SHIP OF THESEUS: A Detailed Video Essay | In Hindi | By Vipin Baloni

[@williamsheksphere6679]

Yeh explanation ko dekh kar aisa laga ki sach mai movie mai jee rahe hai aur background music goosebumps de rahi thi Very nice explanation

[@thevipinbaloni]

I am glad you to know that you like the work. Thank You so much. 🙏❤️

[@PavanKumar-ly2tf]

Anand gandhi is one of the few original storyteller and my favorite Contemporary thinker who use science and art as tools to change our thinking

[@thevipinbaloni]

You summarized it so aptly. I am also a huge admirer of Anand's Intellect and ability to share complex ideas.

[@viputdBeast]

you have done a great deal of benefit to humankind by explaining this movie... god bless you...

[@thevipinbaloni]

glad you like the work. thank you so much for the appreciation ❤️🙏

[@anonymous891]

Nice video, i am just glad there are people out there still supporting this gem of movie which is nothing short of underrated at its core level. Even more underrated is its music i wish people had supported this movie enough for the music to be officially released especially the way anand gandhi uses music and visual in end suddenly throwing darkness and then the title appearing onscreen i can only imagine how amazing it must be in theatre. Thanks for throwing some light on this movie again!!

[@thevipinbaloni]

I am glad to read this comment. Thank You so much for your appreciation. ❤️🙏

[@manmohanbisht5816]

I ll Watch it later. Philosophy teases me😂

[@sridharnalla8554]

Vipin Baloni ..............amazing explanation ........ Your way of understanding about philosophy of each and every seen is great. i did lot had behind this explanation. this movie is not simple as it seen Your words are so deep as movie............

[@thevipinbaloni]

I am glad your like my work. Thank You so much for the appreciation ❤️🙏

[@aishwaryakapoor2149]

So far the best explanation for this masterpiece

[@thevipinbaloni]

I am glad to know that. Thank you so much. ❤️🙏

[@ajeetsingh8826]

Amazing I never seen and hear content like this And your Voice is amazing ,the way of talking and explaining

[@thevipinbaloni]

Glad you like the work. thank you so much for the appreciation bhai ❤️🙏

[@ShauryaVerma-bw9xe]

very amazing video brother loved it and what i think is that we seek continuous perfection on work we are already good at like aliya was a good photographer and she had some rawness in her pictures and and she always had a argument with her partner for keeping the pictures and now when she can see her pictures on sight she's confused that she can click better pictures and she can delete her pictures on her own and she misses that healthy argument. this is like when we want to be independent but somewhere our inner child just want to be a little bit dependent on our loved ones

[@thevipinbaloni]

You summed it up so elegantly. ❤️🙏

[@ashish3932]

What a video man ❤❤❤❤ That line... Can the whole be greater then the sum of its parts and if yes then what are those intengible things that makes the whole greater... ❤❤❤

[@thevipinbaloni]

I cannot even tell how satisfying it is to read such comments. You made my day literally. Thank You so much. ❤️🙏

[@prathmeshchougule6529]

You are a gem bhai❤ Keep it up bhai, Earlier i used to watch movies just for the sake of entertainment,after realising the real cinema,i got to know that this medium has lot more to offer,my respect towards the people who put their heart' out while depicting thier art has certainly increased. Kudos to people like you who become the guides for people like me.

[@yasheditz9232]

I dont know if you guys have noticed it or not but during the Aliyah’s story at the end when she accidentally drops the cap into the river its nothing but her story

[@krishanudutta1933]

what do you mean? care to explain?

[@thevipinbaloni]

Yes, I remember this scene very well ❤️🙏

[@krishanudutta1933]

@@thevipinbaloni can you explain the meaning?

[@KunalMaheta-k8c]

Can someone explain that pls?

[@ravigahlot3810]

​@@KunalMaheta-k8cवो कैमरा कैप आलिया का अंधापन था जो की अब चला गया है, लेकिन ये कितनी सुंदरता से दिखाया गया है की कैमरा की कैप जाने के बाद कैमरा बैग में चला जाता है, और आलिया को एहसास होता है की फोटो वो नही होती जो हम खींचते है, फोटो वो होती है जो हम देखते है। ये मेरी सोच है। धन्यवाद

[@kalpeshchauhan3362]

Simplysuperb Vipin ji, very nice explanation of this great film. Thank you Director like Anand Gandhi are very rare,

[@thevipinbaloni]

thank you so much kalpesh glad you like the work

[@biswajitswain4215]

The way this guy explain it Bhai sahab .....no words ❤❤❤❤

[@jitendrasingh-xz5xv]

Yes 👍 outstanding

[@thevipinbaloni]

Glad you guys are liking the work. I am so happy and satisfied reading these kinds of comments. Truly feeling blessed. You guys are amazing seriously. It's one thing to create content and it's completely a different thing to find right kind of people who really like these kinds of work. Thank you so very much for your words. take care ❤️🙏 thanks jitendra as well.

[@thevipinbaloni]

thanks for watching it bhai and appreciation.

[@thakurabhiraj1]

Last me Jo tumne question bataya uska ek bohot simple answer hai but bohot se aise log hein Jo hard way pe Jana pasand karte hein

[@thevipinbaloni]

I would love to know your perspective

[@thakurabhiraj1]

@@thevipinbaloni The answer is soul.....people's parts works until they have soul

[@prashsin7662]

​@@thakurabhiraj1in this way you are defying the believes of Buddhism , which doesn't belive in the concept of soul.

[@manishmanish8207]

Thank you for making me better understanding of flime...love your work..

[@thevipinbaloni]

Glad you like the work. thank you so much for the appreciation ❤️🙏

[@sanketpatel5137]

Wonderful. Just wow.

[@thevipinbaloni]

Thank you so much for your kind words! I'm glad you enjoyed the video.

[@sanketpatel5137]

@@thevipinbaloni after this video. i search and learn about charwak philosophy in detail thanks

[@thevipinbaloni]

@@sanketpatel5137 Oh that's great ❤❤🙏🙏

[@divanshgupta3404]

The explanation of the film felt better and more engaging than the actual film📽️ to me.

[@thevipinbaloni]

Your comment has made my day. Glad you like my work. Thank You so much Divyansh. ❤️🙏

[@abhiruplahiri1]

An excellent synopsis of the movie. Just watched the movie, what a brilliant peace of work!

[@thevipinbaloni]

Thank you so much for the comment. ❤️🙏

[@Unveilingissues]

I must say you explained really really well.I always had this doubt after watching this movie that what this theory is actually trying to explain.Thanks to you,it's clear now.

[@thevipinbaloni]

I am glad to know that you like the work. Thank You so much. Take Care ❤️🙏

[@surojitbasu4634]

Thank you sir to beautifully explaining the whole story.

[@thevipinbaloni]

I am glad you like the video essay. Thank you so much Surojit. ❤️🙏

[@inzihaq4706]

Dude,TBH this channel is underrated.keep making more videos pls

[@thevipinbaloni]

Glad you think that way. Channel is indeed finding its audience slowly. thank you so much for the appreciation. Will definitely keep on creating ❤️🙏

[@mokshak604]

Bro thanks for sharing your perspective and review for the movie

[@thevipinbaloni]

Thank You so much for the appreciation. Glad you like the work. 🙏

[@stranger6798]

You deserve more to more

[@thevipinbaloni]

Thank you so much for the appreciation. ❤️🙏

[@Study_Serenade]

Wow whatta essay❤ Make more these kind of essay!!!

[@thevipinbaloni]

glad you like the work. thank you so much for the appreciation. take care 🙏

[@Neel_Doshi]

Does any one understand why the person who got cave explorer's heart was not present? The reason given by organizer was some medical reason (infection), but Anand did not wanted the person with heart to be present in museum ? What does it mean in the argument about of 'whole and part'?

[@anonymous891]

i think i know have u noticed in the end before movie ends u hear a heartbeat sound with the music...and here's my theory it could be the fact that with the cave explorer there was another cameraman whose shadow u can see (i could be totally wrong) so it might be indicating he is the person to whom heart was transplanted. The theory mainly arised because you see little clues of what organ has been donated to the people present there (for example a guy coughs as video begins indicating lung transplant in him) so this is my theory!!

[@kunalgaikwad726]

Beautifully explained bro❤

[@thevipinbaloni]

glad you like it, thank you so much ❤️🙏

[@nk1381]

Bahut hi pyara aur visionary explanation and narration of the whole ship of thesius ❤

[@thevipinbaloni]

Bahut Bahut Dhanyawad bhai aapka. I am glad to know that you like the work. Thank You so much ❤️🙏

[@meghpandey5302]

एक अच्छा चित्रण । हिंदी में।

[@thevipinbaloni]

Bahut Bahut Dhanyawad Megh ❤️🙏

[@VirendraKumar-wt1iy]

Thank you Vipin, it’s a beautiful interpretation. Indeed, your version of movie was needed to understand it better. Everyone doesn’t have so much patience and time. Also, I am surprised to see so many male comments, hardly any female inputs. Is it also indicate about the philosophical preferences by gender?

[@thevipinbaloni]

I am glad to read your message. thank you so very much for sharing your views with me. and yes i completely agree with your observation on many male comments. Although, I believe things are changing but it certainly that is the case. I have also found this observation really interesting.

[@Sk_Martin]

Thankyou so much for this video essay.

[@thevipinbaloni]

All thanks to you for taking time and appreciating the work ❤️🙏

[@PratapNeelesh-fn4nm]

Ye movie bhut gjb thi,,,,apki explanation gjb h❤

[@thevipinbaloni]

Thank You so much Neelesh for the appreciation. Take Care ❤️🙏

[@prashantkumar-fc8ro]

Your voice like therapy

[@thevipinbaloni]

Glad to hear bhai. thank you so much for the appreciation ❤️🙏

[@tthe4thpillar]

Kunal kamra has uploaded this movie on his channel. A wonderful wonderful movie !!

[@thevipinbaloni]

it is such a gem of a movie, one of a kind certainly ❤️🙏

[@muditjain8784]

It got me thinking that there are no binaries in life good vs bad for example. Both are inherent in each other

[@thevipinbaloni]

very articulate ❤️🙏

[@clifftonborges2965]

What an amazing analysis 💯👏🏼. I will definitely watch this film

[@thevipinbaloni]

Thank You so much for the praise. Yes you should definitely watch the film. Do share your perspective with me personally on my Instagram (@thevipinbaloni)

[@Ishaan_Aazad]

Behad Umda Explain kiya bhai apne 🙌🏻💯🙏🏻 movie toh outstanding thi hi magar apke iss vdo ne uss par 4 Chand laga diye ✅✨

[@thevipinbaloni]

I am glad to read your comment bhai. Thank you so much for the appreciation. ❤️🙏

[@kirankamate9719]

Great explanation. Loved it.

[@thevipinbaloni]

thank you so much for the appreciation. ❤️🙏

[@Sanjurokks]

Really good work by you, nicely explained

[@thevipinbaloni]

Glad you like the work. Thank you so much for the appreciation ❤️🙏

[@rushikesh.chaubal]

Totally loved the analysis! Makes me think! Gonna watch this movie over the weekend!

[@thevipinbaloni]

Thank You so much Rushikesh. I am glad you like the analysis. You watch it and do share your own perspective with me. Take Care ❤️🙏

[@amaarali1794]

Man you have such keen eye amazing like how you have just explaining is amazing

[@thevipinbaloni]

Glad you like the work. Thank Yo so much. Keep sharing with others as well. ❤️🙏

[@artbeat3665]

Hey too good you have assembled all those good secens from the movie.. I have watched this movie..loved it.

[@thevipinbaloni]

I am so glad to know that you love the work. Thank You so much for the appreciation ❤️🙏

[@garimamohod]

Aapne muze ek behad khubsurat safar pe le gaye , muze bhi humesha yesi chije pareshan karti rehati hai lekin mere pass yesa koi nahi jo meri baato ko samze, sunane me dilchspi le ,mere sawalo ke jawab de, kya sahi kya galat iska faisla koun karega? Bohat hi shaandar video plz yese hi videos banate rahiye thank you so much

[@thevipinbaloni]

Thank You so much for your lovely comment. glad you like the video 🙏

[@nikhildhital112]

mind blowing

[@thevipinbaloni]

thank you so much ❤️🙏

[@pankajkabeer]

Very well expressed. Thanks

[@thevipinbaloni]

hey thanks alot

[@bolshevik_af]

Woah, Great work mate, ngl. Keep it up

[@thevipinbaloni]

Thank You so much. Glad you like the work. ❤️🙏

[@karunaachaudhary]

Thank u so much for this wonderful analysis and explanation , your obsevation and articulation skills are really amazing , there were still few things which i didnt notice and came to learn from u , keep doing the wonderful work sir🙌🏾💫

[@thevipinbaloni]

Glad you like the work. Thank You so much for the appreciation. ❤️🙏

[@menu.mini98]

*Most of the people would have decided to donate their organs after watching this movie. But Luckily I am not between them cause I have already donated my all body parts to society.* 😊

[@thevipinbaloni]

🙏🙏

[@ankitkhera9861]

Just loved this one Bhai ❤❤ Keep it up ❤❤

[@thevipinbaloni]

Thank You so much Ankit ❤️🙏

[@rupeshverma1516]

Nice explanation by you Sir 📝 we are obliged to you for that koti koti pranam 🙏

[@thevipinbaloni]

thank you so much rupesh. glad you like the work. ❤️🙏

[@rupeshverma1516]

@@thevipinbaloni nahi sir hum logo ko aapka shukriya ada karna chahiye itne achhe content ke liye ,aasha hai ki aap aage bhi kuchh achha meaningful content humain dete rahenge 🙏📝

[@SOHEL_BUSINESS_GURU]

Loved❤it

[@thevipinbaloni]

Glad you like the work. Thank you so much for the appreciation ❤️🙏

[@satishbabudeshmukh7341]

Beautifully explained 🤍. Absolutely delightful to watch this after movie, to understand better about the movie.

[@thevipinbaloni]

Glad you like the video. Thank you so much for the appreciation. Take Care ❤️🙏

[@ConsistenTea]

very lovely movie.

[@thevipinbaloni]

completely agree ❤️🙏

[@dailyfamilyguy9409]

Great analysis and explanation ❤

[@thevipinbaloni]

thank you so much for the appreciation. glad you like the work. ❤️🙏

[@prarawat1821]

Wow Baloni, nice video 👍

[@thevipinbaloni]

thank you so much

[@mohammed_kaiff]

Too good❤

[@thevipinbaloni]

Glad you like the work. Means alot to me. Do consider connecting with me on Instagram (@thevipinbaloni)

[@davidvecammessi3286]

Waiting for such more philosophical moves, storytelling or books , any things you have.

[@thevipinbaloni]

Thanks for your comment. Looking forward to create more such videos. Next one Soon. ❤️🙏

[@safiabegum7374]

Plz create this type of vedios

[@viveknandan4950]

Thank you for the video. It was a great video wish you a lots of success

[@thevipinbaloni]

Thank you so much vivek. glad you like the work. Take care ❤️🙏

[@kirannilje7265]

Well explained. Keep it up.

[@thevipinbaloni]

thank you so much for the appreciation ❤️🙏

[@Poorvi_2310]

It's an excellent movie and you explained it really beautifully 🫶

[@thevipinbaloni]

Glad you like the work. thank you so much for taking time and sharing your comment ❤️🙏

[@abhinavbadoni7032]

अद्वैत वेदांत/ उपनिषद को पढ़ो। दर्शन का शिखर।

[@thevipinbaloni]

Ji Jarur Padhta Hoon ❤️🙏🙏

[@ajaymoraskar7124]

Sahi kaha

[@kafka1343]

Explain kar de Bhai tu hi Agar mai criticize Karo uske core subject or fault pe baat karu To bs fallacy mat karna

[@SOPHIUS3126]

R8​@@kafka1343

[@amanpowar8752]

Good job,god bless u

[@thevipinbaloni]

thanks alot. God bless you too ❤️🙏

[@aayushchoudhary1539]

Love your channel hope you grow

[@thevipinbaloni]

Glad you like the work. thank you so much for the appreciation ❤️🙏

[@ajitnishad7314]

Milnd blowing movie and your story telling

[@thevipinbaloni]

I am glad you like the work. Thank you so much for the appreciation. ❤️🙏

[@gauravrai7426]

Last mei plato allegory cave hai.....that explains everything

[@thevipinbaloni]

true ❤️🙏

[@samblisaloni1669]

Beautiful. Keep up

[@thevipinbaloni]

I am glad you like the work. Thank You so very much for the appreciation. Take Care ❤️🙏

[@majedhanief]

Great work buddy ❤❤

[@thevipinbaloni]

Thank you so much, glad you like the work ❤️🙏

[@pallvi8362]

Thank you 😊

[@thevipinbaloni]

Glad you like the work. Thank You so much ❤️🙏

[@safiabegum7374]

Great explanation 👌

[@thevipinbaloni]

thank you so much for the appreciation. ❤️🙏

[@NIRAVSHAH-mq4nr]

Soul is one 🙏

[@thevipinbaloni]

❤️🙏

[@tapassarkar-ot5wb]

Excellent Excellent Excellent

[@thevipinbaloni]

Thanks thanks thanks, hehe glad you like the work bhai. all thanks to you. ❤️🙏

[@ramakantapatra4339]

Like the movie, here also I lost in a different world ❤

[@thevipinbaloni]

thank you so much for the comment ❤️🙏

[@gooddo72]

u earn my respect++ bro

[@thevipinbaloni]

Thank You so much bro. Glad you like the video ❤️🙏

[@sachind.1688]

Excellent presentation

[@thevipinbaloni]

thanks for the appreciation. Glad you like the work. ❤️🙏

[@DharmendraSingh-lu9oo]

GREAT ESSAY. 😍

[@thevipinbaloni]

Glad you like it bhai. Thank You so very much. take care. ❤️🙏

[@ISA9]

This is very amazing movie

[@thevipinbaloni]

Yes this is one of all time favourites ❤️🙏

[@sudeepsharan3207]

Bhai kabhi time mile to dhobi ghaat pe bhi video banaiye ga.. Aase ye wala bhi video bahut accha tha🙏

[@thevipinbaloni]

Bilkul Sudeep Bhai. Dhobi Ghaat is one of the finest movies in Indian Cinema. I will talk about that movie for sure. Thanks for reminding. ❤️🙏

[@Xyz-ln6uf]

​@@thevipinbaloni review Sir(2018) too.... Its message, theme

[@thevipinbaloni]

@@Xyz-ln6uf Sure , thanks for the recommendation ❤❤🙏🙏

[@FaithStudyandPractice]

Beware of such movies and ideas that lead people and especially youth to become idle philosophers wrapped in sadness and inactivity. These ideas drain you of vital energy, fresh starts and zeal and zest for life. They ingrain a feeling that drives you to view life as meaningless and empty. Such views are highly mistaken views and lead only to sadness, depression, self-loathing, self-pity and dead-ends. Live life joyfully, take action, be good, contribute to your life and that of others, forgive and move on, grow, become happy, be grateful and make many friends and allies. Life is to be lived and not to be wasted in analysis only.

[@FaithStudyandPractice]

@Vipin- your explanation was good and my comment is on the movie and the idea itself.

[@thevipinbaloni]

Thank You so much for taking time and sharing your perspective. I really appreciate and respect your opinion. Take Care ❤️🙏

[@bablubaghel8658]

Ise kahte hai jabarjasti ki soch. Vichar karne yogya bat ko jyada nahi sochana chahia. Ise kahte hai ku,tark.

[@thevipinbaloni]

bahut bahut dhanyawad apne vichar sajha karne ke liye 🙏

[@savy9446]

Great yaar ………

[@thevipinbaloni]

Thanks Savy. Take Care ❤️🙏

[@yashibaloni1034]

Superb 👏

[@thevipinbaloni]

Thanks 🙏❤️

[@Xyz-ln6uf]

Wow bro love your content

[@thevipinbaloni]

I am glad you love the content. Means alot to me. Thank You so much. ❤️🙏

[@aliyanalikhan3279]

Addictive voice h yar apki

[@thevipinbaloni]

are thank you so much bhai 🙏

[@ajaymoraskar7124]

Details explain 🙏 thanks

[@thevipinbaloni]

all thanks to you for taking interest and watching the video. Glad you shared your view with me in the comments. ❤️❤️🙏🙏

[@kesheditz-wt7xh]

What an explanation♥️! Which website do you use to download movies?

[@thevipinbaloni]

Hey thanks alot. for this KZbin. 🙏❤️

[@shikharrathod3540]

Can anyone please tell me all movie names shown at starting of video

[@thevipinbaloni]

Here is the list of the movies as they appear at the start of the video:- "Swades" directed by Ashutosh Gowariker "Udaan" directed by Vikramaditya Motwane "Newton" directed by Amit V. Masurkar "Rang de basanti" directed by Rakeysh Omprakash Mehra "Tathagat" directed by Manav Kaul "Gali Guleiyan" directed by Dipesh Jain "Ship of Theseus" directed by Anand Gandhi

[@dilip.bhati1]

Movie ka naam "Part is greater than the whole ?" hona chahiye tha

[@thevipinbaloni]

hehe ❤️

[@Pinak44]

Gr8

[@thevipinbaloni]

hey thank you so much ❤️🙏

[@imnil3797]

can someone recommend me other movies that are based on different philosophical concepts like this one please... in any language.

[@thevipinbaloni]

There are so many of them, you can start with Matrix, The Truman Show, The adjustment Bureau, The Shawshank Redemption.

[@athiyasahil84848]

Wow 😮 amazing bro bhai baground music ka naam bata do jo baground use kia hai pls name of music???

[@thevipinbaloni]

Thank you so much for the appreciation. BG is from the same movie. You can look it up on KZbin as well. I think it's by Benedict Taylor.

[@gurie_999]

any other movies like this ?

[@thevipinbaloni]

there are lots, do connect with me on instagram, you'll get recommendations ❤️🙏

[@suhridghosh5852]

Where can I watch this movie?

[@SOHEL_BUSINESS_GURU]

Boring picture hai

[@StopTheHateX25]

You tube pe .. patience se dekhna achhi movie h

[@thevipinbaloni]

It's available on KZbin. 🙏❤️

[@shantanusrivastava9744]

No one pointed out the spelling mistake in the title?

[@RelaxingASMR_Edits]

Coz we didn't need the subtittles😊

[@sumitstaranand]

Navin = shoham shah = tumbad= real talent

[@thevipinbaloni]

🙏❤️

[@yashwantsharma]

Outstanding

[@thevipinbaloni]

Glad you like the work ❤️🙏

[@Great_effort1456]

Abb sabko pushpa aur kgf jaisi movie chahiye..... Chapri type ..unlogo k hisab se movie yahi hai aur bass South Indian industry me hi banti hai

[@thevipinbaloni]

sad but true 🙏❤️

[@CaptainHomelander]

नागार्जुन के शून्यवाद को पढ़ो

[@thevipinbaloni]

JI jarur padhenge 🙏

[@Dudestuff507]

Ye kya bhai ?

[@Prahim1176]

Book ka naam??

[@vishwanathsarkar16]

I think overall question atom ⚛️ pe hi rukta hain, kya pata ane bale samaye main ham isse bhi age nikal Jaye.

[@thevipinbaloni]

Isse bhi aage niklenge, Science apne pursuit me lagi rahe bus

[@Shubhamguptabam]

भाई Hindi me de do movi 😢😢

[@AmitBangrwa]

❤

[@thevipinbaloni]

❤️🙏

[@beenzi836]

Can you explain, why Aliya’s husband’s nude body since required in the film??

[@thevipinbaloni]

Actually, I did not think about it so specifically. I will get back to you after pondering on it. 🙏❤️