Should The British Apologise To India?

[@nitinpal9622]

This way of debating is far more better than what we see on tv news channels these days where an anchor is just shouting like a maniac.

[@NasDebates]

Thank you for watching!

[@tbg-brawlstars]

True

[@jemi_pandya]

very true-

[@丁日光]

as a vietnamese, i feel your pain, indians, as we was also colonized by the chinese, french and americans sure, british should apologize

[@mrcool2107]

China?

[@丁日光]

@@mrcool2107 its why we vietnamese hate china

[@NasDebates]

When you think about it today - history has not been kind to so many countries...

[@丁日光]

@Laxman Tiwari well... its totally not a civil war, totally an invasion by the us

[@丁日光]

@@NasDebates a sad fact

[@sameernakti4291]

As an Indian we don't wish for the britishers to be felt guilty for something their ancestors did. We only want them to apologize for what happened in those 100 years in their rule. The torture, the pain is all worth an apology

[@newworldorder21]

200 years or more precisely 190 years and I want britishers to be the most guilty people on earth doesn't matter in which time period they are....

[@jwalakinsaan4788]

Definitely..

[@arvind753]

History padh Rey laudey...

[@jwalakinsaan4788]

@@arvind753 teri history mai bhi galiya hi hongi meri history mai toh satya sanatan samaya hua hai...jaha tk teri soch nahi jaati wha tak mere is desh ka vikaas tha...aur aaj jis samaj se tu khud bichad gya us virat samaj ko punah stapit mera desh ka yuva tan man dhan se kr rha hai toh tujhe kyu achamba ho rh hai....mere sabhd tum jese jeev saman manusyo k liye vayrth hai ... jesne apne maa baap se yuva umr tk bolna nahi seekh vo manusya sirf apne maa baap ka ser sharm se jhuka rh hai....meri nahi apni socho..

[@superstoneanimation3891]

Dude, without the British, You guys are still a numerous of kingdoms that fight each other

[@minhquanang5148]

As a Vietnamese, our grandparents suffered the same, we feel you, Indian. But I think this would be a better debate if it's not India and the UK in particular

[@pxrkhali3363]

Respect the Vietnamese from India.

[@amkai2928]

Well, I think Britishers should apologize, they stole 45 Trillion Dollars💁‍♂️. Which is Huge huge Money🗿. Either give back our money or apologize it. Honestly speaking If I become Ruler of India and England isn't part of That European Union, I would have definitely Destroy England, no matters what consequences be🤷‍♂️.

[@nathandei1674]

The French even forced teenagers to fight in WW1

[@thetruth8265]

As an Indian I don't want current British generation to apologise.. but .. i want them to know what their ancestors did to Indians.. i want them to learn about their colonial past in their history books.. with all the facts.. the atrocities they did to Indians, the oppression, genocide starved to death,famine,... The symbols in certain places like Dogs and Indians are not allowed.. i want that kind of chapter in their current generation history books.. to let them know what their ancestors did

[@thetimesofmemes13]

I entirely agree.... i feel they must be like Germany

[@kashikaarora3262]

I agree . Past should remain History . They should know what they did .

[@jdbtabouret.218]

The government should help India now.

[@swapnil8425]

But Germany still apologies what Hitler did You know about bengal feminine this was because of British took food and 3million died

[@NasDebates]

Makes sense, although do you think that they are still represented by the atrocities their ancestors committed?

[@skmasih-ulamir]

This channel is way more better than today's media debates

[@NasDebates]

Thank you for watching!!

[@navyabafna4260]

Agreed

[@you4arun]

Absolutely. Please keep doing this.

[@posiedon7506]

Arnab goswamy, 😂😂

[@AngelR7124]

Agreed LMAO

[@zyphonwhite9853]

As an English person, i've always thought that we should apologize for Indian colonisation, very good debate.

[@Juho221]

Do you mind if I ask why?

[@InstagramUser2]

I'm better than Nas Debates, My content is better!

[@demiray1097]

@@Juho221 For the colonization of India, as a Turkic person, I am still convinced to this day that the British is an expert at leaving places in pure chaos. (North cyprus, india, pakistan etc)

[@samexploresthebeautyofmusi9428]

@@InstagramUser2 Stop praising yourself like a kid?!

[@perseus2966]

@@veereshcharamurthimath473 that was unnecessary

[@srajanverma9064]

Oh.. as an Indian.. that is such an important topic and I was waiting for this topic to be discussed!!

[@mango-du7vk]

As a Sri Lankan i confirm it

[@hammadyousuf9305]

@@mango-du7vk no u are a fruit

[@beastki7424]

@@mango-du7vk Your country is literally in shambles lmao

[@anonymous-or9ne]

host shilpi ke duddoo (boobs,boba) bahut bade hai

[@mango-du7vk]

@@beastki7424 Yeah I know, its all because of our stupid leaders

[@breathinginfood]

Well guys it wasn't just India but it was united India!!!🇵🇰🇮🇳🇧🇩

[@Tanishkmalviya]

Yeah brits have to apologise to every country they ruined including india pakistan bangaladesh Singapore and all other countries

[@xxyxxxndta]

@@Tanishkmalviya half of africa too

[@NonuGamezRobloxE]

@@xxyxxxndta a bit of South America, the 13 colonies of US, Australia, etc

[@turquoiz_the_potato]

@@Tanishkmalviya pakistan was india...

[@turquoiz_the_potato]

@@Tanishkmalviya so was bangaldesh

[@dhanshyamkamath8493]

Aiswarya just nailed it. 🔥🔥 Even if India is the 5th largest economy or has higher GDP, a large population of India is still BPL. So those numbers do not make any sense.

[@hasim5688]

I'm a Bangladeshi, I also want apologies from British. Bangladesh was same country: Indian before 1947, British divided us.

[@shafirihan6081]

BRUH

[@relaxxx13]

@@theunitedkingdomofgreatbri2209 No one is asking for apologize from dumb people like u .....it would be more disrespectful if people like u apologise ..... although on 8th September someone from India atleast made a century 😂😂 iykyk

[@Lakshya-c]

@@theunitedkingdomofgreatbri2209 "you are not getting any apologies, cry about it" Funny how you proved aishwarya's point. France>>>>>>engLand

[@shafirihan6081]

@@theunitedkingdomofgreatbri2209 no need we will occupy west with our powers Including USA See within 10 years USA will fall .,already now EUROPE is suffering

[@shafirihan6081]

@@theunitedkingdomofgreatbri2209 Europe was already colonized by china economically And now britan left EU and it depends on many countries like India usa and Japan to grow

[@rishavbagri4211]

We don't want Apologizes for money or stuffs We want apologies for exploitation,mass murder, identity stolen from us and also being for dividing us.

[@tahiraperveen7601]

Yeah right

[@manjirosano1707]

Can you tell me how they divided y'all?

[@cygnusmir1627]

@@manjirosano1707 partition of India I’m guessing, although that could have happened anyway without the British

[@IndianRepublic_1947]

@@manjirosano1707 they exploited every opportunity to create divide between Hindus and Muslims in Indian subcontinent. You see it in the creation of Pakistan and Bangladesh.

[@Juho221]

How did they divide you? Before the British, India was a collection of many small kingdoms who were all fighting against each other. If you look at the sepoy uprising of 1857, you see that not only British committed mass murder and atrocities

[@xerophyte2004]

Aish ✅ I know an apology won't change anything economically but will definitely change politically . I mean an apology from Britishers can impact widely on our image in the UN. (i.e in geopolitical means) Which I feel a great advantage to us. Also on the other hand, Jash's vision is optimistic.The fact that he wants us to move on and develop asap instead. So in conclusion , I would say they should apologise and we should respect the apology,accept it and move on.

[@NasDebates]

very nicely put

[@muhammadisaac07]

Great thinking brother

[@nerdynehashow6246]

True bro

[@jeanettewee8805]

@@NasDebates I request you to watch Zareer Masani vs Shashi Tharoor debate on British rule. You could get a proper understanding on that. Just search it on KZbin

[@Kitties2266]

Is I’m an Indian I agree with you and aish too

[@InsideTheGlobe]

17:56 small correction, it's 45 trillion dollars

[@faxriyamusayeva]

That has been the strongest dabete of all. Both logical and informative. I personally don't know who to agree, they were both using very valid points. I believe that it is just enough for both british and indian current generations to know the history and learn a valuable lesson from it so that such think won't happen in the future in any way.

[@sustentofila]

They're both such strong debaters!!

[@NasDebates]

Thank you for watching!

[@sanjanaakotyada4753]

@@InstagramUser2 BOTTTTTTT

[@tovgmd]

@@InstagramUser2 how much subs do you have then? :)))

[@joshuacollins5523]

@@InstagramUser2 no your not

[@akashbehera6384]

The guy is very illogical!

[@ariesbaglari2873]

After watching this video, I can give you guarantee that britishers might fell sorry for what they did but when it comes to apologizing in international forum they won't do it properly because it may hurt their pride and ego.

[@praptigandhi5443]

Very true

[@errexe0]

nah

[@debodeepchowdhury]

@abhijeet yaaa🥺

[@saritagonsalves2893]

True

[@mrcool2107]

If so then why germans weren't proud of nazi and Prussia?

[@raghavendraupadhyaya7993]

I am an Indian and India wants Kohinoor

[@NasDebates]

Do you agree with Aish or Jash?

[@U_SportHub.xx2]

you really think you are gonna get the kohinoor back

[@ambid3xter]

get your facts checked bro.. then say that Kohinoor belongs to india! (short Answer.. it doesn't)

[@noname381]

Ooooo kohinoor is our ...its from Gujranwala, Pakistan its not your

[@kalejametpa32]

@@ambid3xter non Indian dude tryna act smart

[@I_guess_its_over]

"Why british should not apologies india" Every indian: *"So you have chosen death"*

[@nirvitaojha8831]

As a Indian I definitely think that British should apologise because before they left they ripped Indian subcontinent into pieces the did not only looted our wealth but used us in so many ways... the way they treated our ancestors was not less than a psychopathic activity.JAI HIND.

[@imsubbingtoeveryonewhosubs8657]

Read my name...

[@unknownuser1875]

I'm also from the subcontinent also I think what British did was awful. But Who should apologiz?? The poor future generation?? Apologize should have been from the criminals. Now what British should do is just return the Kohinoor and other things.

[@nirvitaojha8831]

@@unknownuser1875 that is what an apology is known as returning the kohinoor back.The apology can't bring everything back they took but it will work as an little satisfaction for each and every citizen and their ancestors for their sufferings.

[@mudra5114]

The British did not rip India to piec s but they united India. They did not loot anything. This looting is a lie.

[@nirvitaojha8831]

@@mudra5114 what about when the UK museum signs agreement with the Indian government to repatriate seven artefacts including six stolen from indian temple and shrines and what about the money it is believed that they looted about $45 trillion from our India It is also said that the country which Britishers looted the most is India and talking about Partition On 2 June 1947, the last Viceroy of India, Admiral Louis Mountbatten, announced the Britain had accepted that the country should be mainly divided into hindu india and muslim Pakistan they did what not to destroy our country...... I don't know from where you have gained such kind of stuff but if you think they United our country then of course you must be kidding.Uk is still living on the wealth of our country. JAI HIND

[@krishnapalekar5290]

In jallianwala bagh the people were not even protesting it was just a fair/mela but they just wanted to show their power and supiriority

[@ragboysinterestinglife]

This topic was soo needed! Also tyey took so much of our national resources, if they havent, i am DAMN sure that we would still be the golden bird and would have overtaken USA in economy and poverty would havent been there too... BUT if they didnt came, there would be not CDM and NCM's that would have united india!!

[@ragboysinterestinglife]

@@poojanchal i agree but if u see our past and the ongoing events that were occurring in the world in that time, india would have surely caught up in the race!!

[@InstagramUser2]

I'm better than Nas Debates, My content is better!

[@newworldorder21]

@@poojanchal pooja ji aap rendo bade dekhe aap jese chochle I know one thing if Britain didn't came to our land we would have been better today so stop british propaganda in indian name

[@MythicDelta5]

This just offended me now. We are people too in the USA. I mean the only thing you guys do is just scam people outta their misery from the scam call centers..

[@navinj.antony8573]

@@MythicDelta5 I personally think you Americans would have fared better than us either way cause my people are easily swayed by ideologies. However, I'd say labelling us all scammers was one step too far. Those lying, thieving scumbags only make a miniscule percentage of our population. Most people here work very hard for a living, some of them highly educated and skilled working below minimum wage for your companies.

[@nordimichelle2197]

This channel just is shaping up like masterpiece

[@NasDebates]

Thank you for watching!!

[@reddragon100]

Only if debates in twitter were so nice

[@aradhyamishra5590]

@@NasDebates please get debaters like Abhijit Chavda next time.

[@NasDebates]

@@aradhyamishra5590 Let him know about us than we can definitely bring him on the show

[@tambouline]

i was and am strongly on Aish's side from the beginning but Jash did raise a few unexpected points. Great job you two! Ad about the apology, it doesn't necessarily mean 'verbal'. As Aish said, they are still reaping off of our produce. Let them acknowledge it, and do what they must. Return the Kohinoor.

[@sujith123]

Agree with Jesh, what ever the reason as Aishwarya said for their commute and transportation. Implementing what was not exists all over the country was a good thing and appreciable to teaching to lay railways.

[@Unknown12345why]

Hi. So what I think and what my perspective is that india was looted lika alot and damage is irreversible. But the cultural artifacts which British Museum has is of India from which Britain is gaining money and increasing economy. Most of things there are of India and it's culture. If they return our belongings + an apology from their leaders to our people also along the money which they stole in form of gold jewels food grains clothes and all should be calculated and atleast 60 percent should be returned to all commonwealth nations not only India. Jash,s points seemed to me senseless since he was being pro British filled with their ideology and he also thinks expansion colonialism killing others looting countries mass famines destroying cultures was just OK. Aish was really superb. Her points were very convincing for what she won the debate. She used the actual facts and real examples not like jash using modern world comparing with 19th century. Anyways It was a good competition. Hoping too see many more awesome debates. I would also like to suggest a topic for debate if you want -is tuition and extra coaching classes good for a child or self study is the best

[@AnshSingh-dp9pg]

I agree with you

[@kalejametpa32]

Do you seriously think we'll be rich even if they give back us our resources with this government corruption? 😂

[@redeyexxx1841]

Well Ash is actually playing victim card (as per the requirement of debate) of something 75 years ago. Current generation of Britishers have no obligation to apologise for that or else the Afganistan ancestors (Islamic invaders) ruled us & killed many Hindus too. So do they have to apologise as well?? Makes no sense at all. They don't have to hold any guilt for things of past that their ancestors did.

[@anshumansarthakmeher3811]

We cannot agree totally on any one of the two, we don't want an apology by asking for it and yet we want them to return the valuables with dignity and not pity.

[@NasDebates]

And both viewpoints totally make sense too

[@aosadoifbaiosdfna]

You should do one about Japan apologizing to other Asian countries.

[@NasDebates]

We will note it down :)

[@jdbtabouret.218]

Who cares? The Japanese defeat in WW2 helped mangas to grow, it's true.

[@aosadoifbaiosdfna]

@@NasDebates Cool, thank you!

[@InstagramUser2]

I'm better than Nas Debates, My content is better!

[@jdbtabouret.218]

@@InstagramUser2 strange bot.

[@merlinharshitha2366]

As an Indian ..I think this is an important topic and most expected topic...strong debaters on both side ..

[@banyadeka7950]

Actually England still have many expensive items that they took forcefully by using modern guns from our ancient museum to keep in their British Museum. Which they are refusing to return to us. We tried very much to get those like the Vrindavani bastra of Assam.It belongs to us, made by us and they took it without paying any thing, We still have such things kept in British Museum which we need now to improve tourism and show our kids our ancient past, they doesn't allow us to do that. Such cruel. So, you could ask apologies as it doesn't cost anything and you want to keep those presious items with you. I also want to thank Nas for contacting this debate to interact people about British History In India.

[@GainsWithPiyush]

Mind-blowing perspectives 🔥 Need more of it. Well done Nas Debates

[@imsubbingtoeveryonewhosubs8657]

Read my name...

[@Xbzjnrzhk6619]

First thank you for this debate 😁😁🙏🙏.I am not indian but i am from sri lanka. we happened same. I am not saying to apologize but they took lot of books form us. Those are our traditional knowledge then I think we want back those books because I think knowledge has more power than anything.

[@imsubbingtoeveryonewhosubs8657]

Read my name...

[@visweswararaorao6719]

Ya bro even the same happened to us . I am an Indian

[@adithyav4923]

A great debate indeed!! And I completely agree with Aishwarya! Jash was himself stunned at times for her points.. We can also see him change topics without knowing how to oppose Aishwarya many times.. 😬😂

[@sheela506]

After the drain of wealth our country was brutally empty and poor and its impact is till now therefore "however the criminals must have died but the effect of their crime is making this generation a victim".

[@amanali2052]

I m indian i do think so british should atleast officially announced his appology to india and turn us back our kohinoor, Aishwariya is damn good debates,, thanku nas daily to bring this kind of content i really appreciate it hope

[@Cosmos0062]

Completely agree with Aishwarya..... Such an excellent debate💯💯👍👍👏 Britishers must apologize India🇮🇳... Had it not being colonized our present would have been somewhere else✨✨

[@mrcool2107]

And india would be even more United with Pakistan and Bangladesh with us

[@josephhvhayes]

No

[@mdrakibulhasan7395]

I am from Bangladesh and Bengal in the 18th century was the richest province in the world. The British East India Company came and exploited so much that now we are a 3rd world country. But we don't blame the present generation of British people for that. It's just how most European countries were at that time. I hope we can get our lost glory back. BTW RIP Queen Elizabeth II.

[@mudra5114]

What rubbish, Bengal did not become poor because of the British but other nations went ahead via industrialisation. And the British did not de-industrialise India, but tried to industralise as much as they could.

[@Arya_Rajput131]

We Indians not only want an apology from the British Crown but also the Kohinoor diamond which is in the crown of Queen Elizabeth. This diamond belongs to India, which was robbed by the Britishers. It is one of the most precious diamonds in the world. Although it is said that this diamond is cursed. Some people believe this to be true and some believe it to be a rumour. But one thing is certain that whichever ruler this diamond went to, it took away his power and splendor.

[@brittlesumo6842]

Fuck the kohinoor we want other artifacts too

[@mudra5114]

The diamond was not robbed. Read the history of the diamond. Even the Indian Government agrees it was not robbed.

[@heidijackson9122]

This happened in the past. Let bygones be bygones and let’s forge a better future. Apologies are no longer necessary. India doesn’t need a “sorry” from Britain

[@nehamehta491]

My great grandfather ran an apple export business(very reaping in India) which was sadly banned/taken over by one such British policy😢. If that was not done, today my parents & I would be a millionaire.

[@ketkinandanwar]

Aishwarya you broke it!!!

[@sr.liam17]

China was colonized. The British colonized Hong Kong, and now China wants it back. There were also other colonies such as Macau and Tianjin. Not forgetting the Shanghai French concession and international settlement.

[@ElAsesinoFutbàl]

First off, the 45 trillion usd taken by British, 30 trillion was also spent on India by the British, the kings had the money, not the people, so British colonization was a good thing for India Second of all, the Kohinoor diamond wasn't stolen by the Britishers, the Indian king during the time signed a peace treaty during the 18th century and the Kohinoor diamond was included in that peace treaty, and British did stop invading India, only a hundred years later, British colonized India

[@liverycreator7679]

If it was as good thing then why was the life expectancy in India 32 years when the Britishers left?? And the Indian king didn't gift the Britishers , he was forced to do it because the Britishers threatened him to do it otherwise they would have killed him and at that time the king was only 10 years old...... And everything they built in India was for slave transportation and when they say "Founders keepers" the Britishers didn't found the kohinoor the kohinoor was founded by Indians in the kolur mines , the Britishers just forcefully took it and its also said that "if two fishes are fighting then an Englishmen must have passed by" because Britishers left India in pieces and most of the things kept in British museum isn't even British and the hate between Hindus and Muslims started because of the divide and rule policy of Britishers , and you are saying that it was a good thing for India , if the Britishers didn't came then India would be the richest country in the world

[@shwetajaybhaye5329]

That was a great debate! But there are some important points that Aishwarya missed which are, 1)How much Britishers have impacted us mentally. 2)They made huge changes in our education system where people were taught to be slaves in the schools. 3) Britishers destroyed the Gurukul system 4) They created hatred between the Indians who had different cultures

[@redeyexxx1841]

4th point is not true. Hatred between Hindus & Muslims had long existed since Islamic invaders invaded India like Afgans & Mughals. Partition was bound to happen even if without British ever stepped in India.

[@shwetajaybhaye5329]

@@redeyexxx1841 If you know, at the time of partition many Muslims did not want to leave India. Not all of them did want an independent country. Also, Large-scale religious violence and riots have periodically occurred in India since its independence from British colonial rule i.e after 1947.

[@redeyexxx1841]

@@shwetajaybhaye5329 But many wanted a independent state too. Agar abhi sare Muslim Pakistan chale gye hote toh abhi humlog thoda Shanti se reh pate.

[@swastikkumar5115]

3:20 he said there is no victim here i can guarunteee you ppl that there is at least 15 000 people who are alive since that time in india pak and bangladesh merged up that is way more then enough people to apologies to these peoples families died because of britishers me personally as well my fathers brother died while the partition was happening

[@FirestarXYZV]

I’m early! Thank you for making inspirational videos for people all around the world! Keep being you, Nas!

[@NasDebates]

Thank you for supporting!

[@nousyt]

Comment before watching the debate: I’m neither British, nor from Bhārat Gaṇarājya. I was born in Germany in 1990. The atrocities committed by Hitler and his regime are to this day in peoples mind. Of those who are still alive, and to those who came after. Decades of unspoken hurt and pain manifest in behaviours and mindsets forming the past cultures. Generational Trauma is real, and needs to be met with understanding and empathy, for one generation to break free from those old chains. I can not apologise for anything i have not done. But i can recognise the consequences of what happened in the past. I can meet those who suffered with empathy and sympathise with them and their next of kin. But from those atrocities, also came growth, a deep understanding we are not our ancestors, nor responsible for what happens. But we still need to tell these stories as accurately as possible, for these events never to occur again. Yet, many want to blame those who came after, be hold responsible for the sins of their parents or grandparents. The wish to blame is human. We must acknowledge the past, it teaches us and from that we can grow as a person and through that as a group. Projects to give back stolen items from times of wars or colonial times are in motion, educational programs and merging together in education, creating a world were we understand each of us as being more alike in what we nowadays do, like, and function as a human, than we differ in opinion, experiences or upbringing. Human history is cruel, full of adversity, paranoia, fear of the unknown. And we have always looked for ways to keep the herd satisfied or poor. Wealth created through wars and colonialism happens, and is still happening. Based in greed, fed by experience and hate, those wishing people to change to their custom will tell stories of great conviction, but purely for them selves. To the people of Bharat: All of you who suffer directly or indirectly, you deserve your story. The story of your parents, grand-parents and their parents. You deserve the good and the bad of stories to be told. As emotional as it gets, history exists to change your future to come. No one i. this world has the right to deny your story, your identity, the identity of your parents, and those who were before the colonies came. As much as for us in Germany, not everyone was part or a willing part of what happened, but we can all acknowledge to the past, and work together to a future that does not live in greed, and more, more, more. Europe is an example to the rest of the world, what narcissistic culture does to others and “their own”. Neo-Capitalism growing world wide destroying the vast cultures and knowledge civilisations like yours. Pleasing external influences and stimuli, creating dependencies, competition, and narcissistic minds - rather a true spiritual, inclusive mind. Whatever the future holds, it is about the young generations and those able, to reflect the past and create what could be. Don’t let your rich and vast culture be more compromised than it has been- that i wish for all of Bharat ❤️

[@arvidelltd.3259]

Amazing 👍

[@arvidelltd.3259]

Can tell it's directly from the ❤️

[@nousyt]

@@arvidelltd.3259 Thanks. It does :)

[@arvidelltd.3259]

@@nousyt bro have you gained some knowledge about the Bharat ganrajya

[@nousyt]

@@arvidelltd.3259 You mean the history? I started with translations of Upanisads, Brâhmanas and some more. I had a very good sensei in Judo, who talked about stories of the knowledge of Bharat influencing Asia. In western culture Buddhism is associated more with east Asia, than with India. Apart from that, i believe understanding goes through the stomach, so i learned to cook different styles from this big and vast culture 😁

[@IstakharAlam-og7pn]

Please start the NAS DEBATES🙎🙎🙎🙎🙎🙎🙎

[@mranomalousfagan5382]

You know there is this thing called moving on, maybe India should try doing that.

[@chandnimehta7621]

aishwarya did great job🤝..totally agree with that..cannot neglect the fact what India would be if we were not tortured that way all along by Britisers.If we did best to come up to become one of the super power in 75 years, it doesn't mean that the past what britishers gave us has nothing to do with it. I want my nation to be respected even an apology can work for all sacrifices we had in past.

[@shadow9651]

There is a mistake in Aishwarya's argument, it is not 45 Billion that was estimated, it was actually estimated at 45 Trillion.

[@banyadeka7950]

Jash refuged to agree and said just adding random numbers before Billion. That thing isn't correct

[@taehyungsbreadcheekies3499]

it could be more but well never know since our voices were always suppressed

[@shadow9651]

@@taehyungsbreadcheekies3499 it doesn't really matter, they never gonna pay it back anyway

[@taehyungsbreadcheekies3499]

@@shadow9651 true, but it would be nice if they did

[@ravirana2001]

@@shadow9651 it would be great if they acknowledge atleast.

[@thirstymind795]

This video will be most viewed video on this channel and i supported aishwarya. British must apologise

[@redeyexxx1841]

Why? Crimes of ancestors don't transfer to their next generations.

[@chetanasai7286]

The debate was great. I would like to highlight two points, though: The fact that the mistake is not being accepted proves that the colonial mindset continues, and this mindset is much dangerous than the colonial rule, as it shows as all the native and primitive cultures in a negative way, which has been partly achieved in India partly.

[@prajvalrao4871]

you are merely imposing your opinion on others

[@turquoiz_the_potato]

1:30 I'm indian so I'm not bias, but the Kohinoor was given to the British in an agreement by a ten year old boy, who didn't really know what he was agreeing to. It wasn't really forcefully taken though.

[@kabirvatsyayan01]

but if you look at it, he was just 10 and which idiot would make a 10 yr old sign an agreement?

[@humanbeing2722]

Why was a 10 year old in power then?​@@kabirvatsyayan01

[@36prakharsaxena29]

As Jash gives the example of how China was not a colony but still their economy failed. To this Aishwarya replied because China had closed its economic gates. As an Indian I want to give you a image of India if the British had not looted us. Let's take the example of Japan, they were not formally colonized by any western power(before WWII), but they did open their doors to technology and develop their own industries. Thereby making them the only great imperialist power in Asia at the time of the Second World War. This past boost has benefited them till date. In the same way, India could have stood as a Power full nation in the UN if the British had never plundered us... Britishers must apologize and compensate for this.

[@Txxxxxxt5tttx]

I'm an Indian but I don't think they own us an apology because they helped us build all things though the way they treated us was very unfair I do agree with Aishwarya but Jash is also right they do not owe us ANYTHING!I don't want to bring up the past of anything that has happened because most of the Indian population have a trauma from those things that happened and we need to forget it!Plus without the British still there would a beggar in the world!And that is not the subject were talking about it is a common thing all around the world many other villagers have more beggars in their countries mostly in the Saudi countries though.

[@rubysarma9726]

Imagine If SASHI THAROOR Was present in the Debate?

[@alenp5282]

Watch Zareer Masani vs Shashi Tharoor debate on British rule.

[@senpai_kulhan_sweetheart777]

Yes agree The British should apologize india 🇵🇭🤝🏼🇮🇳

[@redeyexxx1841]

Why? Current British generation didn't loot India. It was their ancestors.

[@Tectonictaless]

@@redeyexxx1841 the current British generation enjoy from their ancestors loot.

[@deveshchauhan18]

@@redeyexxx1841 current British generation had grown with india's resources which is stolen from india after killing millions of indain that why they should atleast feel sorry about that

[@codyshi4743]

Speaking of China, as a Chinese I feel like the British should apologize for what it has done to India. The British should also apologize to China for the Opium War. Also China, may not have been colonized by the British but it has to give up many concessions to other foreign powers like giving up Hong Kong to the British, force to sign many unequal treaty with other 8 imperialist power and force to legalize Opium.

[@mr_prince_guptaa]

Yes i believe that the British should apologize to India and if not reparations then atleast should return all the historical objects such as kohinoor and all the antique piece of British museum which belongs to India. And i somewhat like the thinking of jash as well.

[@varun7819]

Aishwarya killed it 🔥🔥

[@7rx_edits]

Aishwarya smashed it

[@mudra5114]

Aishwarya was farting emotional bullshit.

[@deepapattnaik3454]

As an Indian, I don't want British people now to apologise. But they can be more educated about the matter. Their media houses, parliament could be more humble. They should not be mocking or spreading false news about India to show their glory. They should not be condemning India for it's foreign policies. And every other country they call uncivilized for it's issues when colonialism was the reason for this issue to actually exsist in the first place. I want them to grow out of their mindsets that they are better.

[@McterrainYT]

As a British person I think they should for what they did

[@dhruvsishodiya]

It is very shameful that a guy from indian race is saying that Britishers should not apologize. You should be progressive but you should never forget your past.

[@swastikkumar5115]

11:55 the europeans grabbed on the opportunities because they were greedy we did not grab the opporunity for two reasons first we were already being ruled by mughals next is that in hindu religion i am sure it is written that we want peace in the entire world therefore even if we were free from mughals we would not try and capture areas and stuff maybe the max we would have done is try and get akhand bharat (united india) back like the countries

[@shobhitgamerz5051]

I completely agree with Aishwarya, she put very important facts before jash, India is still fixing their cracks that were made by British Empire, If Britishers wasn't looted us then the whole conditions of today is kinda changed, We could be superpower till now, with best HDI in the world... Britishers are richer than us coz of wealth they had taken away from us in the past. That's why Britishers must apologize to India and give us respect.

[@kashikaarora3262]

It was in the past . We cannot change the past . It we want to be respected then we should earn that respect not demand it . And if we talk about economics of India , yes we were wronged but past is past we should move on from it .

[@shobhitgamerz5051]

@@kashikaarora3262 yeah that's true but that dark past of ours is affecting our present in many ways.

[@jerichoholic5805]

As much as I kinda agree with her, it makes me think, shouldn't the bramhmans of now apologize to the other "lower" castes?

[@gaurav8475]

Is there any reservation for indian students in british colleges?

[@kookiecuter]

I don't think apologies rn will make up for anything done in the past.. Though as for castes are concerned we realised this during our independence era itself that everybody should be treated equally and made laws according to that, criminalized promotion of untouchability, reservation system was introduced etc. That was our leaders' way of making up for the atrocities people had to face because of caste system. Though it doesn't lessen the pain of the ancestors it'll protect the future generations. But what has the British done to make up for anything they did? Steal our money and diamonds and claim that it is "compensation"??

[@gaurav8475]

@@kookiecuter🙌

[@avikmajumder8963]

Can we have "Books vs. Movies" topic in this debate show?

[@sujith123]

The value of developments and infrastructure till date. The contribution of these factors to GDP in form of quality, plan of implementation vs population was the answer for economic imbalance. Still if there was a compromise in developments comparing current population with time of discussion population to get real numbers of difference and reasons.

[@88kocibaba]

This was an amazingly well curated debate! Learnt so much from it and it is great to see both sides of the coin!

[@NasDebates]

Thank you for your support!

[@britishsoilger8144]

@@NasDebates your video was dumb and polliticly correct RULE BRITANIA BRITANIA RULE THE WAVES BRITONS NEVER NEVER NEVER SHALL BE SLAVES 🇬🇧🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🏴󠁧󠁢󠁷󠁬󠁳󠁿🇫🇰🇮🇴🇭🇰🇳🇿🇭🇲🇲🇸🇰🇾🇬🇸🇵🇳🇹🇨🇸🇭🇹🇦💂🏻☕

[@nikstorm]

14:00 I can see the pain in her eyes😢 we all feel how our nation was looted and tortured.

[@muhammadisaac07]

Truly speaking I don't feel like a victim to anyone Rather than This Crazy society That we had today!

[@redeyexxx1841]

Exactly.

[@Mohdhaxb]

Thanks for his content 💝

[@NasDebates]

Thank you for watching!

[@swastikkumar5115]

8:45 the 23 billion is probably indias money that they put back into india and that is out of the trillions we had at one point

[@surendranchennai2676]

Britain should definetly apologize to India through the handover of the symbolic world-renowned Kohinoor Diamond

[@shru911]

Indians have moved on And britishers should also move on... They should not brag that they were a force for good in their history books And if they tell what good things they have done then also mention how much destruction and crime was committed. Just acknowledge the wrongs!! Every victim should get this minimal justice.

[@shrin210]

Yup, no need of apology or reparations, their education and history books should consister of their leaders cruelty and not only brag about it.

[@rohit_0198]

According to jash:- if a person killed someone he mustn't apologize or to get punishment coz the person is not alive whom he killed Not only Britain must apologize but they must pay compensation for all things they have done in the past

[@kashikaarora3262]

He never said that the person who killed another person should not be punished .. it's about that the person who killed and who has been killed are both gone and we should move on

[@rohit_0198]

@@kashikaarora3262 if I agree with your argument then do you think, must Britain acknowledge the genocide, bengal famine, May be you don't know Britain's public are seeing as a great leader to Winston Churchill who was responsible for bengal famine,Reginald Dyer who was responsible for Jallianwala Bagh massacre. After knowing this what do you think? They must return our kohinoor and our precious, ancients things which is exist in present time.

[@kashikaarora3262]

@@rohit_0198 I know these facts . But do you know they also think Mahatma Gandhi was also a great leader . They respected him too . I know what they did to Indians was wrong but Freedom Fighters of India also killed a lot of Britishers . You may say it is self defence but the truth is truth . We both have blood on our hands . I am not taking their side neither am I saying they are right . But holding a grudge would not get us anywhere . We should move on and look forward to make India better on its own instead of begging for the things that belong to us once .

[@rohit_0198]

@@kashikaarora3262 I am not going to chit chat with you because there is not logic in you, I feel bad that there is people like you who is thinking that our freedom fighters were killer, as they declare our freedom fighter bhagat singh a Terrorist, Madam I want also peace but apologies are good things if any one done bad things our anyone support bad things and Britain's public didn't acknowledge those things they must apologize they must pay the compensation and they must return our things that's it 🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@kashikaarora3262]

@@rohit_0198 They do fought for our freedom . But let's get it clear they also killed people . Violence happened. Even if we do bad things for good reasons that doesn't mean it's right . And apologies are good but when you actually feel guilty but when they doesn't feel guilty about it then what's the point of demanding an apology . It just makes us pathetic. And you are talking about logic ? Really you think that killing people for right reasons is fine . Then what's the difference between them and us . They can say they killed our people because of theft , murder , not following their rules if they give it a reason would it be okay for you . Don't get me wrong I respect our Freedom Fighters but the truth is that they killed people too .

[@Em1489]

I’m not from India but agreed with the girl, the British colonised many many countries and they took their benefits and their freedom. But now it’s the time British should gave them Apologies.

[@Juho221]

Do you think that the countries the British colonised were doing well before the British came? The Brits were the first empire ever to abolish slavery, and they forced the Africans to end their slave trade as well. Before the British there were even worse empires and kingdoms

[@cygnusmir1627]

@@Juho221 Ok I agree that I don’t think they need to apologise but what it seems your saying is that the British caused more harm than good which is true in some cases but false in many others, besides the British could have treated the natives of the lands they conquered much better than they did Eg. In Ireland (where I’m from) the British stopped the Irish from being able to vote, own land, express our own religion, speak their own language etc. Did Ireland end up more industrialised? Yes, sort of but it wasn’t worth all the death and cultural genocide caused

[@abhinandandwivedi]

@@Juho221 don't wanna debate bout others countries but India certainly was a giant having alot of resources....prior to invasion of brits.... Whole Western region who had somewhat power to rule wanted to spread their roots in India....such as America back then was misunderstood as India and was discovered ..... because most of the western rulers back then wanted to search for India and mercenaries and sailors were appointed just to find a way to be in indian region...

[@Juho221]

@@cygnusmir1627 Yes, perhaps. But compared to every other country during 19th century, the British were much better and humane. Obviously what they did was wrong, but it was normal for the time

[@Juho221]

@@abhinandandwivedi Yes, India was an important country back then. All European powers wanted to be a part of the spice trade. But the ordinary people weren't doing any better, and there was a lot of wars

[@birnarsinghdsssaasddffgghh4726]

British empire took things from 🇻🇳🇵🇰🇮🇳🇪🇬🇧🇩 and 50 other countries in Nepal 🇳🇵 we had to fight for our rights thank god we got recruited 300years ago and yes they’re empire was standing for 300 years

[@ehteshamanis]

Apology should have be done and Assets which are taken should have been returned to India specially Kohinoor and other precious things.

[@mihneabagescu9318]

Ashwayra took Jash's final argument and did't let him to vive examples.

[@KenjiSan_k9]

here me out, I'm an Indian Making today's generation apologize for the mistakes their forefathers did will change nothing *NOTHING* ! Saying Sorry for something thier forefathers did will change nothing because they're not the ones who are responsible. "Tum galti Kiya, uske liye Tera beta jimmedar nahi hoga" What happened in the past, happened, and we can't do anything about it now, but we can build ourselves back up again. We've been looted, yes. But not by the present generation, AND complaining about "loss of natural" resources won't bring those "natural resources" back. India is growing again, slowly and steadily ! We don't need an apology, we can be partners. I don't hold them accountable for what they're forefathers did. Thank you 🙏

[@vaishanthjv2519]

finally someone logical

[@KenjiSan_k9]

@@vaishanthjv2519 thanks 👍

[@The_Honourable_Company]

I support the guy, he has just very good arguments to back his claim up against her. It's just that colonialism is a very sensitive topic in today's world, and that most people blindly say that it was evil and just brought suffering. I respect people like him who actually side with opinions like that which are often discouraged and looked down upon society

[@akhilviswam7171]

👎

[@ravirana2001]

No britishers did great for us they were our gods we should worship them .

[@The_Honourable_Company]

@@ravirana2001 is this sarcasm or what?

[@savyakhatiwada8418]

As an Nepalese I think that the British should apologize

[@kabirvatsyayan01]

thank u!

[@Saproxzyte11]

She is right like the fact that France owes and apology to Haiti

[@thedarkknight095]

First, sins of the father cannot be the sins of the sons but a son can apologize for his father's sins. Moreover maybe the oppressors are no more alive but people from 1930s to 1940s are still alive. Ask them if they want any apologizies for their pain or their parent's. How can a millennial possibly debate about it when they are receiving almost everything what our forefathers could only imagine. BRITISHERS OWE US AN APOLOGY. and its undebatable. Thanks

[@mudra5114]

The British do not owe any apology. Apology for what?

[@faisalmohammed5167]

Everyone: India was colonized by the British. Goa and Puduchery: ARE WE A JOKE TO YOU?

[@nathandei1674]

Some French territories in India as well: Are we a joke to you?

[@benkigera]

The guy is good, he must be a writer.

[@EvaFun]

this is a reminder that loads of us should own up to our mistakes not just Britain and a life lesson

[@jAI0102]

13:53 so he is saying public should remain calm if a girl got raped??

[@Captaindavyy]

I mostly agree with Aish. To put it from my perspective, I love English people the way they are today, but this wasn't the case during that era. Screw all those 45 trillion dollars. The main point is the violence that were conducted by them. I think at the end of the day, mass murder should not be a thing that can be passed by. When you didn't give them the live you don't have the right to take it. The estimated 50M dead people(incl. my great grandpa) deserve an apology from the heart of British. Not just a normal official statement.

[@yoursuccessmantra3862]

Trillion*

[@hammadyousuf9305]

I think British should apologize to india because of the theft and not only did they steal the Kohinoor diamond they also stole fabric and other necessities and even were the cause for the end of Mughal empire. As studying both india and Pakistan studies. It is clear that the British should return the kohinoor diamond along with a blank check for all the misunderstanding and theft their ancestors did. Aishwariya u did a great job! 👏👏

[@gouravdas493]

@alphabet sim you're that guy 😂hey na .who come here to replie every comment against British .

[@mrcool2107]

Also they should apologise for dividing india into two . Because of them Pakistan Pakistan happend

[@aaronking2369]

We will when the Romans and vikings apologise to britian.

[@mrcool2107]

@@aaronking2369 difference is Romans civilised and invented Britain but British stole all wealth and divided India

[@aaronking2369]

@@mrcool2107 dumbest thing I've ever heard india wasn't even a country before british rule🤦‍♂️

[@manojm828]

doesn't matter if the brits ever apologize or not the people and their monarchs will never ever get the respect they could have deserved if it weren't for their inhuman cruel ancestors nobody is gonna respect the queen or any of her successors we Indians are thought not to celebrate on the death of the elderly even if they are our biggest enemies you see we are human unlike their ancestors

[@Juho221]

Inhuman cruel ancestors?

[@tadeserosheedabiola]

Is this guy saying if I owe his deceased father money , is he not going to collect it back from me .

[@neeti0]

Hey! Nas debates, please continue uploading more videos! You have that power to change the mind of viewers, and i am one of them❤

[@error40453]

Honestly , Aish had me voting for her all along , but Yash's closing statement....damn that hits hard

[@Afnan_Taher]

It was the age of war and conquest. First kings looted each other and then the British joined the fun. All they did was change on Tyrant with the other. I'm from Bangladesh. Historically, the Bengal region alone had 12% in world gdp share. But unlike India, you don't see Bangladeshis nagging over the past. Greed and disloyalty of the people in the Indian subcontinent is what sold this subcontinent to the british. And it is still eating the Indian sub-continent from inside.

[@shrin210]

Yup as an Indian, i agree to your words👍

[@akashpaul4143]

yeah continue stitching clothes for the europeans , you all are good for that .... colonial mindset will take long to end .

[@themoroccanball]

Bangladeshis: *stay in their Mosques and move on* Indians: *nag about the past*

[@brittlesumo6842]

@@themoroccanball "The country who forgets it's past has no future" -Winston Churchill

[@brittlesumo6842]

@@themoroccanball and this is very much true, you learn from your past and get's aware about your surroundings. And it depends how seriously you take

[@prata1019]

19:42 Buddha was born in far southern Nepal, very close to the Indian border. 19:52 Sanchi is in Madhya Pradesh, far from Bihar. And I really wish that there was more talk about the countless disastrous famines across India and the systematic racial discrimination instigated by the British.

[@chillgates8381]

Bruh ur exactly right 😂 But ig at that time we all were under askoka's rule and we were recognised as 1 😅 ♥️ btw i was going to right the same comment 😭 but u already wrote it ♥️

[@taehyungsbreadcheekies3499]

but at first all those countries were apart of akhand Bharat so buddhism was a part of hinduism not a totally different religion

[@prata1019]

@@taehyungsbreadcheekies3499 well Buddhism was not Hinduism on a variety of levels (e.g belief in God)

[@prata1019]

@@taehyungsbreadcheekies3499 well Buddhism was not Hinduism on a variety of levels (e.g belief in God)

[@taehyungsbreadcheekies3499]

@@prata1019 Im not saying it's the same religion what I'm saying is that it derived from hinduism since buddha was a Hindu prince

[@storyreview116]

I want Britishers to apologise for 3 main points: 1. They can handle partition in a far better way but they didn't...and for that millions of people died and faced miserable displacement 2. Their policy towards divide and rule causing us still today...we were happily residing with each other in this subcontinent... 3. They looted huge resources from us and caused famine.. precisely to say the Bengal Butcher Churchill...their policy caused millions of people to die during famine.... And also Jalianwala bagh massacre... Whatever they did "Good" for us is actually to their betterment... Bridges, railways towns are all for them...they just can't take it wy, thats why it is here...so apologize and let the pain be eased

[@sibanitripathy3338]

Ashamed yash...and we'll done Aishwarya your points..your argument..you rocked girl