjoying your take on Nightwish’s tribute to Floyd, since the band clarified that it was not a cover but a “tribute.” Looking forward to joining your journey into Nightwish’s catalog of great music.

[@TheWyldesidewithEricClark]

Thank you and I'm having a blast so far! Cheers from Nashville! Eric

[@572Btriode]

@@TheWyldesidewithEricClark I'm so sorry for your loss Eric, I've been there. My statuesque and pragmatic wife of 30 years worked her guts out with a company that treated her like something you stepped in, so we could both retire here to a quiet bit of France in 2012, she was ecstatic. In late 2014 at 54 she had without warning a massive and immediate fatal stroke - basal artery failure. It was a dark time, very dark. So I can't do Nightwish - Kiss While your Lips are Still Red, just still haven't the inner strength. I can empathise, been there, not fun.

[@TheWyldesidewithEricClark]

@@572Btriode Thank you for your kind words. I hope you can soon find peace and happiness. Cheers from Nashville, Eric

[@don-o-seven1437]

@@572Btriode yeah that one would be too tough. Poet is tough, but poetic enough to drift. KWYLASR is pointed and direct. Condolences and positive energy from GA, USA.

[@572Btriode]

@@don-o-seven1437 Thank you, that's very kind and much appreciated.

[@alxm1271]

Even without their symphonic elements, without their lead singer, they are still a band I would gladly pay for watching. That's how good they are.

[@martine3293]

First of all, I'm sorry for your loss. I loved your reaction, very sincere. This indeed is a tribute, not a cover! It's Nightwish, doing what they do best. Evoking emotions in their listeners, mesmerizing them with their musicianship and showmanship, while still acknowledging the composition of this beautiful song. I'm glad I started you off on this Nightwish journey and I've subscribed to see where it takes you. Your words at the end of the video immediately made me think of a fairly recent Nightwish song called 'How's The Heart'. It's about human empathy and I think it will really speak to you. There's no live version yet, it's too new, but there is a wonderful lyric video kzbin.info/www/bejne/qoXHi3drqqudgtU and a fantastic acoustic version (just Floor and Troy, Nightwish's English multi-instrumentalist) kzbin.info/www/bejne/r4rXnIOme76thdE

[@randymarple9830]

Good job, Martine. Eric is a gem. Glad you found him.

[@gabriel.bardac]

This is a great suggestion, thanks!

[@martine3293]

@@gabriel.bardac 😊

[@louisminten7889]

I think he love that version. Let's hope he react to this

[@alexandersteinmetz6857]

That would fit perfectly, also to lighten Things up an bit! great Suggestion, lady!

[@garyakirsch]

Complement: You, Eric, other than myself, are the ONLY man I have seen that is not afraid to show joyful tears pouring from your HEART. I pray nearly every day that Marko returns. And now, thanks to you sir, my 70 yo head is now on a quest to explore Pink Floyd beyond the Wall that I knew. Hey, try "lara fabian." I'll be two armies: nightlight and pink Floyd. Bty, going g into Wacken Floor was a temp. She walked out witgzcontract.

[@JustJenRx]

Judging by the shirt in the last NW video, I was hoping you’d get to this one! Gabriel is a true legend in the world of Nightwish. He always helps. Sherpa is right! He’d have a long flight as he’s from Romania 🇷🇴, but being a Nightwish “Sherpa” is absolutely what he’s known for. Hey don’t change or adapt to no one! Be yourself and you will be successful on KZbin!!! Good Luck 🍀 Jen

[@davidstephen6753]

Hi Jen, Hope you are well! I've always loved your journey into Nightwish but it's great to see that you also join us in experiencing them with others. I know you will have appreciated the emotions and vulnerability of this reaction. We Were Here!

[@mrFTW1974]

Jen my grrl! Love uah

[@R---66---R]

So precious!

[@JustJenRx]

@@mrFTW1974 ❤️ aww 🥰 hi! Had to come back to this one today! Glad I did!

[@JustJenRx]

@@davidstephen6753 WE WERE HERE most definitely 😘

[@nicolewirth4767]

Reactions of people who “listen” between the lines, know what music is about. Very well explained and a big thank you ☺️ ❤️.

[@ArtMateurMusic]

Nightwish evokes so much reflection and emotions, that in dark times, it can be difficult to listen to it, because it will penetrate the depths of your soul, and whether it can be positive or negative depends on your mental strength ... I for my part believe that nightwish heals the depressions, and that this reflection that forces you to do, does nothing but heal the soul a little with each listening..This happens with this tribute, they will try to enter your soul, and they do it in person, looking into your eyes and giving you everything they have, they will not negotiate even 1 gram of their talent ... this happens in many nightwish songs , this same feeling of weightlessness that is generated by watching this band.

[@mort58]

This might be my favourite musicreaction of all time. Seeing your joy/agony the last 30 seconds never fails to strike feelings into me aswell. Much love from Sweden.

[@tarjatuhkanen7094]

Marko has openly said that he has had some mental issues throughout the years, so he really can put the all emotions into this song. Definitely a tribute. Quite a few massive Pink Floyd fans have even said they like this tribute better than the original because it is heavier. Very true and honest reaction. Well done.

[@npinjest7779]

Thank you for sharing your reaction! Marco is a decade older than the rest of the band, a metal veteran who had definitely done some living before landing with them. And it really comes through in his singing, infusing whatever the song he does with sense and gravity. My personal favorite of his has recently become his last lead vocal with Nightwish in "Endlessness", as it really showcases that infusion and its impact.

[@petersundqvist5465]

This is still good the 18th time i watch and listening , Thank you

[@chadbennett7873]

A beautiful investment of a half hour on my part - thank you, Eric. You earned a new subscriber.

[@orangeguppie6897]

That was my very first reaction , about 20 months ago, when i heard this song by Nightwish, i could not believe what they did with this song, i liked the song before ( i am 62 years old or young)but when i listened to Nightwish i said the same; this is not a cover it is a tribute to Pink Floyd and they made me really love, love, love this song. I did read a comment from somebody that Pink Floyd was happy with the Nightwish version . Thanks for your reaction, see you, bye

[@wannabedane4046]

Sorry for your loss. And, yes, this is a tribute - no doubt about it. In Gabriel's list you find a song by called "Yours is an empty Hope" - hearing you talk about internet trolls and the like, I am pretty sure you'll aprreciate the lyrics of this piece, and if you listen carefully, you'll hear yet another tone quality in Floor's voice.

[@billattercliffe8655]

And do this version as there's another one out there with poor production: kzbin.info/www/bejne/rKqvpIhthphmac0

[@timchambers8230]

So refreshing to see someone so eloquently describe what it is about Nightwish that resonates with the fans. New sub here.

[@sandramelgers6028]

We feel you.....WE WERE HERE.....The Nightwish Army is Here and enjoy your Nightwish journee and do what you do!! Thank you greetings from the Netherlands Nightwish Army 🤘❤

[@ralfmeyer9086]

Hallo, from the Floor Division, Northern Germany. A great reaction.

[@Mark_-jq6wg]

Marko is very much missed. I can only hope he does return one day. This tribute was just mind blowing the first time I heard it 3 years ago and it still is today. I don't think there is a person who could listen to that and not get emotional. Some music you just listen too, but others you FEEL it way down to your very core.

[@sjoerd-jangispen1725]

This song hits me every time. My dad introduced me to Pink Floyd. When I discovered Nightwish, I listened this gem too. Went to my father en we both listened and cried because of the beauty of this tribute. Because that is the only way to discribe it. Thank you for your thoughts and insights. We will always have High Hopes

[@greywuuf]

With nightwish there is a level of professionalism and mastery that enables them to tackle everything. There is also a lack of ego that allows them to serve the music. It is rare that they will say what a song is about... rather it is. "I only know what it means to me, what it means to you is up to you" Floor is basicly an Empath, and at this point in Her career has the choice to only sing music that she connects with, and her ability to "become" the story is truly astounding. You will find Nightwish ( or solo involved with ) that you like more or less, but I doubt you will find one that is not real, authentic , and master class.

[@TheWyldesidewithEricClark]

"I sing a song for one reason, but 80k people sing it back for 80k different reasons." Dave Grohl Thank you so much for the kind words! Cheers from Nashville! Eric

[@davidputterman2719]

Perfectly articulated sir. I am a musician/drummer for the past 50 years and former radio personality from back in the 70's, Floyd is still to this day one of my favorite bands and now to add to that list Nightwish. I was at the Division Bell tour at Gillette Stadium in Foxboro Mass. in 1994. That was the most ethereal experience of my lifetime. If I ever am fortunate enough to see Nightwish live, I am sure that they will bring that same experience to me.

[@Pappa_66]

Thank you very much for this beautiful journey. I still remember this very well, not because it was Tarja`s last performance with NW but because it was an amazing concert! It was their biggest show in Finland so far and they were diamond!

[@SuomenPaska]

I'm very envious of you having had the chance to see Pink Floyd live! I was born a year after the division bell tour. My dad got me hooked into Pink Floyd and Nightwish was my childhood so this was pretty much the perfect cover for me. Great reaction :)

[@anrakspumante5958]

One of the best reaction i have ever seen, i cant express my feelings during this reaction, because my english isnt well enough to find the right words. Greetings from Vienna!

[@randymarple9830]

What a terrific reaction. The fact that you saw it as a "Tribute" gave me chills. So very sorry for your loss. Beautiful lady. I think you should delay Floor singing Alone. Floor and a grand piano brings me to tears, and I don't have the connection to the song like you do. To see what Floor can do with a song, see what she does with "Shallow" from Lady Gaga. Beste Zangers is a Dutch TV show that highlights 6 singers who spend time together and then spotlight each individually with the other singers picking a song to sing to that singer. Floor was 39 when she sang Shallow for Emma. Floor began singing Metal when she was 16 and Emma is 22. Floor had already been thru the path that Emma was now just beginning and....well, just see what she does. I do hope you eventually can listen to Alone, and maybe it will be a healing experience. Much love, my friend.

[@AngelesBustamanteM]

And also check Emma sing Strong for Floor. That show is a gem ❤

[@randymarple9830]

@@AngelesBustamanteM That one makes me cry too!

[@boj99]

Or Floor doing Mama. Fantastic song 😍🇩🇰🎸🎤

[@scottsmith4933]

Eric, thank you for sharing such and emotional reaction of my favorite band Nightwish! Sharing the loss of your partner was sincere and vulnerable. Keep listening to Nightwish! They will heal you. This band will be all your own. I read so many people who have been healed by listening to Nightwish! Peace!

[@crnibass1994]

At around @10:30 of this video you can see Jukka (the drummer) holding his head cause of being in excruciating pain due to chronic insomnia. And then about 10 seconds later you can see Tuomas (on keyboards) nodding his head to Emppu (guitarist) to go check on Jukka. Absolutely beautiful moment. Jukka had to quit playing but now he's the manager of Nightwish.

[@harrythatsme2100]

Great reaction. With Nightwish and Floor the tears will come. But they always accompanied or followed up by a big smile. Like with Floyd , it's therapie for the soul.

[@runkkariruune]

Kiitos! Love You man, so touching! Greetings from Helsinki, Finland!

[@ludvigenholm7168]

Wow, what a reaction. When I saw your Ghost Love Score reaction, I said to myself - The Army has to suggest High Hopes next. And they did. It is an awesome tribute. 🔥🤘

Hi Eric, I'm back to watch this fantastic reaction again for, probably the 20th time. I just love your interpretation of their performance - and I totally agree.

[@brian3971]

When I saw that NW had covered this song I was hesitant, I knew they could play it, I knew that it would sound good, but Pulse has been in my CD player for almost 30 years. They hit it out of the park though, not because they hit the right notes or whatever, but because it FELT right, the tone as you put it.

[@hiawatha.g]

I don't think I've seen anyone else choose this for a reaction. Great choice. And yes, the greatest band founded after 1985, doing a tribute to one of the greatest bands of all time. And now you know how great a vocalist Marko is.

[@alienware18]

You left me speechless... You are simply amazing. I cried as well !!! Hugs and all the best !

[@marianogonzalez1977]

Thanks for this Eric, I just found a new companion into my Nth Nightwish rabbit hole dive. We're gonna be here every step of the way!!!! Cheers from Argentina!

[@pekkakarppinen1608]

This is a great tribute. It's a spectacular performance. One of the kind. ⛄👍

[@len2193]

Thanks for sharing about your soul mate. Your reaction is spot on! This is a beautiful tribute by Nightwish.

[@ralfmeyer9086]

What a great Tribute from one awesome Band to another awesome Band. Awesome

[@laudatosiadastra1218]

Wow, thats quite a compliment to say they are equal in your eyes. I´m glad you enjoyed it so much. Pink Floyd was the first real music rabbit hole I ever went down when I was a kid. Recently, I discovered Nightwish at the start of 2021 and they changed my life, bigtime... I´m glad you are taking this journey - one of life´s greatest journeys in my experience :)

[@gregfancher1]

My friend I felt this song exactly the way you did. Every note, every word, every emotion.I joined the Nightwish Army and continue to be amazed by the talent and versatility this band has to offer. Everyone has the band that they ask how are they not bigger about and this is that band for me. Condolences on your loss and am glad you are working through it. Love the channel and have subscribed. Regards from Denver.

[@majbrat]

Its magic - such a great Tribute. So sorry for your loss sir. Wishing you peace, serene dreams, and beautiful memories that only leave you filled with love. We are all privileged to have certain people come into our life journeys. Your wife sounds like a special woman. All the best.

[@jordanmiller5207]

wow. great nightwish reactions so far. love ur approach and insight. sorry for ur loss.

[@Mind-your-own-beeswax]

I love your style and the way you do your reaction. Bringing insight and the reasons behind it is rare on KZbin. You will learn very quickly that not one of those guys is there to show off. They are a collective and when they don’t have a part to play in a track they step back and let those who are playing that section take the light. As has been stated it was never a cover song but a tribute. You’re one of us now fella and we will be here if you need us.

[@deeduffjr]

It was a privilege watching such a heartfelt reaction, thank you for sharing that with us.

[@monicacarolina6480]

Thank you sir for your reaction. I saw the doubt on your face before the clip started and I had the same, be fore I heard this tribute. Marko, Emppu and Tuomas are huge Pink Floyd admirers. They said they never can't be Pink FLoyd, but wanted to make a tribute to them. I also love Emppu's guitar parts in this song. I feel so deeply for you sir, to loose the love of your life must be so hard and she must be always present in your head. You sir, are one of the best reactors in You tube. Not because you are a specialist like you said. No, you feel the music, you understand the music and can describe it so detailed and precisely. Thank you for being her sir. Much love from Holland x

[@mariogansbeke]

I am so sorry I can't like (thumbs up) this reaction more than once. Damn man, you got me cutting onions.

[@01bigtrev]

I feel like I’m in similar situation. Listened to high hopes from release over the years absolutely love it and heard over the years to listen to this nightwish cover and kind of turned my nose up at going to been listen as I absolutely love the original and it’s only been the last couple of weeks I was on KZbin and thought I’ll watch someone reacting to nightwish. I’ve got to say I was blown away and absolutely regret not being more open minded to someone “covering” it when like you say it’s a tribute and a fucking epic tribute it is.

[@Pitdog108]

For me personally High hopes is a very big part of my life, with that being said imo is not a cover but a tribute to Pink Floyd.

[@Kelsea-2002]

The best two concerts i have seen live are Nightwish 2013 in Wacken and David Gilmour 2016 in Pompeii.I agree with you on every single point.Thank you very much for this reaction.Greetings from Germany

[@rebeccalee2644]

My heart broke to see you cry. I'm so very sorry for your loss, I know how it feels to have a song(s) connected to a lost love one. I have a few myself. I really enjoyed your reaction, so genuine and heartfelt. I found out about Nightwish not to long ago myself, and love watching people discover them as well. Marco is amazing, if you would like more of him there is The Islander or Kiss While Your Lips are Still Red (one of my favorites).

[@TheWyldesidewithEricClark]

Thank you so much for your kind words. The reason I walked away from performing in 2015 was because I felt I lost my biggest fan. She was the only audience I ever needed and I was the only star in her sky. It hurts so much because it felt so much and was true. It's my ghost that haunts me and I'm not sure I ever want it to go away. As I grow, I hope to be able to enjoy what we shared, but for now, that's for when I'm alone and no one can see me. Again, thank you so very much and Cheers from Nashville! Eric

[@muumiveikko]

Thank you, i watch your channel before i go to sleep. your voice and style is relaxing and entertaining. Greetings from Finland. I would love to see your reactions to Finnish metal god Jarkko Ahola 💚

[@davidryall-flanders6353]

I lost my wife to cancer in 2015, she was 50 yrs old. I feel you brother.

[@alejandrariquelme9574]

Thank you for your reaction, sir. All of us, Nightwish's fans, know that this song is a tribute to Pink Floyd, but Thank you for give us a great explanation about the Why. It was great! I embrace you in your sorrow. Continúe with this beutiful experience named Nightwish that I pretty sure you will find great music (not only by NW but also to some artists related to them, too) to add to your soundtrack of life. Cheers.

[@jamesm6377]

Hi Eric. Its NOT a reaction; it's a tribute!! Eloquent, professional and very insightful. You understand the music. You are in my top 10 music analysts now!! One of my favorite Gilmour versions of High Hopes is here... much more laid back and personal. Keep up the great work.

[@rodneyhearne3405]

Eric, you really pegged the emotions and root of this performance. I love the word Tone because it really captures this moment so well. Not simply the sonic meaning but mostly the place in the soul where we connect to the music and the reverence to the meaning and feeling that the writer/composer and yes, the performer conveys. Thank you for a real and raw yet eloquent reaction.

[@tonshimountain652]

One of the truest reactions I have seen in a long time. Thank you for sharing and deeply sorry for your loss, the army is here for you.

[@williamthomas7509]

Had to come back and watch again. Your reaction is so genuine ... like Marco no pretense. Then to have you share how hard it hits in part ... just wow! Perhaps the words you were looking for about the band ... there were the mountain pinnacle that Marco stood on confident it would not crack and fail. They are simply stronger together than their parts and the parts are all damn good!

[@robertcraane7910]

I get you completely, man! I lost my wife too, in 2006. I was/am a singer/songwriter, and I couldn't play anything of my own stuff for years... Or listen to it. That part of my life was gone with her..... Now I can carefully play some songs for myself, but not on a stage. Afraid that I will burst out in tears. Still, thank you for this one. I'm a huge NW and PF fan for a long, long time!

[@TheWyldesidewithEricClark]

Thank you for the comment and kind words. I hope we both find peace and happiness, brother. Cheers from Nashville! Eric

[@lieven2292]

I also had to compose myself, sorry...What a tribute! What a performance! Especially considering their state of mind with the Tarja-situation... Also, Jukka, the drummer, was having a severe migraine attack during this set and still played his hart out but in considerable pain... at about 10:40 in your beautiful reaction, you can see Tuomas nodding to Emppu to go check on him which he does a bit later... these guys are my modern day heroes, I'm not even kidding. I am going to follow you Sir, for I think there is knowledge to be acquired here...

[@alexandersteinmetz6857]

ok, long thoughts short: i am just happy that you just found another NW Gem , and it really did give you that, what this guys in NW want you to feel. really happy for you.

[@beezysbeatz4924]

16:29 ....me too brother. I was at the May 1994 final event ever at the original Cleveland Browns Stadium b4 it was torn down and the Browns moved to Baltimore. This song, this album, means the world to me and not only was I not offended by this performance, at the moment its my favorite rendition of the song. Marko had strain and longing in his voice as he sang it, i had no choice but to reflect on my own life's good, bad and exciting times. I just turned 57 this month so there's a lot to reflect on and this song always enhances my mood after I get the emotional release. Thanks for encompassing the way I feel about this song and immortalizing it on KZbin hopefully for others to connect with as well. The entire rock and roll genre of music my favorite music, is slowly dying and there doesn't seem to be anybody around to take the place of all the legends and the one hit wonders and the musical acts that should be in the rock and roll Hall of Fame and for some reason are not but there are rappers in the Hall of Fame. Gen Z is completely disconnected with rock and roll so I really believe that the best way to keep the best music ever alive is through KZbin reaction channels FM radio is dying I can't tell you the last time I listen to a regular over-the-air radio so there are no more DJs really to promote rock and roll so it's up to you guys and I really appreciate it because I get to hear the music that I've loved for a long time for the first time again vicariously through the reaction channels. Let me tell you the first time I watched a reaction to the song vicarious by Tool nearly gave me an existential crisis lol

[@simone9313]

First of all - I feel you and I´m deeply sorry for your loss ! This song hits me every single time. Thank you for your wonderful words and for sharing your emotions ❤

[@michaelwanklin3580]

Hi Eric. I am so sorry for your loss - and I have felt that loss. I wish you well in your journey to get passed this feeling. Really did enjoy your appreciation of this immaculately produced TRIBUTE to a fantastic PF song.

[@TheWyldesidewithEricClark]

Thank you! Eric

[@billtbodger]

Totally agree Eric, that was not a cover song, it was a song they had to do, Marco was so passionate singing High Hopes, it will never be bettered by any other band. Nightwish ARE that special

Absolutely true that this is not a cover - this is a tribute and nothing else. I love how you totally absorbes the music and get emotional - this song with Marko on vocals, Thoumas on keys, Empu on guitar and Jukka on drums, gets me every time i watch it. Kudos and thanks for your perfect explatantion on how good this was. They totally get the PF tone.

[@andybarber8898]

Subscribed bc of your complete understanding of this musical masterpiece. Your reaction was genuine and beautiful.

[@TheWyldesidewithEricClark]

Thank you very much! Cheers from Nashville! Eric

[@CyclopsRevolution]

I was there in Legion Field as well in '94 I think. When I first heard this "tribute" my reaction was very similar to yours. My past is filled with, not only the music of Pink Floyd but the memories around them as well. I became a Nightwish fan back in the early 2000's. We read an article about Nightwish in some metal magazine and went down to the local record shop and the owner said to check back in a week. Went back and he said he'd ordered two albums from Europe and said he'd call when they came in. About a month later we got them. Oceanborn and Wishmaster. The very first Nightwish song I ever listened to was "Walking In The Air." The reason being, it was mentioned in the article that first brought Nightwish to our attention. Then shortly after, the album Once was released and that was an amazing album. Finding a band like Nightwish back then in small town Alabama, was like finding a vein of gold in your backyard. I've been a fan ever since. A lot of the songs being recommended are Floor singing the old stuff. You may want to take a trip back in time to hear the originals first. Your choice. I enjoy your work here.

[@Boukarroum66]

This is how I was introduced to Nightwish. High hopes is one of my favorite songs ever, and I was obsessed with Pink Floyd growing up. I decided to search for covers to see what can people do with it, and there it was, and that's how I became also obsessed with Nightwish

[@sterlingknight8087]

With Nightwish, everything is given for the song. There's no grandstanding, no trying to front. Everything is designed and performed as to make the song the best it can be.

[@aura5572]

Its beautiful to see how a performance can touch heart and soul

[@droiduser9633]

Another tribute Nightwish did was recognized by Andrew Floyd Weber, "Phantom of the Opera"! Tarja, the original singer, and our twin bearded God Marco did a great job! Floor with Henk Poort (actually was the Phantom on stage), jeez oh peets, greatness on both fronts!

[@jon33040]

Thank you for a superb & really moving reaction.

[@Vigilanis]

Great, genuine reaction mate, so sorry for your loss brother. Yeah even Tuomas said it was a tribute, so glad you got to experience it and keep up the great work!

[@Rye_Toast]

I was lucky to see the Division Bell live, too. A tribute well done takes you back.

[@metallicaguy4679]

Other than metallica. This in my opinion best band. and floor by far best singer I have ever heard

[@GWDH19]

Wow, thank you for your genuine reaction ❤️

[@ciskavandevijver2355]

it's indeed a Tribute to PF....thanx for your beautiful reaction. You nailed it..greets from the netherlands..

[@savadrow]

My friend. I’m no reaction specialist, but I want you to know that this is the most honest and informative reaction/breakdown I have ever seen. The way this touched you emotionally brought me right there with you. I encourage you to continue because you have a great deal to offer. And greetings from next door in Virginia 🤘🤘🤘🤘

[@kurtjanssen3887]

This is the most beautifull reaction I have seen on this one. Pink floyd are gods.....so is Marco and the rest of Nightwish (stil sad about Marco leaving the band). Thanx for this reaction man. 👊👍

[@musicfan9291]

Thank you for your touching reaction. I am sorry for your loss and as far as Alone...........you do you man. I, or better yet, WE understand. Fist time I heard that, I cried as well. I was had bliners on for so long where if it wasn't Rush, Floyd, Tool or Zeppelin it simply didn't exist. Nightwish was the band that allowed me to feel safe to explore music again.

[@TheWyldesidewithEricClark]

Thank you. Cheers, Eric

[@d.w.craigie7087]

Your reaction genuinely moved me. Condolences for your loss. Even over the internet we can relate and connect as humans. As such, I have to recommend "How's the Heart" by Nightwish as a reaction. Given what you shared in this video it seems like the perfect follow up. I appreciate what you're doing and I've subscribed. I'm here for the journey!

[@bwaychick20]

I concur!

[@kimfabritiusdetengnagel2038]

This reaction - along with your previous Nightwish reaction - are by far the best on the Internet. You have a deep deep understanding of what is going on - and why!! Simply great Respect, thanks and greetings from Nightwish Army Denmark 🇩🇰

[@jopes4855]

Now, i have watched this reaction video several times because there is so much feelings that i concur. But also, it also hit me that Heart - Alone is also "cover" . Though, if you had react that song this day, what would have been words after that :D I genuinely hope we meet some day, i am sure i would enjoy evening with you. Greetings from Finland! 🤘🎶 🖤 🎸🇫🇮

[@khymaaren]

Found your Ghost Love Score reaction and loved it. This one made me subscribe. Thank you, sir.

[@jasminlamoureux3381]

I saw the original too, in Montreal's Olympic Stadium. My first real concert, I'll never forget it! Love the Nightwish version too 😁

[@TomTomson81]

Because of your way of doing things, I have subscribed. Absolutely understandable to skip songs if they make you sad because of your wife. To the song. I think it's better than the original. Not only because I'm of course a Nightwish fan, but above all a metal fan. The original is just not my style. Marko's voice is simply sensational, the song darker and draws me more in. Emppus solos just great. Everything I want is in there. And if you consider that Tarja was fired right after this concert (everyone except Tarja already knew it at that time), the lyrics also take on a completely different meaning. Just like the intensity with which Marko sings.

[@tonycardone990]

I've been a Pink Floyd fan since I was a little kid and have heard many other artists try to play their material and fail miserably. This is the one version of a Floyd song that I actually like more than the original. And you're absolutely correct, it is not a cover it is a tribute and it is the best tribute you could possibly want. If you're going to do a song written and performed by the best you also have to be the best, and they are. Also I would like to say sorry about your loss and when or if you are ever prepared for Floor doing Alone be warned it is on the same level brother.

[@TheWyldesidewithEricClark]

Thank you. Cheers. Eric

[@darkiee69]

David Gilmour himself shared this version on his twitter account. And I've seen a lot of lifelong PF fans say the same thing you did, it's a tribute, and it equals the original. And I'm sorry for your loss.

[@WardDorrity]

I really appreciate your understanding of the music you review. You are one of the few who do. At 71, I also appreciate your life experiences. I can't pretend and say that I understand, but in many ways, I get it.