Sindh, Partition and the Creation of Pakistan - Jami Chandio - Writer/Scholar -

[@jamichqndio]

Thanks dear Shehzad for making it happen; I thoroughly enjoyed discussion with you on many pertinent themes of history and politics 🌺🌷🙏

[@ThePakistanExperience]

Thank you sir 🙌

[@Mr-NO-BODY24]

Great jeay sindhudesh

[@faheym1]

Really enjoyed the conversation

[@UmairShah-nx5kd]

​@@Mr-NO-BODY24 from Karachi 🇵🇰❤

[@VikramMehta1984]

Good conversation as usual and to hear about different ideas. But Sorry to say that the honored guest really is trying to twist history (example as Shehzad challenged - on Pakistan formation on ground ideas) and international references around Federal states (Ethiopia, Nigeria and many others have civil wars. Quebec and Scots still have strong independence movements with over 40% support). Sind assembly might have had different expectations when joining but need to acknowledge the reality, otherwise his point of view doesn’t carry real weight.

[@mugdhanaik4427]

In India siddhi is one recognised language.. i seen Juhele Lal Mandir and all.They built too many education institutions and part of growth story. End of the story Panjab Siddh, Gujarat Maratha is in national anthem..

[@HasnainAbbasi2006]

@@mugdhanaik4427 It's not Siddhi, it's "Sindhi" & so as "Sindh" not Siddh

[@RohitSharma-oh8qm]

​@@HasnainAbbasi2006 spelling mistake h

[@syedshakir6537]

Thank you Shezad for introducing us to this towering intellectual. Sir Jamin you truly represent the Sufi soul of Sindh in approaching and bisecting the multiple problem facing Pakistan. No name calling, no "Gali Galoch" , sensible discussion.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@ahmedqureshi7334]

Sir Jami chandio is one of the most sane voice in Pakistan. He has high level of intellect. He has strong roots with his land. Personalities like him are assets for our country. Jiye sindh, jiye Pakistan

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@Firmino_11]

I watch the show for years now and one of the integral reason for it is your language. The sheer lack of filler words and use of precise words in all the different languages that guests and yourself use, is simply a blessing. Please continue doing the great show and more more followers to you.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️🙌

[@shames-ulhaq4296]

ایسی خوبصورت، نرم و نازک اور شگفتہ اردو بولنے والے ذہین، دانشور اور وجیہ انسان سے ملاقات کروانے کا بے حد شکریہ۔ افسوس کہ جس ہائی کورٹ کے وکیل سے جامی چانڈیو صاحب نے ساہیوال کے تاریخی مقامات کا پوچھا، وہ ساہیوال کو نہیں جانتا تھا، الحمداللہ ساہیوال میں ہزار سے زیادہ سکھ کمیونٹی رہائش پذیر ہے اور کافی حضرات روایتی پگڑی اور داڑھی میں نظر آتے ہیں، ساہیوال کے ایک جانے مانے سکھ حکیم کے پاس جانا ہوا تو انہوں نے گُرمکھی میں نسخہ لکھ کے دیا جو ان کے ماتحت نے تیار کر کے دیا، ساہیوال کے عین وسط میں ایک تاریخی اور خوبصورت گُرودوارہ ہے، افسوس کے ساتھ جسے مسجد میں تبدیل کر دیا گیا ہے

[@DeathadharmjeeBhoordanjee]

Shamash al haq kiyaa panjab mea ravadaree bhaichara hea insaniyet hea ???? Nahee hea leakin AAP TO HEA CHALO KUCHH ACHHA BOLA

[@shames-ulhaq4296]

@ hosla afzaai ka shukriya. I was only telling the truth as it is, thank you for your beautiful words ❤️

[@2003Kamber]

I never come a cross of such a clarity of thoughts which Jami Chandio has. Please invite him again to explore more about the land of Sindh. He is such a gem. Thanks Shazad you are doing a great job. Keep continue From London

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@IntegratedServicesExcellence]

Jami is one of rare genuine scholar of country who puts his arguments based on historical references and evidence, logic , rationale and scientific approach. Cake on ice is his humility and tolerance during dialogue for others

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@Abdullah-uv9nk]

I’m the son of Muhajirs and I agree with him on a lot of things. He talks about bridging gaps and finding solutions to the issues of Sindh, I hope he is promoted more so we can see some peace in the province.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@atulmalhotra2303]

Don't hold your breath for it. Intellect and political power never go together.

[@toxic5445]

Ye son of muhajar kia hota h puri dunya k mohajron ki o0wlad h kya Tu ? 🤣

[@Abdullah-uv9nk]

@@atulmalhotra2303yeah I’m skeptical but we need more people like him

[@kbsaand1]

After more than 70 Years why you are still Muhajir?

[@sajidakhanum933]

Please bring Romaisa Chandio to this podcast. Thank you again after Saif Sir Jami Chandio is here to make us understand Sindh and sindhi.

[@akshaysingh1538]

As said, in India as well, almost all Hindus of Punjab worship Guru Nanak dev ji. And of course Guru Nanak dev ji is respected all cross India, especially North of India. P.S. A great intellectual discussion. And such a pleasure to listen to Mr. Jami's beautiful Urdu. Love from India.

[@randomlifein3d]

Urdu invaders ke creation Hai .... When I also didn't know being victim of glorification of our public's murderers and rapists I loved it ... But when history came out in this era of easy information access... Just felt so guilty and thought of all those people who died and our prime men, Gurus and others who fought for the survival of our civilization... Asking for forgiveness every day for stupidity.... It's our responsibility to know the right info ...

[@uddhevhm919]

What the f*** ? Who told you all hindus worship Nanak ? Except few hindus specifically migrants from Pakistan punjab no Hindu worship Nanak. People in East, South don't even know who Nanak is !

[@rohand04]

Not just Hindu.. we Christian Buddhists and Parsi all make sure they respect guru nanak ji.. and I still have not met a single Muslim too who disrespect him

[@chevellesome]

Wow man!! Shahzad..today, the way you asked and formed your questions is giving me chills in the spine!!

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@ZebuJaan]

This way TPE's actual spirit of being the voice of whole Pakistan reveals. I hope you'll go for other best minds from Sindh, Balochistan and KP onwards. Wish you luck ❤

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@aroonkumar1445]

Jami is speaking on the behalf of Sindhi nation❤ the outsiders and those who are unable to digest his words should keep it in mind.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@abdulmajidbadini5871]

Very nice intellectual informative program. I am a Baloch American from Balochistan in Pakistan

[@abdulmajidbadini5871]

What you think about chandio😮tribe ethnicity TO Baloch nation, and Balochi language..?

[@abdulmajidbadini5871]

Balochs of sind posting their language cultural and national identity in sindh.what you think about it..?50%population are Balochs in Sindh. By land and country they are sindhi but historical by nationality they are Balochs. What you think about it?

[@neerajkhanna900]

Islam is a FEUL of DICTATORSHIP FEUDALISM and it's a DISEASE which has taken shape of PANDAMIC in 77 years of KANGALADESH KANJARKHANA HEERA MANDI COMEDY CIRCUS 🎪 named Pakistan .

[@zahoorgabole6727]

Just completed watching every single second of this podcast. Why such great minds are not invited on TV shows!!!!? Hates off to you for doing such a marvelous job of enlightening minds which are unaware of Sindh and it's culture. Love ♥️😘

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@deevaan]

You could not have a better ambassador of Sindh than Jami Chandio. You have recently spoken about a "reawakening" of your Sindhi identity. The best way to help you in this journey will be if you commit to learn/understand one verse of Shah Latif every month. Overtime, you will start to gain your own perspective and can reclaim what is innately yours. BTW Jami Chandio is also an authority on Shah Latif. After Saif Samejo, listening to Jami Chandio has been a treat. Best wishes to you in your journey.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@akramshaikh9419]

We should clearly say that Sindh assembly passed resolution in the favor of one-unit A few opposed but they were ignored.

[@akramshaikh9419]

Overall interview is good for beginners.

[@akramshaikh9419]

PPP has been a very popular party in Sindh since its inception, whether, we like or dislike.

[@akramshaikh9419]

Shah Latif award is rightly awarded to Jami. It is not support to government

[@wajahatahmed7935]

Excellent talk by Jami shaib. Bring Comrade Masroor Shah on this podcast. He is an emerging intellectual and leader of Sindh.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@sabaanvery9866]

Thanks!

[@salmanchk]

I have been watching him since my school life but this is for the first time i am listening. He is an intellectual gem. Weighty arguments augmented with rationality, references and reasoning. I regretted for not listening him earlier.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@salmanchk]

@ThePakistanExperience gracias 🙏🥰

[@abdulrazzak4149]

Sindhi language must be learned every resident of Sindh.

[@Indus720]

Sindhis strongly objected to Partition on religious lines and never supported Jinnah and Iqbal’s communal politics of the time. Sindhis even stopped Hindus from migrating from Karachi and leaving behind their ancestral land.

[@maintenancephone3649]

U r suffering from grave delusional state bro... If it is a considerable statement then what was the act of sindh's separation from Bombay presidency ....? How can u justify this one....?

[@areebanaveed9485]

Sindh assembly was the first to pass pakistan resolution....with Muslim legue and hindu Mahasabha...

[@viratkohli1906]

​@@maintenancephone3649no logic. That was just like Gujrat separate from Maharashtra

[@Gullistaan]

Hey man, please stop. You know nothing about the role of Sindh in the Pakistan movement. Sindh was the first, which passed the Pakistan resolution on 3 march 1943. Before commenting make sure you have studied history properly.

[@asadaziz6429]

​@@areebanaveed9485And after it they enjoys the independence.

[@logicalboy424]

I always love listening to Jami Chandio Sahab. Please bring more Sindhi intellectuals to your podcast.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@Abdul-cu3xz]

Invite Ayaz Latif Palijo ​@@ThePakistanExperience

[@dhatkigeet5105]

I wish every urdu speaking person listens the part Separating Karachi from Sindh, Jami Sahab is literally speaking on behalf of every common people of Sindh.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@UmairShah-nx5kd]

People's party ka jab tak khatma nahi hoga Sindh province say karachi Kai logo Mai nafrat rahay gi

[@salmanchk]

As an offspring of an immigrant family, i totally agree with you. He is speaking for every common man living on this piece of earth. I feel so bad and sad that people like Jami sb weren't heard, the way thay deserved to be heard.

[@khalilsamoo1047]

Fantastic discussion, Shehzad! 🎉 01:37:21 I’ve always found the question about Sindhi Nationalist Movements challenging, but the way Jami Sir addressed the question, was very thoughtful, reasonable, and logical.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@mustafa9201]

Loved his opinion on a possible Karachi Province. I'm all for inclusiveness as the proper solution to Karachi's problems are enforcement of local governments. Once that's done we can get over the need of a separate province

[@2003Kamber]

Jami is an Opitome of Sindhi and Urdu elegance.

[@a.j.jamali6376]

Thank you, Shahzad, for inviting Jami Sb to share his insights on Sindh. His comprehensive discussion on the region's history, social values, religious, linguistic diversity, and rich cultural heritage truly broadened our perspectives. His thoughtful commentary added immense value to our understanding Sindh's view point.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@noordin8969]

Among very few episodes which i listened till end without any pause❤️Kudos to you shehzad👍

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@AneesSanghaar]

شکریہ شہزاد بھائی استاد محترم کو سننے موقع دیا جنہوں نے حق آواز میں حق ادا کیا ۔

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@saanavi]

I thoroughly enjoyed Jami Chandio's insightful comments on culture, language, and society - a fascinating lesson for an 80+ engineering student like myself! The intellectual prowess of Pakistan's experts and presenters is truly a societal treasure. Their passion for exploring roots dating back millions of years is like a fresh breeze. However, I couldn't help but wonder, 'what next?' for Pakistan's progress. Interestingly, the learned Professor seemed to overlook the 'millstone' of Kashmir, which, in my opinion, is the biggest hurdle to Pakistan's advancement. Putting this issue on the back burner could liberate Pakistan from numerous problems and eliminate the need for excessive militarization.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@CIMathew-q5y]

One of the BEST podcasts in this space. Hats off to the clarity which the guest possesses.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@hyderali8024]

We all want to listen to Not only jami chandio but his brave daughter too...

[@hunainshoukatsoomro2057]

Jami chandio is a great scholar

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@munnancs]

Thanks

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@sameeralee8068]

It always has been treat to listen to Saeen Jami Chandio. He is my teacher at Centre for Human Rights Education-Pakistan. I envoy him because of his profound knowledge regarding few subjects like politics, sufism and the way he keeps his point❤️🌺🫶🏻

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@Engrali92314]

invite Ayaz Latif Palijo too

[@KacheloShahzeb]

Shahzad i am very happy that you invited jami sahab on TPE. One year ago i texted you and suggested you that please invite some sindhi adeebs like sir jami or ayaz latif palejo sahab and others. Finally it happened really enjoyed every second of this informative podcast this type of genius peoples always speak truth about all issues. Love you shahzad and please invite some other sindhi adeebs . ♥️♥️♥️

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@AftabRahimoon]

It was an amazing podcast Shehzad. Jami sb is one of my favorite Sindhi Writer, philosopher and Intellectual. It was great to see him talking about historical perspective of Sindh, Balochistan, KPK and Punjab including South Asia . Hope to see him in an other podcast.❤

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@rizwanalinarejo1154]

Great work Shahzad, invite Ayaz Latif Palijo on the show!

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@sajjadhussain9724]

Yes that will be epic!

[@rizwanalinarejo1154]

​@@sajjadhussain9724 yes, Ayaz is more vocal.

[@liaqathussain9133]

Love someone from sindh. There should be more Sindhi here. Love him

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@mariyams3445]

Excellent podcast. Very informative! Keep this good work, Shehzad. More power to you for using your platform for being a voice of Sindh and embracing your identity ❤

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@SalmanHoon]

Finally Jami Sir on podcast. What a absolute brilliant podcast. Thank You Ada for inviting him.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@ajaysaranchoudhary9338]

It' s well said.....in India many religious leaders left Hinduism and created different religions like Gautam Buddha created buddhism, mahavir jain created jainism and in same way sikhism also came into light❤.....of course due to some drawbacks in Hinduism like caste system which was horrible in those days 😮 specially 😢.....but till today we are taught about these religious leaders respectfully in our school and college books and all hindus visit gurudwaras bodh and jain temples with out any hesitation ❤ Among all the communal debates happening in today's world I definitely admire and proud of this integrity and liberalism of Hinduism ❤

[@Hindjpeg]

Asalamalekum shezad very few people are are there to think rationally amongst both sides of border,. My salute and love 💝 from India.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@georgecarlinn6288]

This is not rationality when ignoring reality, army is in power, democracy is farce, and asmani kitab says kafirs are to be slaughtr according 5 times no other God only Allah exists

[@NiazHJafri]

Great podcast 👏👏👏👏👏 One humble request to you Shehzad: please don't stop & continue doing the podcasts as long as possible. You are the reason that I am exposed to very many hidden gems of Pakistan. There are a very few people in Pakistan, who make sense in the digital space so please do the good deed & continue speaking the truth boy. Pakistanis desperately need people like: You Syed Muzammil Shah Faisal Warraich Engineer Mirza Uzair Younus Dr. Taimur Rehman Dr. Ammar Ali Jan Professor Parvez Hoodhbhoy Others So please please........

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@nasirsoomro7485]

Jami sb is an epitome of secularism in Pakistan.🌸💐

[@saifsamo9750]

Such an intellectual podcast. Jio shehzaday 🎉❤👍 !!

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@mt6611]

Love ❤️ this podcast , brilliant guest🎉

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@dilbagsingh-h6c]

Hindus in Sindh were roughly 25 percent during partition as per population 24 to 25 percent area should have been given to them after division but whole of Sindh given to Muslims why?

[@georgecarlinn6288]

Because kafir have no choice women have no choice according to @smani kitab

[@abdulkarimwalhari7433]

Jami Chandio is Intelectual and Great we in Pakistan need people like him He is very Humble person I and my friend once Mate him in Sindh language authority Hyderabad He was very humble and Kind toward us Student who was learning ABC of Politics

[@shahnawazhingorjo743]

Jami chandio sahib is proud of Sindh.

[@quratul07]

We never found such a towering intellectual in any political talk show in mainstream media . That's unfortunate. Punjabi and urdu speaking political analysts should show some openness towards sindhi or Baloch intellectuals, too.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@aijazhturk0125]

Thank you Shahzad for having Jami on your podcast, I had requested you long time ago to invite him. Please have Amar Jalil, Naseer memon , Shahab Usto & Fazlulah Qureshi on you pod cast please. I thoroughly enjoyed Jami’s presentation 🙏

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@syedrazaabbaszaidi697]

I'm an urdu speaking Sindhi/Urban Sindhi and love to listen Saif Samejo, Shahzad and Jami Chandio.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@MuhammadAli-bt4ir]

Ghias, appreciable step to bring in an acclaimed scholar of Sindh in your show. ❤

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@zakirhussainradhan]

Jami sahab, you are real intellectual like Ayaz Lateef Paleejo and proved that you have learnt alot not only from late Rasool Bux Paleejo sahab but self study as well.

[@ashfaqjatoi8403]

Thank you Shehzad bha for bringing Jami chandio sb in ur show❤

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@tarotdivine5638]

❤ Loved this podcast, answered many questions about the relevance & importance of language & its connection with culture & thinking. Hindu Sindhis who migrated from sindh to partitioned india lost their language and adopted the local language & consequently local culture. The loss cannot be recouped

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@kanika0846]

Every Hindu in the north India is a nanak panthi. We love our sikh brothers immensely. In our car we have guru nanak photo. There's nothing to be surprised about. Hindus and Sikhs were always one

[@atulmalhotra2303]

Thanx for saying that.

[@bluebird7230]

Nice joke

[@kanika0846]

@@bluebird7230 to a muslim, yes, religious unity is a joke for them

[@bluebird7230]

@@kanika0846 i am sikh stop including Sikhism in Hinduism or any other religion Sikhism is total separate Religion and Guru ka sikh can never hate anyone as i can see your hate against Muslims.

[@kanika0846]

@@bluebird7230 I don't know what sikh you are 😂 my area is full of Sikhs, they have shops and everything and guess what, they worship maa durga, Ganesh ki and Krishna. They celebrate diwali and Dusshera too. So please 😂😂 I know you're a muslim, Don't feel ashamed of your identity

[@sameerchaudhry7725]

Punjabis of Pakistan also need to wake up and own their identity. Strong Punjab means stronger Pakistan and more stability

[@Sarwankhan81]

Thank you, Shehzad, for enabling Jami to educate underprivileged Sindhi and Pakistani youth who have long been intellectually robbed by populists. Also, you need to practice more Sindhi. One day, you should do a podcast in Sindhi because we are not an orphaned nation.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@ksuneetkalyanikar5619]

Really great podcast, salute to both , true to depth ...

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@suffyanmalkani9613]

That's great ❤ Glad to see Jami Sahab there, Jami Sahab is our renowned Teacher, mentor & also sathi of our struggle. Shehzad Sahab please invite Dr Syed Azeem on this podcast about the revolutionary spirit and history of third wold countries like pakitan.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@aijazahmed5243]

Iam glad to see and hear Jami discuss thoroughly on different issues in your program 👍

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@umairjatoi3363]

Jami sir should be permanent guest of TPE

[@ThePakistanExperience]

I agree

[@rrlectures196]

Give a podcast with Sir Naseer Memon Sahib, the Sindhi Civil Society Professional Based now in Islamabad.

[@jrahman38]

The identity crisis ties to economics. If one group sees that other group regardless of right or wrong reason ascend the socio-economic hierarchy, people tends to retaliate using identity as a means to promote themselves. It is very hard to resolve this issue unless we agree on the principles of social justice and merit and let the heterogeneous society evolves by embracing other cultures and identities.

[@Mr-NO-BODY24]

Iam thankful to shehzad jisne hum sindhiyon ke awaz ko duniya tak puhchane ke koshish ke ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@mkslive6856]

جامعی چانڈیو صاحب سے پہلی مرتبہ تعارف ھوا۔ غیرمنقسم ھندوستان خاص طور پر تقسیم ھند پر کمال حد تک دسترس پائی۔ ان کو انتہائی متوازن سخصیت کا حامل پایا۔

[@AmjadAnsari43]

Jaami chandio sahib is very calculated intellectual! 🎉

[@sarmedahmed9887]

Yes sindhis are the only people who tolerate and are still living in such diverse cultures and religions i have many hindu friends in sindh and in malaysia never have i ever discriminated between them and other friends nor they treat me indistinctly.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@gauravmathur3142]

Can a non-Muslim become PM or President in Islamic republic of Pakistan? If not, why not?

[@sarmedahmed9887]

@gauravmathur3142 no non muslim cant be appointed at high rank sensitive positions and its in the constitution article 41 why you wont find that answer by book according to law. Consult some senior analyst may be shehzad can answer about this, but there has been 3 non muslim chief justice of Pakistan in recent history justice bhagwan das....

[@sarmedahmed9887]

@thepakistanexperience shehzad i would love it if you invite someone to talk about CSS ,as being an ex css student and the fact that i passed written exam i am totally against it because css is only about English thats it.focus on knowledge is 10% but the way, the grammar must be correct and your writing skills that counts 90% even if its islamiyat or history whatever the subject and your answer makes sense ,suppose you are telling 14 points of jinnah or explaining a physics's law if your grammar isnt right or the words and sentences arent up to the mark to their level you will get lesser marks than others. The criteria is correct english not correct answer.

[@muneerahmed7530]

​​@@gauravmathur3142 Hindus and Christians each make up 1% of Pakistan's population, making it nearly impossible for them to win a parliamentary seat solely based on religious politics. In contrast, the situation in India is significantly different. India has: 4 Christian-majority states, 3 Muslim-majority states and a union territory, 2 Buddhist-majority states, 3 Adivasi-majority states, 1 Sikh-majority state. Population distribution in India: Hindus: 48% Dalits: 18% Muslims: 15% Adivasis: 10% Christians: 3% Buddhists: 2% Sikhs: 2% Others: 2% (Total: 100%) In Pakistan, minorities have specific constitutional protections. They are allocated reserved seats in the national and provincial assemblies, as well as quotas in government services. Furthermore, minorities can contest all general seats, but Muslim candidates cannot contest the reserved seats for minorities. This marks a key difference between the constitutions of India and Pakistan. In Pakistan, minority rights are safeguarded through these reserved mechanisms. In India, however, the constitutional representation of minorities is not proportionate to their population.

[@danishmahdi3295]

Listening to Jami Chandio on ur podcast was food for thought.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@rajeevrai6531]

Fantastic as usual !!!! Used to know about Pakistani society and history from the likes of Faiz and Jalib durimg my youmger days. Nowdays, Dr. Parvez Hoodbhoy, Shakeel Choudhary and Shahzad Ghais play that role. See/listen to almost your videos !!!!! Kudos to you, Shazad, from India !!!!!

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️🙌

[@saleemnaqvi2200]

Dear Shehzad, thank you for this wonderful podcast. Listening to Jami was a delight. I am so happy to hear his views about the diversity in Sindh and his owning all ethnic groups who are permanent residents of Sindh. We need more intellectuals like him who believe in tolerance and acceptance of diversity. His Urdu was also delight to listen to. There are a few points that were raised during your discussion with him that I would like to comment on. One is the wording of the Lahore Resolution, the other is the resolutions passed by provincial assemblies in favour of Pakistan and the third is making Karachi the capital of Pakistan. I will express my views on these in separate comments.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@jabbarhabibani8577]

Thanks Shehzad for inviting Jami Chandio in your program

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@MirzaMutahir]

I deeply appreciate the concept that identity can either spark conflict and contention or serve as a unique piece of a larger, beautiful mosaic. While it may sound trivial or cliché, it holds profound truth.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@MirHussain-x9b]

دل ہے صحرائے سندھ کی ہواؤں سا وسیع ہم کو جینا ہے محبت کی رواداری کے ساتھ

[@zakirhussainradhan]

Jami sahab, Nodoubt , you are an intellectual in real sense.

[@lifestyle-js1yu]

Wow, what a history know, I literally shocked when this guest talk about NFC award, divided by geographic base after East Pakistan became independent, How NFC award divided by population base. It is clear that only Punjab is pure Pakistan.

[@farhansolangi]

Great JoB shehzad thoroughly enjoyed discussion of Urdu of Jami chandio and he nailed it.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@abbashassan999]

Sending love shehzad bhai you invite our most interesting personality jami chandio you doing well ❤️ keep it up ❤

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@mohsinafzaal7159]

Very impressive podcast very impressive Jami Chandio Sahib ❤

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@njaveri37]

MY FRIEND JAMI CHANDIO IS CLEAR IN TALKS AND TALKING TRUTH - MUMBAI

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@PakHatf]

Here is how a Genuine n intellectual voice speaks 📝📚📑😊🙏 see how media channels avoid such personalities to come on screens. N they have been doing this for decades💥🤔

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@quratul07]

That's exactly my point. The mainstream is deliberately avoiding such intellectuals and ideological personalities.

[@idbhandari9952]

Unity in Diversity is the CENTRAL to Indian thought process. Tribals,Dravidians Huns,Sakas, Arayans,Afgans,Ujbeks, Arabs, Persians and the rest are all part of India.There is no confusion The Constitution of India gives Equality to all hence it is successful to great extent. Pakistan is part of this philosophy. Better to accept reality and live in peace. Punjab is suffering because of exclusiveness after 1947 appears to be true NATION STATE IS A DANGEROUS IDEA. Excellent enlightened discussion.💐🌹

[@AkashAnsari]

Thanks Shahzad very much informative and historical discussion with Jami sahib

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@AliKhuwaja198]

Jami Chandio is our respectable and educated intellectual and I agree to most of his narrative. Isn't it strange, the historical perspective he gave about Sindh and in context of Pakistan was taken from books of Sain GM Syed and yet he seldom mentioned the role of Sain GM Syed in that era including formation of Sindh United party (btw ZA Bhutto's father Sir Shahnawaz Bhutto was also part of this party) which won the majority seats of 1936 election, the first ever election after independence of Sindh from Bombay presidency. This party defeated both Muslim league and Congress in Sindh. And it was GM Syed who let the Sindh Assembly pass the resolution of Pakistan from Sindh Assembly without which Pakistan would not have even existed. As far as the future is concerned, this country which was created on the baseless identity is slowly but surely is moving towards its logical conclusion so expecting to do politics of vote and elections is making fool to oneself that it would change it's destination.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@AliKhuwaja198]

@ If possible keep Zulfiqar Bhutto junior in your list of future guests please.

[@NazimUdDin-tg8jg]

Yes Jami sabh is right, after Dr Shahnawaz's death umerkot was full of fear. We people of Umerkot are thankful to Nationalist people who broke the winds of fear.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@umairjatoi3363]

Jami Sir ko sun kar bohot achha laga informative podcast after a while shehzad bhai

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@IntegratedServicesExcellence]

Its not only karachi but people of other parts of Sindh used to have trade and business with Gujrat, Rajasthan and Mumbai

[@Factfuluniverse1]

Exactly and tgere was a great water body in between gujrat of india and thar of sindh, connected with the indian ocean, people used to use those water ways also besides karachi port of debal

[@JAli-gy4wj]

1:41:00 "Zardari sahab ne corruption or aqraba parwari ko democratize kr diya he" Zbrdast! Thank you Shehzad sir 👍❤ thank you so much Jami Chandio sir!

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@akhtarkakepoto4422]

Thanks Mr Jami Chandio and Shehzad sahib to review all jumps of politics in Pakistan specially for Sindh although it was lengthy discussion but we enjoyed and backedup tiny misunderstandings. Wel done Palijo sahib .

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@VictimHood-qv1hx]

All Hindus have migrated to India , only few are left behind . Pakistanis in Sindh are descendants of various Arab, Turkic and Persian empires who ruled India .

[@Abhi_Maan]

Somedays you are descendents of Arabs, somedays you are children of turks and somedays mongols. You dont even know your own roots. But actually You are those hindus who converted due to the tyranny of invaders.

[@akytolz]

Only 3 million Hindus left in Sindh... That's it... Lol

[@pmishra786]

Lol, Sindhis are nearly 95% native of Sindh. Not from Arab or Persia.

[@dharmikrakshak8340]

Hindu never migrated .they kicked out .

[@sumitnimawat7408]

In india sindhis are one of the most successful community.

[@Bashir-n2x]

Yes new generation can't speak Sindi

[@rajsinghji-84]

@@Bashir-n2x so?

[@sumitnimawat7408]

​@@Bashir-n2xEven every Pakistani sindhis can't speak sindhi

[@UmairShah-nx5kd]

​@@sumitnimawat7408 wikipedia pay census check karlo Urdu speaking ki percentage sirf karachi aur northern Punjabio Mai hi Badi hai karachi to hai hi Urdu speaking ka city aur northern Punjab Kai to culture Mai hi Urdu hai

[@logicandlove8555]

Sindhis are the richest in India. The most glamorous and wealthy community. New generation urdu/hindi nahi bol pati rich logo ki.

[@abdulmajidbadini5871]

Is there any link about Jami chando books?

[@livewithamirhussain9202]

Nice to see our friend Jami Chandio in your podcast

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@razkaraj2150]

Love your Podcasts Shehzad bhai♥♥♥. 1:05:01 Loved the way he explained how Sindhi culture is alive but Punjabi culture isn't because Punjab saw partition. I don't exactly agree with it, Indian Punjab has lots of religious diversity and has remain peaceful. I think Pakistan studies should teach religious harmony so there would be more tolerance towards other religions. I have seen whenever any scholars come they usually see religions as different, but as Indian and having lots of Gods help place other religions God at same space. We don't usually see Eastern religions different as Hinduism itself is extremely diverse and nobody can claim mine is the only way which is a problem I have seen with western religions. People being very religious would follow these scriptures and people who became liberal don't really give too much importance to religions and see all religions as same.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@wafaadeelqazi8107]

Wonderful Shahzad, It is always pleasure to listen Jami.. You must invite Comrade Masroor Shah to your podcast. He has such a brilliant mind that not only does he astonish his listeners, but the way he articulates his perspective with such skill and simplicity makes people spontaneously say, "What a genius!"

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@neilmichael2676]

Now this what you would call a scholar!! Brilliant conversation!!

[@ThePakistanExperience]

🙌

[@najmussaharbangash6924]

Excellent discussion; please bring more of such programmes. Thank you.

[@ThePakistanExperience]

❤️

[@nazarmohammadabro5417]

Please bring Naseer Memon sb on the podcast