Religious Israelis: Does it bother you that I am an atheist?

[@axlfoley7795]

A Muslim should ask other Muslims the same question and see what happens 😊

[@taha.Rabeeah]

70% of the Arabs are religious. We naturally reject atheism. The general reaction is that we will be sad and call on the atheist to worship the one God so that he will not be punished after death.

[@vencentjansen]

Because Muslims are true believers By the way am not Muslim But i have to say the truth it's bother me that group of ppl decided to kill and steal Palestinians land for religious reasons and then they became not religious anymore this is horrific

[@axlfoley7795]

@@vencentjansen I am upset that people are uneducated as yourself.I would love to talk unbiased history with you. Because they didn’t steal anybody’s land , nothing to do with biblical times either

[@fahadkhan5721]

@@axlfoley7795 The UN says otherwise

[@axlfoley7795]

@@fahadkhan5721 you mean the un partition plan the Arabs rejected ? And then tried to exterminate the Jews, and lost

[@reddragonready]

I, an atheist, once was sitting in a kitchen in Tel Aviv with 2 haredimin their early twenties..one was trying to tell me to convert to Judaism..in a most polite manner. The other, who had known me since he was 9, was telling the first..don't bother, she already believes in what we believe. Referring to the essence rather than the rules of religion

[@dannyarcher6370]

Nice story. 😊

[@interestingyoutubechannel1]

Beautiful story.

[@nathanj109]

As a non Jew who is curious, can I ask what was their meaning of the word behind “essence”?

[@neortik7]

they want you to believe in Talmud ? I personnaly believe in Jesus but i don't agree with all the religious teaching of this World specially Catholics. The most important opinion is from the Lord. The Lord was against tradition of men. Sadly men that believe in Jesus Christians continued to follow tradition and add humans laws not created than God

[@RabiaSammy]

you sjoudlnt convert to judaism you should be a noachide

[@darksol99darkwizard]

I can’t wait to see the palestinian version of this

[@Arbnvbe]

like jews in Islam it is said that we are one, and we are responsible for one another.

[@ori1676]

In Gaza you can get unalive even if your'e from the wrong militia that opposing Hamas. let alone if you're openly Atheist

[@tommykawaii]

There has already been a video about that. The answers were way less brotherly 😬

[@lalove4574]

- extemists muslims think like extremist jews - moderate muslims also think like extremists jews - while moderate jews are very open-minded -- that's why, as an Atheist, I prefer Jews/Judaism over Muslims/Islam

[@achilles7607]

​​@@lalove4574 And still your statement is only partly correct. While orthodox Jews might be considered extremists, and they will be upset by an atheist Jew, they will not force their religion upon him nor hurt him in anyway. Extremists Muslims absolutely will do those things.

[@kawhileonard3745]

Loved how the haredim explained it. Insightful

[@eladsinger9215]

Deep and caring believers.

[@uriel7203]

The last guy, in my opinion, articulated it the best. Simply stated, when your brother is hurt, even if he doesn't know that he is hurt, you still care aboit him.

[@barakingplayz5581]

I'm sorry but when a religious person say that someone chose the "wrong path" when they decide to not believe in god, that can only cause devide. Just accept someone think in a different way than you and stfu

[@uriel7203]

@barakingplayz5581 In my experience, the most fanatically religious people are athiests. I don't understand what kind of divide this man has caused you. Remember, he didn't approach the athiest, rather it was the athiest. Not only did he approach the religious person, but he also decided to engage the religious one on the topic of beliefs. So the religious one replied. So maybe it is you who needs to "stfu" because you are clearly not self-conscious. You also didn't care to take into account that the religious one did not push away the athiest or even hinted to doing so. As a matter of fact, no religious one in the video felt threatened or was hostile towards the athiest. You are the only one here who displayed hostility.

[@RoVicD]

Sorry but it's condesending to tell me that I'm on the wrong path or to tell me what's huring me. I can decide for myself.

[@barakingplayz5581]

@@uriel7203 I want to remind you that people usually don't act in fanatic way when filmed, but you're really going to say the ones who spit on girls, or tell girls to go to the back of the bus, or call people names for not abiding by their religious beliefs are really the moderate ones?

[@uriel7203]

@barakingplayz5581 what are you talking about? I'm an "ultra-Orthodox" Jew. I live in an Ultra-Orthodox enviroment. We go around, and I never saw anything you said. You remind me of the Hamas media that either flat out lies or mines like a gold miner to find the most deviant behavior and apply that on everyone. That is exactly what I mean by athiests being fanatical. Tell me, are you one of those who describes themselves as a militant athiest?

[@rich9587]

Thank you for taking the time to run this channel the way that you do. I think you are doing important work.

[@Kasha5784]

A chareidi would feel deeply saddened by the joy, security, meaning and connection an atheist would be missing out on by not believing in G-d. BUT that would not affect my love for you my Jewish brother! A Jewish soul is a Jewish soul and is eternally part of the Jewish nation (and welcome in my home and heart and table always regardless of level of observance!)

[@TSIRHCSEVAS]

No Torah commands different. You are part of Israel commonwealth only if you go after Hashem of Abraham Isaac and Jacob

[@Kasha5784]

@@TSIRHCSEVAS Not sure where you're getting your info, but speaking as a chareidi, we are commanded to love every Jew regardless of observance (but still mourn those alienated from their birthright.

[@EWaugh1]

​@@Kasha5784Hopefully you are commanded to love the non-Jew as well.

[@interestingyoutubechannel1]

@@EWaugh1 Of course we are! All Jews, whether non-religious or religious, know the verses such as "love the stranger, as you were strangers in the land of Egypt" and many similar laws of ancient Israel. Human beings are to be cared for, according to our traditions. That doesn't mean that we don't have a special place in our heart for a brother/sister from our ancient nation, that's natural, like for every people.

[@EWaugh1]

@@interestingyoutubechannel1 If a German were to say that he loves Germans more than other people how would you react?

[@BrentStrathdeePehi]

I can accept and understand both sides tbh - for modern open minded more individualistic Jews it’s natural to not be bothered at all but for more traditional collective minded Jews there could be a concern that the Jewish identity and religious culture is slowly but surely being lost to modernity…

[@Thenoobestgirl]

True

[@jaredf6205]

I think the biggest thing is that we know belief in God is not required to be ethnically Jewish or culturally Jewish, and in general even religiously Jewish, as in an observant practicing Jew still need not believe that God exists. A belief in God is in fact, not a requirement of practicing Judaism. I can think of so many reasons why it might upset people though. I think some people may genuinely worry about your “spiritual health” especially if they see you as a brother. They may get great benefit from their belief in God and feel sorry that you are not experiencing the same thing in the same way that they are. I think a lot of people may feel insecure, they spend their whole life dedicated to God, they spend all their spiritual effort on the belief of God, They put a lot of genuinely hard work into living a religious life dedicated to God, and to come across someone who’s going through all the work of practicing the religion from their point of view for no reason, It could cause a lot of complicated and insecure feelings.

[@manos5464]

Τhis modernity created Israel. Not some primitives with ponytails doing nothing all day than reading a specific book.

[@marcwells03]

It pains me as a Jewish atheist that my fellow Jewish brothers believe in a sky daddy. How are they not embarrassed to believe in such fairytales?

[@blackout8630]

@@marcwells03 So if you were in front of Corey and he asked you "Does it bother you that people believe in God" you wouldn't know how to answer on that spot right? Because I'm putting money that you wouldn't let the words you wrote here come out of your mouth. Even more in-depth: to Jewish believers we believe the whole nation witnessed God giving us the Torah on Mount Sinai, hearing that there are people calling themselves Jewish while having no belief in that God(who created our world) is considered ungrateful and we see that as a direct blow to our religion. Jewish = Judaism = Torah and in the Torah it says (loosely quote): "You will not add or take from what is written in the Torah".

[@Danafeuer]

I went through the ghiur (process of conversion to Judaism), at a very young age, after being born to a Catholic mom and a Jewish dad, I'm still religious to a certain point, and I must say, how beautiful it is that everyone was so respectful to you, even the most observant (Lubavitch) and all. The difference between us and sadly, many others.

[@MohammedHassan-ym8qf]

Joseph, Jacob, Samson, Abraham, salomon, saul, david, daniel, Isaac, and Moses, were Mslims

[@MohammedHassan-ym8qf]

Islam was the first religion it started with Adam and ended with prophet Muhammad pbuh

[@seifhabache6548]

unless you're muslim of course

[@Danafeuer]

​@@MohammedHassan-ym8qf exactly what I was speaking about. Here we have an example.

[@MohammedHassan-ym8qf]

​@@Danafeueryou know Islam is the right path 🕋🤲

[@Dhua_diary]

2:09 bro got instantly depressed 😬😂

[@mazaltov-indonesia]

why question should goes to the interviewer

[@Lilbendem]

Amazing to see how open minded many of them are. No need to force beliefs onto others.

[@ori1676]

In Judaism you dont just k, ll another Jew just because hes secular or Atheist, its not like in Islam. in fact in the Talmud there was a Rabi that went Atheist and left Judaism ( Rish Lakish) and his community still respected him after

[@axlfoley7795]

Because there not Muslim

[@Kasha5784]

@@ori1676 Beautiful comment but I think you're mixing it up with another Tanna. Raish Lakish did not leave the fold.

[@ori1676]

@@Kasha5784 You are right it was Rabbi Elisha Ben Abuyah, Talmud Bavli, Tractate Chagiga (I had to ask ChatGPT) it possible to read about him on ChatGPT as well

[@ori1676]

@@Kasha5784 You are right that Rabbi which left the religion was Elisha Ben Abuyah and hes mentined in the Babilonian Talmud

[@TheTacoMonger]

I love the Israeli people. Good hearts

[@divemylollol6152]

God bless them amen

[@sharonrichards1627]

@taco, Go watch the documentary "Holy Redemption: Stealing Palestinian Land" and get back to us.

[@mcb00]

Except when it comes to war

[@mcb00]

Gaza says otherwise

[@csfiskus610]

I'm Jewish and observant. I don't care what people believe in or if they believe at all. My biggest issue with secular Jews isn't so much that they don't practice or believe. It's that most of whom I met seem to care more about everyone else except for Jews, especially religious/Orthodox ones. I'd love for you to do a video segment on that.

[@interestingyoutubechannel1]

I don't think that's true, I'm an atheist Israeli Jew and I care a lot about Jews too. Most of the secular people I know care deeply for all brothers & sister of our people. With orthodox Jews, its not that I don't like all of them, or anything like that, its that I find it frustrating how they have preferential rights above the rest of us e.g. we have to go to the army they don't, we have to work, many orthodox live on welfare because they want to study Torah and Talmud all day. Many of orthodox are in the worst levels of poverty, and they don't "lift themselves up", so the State tries to. Again, I would never judge an orthodox person when meeting him, everyone is an individual, and I know some wonderful people who are orthodox, but I'm talking in general.

[@yoezra]

The problem is that the religious people in Israel are forcing their way of life on the secular Jews. Live and let live. Practice your basifies and leave us alone.

[@Gideon01]

Do you really not understand where the antagonism comes from? I'm talking only about Israel! As for religious/orthodox Jews living anywhere else in the world, We seculars have zero problems with them.

[@Thenoobestgirl]

Do you live in Israel? Because here in Israel I feel like the seculars care very much about ourselves versus everyone else.

[@jasonkemmerer5654]

@@Thenoobestgirl if you truly care about the most important thing about you which is your own soul then you will seek after GOD/ADONAI with your whole heart and find HIM. and HE Will show you The Way to Salvation/YESHUA

[@juansinmiedo7096]

¡Gracias!

[@tylerlately]

As long as a society is secular, we're not enemies

[@ForeverRepublic]

I wouldn't say Israel is a fully secular society.

[@V20147]

@@ForeverRepublic the society lives by secular standards with religious characteristics, we have a lot of religious people from different religions, and also a lot of non-religious, and usually we're very tolerant to different views and harming someone because of their beliefs is unacceptable, this is the only way for people to live freely and fully expressed.

[@ForeverRepublic]

@V20147 I agree completely. I was just comparing it to France, where I spent a good portion of my childhood. When you live abroad you realize that we take our small Jewish country for granted. Our values are reflected in our society and that's a very good thing in my opinion.

[@playinglifeoneasy9226]

This is why many of us are not so anxious to have a theocracy in Israel and current Israeli society there would be a place for me, but if we had the heifer and the Temple and all that I feel like there would be no place for me and my children. I prefer Judy the way it is you do what you wanna do what you feel you can and everybody hopes that you are doing well and that you stay connected the line between religious and not religious. I know a lot of people at some point, they’re religious then another other point they’re not and then they are again and then maybe they’re not or maybe they are but sometimes and you know people do what they can and the ideas to stay connected and you know have fun. Holidays are for fun, once you have central authority, it becomes a problem.

[@extremebeastreaction6245]

@@playinglifeoneasy9226I don’t really know if there’s no place to live because people during David’s time did have Samarians who are similar to secular and they also had almost gangs, well that is what caused the destruction of the temple but. It is because there was no togetherness and people didn’t respect each other.

[@bit7389]

Just do me a favour and don't send an Ex-Muslim with the same question to "Palestine".

[@nathanj109]

There are Christians in Palestine. I’ve seen videos of how the Isreal people treat Christians 💦 So let’s stop the bs please

[@timmysleftnutsack5075]

Palestinians have bigger things to worry about than some stupid question for a bunch of chronically online KZbin users.

[@jimmyvolakis5194]

#FromTheRiverToTheSea #FreePalestine 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸

[@nanahasanah4457]

"Tidak ada paksaan dalam memasuki agama islam" Al-baqarah : 256 , pernakah kamu berpikir kenapa masih ada kota tua yerusalem dengan tiga agama yahudi, kristen, islam bahkan dibawah kepemimpinan muslim, tiga agama itu hidup berdampingan sebelum penjajahan inggris, karena itu adalah ajaran islam "semua manusia sama dimata Allah yang membedakan hanya ketakwaannya" Al-hujurat :13 , bahkan orang-orang yahudi dilindungi saat perang salib, nabi Muhammad saw membuat PIAGAM MADINAH untuk mempersatukan yahudi dimadinah yang selalu bertikai, sebaiknya kita belajar lebih banyak sejarah.

[@nanahasanah4457]

"Tidak ada paksaan dalam memasuki agama islam" Al-baqarah : 256 , pernakah kamu berpikir kenapa masih ada kota tua yerusalem dengan tiga agama yahudi, kristen, islam bahkan dibawah kepemimpinan muslim, tiga agama itu hidup berdampingan sebelum penjajahan inggris, karena itu adalah ajaran islam "semua manusia sama dimata Allah yang membedakan hanya ketakwaannya" Al-hujurat :13 , bahkan orang-orang yahudi dilindungi saat perang salib, nabi Muhammad saw membuat PIAGAM MADINAH untuk mempersatukan yahudi dimadinah yang selalu bertikai, sebaiknya kita belajar lebih banyak sejarah.

[@MrLetmein2011]

Wonderful open minded people, God bless you 🙏🏻💙

[@Augusto4888]

G** Don't exist and colonizers like you should ***

[@ciaronsmith4995]

Iran is coming. Be scared.

[@LloydChristmas-vx2wh]

Excellent and relieving answers to me.

[@58erkansivas]

I like your videos, love from Turkiye❤

[@divemylollol6152]

Are you Muslim ?

[@MarkMerkesh]

Shalom, my brother. Love your country so much! It’s gorgeous.

[@NoamTheGOAT50]

וואו, המרואיין האחרון, כל הכבוד לו, יצא תותח, לדעתי לפחות.

[@dedsecanimation9493]

Lo Hashem

[@Linda43]

A Blessed Shabbat Shalom To All Am Yisroel And Friends Of Zion 💙 🕊 💙.... All My Good Thoughts And Prayers For Our Brave Soldiers And Hostages 💙

[@yjshine6961]

It is very easy to respond to this question in the way most of the charedim did, as when one does experience the greatness in believing and learning Torah and Mitzvot, it can be difficult to see that other people in Am Yisrael are not having the same incredible experience due to our viewing each other as family. However, I think that it is important for more Rabbis to stress Ve’Ahavta L’reaha Camoha and having more faith in HaShems ways and understanding that nobody is on the “wrong path”. I think a lot of us are still operating through the survival instincts we gained from persecution and assimilation, which is somewhat valid, however this can only be achieved through love and compassion, not guilt and shame.

[@MohammedHassan-ym8qf]

If they read the Quran they'll become mslim many rabbis read the Quran and accepted prophet Muhammad pbuh and Allah last revelations through prophet Muhammad pbuh

[@tiarabite]

@@MohammedHassan-ym8qf Quite poetic that on a post of a jew who mentions issues caused by persecution and assimilation, comes a reply of a muslim preaching. The lack of self awareness is stupefying and astounding.

[@RomanPer]

@@MohammedHassan-ym8qf lol. Do you have the exact count of "many" rabbis that became Muslim? It's so easy to throw around the bs statements like this "Many rabbis accepted Quran" lol

[@Kasha5784]

@@MohammedHassan-ym8qf Thanks anyway, we are very happy and fulfilled with our Torah and have very little interest in looking elsewhere!

[@bigdawg8676]

​@@MohammedHassan-ym8qf60000 muslims convert to judaism everyday.

[@kylesavage4525]

Despite being an atheist myself i can see why they feel that way . If i was religious i am sure that it would sadden me too if people close to me were atheists or of any other religion because that would mean (in my religious pov) that their soul would not go to heaven and that would be a heartbreaking thought. It would be somewhat similar to watching a friend or family member choosing a path in life that is harmful like doing drugs or become a prostitute or become obese. Of course everyone has the right to choose their religion and way of life but i would definitely try to talk to them.

[@skontheroad]

Must say, spent a shabbos 15 years ago by friends in Chasmonaim (where the last interview was done) and it was one of the most memorable, uplifting, fun shabbats I have ever had--for the rest of the family too. What I do remember the most was Friday afternoon after helping to cook and prepare, we went for a walk so she could show me the community. While walking along the edge, a bunch of kids were slinging rocks and shooting bottle rockets at us. They were not little kids, nor were they little rocks! I was shocked and said, of course, "What is going on??" She said they do it EVERY Shabbat to annoy them at the least and actually do real harm at the worst (meaning it is not safe to take walks NOW). Every time I see the Palestinian kids doing that on the news I think of her and her family. And her 7 kids who all fought and served (one way or the other), to help keep us safe, even in the face of adversity, with kids across the way who have never even met you, trying to hurt you! Sad!

[@gomerpyle7721]

Well…I am sure those kids life isn’t easy, due to lots of factors. Don’t know what it is about Abrahamic religions and casting/not-casting stones at people…

[@KoveytBud]

Did/do you realize that Chasmonaim is a settlement built in the West Bank, which is an internationally-recognized Palestinian territory occupied and taken by force by Israel. According to the Applied Research Institute Jerusalem (ARIJ), Israel confiscated land from several Palestinian villages/towns nearby in order to construct Hashmonaim: 945 dunams from Ni'lin, 186 dunams from Al-Midya, 5 dunams from Saffa.

[@tg2683]

Probably kids with issues. They have them in every religion.

[@isaacabramov8434]

@@KoveytBudthose laws are intl mumbo jumbo and are used to commit jihad by kids who are indoctrinated early in life to victimize themselves and strengthen jihadism. There are intl laws that state we have the right too, and regardless, if living somewhere causes conflict and upsets people, we won’t back down; we’ll fight back

[@dua85]

​@@KoveytBudSo what? Are you implying that jews cannot live there just because they are jews?? Do you also support when French people attack Muslims in France because it's the international recognized borders of France??? Do you hear yourself?!!

[@gliboperuta9213]

this was a good interview. wish it was more people. maybe we get part 2 😊

[@ForeverRepublic]

Judaism teaches that we are responsible to each other before G-d, so from a Halachic perspective, it will bother any believing Jew. But in my view, an atheist Jew is better than a fanatic non-Jew who seeks to impose his beliefs on Jews. We also must not force our brothers and sisters, HaShem will guide them.

[@bunjijumper5345]

Judaism does not teach we are responsible for each other, it teaches Jews are responsible for each other. Non Jews are not part of that pact.

[@kalatiso5541]

@@bunjijumper5345 Those who bless the jews will be blessed back. Actions speak more than words, if you ever met a jew (doubt you have) and be friend him, you will see that a Jew will stand by your side any day. (as long as you do the same for him)

[@Dhua_diary]

* yawns * thinking victim* at it finest, no one forced you on anything, stop comparing jew to non jew in this sense, everyone lives by his own principles 👌

[@ForeverRepublic]

@@bunjijumper5345 Yes, I was referring to Jews. I don't care about non-Jewish atheists. That's not my business.

[@ForeverRepublic]

@duhaNomad No thankfully my ancestors resisted the many attempts to convert us to a foreign religion.

[@DartLuke]

When was the video made? I see many people in masks

[@Seanonyoutube]

1918 flu pandemic

[@skontheroad]

😂😂😂​@@Seanonyoutube

[@ArchiURURU]

Top secret: these masks were around even before COVID

[@BeMe91]

​@ArchiURURU and after, there are still people wearing them in a public space.

[@nathanj109]

We have many Oriental tourists in London who wore masks before and after the pandemic

[@Event_Horizon14]

I really enjoyed the perspective of the last interview! You can tell the guy really cares and is a kind soul!

[@ib3645]

The verse in Habakkuk translates as "a righteous person lives by his faith"

[@jep6752]

The Hebrew word is "by his faithfulness"" in the MT. = בֶּאֱמוּנָתוֹ The LXX and Vulgate use the words ἐκ πίστεώς and FIDE (faith) because they do not have a noun to express the Hebrew original.

[@babd3121]

@@jep6752 The Hebrew original is reflected in the LXX since the MT's oldest is from middle ages.

[@ib3645]

@@jep6752 וְצַדִּיק בֶּאֱמוּנָתוֹ יִחְיֶה אמונתו= his faith, what he believes in/trusts faithfulness=נאמנות/מהימנות depending on the context

[@silverbackhayabusa]

@@jep6752 אֱמוּנָה ʼĕmûwnâh, em-oo-naw'; or (shortened) אֱמֻנָה ʼĕmunâh; feminine of H529; literally firmness; figuratively security; morally fidelity:-faith(-ful, -ly, -ness, (man)), set office, stability, steady, truly, truth, verily. Not all translations rely on Hebrew to LXX and Vulgate then to English but also directly from Hebrew to English. It's bad to assume that the word was necessarily translated from Hebrew to Septuagint or Vulgate because you're assuming the version of Scripture a person is using when they choose faith over faithfulness. A a quick skim in a concordance shows a handful of verses with the word translated as truth, faithfulness, faith, steady, office, truly etc. In Hab 2:4, it shows the word as faith. In a lexicon, it shows both faith and faithfulness depending on the version. The theological Wordbook of the Old Testament describes it more as faith than faithfulness though it holds faithfulness as one of its meanings: "This very important concept in biblical doctrine gives clear evidence of the biblical meaning of ‘‘faith’’ in contradistinction to the many popular concepts of the term. At the heart of the meaning of the root is the idea of certainty. And this is borne out by the nT definition of faith found in Heb 11:1.

[@jep6752]

@@ib3645 That's an incorrect translation. You are probably working from the KJV or presuming the quotation of it by Paul back into the text. Here is the lexical data below: Strong's Number H530 matches the Hebrew אֱמוּנָה ('ĕmûnâ), which occurs 49 times in 49 verses in the WLC Hebrew. אֱמוּנָה noun feminine firmness, steadfastness, fidelity Exodus 17:12 + 46 times; אֱמוּנוֺת Proverbs 28:20. 1. literally firmness, steadiness

[@josephsorce2543]

"When You Write a Book Proclaiming Yourself Blessed by Your Almighty 'God' as 'The Chosen People' ... That is so Coool and of course, has ta be ... True !!!"

[@fyukfy2366]

I'm not religious and I don't believe but I completely understand how it would bother a religious person. If you was sure you knew the most moral way to live and I refused to live that way, wouldn't that bother you for both my sake and your sake and the world's sake? Doesn't it bother when other people do things you see as immoral like lying and cheating? That's just what religious people see, whether they're right or wrong is a completely different issue

[@Litefrire]

Agree it says something about their religousity if they don't admit to caring. I think bothered was the wrong world to use, it implies you would interfere if you could

[@kimc555]

The last man - very honest and kind. Can anyone explain the concept he gave of not being around or with someone who is breaking Shabbos laws?

[@ori1676]

Because Electricity or fire is forbbidin in Shabat so he doesnt want the sins to destroy the feeling of the holiness and the enviroment for him and his family

[@sheckartze]

By desicrating the shabbat in his present it reduces the atmosphere of holiness of the shabbat and this negativity affects the observant person by reducing his or hers spiritual sensitivity

[@pjaworek6793]

Love your channel

[@Armallarwin]

Bro Don't ask this question in Muslim country, because you will not receive the answer, it doesn't mean they wouldn't answer you, it means your head wouldn't be on your body. An Atheist from Afghanistan.

[@dee74raz]

If you asked that question in the Palestinian areas, your life expectancy will be shortened dramatically

[@StringUSA]

Probably not

[@MrMago11]

Oh Stop being so dramatic. Nothing will happen you coward

[@user-td4do3op2d]

Only if he was a former Muslim (apostate).

[@timmy_430]

In peace?you gotta be joking ​@@fabiorachid3430

[@yigalgurevitch2936]

Corey made a video 8 years ago asking similar questions to Palestinians kzbin.info/www/bejne/d6u1kH1sfdelqJY

[@andred7684]

If it were an ex-member of the religion of peace asking its members (the religion of peace members), it would be really ugly and the video would be censored. (Saying this as a person who wanted to do Guiur, but became atheist halfway through)

[@capncake8837]

The video wouldn’t even be released. Unless, of course, the members of that group wanted to brag about what they did to the ex-member.

[@mikicerise6250]

Well, the peacefuls are the peacefuls.

[@marianmorley]

It wouldn't actually Muslims care deeply about all human beings and are peaceful despite your islamaphobic slander

[@sarwaralam9217]

@@mikicerise6250 I wish Israel expels all Muslims and Arabs. It should be a pure Jewish nation. It is HaShems commandment. We need to preserve our purity.

[@circassian3771]

They're not bothered when people are ungrateful to their creator.... The sons of Israel ladies and gentlemen

[@ntheg]

Beautiful video thank you

[@ronanbakker]

I'm from a small Dutch Israeli subculture and I was allowed to be an atheist by parents cause they don't really like dogma's or authority (that's really fair actually). However with the war going on I feel some kind of human greater consciousness and shared emotions / dreams that you cannot deny, also if you are a non believer. And on Sundays I am fine with using technology however I will not work / study to take some time to reflect spiritually because I feel some kind of burden and mission. Dear brother I think you're also adopting the scientific worldview and I would be happy to debate with you about spirituality and faith and why it's important during hard times, which human souls, even trained ones, barely can cope.🙂

[@viosh7137]

Dutch israeli is Amstelveen or ..

[@ॐIo]

Ethno-Nationalism

[@pugo7925]

Did you mean Saturday by any chance?

[@joge2468]

@@ॐIo I wonder, are Indian reservations ethnonationalist?

[@sh25098]

The idea of a "messiah" is a disputed concept in judisem. It only appears in the later books of the torah. Also the idea that jews are not allowed to migrate back to israel or should wait for the messiah is again highly disputed . It is based on an interpertation of an oral traditional phrase , not something that was explicitly written in the torah.

[@paprikaman1124]

The Messiah is one of the 13 pillars of the Torah that were written down by rambam (rabi Moshe Ben maimon) or Maimonides It's not disputed

[@burnin8orable]

I'm curious to see how Palestinians react to this question.

[@deutscheseele]

"If you are a jew, you are a brother"

[@Howie-f3z]

Even if I am a bad, bacon-eating, Shabbos-desecrating Jew?

[@eugeniev-a4]

I am not crying 5:30

[@ori1676]

The Torah tells us " All Jews are responsble to eachother" meaning we should take care of other Jews and treat them as brothers no matter what - "כל ישראל ערבים זה לזה"

[@adnanben784]

​@@ori1676your torah is corrupted Dont you know ?wake up

[@maaz322]

Then you realize that the whole premise of the creed applies to ethnicity alone. He gets to be his loved brother simply because his birth, nothing more, not even chosen observance of a faith. I don't think there's such beliefs quite as backwards, ethnocentric, and anti-humanitarian as that. No surprise that many convicted abusers and criminals have fled to Israel and been offered protection because 'ethnic brotherhood surpasses goy law'

[@ori1676]

@@maaz322 Ethnic brotherhood as you called it (Tribal thinking) is a human trait that exist in everyone of us and exist in every ethnicity. dont be naive or lie to yourself. other ethnicites care for eachothers as well

[@realDanielAugustine]

@@ori1676 Yeah, that's not what this is.

[@i8fish]

I look forward to you asking the same question to your Palestinian brothers in the West Bank.

[@flyingrobotduck]

I wonder what the response would have been in Muslim countries. Not that all Muslims are intolerant (I know that isn't true), but I guarantee the response would be far less understanding.

[@gomerpyle7721]

Little harder to pin down the beliefs of 2 billion Muslims versus 16 million Jews

[@flyingrobotduck]

@gomerpyle7721 They've done polls, the results are not good. I'm not trying to bash Muslims, in fact I think we should support moderate Muslims who oppose Islamists. Israel treats non Jews (including Muslims) far better than any Muslim country treats non Muslims.

[@gomerpyle7721]

@@flyingrobotduck I agree wholeheartedly. I think Islam is currently undergoing a reformation- it won’t be pretty (if Christianity/Judaism past is a model). Just look at the way most Arab nations are handling Palestine- no takers at the moment…but should they have to?

[@mariembenltaief6097]

​@@flyingrobotduckhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh.....you little poor mind Israeli treats muslims better than any other muslim country 😂😂😒 Are you serious........ Proud to be arab muslim from arab country.....hatts of love to all arabs country ❤❤❤ There is no way you come to understand how cool are they,best people in the world Respectful,loving,joyful,funny...and the most important think that they never misbehave with innocent people Keep praising your beloved israel,it what brainwashed people like you deserve,enjoy your system which is sh*** according to us,and we will enjoy our systems

[@dogbert52]

A salad of taqqyia + chop chop

[@npgibson69]

Does it bother them that I’m Hindu? Backstory: my great grandfather died in 1926 and my great grandma, with three young kids, left the Jewish community in Philadelphia. My mother got into Krishna and I was born. Some of my cousins are Christian; does that bother anybody?

[@interestingyoutubechannel1]

Why would it bother us? We respect your right to live how you want to live, end of story.

[@ori1676]

So yes you are Jewish by ethnicity but you can choose to live how you decide

[@EAlyahya]

So the haredim will say they feel bothered, but the datim won’t.

[@mazaltov-indonesia]

the interviewees should ask you back "lamah" - "why"

[@ladelet263]

The date is unfortunately a bit deceiving. This is obviously a rerelease from Covid approx. 3-4 years ago

[@luloa1107]

Atheist but believes Palestine is his “home land”. The irony 😂😂

[@Woobyer]

🤦 It’s about history and indigenous people not religion that anyone can interpret differently.

[@dannyarcher6370]

Now go ask the Muslims in Ramallah and Hebron.

[@Thebluewidesky]

What the heck they gonna do? They are busy keeping an eye from israleis like baruch goldestien to not make another masscre because they aren't jewish.

[@DarkwolfTurismandentertainment]

They will respond with a chapter of Quran. Basically ordering muhammed to tell non believers "your religion is yours,my religion is mine." Everybody is responsible from their religion

[@dannyarcher6370]

@@DarkwolfTurismandentertainment which is why the have a funeral for anyone who leaves Islam, right?

[@sarwaralam9217]

@@dannyarcher6370 I wish Israel expels all Muslims and Arabs. It should be a pure Jewish nation. It is HaShems commandment.

[@nanahasanah4457]

​@@dannyarcher6370 Al-baqarah: 256 "tidak ada paksaan dalam memasuki agama islam" Muslim percaya semua manusia akan bertanggung jawab akan dosanya masing- masing dihadapan Tuhan, pernakah kamu berpikir kenapa kota tua yerusalem dengan tiga agama, yahudi, kristen, islam masih ada dan hidup berdampingan bahkan sewaktu kepemimpinan muslim, bahkan sewaktu perang salib orang- orang yahudi dilindungi oleh orang muslim, Al-hujurat:13 "semua manusia sama dimata Allah yang membedakan hanya ketakwaannya " Nabi Muhammad saw membuat PIAGAM MADINAH dan itu untuk orang-orang yahudi, sebaiknya kita lebih banyak belajar sejarah.

[@JohnDoe-eo8ux]

Repent, and believe in the gospel. ☦️Christ is Lord✝️

[@roserose749]

Akin to a guy having 100 dollar bills and he doesnt realize their value so wastes it as toilet paper... it would be upsetting to watch that. Seeing anything of value, devalued is upsetting. A Jewish atheist who doesnt understand the value and richness of Judaism is sad.

[@fyukfy2366]

There's no such thing as a Jewish atheist, any Jew can appreciate the culture and traditions and community our people provide even without believing. I don't believe in god yet I still live in Israel, fast on Yom kippur, go to synagogue on the high holidays and have kiddush with my family every Shabbat. Am I less Jewish than someone who believes in god yet keeps none of our traditions?

[@oreytan8160]

@@fyukfy2366 im probably more atheist than most of the jews i still see myself as part of the people and the nation

[@capncake8837]

@@fyukfy2366 The word “Jew” can refer to both someone who practices Judaism or someone who is a member of the Jewish ethnic group. As such, it is possible for an ethnic Jew to be atheist. That doesn’t change their ethnicity.

[@dfs-comedy]

I am a Jewish atheist who understands and appreciates the value and richness of Jewish heritage and culture, but who also cannot believe in a God.

[@arielaw4]

I think what you mean to say is doesn't understand the beautiful relationship with God. Many non believing Jews very much see the richness and value in Judaism itself

[@Adam20672]

Can you do "I am a Christian, does that bother you ?"

[@manyalevine1017]

I think that believing in God is an amazing thing. I would want that for a person I care for and since I care for all my Jewish brothers and sisters I want for them the best.

[@joshuamartinpryce1237]

I think true faith is not swayed by difference and it is honouring all despite class and religion. False religion is focused on boasting itself, but true faith humbly accepts the opinions of others. Atheists are bothered by religious folk but Christians allow God to be the judge.

[@adelabdallah4930]

Why do colonizers think that judaism has to do with a nationality? What if their grandparent from europe converted to judaism they become indigenous to land of moses? Also many palestinians had jewish ancestors who converted to christianity and islam as it's a matter of faith that would be changed so that's a Disrupted mentality if someone thinks judaism is a nationality... But only zionists think so ofc i mean they gotta give any reason to colonize even if that's prohibited in judaism to have their own land until God wills

[@stud6414]

Why are the Arabs in Morocco of they hail from Saudi Arab. Did they colonize the place

[@shorletav]

If someone you care about wants to do something self-destructive…heroine, reckless driving, whatever…do, you care?

[@Dexuz]

The main question should be, "is it really self-destructive? Maybe I'm wrong".

[@GhostlySD]

Questions about the increase in Israeli secularism would be interesting.

[@HowlingWo1f]

As a Jew, I can tell you that we all feel connected and like brothers in one family, so those that are religious and observant, it will be painful as if it was one from their own family, but for those who are secular this is not important to them, as long as ur happy. Every Jew is connected like a family, and we look out for each other because we always had to, So become part of our genetics 🇮🇱🇮🇱

[@psalux18963]

"Become part of our genetics"? I'd like to know how much of their DNA is shared between askenazi jews and iranian jews, and then make a comparision between palestinian arabs and the 2 groups mentioned before. I am sure that palestinians would share more DNA with each of the 2 groups than the jews of the 2 groups between them. Because, despite mixing with other people, the palestinian arabs have the most pure ancient jewish DNA, or ancient canaanite DNA (the ancient jews were just a subgroup of canaanites). And if we make a comparision about the shared DNA of ethiopian jews with indian jews, or chinese jews, what do you think we would find?

[@npgibson69]

@@psalux18963I have lymphoma, which is not well understood, but believed to have a significant genetic component. The incidence of lymphoma is twice the global average among Palestinians, and tripled among Ashkenazim. It seems we are connected in a meaningful way. I think maybe they should stop bombing hospitals, but what do I know?

[@joge2468]

@@psalux18963 If you’re sincerely interested in the genetics, Razib Khan has done a great meta-analysis of the research to date.

[@kaifreyleue5961]

I'd be curious to see a question for Israeli Jews in general: How often do you go to synagogue? Where I live, a lot of people only go to church on Christmas and Easter. I wonder if it's similar among Israeli Jews where most only go to synagogue a few times a year, or not at all.

[@oreytan8160]

About 50% or more not going to synagogue at all

[@asafheller5720]

Orthodox go 3 times a day, holidays and even to classes over Alacha, Talmud and or other books like Zohar, Religious Jews go 3 times a day, holidays and classes, Traditional Jews (Mesoratim) goes 3 times a day and holidays in the Mesoratim you have also those that only go during holidays, and regular Israelis that are in between go mostly on holidays - excluding the secular ones that just celebrate the holidays at home and small minority that dont do even that.

[@alexaiz7521]

it deppends on the comunity. being jew dont translate to being religios. its firstly atnicity going hand in hand with religion. the ppl in israel have many comunities with diffrent relationship to religion. some going almost to the letter and that the usually black traditional clothing or those that going with kipia and tsitsit under the clothing. then there are the traditionalist that keep the food related things and maybe going to the tample from time to time and there are those that mostly look on this part as part of our historical calture but not religous at all basicly atheist

[@MsBhappy]

In 2016, 33% of Israeli Jews said they never went to synagogue (vs weekly or monthly) and only 21% said they prayed daily (vs 61% of Israeli Muslims) (Pew).

[@interestingyoutubechannel1]

I'm Israeli Jew, I don't go to synagogue at all. Only for friend's or family member's bar mitzvah etc.

[@ramblingrootscamp]

How can an atheist still be considered jewish because it is a nationality but if a jewish person converts to islam or chtistianity no longer considered a jew?

[@sapiruwu3799]

First - ethnicity Second, even if you convert to other religions you will still be considered a jew, I have a friend who converted to Christianity and ppl here describe him as the Christian jew

[@ramblingrootscamp]

@@sapiruwu3799 since most of the Palestinian population is descended from Israelite populations that converted as DNA and Sir Names prove why are they not considered Jewish ethnically? They have lower % of outside admixtures then Ashkenazis and Sephardic Jews?

[@sapiruwu3799]

@ramblingrootscamp that is a subject that was debated alot. I think the whole ethnicity thing is bs but anyways, the claim is that after about 4 generations of no jewish identity in the family you won't be considered a jew and ud have to convert. Especially if you are a men and hadn't have Brit Mila. Do keep in mind, some would still consider them to be jews anyways but that's why I don't like this. There is definitely a Jewish identity that almost every jew I met has, but maybe it's just like trauma bonding lol

[@sapiruwu3799]

@ramblingrootscamp also alot of Palestinians today are not decended of the Israelites. Majority came from Arabia/jordan/Syria/Egypt I'm sure there are some Israelites there but they are a minority

[@79joddy]

A lot of religious people but judging by the number of face masks they seem to have little faith.

[@oreytan8160]

Lol the mask was a law in Israel in the corona pandemic time

[@tg2683]

hhmmmm maybe they are just following the law

[@arielaw4]

That's not how Jewish faith works. Most Jews believe you need to take action. There's a joke that goes along the lines of a man is stuck on his roof and there is massive flooding. A car comes by, a boat comes by, and a helicopter comes by telling him to hop in as they will save him. The man replies each time, 'no thank you, god will save me.' Then he dies and he asks god why didn't you save me?' And god replies, 'what do you mean? I sent you a car and boat, and a helicopter.' So you shouldn't be reckless and think it's okay because God will save you. That's not how it works.

[@MsBhappy]

I guess you don't ever wear a seatbelt, don't ever wear sunscreen, don't brush your teeth, don't get any vaccines, don't ever carry an umbrella or raincoat on a cloudy day... Because fAiTH

[@ladelet263]

Joddy the date is unfortunately a bit deceiving. This is obviously a rerelease from Covid 3-4 years ago

[@RealAlfredMahpud]

4:36 he explained it good

[@OktaviusBiedermann]

Religious hardliner have always been a problem for humanity.

[@choyayahyah]

Maybe he should ask people like you if you have an issue with religious people? Obviously you do

[@OktaviusBiedermann]

@@choyayahyah I'm religious myself lol

[@divemylollol6152]

@@OktaviusBiedermannwe don’t know if heaven and hell are real place anyway until someone comes back from heaven

[@eddihaskell]

The founders of Israel Theodore Herzl, Ben Gurion, Golda Meir, and Yizhak Rabin called themselves atheists. This had nothing to do with their Judaism and belief in the Jewish People, Zionism, and necessity for the State of Israel. They are two separate issues.

[@Pasture_Prime]

The same Ben Gurion that told the peel commission 1937 "the Bible is our deed to the land"

[@eddihaskell]

@@Pasture_Prime That has nothing to do with belief in a divine being.

[@Pasture_Prime]

​@@eddihaskell you said it had nothing to do with their Judaism. Bro smh

[@israteeg752]

Rabin was not a founder, but rather a participant . At time of the Israeli Declaration of Independence Rabin was and army officer, not a statesman. Second, Ben Gurion was a secular person but did believe in God, and specifically mentioned this in an interview with the Israeli Tv during the late 60'es. If you understand Hebrew, please check the following link. kzbin.info/www/bejne/hICae4yhmd93mqs

[@nashbeuh]

You're jewish? Yes! Ok brother! So reassuring that you are!

[@israteeg752]

If you are not Jewish, a Charedi Jew wouldn't care either way.

[@Zack-hv9cl]

it makes sense to ask the next question : do u feel closer to an ethiest jew or to a christian or muslem believe in God ?

[@ori1676]

He already asked it the answers were mixed

[@POONANI-m2r]

try this in an islamic country.

[@handsomestik]

Yeah you are right

[@Matzieu1]

Does it bother you that they are not bothered?

[@gary9933]

If you were a gentile i think they wouldn't care either way.

[@dani-ks9cg]

A few weeks ago during Ramadan in Gaza, the crowd brutally hit a person who felt weak and ate before the fast ended. The Jews, unlike the "palestinians" (aka Egyptians and Saudis who are not allowed back), are peaceful and tolerant (except a VERY FEW extremists)

[@abuansari05]

you mean to say the jews that are blocking aid and believe more force should be used in Gaza are peaceful?

[@babd3121]

Nice revision of History Bro, So Poles Russian German Khazar Proto Turks are peaceful now?

[@Arbnvbe]

loooooool gtfoh with your lies you disgusting liar. It shows how zionists jewz are so peaceful and tolerant when you see the genocide happening. And the videos of christian tourists in Jerusalem being spitted on by jews. Y'all are the least peaceful adn tolerant people in world. But don't worry you can lie all you want, people are now seing the truth.

[@playinglifeoneasy9226]

@@babd3121 what are you talking about? This is very unrelated to the comment that you were commenting on.

[@dani-ks9cg]

@@babd3121 Even if I assume for a minute your conspiracy is true (which it isn't) , all of them are still more peaceful than the terrorists you support

[@איתןפוזילוף]

2:45 yet another time when Habakkuk is misquoted….not a “MAN should live according to his beliefs, “ but rather The RIGHTOUS should live according to his beliefs….” misquoting this can have consequences

[@benignuman]

As a religious Jew it hurts me too (even though I am not Haredi). As a parable, it is like your friend from High School that was brilliant and talented. They could have been a brain surgeon, a scientist, a musician, an artist, anything. And you meet them 20 years later and they are bagging groceries and a bouncer at night. Even if they are happy, it hurts to see that. A Jew that is an atheist has no portion in the world to come. They may be happy here but when they die, that is the end. That loss of potential is really sad.

[@cielush1848]

"A Jew that is an atheist has no portion in the world to come" אני לא חרדי או מאמין בעצמי, אבל אני 99% בטוח שאתה טועה כאן.

[@DanielGalimidi]

There's no world to come, there's no God. All that exists is what has been scientifically proven to exist.

[@mikicerise6250]

Well it's the same for me as an atheist. Sad to see people who could have been scientists or brain surgeons who could contribute to what is real waste their potential on what is purely imaginary. 🤷

[@cielush1848]

@@mikicerise6250 yea the logic on the original comment is completely lackluster, although as with many toxic/evil things and mindsets... they are with good intentions :/

[@tommykawaii]

@@mikicerise6250except that mostly their beliefs do not waste their potentials in this life? A believer can be almost anything a non believer is. Except for a few things. But once life is over, it doesn’t matter anymore. If they are wrong, they simply cease to exist. There’s no regret or perception of wasted time. If they are right, however, they have eternity in the other side, something that non believers can never partake with. So their sense of “hurting” as they described, kinda makes more sense

[@handsomestik]

Great people

[@The_Voice_of_Reason748]

"Most Zionists don't believe that God exists but they do believe he promised them PALESTINE" - Ilan Pappe

[@baruchdego8934]

Because Jewish is firstly nationality. You don't have to be religious to be Jewish.

[@shirelsloomi8452]

What a surprise to see Ilan Pappe's quote here (sarcasm). It is really complex, let me start at least diving into it: A. Being Jewish is not only a religion, it is a people, group, tribe, ethnicity. B. Many Zionist believe in god just in different ways: 1. Some believe in the existence of a divine entity but they do not necessarily believe it is the "Jewish" god as it is perceived in the bible. 2. Some believe in the existence of a divine entity and that this divine entity is the god of Israel, but they do not believe in the religious system or in the connection of belief to practicing the religion. 3. Some believe in god of Israel and in some of the commandments. 4. Some believe and follow the commandments very very strictly as an integral part of life. Etc. etc. etc. it is not as simple as black and white, you have 50 shades of grey....

[@marianmorley]

​@@shirelsloomi8452so they cherry pick then. Very wishy washy. What about ppl who's ancestors converted to Judaism; their genetics are not semitic and now their offspring no longer believe in God, but live in Israel are they Jews?

[@shirelsloomi8452]

@@marianmorley It is a very good question, not gonna lie about it. I don't know the answer, I am not ashamed to say that. Anyway, it is annoying because it seems everything Jews do will grant tons of criticism- if Jews don't let people convert then they are bad, If they let people convert but not integrate into the society they are bad, if they don't marry non-Jews they are racist and then bad, if the marry non-Jews then they don't deserve to be in Israel etc. etc. etc.... Anyway, there aren't many converts in Judaism as it is not a missionary religion. So though your question is interesting, it represents rare scenarios.

[@anthonyr963]

To anyone with a brain: Does the Bible and Quran say God gave the Jevvs the land? Yes or No?

[@navit4369]

They said it is hurt in the heart if you not beliver. they did not said it is insulting . It is in the Judaisim - every man to his belives

[@chaimtriebitz5523]

Jewdism is beautiful

[@divemylollol6152]

I believe in Spinoza God theism is for children

[@divemylollol6152]

People who believe in God 👇

[@MohammedHassan-ym8qf]

And in prophet Muhammad pbuh and Allah last revelations through prophet Muhammad pbuh

[@Dhua_diary]

​@@MohammedHassan-ym8qf الحمدلله

[@brandonlefton1346]

This fool just wants likes and comments

[@darksol99darkwizard]

Your finger is too far to the right

[@שלמה-נ1ח]

​@@MohammedHassan-ym8qfOnly muslims believe that

[@Rvbcaboose714]

Eveey convo should go like it did with the first Israeli. He couldn't understand why he should be upset with YOUR choice in belief. That's truly the way it should be, everywhere, every single day

[@jean-sylvaintremblay7694]

I’m an atheist and believers bother me.

[@ChrisKhaled83]

irritating, are they not?

[@Dewbird6995]

Why?

[@Michal-ke6lu]

People are wearing masks now? When was this recorded?

[@chrisvalleqatsi]

It bothers people who are not as secure in their beliefs as they would have you think. They rely on concensus and groupthink for validation, and people who defy/challenge their worldview indirectly threaten their identities.

[@eitanshapiro862]

You obviously know nothing about Judaism if that is what you think. Espescially Charedim and Charedi culture. Charedim and religious Jews in general (like myself) will follow what we believe and the laws that we are meant to follow no matter what other people believe. However many of those laws as well as cultural aspects of the religion are communal and create a bond among our people. When there is someone else within our people who does not believe in the religion than it saddens us that we cannot have the same communal experiences with them.

[@wow2031]

Not really. If you belive something strongly and think it's the one and only way, you'd be bothered by someone who doesn't follow that thing.

[@ze_genz9139]

In theyre case its only if they literally view you as family are they upset. they dont care about gentiles not being jewish, they care about jews not being jewish.

[@dannyarcher6370]

That's the case of Islam. That's not the case here. It bothers Jews not because they see it as a betrayal, but rather that they don't want to see their own fall from what they consider to be a beneficial path. At least, that's how it appears to me as an atheist.

[@zevspitz8925]

Excuse the crudity, but if you objected to someone advocating for cannibalism, should others interpret that as you being unsure about the moral ills of cannibalism?

[@pixel_hook]

I’m an atheist Hispanic and I might try this is Latin America if that’s ok with you, I don’t want to copy you unless ur cool with it??

[@ozgurkarakas4909]

1st conversation: - I'm a muslim, can I convert to Judaism? -No! -Lama? -Because your mother is not a Jew? -Ok. What about my mother, can she convert then? -No, her mother should be a jew? - Come on! But my grand, grand, grand.. mother is Eva, as well as yours! What is the problem? 2nd conversation: -My mother was a jew, but I'm an atheist. -No problem, you are my brother. Mussolini and Hitler are so called Fascists. Come on! Theirs were ideology, but judaism is a religion. Fascism is a religious doctrine of Hashem for those people. Means, Mussolini and Hitler DID NOT believe that if they had broken fascist doctrine they would be sinfull or punished by God. But for those jews fascism is a subject of faith and if they have broken fascist doctrin they would be sinfull and be punished with hell by God. Nowadays we can see in Gaza how dangerous is that type of religious fascism

[@ozgurkarakas4909]

@idk-th7uj Q1: When I convert to judaism, will I be fully equal to a mother born jew, or some kind of second class because of I still do not have any jewish blood? Q2: Who applies that test, Hashem or is there an official authority in Israel for this purpose? Q3: Are the questions fixed? Or applied depending on the individuals? Is it possible to have them before that sciencirety test to study on them to get a high degree? Q4: If I pass the test, will I have some rights like mother-born jews? For example, to have citizenship of Israel, having working and staying visa in Israel, or settle on Palestinians' lands and build a dublex villa...?

[@dogbert52]

​@@ozgurkarakas4909why are you people so addicted to lying? Or those are the conversations going on in your head?

[@DoodiDo]

​@@ozgurkarakas4909 Q1: Yes, it's a commandment to love the convert, it's mentioned in the Torah thirty six times and relates to the commandment of love of Israel. According to the Rambam, a convert needs to be treated better than a Jew. Q2: It's a process of time, one day in the synagogue, two days in the synagogue, three days.. Suddenly you realize you are there for months and everyone already see you as a convert, yes you will be tested through out the whole process, but it wont be official, more like unexpected questions. I believe a respected Rabbinical institution is enough to be recognized as a Jew, but most be Ultra Orthodox Ashkenazi wave, or Ultra Orthodox Mizrahi wave, no other sects will be truly recognized by all jews as a legitimate convert. Q3: It's more of a process of testing while being part of the community, you know random questions, or people look how you behave on a prayer, generally they just want to see if you are a follower of the commandments and really scared of god. Q4: Yes, but don't settle on Palestinian lands, in my opinion its better to end the conflict, however we can.

[@deguilhemcorinne418]

One friend of my husband is a Jew converted to Islam. A very flexible islam. We think he did it primarily to contest his father's authority, but still, he is very concerned by the hostility against his new religion.

[@mkbijnaam8713]

so weird that the dude at 1:10 talks about Jews as if they are an ethnicity , its a religion the dude himself probably is a European Jew . He asks you the Atheist if you are a Jew and you say yes ? But your an Atheist so how can you be a Jew ? And dont say its my ethnicity the old Semite Jews who come from the Israelite blood line are almost no more and even if they are they are not more then 1% to 5% of the Jewish population . Old British records talk about that back in the Ottoman empire about 5% of Palestines population was Jewish that most of them were Pilgrims . The Jews these days are either North African , European or for some reason alot of Erritreans in your army these days i bet they need that citizenship . But and i dont mean this in a toxic way i just want to know do you yourselfs rly believe in this ?? like that you are an ethnicity . Im really facinated by the Jewish religion its one of the oldest Abrahimic religion and super intresting but also very weird

[@dogbert52]

You go tell him what he is. Surely you, the superior person, will explain to the sub human, what he is. Because clearly you are a super human and he isnt

[@chavablanks893]

Jewish is an ethnicity. Judaism is passed down through descendants. It is a religion as well. Please educate yourself before spreading misinformation

[@mkbijnaam8713]

@@chavablanks893 most religion is passed down trough descendants ahhahaha , you talk to me about education while you talk total bs . What is your education facebook posts ?? ahahhahaha Its a religion at some point a group of people took on that religion and spread it . Other people that were already born on earth grown ass man became jew . Even your prophet wasnt born jew he became jew . Most jews today are europeans thay became jewish the other jews are north africans or arabs . go educate yourself :D

[@lornm1856]

Bro geneticists say jews come from the Israelites

[@mkbijnaam8713]

@@lornm1856 Israelites are just Canaanites dude the same people as what the Arabs come from . Jews are just Arabs with a different religion . Semitic people your all the same just different religion stop trying to make Judaism an ethnicity just for religiose propaganda sake

[@JohnPean-xy2ou]

Apostasy in Islam in some regions is prohibited and even can be put you at risk of execution. I don't think that there is any moral equivalence between the 2 religions, maybe some radical jewish sects will try to linch you, but then again it doesn't represent majority of jews around the world

[@peterc.4143]

Jews have a concept called Rodef, which is essentially like a Fatwa in Islam. Rabbis have determined certain Jews as a Rodef, which is basically ex-communicating them or worse. Israeli PM Yitzhak Rabin was assassinated by a Jewish religious extremist, after Rabin was declared a Rodef by some Rabbis in Israel, all because he wanted to make peace with the Palestinians. Don’t be fooled, there are many extremist groups and sects withjn Judaism, even the non-religious political Zionist ideologies are extremist and promote violence.

[@axel-fh1ru]

Israelis are kind .they deserve the support not the Palestinians

[@MifiMurder]

היי קורי, אולי תשאל חרדים על חוק הגיוס? 🙏

[@TribeOfJudah.]

This whyt ppl didn't match deteurmony 28, if they read it they'll see that bleq ppl match all words in deteurnomy 28

[@Dexuz]

Deuteronomy 28 is wild, I guess God changed his mind about giving out blessings and curses willy-nilly, can you imagine a world where if you disobey he straight up makes your fiancee get raped?

[@yb8909]

3:08 "Hopefully about the non-jews too!" You killed me there! I truly feel for you brother in humanity. I'm muslim but I must admit that this deeply ingrained ethnocentrism leaning to pure racism is both shocking and perfectly understandable for a people that never wanted to grow in number by means of conversion but only through biological reproduction. It makes my admiration for a pharisee jew like Saint Paul only greater. The guy was so profoundly revulsed that Salvation or God's kingdom would be forbidden to non-jews that he sacrificed fundamental principles of the Law precisely in order to welcome all human nations into the God of Israel kingdom. This is true LOVE. But again, I'm Muslim and we have little to nothing to learn about warm welcoming of the non-muslims yet I'm amazed at how much we (religious jews and muslims) think the same way. Finally Hegel was right, "islam is universal judaism". Keep it up bro! Cheers from Morocco!😉❤

[@yb8909]

@user-jt8vj1vm6y Who spoke of afterlife? Salvation is here and now. But thank you for making my point coz Jesus taught only to jews... and when a Phoenician woman asked him to save her daughter he told her that children's food cannot be given to dogs!!! Matthew 15:21-28 (even Jesus calls a non-jew a dog... go figure!)

[@yb8909]

@user-jt8vj1vm6y At last a Moroccan and an Algerian agree on something... 😅 Salam!

[@yb8909]

@user-jt8vj1vm6y Read again our exchange, you'll see that you mistook Salvation and God's Kingdom for the afterlife. That alone suffices to undermine any "intellectual quality" pretense, of course regardless of nationality... wasn't it the whole point of my comment??? Here again... ;)

[@yb8909]

@user-jt8vj1vm6y Beside, despite the fact that I'm Muslim yet I feel closer to a Moroccan Jew or Israeli than to a Muslim (or so called) Algerian. Affinities between Morocco and Jews (Moroccan or not) are infinitely deeper than what we share between Moroccans and Algerians. Go figure!

[@yb8909]

@user-jt8vj1vm6y Goodness! Who spoke about genetics??? At each of your comment you bring about an argument that had never been mentioned and in this case not even thought about. And as if was not enough your ignorance spreads with the self-assurance typical of the "know-nothing". So let me give you a lesson about Moroccan Jews: Moroccan jews are divided in two major groups: those indigenous to Morocco (from Atlas mountains and Draa valley) who speak berber and share the berber DNA... and those who were expelled from Spain (you find them mostly in cities and share color and DNA with Iberian Muslims who were expelled as well). And please now leave me alone because exchanging with you is like emptying the ocean with a spoon! Stupidity has no limits!

[@eugeniev-a4]

It was a beautiful videos. But also some says a Jew saying he is an atheist is a liar: Our life is a miracle, and also you have a divine soul, so it is just out of denial that you can be an atheist but inside you know. (I have been an atheist too until 15 and then realize, tons of miracles were happening when I prayed and I was really opening my eyes to see it and realized G.d presence was so obvious. That and being religious, giving a meaning to life and working on my character and accepting that you can’t avoid being a Jew, it doesn’t make sense to live only to be an animal going everyday after its basic needs and repeat and repeat the most futile things )

[@shir_azazil]

Then you were an atheist before you changed your mind. Atheists are really really atheists, they don't lie to themselves. Your point is unprovable

[@Dexuz]

Same fallacious argument that Christians use, at least Jews have the decency to keep it to their own tribe, apparently.

[@Omar-Khayyam]

Jews are the only atheists in the world who believe in biblical prophecies, they all make aliyah to the promised land what a contradiction

[@Abu_Shimshi]

israelis dont think that they are from Israel because of the Bible... Jewish is an ethnicity as well, they don't have to belive in god

[@thedreamliner007]

Israel is not a prophecy, it is an historical reality

[@user-td4do3op2d]

Atheist Jews move to the land because it is the ancestral homeland of their people and it's a wonderful country where they are guaranteed safety. Israel is the best country for Jews, Christians and Muslims in the Middle East, by a long way.

[@yigalgurevitch2936]

The only person who makes senseless statements should look into a mirror. 🤡

[@NXDL25]

I'm sure you'd want Mekkah and Medina back into muslim rule if it was invaded by a foreign army and that's understandable. Give people back their holy lands.

[@schlafcomandanten]

BDS

[@abouzrawmd]

محاولة للإجابة عن النسخة العربية من السؤال : ماذا لو قرر أحد أصدقائك/إخوتك/أبنائك أن يعلن إلحاده/عدم إيمانه بوجود إله .. الإجابة : المجتمعات الإسلامية هي طيف كبير و واسع من العينات التي تختلف إجابتها حسب نوع و قوة التدين .. هناك يرى في وجود الدين و الإيمان بوجود إله هو الشرط الوحيد لبقاء المجتمع و الضمانة الوحيدة لوجود الأخلاق و التعاملات اليومية، يعني نفي وجود الدين و الإله هو إعلان عن التحلل من كل الضوابط الأخلاقية أي الفوضى المطلقة .. و هنا إعلان اللادينية يعني التمرد على الأخلاق و القانون و الاستعداد لفعل كل عمل لا اخلاقي .. في أقصى الطيف يوجد نوع من المسلمين يرون أن الأخلاق و الانضباط للقوانين و الأعراف الإجتماعية لا يأتي من خوفهم من وجود إله له محكمة في العالم الآخر يعاقب و يحاسب فيها كل من عمل عملا سيءا في الحياة الأرضية، بل يعتبرون إلتزامهم بالأخلاق و القوانين و الأعراف ناتج عن اقتناع فكري بأهمية هذه الأخلاق في تماسك المجتمع و الأسرة و الفرد .. إعلان إلحاد أحدهم أو تغييره لمعتقده أو دينه لا يغير من درجة أخلاقه في شيء وهو حرية شخصية كباقي الحريات.. هنا أتذكر ما وقع للفيلسوف اليهودي الهولندي باروخ اسبينوزا مع جماعته اليهودية، حين نشر أفكاره عن الإله و الكون و نقده لروايات التوراتية و تناقضاتها التاريخية و المنطقية، حينها اعتبرته جماعته اليهودية خارجا عنها و خطرا عليها و على الشباب خاصة، فعاقبته بالحرمان الكنسي، وهذا نص قرار الحرمان : نص حرمان سبينوزا في الكنيس: "بحكم الملائكة وحكم القديسين، برضى من الرب، المبارك، ومن كل هذه الجماعة المقدسة، أمام هذه المدرجات المقدسة للشريعة، والقواعد الستمائة والثلاث عشرة المنصوص عليها فيها، نحن نحرم، نشجب، نقطع، ونلعن باروخ دي إسبينوزا باللعنة التي لعن بها يشوع أريحا الملعونة، باللعنة التي لعن بها أليشع الشباب، وبكل اللعنات المكتوبة في الناموس: ملعون هو في النهار، وملعون هو في الليل؛ ملعون هو حين ينزل، وملعون هو حين يصعد؛ ملعون هو حين يذهب، وملعون هو حين يأتي؛ والرب لن يعفو عنه؛ سيشعل غضب الرب وحنقه على هذا الرجل، وستحل به كل اللعنات المكتوبة في سفر الناموس ويدمر الرب اسمه من خلف السماوات؛ ولأجل خرابه، سيقطعه الرب عن جميع اسباط إسرائيل، بكل لعنات السماء التي هي مكتوبة في سفر الشريعة؛ وأَمَّا أَنتُمُ المُتَعَلِّقونَ بالرَّبِّ إِلهِكم، فكُلُّكم أَحْياءٌ اليَوم! كخاتمة لهذه الإجابة يمكن أن أقول أننا في العالم الإسلامي لا زلنا نعيش في زمن القرن السابع عشر ميلادي، زمن الحرمان و التكفير و التهديد، هناك بؤر للأمل في بعض المجددين .. والأهم ليس علينا أم نمر بكل المراحل التي مرت منها المسيحية و اليهودية في مسار تجديدها للدين، يوم كان يحرق المخالفون أحياء ( برونو ) أو يجبرون على التنازل عن أفكارهم ( غاليليو ) ... يمكن أن ننتقل مباشرة لمجتمعات الحداثة نأخذ منها الجيد و من تراثنا الديني كل شيء نافع ..

[@shikshakshokwithjuliana]

In Israel people do judge others, but they will not think to harm someone due to his or her beliefs.

[@yasirkhan6455]

they only harm those whose land & belongings were promised to them

[@oreytan8160]

@@yasirkhan6455 you mean those that started a war every time in history and cry they are the victim?

[@mikeymike7721]

@@yasirkhan6455 thats a very skewed perspective. i would say they are defending themselves from those who are fighting a religious war against them (ie. iran and its proxies).

[@yasirkhan6455]

@@mikeymike7721 if we dont lie, someone else will!

[@mikeymike7721]

@@yasirkhan6455 some people truly believe that they are always speaking the truth

[@Evantrop]

Haridim tapilim

[@ophirhaddad]

Stom tapeh shelkha akh yakar, savir lehaniakh shehem ovdim yoter kasheh mimkha. Dai im hashtuyot

[@yigalgurevitch2936]

kurbanot shel shtifat moah arukat shanim.

[@MrEVAQ]

lama kulanu medabrim kakha?

[@shir_azazil]

​@@MrEVAQzot hamediniut hachadasha

[@user-zg3nb1mk5b26]

Say what you want, but one or two generations and you won't have any Jews left, or your son or grandson will assimilate. And finally there won't be any secular Jews left in the world, only ultra-Orthodox will remain as Jews.

[@OsiasNocum]

Dialogue is best..😊

[@jonnyblunt4755]

I think it was unfair that you didn't emphasize the difference between being bothered and being pained. Two messages came across through the various answers, one that people felt it wasn't for them to tell others how to live their lives, and the other that people felt pained when fellow Jews don't believe in God and the religious Jewish path. Those two messages are not mutually exclusive, even if it's human nature to lean towards one rather than the other. The Haredim did not in any way suggest they intended interfering in your choice of life; some chose not to elaborate, and some said that they see you as a brother gone astray. I think you unfairly implied something more negative about them when you pointed out their response.