SA Western Cape HC JSC Interview of Mr D M Thulare - Judges Matter (October 2019)

Judicial Service Commission October 2019 interview of Mr D M Thulare for the Western Cape Division of the High Court.
Judges Matter is a South African non-profit organisation dedicated to encouraging broad-based public engagement with the important process of selecting the judges of the superior courts of South Africa. For more info: www.judgesmatte...

[@zibalulemdeni2334]

Thulare J mastered this interview. His appointed was a win for the SA Judiciary. His judgments radiate wisdom.

[@smd2505]

I liked the bold contextualized comment on newspaper regarding the license booking and testing procedure in daveyton and really speaking he justified his comment accurately.

[@jaredbadenhorst1646]

Excellent interview. Very impressed by him

[@lungankinti9966]

Thulare was a very strong candidate here..he was above this JSC no wonder the CJ ended up attacking him through the office he occupied..the CJ ended up being defensive here...its sad.

[@tafadzwamakara4519]

Very sad the man is bold

[@audreymakale541]

this man did his research before he comes here clearly he knows why his here.....good interview inded

[@matometrevor2916]

This man is just amazing! A great judge he is!

[@igboukwu]

This guy is very good, things must change with respect to how magistracy is carried along in the judiciary.

[@Lovemechipsy]

Geat philosopher!!!!

[@abramm3383]

"Contemporaneous" This candidate is extremely strong. CJ personally attacked him at the end of the interview. 😂

[@Dzhambila]

This guy is very good. I hope he gets the post

[@TshoksOlam]

I waited in anticipation for this one.

[@nkosikhonakhumalo1078]

Dudge Thulare, a very good interview. I’m inspired!

[@yonelacetywayo7778]

Very impressive interview by Mr Thulare, soo detailed and bold indeed

[@victorchabala]

Thulare is no ordinary judge. He is exceptional.

[@mandzosam9363]

This man is a Judicial Philosopher. A nerd, He killed all the questions including the CJ's. The CJ is refusing to understand his logic when he articulates the reasons regarding what was published by the media... Respect!

[@bonnyjacobs5381]

My brother im sorry to say this, but equally so im afraid not to tll the trueth.this knowledge is above the interview pannel.he really deserve this position.he is not justnswering question but he further educate those interviewing him.

[@davidmakanda8610]

Did he get the job btw...he really deserved it

[@petjeteke7972]

very confident judicial officer

[@christoherndlovu4765]

Good and bold presentation indeed

[@bonnyjacobs5381]

Indeed this guy must be considered for the position.i like his self confidence and how he maintain principle irrespective who he is faced with and how passionate he want the position.

[@sandilemathebula3570]

This guy is good !!!

[@Thabzalzk]

Western Cape is blessed to have Judge Thulare

[@siphomzizi6016]

I lost respect for CJ Mogoeng after watching this interview. The CJ should have carried himself professionally. It looks like the CJ catches feelings when criticised. I am glad Thulare stood by his words.

[@sandisomtshotshisa9861]

Respect Mr Tulare is not shaken

[@mlulekimnguni5280]

That answer in relation to the land debate 😩🔥🔥😂😂😂

[@sammymanganya9920]

Chief Justice did not appreciate that view there at the end. I felt he could have engaged him better on that fact instead of trying to impeach him on what he says is not truth. Otherwise very strong character.

[@kylepetersen4859]

Excellent jurist, an indictment of our system that he was not appointed based off this interview.

[@bonganimsweli3960]

This man knows his story

[@sandilemathebula3570]

100%

[@hasanibethuelndomanyane1470]

He should be the one questioning them!

[@sandilemathebula3570]

Well said...

[@MrJohnyto]

How this man did not get a job I am puzzled.

[@misheckmainza2685]

he is a good judge and i stand with him ,,even if the cj is against him somehow

[@dulciblewinegaard784]

What about the Aboriginal nation please explain

[@siyandakhanyile6579]

"To the extent🙄🙄🙄🙄"

[@surprisedimakatso4884]

I respect thulare

[@TshoksOlam]

This magistrate is chitty chatty. I wanted to defend him based on adverse article written on his squabble between him and the CJ.

[@abram3554]

Brilliant Judge

[@awb9012]

What does Ubuntu mean when we are compelled to seek the assistance of a white owned company to assist with parcels of good for needy children? And then we refer to the legacy inherited by our white counterparts (Latin) which Dali Mpofu refers to as pompous? Or am I being odd in my observation. I see a form of cognitive dissonance at play

[@brianramokgopa4347]

Chief Justice was catching emotions I didn't lyk that about him as a chief Justice his last comment embarrass Mr thulare how do u say next time you should check your fact before u speak on public mxm

[@mfanelomdudo]

Started very well,it only went south at end and it looks likes the CJ was very upset with his utterances that he uttered

[@raymondhlekwa7021]

UMogoeng wayengayifuni le chap

[@normantawandanyahamana6786]

The Chief Justice and the candidate have different views on how to run things. Unfortunately the guy did good in the real interview

[@thokomhlongo3751]

CJ mara

[@mandzosam9363]

Did Mr DM Thulare got the Judgeship job?

[@lungankinti9966]

Nope...sad

[@moetieugeneramabodu6149]

He's now an Acting Judge at the Western Cape High Court

[@bonnyjacobs5381]

Thats unfair Mr Thulare was the best candidate, its so sad😭😭😭😭

[@ronnymashaba1189]

Yohhh wow

[@victorchabala]

If Thulera did not get the job, the reason wasn't because he wasn't qualified. Irrespective of the outcome of the interview, he was clearly my favourite candidate for appointment. Unfortunately, my position clearly doesn't matter. But I can say this of Thulera, he stood above all shoulders. Let me say this to him, Thulera, you have the admiration of all of us who witnessed this interview. I cannot mention names, but learn from me my brother, truth has never been popular.

[@luyandagcuwa8225]

This is one of my favorite interviews, understands the rule of law, bold, confident. The chief justice attacked him for no reason; but he stood by his word

[@zanovuyoqwebani4779]

I think former chief justice Mogoeng was testing his abilities in enforcing the law

[@mthobisi8877]

What an interview, what a judge! This man is exceptional, firm,bold and stands his truth! Indeed a Legal philosopher!🙌🏾🔥

[@ps.witnessnciya9722]

7h

[@pt2510]

Mr Thulare maintained his calmness in the face of a barrage of unfair questions by the CJ...

[@tembakazimvunelo3623]

I observe that all the people sitting in this interview platform are all people of integrity and of high standing, why have they allowed someone much corruption to ruin the lives of the people in our country? Esp corruption in places of authority, just explain that one