संवाद # 86: Rohit Pathania on Jammu history, from golden times of Dogra rule to 2nd class treatment

[@abhisheksharma4996]

Thanks for discussing jammu and dogra history.Dogras are only rulers who extended boundaries of present day india.Jammu has always been ignored thanks for giving voice to dogras.You should also invite manu khajuria ji

[@akkkkk813]

Dogra is language of cash because I have a lot of my friends who are from Jammu and they call themselves as Dogra Rajput

[@abhisheksharma4996]

@@akkkkk813 jai dev slogan which rajputs still use while interacting with each other refers to dev dynasty of rajputs which ruled jammu till 1000yrs.

[@aman4219]

@@akkkkk813 believe in cobra but not dogra

[@abhishek2026]

@@aman4219 tu hai dhai din ka jhopra, hata le apna thopra,

[@Dhrumit.Prajapati]

​

[@satyamgautam108]

Believe me or not Rohit Pathania is one of the best historian with perfect speaking skills...hats off man🔥👍

[@BharatBased]

Thank you for bringing Rohit back again & fulfilling your promise of speaking about Jammu & Dogra history. Keep on doing the good work 🙏🏻

[@nischesharma]

Bhai ansu aa re mere jammu ki baat sunkar pahli baar jammu not part of kashmir jai duggar jai bawe waali mata

[@nischesharma]

Bhai aaj tak kisi ne ni bola about pakistan ke paas kahsmir rati bar ni poora ka poora jammu hai

[@hawkzop4551]

the greatest ruler maharaja gulab singh ⚔️🗡

[@isleftisright2986]

भाईयो में भाई, रोहित भाई 😉 रोहित जी की चर्चाएं काफी सहज और आज को परिभाषित करने वाली होती हैं।

[@jethu2945]

I as from Punjab had very bad Immprestion of dogras thank u for clearing that thought

[@panditbhudev21]

Because jahalat among Sikhs is not limited to Dogra regime only but to entire Hindu Community.Khalistani bastards simply forget how Dogra regime took revenge against Muslims when Mirpur Hindu Sikh massacre happen.More than 200000 Hindus Sikhs were butcherd by Muslims in Rawalpindi,Mirpur,Tattapani etc etc POK.But it were only n only Dogras who start ethnic cleansing of Muslims in Jammu,Kathua,Aknoor etc.

[@jaihind2027]

Only jatt sikhs

[@abhisheksharma4996]

Dogra historians should be more platforms to show their point of view bcoz jammu has always been nationalist and till now dogras of jammu serves heavily in indian army.Giving power to dogras to jammu will solve the kashmir problem.

[@looser8749]

Thank you so much for this episode From Jammu

[@nischesharma]

Bawe waali mata ki jai

[@mrshadowcool174]

Arihant try to create a series which includes each state, especially those were Hindus have been persecuted the most or states where communists/evangelical nexus is growing eg Meghalaya, Mizoram, Tamil Nadu, Jharkhand, West Bengal, Andhra/Telangana & etc Also an overview on the Hindu history and Dharmic consciousness of each state would be enlightening. Btw Great to see Rohit back. Truly captivating conversationalist!

[@MOHIT836]

Listen,I m an avid readerof history but the problem is not many books have been written on the above mentioned states, moreover the language problem ,so majority of regions have been isolated.

[@tusharnagpal266]

Manipur please, Meghalya is already on its last legs. Manipur is still our hope for Hinduism in Northeast.

[@vikramwadhawan6342]

Brothers you both are doing great job by informing Hindus about there glorious past.God willing one day we will again gain what we have lost in 1947 and before to both islamic invaders and Christians colonists.

[@amazingdude9042]

It's amazing to see podcasts like this where host and guest both has so deep knowledge of their topic. and here people like us can't even remember 5 pages of some book we read.

[@talentedboys6384]

Dogras are born fighters . But nowadays they forget fighting skills. They should read their proud history and should keep their traditions of fighting.

[@PiyushKumar-ru6io]

Rohit is very knowledgeble and passionate.

[@robinparihar4196]

here a listner from kishtwar , j&k thank you rohit sir for such a briliant clearification

[@swapnilanvekar8850]

Rohit pathania ur r genius bhai....grt

[@gabbarrf1745]

Definitely need an episode on uttarakhand with rohit sir.

[@sunishabali6703]

Very very well read man. There are very few people who know history of jammu like he knows.

[@abhisheksharma4996]

Plz invite manu khajuria ji to discuss history and culture of jammu.History of jammu needs to be told bcoz kashmiri leadership has destroyed dogras intellectually and jammu is facing existensial crisis bcoz jammu do know their history.Jammu has always been nationalist area of bharat.

[@tggammer7772]

Bhout kushi hui yeh sunn ka..... jammu kashmir ka bhaderwah sa hu ... Jo kabhi chamba sa jada link hua karta tha .....aur very happy to see that someone highlighted the relationship between jammu and Himachal ❤❤❤❤. ..... Love this ❤❤❤

[@sumitaggarwal6653]

Arihant & Vaad team, please use many tags related to contents in the video. Use common TAGS & precise video title that helps YT algorithm to promote the video 🧐🙏👍👍

[@shaunak1857]

Rohit Pathania: The best guest on Vaad!

[@ritagupta9854]

Very precise,grave and an eye opening podcast.thanks Vaad for bringing our past and forgotten truth

[@Vyom4676]

One of the best,Rohit ji and arihantji pranam 🙏

[@Anup_BHU]

Love and respect every Hindu from Sonbhadra, UP. My emotions with you . Vande matram Jay hind

[@yogawithanish]

It was Chaman Lal Gupta who was MOS Defence who started the VDCs

[@sunnyrazdan8244]

Excellent analysis and in depth knowledge by Rohit Pathania ji......great 👏

[@indsingh3953]

Thank you Vaad For Bringing Up a Podcast for DOGRAS

[@NishantShyamGoutam]

Kudos to Rohit and Arihant for bringing this wealth of history into light

[@rahul2000]

this is so underrated, everyone should be exposed to these facts

[@jinks3669]

These stories need to be heard. Let's create a powerful informed ecosystem. Hindus have been so ignorant about their own history.

[@kyukki5732]

28:44 he is saying the truth here even my late grandmother who just died in 2021 at the age of 97 told me how she ran from Mirpur carrying her 3 infants hide in fields for nearly 3 days in 1947 because of the barbarism done to Hindus by Muslims of that area.

[@shan-tb2rg]

Thankyou Arihant bhai🙏🙏

[@VVVedic]

Islamic appeasement is the worst thing our govt & leaders do. Instead of empowering Hindus they appease islamists who are against non-muslims & Bharat.

[@journeywithsarita]

Kya shandar podcast hai

[@Tejinder_Singh1216]

Gulab singh paid 15000 nanak shahi to Sandhawalia Murdered Sikh Maharaja Sher Singh raja dhian Singh(Gulab Singh's Brother) Suchet Singh (Gulab Singh's Brother ) and hira Singh ( Gulab Singh's nephew) Gulab Singh had taken most of the lahore treasury to jammu.

[@dushantanthal2695]

Do you think Britishers could allow him to do this ? Don't fall for rumours atleast think logically. Your hatred for Dogras made you blind. Good and bad people are everywhere. We have to be United against invaders. And don't fight among ourselves.

[@Yuvrai96]

​@@dushantanthal2695Dogras fought for and helped in the construction of Sikh Empire. Now these idiots hate Dogras

[@dushantanthal2695]

@@Yuvrai96 They can't even rule for more than 50 years in the entire history of mankind. Even during their rule Dogras were the main force supporting them otherwise they couldn't have survived that long. These people are jealous of Dogra might that's why they hate Dogras.

[@AdityaMahotra]

Good episode.

[@mrraam31]

Amazing history. Two requests, first please add subtitles it will capture certain key information and second, wherever possible when the guest talks about any geographic location, if possible please show it on a map. Thank you once again

[@abhisheksharma4996]

Plz invite and promote Ankur sharma to discuss jammu history and discrimination with jammu.Ankur sharma ji launched ikkjutt jammu party to be the voice of dogras of jammu.

[@myksaussietales5869]

Proud Jammuite living in Australia ❤

[@GouravGouravjasrotia]

Very good knowledge

[@IncredibleNeo]

That german lady thing is more a rumour than anything else....

[@balbirbhai4452]

I invite everyone from jammu to atleast watch this once

[@Abhishek-qv8zd]

The video serves such a great purpose to make history accessible for mainstream, otherwise stories like these will be lost to obscure books in some university libraries.

[@rohit.chouhan786]

Bhaderwah was also ruled by Chamba for a small period of time

[@mtarkes]

Love to all Jammuwalas from Odisha

[@myselfdhar]

Jamwal* surname haii mainly from Jammu

[@vedashriram39]

Arihant .....God bless you. @50 mins....one can guage the sadness of Hari Singhs status. Why did Karan Singh join Cong.....the traitors.

[@GouravGouravjasrotia]

PojkGB part of India 🇮🇳✅ state of maharaja harisingh ❤

[@sambhavmagotra8420]

ओ डोगरेयो, वाज़ चुक्को ते अपने हके आस्तै लड़ो, नेईं ते इनें कश्मीरिएं मुस्लमानें तुसेंगी खाई ओड़ना। Please raise a voice for Separate Jammu🚩🚩

[@amanprasad1345]

Need this type of video on State of Bihar

[@dukezango]

Wow only good part. You should have told audience black part also how dogra come on throne who they betrayed who accompanied them in their conspiracies and who is responsible for whole blood shed in J&k. Only nice things bravo dogra rajputs nd kashmiri pandits

[@bhayaji4176]

रोहित भाई को सुनना हमेशा सुकून भरा होता है जो मुख्य विषय ही नही बल्कि उसके आस पास की छोटी-2 बातों को भी कवर करते है।

[@user-bp5dm4tp6c]

Thanks for sharing truth

[@soodabhi]

Rohit and Puneet Sahni are two sources of Panthic history and pride.

[@jagdeeppathania1261]

It's a good podcast , please mention the books of Mr Rohit pathania

[@Mian.Bharatsinghpathania]

A video on ram singh Pathania ⚔️🚩

[@atul4bits180]

Awesome video Kudos to the host Thanks a lot

[@bhavneetsingh2931]

We all know how gulab singh acquired Jammu from sikhs

[@umeshbhat6540]

Dogras, Hindus have a long way to go. Ankur Sharma ji is very educated and deserving person but it's better to stay united.

[@AdityaJape]

time stamps ?

[@sushantthakur3100]

Rohit pathania should be more on this channel

[@sumantdogra3278]

रोहित पठानिया , का विश्लेषण साधारण, तथ्य भ्रमित करने वाला है, विरोधाभास भी है जम्मू के बुद्धिजीवी अब जाग रहे है। यह देखकर कर प्रसन्नता हुई । वर्तमान मे जम्मू क्षेत्र नायक विहीन है। राजवंश ने बहुत निराश किया है ।

[@adi45713]

Brilliant podcast!

[@DineshGarikapatty]

It is absolutely correct that it is Pakistan Occupied Jammu (PoJ). Movies shud be made on these events, so that ppl know the truth.

[@onamrajput8320]

From jammu , and jobs distribution was also 80:20 ratio before 2019 , and no political leader even protests about that..

[@kakoosheikh9934]

I am from POJK...HUMKO YE SAB STORIES APNY GRANDFATHERS AND GRANDMOTHERS ny btain thii k mirpir kotli me hindu ka genocide hiwa thaaa pathano ny bht ghult huwa thaa

[@RaviSharma-xx2pe]

Ram.chand dubey remained Governer of J&,,k.for 3 4 decades L M Khajuria remained Director of sericulture there were many dogra officers

[@califrao]

Very good interview. Always love a history story based on facts. The latter part of political fights has thus familiarity with what us going in in the political circles of Pak don’t you get tgat feekung ?🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼

[@aranews489]

Dogra is powerful soilder

[@Matter.of.fact27]

Arihant bro, conversation bahut informative tha, thoda achha aur Kiya ja sakta tha Kai jagah pe maps daal ke.....Baaki overall best....

[@jyotivyas9286]

जय सनातन हिन्दू धर्म। 👌💐😊

[@sardevsingh7792]

Sheikh Abdullah was in deep connection with communists, Russia & Pakistan supported by western powers to declare J&K as Independent Sultanate in 1953, when he was arrested & imprisoned on instruction from Nehru who had been his stauntch supporter from 1945-till 1953.

[@Chahaman_हर्षित_00]

Actually hatred against the Kings of Princely states, made Jawahar Lal Nehru, betrayed the terms made with them, in name of Constitution.

[@aaitiniti]

डोगराओ का इतिहास बहुत पुराना रहा है ये खश रेस से है।

[@decodingmyroot]

Superb

[@sanjayshardha9645]

I don't know how despite having martial race of dogra's gudwalis gujjars in jammu. It is made second class citizen of kashmiri bakris

[@sarthaksharma2135]

Because jammu's politicians have mostly become slave of Kashmir valley Jammu City is refugee capital now Dogri Culture is only left in villages and small towns and jammu's society has undergone decline overtime with no support from Delhi

[@Kshatriya288]

Gujjar shudra 😂

[@abhisheksharma4996]

I think professional historian like vikram sampat sir should do academic research on tussle between sheikh abdullah and maharaja hari singh ji.Sheikh abdullah launched jihad against maharaja hari singh ji with the help of ahmed shah maulvi who gave speech in jama masjid which resulted in lynching hindus in 1932 and migration of pandits into jammu as a result Muslim conference now National conference came into existence.Now today that jihad is called same as moplah which is now called as not jihad but a rebellion of unemployed youth of kashmir

[@nivv6613]

Eye opening

[@nitinmisra6515]

Why are we always dying to show our secular credentials? We don't get the same treatment when we are in minority numbers.

[@SwatiAgarw]

Bhaiyon discussion was good but please have some mercy on lay man. If you can go a bit slow and also show maps on the screen while having discussion, it will be useful.

[@Azad-ut5qu]

there is no doubt about it that kashmiri pandits are selffish community they always think about thereselves. even they dont donate even single penny for temple construction so all temples in kashmir are constructed by dr karan singh. sanatan dharam.

[@derababananak4667]

Make a podcast on haryana

[@SunilKumar-mw4xf]

Dear Rohit, Whatever you are doing is very good, BUT YOU NEED TO KNOW MORE, I MAY CONTRIBUTE LITTLE TO YOU

[@rajivjain9256]

We need more information on j k i wish best of luck to jumu region

[@no-one3296]

Bhai Puneet Sahani ko invite karo.

[@harikeshsingh5049]

Please Tell me if said book is available in flipkart. Tell resources of its availability

[@ranbirchauhan96]

Bhadrwah was part of Chamba given as dowry to Jammu to royals. HP four monarchy to merge and make an independent like Nepal

[@lalitsharmaish]

Bura na maniyega aazad kashmir k barey main aur Amritsar treaty k barey main aapki jaankari kam hai 🙏

[@navdeeppathania3699]

Pahadiyon ki problam ek jgha stand nahi hote agreed 👍

[@saitandale8482]

Bhari hai

[@singhmandhir3496]

Gulab Singh ek Gàdar the Sikh state ke,

[@bhayaji4176]

आपने जम्मू में बढ़ती रोहिंग्या बीमारी के बारे में बात नहीं की।

[@pavitramehta1]

Hello. Could i get coordinates of Mr Pathania? Will appreciate any help regarding that

[@nischesharma]

Bhai aaj tak kisi ne ni bola about pakistan ke paas kahsmir rati bar ni poora ka poora jammu kabja hai thank you sir thank you so much

[@indsingh3953]

You Missed Most important person of Dogra History Local Robinhood Main DIDO JAMWAL

[@AKA_ABpositive_]

1:11:38 Areyyyyyyyyyyy Bhai Jammu Card bol Rahe h vo jese Victim card... Patta 😒

[@AnantKumar-ji1re]

Utube me ye badi subidha hai, koi Aur ye hi karan hai ki in param dharm nirapekhsha nitiyon ko Katuwe Musalmanon par attyachar kahkar chalane me safal ho jate hain. Sialkote me dange hue aur sadharan Dogra sarnarthi bankar Jammu aya Swabhawik roop se Jammu me pratikriya hui. Mirpur ke massacre ka jawab janta dene ko nikli. Dogra prashashan bajay kanoon vyavastha samhalne ke khood dango me kood padi. Jo tanga chalak Hindown ko bachakar Sialkote se Jammu laye the sabse pahle un nirdosh nihatton ko markar kritagyata gyapan purva mardangi ka pradarshan kiya gaya. Hamare param itihaas gyata, nahi jante ki October 47 se pahle yadi koi Bharat me vilay ki baat karta tha to usay deshdrohi karat diya jata tha. Gaye the Shri Golwalker, " Hindu rashtra me Hindu raja ko sammilit hona chahiye, unhe Maharaj dwara bataya gaya, " Hamara hawai adda Lahore, hamara bandargah Karachi, hamara vyaparkrndra Rawalpindi, ye bich me India kahan se aa gaua?" Fir hua kabyiliyon ka akraman. Ayogya, sena ko netritwa dene me asamarth, janadhar vihin shashak usi Bharat ke sharan me bhaga jise ab tak woh bagair lag lapet ke hiraqat ki drishtise dekha karta tha. Par apne swarthi swabhaw va praja virodhi charitra ka nirdeshan dene me ab bhi pichhe nahi tha. Rajya ki sena ke 40 truck the, yudh me unka upyog kiya na ja sake sabse pahle Maharajadhiraj ne iska prabandh kiya. In sabhi truckon me Maharaj ke kimti kaalin aur paintings lade gaye Aur unhe lekar Maharaj Jammubhag khade hue. Is 'visheshyagya' ne Sherwani ka naam suna hai? Ya to yeh param agyani hai ya fir nirlajjata se jhoot bolna iska swanhaw hai. Parantoo abhi climax baaki tha. Jis Nehru aur Sheikh ke prayason se Kashmir ka Bharat me vilay hua unka pahla kaam tha land reforms. Are gazab. Gharib aadmi do waqt pet bhar bhojan kar lega? Maharaj ke adhikaron ka itna bada hanan. Praja Parishad khud he nahi Maharaj ke adhikaron ko bachaane Shyama Prasad Mukrji ko aur bula layi. Hindu Muslim ka rayta jitta failaya ja sakta tha failaya gaya. Parinaam? Punchh vidrohiyon ne aur sab kiya Bharat ka rukh nahi kiya. Bhala ho Praja Parishad aur Shyama Prasad Mukerji ka 47 me itta Hindu Musalman nahi kar paye warna Sardar Ibrahim ki tarah Sheikh Abdullah bhi Pakistaniyon ke atuachar akele jhel lete Hindustan ki ore rukh na karte. 70 varshon me ghati ke netaaon ne nisandeh pakhshapat kiya hai. Fir bhi sarkari naukariyon me Pandi 90 ke dashak se pahle apni jansankhya Ke anupat se kahin adhik the. Ye to vidwan purush bhi maan rahe hain ki adhiktar audyogik ikayiyaan Jammu me lagi hain. Katue ghati me ladkar khud jitna mar rahe hain utna koi aur nahi maar raha. Hindu Musalman kar kar ke kya Jammu me Hinduon ki wohi gati banana chahte ho. Nehru Gandhi ki secular nitiyan nisandeh Muslim tushtikaran si lagti hain. Par inhi nitiyon ke dirghkalin parinam swaroop overwhelmingly Muslim population wala Kashmir Bharat bana. Bangladeshi ke Musalmano ne Bharat ke saath kandhe se kandha milakar Pakistan se yudh kiya. Hindupanai ka prabhav tha ki Sardar Ibrahim ne samast anyay sah kar bhi Bharat ka rukh na kar akele Pakistan se yudh kiya.

[@tggammer7772]

Sir please tell me about these books....and which book should i read..... please it's my humble request to you... Share a booklist with me

[@Ajhng]

Pls invite the great palki sharma also on show ,shashi shekhar who unravel the realities of western media and also people who despite being india spare no efforts to demean india on global stage.Also call gaurav rastogi who runs hindu spiritual centre in usa where traditionally chaplains are existing for all religions but hindus .He has appeared on pgurus on channel.Even tripudamqn singh whose book on sixteen stormy days is reality of leftists and congress exposed.Also pls call Sheela bhatt who has interviews with most underworld gangsters and talks about an indai beyond Delhi

[@Imroz11]

A court historian will feel ashamed in front of this man, an apologitic for atrocities of dogra monarchs. Presenting one side view of story

[@sankaetsingh7603]

Bro pls hve discussion about massacred hppnd in chenab valley

[@indsingh3953]

Sardar Patel ne Maharaja Hari Singh ji k sath dhokha kiya tha jab Hyderabad ka nizam India k anti tha Hyderabad ko India mein merge krne k baad Nizam ko nizam hi rhne diya aur Maharaja Singh ne India ko join Kiya unko kya mila Apni hi State se exile Centre Govt Never cared about DOGRAS because they their patriotic and never do protest like happen in Kashmir