Real Time with Bill Maher: Overtime - Episode

[@pedrorigual5933]

I just love to hear Neil talk about anything. Seriously, everyone should watch Cosmos, he's so freaking cool, he makes you love science so much more. He is mankind at it's best.

[@GeneralKabl3]

So true

[@posthumanismkarma6120]

all those kids science shows that came on the 90's (bill nye, magic school bus, beakmans world) really sparked my interest in science. I believe they should do that again

[@tjmed7708]

I really watched this whole thing just for the parts where neil degrasse tyson talks

[@TheWildmanden]

"I don't know who they have that could probably defeat Hillary"... Oh you have no idea...

[@maxm4696]

"I don't know who could defeat hillary as president." If only they knew

[@lindabarba9440]

Barba the same time to get a

[@grizzly2575]

The answer was: Hillary _ who couldn't be bothered to show up *once* and campaign, in states she lost by only *THREE* votes per precinct.

[@russoanthony8140]

RIP Debbie Wasserman Schultz

[@Social_Mechanic]

Rest In Shit you mean

[@WeezaY5000]

Rick Wolford Haha. Thank you for that laugh.

[@undeadminion811]

If only...

[@Einomar]

Russo Anthony sicko

[@MysLed]

Maybe not RIP (thats a tad too far) but if only she had been her final paycheck with a card saying "farewell, good luck on finding your next job" before the 2016 elections than Bernie would have been given a fair shot rather than the loser she forced upon us.

[@EatHoneyBeeHappy]

Lol watching this video today is hilarious.

[@maxm4696]

i love it when republicans try to be pretentious

[@lenomarin3484]

+breaded wormula I love it when democrats lose :)

[@stephjovi]

Diogenes especially men of any color could be president before a women can. Even orange people became US president first 😂

[@YTEdy]

@@maxm4696 I love it when republicans confuse humor and arrogance.

[@djstubbs]

The irony of Neil saying STEM is the best you can get out of those four letters when Bill's an owner of the METS...

[@brenden084]

Hey debbie, feel the bern

[@irisdoggy001]

A bunch of smart people all talking reasonably, its nice not to have anyone screaming at each other.

[@tysdisposition5357]

America is a company not a country.

[@Vordrazz]

Every time Reiner speaks Neil leans away for fear of being hit by swinging arms lol

[@LeoDaShaman]

"I don't know who they have that can beat Hillary" 3 years later she gets beaten by an Oompa Loompa organgatang

[@RobertCLudwig]

The one disagreement I have with Neil deGrasse Tyson's view on education is that, while strengthening students understanding of Science | Technology | Engineering | and Math (STEM) is important, it is also important to maintain a firm grounding in history and literature. These subjects form the basis of who we are as a people which is necessary if you are govern with an understanding of one's traditions and a historical perspective of why ideas failed in the past to allow better ideas to move forward into the future. Without this grounding, you end up with a society of technocrats that are very capable worker bees in the areas of technology but are easily mislead by reinvented histories.

[@EddyCutz]

#word

[@chebob2009]

Very true. Although I would counter by saying that the very best way of protecting yourself against reinvented histories, and all kinds of delusional social programming (and more generally, just detecting if you're being fed bullshit), is to understand the scientific mindset.

[@barryalexander6836]

This about that knowing history in and of itself will do nothing to stimulate those areas of STEM. Of what use is it to know Einstein put down on paper the theory of relativity if you can't use the math involved.

[@RobertCLudwig]

You're focusing on technological history. I'm taking about societal history, what defines us as a people.

[@katherynemero4118]

The episode should be called "Why Bill Maher is correct when he says Americans are stupid."

[@occasional_doomer]

Agreed. Exactly my point.

[@MrThinkdouble]

I like how Bill starts out talking about how more young people need to be drawn into the sciences, and then when the brilliant scientist on the panel says something about science Bill completely ignores him and diverts the attention to an actor.

[@Urasims]

He has to end the show, and that's usually how he does it. I know I could listen to these guys for a lot longer, but sometimes you have to take your entertainment in moderation! Thanks, Bill, for making an entertaining show each week!

[@Aeroldoth3]

That's not what he was doing at all ! He was being a good host, and including Rob in the conversation. Everybody else had a good talk but Rob was mostly silent the whole time, so as the clip ended he acknowledged him as well. It had NOTHING to do with ignoring the scientist to fawn over the actor.

[@placebo5466]

Watching Debbie Wasserman Shultz talk about the Tea Party, sounds exactly like the liberal and Democratic movement in 2017.

[@kitefan1969]

Where is Ann Coulter? Didn't the panel want to hear her opinion?

[@kitefan1969]

I was being sarcastic... That woman is insane.

[@childwaters]

David Guidolin She's crazy like a . . . Fox.

[@writerconsidered]

childwaters laughing all the way to the bank. smart enough not to run for any office.

[@IAmNomadical]

Nobody wants to hear Ann Coulter's opinion.

[@temporaldisplacement]

IAmNomadical She makes me laugh when she makes fun of herself ...which isn't often. Her 'gods honest' policy ideas are .........shit.

[@imshadi]

Love all the people in this panel. Why can't we have a government with THEM!

[@lennisiale2720]

This woman said "we are getting our lunch eaten" in reference to street talk. She a real one ha!

[@RichardBronosky]

6:13 HA HA HA! Very funny to watch this 2013 interview of Debbie Wasserman Schultz in 2017.

[@Fergus-Collington]

Ha

[@wsurounder21]

Everytime I hear Wasserman-Schultz speak, it sounds like one long audition for a better job

[@wrathofme03]

Neil Degrasse Tyson could be on any T.V show and make it an amazing T.V show.

[@chrissearle23]

Bill is just great

[@EHCBunny4real]

I attended a university where they want their students to have a rounded education. In fact many of their students graduate with multiple degrees in the arts and sciences. I am one of them.

[@greenbaydahg]

If you're reading this, and Bernie is the Democratic nominee, cclick here -----> 5:20

[@thegreatcatsby2321]

Oh yeah, after Iowa and New Hampshire, and with the Nevada caucus just a few days away (with them tied in the polls), this is looking pretty interesting. Fingers crossed. #FeelTheBern

[@EiToCi0to9]

+Evin Paauwe, I interpreted it as there will be a woman president as they (the Republicans) have nobody that can defeat Hillary.

[@crabdabs8497]

Yea boiiiii

[@redstate86]

That begs the question: what's in the water?

[@kicsike24]

I love Neil DeGrass Tyson, that's why I watch the show.

[@BigEBikes]

This was filmed 3years ago and we Still have the same problems with Congresses... That's sad ): ,,, America needs a all new Congress and President...

[@BatmanHQYT]

Chris Traeger!

[@BrendanBeckett]

Debbie Wasserman Shultz is such a politician jesus

[@northwoodsharmony3523]

the congresswoman on the panel nailed it, I am a foreigner who would desperately like to move to the US to undertake a masters, learn, contribute, become a taxpayer all that stuff, but the immigration policy wants you in and then straight back out again. It needs to change to allow the people who want to contribute and are willing to be productive citizens to stay and be a part of society.

[@INMATE2468]

*_Bernie/Warren2016_*

[@Greyskymorning395]

No one can beat Hillary? Two words, Elizabeth Warren.

[@MrThinkdouble]

I'm a huge Elizabeth Warren fan, but if you think that she's Hilary's biggest rival you're fucking delusional.

[@Greyskymorning395]

That's true, Wall Street would never have it.

[@Arzgan]

MrThinkdouble When Obama ran in 2008, anyone who thought he could beat Hillary was "delusional." Hmm...

[@Multihopefulness]

You wasting your time. you can't go against the establishment.

[@ethanike]

***** Wall Street aside, Hillary has been in the politics realm for 16 years...not to say Elizabeth Warren doesn't have the experience...but Hillary has more world diplomatic experience.

[@Stingerbillion]

I said this several times. People/Parents need to talk with their kids about taking interest in STEM courses where the demand is, jobs are, competition is, job security/pay are. Liberal arts isn't going to get you job security, nor is political science and psychology. UE wouldn't be problem nor taxes if people had STEM degrees.

[@TempestTossedWaters]

Yes, the Tea Party has obstructed Obama a lot. But it's not like Obama is a huge progressive either, he is almost identical to Bush on for example foreign policy.

[@dolphinsattack]

Barack Obama And Obama promised he'd be different than Bush so Obama is the liar and fraud not Bush. This is all on Obama. The one who says he will be different than Bush and end the Bush era policies but then gets elected and continues them is the fraud. No other president has lied more than Obama, he's a pussy ass bitch coward who doesn't fight his own fights and never did. Obama doesn't know you exist and he doesn't care about you.

[@TempestTossedWaters]

Barack Obama I guess no difference at all isn't accurate. Obama and Bush have a difference in tactics. But not being a slack-jawed mouthbreather who does stupid things doesn't make them have a genuine foreign policy difference. Obama is no progressive.

[@lezlitaz]

Alexander Powers so when those drones come here, will you be lined up cheering when less innocent people are killed?

[@Stingerbillion]

That's very true. I agree.

[@jackky265]

Dragonworks shut up kid you don't know anything

[@djstubbs]

Debbie makes some great points about immigration.

[@trumpetman]

This is one rare occasion where I don't completely agree with Dr. Tyson. STEM is super important but how do you get away from the books and the tests and really begin to innovate? The arts can stand alone and have been for as long as there has been art. CREATIVITY is the key and people don't get creativity from physics books alone. There's STEM and then there's the art of STEM. Sir Issac Newton was a creative mind with the like of Bach and Beethoven. Creating is art no matter what the medium is. Oil, music, sculpture, poetry, or going to Mars. The same kind of thinking out of the box is required.

[@reformcongress]

DWS, it's rich when she says that anyone that disagrees with the right is a liar, when she is a liar actually.

[@ByTheReaper]

Why did HBO cut 6 minutes? This very segment is almost 16 minutes long on their own website...

[@TheFi1thyCasual]

The government built the roads? LOL.

[@Aeroldoth3]

8:40 Can someone please tell me what this 10-1 thing is they're talking about?

[@OfficialJab]

What is it about that table on this show that makes people need to touch it to explain their points?

[@KillgoreTrout43]

I like DWS. She's a smart and dedicated woman. She is not putting personal political gain, over the American people. A rare thing in today's Congress.

[@BoxOfOranges84]

Are you kidding me? She's freaking chair of the DNC. Listen to her on cable news and you'll see she's the biggest political operative in the game right now (next to the RNC chair, of course). EVERYTHING that comes out of her mouth is for political gain. But I'll give her credit, she has you completely fooled.

[@KillgoreTrout43]

She speaks for the party, not herself. That's her job. That is not acting for personal gain.

[@esquerdista2952]

You sure about that?

[@realmarktilford]

Yeah, DWS- How did that "Middle of the Road" strategy work out for you?

[@crabjuice47]

Who do they have that can defeat Hilary. Oh you sweet summer child.

[@mikalhernandez]

The hypocrisy is thick in this one. 🤣

[@EHCBunny4real]

Why limit yourself. We can be artists, technicians,engineers scientists and mathematicians . Da Vinci was one.

[@TheChucnoris]

ewwwww why are you backing her up? Bad move dude

[@aeroscience9834]

3:00-3:42. If the problem relating to STEM education is immigration as you said it, why do we need special grants for women and minorities in this country? Makes no sense.

[@xxnotmuchxx]

NDT's YT channel is StarTalk Radio.

[@bobbyington2422]

Schultz is not for the people, she;s for what she wants which is not want the people want! Bernie 2016!

[@ianmonam]

I have a degree in engineering and 19 years experience writing software for some very sophisticated applications. I'm now finishing nursing school, because I can't find a full time job in engineering. I was born and raised in the US. We don't need to import engineers, there are plenty like me to be found.

[@MrSERGEANT100]

Software engineering? Depends on which kind. Could be your just in the wrong area. I can't really say on it, but you just may have to check a different area. Best I got from what your saying.

[@ianmonam]

I don't know. Was laid off in March 02, and have only worked contract jobs since then. Have given up and earned a degree in nursing. When I was first laid off, was about the time of the dot com bust, and the country was full of out of work software engineers. I would rather work in software than nursing (better hours and not as gross), but that has been the reality for me. In part, it is because many jobs like the one I had can be done remotely (i.e. overseas). However, it does seem many work in this country still in that field, but it has evaporated for me.

[@ianmonam]

Thanks. Have a good night.

[@dillonbruyer2963]

I was in steam and it was soooooooooo fun! :)

[@danpiper9184]

I hope we get that woman president in 2016! I mean, who have they got to beat her?

[@wiggalama]

:)

[@Caryutunarkzew]

NO to water!

[@deblibra6884]

My family has degrees and for Black engineers coming out of college. Corporations are asking for 5-8 years experience and not giving them the jobs. They have straight A's but are working for 10,00 an hour and can't pay student loans that paid for that terrific engineering degree. H1B visas are being hired and their hiring their family and friends. I'm tired of hearing that Americans aren't educating their kids for the complex future technologies. They are and their suffering for it. Can't get the job. It makes noo sense.

[@strazze14]

I am in a similar situation and can only get contract positions. My friends from college are worse off. One, a geologist and the other, a climatologist are working at walmart and Victoria secret respectively.

[@anaruskie]

"I don't know who they have that would defeat Hillary" hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahhahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaahahahahahahahaahahahhahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha God that's too good

[@matthewotto8322]

Never underestimate the Democrats' ability to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory

[@alanb3163]

2:55 "because we are getting our.." ... "because we are not educating.." Can anyone decipher what she said between those quotes??

[@timetraveler6615]

Neil looks so uncomfortable not talking. It’s either he is talking and looks comfortable or he is not talking, looking around everywhere, moving to and fro, which makes him look uncomfortable.

[@artsHscience]

Having trouble getting through this episode All the time she speaks I'm muttering "fuck you Debbie, fuck you Debbie"... You can tell from her voice that she smokes 2 packs a day and probably drinks a lot.

[@Ochoaj300]

SAME HAHA

[@Rabadamtimtimti]

If DW Schultz wins the democratic nomination, it will be a walk-over for the GOP. Especially if their nominee is Chris Christie.

[@langa77777]

the new rising star just quoted a movie for philosophical purpose. nice la

[@thelovebelow3378]

Good to see Neil again.

[@abhimanyukarnawat7441]

tea party is love

[@starkiller18]

i would love to see Elizabeth Warren run for president that woman is amazing.

[@darreljames7453]

One reason why you see so many foreign owned businesses here, their kids are coming here on grants and so much more.

[@tryingtobefairandobjective3480]

Rob must be there for contrast.

[@kattengat2]

Yea. The other day on the rose parade they referenced STEAM and I was thinking what’s the A? When they said Art, I was thinking that defeats the purpose.

[@ashiko19]

Ah man! I missed an episode with Neil degrass Tyson and Rob Lowe?! I hope it's on demand

[@vladwanderer7422]

Bill, I am somewhat surprised that you were unable to recognize Neil's message about importance of our society collectively to be able to recognize one of the "First Priority" goal thar majority will accept as the NEEDED ONE

[@CraigTalbert]

5:52 because there's never hyperbole or exaggeration in movies.

[@elsecretopez]

i didn't understand what was the woman's offer/policy? can anyone help?

[@occasional_doomer]

Well, not everyone can really live up to the standards set by a guy like Da Vinci. He was a rare human being.

[@fathertimegaming17]

Imagine if you were able to go back and tell them that Donald Trump would be elected president and 2016. You would get laughed out of that room and even perhaps institutionalized.

[@ThumbsHunter]

Bush Clinton Bush Obama Clinton? Talking about choice....

[@DanOfAwsome]

hopefully not another bush.

[@lobelia1997]

Dan Cosme ron paul 2012!

[@MRxLUGIAx]

lobelia1997 im glad im not the only believer ron paul 2012

[@Hentarded]

The woman on the panel says to get more women into engineering we need incentives to benefit them. At college level no. At highschool level maybe as that is where young individuals make their life choices or atleast start getting an idea what to do. Over here in UK there are special engineering events and scholarships for women in engineering at university level, but are wasted because the young girls who need to be influenced (highschool students) aren't getting this information. Even then I doubt the number of girls would drastically increase in engineering as it's down to choosing what they want to do and since UK and USA have freedom of choice it appears they choose not to do STEM.

[@YoungEducationUSA]

I cant believe my hero NDGT just hinted that without government we wouldn't even have highways...everything else though right on as always. We certainly need much better priorities and we dont need government programs in order to provide incentives to raise interest in education.

[@chrispa9573]

Where was Coultergeist?

[@Texaroni1231]

I think the problem with the immigration issue is that different people, in different parts of the nation, are experiencing immigration differently. While she's discussing immigration that's involved with allowing bright minds to get an education here (which I think is amazing), I live in South Texas and see a COMPLETELY DIFFERENT aspect of immigration. I see the type of immigration where cartel coyotes are running people across the border, stuffing them into vehicles, and holding them hostage in homes for weeks without releasing them. I see the part of immigration where 30 immigrants pile out of a van and vanish into your neighborhood. It doesn't generally seem scary, but when you have no idea who these people are and where they come from, it's quite frightening. How many of them are seeking work, fugitives from their home country, extremists intent on doing us harm? There are different avenues of immigration and they should be addressed separately.

[@alexconn6149]

Who is watching this in 2017 with Debbie Wasserman Shultz being a corrupt

[@RiasatKhanSakif]

TYSON....HELL YEAH!

[@lasttango4609]

Neil for President !

[@alecrains6481]

They still belelieved hillary would win. The good times

[@giordanobruno9106]

neil is the only 1 worth listening to on this crappy panel.

[@DHVester]

good old Neil, bring him back more often

[@blinktwiceforyes4820]

Moderates are why we have a disparity in wealth.

[@navylaks2]

Bill What about Jill Stein the green candidat

[@kattengat2]

Wasserman - what a criminal.

[@FPSchazly]

i agree. there was a lot less shit to know back then. even if we all may have the potential to do anything, that potential tends to get pretty refined in high school. i mean, if you didn't take algebra 2 or even pre calc in high school, youre gonna have a hard time doing engineering in college. also, willpower and motivation play a huge role in how well you learn. if you really dislike a subject or have no interest in it, it's going to be very hard to stay course and learn that discipline.

[@Qswizzle1]

I am against it

[@frejagonzalez2347]

I love Neil Degrasse Tyson.

[@thecronus524]

I have so much more respect for Bill Maher and Neil deGrasse Tyson ... I would never sit next to a cobra. #CouldHaveBeenBern

[@willpache]

Please, enable subtitles in Portuguese. PLEAAAAAAASE

[@bboyroxas]

NEIL NEIL

[@jo-jovolkswagen7136]

what you mean water ? but the water from what I understand it mean the order

[@janniknordbykjeldsen8767]

Here is a mad thought. Dismantle congress and the senate and make a parliamentary system with MULTIPLE parties, so you can get stuff done with a broad democratic vote and the loons can throw poop as they always do!

[@yonisgure7348]

"the best word you can get out of those letters" lol, somebody's a Yankee fan.