SATC | Charlotte Goes to the Judaism Classes

[@ozyvillanueva9277]

I personally never saw an issue with Charlotte converting. Harry was clear early on that he had to marry a Jewish woman and didn’t pressure Charlotte to convert. She made her own choice and clearly her religion wasn’t important enough to stop her from marrying the love of her life. Good for her.

[@actaemazantor9558]

However that also meant that, to Harry, religion was more important than her.

[@stefanmakara373]

@@actaemazantor9558 And to her, having a baby was more important than Troy. It's about who is compatible, what is a deal breaker and which compromises to AVOID the dealbreaker are acceptable. Half assing a baby to stay in marriage is not acceptable to any party- the wife, the man himself, the poor baby. However, changing religion you are not too connected to anyways IS okay.

[@nenisguevaragomez8122]

@@stefanmakara373I agree.

[@sapnajain3121]

@@stefanmakara373 well said

[@bigbowlowrong4694]

@@actaemazantor9558 Yeah, she kinda went from one mommy’s boy to another - “oh I can’t marry you, because if I marry a shiksa my mother will FREAK. OUT.”

[@suburbantimewaster9620]

Even after the temporary break up with Harry, Charlotte remained Jewish. Considering how hard she worked to convert, I can actually see why. Probably didn’t hurt that everyone at the temple loved her. At least, from what I’ve seen of the show. I haven’t finished it yet.

[@Arginne]

Once you convert to Judaism youre a Jew for life. There isnt any becoming un-Jewish after that even if you stopped going to synagogue.

[@Ummmmmmmm841]

Tbh it’s charlottes decision so good for her. Religion is where I normally draw the line, I probably won’t be near anybody who wants me to conform in any type of religions lul.

[@deepin6547]

I won't ever give up my Hindu religion for the sake of marriage. It's part of identity.

[@mozorellastick2583]

She clearly didn't feel that way abt her Christianity

[@sapnajain3121]

Same here..Vedic culture is a way of life

[@MrSAYANTAN22]

True....our culture and religion is superior to any.....its a pride to be born a sanatani.......but yes christmas is a personal fav that like everything sanatani dharma doesnot mind u celebrating

[@sarcasticallyrearranged]

Sayatana, your culture and religion is superior to none. No religion or culture is without fault and you must be deluded if you truly believe it.

[@Bulhbluhbuy]

@@MrSAYANTAN22 thats a messed up way to think. No religion or culture is “superior” it simply is

[@Kat31017]

Harry never really seemed religious tho. When they were supposed to be celebrating Shabbat he wanted to watch the game. I think he wanted her to become Jewish only for his family..

[@evandewind4264]

Judaism isn't only religion though. It's an ethnicity and a culture. It's passed down through the mother, so if Charlotte hadn't converted, he would not have been able to have a Jewish child. He wanted his family to be Jewish, and they are because Charlotte converted.

[@ViguLiviu]

His mother on her deathbed said to him to marry a jew, she was a survivor of the holocaust. It was more about keeping a heritage alive. She couldn't become an ethnic jew, but she could become a religious one.

[@kuafer3687]

​@@evandewind4264the passing of culture only through mother is a bs

[@evandewind4264]

@@kuafer3687 I didn't make the rules of Judaism. Everyone on earth can enjoy Jewish culture, but only children of Jewish mothers or converts are Jewish under the strictest criteria when determining who is Jewish.

[@nenisguevaragomez8122]

It was Charlotte's decision to convert to Judaism, I mean I don't know why many here throw hate at Harry, he already had made clear that he would only marry a Jew for whatever reason you want but it is his decision and his standards, and it was in Charlotte's hand to decide to walk away or to find a way to be with the guy he loved, she decided to convert, it was HER decision, Harry didn't ask or tell her to convert.

[@BrandyTexas214]

I’d never give up Christmas for anyone

[@WeneedmoreGodsinTshirts]

You wouldn’t have to necessarily not every Jew doesn’t celebrate Christmas also if you live in America you kind of have to celebrate it whatever religion you havs

[@Bulhbluhbuy]

Okay? Who asked you

[@sirrykr1679]

I am NOT religious really. But I still consider myself Christian, its part of my identity. Its kind of funny but as a child and teenager I sought out to express my faith, but my parents never steared me towards religion. During my adult years (I am middle aged now) I have become much less religious but never considered myself as agnostic nor atheist. My mind is a sceptic but my heart and soul remain Christian.

[@AdaraBalabusta]

Okay. Repent of idolatry and obey the Seven Noahide Laws.

[@BrandyTexas214]

@@AdaraBalabusta no

[@dietrichjoanne]

I could never give up my Christian faith for a man.

[@UsernameUnkwn21]

Nobody asked u

[@leahnyb6878]

@@UsernameUnkwn21 be nice :-) #no karens

[@leahnyb6878]

@@UsernameUnkwn21 Who I am? Not a Karen :-D

[@UsernameUnkwn21]

@@leahnyb6878 Karen is nothing more then a name, you are someone who thinks the world appointed them the hall monitor, have no real worth or value in the real world so leaving comments on KZbin videos is where you search for validation of your less then remarkable life 🐑 🐏 🐑 🐏 🐑 🐏 🐑

[@nizvkfb7vsbvrsct723]

Well Charlotte was not a practicing Christian so it was not really giving up anything but more so finding a religion she prefers.

[@gallyi34]

Many people are christians because their parents chose that for them. Like my fiancé but now he is an atheist. He doesn't believe in jesus . I think it's the same for Charlotte. She's a christian, she probably believes in Jesus but doesn't really practice religion. She was only attach to sentimental sides of christianism like Christmas and Christmas tree for example

[@Spearsy1995]

Harry is my favourite of the husbands apart from this story line - if you love someone you love all of them including the parts that are inconvenient, And asking someone to change religion is basically saying - my beliefs, my family, my culture are more important than yours.

[@cheshirecat1212]

I’ve asked dozens of both diaspora and Israeli Jews how they feel about the female partner converting for a man and the general consensus is ‘Why would you change for a man who doesn’t think you’re good enough as you are?’ I met a girl once whose mother had converted for her father. My boyfriend at the time, who was Jewish, thought the same, even remarking that it was ‘fucked up’ that her mother wasn’t good enough until she converted. I think Charlotte did it mainly because she’s a fan of Elizabeth Taylor.

[@elizabethmelnychuk6034]

The loss was Jesus Christ. I could not not do that,

[@AdaraBalabusta]

Worshiping Jesus as a deity is idolatry. ❤

[@dehende07]

I know jew that celebrate Christmas, And no they're not jews for Jesus they're actually practicing jew....... My next door neighbors waw jews And they didn't want their children to feel left out only celebrated Christmas by having a Christmas tree and toys under it.... I don't believe they celebrated the true meaning but they just celebrated the holiday

[@dani-ell-ah]

Some do because Christmas as we know it has very little to do with religion. Even Christmas in an active Christian household can be very different to the commercialised idea of Christmas

[@AdaraBalabusta]

Jew starts with a capital J. Have some respect.

[@aloha2orangeneko]

Atheists celebrate Xmas too. It’s a secular holiday as much as it is religious.

[@KS-cl8br]

She should have him convert.

[@creativewriter3887]

WHY?????? that was a stupid comment. Harry didn't ask Charlotte to convert. He made it very clear that he could not marry a Non-Jew. SHE made the decision to convert to get Harry but the Rabbi (as is his DUTY) made it very clear converting to Judaism for "love" is NOT a reason to convert. Being a Jew is a LIFELONG commitment.

[@KS-cl8br]

@@creativewriter3887 Because Christianity is more evolved and doesn't have all of those rituals and classes.

[@creativewriter3887]

@@KS-cl8br No just a disgusting message that children are born vile and need someone to be killed and shredded in order for them to be saved from death and lived in forced slavery and mental manacles of abject forced praise to a god who could very well have just forgiven them from the onset. No no.. rituals/classes on how to better the world, better yourself and help others is BAD but living a life of self loathing, self-aggrandizing (by duh bluhd of christ) teaching people that their worthless and making the neurotic about sex, life, god and hating everyone else.. well, that's much much much better. yeah right.

[@devinxoxo8350]

@@KS-cl8br Anyone who’s claiming that Christianity is evolved clearly hasn’t read the Bible and isn’t aware of the majority of other sects of Christianity.

[@user-nn9kv7rv6k]

​@@devinxoxo8350"More evolved" I can almost smell the Christian arrogance

[@thedebatehitman]

First!

[@highheels5596]

And last.

[@katieblake8911]

ok I am sorry but no matter how much I loved a man I would NEVAH EVAH give up my christian faith for a Jewish man probably much less date one and neither should anyone else it dishonors Jesus in the worst way it is turning your back on him

[@crazybeautifullens]

There are Jewish people who are saved in Jesus. They're the messianic Jews. There would be no need to give up your Christian faith if one married a messianic Jewish man who is in Christ as well. I think a Christian married to a Messianic Jewish man would be the perfect match ☺

[@katieblake8911]

@@crazybeautifullens true but I am talking about men that are not saved in christ

[@crazybeautifullens]

@@katieblake8911 I understand 🙂

[@cattyelse2372]

@@katieblake8911 what does it matter if ones loves? religions are all fantasy

[@katieblake8911]

@@cattyelse2372 ugh no not so much but you are entitled to your opinion

[@RiichanTV103]

they are really going out of their way but subtly telling people through almost every shows like sex and the city, friends, Brooklyn99 etc that being Jewish is essential.

[@DixieFaukner]

what jewish refrences were in friends and brooklyn99?

[@ShowMeYourKitties0]

I converted on my own accord and I ended up dating a devote catholic. We work it out. No idols in the home, but he can have Xmas like I can my holy days. It’s take and give. Don’t convert to a Judaism as a Christian unless you are prepared for it. Because it’s a change but it’s worth it.