Can you chop down a tree with a SWORD?!? |

[@scottybreuer]

The running joke about Kramer trying to find the rest of the group is fantastic.

[@sirzorg5728]

Living Anachronism is a great channel.

[@goukeban6197]

One day the joke is gonna be that he appears out of nowhere and they don't know what to do.

[@gavinotheshitpostartist5586]

@@goukeban6197 I was honestly thinking he was suddenly gonna appear at the end of video when they were walking away

[@Wondrrboy]

He has before Zoro

[@ironbatman9689]

They're on long distance party

[@TheMortalMan]

Fun fact: Kramer is actually in every Shadiversity video, but he's so good at stealth that he can't be seen or heard

[@MrRaposaum]

When stealth roll is so good it puts you on an alternate reality.

[@brenomatos8384]

@@MrRaposaum I can do that in my DnD campain.

[@zderpydiamond4800]

@@brenomatos8384 Pov: You have a +20 to stealth.

[@brenomatos8384]

@@zderpydiamond4800I could temporarily jump to another dimension. It was fun to disappear in front of the enemy and sneak attack from behind.

[@zderpydiamond4800]

@@brenomatos8384 *PFFFFFTT!!!* THATS F***ING HILARIOUS!! I LOVE IT!

[@gebus5633]

3 vs 1 and the tree was unarmed. Moral victory to the tree.

[@derekstein6193]

A tree did defeat one of the blades. Good on it.

[@lolinognori8200]

That tree was armed... it had a stick

[@Dang_Near_Fed_Up]

@@lolinognori8200 Next I guess you will say it was armored as well, with wooden armor. LOL

[@rurikaunimoto]

​@@Dang_Near_Fed_UpI mean... technically... and it's arms are literally sticks.

[@torejorgensen5344]

Three vs tree... not that big a difference 😀.

[@Grandwigg]

That poor guardsman who used to be an adventure . . . The opening sketches have been absolute treasures. And Kramer's bit was priceless.

[@bigguy7353]

A man being able to be an "adventure", which is a concept, is what truly interests me.

[@informationyes]

@@bigguy7353 Going going an adventure is just exploring things for yourself

[@User-435ggrest]

Felt like watching a comedy TV show😂

[@Oficial_Mithin]

Honestly I give all swords a thumbs up for surviving that much abuse to begin with haha

[@clorkmagnus]

I give modern steel a thumb up because I feel like old swords with old steel gonna drop dead with this kind of abuse.

[@ventana2011]

El falchion en realidad es un machete Truper modificado del mango. Le agregaron pomo y gavilanes. Fue una buena mejora.😊

[@epicdragon409]

The day when Kramer and the shadiversity knights finally find each other will be a great day!

[@horse3015]

The big crossover!

[@MassiveDynamic9]

I think that it is now proven beyond all doubt that bigger trees require more chops than smaller trees.

[@rubberbandba11craft]

is that you osvaldo12?

[@radioactiveassassin5218]

Is it though? I feel like some more testing should be the done.

[@Handles_AreStupid]

@@radioactiveassassin5218 if you use a chainsaw on a small tree and on a big tree, they both only take one "chop", so this is clearly disinformation. Can't fool me.

[@bartle6168]

It would be a lot easier if anyone of them knew how to chop down a standing tree.

[@MephiticMiasma]

When Shad admits it's a bad idea, you know it's going to be fun.

[@Epck]

Bad for his swords 😢😢😢

[@rayceeya8659]

"A sharp sword is better than a blunt axe" That's some philosophy shit there.

[@Crossbow-xy4xg]

Sun Tzu, probably

[@Talishar]

Especially when using absolutely terrible technique with the axe with most of the swings being oblique and not being squared up with the tree.

[@elio7610]

Seemed like a safety hazard the way it was being used.

[@AllisonRutherford-vs4dt]

It's also inaccurate as fuck, a dull axe will always chop better than any sword, but they don't know how to swing the axe properly, they're meant to be chopping wood not sparring

[@rayceeya8659]

@@Talishar That're also using the wrong axe. To fell a tree you use a felling axe. That's a splitting axe.

[@kungfugirevik657]

Shad: Feelings? Feelings! It's about the results! Blending the skit with the sword testing is great. The channel is getting better and better!

[@A41Rory]

First couple minutes just define its not the treasure at the end of the journey, its the friends you make along the way

[@Mr_Jumbles]

Well yeah, because they already stole the treasure at the beginning of the journey. SWORDS!

[@elio7610]

Friends? Or enemies?

[@BloodSlinga]

And pissing off Ogres

[@TheOtherMwalimu]

and Kramer! 😊

[@Quack-e9u]

how? did you post before video video is 8 hours your comment is 9 hours ago

[@MikeiusOfficial]

Shad hits the exact same spot almost every time and is casual about it.

[@asdalmeida]

This "story format" was great: setting up the premise for why our adventurers would need to use their swords to cut down some trees and then seeing them walk off into the sunset after a successful conclusion. Well done!

[@hannibalburgers477]

It is fine but it triggers my early-youtube PTSD

[@futabafanclub]

@@hannibalburgers477 Is… Is that a good thing?

[@ForsakenGaming666]

The way Shad, Nate, and Tyranth do their adventuring stuff, it makes me think this: If they could appear in a Viva La Dirt League "Epic NPC Man" video, it would be sooo much fun! I mean, VLDL is in New Zealand, so they really aren't too far away. Maybe one day, when Shad and the crew are more financially stable.

[@IvanBarsch]

I’ve had the exact same thought! Even better, (I know Shad isn’t the biggest fan of DnD) but I’d like to see any of these three as a guest on NPC DND.

[@stephenadams8712]

Or maybe deerstalker pictures as they have DnD and elder rings

[@ATurkeySandwichGAME]

Tyranth was holding back. That katana not only would have cut that tree in one go, it would have cut space and time all together

[@swordweaver9696]

yeah, an iaigiri woulda gone straight through multiple trees

[@fatsu]

i disagree, its not a traditionally made katana. it's only a cheap imitation.

[@juliusnebulus7303]

I was surprised it even survived the first swings. Katanas are okay, but were never meant for anything else then traditional combat (only in life or death situations, otherwise even unsheathing it in front of others would give you a death sentence) and looking cool. A good result from a mid weapon. Not bad.

[@shadowwolf2608]

He could have saved so much time if he used Thunder Breathing 1st Form X fold in order to cut them all down in milliseconds.

[@xaius4348]

The Katana surprised me. Maybe that tree identified as a Tatami mat

[@bradbrandon2506]

Thanks! And thank you for listing this in the short!!

[@chrisbaker8533]

Just couldn't resist the 'arrow to the knee' could ya. Priceless.

[@stevel3620]

Hey! No lollygaggin!

[@SoftisNelaris]

They got the low-hanging 'arrow to the knee' joke but missed the opportunity to say they stole the Ogre's Sweet Roll (along with the swords)

[@PaulShattter]

I think we can all agree this is the best video he has made yet. The story going on in the background, along with the jokes and on top of that somehow the education that got fit into the video was all incredible. The color correction was also really good, I feel like Shad got a new camera or editor or something, it just looked more vibrant.

[@Ekseth]

I must admit I was worried for the claymore and the sounds the poor thing was making and the katana really surprised me with how good it performed.

[@jasonr5989]

I've got a Swamp Rat ( Busse Knives ) Waki which eats up any wood ( but has trouble with dry tuart...even a sharp axe has trouble with tuart...). It also cuts metal. It's SR101 not Infi. Infi excellent for knives, but SR101 is the go for a longer blade.

[@PJDAltamirus0425]

Well, the cross section of a katana is the most axe like. Narrow and somewhat thick. Tbh, a flacata, Jo pi and flax would probably as well or even cus of cross section and the forward curvature.

[@Markbell73]

And that was the 300 dollar Katana on top of that. Very impressive build quality.

[@Markbell73]

But the Bastard Sword needs a new name. It is no longer fair to call it a bastard. It chopped into two tree's, and was thirsty for more bark! Boramir, Son of Denethor. You my good sir, are honored. Your sword is blessed by the God of Chopping.

[@JeffDeLamater]

@@Markbell73I didn’t remember for the $300 katana, but many less expensive katana are through hardened and actually perform better than the differentially hardened ones. But the through hardened ones don’t have a Hamon, which is part of the katana aesthetic. Though some through hardened one will have an acid etch Hamon to mimic the pattern.

[@ninjalionddhogan4060]

I honestly thought that I would need some time to adjust to the new recruits, but they fit so well and are so entertaining that I barely even noticed the addition of them Well done

[@godcats959]

My heart skipped a beat, every time they smash those poor swords into the tree.

[@jarydjarjarsfasha2998]

Are you a ghost?

[@godcats959]

@@jarydjarjarsfasha2998 Uhmm No!?

[@jarydjarjarsfasha2998]

@@godcats959 cause ye must've died from ya heart beat skipping so much

[@Zoddlander]

I was heartbroken when i saw that Kreigsmesser brake! 😭

[@godcats959]

@@jarydjarjarsfasha2998 well i'm a God(Cats) i can just come back to life.

[@r3dp9]

2:48 That shot makes it look like you're on a greenscreen but flipped the backround image upside down. There's a "blue sky" below and ground above. Took me a second to realize my eyes were tricking me.

[@theickster3008]

Still throwing a Skyrim reference in 12 years later. I both love and hate you for this Shad.

[@DH-xw6jp]

Maybe if they ever release the next game we can move on to new references.

[@timogul]

"Arrow to the knee" will be a common phrase 100 years from now, and no one will know why.

[@LadyBirdieBop]

Ok but my favorite quote award goes to Shad with, “I know it’s not cricket but these guys fight dirty!!”

[@Jerryboy123]

The ending was truly epic.

[@Gterr1971]

I respect how you all stayed in character

[@astahfirula]

Kramer is that friend that is always missing the rpg sessions so they have to make his character be doing something else. 😂

[@josephcollins4823]

I had a friend that was a gnome that was always missing so we just had him sleeping in the bag of holding

[@kwmcgreal]

Thank you for the disclaimer about the trees! I appreciate your care

[@Amelec1]

Gotta say, love the incorporation of story into these videos, creates a bit of fun and education... A great blend

[@biohazard9254]

20:09 Shad being kinda cocky is something I didn’t know I needed, love the content guys!

[@markthintie5132]

All swords perfomed great. I am still surprised the Katana did not break.

[@johnmullholand2044]

More surprised that the claymore didn't break. A longer sword, against a hard target like a tree seems like a easy way to break a sword.

[@embee7434]

I look forward to the day that the compilations can be made with all the intros and outros and we get to just watch your grand adventure unfold... I just love them. Such a fun video! To many fun bits to mention them all, but I'll say I LOVE Cramer's cameos. The outcome, I think, shows that 'your favorite sword' is the best sword to cut trees down with.

[@zacchaeusabbiati2452]

I love this new content so much XD Great balance between amusing fantasy hijinks, and actual educational material!

[@MrCoxmic]

3:00 definition of a man, "we're idiots and we like having fun"

[@spidersoldier1039]

Glad you are feeling well enough to do these kinds of videos Shad. Very cool topic!

[@patrick_j_lee]

That bit at the beginning was incredible - the acting and banter were great . You really should consider making skits/short films as their own videos.

[@KoshoShinogi]

The directing and editing style since Tyranth joined the channel is so entertaining. And the chemistry the three of you have is incredible. Hats off to you sirs. Surprised by the katana in this. Sure they're sharp, but they don't have as much mass as some of the other swords to push through thicker objects.

[@lexievv]

They are more ridged and wobble less tho, so maybe more of the force of impact is actually going into the wood.

[@kikixchannel]

@@lexievv They are also thinned probably, so there's less opposition from the wood. The exact reason why claymore was crap. It was too thick.

[@stefthorman8548]

what? katanas aren't light at all, what makes you think it has less mass?

[@KoshoShinogi]

​@@stefthorman8548 Mass and weight are not the same. Mass is a measurement of how much matter an object contains, not how heavy it is. But let me clarify my statement. The falchion and broadsword are wider than the katana. The katana is a longer but narrower sword, so its overall mass may be similar, but at the point of impact where the sword strikes the tree, the other two have more mass. More mass equals more force. I am by no means a physicist so feel free to correct me, but that was my thinking when I made the statement.

[@kikixchannel]

@@KoshoShinogi Um...Katana does have more mass... You're right in that mass is not the same as weight. But that's mostly all you are correct on. In a world where gravity exists, objects with more mass will be heavier. That's because weight IS just mass times the gravitational force (which is equal). An object with twice the mass will also be twice as heavy. Furthermore, going by their size and balance, katana is more dense so there's even MORE mass at the point of impact. Because there's more mass in smaller part of the small blade. This is exactly the crux with a katana. Its density, stiffness and being blade-heavy makes it a good cutter, but far more fragile and less 'agile' than western blades.

[@shawnwolf5961]

Sorry Shad, Sorry Nate. Got to give it to Tyrath and his Katana. That thing even *looked* like it was cutting smoother than the other swords. That said all 3 of those rocked and I cannot say how much I wish I could be there chopping too. Looked like a hell of a lot of fun!

[@Xyponx]

I was pretty shocked, even as a certified weeabo, that the katana performed so well.

[@doubleh3978]

I really like that you guys put the care even in selecting the trees you already want to cut down to do something like this instead of cutting down random trees like many people would do. And i always love to make something i HAVE to do (like you had to cut down those trees) and transform it in something funny (like trying to cut them with swords), i like to kill two birds with one stone, it's a smart move. Well done!

[@cdgonepotatoes4219]

People who don't spare a thought about what to do with the felled tree, usually aren't bright in general an therefore you shouldn't pay them mind. Videos like this are generally made because there was the opportunity to do so, either they or someone else is doing landscaping or they found a dead tree.

[@DH-xw6jp]

Whoa, this is a video about tree cutting. Why would you bring bird killing up? Do you want to anger the emus?

[@bigguy7353]

Imagine even caring about what someone does to dead trees on their property. The disclaimer made me laugh.

[@JackSparrow-gn1zn]

After watching all the slow-motion hacks I think I can say Nate never miss-aligned his edge. Impressive

[@snipercommando9]

Shad does more for the environment here than the entire Established Titles grift.

[@cocodojo]

I'd rather give money to Shad for his Shadlands knowing that he'll actually plant saplings there to grow into a forest and just get a title of "Honorary Shadling" because that's way cooler than a fancy fake title.

[@jedodom3056]

@@cocodojo I too wish to be an Honorary Shadling.

[@goodguy4611]

Gift us the title of Honorary Shadling!

[@zandensterner3918]

I really loved the costume design at the start of the video. The darker red fits Nate's calmer character and the the fur fits Tyranth's more flashy character really well.

[@tituslaturno4914]

Oh my lord that final shot with the three of you guys on the hill… that looked cinematic 😮I swear these videos get cooler with every try and it’s so much fun to see the stuff you guys get up too

[@BobT36]

That lake in the background looks fantastic!

[@LeonDuginski]

I always look forward to your weekend content! Thanks for another great video

[@RiderofRiddermark]

I really love the skid bracketing the core theme of the video; the TTRPG vibe truly fits the overall mood of these videos. It's also funny to see how the moment they hand a single edged sword to Tyranth, he just goes beast mode on the trees. 12:24 and 20:26 look so badass.

[@derekdoolittle257]

The intro roleplay made me realize I would not only love a DnD game with these guys, but I would be fascinated by an rpg system they built off of historical accuracy of weapons and armors

[@Grandwigg]

Shad narrated an adventure using his Cogent roleplay system with several sword channels a while back before his other channel pivoted towards reviews. It was a load of fun

[@ThePianiolist]

The opening sketch is incredible, and it makes me think that now what I need in my life is a medieval style office series

[@gavinotheshitpostartist5586]

Dammnit, Kramer keeps getting teased. Cant wait for him to finally be able to get to Australia

[@soya_kitchens]

The story bits (especially the end scene there) have elevated this channel to such a new height! I honestly would be satisfied if sword videos were temporarily benched for an awesome live-action short story/mini-series!

[@colvyre6622]

Chewed up the trees on par with some local beavers. This was interesting... and to be fair to the other swords, the falchion actually was a machete in a past life 😆

[@OlafVonBarto]

You guys keep getting better and better. Great video!!

[@johanjarvinen]

It would have been interesting to see how a Chinese (two-handed) dao would have done, since they seem like they'd be tailor made for chopping. Also a guandao would be fascinating, but I'd imagine if you had one on hand you'd not be keen to use it for such a test.

[@stephenmetcalf5668]

Those camera shots at the end, beautiful landscape.

[@crozraven]

16:59 EXACTLY, modern mono steel are indeed simply way better than folded steel that lacks purity. This tree cutting test has given us quite a big info that having the same material factor, katana blade profile proved to be just as good if not better in cutting & chopping compare to longsword blade profile.

[@TheKazragore]

Comparing the level of engagement in the comment section vs the view count tells me that Shad has some seriously engaged viewers, and definitely deserves more of them. KZbin's algorithm is slacking off.

[@VidelxSpopovich]

As a big fan of bastard swords I’m really happy to see this.

[@carltonwilliams9256]

The Men in Tights clips broke me bad😂😂😂

[@polishFantasyEN]

Just a few seconds into the video, and my elvish soul rejoices at the mention that the trees are going to get replanted. Now I can enjoy in peace. A true great man: Shad.

[@inthefade]

My inner Ent… Is… Considering… That I am… Possibly… Pleased.

[@teancrumpets5685]

leaf luvin knife ear

[@azurE2g]

opening and final skit was fantastic.

[@brycetheviewer9986]

oh my gosh ❤ its funny its informative its sooooo interesting and you even managed to make it into a small story!! Guys, you are doing best ive seen of ya❤

[@bradbrandon2506]

I'm just glad I finally found a way to help out.

[@sbskinner369]

I want more lore for these adventurers PLEASE 😂 It's fantastic!!

[@robertgehrig1631]

Funny the Kramer running gag. Several videos now. I once wrote a scene in a book about a sword smith sharpening a sword after his son used it to chop down a tree. Thus requiring him to sharpen it. Fun to watch someone actually sort of living out a part of that. Now I’m curious on how hitting the wood affected the actual blades. How much damage was done to the edges?

[@Desertneo]

The Katana held itself way better than I expected. I'd give it a tie with the Bastard sword, which is a major step-up on the way I considered Katanas so far!

[@noble7525]

This bastard sword has survived through hell and back. It has been broken and repaired, and somehow, it's still going. I can imagine it telling it's stories to it's sword grand children

[@NemoConsequentae]

"Gather round, kids, and I'll tell you about the time my user was attacked by the ferocious copse of trees!"

[@MaaZeus]

What bastard sword is it anyway and how much it costs? It is a very gorgeous sword, I wouldn't mind owning one.

[@TengokuEXE]

Honshu single handed Broadsword. It is around $200. It may not be a $1k sword, but it doesn't need to be. Some hate the modern aesthetic, but I think it's cool.

[@tylerdillon3745]

I missed this video, I watch KZbin every day but it didn't show me this one. I am getting a bunch of random crap for suggested watching, but I had to dig through my subscription history to find that Shadiversity had released this.

[@rzgaming5678]

Another thing to take into account is the trees will have different densities, despite having grown in one area. So sword performance may vary with that. Adding that on top of other variables. That said, those poor swords lol

[@Daedricsoulslayer]

The craftsmanship of those blades!

[@jakubstibor8566]

The end felt a lot like a top gear challenge ending😂

[@samuelberry4186]

The silhouette look at the end looked great.

[@BluegrassKnight]

Great Shad and Co., a good name for your new machete sword I think "Falchete" would be a good fit for it, keep up the great videos.

[@Crazozourus]

Wild Hunt vibes, going through Shads land. Awesome.

[@kaninom_KAS]

Good to see your health is in a good enough state to take part in these activities! Amazing video!

[@musicfanatic24]

I love your acting, guys. From these scripts as part of the video to whoever is sponsoring whatever video, you guys do such a great job!

[@Khalleh1]

I hope shad keeps making this amazing content, also i think the katana wins as you wouldn't want to have reverb in the handle as that would tire the hands more then if there wasn't, like the katana

[@straightjacket308]

Yeah but since it's so rigid too it'll bend easier unlike the European swords which are meant to flex and maintain their shape.

[@inthefade]

Chopping trees isn’t the purpose of a sword. You’re thinking of an axe.

[@MrPablosek]

@@inthefade That's not the point of the video.

[@richardwilmer4550]

Weeb

[@joaquinpalavecino6308]

That last shot with the silhouettes was just beautiful

[@adrigl3371]

I love how they where color-coordinated in this video, they look like an adventuring party with matching uniforms

[@lacasa3514]

Love seeing the land, beautiful. I like how you found a way to be 11 forever. Well done, sir.

[@mudwalkers8338]

I love the slo mo shots of Shad. You can tell he’s having so much fun!! 🤩🔥👣

[@veldryn01]

To help with the algorithm ! Nice video as always ! Cheers !

[@felx233]

Very interesting video, they are the only ones I know that test several swords at the same time

[@OmarTFL]

You guys are such a lovable trio! Videos like these are what make me love this channel so much, and while I'm not able to financially support you guys at the moment, you'll be the first channel I join once I finally am : D Keep up the great work boys

[@shadiversity]

Thank you so much Omar, you're the best!

[@docreaver1138]

Another fantastic episode, guys! Really loved seeing Kramer again! Keep up the good work guys!

[@_Michiel_]

This one was awesome, guys! I loved the banter (and the sword cutting of course!). Keep 'em coming please!

[@marcusc9931]

My rpg party will be facing a treant tomorrow. This is very informative

[@alexanderren1097]

20:27 friggin perfect! Side note: I know perspectives from the video aren’t the same as being there in person but it did make me nervous that he’s not wearing a helmet or hard hat. Maybe I’ve spent too much time offshore. Something to consider next time

[@grantpflum6844]

That Falchion really is beautiful. It immediately draws the eye, even among all the other swords you were carrying.

[@SamuraiHonor]

Saw this vid mentioned in the whip video. Here for the extra engagement.

[@CaptainSweatpants90]

Shad really has come a long way from "MACHICOLATIONS!!" to "absolutely fucking smashing his own swords in every other video!", and I'm totally here for it

[@Castawayassassin]

Summer is really arrived to my heart seeing the three siluetts walking into the sunset. Great video, great format choice. Great swords. Telling tales is timeless. Can't wait it to be continued!

[@gregorybrazell5133]

After watching the 'dull axe' part... have you considered how well a tree might be cut down with a mace, flail, maul, etc? How about nunchucks?

[@TheLastMoonFall]

You're funny, man

[@phoenix_dreams6206]

Loved the bit of roleplaying of adventurers.

[@BigPanda096]

Kramer additions are always great.. hes just very good at stealth.

[@TheMadPoetHimself]

That last shot was peak cinema.

[@JH-vl6eh]

Not taking away from the abilities of the swords to chop wood, but a properly profiled and sharpened axe, I think, would have blown your mind by how well they cut.

[@Markbell73]

Orc filth. They come with axes. They come with fire. Curse them. Knawing, biting. Breaking, hacking, burning!

[@whosweptmymines3956]

Yeah, I cut down plenty of trees with axes in my teens and it's remarkable how effective they can be if you use the right ax for the job and make sure it's sharp. Cutting down a tree with an ax designed for splitting is a truly awful experience.

[@ToxicityAssured]

I think they knew and added the axe for a fun comparison...? I hope that's what that scene was all about. I have lots of Kelly, Keen Kutter, Plumb, Collins and a few others from good makers. Thin the bit down some, learn how and where to chop to remove chips and let em fall! I find chopping up fallen trees on family lands very therapeutic.

[@Callacallan]

I really enjoy the Krameos we've had in the past few videos. Very funny.

[@JohnAndJohner]

Realistically, specific swords aside, it should just be the sword that is most axe-like, which in the blade would be something like a kriegsmesser, or even more exaggerated would be maciejowski falchion. That kriegsmesser handle does look painful, though, both the material and the shape.

[@JakeDanczyk]

I agree with Shad, the bastard sword impressed me the most from what I could see. Tyranth did mention the Katana being the most comfortable, a factor we can't "see".

[@shawn6860]

ya, comfort would be a big factor. especially if wielded for a long time.

[@macchxero]

Amazing video! I had nearly zero expectation on the katana. But hey! It went so well that actually performed better than the claymore AND kriegsmesser surprised me. For chopping tree though, I would prefer the Falchion and the Machete. But overall I'm gonna vote for bastard sword, not only because it's my favorite type of sword, but also for its practicality and versatility (that's why I fell in love with it two decades ago)