Shaykh Dr. Shabir Ally | Juxtaposing the Quran, Jumbling Aisha's age & Jinn Possession | MindTrap#16

Navigating through Crucial Conversations & Difficult Dialogues on Faith in our World today.
*[Timestamps below]
Guest: Shaykh Dr. Shabir Ally
*The objective of these videos is to bring to the public such conversations that have for too long remained private, for the privileged and seldom spoken before the flock. And so the legend has it, the noose eventually loosened from around the neck of Liberty.
With Love
MALM
02:45 Dr Shabir Ally's journey recap
03:55 Have people moved along with your views? Traditional vs Thinking people.
06:52 Primacy of the Quran / Examples of Quran vs Hadith rulings / Stoning
12:18 Penalty of apostasy / No compulsion in Deen
14:07 (Compulsion) Why is this apparent to you, but not to the Ulama of the past?
18:58 Do laws change to reflect the day and age we live in? / Letter of the Law vs Spirit of the Law
25:10 Are you not just giving your own Akal over the Quran and Hadith / Giving preference to the intellect?
28:01 Do you think the Akal (intellect) has been demonised?
30:46 How can Nakal be understood except through the Akal?
32:56 Prophet's marriage to Aisha and Khadija (age discussion)
47:54 Is this all a cry to appease Non-Muslims?
55:00 People claim that you are challenging Sahih al-Bukhari
01:01:56 Mutawatir / Living tradition / Fiqh / Farabri / Bukhari
01:09:30 Hadith can be easily misrelated
01:15:08 Thoughts on Exorcism / Demonic poessession / Jinns / Personal responsibility / Jesus / Medical intervention / Magic
01:40:09 Is Islam feudal or anti-feudal
01:40:47 An ayah about Black Magic? ( 113 Al Falak, ayah 4)
01:42:17 Someone asked about "Right hand possesses" / Slaves and Concubines

[@nycnow811]

I love Dr Shabir Ally, hes such a father figure, that awesome grandfather figure, may Allah preserve him always.

[@azzkam8972]

I don’t agree I’m afraid! he’s still a young lion not an old grandad figure

[@notionSlave]

Except Shabir is a heretic for saying in one of his 'Let the Quran Speak' videos, that Hell-fire is a myth, that Allah simply uses that warning to scare people.

[@azzkam8972]

notionSlave if he said that then I can’t agree with that.

[@nycnow811]

@@notionSlave what's the video titled

[@notionSlave]

@@nycnow811 Title: Q&A: Are the Quran's Descriptions of Hell Literal? | Dr. Shabir Ally kzbin.info/www/bejne/j5S0omp5p86mmdU

[@imranabbasi8198]

I’ve been following Dr Shabir since 2003 and I miss old him with dark beard. May Allah protect him and grant him long life. Ameen!

[@MuftiAbuLayth]

im sure the Dark bear issue can be resolved 👀 😂

[@imranabbasi8198]

Mufti Abu Layth ... Nostalgia Mufti, is Denial... Denial of painful present 😊

[@etiennebisset5642]

In 2014, Christian Prince sent an invitation to Dr. Shabir Ally for a debate with him through the response of this public video. Now it is 2020, and six years later, it's still a no-show. Why is Dr. Shabir Ally reluctant to debate Christian Prince? His valid reasons might ruin his preaching career for good? Is his career more important than the truth? If you love Dr. Shabir Ally, ask him to call Christian Prince. He's online and "live" on KZbin every day when he's not occupied. It's FOC (free-of-charge) to call. kzbin.info/www/bejne/fHaziX-Yob1nors

[@shairsko9360]

@@MuftiAbuLayth GGG (grow gray gracefully) dude ! 🤣

[@moedot7]

Timestamps: 02:45 Dr Shabir Ally's journey recap 03:55 Have people moved along with your views? Traditional vs Thinking people. 06:52 Primacy of the Quran / Examples of Quran vs Hadith rulings / Stoning 12:18 Penalty of apostasy / No compulsion in Deen 14:07 (Compulsion) Why is this apparent to you, but not to the Ulama of the past? 18:58 Do laws change to reflect the day and age we live in? / Letter of the Law vs Spirit of the Law 25:10 Are you not just giving your own Akal over the Quran and Hadith / Giving preference to the intellect? 28:01 Do you think the Akal (intellect) has been demonised? 30:46 How can Nakal be understood except through the Akal? 32:56 Prophet's marriage to Aisha and Khadija (age discussion) 47:54 Is this all a cry to appease Non-Muslims? 55:00 People claim that you are challenging Sahih al-Bukhari 01:01:56 Mutawatir / Living tradition / Fiqh / Farabri / Bukhari 01:09:30 Hadith can be easily misrelated 01:15:08 Thoughts on Exorcism / Demonic poessession / Jinns / Personal responsibility / Jesus / Medical intervention / Magic 01:40:09 Is Islam feudal or anti-feudal 01:40:47 An ayah about Black Magic? ( 113 Al Falak, ayah 4) 01:42:17 Someone asked about "Right hand possesses" / Slaves and Concubines

[@AQ1888]

moedot7 Thank You!

[@samboy1406]

thanks

[@elwise5864]

Thanks!

[@basheermuhammad2247]

Thankyou 👍

[@ronmc333]

Thank you

[@Azzarrati]

Shaykh Shabbir has been underrated. He is one of the top notch scholars of our time !

[@etiennebisset5642]

In 2014, Christian Prince sent an invitation to Dr. Shabir Ally for a debate with him through the response of this public video. Now it is 2020, and six years later, it's still a no-show. Why is Dr. Shabir Ally reluctant to debate Christian Prince? His valid reasons might ruin his preaching career for good? Is his career more important than the truth? If you love Dr. Shabir Ally, ask him to call Christian Prince. He's online and "live" on KZbin every day when he's not occupied. It's FOC (free-of-charge) to call. kzbin.info/www/bejne/fHaziX-Yob1nors

[@MacMac1313]

@@etiennebisset5642 I see your same comment everywhere. Are you trying to disprove Dr. Shabir Ali yourself ??? Or are you really trying to hype up this " Christian Prince " for personal reasons ??? If so, can you email and contact Dr. Shabir on your own accord to get answers directly from him ?? Or are you jumping to conclusions without answers to your questions yet ?? It seems like you're already claiming victory for something that has not happened regardless of the time where this supposed invitation was given. As long as the debate hasn't taken place then there is nothing for you to prove here. Otherwise, send your emails and questions to Dr. Shabir Ali. Also, I notice that this is a matter of debate. If this is true, can you please explain to me in mathematics what does 1+1+1 equal to ??? I'm a former Catholic of Mexican, Chicano descent and left that denomination for a reason. So don't come at me with differences of upbringings and country of origin topics when it comes to Islam because it sure won't work with me. I'll wait for your response.

[@etiennebisset5642]

@@MacMac1313 I will not waste my time in you.

[@mirza_saabb193]

Dr Shabir is a legend...someone put the timestamps please!

[@jawada2508]

I'm working on it InshAllah

[@mirza_saabb193]

@@jawada2508 inshaAllah thanks brother ✊

[@moedot7]

@@mirza_saabb193 Check comments for Timestamps 👍🏽

[@etiennebisset5642]

In 2014, Christian Prince sent an invitation to Dr. Shabir Ally for a debate with him through the response of this public video. Now it is 2020, and six years later, it's still a no-show. Why is Dr. Shabir Ally reluctant to debate Christian Prince? His valid reasons might ruin his preaching career for good? Is his career more important than the truth? If you love Dr. Shabir Ally, ask him to call Christian Prince. He's online and "live" on KZbin every day when he's not occupied. It's FOC (free-of-charge) to call. kzbin.info/www/bejne/fHaziX-Yob1nors

[@fatimaxo4885]

@@etiennebisset5642 because dr ally is more concerned with guiding people rather than getting into pissy debates with those rude individuals. Also dr shabbier ally has already debated Christian apologists and he spanked them all pretty bad. He even opposes some very tough Islamic rulings even amongst fellow scholars so I can assure the words that can jeopardize his life does not scare him. Please show yourself out ...

[@yusuffulat6954]

We need another episode with Dr Shabir 🤩

[@Hello-vz1md]

Watch Farid Response video s

[@etiennebisset5642]

In 2014, Christian Prince sent an invitation to Dr. Shabir Ally for a debate with him through the response of this public video. Now it is 2020, and six years later, it's still a no-show. Why is Dr. Shabir Ally reluctant to debate Christian Prince? His valid reasons might ruin his preaching career for good? Is his career more important than the truth? If you love Dr. Shabir Ally, ask him to call Christian Prince. He's online and "live" on KZbin every day when he's not occupied. It's FOC (free-of-charge) to call. kzbin.info/www/bejne/fHaziX-Yob1nors

[@oye214]

I feel proud when i see Shaykhs like Dr Shabir. Wallah what a way to deliver.. A man with so much wisdom MashaAllah.. Mufti Layth next debate should be with Javed Ahmed Ghamdi school of thoughts.

[@faree38green]

Epic intellectual discourse between two very rationale and enlightened learned scholars! Well done Mufti. Much love to you!

[@nycnow811]

The fact that even in very recent Kurdish history (I'm Kurdish) absolutely nobody knew their own birthdays, my mom and dads birthdays are January 1st, which is definitely not the case.

[@mohamedkamrar8718]

same in pakistan

[@Fahad-gf1wx]

@Sam E are you berber

[@YA-hm5zy]

Salaams my Kurdish brother. UK muslim here

[@uzzolnakhkaitra5137]

Yes it was very common in remote villages of Indian subcontinent.

[@memememmee7794]

This happens all over the middle East. So ironic because it's their obsession with calculating age based on year that creates fake birthdays where being born after mid year means you're declared a year older after a few months. So many people have January first as their birthday to "save" a year of the child's life.

[@kaisersoza4829]

Truly a landmark in Islamic history, Subha Allah.

[@ashkehlan4743]

About Professor Javed Ahmed Ghamidi, I not only believe that there is no scholar of his stature profundity of religious thought and precision of its understanding and lucidity of his articulation in the Muslim word, but I also believe that I have yet to see anybody more profound just and humane than Professor Javed Ahmed Ghamidi sahib, when it comes to commentary on social issues including human rights. May Allah bless his countless blessings upon Ghamdi sb! Ameeeeeen. ( USTAAD MOHTARAM MAY YOUR SEED PROSPER GOD WILLING)

[@libbzany2875]

Please mufti have him back on again please mufti you two are my favorite

[@sahandmahmoud1192]

This episode was toooo good!

[@moucheali3911]

Great guest He probably one of the few with Islamic knowledge as resonable as yourself

[@arampm]

That was a wonderful discussion. What an excellent ruqiyya! All the doubts in my mind about the demonic posession are rooted out. Alhamdulillah. JazakumaAllahu khairan.

[@ahmedmohammad7300]

What an enlightening session this was. ♥️

[@isitreal79]

Thanks again MALM for the information and in this case a fantastic guest.

[@erminization]

MALMxDOOM next episode make it happen

[@MuftiAbuLayth]

Our pleasure!

[@abdulraufsalifu5549]

Maa shaa Allah, mufti thank you so much for this brilliant discourse with this legend. Allah bless you all.

[@MuftiAbuLayth]

My pleasure

[@BukhariZ]

@@MuftiAbuLayth Salam not sure if you would still read it. But a great discussion and esteemed guest. I have a request. I take that you can talk in Urdu and in that case you do a session with Javed Ahmed Ghamidi please

[@777joemac]

Very beautiful episode ....i am a here listening till the end

[@poetaali5718]

This is so beautiful! الله يجزيكما

[@nazammushtaq8103]

Love Shabir Ali First time I met him in 2006 I was so impressed by his knowledge masha Allah

[@djamelzitouni950]

One of the best video.... very refreshing lol. Thank you both, Shabir Ally and mufti Abu Layt.

[@MuftiAbuLayth]

Glad you enjoyed it

[@etiennebisset5642]

In 2014, Christian Prince sent an invitation to Dr. Shabir Ally for a debate with him through the response of this public video. Now it is 2020, and six years later, it's still a no-show. Why is Dr. Shabir Ally reluctant to debate Christian Prince? His valid reasons might ruin his preaching career for good? Is his career more important than the truth? If you love Dr. Shabir Ally, ask him to call Christian Prince. He's online and "live" on KZbin every day when he's not occupied. It's FOC (free-of-charge) to call. kzbin.info/www/bejne/fHaziX-Yob1nors

[@djamelzitouni950]

@@etiennebisset5642 Il faut poser la question a Mr Ally, pas à moi. Les gens sont libres de refuser un debat, cela n'implique rien et j'imagine que Mr Ally a d'autres raisons pour ne pas donner suite, des raisons bien plus terre a terre comme le niveau de connaissances, le parcours universitaire, l'anonymat, le niveau de language etc... Paix.

[@cricuts1]

Absolutely loved the conversation. Two learned scholars having a meaningful discussion in order to educate people.

[@kroozi]

Shabbir Ally brings so much peace to my heart!

[@etiennebisset5642]

In 2014, Christian Prince sent an invitation to Dr. Shabir Ally for a debate with him through the response of this public video. Now it is 2020, and six years later, it's still a no-show. Why is Dr. Shabir Ally reluctant to debate Christian Prince? His valid reasons might ruin his preaching career for good? Is his career more important than the truth? If you love Dr. Shabir Ally, ask him to call Christian Prince. He's online and "live" on KZbin every day when he's not occupied. It's FOC (free-of-charge) to call. kzbin.info/www/bejne/fHaziX-Yob1nors

[@m.e.e2878]

Love Dr. Shabir Ally

[@etiennebisset5642]

In 2014, Christian Prince sent an invitation to Dr. Shabir Ally for a debate with him through the response of this public video. Now it is 2020, and six years later, it's still a no-show. Why is Dr. Shabir Ally reluctant to debate Christian Prince? His valid reasons might ruin his preaching career for good? Is his career more important than the truth? If you love Dr. Shabir Ally, ask him to call Christian Prince. He's online and "live" on KZbin every day when he's not occupied. It's FOC (free-of-charge) to call. kzbin.info/www/bejne/fHaziX-Yob1nors

[@ahmedbenramood5135]

أسعى إلى الحقيقة أبعد من عقائد الدين Two reflective and great scholars, Shabir Ally and Mufti Abu Layth having a very interesting discussion. with so many ‘controversial’ topics as Shabir mentioned. Let’s have more of these dialogs by other open and intellectually minded scholars. I have an academic background myself in the Sciences of Religion, and love these refreshing conversations.

[@OmarAbdulMalikDHEdMPASPACPAPro]

Peace be to you all (AsSalama'laikum)! Greetings from America!😊🇺🇸 I REALLY enjoyed this discussion. May AllahSubanawata'Allah grant you both good health during this Covid-19 challenge, and beyond!😷❤☝🏾️

[@etiennebisset5642]

In 2014, Christian Prince sent an invitation to Dr. Shabir Ally for a debate with him through the response of this public video. Now it is 2020, and six years later, it's still a no-show. Why is Dr. Shabir Ally reluctant to debate Christian Prince? His valid reasons might ruin his preaching career for good? Is his career more important than the truth? If you love Dr. Shabir Ally, ask him to call Christian Prince. He's online and "live" on KZbin every day when he's not occupied. It's FOC (free-of-charge) to call. kzbin.info/www/bejne/fHaziX-Yob1nors

[@OmarAbdulMalikDHEdMPASPACPAPro]

@@etiennebisset5642 I don't know who you are. However, I pray to the Lord that He grants you protection and good health during this Covid-19 pandemic! Stay safe!😊

[@MunaBushra]

Amazing insight 👌🏽

[@MuftiAbuLayth]

Glad it was helpful!

[@worshipperofallah1]

@@MuftiAbuLayth . Bukhari says Ayesha (may Allah be pleased with her) was prepubescent, she was on a swing & playing with Dolls when Prophet Consummated Marriage with her. Commentary of Fatih Al Bari says she was Prepubescent.

[@tamurkarim1251]

Two of my favorite go to people for knowledge

[@etiennebisset5642]

In 2014, Christian Prince sent an invitation to Dr. Shabir Ally for a debate with him through the response of this public video. Now it is 2020, and six years later, it's still a no-show. Why is Dr. Shabir Ally reluctant to debate Christian Prince? His valid reasons might ruin his preaching career for good? Is his career more important than the truth? If you love Dr. Shabir Ally, ask him to call Christian Prince. He's online and "live" on KZbin every day when he's not occupied. It's FOC (free-of-charge) to call. kzbin.info/www/bejne/fHaziX-Yob1nors

[@OmarAbdulMalikDHEdMPASPACPAPro]

I appreciate the way the Shiek describes the concept of "akl"!😊❤☝🏾️

[@thehourglassfan3515]

Awesome episode.

[@stevenv6463]

Really great to hear Shabir Ally really open up. I love his debates with Christians but he seems very reserved and careful when he is on his program, Let the Quran speak. But here he is not avoiding controversies, it is good.

[@pegg3325]

Two of my most favourite scholars together. Magic. Thank you and much love #MALM.

[@pegg3325]

Sam E greetings from Auckland, New Zealand.

[@Lonzetta_3laama]

Both very refreshing minds , much luv from Houston Texas

[@zachharith3286]

Mark Lonzetta htown 🤘🤘

[@etiennebisset5642]

In 2014, Christian Prince sent an invitation to Dr. Shabir Ally for a debate with him through the response of this public video. Now it is 2020, and six years later, it's still a no-show. Why is Dr. Shabir Ally reluctant to debate Christian Prince? His valid reasons might ruin his preaching career for good? Is his career more important than the truth? If you love Dr. Shabir Ally, ask him to call Christian Prince. He's online and "live" on KZbin every day when he's not occupied. It's FOC (free-of-charge) to call. kzbin.info/www/bejne/fHaziX-Yob1nors

[@salmansaysit]

Every scholars has something to teach but problem starts when everyone tries to explain each and everything perfectly as per their understanding. Learn bits from everyone don't think they are infallible.

[@Yesnomaybeso1001]

Amazing discussion

[@elkiwi69]

Very enjoyable talk.

[@kroozi]

This is criminally underrated

[@bluesquare1234]

Great podcast.

[@MuftiAbuLayth]

Thanks for listening

[@Kim_Jong_Un_.]

Great video with 2 intellectual people

[@emanjewels7588]

Masha Allah shsikh Shsbir very undestand. And Great.

[@TheAARSAA]

good discussion .....

[@BaniAadama]

2 geniuses! MashaAllah

[@un1versalart426]

This meetup had to happen and I am glad it did. Let's not stop here, next up: Reza Aslan Shayk Attabek Shukurov Who can name some others that would fit in such a meetup with Mufti?

[@moedot7]

Javed Ahmed Ghamidi

[@Azeez396]

Dawah man lol

[@Azeez396]

Nouman Ali Khan and Hamza Yusuf would make an interesting conversation for sure

[@erminization]

I really think this is the end all be all.. until maybe the long awaited debate with Shaykh Yasir. :)

[@raja7496]

Would pay to see Mufti with Javed Ahmed Ghamidi Sahib.

[@cryptowizard9578]

My two fav Muslim scholars alonwith Javed Ghamidi of Pakistan. I used to listen Ghamidi Saheb but I just found these two scholars this year. Its my bad luck I did not found them before.

[@babulsarwar3714]

Vital point to be mentioned is that the relationship between rulers and some of the organized religious group from the time unknown to todate contibute to corrupt Creator's religion for people for the interests of those two parties.

[@muslimabubakar9384]

If stoning is Allah's plan for eternity He would have allowed it to be included in the Qur'an. Qur'an is the primary source of Sharia and Haidth is only meant to explain the Qur'an more. Qur'an is clear that on the type punishments for Adultery in Islam - Stoning is not there!

[@shahbazshah5669]

Really

[@lilbaigs5003]

@A Hadith unfortunately cannot be validated. Allah never said in the Quran there would be an additional book muslims need to follow. How can we know whats true and what isnt??

[@lilbaigs5003]

@A You kidding arent you. Hadith have chains... how do you know those chains werent misquoted...or certain info added. Does the Quran advice us to refer to another book for guidance??

[@lilbaigs5003]

@A Astagfirulla may Allah guide you .. you said you could say the same about the Quran??? The Quran came from Allah via angel Jibreel. There is no question about the Quran. It is the final testement to mankind. The hadith however is a totally different thing. Its man made. We have no way of validating whats true and what isnt. Many hadith have been heavily critisized. At the end of the day the author of the hadith are men who are capable of making errors. The same CANNOT be said about the Quran

[@lilbaigs5003]

@A Oh so you would say they are VERY reliable. Not just reliable. What guarantee do you have? How can you know?? This is the problem..us as muslims have had this indoctrinated into us that the Hadith must be trusted.

[@hilmyahmed6446]

The beard fading is cool. Goes well with the haircut.

[@truthseekers7608]

Whao what a video... You naughty naughty... your so serious as well, I am glad you called Dr. Shabbir Aly... This kind of content is really required...watched few videos of yours and Alhamdulillah finally someone came with actual age of Aish RA openly... Even though I already knew it before watching the videos Alhamdulillah. I wish someone like you can come to us as well with al kafi narrators... And let us know what is illogical and how... It makes me feel very good when someone comes in defence of our beloved Prophet Muhammad saww. Even though we can prove many things from Bukhari like fidak etc. but there is no sect which is greater than the honour of the Prophet saww. Please don't use disrespectful/bad language in response. May Allah bless you "Mufti Abu Layth" Sahib.... Mufti style humour "Ab aya hai unt pahad ke niche".😅

[@truthseekers7608]

Just wanted to add something, what do you say about the following ayah. Quran 2:102 And they followed [instead] what the devils had recited during the reign of Solomon. It was not Solomon who disbelieved, but the devils disbelieved, teaching people magic and that which was revealed to the two angels at Babylon, Harut and Marut. But the two angels do not teach anyone unless they say, "We are a trial, so do not disbelieve [by practicing magic]." And [yet] they learn from them that by which they cause separation between a man and his wife. But they do not harm anyone through it except by permission of Allah . And the people learn what harms them and does not benefit them. But the Children of Israel certainly knew that whoever purchased the magic would not have in the Hereafter any share. And wretched is that for which they sold themselves, if they only knew.

[@Tskyn]

Is there a thing around arabic count whereby units could be interpreted to mean 1s and 10s? Like 6 may mean 16 and 9 mean 19?

[@OmarAbdulMalikDHEdMPASPACPAPro]

I always wondered that myself.🤔

[@omerali2690]

Its like someone is counting... So let is say that some is counting... 21, 22, 23, 24 and then he drops the word twenty and count like this.. Five, six, seven, eight, nine, thirty, thirty one, two, three, and so on.... In arabic, this addition of unit 10 starts from ten so sitta ( six ) ashara ( 10 ) and tisata ( nine ) ashara ( ten).. Its quite possible that this word ashara (10 ) dropped somewhere.

[@omerali2690]

Its like someone is counting... So let is say that some is counting... 21, 22, 23, 24 and then he drops the word twenty and count like this.. Five, six, seven, eight, nine, thirty, thirty one, two, three, and so on.... In arabic, this addition of unit 10 starts from ten so sitta ( six ) ashara ( 10 ) and tisata ( nine ) ashara ( ten).. Its quite possible that this word ashara (10 ) dropped somewhere.

[@abrarqadir503]

good guest

[@saintsflow71]

Please do more with shiekh ally

[@faisaliqbal6322]

Wow..surprised!

[@HitherandYarn]

Ameen, Sheikhs.

[@aleefmohammed244]

I don't practice or follow mainstream Islam but may God bless Dr Shabir Ally and grant him heaven.

[@Raniyaasoussi]

Assalamualaikum it's a great conversation on the current discourse. Could please someone edit the correct translations of this conversation. The screen seems to play an automated translation which does not correctly catch the particular words and phrases especially the Arabic terms! Jazakallah!

[@curiosone8843]

Mufti i just noticed a NOSE like me today 😀

[@SuperBallashotcalla]

put the podcast on stitcher for android

[@khanG-gq9hc]

💯👌🏼

[@mohammedameen5653]

after 1400 someone has understood the quran more than all the generations before him

[@chunji1971]

Mufti can you please debate farid gangu teli

[@MotorStorm66]

What about the opinion that Aisha (r.a.) was physically an adult at the age of 9?

[@phenomenal17playz]

I like shabir ally

[@islamforall437]

May ALLAH bless these two Scholars. They are transforming Western Islam in such a powerful way that Middle Eastern 'Scholars" have failed to... Use of Aqal is the way to win the hearts of this Generation.

[@reggjackson3915]

I've never watched 'Mindtrap' before and I must say this was refreshing because several other videos that I've watched of yours just was full of corny jokes and you seemed disrespectful of others that didn't hold your opinion. Believe me I really like a GOOD joke though. My views have been pretty much in tune with yours though I don't know all of your views and I'm sure we would disagree on somethings. Great job with this one and "may ALLAH reward you for your efforts".

[@etiennebisset5642]

In 2014, Christian Prince sent an invitation to Dr. Shabir Ally for a debate with him through the response of this public video. Now it is 2020, and six years later, it's still a no-show. Why is Dr. Shabir Ally reluctant to debate Christian Prince? His valid reasons might ruin his preaching career for good? Is his career more important than the truth? If you love Dr. Shabir Ally, ask him to call Christian Prince. He's online and "live" on KZbin every day when he's not occupied. It's FOC (free-of-charge) to call. kzbin.info/www/bejne/fHaziX-Yob1nors

[@_John_P]

(09:40) "Where in the Quran it says that adultery should be punished with stoning (laughing at their ignorance)? Nowhere! The Quran says the punishment is flogging!" Yup, much better than stoning.

[@ashiqurrahman6140]

Thank God scholars like you exist

[@etiennebisset5642]

In 2014, Christian Prince sent an invitation to Dr. Shabir Ally for a debate with him through the response of this public video. Now it is 2020, and six years later, it's still a no-show. Why is Dr. Shabir Ally reluctant to debate Christian Prince? His valid reasons might ruin his preaching career for good? Is his career more important than the truth? If you love Dr. Shabir Ally, ask him to call Christian Prince. He's online and "live" on KZbin every day when he's not occupied. It's FOC (free-of-charge) to call. kzbin.info/www/bejne/fHaziX-Yob1nors

[@samsungkartit]

But what is the solution ? Speaking about this topic is okay, but now we need to reevaluate all hadith

[@aliditta7768]

Hello MUFTI ABU LAYTH will you invite Mufasil Islam to your mind trap?

[@yusufjunjua7775]

Shabir Ally sounds and looks like Robin Williams (RIP)

[@k2411871]

Sam Guerrans next please

[@anwaroleolo9795]

no one: Mufti Abu Layth: Orrriteeeeee

[@mistercach]

Hadith is like the gospel of paul, john and Matthew.

[@tanjavankessel9842]

Analog fighter Paul was not an evangelist, but his letters are included in the New Testament. The gospels were written by (or attributed to) the four evangelists Mark, Matthew, Luke and John

[@elwise5864]

@34:00 ish - Aisha talk

[@Solo.Gr8]

Talk about hudood punishments with modern time

[@Vibestr]

1:00:15 Shaykh Gibril Haddad wrote on this issue and claims the hadith about Aisha's age of 9 is muttawatir

[@worshipperofallah1]

No, this Hadiths About Age 9 is Not Muttawatir.

[@Vibestr]

@@worshipperofallah1 Have you looked into Gibril Haddad's argument? Not that I agree, but if you are informed on the matter, perhaps you can take a look and get back. Thanks.

[@babulsarwar3714]

Are we united because of the tradition or because of the quranic foundations? Aren’t we kind of divided in terms of our own understanings of traditions or even on quranic interpretation in generally speaking? Isn't the bottom line singualrity in diversity and in the end of the of the day it’s between the individual and the Creator?

[@memememmee7794]

Khaled abou fadl, next, malm !!!

[@pamassiesso2159]

Let me help you. How do you know that the sister of Aisha did not overstate her age

[@pamassiesso2159]

@KZbin Funny she was 9 and Mohamed raped her

[@ahmadshamil5606]

@@pamassiesso2159 RIP Jesus

[@pamassiesso2159]

How do you know that Mohammed is a prophet

[@fatimaxo4885]

@@pamassiesso2159 very interesting that all the ‘Jesus is lord’ folks come on here spewing hate and offensive language.... if that’s your way of spreading Christianity you failed miserably. You only strengthen our faith even more, but sadly angry Christians like you will never learn.

[@user-ki7ff2oc9u]

I think the issue of Aisha's age will be solved if one read the The Lost Calendar and The Prophetic Events by FR Shaikh.

[@randomimmigrant348]

Suggestion for the next MindTrap guest: Sheikh Asrar Rashid

[@moedot7]

Looool 1 hour on santa, 1 hour on rashidya and 1 hour on "thats not what I said word for word"

[@DrWoofOfficial]

9:55 why not??

[@strategicrouter3246]

People who will try to interpret the Qur'an on their own, without understanding the Context of why the Verse was revealed and the Sunnah related to it, will always be MindTrapped.

[@strategicrouter3246]

@heera rodriguez I don't believe they have the exact historical contexts of when and why the verse was revealed. Making claims is always easy. And this is exactly why MALM rejects most hadith from Abu Huraira [ra]

[@abhinavmenon9140]

Mufti sahab why do you drink so much soda?

[@MuftiAbuLayth]

ive quit now 😂😂

[@Peter-xf9jy]

Ah now oral reports led to misconceptions about what Mohamet had said? Wasnt the Quran transmitted in exaclty the same way? orally?

[@Peter-xf9jy]

@Qasim Alam thats why 70 dead qurra2 triggered the crisis ... and abu Bakr realised that one patch of paper is more reliable than the tahadduth of (alledgedly) hundred-thousands?

[@Peter-xf9jy]

we know now for sure (from your own sources) that not all letters remained unchanged. even Dr. Ally now admitted that already Uthmans copies differed in "minor particles". wallah hhh

[@Peter-xf9jy]

@Qasim Alam This Tawatur is an unprovable - hence irrelevant - claim. why ? bc none has the time to check it. hhh

[@Peter-xf9jy]

and to prove it for the past is completely impossible hhh but to disprove it is easy. 70dead reader caused Abu bakr to do a thing what Mohamet didnt do, collect and write the Quran down.

[@Peter-xf9jy]

@Qasim Alam it were enough to worry ... and to write the whole thing down. so he surely didnt have a million of them

[@semakulaatibu4564]

Moslems should understand the difference between russul,and the prophet. Prophethood for the followers of taurat. The followers of Quran only requires to follow the messenger.

[@NotesofKhan]

Jesus has a virgin birth. And to believe otherwise is outside of Islam

[@obaidulhaque7687]

But I believe, prophet Zakharia was father of Jesus/ issa AS.( Aggregated whole )Quran . Al emraan and Mariyum. And Prophet Yahiya his own brother.

[@NotesofKhan]

Kufr!

[@MyKathylee]

Why does he bring up the old law of stoning in the old testament which was abolished in the new testament to make a point. Always trying to drag other religions to justify things in islam

[@atilla4352]

because there is a hadith 2here it says there was a Quranic chapter about stoning but a goat ate it so some ISis or extreme person still belive and lives by this as people should be punish by stoning to death. This was practiced by the jews and Christians and the Quran does not mention stoning. this is why they brought this up.

[@MyKathylee]

@@atilla4352 I thought the goat ate the breast feeding adult bit of "revelation"

[@pamassiesso2159]

If she was 18 then she is a liar

[@worshipperofallah1]

No, if she was 19 she not a Liar Bcuz she directly did not said to Bukhari, imam Bukahri came 200 years After the Death of Ayesha. So somebody in the chain of Narration or chain of Transmission has wrong information about her Age or Bad Memory..

[@worshipperofallah1]

Ayesha was Not Lying somebody After her death. Fabricated those Hadiths. That she was 9.

[@Peter-xf9jy]

Aha, stoning is to YOU not a barbaric punishment ?

[@Peter-xf9jy]

The Quran also says lock them up until she dies or Allah helps her out. thats also a cruel death penalty. not to forget death for making Fasad in the land, that can easily include Zina. so you pl. could easily flog and then lock her up or stone her to death.

[@libbzany2875]

Bro what? Stoning isn’t even the punishment it’s 100 lashes

[@Peter-xf9jy]

@@libbzany2875 ah, so the stonings in KSA are a pagan ritual, nothing to do with Islam.

[@Peter-xf9jy]

the lashing is for the unmarried persons. married get stoned. bc zina can be adultery or fornication.

[@libbzany2875]

@@Peter-xf9jy no both are only 100 lashes stoning isn’t even stated lol

[@danvan2683]

You guys really need to accept the narrative of jesus Christ, from what i understand even in Islam he is a unique prophet, other ways Islam is founded on a denial of his unique nature, the pre-existing YHWH of moses and abraham, its a pretty big deal my friends.

[@j2shoes288]

Comparative Religion Scholar, so, talk about Comparative Religions, not stuff that is not his forte.

[@djamelzitouni950]

He did touch on bible. But may be he cannot go further into saying that many hadiths are coming from Jewish and/or Christian influences.

[@user-cm2sf6nq4m]

So your telling me Sahih Hadith are lies (Sahih means the Hadiths is authentics)??? Sahih al-Bukhari, 5:58:234 Narrated Aisha: The Prophet engaged me when I was a girl of six (years). We went to Medina and stayed at the home of Bani-al-Harith bin Khazraj. Then I got ill and my hair fell down. Later on my hair grew (again) and my mother, Um Ruman, came to me while I was playing in a swing with some of my girl friends. She called me, and I went to her, not knowing what she wanted to do to me. She caught me by the hand and made me stand at the door of the house. I was breathless then, and when my breathing became Allright, she took some water and rubbed my face and head with it. Then she took me into the house. There in the house I saw some Ansari women who said, "Best wishes and Allah's Blessing and a good luck." Then she entrusted me to them and they prepared me (for the marriage). Unexpectedly Allah's Apostle came to me in the forenoon and my mother handed me over to him, and at that time I was a girl of nine years of age. Sahih al-Bukhari, Volume 8, Book 73, Number 151 Narrated 'Aisha: I used to play with the dolls in the presence of the Prophet, and my girl friends also used to play with me. When Allah's Apostle used to enter (my dwelling place) they used to hide themselves, but the Prophet would call them to join and play with me. (The playing with the dolls and similar images is forbidden, but it was allowed for 'Aisha at that time, as she was a little girl, not yet reached the age of puberty.)

[@emenjay0077]

Good grief. Aishas age is understated - Mohammeds first wifes age is overstated!? This is the most laughable excuse for Aishas age. Actually the excuse that they needed to make her young so they would not think she was a sl*t is even better😂It is pure speculation on both your parts.

[@SuperPEACEMAKER786]

Abu layth will go through the hadiths about her age

[@ShoebAdnan]

@Emenjay, Search the age of aysha in mufti's youtube channel. You will find many videos explaining the issue. If you are not an idiot, I hope you will change your mind after watching mufti's video.

[@ShoebAdnan]

@@nathanrichmondhoag1021 , Yea, why are you telling me that?

[@nathanrichmondhoag1021]

@@ShoebAdnan im responding to the thread genius

[@gregoriysharapov1936]

@@nathanrichmondhoag1021 Yeah, with a few variations forward or backward.