Should you pigtail your electrical outlets? The answer might surprise you.

[@BackyardMaine]

Hello everyone. I have some new info about the channel. My electrical #shorts have been getting millions of views so I have decided to start doing longer electrical videos. The plan is to post one five minute electrical video every week. Let me know what you think? Thanks for supporting the Channel (John).

[@gcnewd]

Longer works for me

[@josechavarria5944]

Gracias john

[@BackyardMaine]

@@josechavarria5944 de nada Jose..

[@jamesortolano3983]

John thanks for all the content ,editing nd time you devote. Nd thanx for sending me this video on series nd parallel wiring. I agree with you on both situations having there dedicated applications. As an HVAC-R mechanic since the 80's ,nd as furnaces internals are always series wired. I cant understand why any electrician would disagree with this application. Switch legs,multiple switch locations,dual powered brakers with a common neutral, sub panels . These are just some of the wired applications needed nd appreciated by myself from you sparkies So far as to say ,or hear someone say in your field that parallel wiring is best is just one sided. Any real ,true electrician will tell you they are both needed. In my almost 40 years of dealing with it ,I would say those that argue this fact are just Green. Nd in time ,yes time as with all things they will realize no one side of any argument is correct. Just my opinion, nd I'm grateful for you to bring this up to the many. I only hope the young ones ,the green ones realize both side are valid..

[@BackyardMaine]

@@jamesortolano3983 Thank you my friend. You are 100 % correct. I have noticed on youtube anything you say people will argue. Ive been an electrician for 38 years and spent my last 10 years working as an electrical engineer. I have seen it all. Thanks again and I will try to keep the content coming.

[@stevenbullock9276]

I'm a retired electrician of over 40 years. Depending on the application, I use both methods. The only thing I will never do is use the push-in connections on the back. I've replaced way too many that were wired that way where the wires fall right out of the back- including the home I'm in now.

[@lukesenft4307]

Job security

[@yami4g63]

Yea I had to fix all of the backstabbed outlets in my house. Loose causing arcking.

[@ysagas]

I keep seeing this same message but the amount of years change lol is there some type of astroturfing going on ?

[@tredogzs]

Wago and backstab ... those friction fit are trash

[@jesse7jesse7]

@@lukesenft4307 too easy to mess it up. conductor around screw harder to mess up - unless you wrap the wrong direction!

[@deej19142]

I'm commenting at only 1:30 into the video, but here's why I pigtail. Two basic reasons. One, it's a lot easier to push the receptacle back in the box with only two wires on it, and two, if the plug fails, with a pigtail you would not lose power down the line. Ok back to the video. Lets see what else I can learn. Edit: I did learn a few things, this guy is awesome!

[@coriding]

Great video! Another good reason to pigtail is that it makes the receptacle much easier to swap in the future. You only have 3 screws to worry about, instead of 5. Not a huge deal, but any time I swap ones that aren't pigtailed, I always change it to a pigtail connection. I like to leave things better than I found them.

[@BackyardMaine]

Thank you and thanks for adding value to the conversation.

[@glasshalffull2930]

With pigtails, you have extra wire (or could replace the pigtails), so to speed things up, just cut the old wires at the receptacle.

[@zigarooSJunk]

when going pigtail, does this account as more wire count for the volume of the box?

[@surferdude642]

​@@zigarooSJunkI think that the box fill calculations account for the possibility of using pigtails, so the answer is no, pigtails don't count in box fill calculations.

[@carlodonnell146]

@@glasshalffull2930 pigtails are great for electrical work, but not for the pigs because they lose their tail everytime we need a tail; just a bit of humour!!! I think pigtail are a good way to do it!!!

[@trevorkolmatycki4042]

This is interesting: Most people condemn back stabbing receptacles… and there have been failures so rightfully so. Majority of the same people will use wagos and/or push fit connectors. Both are the same type of connection, just like a back stab. So the problem isn’t back stabbing, the problem is poor quality products. Imagine your quality 4 port wago or quality push fit connector built right into the receptacle… with internal solid bus tap to feed the receptacle… this would be very space efficient and lightning fast to install. But… most people would shun it because “backstab bad”. When in reality the problem is “cheap crap receptacles bad.” BTW this was the best discussion of pigtail vs daisy-chain I have heard yet… Subscribed! Cheers!

[@sigcrazy7]

You don’t have to imagine a Wago built into a receptacle. Both Leviton and Hubble are making receptacles with lever connectors built into the device.

[@xHadesStamps]

Backstabbing is not the same type of connection, it’s a brass leaf “spring” that the end of pokes into your wires. Wago lever splices are a gradual cam clamp, and push-in connectors…I have no idea how they work.

[@RandyK1ng]

I have had bunches of failures with back-stab receptacles. I have had ZERO failures with screws and, now, ZERO failures with Wago. It's different tech.

[@jenniferrabuchin364]

Thanks for your videos! well presented information. I work for a building department, and we've had this discussion before. IMO pigtails are better. My mom called me up once to say all of the plugs one one side of the house had gone dead including the one for her refrigerator. Checked it out, and a recep upstream on the circuit had burned up, causing all the downstream plugs to lose power. So I recommend that people use pigtails to wire their plugs. Thanks again, take care

[@mikeheller1225]

I do electrical work for Habitat for Humanity. In building new homes, we always pig-tail, since that allows us to easily do a continuity check from the panel to the last outlet on a circuit BEFORE the sheetrock goes up -- has saved us tons of time fixing a wiring error, an over-enthusiastic staple, etc. when it's still easy to do.

[@SaltMinerOU812]

Yeah that's a pretty good idea actually

[@raterus]

Bah! The most exciting part after drywall is seeing that line actually work! (Seriously though, that is a really good argument)

[@thomassciurba5323]

Finally an argument that makes sense.

[@jonnybravo4389]

Just had to replace a receptacle in my bedroom, hooked a window ac to it and it quit working after a couple days. Flipped the breaker, took it out to inspect and come to find out whoever did the electrical on my house used recepticals that ONLY have back stab connections, the only screw on the unit was for the ground wire. Now my summer project is to go room by room and upgrade every single outlet in the home to a higher quality receptacle and eliminate all back stabbed connections. It was incredibly frustrating because that outlet is tied to two other outlets as well as the light switch so one outlet being bad means the whole room loses power. However i did not pigtail, I wired directly to the screws on the receptacle because that was how my dad taught me to do it years ago. I'll definitely be considering pigtails for future installations though. Thanks for the video

[@BackyardMaine]

I think pigtails have a place but through wire in mist applications. The back stabs are not reliable at all so you're doing the right thing by getting them replaced.

[@chrisloesch1870]

Window ac units are borderline dedicated circuits in my opinion they draw ALOT of amps. Any outlets along that particular line are gonna be prone to failure and melting due to the constant amperage being pulled through that line. That’s why kitchen gfis and smaller appliances often have dedicated circuits. Just a week ago I went on a house call where a customer had multiple outlet failures on a circuit due to plugging in and running a hot tub on a 15 amp breaker line. The tub TECHNICALLY can run on such a circuit but it should be on its own dedicated line. At the very least every outlet on that line should be pigtailed to avoid that much amperage being drawn through the outlet on its way to the hot tub outlet as a stop gap measure.

[@Hunter-yc4xi]

@@chrisloesch1870 Hot tubs are required to have a GFCI on them. Though I have seen some of the 110vac units come with them on the cord.

[@1575murray]

I replaced a bunch of Slater residential receptacles in my cousin's old apartment which had only back stab connections and were badly worn out causing intermittent connections. I used Leviton commercial grade 15 amp receptacles since most of them were on a 20 amp circuit and were through wired. Where necessary I used the back wire feature (not the same as back stabbing) since the commercial grade receptacles had 20 amp pass through capability. I can understand builders using these types of receptacles as even a few minutes per apartment saved could make a difference in the contractor's bottom line. My mother's senior residence apartment had similar receptacles although they were on 15 amp circuits and I replaced all eight of them to keep her safe.

[@haroldgreen1425]

The main reason for pig tailing in commercial work is so you can remove a device without breaking the circuit. Especially true on multi wire branch circuits where even if you shut off the device circuit you still have a neutral in use by another circuit and it can be dangerous to break it.

[@BackyardMaine]

Exactly. Plus it’s a code violation to use the device to connect the neural on a multi wire branch circuit.

[@mackellyman5642]

@@BackyardMaine And the truth will set you free. This is excellent content, and all the required people are checking in with comments.

[@rupe53]

later code will also have you using a 2-pole breaker on a shared neutral so the other circuit should be off if that's the case. OTOH, if it was wired by older code, it's a crap shoot!

[@illestofdemall13]

I always pigtail mine. From experience I can say that when non pigtailed receptacles fail, it's a pain to chase down the problem because several other receptacles downstream of it are also out.

[@annteve]

A failed receptacle bridge would not affect upstream outlets; the fault would be easy to find tracing the circuit from the panel to the last live outlet.

[@walterbordett2023]

If wires are not exposed, tracing the cable path of the circuit may be difficult. I don't like stuffing five solid twelve gage wires attached to a receptacle into the box. I always pigtail and often use stranded pigtails to the receptacle terminals. I always use commercial or federal spec grade devices as they are easier to wire, and are much more durable in use. The big box DIY cheapies are junk not worthy of my time.

[@NelsonJ1]

​@@annteveExactly, it's extremely easy.

[@jeremysmothers5143]

What are you guys talking about with it’s hard?! It’s easier bc the problem is obviously at the last outlet ahead of the ones not working it isolates the problem faster

[@illestofdemall13]

@@jeremysmothers5143 you can't always tell which direction the wire is going. It's easier to troubleshoot when only one outlet stops working.

[@dantigar7318]

The clarity of your presentations, backed by the NEC code book, make your videos top notch. It's nice to refresh my knowledge now and then. New subscriber, long time electrical apprentice, (retired).

[@BackyardMaine]

Wow, thanks! I try really hard to provide clarity and back it up with the code. There is a lot of misinformation about code requirements on the internet these days.

[@Oldhogleg]

One of the things I like about pigtailing is that it allows you to prewire everything. Makes for real quick and easy to install devices.

[@SaltMinerOU812]

That's an excellent point

[@rainmaker3700]

That is the way I always do it.

[@rodgraff1782]

@@rainmaker3700I don’t agree. Just another splice to fail, and more garbage in the junction box.

[@martingo2680]

As a truck driver always wanted to become an electrician, these videos are great..😊 I've learned so much.

[@BackyardMaine]

Great to hear! Thanks for watching..

[@beenschmokin]

The "problem" with pig tail option in residential is that the boxes are not designed for pig tails so getting the wire into the box often causes more hazard by overcrowding. That's the only down side I can see. Both work and neither is better. It's application. Good video.

[@BackyardMaine]

You are correct and thanks for sharing.

[@natemartinez4595]

Gotta be caefeul and use your adult brain. If there's 5 wires versus 2, probably shouldn't lol

[@davidpotts3844]

that is totally a wrong statement, all boxes are designed for the use of wirenuts, splices and device. A single gang residential box is designed for a count of 9, #12 wires, that is a in/out splice and device is a count of 9 ground only counts one time as a non current conductor

[@BackyardMaine]

Like I mentioned in the video.@@natemartinez4595

[@62Cristoforo]

Which is why I make a practice of over-sizing my boxes, just in case. Costs a bit more, but less headache in the future if there’s a need to add devices.

[@uxwbill]

I had always used the through wire connections until I took a basic electrical class as I went through an HVAC/R program. The HVAC instructor saw me through wiring and stopped the class for a moment to point out that while what I was doing was completely legal and allowed, the idea of all that current flowing through those little tabs made him uncomfortable. That was how I learned about pigtailing. Ever since, I've almost universally done the pigtailing thing and found myself liking it better. When I rewired an old house recently, I reused some of the old steel junction boxes. Of course, they're smaller than the new ones and I soon found there just wasn't room to pigtail most of the time...so back to through wiring it was! I've never used those push in connections, as I've seen too many of them pop free when replacing failed switches or worn outlets.

[@BackyardMaine]

You will be fine. The little tabs your instructor was pointing out are UL tested at 30A and have a 20A rating even on 15A receptacles. Both wiring methods are code compliant and equally reliable when done correctly. I base my options on 40 years working as a licensed electrician and the last ten years as an electrical engineer

[@uxwbill]

@@BackyardMaine Oh, no...I wasn't worried. I had just hoped to share a little (?) story about how I learned of pigtailing. I still use both approaches depending upon what I'm working with. Thank you for the response, especially in light of how many views your channel and videos get!

[@doctorwu1303]

I am not an electrician but love to do my own electrical jobs (within reason) around the house and business, I do know my limitations! I really like your professional and common sense approach to teaching about electrical issues and don’t take the ‘it’s my way or the highway opinion’. Some electricians get really emotional and butt hurt when they are called out or shown a better way to do things. You have a really good and informative channel. 😊

[@BackyardMaine]

Thank you so much! I do my best to just present what my 40 years in the electrical field has taught me. The goal is to help people out.

[@MrTrashcan1]

I'm doing basement rooms surface mount with conduit. So I'm not pigtailing because it's all linear and if one outlet or connection goes, it will be easy to track down the source. Plus these are commercial outlets, so easy to just backwire. For hidden work, I may jumper 2-gang outlets within a box, but will pigtail to the next box.

[@BackyardMaine]

Agreed

[@mondavou9408]

I like the clean presentation. I'm DIY and this is exactly the type of questions I wrestle with and since I have no real world experience, its the information I need. New Sub.

[@BackyardMaine]

Awesome! Thank you! You are actually my target audience (DIYers who want to do some basic electrical work in their homes). Welcome aboard!

[@cherrypieforbreakfast1499]

After chasing down a few receptacle problems in my rental properties over the years (which were, of course, all back stabbed) I started pigtailing everything when renovating my houses. Never had a problem since.

[@BackyardMaine]

Yes for sure anything back stabbed should be pigtailed.

[@TheElectricalNut]

Pigtailing is always a great idea but not pigtailing wasn't the cause of your issues it was the fact that they used the stablocks(backstabs) on the outlet instead of using shepherd hooks and securing it under the terminal screw directly

[@CaptainTwitchy]

@@BackyardMainewhy are they allowed to make backstabs if they don’t work and can cause problems? Or, secondly, why don’t the manufacturers make the damn things work?! 😂

[@BackyardMaine]

That is a pretty good question. I really don't know but I have a theory. I think manufacturers are trying to design outlets and switches that a homeowner or DIYer can easily install. About half the sales of these products come from people doing the work themselves. That's why they also have the side screw connections to keep the contractors coming back because they know the stabs are not very reliable. These connections do work and sometimes will last a long time but a higher percentage of them will fail as compared to a side screw terminal connections. The higher the current draw the quicker they will fail. Just my opinion after working as an electrician for almost for decades.@@CaptainTwitchy

[@AB-dl1hz]

​@@TheElectricalNutThat's what he said

[@sifat9667]

Thanks for giving me the courage to throughwire using the connecton ports. It worked out great!

[@BackyardMaine]

Glad I could help!

[@davidsteinberg8024]

I had this discussion with a colleague engineer who was a part-time electrcian nearly 40 years ago and the conclusions were the same. I've owned three houses all with K&T with those tiny ungrounded metal boxes. My advice is when servicing a switch or receptacle cut out the metal box and replace with a plastic old work box. Especially handy when putting in a GFCI.

[@tommywatterson5276]

It's definitely not a bad idea. I do the same thing jumping off hots to switches too.

[@JohnM1774]

Hi, GREAT video !!! I have been doing electrical, went to a very good vocational school, graduated in 1977 and I have watched a few of your videos and learned a couple of things I never realized with the wire strippers. I am not a licensed electrician but do work NEC certified. Keep up the GREAT videos (and yes I subscribed) Thank you !!!!!

[@BackyardMaine]

That’s great to hear my friend. Thank you.

[@Joey-kv6qr]

For my electrical code we only use pigtail even if there is 2 outlets together. This is because the current that passes thru the outlet tab sometimes gets overloaded and causes it to glow hot and cause possible fire. There is another advantage of using pigtail method is that if the outlet needs to be replaced its easier to install 3 wires back vs 5 wires on the outlet.

[@BackyardMaine]

The passthrough current rating is 20A even on 15A receptacles which is greater than the 14AWG wire or equal to 12AWG and of course it's not insulated so no worries there. In 38 years I have never seen a device fail in that way.

[@chrisloesch1870]

@@BackyardMaineI have. And it shocked the hell outta me when I saw it. The homeowner was extremely lucky it didn’t burn the whole house down. It did , scorch the receptacle box and melted the receptacle almost down to nothing and never tripped the breaker on a 15 amp circuit with 14 gauge wires and through connections of 4 different outlets all gfi (yes the house was built in the early 80s). It should have all been pigtailed in my opinion.

[@Sparky-ww5re]

​​@@chrisloesch1870assuming the receptacle wasn't some Chinese knock-off with a fake UL mark or no UL listing, it is rated to pass thru 20 amps, in fact if you were to disassemble a receptacle down to the internal contacts you'd find double T shaped for NEMA 5-15, 5-20, 6-15 & 6-20, the cover bonded to the receptacle determines the NEMA configuration. Based on the age of the house during that time Federal Pacific Electric panels were fairly common and had a high failure rate of not tripping during a sustained overload, even failing to trip on a dead short. Red tipped handles, and Stab-Loc name on the panel are things to look for. Also research Federal Pacific Electric. You'll find numerous reports of failure and that these panels are extremely unreliable and unsafe and they are no longer in business.

[@pld8993]

@@chrisloesch1870 What you believe you observed is not what you actually observed. It is more likely that the receptacle overheated at that location due to a loose or compromised connection. If the receptacle is fried near the terminal screws/link, unless you are watching it happen in real time, you could not attribute that to a glowing, overloaded terminal link. The link between the terminal screws is rated for 20 amps and in order to be rated as such under UL rules it must be able to handle 150% of its rating, which is 30 amps. If there was a pigtail and the connection at the receptacle was loose or compromised, the exact same outcome would have occurred. In other words, pigtailing would not have made any difference in the outcome. I've been an electrician for over 40 years and I've never once seen the link between the terminals magically fail or overheat on a properly installed recipe. It doesn't get overloaded and glow hot, not sometimes or EVER. In order for that to happen you're have to have that 15amp receptacle on a 35+ amp circuit.

[@jonhansen4745]

@@BackyardMaine I've seen it at least 3 times that I can recall over the past 40 years. In all 3 cases, the entire circuit had been overloaded & it didn't trip the breakers (in one case the circuit was backed up to a 30A screw in fuse) In 2 of those cases all it did was burn up the entire 15 amp receptacle & burn itself open. In the other case it started a fire in the wall in a basement with wood paneling. This was also an older 15 amp outlet wired with #14 cloth romex & backed up to the 30A screw in fuse. Thank God the homeowner heard his smoke detector in the basement go off & caught it before it caught the whole house on fire. The only time I wire receptacles in series is GFCI outlets or those times I've replaced receptacles with new ones and the wires were in small steel boxes with the all wires cut short & stabbed in the back. I might add that I only use commercial grade receptacles that accept a straight wire behind a plate tightened by the terminal screws. I have wired some of these through the outlet in series. Whenever possible I will add pigtails to these boxes also & do it the best & correct method.

[@williampagdon4822]

I have just started the exact Project you described (6 Short Wires and adding a GFCI to the End of the Run), so you have confirmed my plan to add Pigtails. I expect to use WAGO Connectors for this. Thank you for your videos, they have been very helpful and interesting.

[@BackyardMaine]

Excellent! Thanks for watching.. I just uploaded a new video on light switch wiring.

[@TheBenjammin]

I do apartment maintenance. I replace every outlet in every apartment I turn because the electrician that originally did the wiring backstabbed every outlet. I only use commercial grade outlets because they take less time to wire and I never pigtail. Never had a problem.

[@BackyardMaine]

I never back stab either. I have a video on that as well. kzbin.info/www/bejne/m5CmkKetnZqZh6c I use commercial grade as well but I like to add the residential grade to my videos since so many people use them.

[@BackyardMaine]

I rarely pigtail either and have never had an issue. As a matter of fact I wired my own house 25 years ago and have never had one electrical problem. All through wired.

[@JeffBanfield-t6v]

Don't use 20a commercial grade outlets on 15 amp circuits. That's a code violation.

[@cliffweinan3907]

Great explanation of 20a current capacity of the outlet pass thru. Thanx.

[@BackyardMaine]

Glad it was helpful! Thanks for watching and for your comment.

[@ericnortan9012]

Master electrician, 30 years in the trade. I pigtail every device (except gfci).

[@progression_decibel]

Any particular reason(s) you don't pigtail GFCI receptacles? I have about 8-9 receptacles (on two different 20A kitchen branch circuits) that currently have one GFCI receptacle on the first receptacle of the circuit and most likely feeding & protecting the load to the downstream receptacles since they are all standard ones. It seems silly but I don't want the scenario where we trip one receptacle and it knocks out all the other receptacles and I have to go reset the breaker and I was going to either 1) replace ALL receptacles with GFCI ones and pigtail them all [I know seems overkill or costly but I figure buy once cry and replace once] or 2) have my electrician change out the two breakers for GFCI breakers and replace all receptacles with standard ones AND still pigtail all of them. Value your input and recommendation, thanks!

[@ericnortan9012]

@@progression_decibel that's the reason, cost. Unless the customer requests it. I do pig tail them in certain situations, for reasons you stated. You don't want to be chasing the source gfci all over the place for sure, but a standard kitchen install is usually a gfci protecting the rest of the standard devices on the circuit. Ideally in my eyes we just install gfci breakers and be done with it, but again cost always factors in. I should have said that in general I don't pigtail gfci's, but in some cases it's the better way.

[@douglashitchlock4580]

We had aluminum wire in the 70's. Push in was common practice. Hydro had to promote pigtails and coalox to deal with failure and fires

[@johng.4959]

Good stuff! Yup, I always Pigtail my outlets also.

[@BackyardMaine]

Right on!

[@lakeforkwiring]

Great Video ... I like to pig tail because #1 its less likely to fail than the plug thru wiring and #2 you won't loose any down street devices.

[@pld8993]

Through-wiring, daisy chaining through the terminal screws, is not more likely to fail than pig-tailing. When done properly, both methods are equal in integrity and function.

[@Calico5string1962]

With over 40 years of experience, I have done both. I tend to like pigtailing better, and usually will do it in most instances. We always did pigtailing on commercial/industrial work. In all my years, I have seen many failed "thru-wired' receptacles in residential repair work, usually because one of the screws gets loose, causing high resistance and over heating of one of the conductors (and damaging the recep), which causes issues with the down-stream loading & devices. That said, I have NEVER encountered a failed pigtail installation (i.e., a failed/over heated wirenut). Never.

[@pld8993]

Also 40+ years experience and I've seen many more failed splices, some with melted wire nuts, than failed through-wired receps. When properly installed, either method is likely to last forever. I'd trust an amateur to tighten a screw before I'd trust them to make a good splice.

[@jasonfoster9118]

I don't do it unless it's a special case, simply because I don't like having extra wire nuts in the box. Either way but I've seen lots of people that can't properly use wire nuts so there's that too. As a side note, I worked on a residential job this week where the electrician had used Ideal push lock wire connectors and I found problems in 3 boxes with loose connections or wires coming out of the connector.

[@BackyardMaine]

I’m with you. I through wire with exception of what I noted in the video. I’ve been an electrician for 38 years with the last 10 years working as an electrical engineer.

[@pld8993]

Been in the trade 40+ years and teaching it for over 20. I only pigtail when I need to, extra work, splice adds a potential point of failure and takes up more box space, etc. Whether pigtailing or using the terminal screws for feedthrough, both methods are equal in integrity and function when done properly. There's a widely held belief/myth, even amongst some electricians, that pigtailing is better electrically and that the NEC doesn't allow using the device for feedthrough current; both false.

[@BackyardMaine]

@@pld8993 Did you watch the video my friend? I pretty much agree with everything you say in this comment..

[@pld8993]

@@BackyardMaine I did and I know, which is why I posted. Most of the others' videos I've seen drank the "pigtails are always better and using the screws is bad" kool-aid. Well done.

[@dougb8207]

I ran into trouble with some of the push-lock connectors, realized I wasn't stripping the insulation far enough back, and the connector was trying to grab the insulation ... came right out.

[@Vinka236]

I like the pigtail method just to be able to test the wire for any problems before they close the walls in new construction. So, later on when I'm about to do the trim, I re-test the wires to see if someone screwed off with my wires. If they did, it's usually the drywall guys.

[@BackyardMaine]

Good thinking.

[@sleazybtd]

Not an electrician, but I use whatever mood strikes me. If I'm feeling lazy or if there's limited space in the box, I just through-wire it. If I'm feeling professional, I pigtail it to make it easier for future-me to replace the outlet.

[@MrJahka]

Thanks for sharing your opinion on all dozen receptacles you’ve ever wired up, non-sparky. I’m sure a hobbyist/DIYer’s opinion is extremely relevant on this topic lol

[@sleazybtd]

@@MrJahka Just out of curiosity, what exactly did YOUR opinion here bring to the discussion?

[@MrJahka]

@@sleazybtd personally, in the industrial/commercial world we pigtail everything because then the fault will be isolated to the device, if it fails. The issue with using the device as a throughput is that if it fails the whole circuit fails

[@SaltMinerOU812]

I like pigtailing with wagos. I know here comes all the know it all's to scorch me but I make it fit in nicely and I just put a quick piece of tape over the lever so no chance of getting caught and popped open. Pre wire all your outlets and snap them in

[@papatutti59]

DYIer here. As a retired automotive mechanic, I got a big basement project next month at my daughters home. I’m looking for how to run electricity down to the basement. Gonna do a complete remodel of that old stinky basement. I decided to pigtail all the outlets. I would rather run them in parallel that in series.

[@BackyardMaine]

Pigtails are not a bad idea but they do take a few minutes longer and consume more box space. Through wire is still in parallel but at the receptacle rather than at a wire connector. I do know what you mean though.. Christmas lights are in a series because the current from each light actually runs through the lamp itself and voltage is dropped at each light bulb. This is why is one burns out you lose part of the string.

[@johnypitman2368]

the difference between parallel and series isn't what you think. You never wire in series in residential wiring. you always wire in parallel. As mentioned by John above you cannot pigtail gfci receptacles unless it is the only one. If as you most often do have other common receptacles downstream and want them gfci protected they have to be wired to the load terminals of gfci to become gfci receptacles. Commercial receptacles are worth the money. Also I personally ONLY use copper wire even for 200amp wires.

[@surferdude642]

I agree with everything you said and as a diy'er I always pigtail. I've made an effort to learn how to correctly twist wires and use wire nuts using 12 gauge wire. It's a good skill to have and makes one more competent. It also looks more professional, IMO.

[@BackyardMaine]

I have a short video on wire nuts as well. Thanks for watching.

[@brandongregori995]

Wago connectors are a game-changer. Definitely recommend checking those out. I never want to go back to wire nuts.

[@gr8dvd]

@@brandongregori995 Did small job for neighbor who had bought those, as an old school DIYer I was hesitant to use wagos in lieu or pigtails. Tho they seemed very good as is, I wrapped electrical tape around the toggles for my peace of mind 😀

[@brandongregori995]

@@gr8dvd The Wago lever nuts? I wired my whole cabin with them and never had one come loose. Just make sure they are genuine Wagos and not some knock-off.

[@brandongregori995]

@@gr8dvd Also the lever can move after you close it, and that's normal. That doesn't mean the clamping mechanism inside has moved. It takes a fair bit of force to actually unclamp it.

[@harveybc]

I live in the country without codes so even not being a licensed electrician I can do my own wiring. Worked my way through college at an industrial plant as an electrician helper so house wiring is easy when compared to the 3 phase stuff I did back then. When I built my workshop I didn't pigtail any of my outlets. My daughter bought one of the buildings you see for rent and turned it into a mini-home. When we wired it we used pigtails. Why? No idea but we did. From what I've seen I much prefer direct wiring. Unless absolutely needed I think pig tails are just an added pain in the posterior. I did have to replace one of the outlets in our house and it had very short wires so I had to pigtail. Unfortunately all my other outlets are the same, (house built about 60 years ago.) What a pain.

[@josepheastman8509]

I think that you covered this really well with 1 big exception. I have seen 15 amp breakers that were supplying power to a 17 or 18 amp shop fan (not enough to trip the 20 AMP breaker) burn up slowly over time.

[@BackyardMaine]

I don't understand. 15 Amp breaker should trip at 17A or 18A not at 20A. You must have a typo..

[@josepheastman8509]

@@BackyardMaine I did have a typo. I meant to say that I have seen a 20 amp breaker supply a 15 AMP receptacle, that was powering a shop fan that drew like 17 amps or something close and the 15 amp receptacle slowly burned up.

[@ranger178]

there is something wrong with that fan if it has a 15 amp plug it should normally draw less than 15 amps most appliances are limited to 13 for safety except motors when starting up of course. so, the outlet is putting out more amps to the actual plug than it is rated for it is rated to pass 20 amps to next device down the line or two devices plugged into two separate plugs. of course, it could just be a junk grade builder 15-amp outlet which frequently loosen up at the contacts and overheat from arcing.@@josepheastman8509

[@ElectricRob]

@@josepheastman8509 I'm surprised that a fan drawing more than 15 amps did not have a 20A cord and 20A cord cap (plug), with the one horizontal blade. Unless it was a faulty fan.

[@jeffcarter1466]

You have a pleasing presentation style that makes for easy to watch, informative videos. I hope you continue sharing your core expertise.

[@BackyardMaine]

Thank you so much! I will... Much appreciated.

[@bernsfindsandmore7636]

I am not an electrician but know how to change a receptacle and I always pigtail. I just became a homeowner and have updated all my outlets. Seems someone was lazy and backtabbed most of them. I went ahead and redid them for peace of mind. I used wagos so it made it so much easier. I just wrapped it in electrical tape for even more peace of mind.

[@surferdude642]

It's not necessarily that someone was lazy, in the construction industry, like others, time is money. It's probably a good move by you to check and change them. You won't find this on 20 amp circuits, because 12 gauge wire won't fit in back stabbing holes.

[@bernsfindsandmore7636]

@@surferdude642 I found a 20 amp in my laundry room that was backstabbed... even I was surprised that they attempted this. I updated that receptacle as well.

[@MrSleepProductionsInc]

#12 fits if you drill out the hole! 😂 Not me but have seen that done in a new neighborhood.

[@pyrotech7210]

​@@MrSleepProductionsIncseems like there is something against code about that... Manufacturer instructions, maybe?

[@roadrunner694]

@@surferdude642 I've seen the back holes rimed,to stab a 12 gage in there.

[@ral819]

Nice video. For a layman, I try to learn what Electricians recommend . Fortunately, I have a friend who works for a power company that I can rely on as well.

[@BackyardMaine]

Thank you!

[@jt2112able]

Electrician for 38 years, I always prefer pigtail method despite the ability to use a wiring device as a terminal point. I never back stab and always remove back stab installs if I service something (residential or industrial) and replace with pigtails. J hook or pressure plate/screw on a commercial device I am good with.

[@jeffw8057]

I always pigtail as long as there is room in the box. I don't like to depend on the outlet for downstream receptacles. And I always use Wagos...definitely the way to go! Never ever backstab.

[@jensschroder8214]

In Germany: the sockets have two contacts for all three lines. These are push-in contacts, the bare cable just needs to be pushed in. This connects from the socket to the next socket and so on. If a branch is required then pigtails are used. There are also 3-way and 5-way push-in clamps. These are also available in 2-way and 8-way versions. There is a trick to remove the cable without cutting it off. The push-in clamps for rigid cables can be assembled very quickly and hold well. There are lever-operated clamps for flexible and rigid cables. In 2-, 3- and 5-way

[@RobertClifton-s3s]

Thank you for your videos. They are well thought out and presented in a clear and concise manner. You are much appreciated.

[@BackyardMaine]

I appreciate that! Thank you.

[@lisasmith1850]

Thank you for this clear explaination. This really confused me on one of my outlets. Thank you for sharing this information.

[@BackyardMaine]

Glad it was helpful! Thanks for watching

[@notcoachfou7841]

I'll tell you why I always pigtail: I just about only wire raised covers in surface mounted boxes. Makes life easier to build cover receptacle with pigtails, and much simpler to replace a receptacle in a double-duplex raised cover.

[@BackyardMaine]

I alway do the same with raised box covers.

[@cybercapri]

Me, personally, prefer the Pigtail Method regardless because should something happen to that one receptacle then it won't affect any other circuit. And if you need to replace that one receptacle then, again you won't affect any other circuit and you're dealing with 3 Pigtailed wires instead of 5 to change it out; and there's no need to remember which is the hot. It also makes getting that receptacle in and out of the box easier due to less wires involved. Pigtails are also easier to replace should the wires become damaged or broken. Ya man, I'm all in on the Pigtail side of this argument/conversation. Hell I can't even play Devils Advocate and think of a single reason in favor of Non Pigtail Use... Cheer's...

[@BackyardMaine]

Thanks for sharing..

[@glasshalffull2930]

Don’t know if this would help much, but when I saw your hint it came to mind that you could use the extra length Romex as an indication that this is the ‘line side’ and the short Romex is the load side.

[@BackyardMaine]

Good idea..

[@johnhogan3810]

You can also use the cut off for your pigtails

[@BackyardMaine]

@@johnhogan3810 I talked about that at the end of the video.

[@TheWarpartyofone]

Line ALWAYS against the stud/ wood, load outside.... works everytime!

[@jpmacoo]

@@cmmartti I almost always hang the boxes on the left side of the stud, since I hammer lefty. Every so often I have to put one on the right, and it's usually obvious then (switch box on the right side of door, etc.)

[@James_Knott]

I'm in the pig tail group, as that's the way I learned it way back in my high school electricity class. Yes, there was electricity back then. 🙂 BTW, the electricity teacher had previously been an industrial electrician.

[@pld8993]

My high school electric shop teacher, it was 1980 and he was probably close to 70 years old, taught us all the tricks for making perfect western union splices and wrap with friction tape. Believe it or not, technically still legal to do.

[@James_Knott]

@@pld8993 Mine wasn't that old, but I'm the one who taught him about superconductors on the first day of grade 9. He was talking about how all conductors had resistance and I then asked what about superconductors? He'd never heard of them, but I had, as I had read about them in an encyclopedia I had at home. So, the next day, I brought that volume to school, to show him.

[@chrisanthony579]

I'm a commercial GC and most architects/engineers prohibit feeding through devises but the boxes are 4x4 with plaster rings so much more space. When I do my own work at home, most times I'm feeding through since I like neater less full boxes.

[@BackyardMaine]

Yes, what I'm talking about here is residential wiring. I spent almost all of my career in industrial electrical construction with my last ten years working as an electrical engineer for Texas Instruments. We always pigtail in industrial work but I don't see the necessity for residential work.

[@johnmiller732]

Having been a GC in several states , seen it both ways. Why the aversion to 4X4 boxes with plaster rings ? Cost ?

[@BackyardMaine]

Cost and also metal boxes and fitting are more prone to short circuits. In the commercial / Industrial setting usually only qualified electricians are installing and servicing electrical equipment so it's less of an issue. @@johnmiller732

[@johncochran8497]

My opinion is that pigtail is more reliable. And for those who say that adding an extra splice inside the box adds an extra failure point and hence makes it less reliable, there's a simple argument. Here are my assumptions. Each electrical connection is a possible failure point. For these circuits, we have 2 types of connections. A screw connection, or a wire nut connection. For this argument, I'll consider both to have the same reliability. Now, we have a daisy chained series of outlets. Let's look at the number of connections for pass through vs pigtail. I'll number each outlet from the source, starting with 1. 1. Passthrough, 1 screw connection. Pigtail, 1 wire nut, 1 screw; Winner - Passthrough with 1 connection vs 2 for Pigtail. 2. Passthrough, 3 screw connections (1 into 1st outlet, 2 from 1st outlet, 1 into 2nd outlet). Pigtail (2 wire nut, 1 screw); Tie Both methods have 3 connections between the source and outlet. 3. Passthrough, 5 screw connections. Pigtail, 1 screw connection, 3 wire nuts; Winner - Pigtail with 4 connections vs 5 connections for passthough. 4th and higher, pigtail's lead increases in few connections vs passthough. As an additional argument, look at the ground wire. There's a damn good reason that a pigtail is required there. It's for both reliability and to prevent losing the ground because of maintenance on an upstream device. If the code requires that special treatment for the ground connection, there's no good reason to not use that level of care for the neutral and hot connections either.

[@BackyardMaine]

All good arguments for pigtails.. I have never had a failure of a screw connection in my 38 years in the trade.. Not one of mine.. Now I have seen loose screw connections which were not properly tightened and I have also seen failed wire nut connections. For me it come down to preference because realistically in my case either method is going to be reliable for decades. Probably why it's not called out by code.

[@matt123231]

The Canadian electrical code requires only the neutral be pig-tailed. The rational is that most contractors use the backstab option for connection for convenience proposes and failure rates during the typical 30yesr service life of the device are relatively high.

[@eudoxus100]

This is only required in multi-branch circuits. In standard residential circuits it isn't required. And it has nothing to do with backstabbing.

[@matt123231]

@@eudoxus100 What isn't required? And what exactly is your definition of a "standard residential circuit?"

[@matt123231]

???

[@DanielLodge-ts2st]

I am a DYI and I use the pigtail method. I like to prewire my outlets and then make the hookups using the pigtail method. I find it easier to wire the plugs beforehand. Also the other reason to do pigtails was if you have aluminum wiring in the house. It is strongly recommended to have 4 inch copper pigtails connecting the outlets AND switches to the aluminum wires making sure you used an anti-oxidizer coating on the pigtail connections due to the different metals being connected. Today they have special connectors for that which is much better.

[@davenag957]

Like you, I have been in the electrical trade a long time. My first code book is from 1978. In those years I've worked in residential, commercial, industrial manufacturing and chemical wet processing environments. I've seen countless failures of all sorts of devices and equipment. Most of those failures are from either poor installation practices or environmental degradation. The equipment is normally not the culprit. Loose and improperly made connections is number one. Moisture, humidity or chemical attack is number two. The listing agencies and code commitees go over the top to guarantee safety. Devices and splicing components are tested way beyond the loads they are rated for. Its all up to the installer to use these products correctly. As soon as I open an electrical box when troubleshooting, the workmanship, or lack of, tells me what I will need to look for throughout the rest of the installation. Wire nuts falling off, loose device screws, loose boxes, loose locknuts, lack of proper grounding, short wires, etc. The human factor part of the installation is the variable, which is THE hardest part of the equation to solve. With all that said, I would recommend pigtailing the devices, as I feel it will hold up the longest in the real world. Most installers/DIYers don't have a torque screwdriver and dont tighten the device screws properly, leading to overheating and ultimate failure. If the screws aren't tight, they will loosen as the device is being pushed into the box. At that point, the downstream load will begin the degradation process leading to failure of the entire circuit, instead of just the one device.

[@BackyardMaine]

Great comment from another experienced electrician. I talk a bit about the quality of the installation in my latest video if you're interested in watching it. It certainly isn't geared toward someone like you with decades electrical experience though.. kzbin.info/www/bejne/iXOoqoOdotinodU

[@pld8993]

Correct, improper installation is almost always the issue. Been in the trade for over 40 years and I can tell you that not having a torque screwdriver (never used one) is not a serious consideration as to whether or not something is sufficiently tight. I've seen many, many, many more bad splices from amateurs than loose screws. Tightening a screw is much simpler than making a good splice. It sounds like you're saying that you don't trust an amateur to tighten a screw sufficiently but you trust that they will make a good pigtail. Really? Faulty logic.

[@davenag957]

I'm just reporting what I see. More loose screws than loose wire nuts

[@davenag957]

2023 nec requires using a proper torque device. I saw a reference to a study of a bunch of experienced electricians somewhere, maybe Ryan Jackson, Sparky Channel or Mike Holt, that proved the need for a torque wrench. They had them torque a bunch of stuff as they have normally done for years and somewhere in the high 60% range of screws were under torqued. Quoting from my failing memory but it was somewhere in that ballpark. I believe that's what prompted the code change. So maybe screw tightening is a serious consideration after all. Someone out there should be able to dig up that study.

[@BackyardMaine]

I just finished the 2023 update a few months ago. Noting new about torque. We need to follow the manufacturers recommendations by code and if you look it up they will always have a torque spec range. For example Leviton is 14-18 inch pounds. As installers we don't not need to use a torque screwdriver by code but we do need to be within the torque range and although I have been seen it, an inspector can spot check torque. For me hand tight on a device is about is within range. @@davenag957

[@fredmauck6934]

I was taught to Pig-tail in my training . My recollection is that there was a code reqyirement that removing a device not interupt the neutrual. Reducing the number of conductors to the device makes for easier device instal lation into the box and reduces the number of screw terminals that may loosen over time as well.

[@BackyardMaine]

I’ve been a licensed electrician for almost four decades and there is no code requirement for pigtails. It’s optional. We pigtail often with industrial work or even in commercial installations but I almost never see pigtails in residential. But like I said in the video there are applications where it makes sense. If you like that method of course stick with it.

[@waxphantomscousin8278]

Nec 300.13 (B)

[@BackyardMaine]

That's just for the neutral on multiwire branch circuits. I mentioned that in the video. 300.13 Mechanical and Electrical Continuity - Conductors (A) General Conductors in raceways shall be continuous between outlets, boxes, devices, and so forth. There shall be no splice or tap within a raceway unless permitted by 300.15, 368.56(A), 376.56, 378.56, 384.56, 386.56, 388.56, or 390.56. (B) Device Removal In multiwire branch circuits, the continuity of a grounded conductor shall not depend on device connections such as lampholders, receptacles, and so forth, where the removal of such devices would interrupt the continuity.@@waxphantomscousin8278

[@starseeddeluxe]

So for all 240 volt, or 3 wire Romex where you're running 2 parallel 120V circuits you have to pigtail the neutral, no exceptions? In that case, 240V outlets in garages cannot use the pass through on neutrals?@@BackyardMaine

[@BackyardMaine]

@@starseeddeluxe A multi-wire branch circuit supplies line to neutral loads only. A 240v circuit supplies line to line loads and often times requires a neutral for line to neutral load on the make equipment. (lights etc.. When you run a three wire to supply 120v receptacles where both hot conductors return on the one neutral thats considered multi-wire and the neutral cannot feed through the device. 300.13 (B) and 210.4

[@larrymabe1146]

Back in the the 70’s while going to college in Atlanta, I worked for a remodeler, and we remodeled a REALLY OLD house that still ran uninsulated wires on glass standoffs ! ! ! And it didn’t even run a ground wire….. That was a chore running new electrical services in that house……..

[@BackyardMaine]

Ahh yes knob and tube wiring. I rewired many homes in VT and MA back in the 80s and 90s with knob and tube. Actually my Moms home was one of them.

[@Justsomeguyus]

This would be expensive for some production electricians, but today I wire the box with Wago's or Ideal lever connectors, pig tailed with stranded wire. No more fighting with three to six stiff wires in trying to get the fixture in the box.

[@whitetiger8652]

I don't understand the use of stranded wire. My opinion is the stiff wires would be a better connection. Just my opinion. Thanks.

[@Justsomeguyus]

@@whitetiger8652 Stranded is much more flexible and it actually is a bit better at carrying current. In some situations it can be a bit more trouble to get a good connection, but with the Wagos it just doesn't seem to be an issue.

[@whitetiger8652]

@@Justsomeguyus Thank you.

[@johnjohn-ne8fw]

Always providing good insight. Thx👍

[@BackyardMaine]

Thank you my friend..

[@foogod4237]

I used to be on the side of always doing through-wiring whenever I could, mainly because IMHO wire nuts should always be avoided whenever possible, just on principle. However, more recently I've come to tend more towards using pigtails with WAGO-221s instead, as it actually makes it much easier to install/change/etc (you can attach the pigtails to the receptacle while it's out of the box, then just plug the wires into the WAGOs, flip them closed, and button everything up. No trying to mess with tightening screw terminals in awkward positions with the device hanging out of the wall, etc.). And the WAGOs eliminate all the major issues that wire nuts have, so I actually don't mind using them.

[@pld8993]

What exactly are the "major issues that wire nuts have?"

[@foogod4237]

@@pld8993 Well, let's see, where to start... Wire nuts can be fine, _if they're done correctly,_ but a lot of the issues fall into the category of "it's just too easy to do them wrong, often without even knowing, and if you do it's a fire hazard." If you don't twist it enough (more than most people think you should), it's a fire hazard. If you twist the wires together yourself first, and do it the wrong way, it's a fire hazard. If you don't know and use the right color nut for your wires, it's a fire hazard. If you twist too many wires together, it's a fire hazard. If you don't twist enough wires together, it might be a fire hazard, too. If you try to connect solid and stranded wire together and don't do it exactly the right way, being very careful, and probably having to do it a second time anyway, it's a fire hazard. If you undo a wire nut connection and then try to twist the wires back together without cutting off the old mangled wire ends, and stripping fresh new ones, it's probably going to be a fire hazard. If one of the wires slips while you're twisting it, it's a fire hazard. Even if you do a pull-test after you're done, it doesn't always guarantee it can't come undone later, and you can't see inside to tell whether everything is actually making good contact or not. The number of wire nuts I've come across in prior work which were done wrong, often barely making a connection (or where the connection is broken entirely) is actually more than the number I've seen done right, I think. Add to this that they're just plain bulky, which makes cramming a bunch of them into a box just that much more likely to pinch something the wrong way, or just not be able to get things closed at all, and they're an absolute pain to use on short wires, which is so often the case when dealing with existing installs, and I'm really just so glad we actually have several better options these days.

[@pld8993]

@@foogod4237 So no actual data that wire nuts have "major issues," just a bunch of what if scenarios. Hardly an argument against wire nuts and obviously just a pitch for wagos. If you were an actual electrician you'd understand how ridiculous your very weak position is.

[@starseeddeluxe]

Thank you for explaining, I read your whole summary about wire nuts. You raised a lot of really good points. Although with Wagos, aren't those only for stranded wire? With solid wire, you're basically only getting a tiny contact patch? I didn't even know they were rated for solid Romex? Are are you only using stranded wire? On the commercial sites, we only use Wagos, never wire nuts, in exposed control panels. Because the Wagos add a really nice commercial look to the inside of panels where there are exposed wires. I rarely use Wagos for 120 volt circuits except when I have more than 3 wires, and all the wires are stranded.@@foogod4237

[@Tom-og7fi]

Wago connections are not near as solid as wirenuts. That is a fact.

[@firemanf29]

Pigtails are the only way to go. I’ve seen the metal clip in a receptacle burn through over time.

[@BackyardMaine]

In 38 years I have never seen that happen.

[@chrisloesch1870]

Yep! Saw one last week. Should have been pigtailed and it was through wired and the whole outlet melted. No bueno

[@pld8993]

@@chrisloesch1870 What you witnessed was a melted receptacle, you didn't witness a failure of the link between the terminals. This effect was most likely from a loose connection that was arcing, which causes extreme heat, and extremely unlikely that the metal link between the terminal screws magically failed. That link is rated fro 20 amps on a 15 amp receptacle and is tested to 150% of its rating (30 amps). They don't burn through over time. It doesn't happen that way.

[@roadrunner694]

If the device has power going through it, it seems to me it does not matter if you pigtail or through, the device does not know the difference, if the metal tab is going to burn and melt,it will do it anyway.

[@pld8993]

@@roadrunner694 Yes, except that the metal tab is not going to burn and melt.

[@jeffwolf8018]

I'm not an electrician but I do plenty of electrical work and I almost always use pigtails to me it just makes sense

[@BackyardMaine]

You certainly can do that if you prefer.

[@johnkulpowich5260]

My favorite part part of the code book. Fine print notes

[@GreasyReecey]

Daisy chain plugs, its about speed and making money. Just do it solid and correct and there is no issue. However, never use back stabs because the amount of contact between the tabs and the wire is very minimal for current to pass through. Also connections become weaker over time with old tabs which is dangerous.

[@ranger178]

I like to use the commercial grade with the straight in screw down terminals when having more than two wires because it adds another wire to an already overcrowded box by putting a pigtail in and makes it hard if you are trying to put 4 wires in a wire nut to make the pigtail.

[@HCkev]

I don't pigtail unless necessary(more than 2 conductors). The more junctions you have, the more potential failure points you have. Beside the screws on a receptacle are a nice, solid connection. Moreover, if you need to undo the connection, you can easily remove a hook from a receptacle and put it back the way it was; with wire nuts, the wires are twisted, and while you may straighten them up and re-twist them, you can only do it a few times before the conductor becomes brittle, which will require you to cut, re-strip and re-twist. Over time, that means the wires are getting shorter and shorter. Oh, and wire nuts also take a lot of room, which sometimes make putting the receptacle back into place a challenge (although it's more a problem for switches, things like dimmers and smart light switches tend to be bulky and barely fit with wire nuts behind)

[@BackyardMaine]

I completely agree.

[@pibbles-a-plenty1105]

"The more junctions you have, the more potential failure points you have" Yep, that's right. Through wiring adds MORE junctions.

[@HCkev]

@@pibbles-a-plenty1105 that's the opposite actually. Using the receptacle is one junction, both wires goes straight to the receptacle. With a pigtail, then you've got the wire nut AND the connection to the receptacle.

[@BackyardMaine]

That's correct which is why I said a properly wired device. If done right you will never have an issue with either method. For example I wire my own home 25 years ago. All through wired and yes we use a couple of windows AC units in the summer. I have yet to have a sing connection problem in the house. @@pibbles-a-plenty1105

[@drewlinton3472]

@@HCkev I think what he's saying is for a receptacle farther down the chain, the current travels through 1 junction per box in a pigtailed scenario, where using the receptacle as a pass through turns that into 2 junctions (1 in and 1 out) per device (meaning 2 duplex outlets in a double gang box=4 junctions). I use both methods depending on the application, but eliminating junctions was precisely the reason I pigtailed the fourplex boxes above my workbench.

[@MyClutteredGarage]

I’m binging your channel on this overcast Sunday, John! 😄❤️

[@BackyardMaine]

You're the best Ed. I have another one going up tomorrow. Friday.

[@OrangeismyNewGreen]

Great tips John, I need to check a couple of outlets. 🙂🙋🏼‍♂️👍🏻

[@BackyardMaine]

Thanks Luc. Kind of a new direction for the channel due to the response I’ve been getting from my # shorts videos. Thanks for supporting the channel my friend.

[@wretchedegg6336]

I believe that you should pigtails, if there is enough space. That way you’re not eating away at the line it self when making corrections or repairs. That pigtail can always be extended. If there isn’t enough space for a pigtail, just measure twice and cut once and you’re good to go

[@Bruce2518]

I’m in the pigtail category. Always parallel your receptacles. Do it the other way and you get a voltage drop when you have multiple devices going at the same time. Like turning on the vacuum and the lamp dems. It’s a higher quality install.

[@pld8993]

All receptacles in a circuit are paralleled, none are wired in series.

[@ferencszabo3504]

As being electrician myself looking at the video i was thinking I'll stab myself in the eye seeing another wiring video, but otherwise great content! Cheers!

[@BackyardMaine]

I feel the same way my friend. Love making them but don’t like watching them. Been an electrician for 38 years.

[@joejoe6949]

THAT TIP IS OLD SCHOOL. IM BEEN DOING FROM THE START 24 YEARS AGO.

[@BackyardMaine]

I'm old school been an electrician for 40 years.

[@seanthumper]

No black and white answer? On the internet? Nice change of pace, thanks!

[@Gary-ts6dh]

3:27 - The length of wire in this image is a violation: see NEC 300.14 - Length of Free Conductors at Outlets, Junctions, and Switch Points. It says that the free conductor length must be at least 3" past the opening or 6" past the point where the wire exits the raceway or cable into the box. 4:15 - I hate to even attempt to add up all the time I could have saved on trim-outs over the years by applying this tip. Great one!

[@BackyardMaine]

Both requirements are met with this installation. The wire is at least 6 inches past the box entrance and at least 3 inches outside the box. I made a video covering cable length. Nice try though.

[@Ephesians-ts8ze]

Another situation where pig-tailing is a must is in houses built in the 70’s with aluminum wiring (if the house hasn’t burned down yet). Those screw terminations are sure to get loose over time with the expanding and contracting of the aluminum under the terminals especially if there’s significant load on the circuit.

[@roxyviews7644]

Single plug circuits like microwave or fridge are supposed to match amperage. I did wire through method years ago. After about 25 year I had a trouble shoot call on a longtime client. Turns out the screws got loose, intermittent issue solved. Pigtails pretwisted with lineman's is the way to go imo.

[@vince6829]

Thank you for sharing your knowledge.

[@BackyardMaine]

My pleasure! Thanks so much for your comment.

[@C1Ksdafafdsa980ufsd]

Most of the failed multi-conductor outlets I've encountered were all back-stabbed. So, if I can screw in the wires, I'll do it, but use a pigtail if there are so many wires that one must both screw in and backstab.

[@HCkev]

Yeah, I don't pigtail when there are 2 conductors, but if there are 3 or more I will pigtail. I don't like relying on backstab either.

[@anthonyesposito7]

I'm a group one person, always pigtail!! Nice video!!

[@BackyardMaine]

Awesome! Thank you!

[@elfnetdesigns702]

Pigtailing is good for rental property's because between renters of a property you likely will have to replace outlets switches, etc. and pigtailing makes this replacement quicker for anyone working behind you like a maintenance person because it is literally a direct replacement by untying the leads and removing the old outlet and tying in a new pre wired outlet and closing the box up. Prewired meaning you add the pigtails before you get on the jobsite. I have a whole box full of switches and outlets prewired just for this purpose so I am in and out of a tenants space as fast as possible with little footprint.

[@dustinmcfarland2570]

I always try to avoid pulling 3 wires to a receptacle box. For no other reason then the extra time it takes to make them up. That said I also won't hesitate to add that third 12/2 if I'm pulling home runs and it's the closest box to the panel on that circuit. Besides 3rd wire or short wires there is no argument for over handling a receptacle box. Pigtails for the sake of Pigtails is crazy talk my old journeyman would roll over in the grave

[@BackyardMaine]

I completely agree. Wire is expensive so I will add three to a box but I try to avoid it as well. Pigtails when needed only.

[@paulmaxwell8851]

I hate pigtails. They just add more fill to a box and make it more difficult to stuff back in. But here in British Columbia, Canada the inspectors expect pigtails, so that's what we do.

[@icanreadthebible7561]

Pigtail. Think about it: what if there was no device at this box, as in only a junction box with a blank cover? BTW: If I can loop the romex in and out of a box, without cutting it, I'll sometimes use a THIRD option: peel off the outer jacket, shave the insulation off, make a loop in the uncut conductors and hook them around the receptacle screws. No break in the conductors, no chance of failure downstream. And the wires are long enough in case I want to pigtail later. Takes longer, but hey, it's my house, my work, so...

[@troubleshooter1975]

LOL - I found your post only AFTER I just posted the same thing above! I am inquiring if the code addresses this method at all... [I mean aside from the section addressing connection methods and degrees of wrap on a screw...] I don't remember if I found anything specific on this practice.

[@PongoXBongo]

I use pigtails to avoid trimming back the feed wires. With the pigtails, I can swap devices with fresh-cut connections every time, no touching of the feeds needed. I also reduce box clutter by using 3- and 5-way WAGOs instead of giant wire nuts.

[@BackyardMaine]

I guess that makes sense if you're changing your devices often. I figure a change is needed about every 30 years or so if the original installation was done right.

[@PongoXBongo]

@@BackyardMaineFair point. I'm just a homeowner, not a pro doing jobs for others. But, if I'm going to touch something, I will try and future-proof it while I'm at it. New smart outlet? New pigtails that weren't there before.

[@fc-pl9kr]

over time I've seen a lot more receptacles fail than wire connectors fail and had to diagnose the failure. thus i pigtail for the most part.

[@BackyardMaine]

Yes, it's not common to find a wire nut failure but I will say the only failures Ive seen on through wired receptacles was either back stab connections or simple poor installation of the side wire terminals. For example in one home they noticed flickering and a warm receptacle in the bathroom. I found loose connections and when I checked the other near by receptacles that were fine they also had loose connections. I ended up spending several hours tightening all the connections in the house..

[@uniquegiftpens]

As an electrician, I have replaced many "fed through" outlets that have failed and scorched the wall, and in many cases, on holidays and after hours. Never feed through an outlet where a refrigerator or air conditioner may be plugged in down line. An outlet that is "fed through" does not meet the NEC requirement of a "line to line connection", rather it is a line to device to line connection. I have a lifetime of electrical experience and very much enjoy your concise and practical advice.

[@BackyardMaine]

Thanks you.. I have been an electrician for 38 years myself. I think if you look at the code you'll find that the only requirement for pigtails is on the neutral for multiwire branch circuits (two hot one neutral). I believe is 300.13 (B)..

[@pld8993]

Please share the code reference for this supposed "line to line connection" rule.

[@pld8993]

I've seen many splices go bad and melt wire nuts. That does not in any way prove that splicing is inherently bad. You're using faulty logic and assumptions.

[@Icehso140]

Pigtails for me...but I have to follow the specs on big jobs. It's easier for maintenance to replace a device. Also, it's easier to push in a device/receptacle if it only has 3 wires on it vs 5. Plus, we're pulling stranded and pigtail a solid for the device connection, and the box is a 4 square with a plaster ring.

[@nukiepoo]

We use the new Leviton receptacles that have the Wago-like "Lever-Nut" connections. Since they accept stranded wire as do Wago LeverNuts. So, we prefab said receptacles with stranded THHN pigtails and a triple port LeverNuts. This makes trim out fast and clean. No more (5) 12AWG solid conductors coming off the back of small appliances outlets which are a PIA to fold and push into the box AND have the device face in the same plane as the cover plates. And, troubleshooting is lot easier than dealing with wirenuts twisted into oblivion by a battery drill with a wirenut driver

[@roberte.6892]

this is the exact video i needed. liked and subscribed!

[@BackyardMaine]

Glad it was helpful for you.. Welcome to the channel!

[@tactisquatch]

Fantastic video. Exactly what I was looking for to trouble shoot in my old house I just got.

[@BackyardMaine]

Awesome.. Thank you

[@mothman-jz8ug]

Pigtails are good if you have left the caveman era and started using Wago's to make the pigtails, AND if doing a larger job and will be doing several receptacles. In a couple minutes time, the pigtails can be attached to the devices while you sit on your built-in cushioning device and have some coffee. Then, when the actual installs take place, just take care of the in/out wiring. Simply add the pigtail to the appropriate connectors in turn. On to the next... If using metal boxes, the pigtails for the receptacle and box can be joined in a 5 space Wago ahead of time as well. Then just connect to the box and insert the line side/downstream EGC conductors.

[@HIFINatic]

You really got some nice clean informative videos. Thank you very much I subscribed and liked.

[@BackyardMaine]

Awesome, thank you! Much appreciated

[@craig156]

If you have aluminum wiring like I do I think you have to pigtail because getting hard to find CO/ALR outlets and switches plus the newer dimmers etc are wired with copper wires already.

[@kirin347]

Also have to pigtail at least the black on a half switched duplex. I know noone does it any more, but it IS why the busbar is exposed and has that thin tab.

[@philipdamask2279]

Pig tailing costs more because of the connectors, but pigtailing does allow downstreem outlets to remain on when one outlet goes out. It is also easier to find the bad outlet.

[@MrMedicals12]

In commercial work we pigtail everything because we have three phases on one neutral wire (multiwire circuit). If you lose a neutral the voltage could jump to 240 volts. I would like for you to cover the multiwire circuit of a NM-B 12/3 cable feeding receptacles in a home. .

[@BackyardMaine]

I have that on my video list. I will cover that sometime soon. Thanks.

[@_Lazare]

Well spoken Question, how come electrical boxes haven't increased in size ?

[@BackyardMaine]

You can buy different depth electrical boxes to allow for more wire and device fill. I always buy deep boxes unless a specific application requires a shallow box. The code has a whole section on box fill. I may make a video cover that at some point..

[@Sparky-ww5re]

I only use pigtails in one of two situations. Where I have more than two cables entering the box, so I can use the screw terminals instead of backstabbing the third set of conductors since backstab although permitted for 14awg solid copper wire and 15 amp circuits tends to be problematic. Or to comply with NEC 300.13 (B) Device removal. In multiwire branch circuits the continuity of a grounded conductor shall not depend on device connections such as receptacles, lampholders and so forth, where the removal of such devices would interrupt continuity. I don't like having extra wirenuts and wire in the box if it's not necessary. But it does make replacement easier, that's a plus.

[@BackyardMaine]

Exactly.. Well said. I often get comments stating the code requires the neutral to be continuous so it has to be pigtailed and not run through the device and I have to remind them that this applies to multi-wire branch circuits.

[@jheiny1231]

Pig tail all the time. The neutral your disconnecting may have a load on it that is used on another hot wire but same nuetral being shared. Nuetral carries the amperage. And will kill u. Amperage is more deadly than voltage. Atleast in a house. So just pigtail and never disconnect the Nuetral splice unless the panel is shut down or its brand new wiring installed by yourself. This is the main reasoning for the pigtail being the correct way. I get a kick out of people making electrical videos and posting it to KZbin not knowing the dangers they can cause to people from not knowing the dangers that present in telling there audience what they can do

[@BackyardMaine]

@@jheiny1231 Im a master with 38 years of experience. lol. You however are missing some very important facts and you may actually want to brush up on the code. What you are talking about here are called multi-wire branch circuits (I'll help you out with the terminology) these of course have two hot wires on a spit phase system returning on one neutral. There are several additional requirements for these circuits listed in 210.4 (A-D). Another requirement is the ungrounded (neutral) wire cannot tie through the device so it has to be pigtailed. See 300.13 (B). This is why I stated in the video that pigtails are required on multi-wire branch circuits. So now you learned something new and your comment was not a complete waste of energy.

[@jheiny1231]

@@BackyardMaine your talking what the code wants someone to do. I'm talking about the real world. Disconnecting nuetrals is deadly. And your audience is obviously people looking up videos trying to do something they don't know how to do or they wouldn't be watching your videos. There's no safety at the panel when you become part of the path with the nuetral. Sounds like you never experienced getting caught on a nuetral that the path back to home was disconnected

[@BackyardMaine]

@@jheiny1231 I have worked in the real world my whole career. I know that people will do their own electrical work so I provide information / education to help them do it right. I see a lot of channels showing people good info but then they make a couple of pretty big mistakes because they are not licensed pros and they don't know what they're doing is a mistake. Anything thing that I always taught and stress in many of my videos is to always turn off the power before working on electrical devices. But you do bring up a good point so I guess I'm make a video on multiword branch circuits and the dangers of a neural on old systems when the breakers were not required to be on the same lever or a two pole breaker.

[@bobmcgehee1749]

I always pigtail GFI, unless there’s more than one outlet in a wet area.