SIG X-Five Legion vs. Walther Q5 Match SF

[@willwilliam217]

I purchased the x5 legion shortly after it came out and ordered a romeo 1 pro. The optic did not arrive for three or four months so I got to use the dawson precision adjustable rear sight which was great. I used for target range time and it was very enjoyable and fairly accurate. Installed the optic and my accuracy decreased (1st and only optic that I own) in bullseye shooting. 18 months later purchased a cz shadow 2, for me the cz is far more accurate with brass lok grips. Never had a opportunity to shoot a Walther.

[@jeffreylocke8808]

The Walther metal frame SF would be my pick. Q5 is going home with me someday. And Walther has a deep optical cut to keep the red dot low to co witness iron sights.

[@ronmartblog]

I sat in your shoes and finally bought it because of the money back guarantee It’s never leaving my collection- I love it

[@katrinagwen]

Can you elaborate on your logic behind picking Q5's steel frame?

[@dukaschmichmol863]

bought me a Q5 black ribbon today, i love it

[@jamesdelong6401]

Yeap! I know I'd like to add a Walther ppq m2 Q4 sf

[@saabaru007]

I've shot both pistols. I really thought I was going to like the X-Five Legion better. Turns out, I liked the Q5 Match SF better. The Q5 felt better in my hands and when shooting it, despite the heavier trigger pull. The only drawback to the Q5 is the price difference compared to the cheaper X-Five Legion.

[@sunnantariq723]

I found the Q5 SF Match for $1100

[@BERETTA9mmUSA]

These Pistols both look like Great Shooters! That said, I sold mine to help pay for my Custom 1911 Addiction, I think is was a Wilson Combat & a Les Baer if my memory is correct. Anyway, I enjoyed the Video! Stay safe my friend. 🤠👮🏻‍♂️🇺🇸👍👋👻. B9USA Sr.

[@JustinOpinionChannel]

Yeah, that's an expensive addiction you've got there!

[@cmonsterz]

Fun video, JustinOpinion! Mix in the Beretta 92x competition for tri star battle of the titans!

[@hungrylikeawolf6738]

Great content and thanks again for another great comparison.

[@walkermitchell4444]

Hello 👋

[@ChrisB-zz8dh]

Love all Sigs and the Walther steel frame is on my bucket list!

[@Boniswahn]

My choose was the Walther Q5. Felt better in the hands with more accuracy. In Germany the Sig X5 is much more expensive. I bought the Walther half price compare to Sig ...

[@thelastsignature]

Amazing video thank you as always!

[@hondasaurusrex6998]

Well done! Perfect for a Friday.

[@buncha5651]

Great video except open sights on one red dot on the other ? Always enjoy your videos. Would like to see you review the Canik SFX Rival Darkside.

[@joquin4618]

Nice 👍! For the algorithm Keep up the good work

[@SwissMovement]

Ahh, the song of my people, my favorite at the end!

[@walkermitchell4444]

Alex 😎👋

[@craigjohnson6141]

Great review. I would have a difficult time choosing one over the other. Both seem to be awesome pistols.

[@walkermitchell4444]

Craig 😎👋

[@richardoliver1468]

Thank you for another great video. I feel that the issue you were experiencing with shooting was a result of shooting iron sight then going red dot and back to iron sight. that might have caused some muscle memory challenges for your eyes.

[@In_con_ceivable]

I love Walther pistols, haven’t held the Q5 but I’m sure it’s just as heavy as the Legion Five, which Ive held and man is it a heavy and big gun. ( for my little hands 😂 any way)

[@chemicalspore]

I was lucky to get the Walther, these things were flying off the shelves.

[@jamesdelong6401]

😎🤘. Song of my people sounding good

[@jmnasman]

I have several PPQ's, but the Walther Q5 SF is on my bucket list. 😎

[@walkermitchell4444]

Jonathan 😎👋

[@allysonhanks9159]

Hi Jonathan how are you doing😊

[@work7510]

What magazine is that your using for the ppq m5?

[@talkingrock7011]

Happy Father’s Day , my choice was the Legion and I also built one from one of the caliber x- change kits yep I like my Sig’s

[@ImOldGregg]

I chose the cz tso

[@johndeere1951a]

Come on. "If you could have only one, Which would it be?" Life is short. Make a commitment. Be strong. One must feel better to you . Thank you for your presentations 🎯💥👀🗽⚖️🇺🇲☮️

[@josefsmith9919]

The Walther has always felt better in my hand. I’m an odd duck liking Beretta 92 series over any Glock ever. Also, what’s that shirt brand/manufacturer?

[@ronmartblog]

I own and really love both too. The X5 Legion is a delight when running fast - especially during mag changes - so I love it for competition. While it does have more muzzle rise than a Glock, it returns to zero very well - exactly like the QF (on both points). The Q5 is sexy and just oozes quality, so it’s both a great shooter and safe Queen. It’s also a better target gun and better at making big holes with a single mag. However it’s weakness is the stupid safety blade that locks up if you don’t land on it just right (worse than any other safety blade trigger on the market IMHO). It also has some sloppy first pul travel, but it makes up for it with a brilliant reset and amazingly accurate barrel. The Q5 is the wow gun, but the X5 is the race gun that is also fun for infinite customization.

[@walkermitchell4444]

Ron 😎👋

[@stenmoller5700]

Get the Expert and be happy ever after.

[@russell5414]

If its the Q5 Match Black Ribbon version it comes with the Walther Dynamic Performance Trigger, a much better trigger.

[@johndeere1951a]

Walther c 1886 SIG Sauer c 1853 My vote? WALTHER 🏆✌️

[@hopewilliams6705]

I wish Walther would have released the DDX !

[@ronmartblog]

The PDP Pro SD is as close as we are likely to see so you Parker comp on that and be effectively close - it’s just unfortunate it’s not a steel frame

[@MrCcfly]

which one for paper targets ? all these new ones are for active competitions ,and not for target points at 25

[@WilliamTaylor-b3t]

I own both their both excellent.. the Walther cost more than the Sig without the red dot…

[@JeepCherokeeful]

Excellent!

[@62dobie]

I'm fine with either.

[@nitemare5030]

Ahhhh it’s still my favorite song. Song of the people 😁

[@Bill-jv5eg]

I love the Sig! ……but the other looks great also

[@Sams911]

I guess I'm old school... have many great pistols from all the great brands.... Wilson, Stocatto, Walther, HK, Sig, Les Bear, CZ, and more... But as a hobbyist / collector and gun history buff, I have NO desire to get a red dot mounted on any of my fine pistols... aesthetically it bothers me, but frankly it also feels like cheating.. That said, maybe I'll get one done just incase I need the accuracy some day. Thanks for the great content, I think you meet my stringent criteria for a subscribe!

[@TineEdong]

I understand what you mean, I can use drumming as a comparison. I was always against the use of triggers over mics because you don’t have to hit the head as hard to make the same sound. You literally hit tap the trigger on the head to make a loud bang from the speakers. So it is like cheating, but to get 300+ beats a minute to sound good from a mic is difficult and sounds like a big blob. Don’t consider it cheating, it’s like an addition or evolution to shooting! Cheers!

[@OrionCorsari]

Zzzzz zzzzz zzzzzz wake me up when SIG wakes up and makes an all steel version

[@steemerxaxon1643]

I would 100% PICK THE WALTHER Q 5 MATCH

[@giannimoscotto7386]

Nice pistolon😉

[@walkermitchell4444]

Hello 👋

[@willwilliam217]

Got a message to text you, you have something special for me. I think the response from you may be a scam and the something special may be a virus?

[@walkermitchell4444]

Will 😎👋

[@jonnytestnj2668]

The x5 legion is obviously the superior pistol. The q5 has had much less use and marginal success in uspsa

[@seandurns110]

Walther

[@karapusat4002]

🔫S🙋🏿‍♂️G🔫

[@giannimoscotto7386]

Ani more aim lok video....goodmorning

[@philliplatham4256]

👍🏻👍🏻🇺🇸🇺🇸☕️☕️🛎💯

[@allysonhanks9159]

Hi how are you doing😊

[@philliplatham4256]

@@allysonhanks9159 👍🏻👍🏻

[@allysonhanks9159]

@@philliplatham4256 Okay 😊

[@philliplatham4256]

Yes I am just enjoying life mine can’t get any better

[@hawghawg381]

Canik tp9sfx is better