Who Lives Who Dies Hamilton Reaction

Check out this Vocal Coach Reacts Hamilton - Who lives who dies who tells your story! Watch and learn to sing like the cast of Lin Manuel Miranda’s hit show as this singing teacher breaks down the vocal styles and techniques of the cast of this Disney + original. So let's sing Something LaLaLa!
🎵 ⚠️ Join live MASTER CLASSES, get BONUS VIDEOS, LIVE Q&A with Audrey and hang out in our CREATIVE COMMUNITY:
👉 www.SingWithAud...
❓🤔 WANT TO IMPROVE YOUR VOICE FAST? You need the QUICK FIX course!!
👉www.SongsFromAS...
⚠️ Grab A Free "BREATH SUPPORT" Course Video Here:
👉 www.VocalFreebi...
❓🤔 WANT TO SING? ...THINK YOU CAN'T?!
Sign up today for private voice lessons exclusively with Audrey:
www.SongsFromaS...
🎥 Get my PRIVATE FEEDBACK on a video of you singing:
👉 www.wisio.com/...
📸 Get more behind the scenes footage and sneak peeks on my IG:
👉 / songsfromasuitcase
💬 Continue the conversation at DISCORD:
👉 / discord
💬 Live Chats,Early Release Videos, Bonus Content on my Patreon: Patreon.com/SongsFromASuitcase
✅ Check out my website for online singing lessons and DISCOUNTS:
👉 www.SongsFromaS...
Vocal Coach Reacts to Hamilton:
• Vocal Coach Reacts Ham...

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

🎵 ⚠️ Get the SING W/EMOTION MASTER CLASS, Vocal Warmup Challenges, Live Q&A w/Audrey and hang out in our CREATIVE COMMUNITY: 👉 www.SFAScommunity.com

[@martaramirez6891]

I can’t trust people who doesn’t get emotional with this song

[@dollopofvanillecream]

same

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

LOL

[@anonymousfan.4451]

I guess you can’t trust me 🖐😌

[@martaramirez6891]

@@anonymousfan.4451 I guess so 🤷🏻‍♀️

[@Jimins__Pookie]

Sorry, it takes a lot for me to feel something. I only cried watching Hamilton when "forgiveness" was sung in It's Quiet Uptown.

[@crow337]

That gasp she does in the end gets me every time. All the tragedies she went through in her life is all culminated in that one gasp.

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

that's one powerful gasp LOL

[@michaelt3779]

Out of all the explanations of the gasp I think I like the breaking the 4th wall one where it’s Eliza seeing the audience and realizing we are all hearing their story. She said that she would have multiple reasons for the gasp. From a Variety interview she added that the theory about Eliza breaking the fourth wall was accurate, and she would “look out and see all these beautiful faces and acknowledge that story we had all taken a ride to witness.”

[@dougbetts75]

Me too!

[@t0astygh0stt]

@@michaelt3779 My theory’s a lil mixture of like all the theories I’ve seen XD I think it stands for Eliza •Seeing that their stories were all told via this musical (the 4th wall break) •Seeing and reuniting with her deceased loved ones and god •and by extension of the previous point, dying

[@queencerseilannister3519]

I always thought the gaso meant, she was stunned she was the last one standing to tell the story.

[@pigs18]

"Angelica, while she's alive she helps me tell your story." There are four characters not in white at the end of the show, Burr (Who Lives), Hamilton (Who Dies), and Eliza and Angelica (Who Tells Your Story).

[@Isabella_THE_RAT]

OMG IM SPEECHLESS

[@ghostking7853]

A theory that I like is that when Hamilton walks behind Eliza, he is stepping out of character. From that point on he's no longer Hamilton, but he is now Lin. Lin is showing her that she succeeded in telling Alexander's story. This also ties into the theory that Eliza's gasp at the end is her finally being able to see the impact that she (and Alexander) had and is seeing the audience for the first time.

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

this is beautiful love it!!!!

[@beatriztauro7930]

actually, Lin said that this changes from Eliza to Eliza. Some of the actress said she imagine Eliza seeing heaven and all her loved ones (her sisters, her son, her husband). Some says exactly what you've said: Li is showing to Eliza that her story was told and was important. But there is not a single answer about it ;)

[@CDG1228]

Lin himself dispelled this idea in a tweet: "It’s a lovely notion but it breaks down the moment I’m not playing the role (how I wish you could see @JMunozActor or @JonRua, who also played Ham that first year!) The Gasp is The Gasp is The Gasp. I love all the interpretations. ❤" 7/8/2020

[@ghostking7853]

@@CDG1228 Again I just said a "theory"

[@enriquev1271]

@@CDG1228 Philippa said that was her favorite theory about the gasp meaning tho

[@melaniegoldstein2784]

We all need to give a HUGE shout out to the chorus. I can't think of another musical with more powerful or moving back up vocals

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

The ensemble always deserve huge rounds of applause

[@CWazBroadwayBandGeek]

Phillipa: *gasps with her heart and soul* Me: *puddle of sobs and emotions*

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

She's awesome like that

[@chloe_3787]

Phillipa Soo will always be my favorite part of Hamilton. She and Lin are the ones we get to see really, really act, and honestly, she’s just head and shoulders ahead of him on stage. No hate to Lin; he’s a creative genius and a damn good actor. But you can’t beat that classically trained voice and her emotion.

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

FACTS

[@casheycashey3614]

This is def the most emotional song for me I’m excited

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

hope you liked it!!!!

[@casheycashey3614]

@@SongsFromASuitcase I did 😭😂😂 good stuff

[@amy58_____]

When she breaks through the fourth wall for me makes this whole song!!

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

It's awesome!

[@anapuello8871]

Her gasp is about watching her legacy being shown to her and told to the world by Lin Manuel. The emotions flow when seeing it all together and the extent of it. A true moment of full paroxysm.. we all gasped and held our breath with Eliza.

[@MidnightL2008]

Even if you don’t watch it on the channel you need to see the video of the Ham4Ham where Oak (Mulligan/Madison) sings Defying Gravity while impersonating Mickey Mouse. It is AMAZING!!!!!! 🤣🤣

[@tastetherainebow7791]

ITS HILARIOUS

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

Wait what???? that sounds like the best time ever!!!!

[@katiesills722]

@@SongsFromASuitcase kzbin.info/www/bejne/ZmipXoOveNR5gbc

[@alaynawood1584]

My problem with singing this song well is I can't sing around my choked up tears lol. I literally can't sing this song without bawling.

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

That just speaks to the power of the song

[@derrekjones2129]

It’s mind boggling the Lin -Manuel wrote that piece. I think some roles are written for certain people in life. She has everything, all of the complexities of the character are wrapped up in this piece. She evolves into a courageous woman, and, still maintains her shy, tender qualities. I see a deep well of strength in her capacity to forgive and champion an imperfect man who did so much to build up and destroy. That is the true power of love. When she says “…in their eyes I see you Alexander..” her timing and subtle movements are so intimate. It speaks volumes of what she really saw in him that most of would never understand. It’s what a mother sees in her child that the child can’t see in himself. Mrs. Soo blows this away. It chilling and brings tears to my eyes every time I hear it. Even her imperfections (not the strongest voice) brings depth and authenticity to the Character. Out of the shadows she ponders, “when my time is up, have I done enough, will they tell my story?” “Oh, I can’t wait to see you again”. Wow! Every human being poses that question to himself, and longs for someone dear that has gone on. Thanks for posting and your review. You have great energy. Loved it!!

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

I love this comment!!!! The layers that not everybody it s gonna catch, but that are there and inevitably make the show so magical!!!!

[@vgolf10]

and the insanity of depth to the writing. Eliza's been singing "would that be enough" to Hamilton at times, to Hamilton, after their son's death saying, if he can see her smile again, "that would be enough", finally putting family before legacy. and then to Eliza finally understanding Hamilton's legacy and say, "have i done enough, will they tell my story". To the finale with Eliza seeing the audience and got the answer that, yes, her story has been told. the tears... another tidbit that perhaps i might over analyze. in this song, pay attention to when the word "time" is mentioned. it is being used as different context: legacy, determination, opportunity, death. For example, when Angelica and Eliza harmonize, "she was right on time" - this represents love and death in one instance. As in Angelica was always there for Eliza and then also after they finish the "time" word, the light shone on Angelica fades away.. like death. Also, when Eliza ends with "only a matter of time" you hear a bell sound.. like a toll.

[@ranarahmanfard6523]

This song makes me cry from the first note right up until that gasp at the end. Perfection!

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

It's so good

[@xo.makenna28]

The last part of the song when Eliza gasps always makes me sob. I was confused the first time I watched it but the second time I realized that at that point Lin wasn’t playing Hamilton, he was playing himself. Eliza was still Eliza but Alexander was Lin and he was leading Eliza up to the front of the stage and showing her that he told her story.

[@elbatorres6113]

Every cast member sings beautifully and soulfully! Instant connection with the audience! Lin Manuel Miranda and the Hamilton entire production... THANK YOU! Love your reactions! Good vibes always, from NYC!

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

So good!

[@fayc_fayc2115]

I’m really hoping you can listen to Burn by Andra Day for the Hamilton Mixtape. Preferably the studio version because it’s just so powerful

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

Should I react to that next??? 🤔 🤔 🤔 Let me know on my community board: kzbin.info/door/Ud6f8IvYBlD7rz4cjOAMdAcommunity

[@philiphamel8504]

I don't know if anyone has mentioned it, but Eliza is one of the few who doesn't rap in this musical. Almost like she doesn't need to rush through saying what's on her mind. Like she has all the time she needs.

[@lucinda2329]

She beat boxes when their son is singing for his dad...

[@sansskeloton1900]

@@lucinda2329 beat boxing isn't rap. What's your point here?

[@MetronV]

Gah I thought I'd made myself immune to the emotional impact of this part through countless watchings and listenings last year...but noooooo.

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

It's a powerful song no way we can deny that

[@beaniethetortoise3529]

I think the gasp was Lin taking her to the audience, and her seeing everyone whose watched her story, realising her story was told.

[@kendallmondo8315]

There’s actually more than one episode of greys anatomy named after Hamilton songs

[@boborambles]

Wait, what?

[@kendallmondo8315]

@@boborambles yeah there’s who lives who dies who tells your story then the room where it happens and I’m pretty sure there’s another one

[@boborambles]

Oh cool! I’ll have to check it out!

[@jadaarmstrong2082]

And Leslie was in an episode

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

Really? I knew that most if not all of the episodes are named after songs but how many are named after Hamilton????

[@mattdillon849]

Who cried their eyes off during this (me!)😪😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

[@mattdillon849]

Actually after Alexander(lin) goes behind eliza(phillipa) he's not alex anymore its lin and then when eliza takes his hand he shows her that he told her story and he said the gasp at the end can mean anything when she passed,surprised,shock,or happy its very touching (and thats why I think its called hamilton cause lin tells Alex's but also elizas even after her husband died its very heart warming i wish we could go back in time to show the real eliza what he/we did :-) ))

[@Emma-tn5dz]

Nooo! You can’t finish your Hamilton series without ‘One Last Time’ and ‘Wait for It’😭

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

What should I react to next??? 🤔 🤔 🤔 What do you think? Let me know on my community board: kzbin.info/door/Ud6f8IvYBlD7rz4cjOAMdAcommunity

[@alexandrecreao]

It doesn't matter how many times I listen to this song and it always gives me chills

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

its just magical

[@alishal6031]

This song always gives me goosebumps every time I hear it. I love your reaction and analysis to as well! I'd love if you reacted to some of Melissa Benoist's singing too! Wrecking Ball is a good one for the Glee weekend!

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

I would love to react to all the amazing artist and shows out there but with so many good options to choose from, I need your help making a decision by leaving ideas on my community board 🥰 Here’s the link 😁 kzbin.info/door/Ud6f8IvYBlD7rz4cjOAMdAcommunity

[@meganjohnson9022]

It doesn't matter how many times I watch this play or listen to this soundtrack, that song always makes me tear up.

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

It's very powerful

[@TheBentiZ]

Love your videos! You should check out Angelina Jordan, a music prodigy. I put a spell on you (Black & white version when she was 9), Feeling good (10 years) or Bohemian rhapsody (13 years) She will blow your mind!

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

I would love to react to all the amazing artist and shows out there but with so many good options to choose from, I need your help making a decision by leaving ideas on my community board 🥰 Here’s the link 😁 kzbin.info/door/Ud6f8IvYBlD7rz4cjOAMdAcommunity

[@dreamsscapee]

can't wait to see your reaction to this artwork!!

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

🥰🥰🥰

[@joshuajones471]

The story behind Eliza's gasp is that the man looking at her at the end is not Alexander Hamilton but Lin-Manuel Miranda himself. She gasps as she realises Lin-Manuel did in fact tell her story.

[@evaisimmature]

hamilton: an american musical is the hamilton family’s story. alexander and eliza HAMILTON. eliza tells alexander’s story and lin tells hers

[@Bluebird383]

Please react to What'd I Miss. I need that I'm my life

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

Should I react to that next??? 🤔 🤔 🤔 Let me know on my community board: kzbin.info/door/Ud6f8IvYBlD7rz4cjOAMdAcommunity

[@Bluebird383]

@@SongsFromASuitcase okay

[@mldag1678]

2:30 when you did this my mind immediately went to a priest in church singing/speaking from a section of a holy text or something and it just added so much more depth to Eliza's singing for me lol edit: also im weeping bc of this song for the 10000000th time and im at WORK help

[@kahlanwilliams267]

A small suggestion, a constructive criticism really. I get you're doing the technical theory. Thats the purpose of the videos. However, it can be really jarring when you pause mid-phrase. It doesn't take much to just put it back a little each time you pause so the whole phrase can be listened to and the technique you've described can be seen. Just a small thing but would just make it even closer to perfect.

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

Thank you we always want to know about our opportunities to grow 🥰

[@frenchypasmt]

She was singing to a bust of him. She did this all the time. It was really a testament to her love for him.

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

the details!!!!!

[@lettiewilson9504]

A fun fact is eliza is the only one that doesn't really rap because she had more time.

[@mechulyeldell1094]

As a grown ass man this song gets me everytime. Everytime. Lump in the throat holding back tears.

[@truejustice6206]

She gasped and now I am sobbing at 4:00 on a Sunday morning

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

OMG! Sending a 🥰virtual hug🥰

[@truejustice6206]

@@SongsFromASuitcase :O Thank you for your hug, my friend! ❤️

[@cardboard1516]

This song gets me every single time even when I know how happy/sad it is

[@LM-xw1hf]

You should react to Stand Up from the movie Harriet:) The studio recording and live are both gold.

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

Should I react to that next??? 🤔 🤔 🤔 Let me know on my community board: kzbin.info/door/Ud6f8IvYBlD7rz4cjOAMdAcommunity

[@Ari_Hazel2026]

Some people say at the end it’s supposed to be the creator leading Elizabeth to the front to see the crowd. Showing her that her story was told

[@QuikVidGuy]

Oh, I forgot you finally got clearance to travel, I was surprised by the new room

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

LOL yeah

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

I've actually been living in Thailand for three years now :)

[@Naturalnlvnit]

omg I tear up every time I hear this song

[@grape5120]

my favorite fan theory is that at the end it’s not hamilton taking her hand it’s lin and he shows her that someone is telling hamiltons story and the gasp is her seeing it relieved her work to make sure their legacy wasn’t forgotten paid off

[@alaskacosplay]

When it comes to this song, I end up in tears because of what Eliza has done and I just cant help myself but cry.

[@kfiraltberger552]

It feels like a few songs in one because it has like 3 or 4 different sections and connects them in 1

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

Amazing right?

[@tatiana4847]

Can you please react to the Hamilton The performances Kennedy center 2018

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

Should I react to that next??? 🤔 🤔 🤔 Let me know on my community board: kzbin.info/door/Ud6f8IvYBlD7rz4cjOAMdAcommunity

[@elyanguerin2317]

you should react to Phillipa singing in the movie Over The Moon

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

What should I react to next??? 🤔 🤔 🤔 What do you think? Let me know on my community board: kzbin.info/door/Ud6f8IvYBlD7rz4cjOAMdAcommunity

[@TheCloverSystem]

“But when you’re gone who remembers your name? Who keeps your flame? Who tells your story?” And then “Eliza” for me it implies that SHE remembers his name. SHE keeps his flame and SHE tells his story

[@Happymali10]

It's really interesting to rewatch the old white house performance of Lin's "early draft" opening song, where it was still a concept album not a musical. A lot of the changes are because in that version it's 2 narrators (Aaron Burr and Hamilton), while the final version has 8.

[@dougbetts75]

DAMN YOU Songs From A Suitcase! You HAD to go and react to this song ... and I HAD to watch it ... and my eyes well up EVERY SINGLE TIME I watch it! LOL! Such a great song -- actually the whole show!

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

Muhahahah! *cue evil laugh*

[@Lisa.M.]

I cry every single time!

[@lucinda2329]

❤ ✿❧🌿❧✿ ❤ I love the way Washington responds to Eliza saying she continues the work to end slavery... His expression and step backwards serve as acknowledgement he could have done more...beautifully done by CJ.

[@deckenneth]

This, right here, is the reason the show is called Hamilton, not Alexander Hamilton...

[@Officialmelbanks]

Please react to total eclipse of the heart by glee

[@leticiawerli7375]

YESSSS

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

Glee it's just a never ending list of good options BUUUT I need help narrowing that list so get over to my community board and tell me what YOU wanna see me react to. Let me know on my community board 🥰: kzbin.info/door/Ud6f8IvYBlD7rz4cjOAMdAcommunity

[@def0notviolet]

Who lives Eliza who dies Angelica who tells your story Lin

[@iceenia4387]

where can you find the video cropped? i cant find it anywhere but disney

[@ghinanaeem5723]

Why do you remind me of Laura Bennanti? I think it's your smile

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

I actually reviewed one of her songs becuase everyone says so!

[@ghinanaeem5723]

@@SongsFromASuitcase Haha, glad other people think so too! I'm new to your channel and I love it ❤

[@Kranzinator28]

Her emotions at the end of this scene are real. She found out her uncle died right before the show.

[@taliaulakai9650]

Omg I watch Hamilton like 30 times it is not sad

[@alana_w]

Im exited for this one!

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

hope you liked it

[@aresef]

Brilliant acting choice--when Eliza sings about speaking out against slavery, you see Christopher Jackson behind her hanging his head in shame. Jackson did a lot of not just research but soul-searching when he played Washington, and that acting decision was likely a byproduct of that.

[@lillian7411]

Not me watching this completely out of context…trying not to cry…bawling my eyes out at “the orphanage”. I am UNWELL

[@johnparla6252]

If I get the chance I will Wright a Hamilton 2 and yes there can be one. Washington himself had a vision. The spirits that you see in this song will save America when America is invaded

[@MusicalTheaterGeek24601]

you should react to some songs from smash. they are absolutely amazing and are sung by really talented people

[@leximiller932]

She was crying for real I herd

[@SophieFoster130]

this song makes me cry every time

[@roxanatorres5235]

This song makes me cry every single time. As soon as they sing “The Orphanageeee” I melt 😭

[@noelcain20000]

I always cry at this song

[@pr4028]

😍😍

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

🥰🥰🥰🥰

[@100JAD.]

I love how you fangirling over each of them

[@sannajensen5448]

You should react to “du måste finnas” (Swedish version) by Helen Sjöholm in the musical Christina from Duvemåla (written by Björn and Benny from ABBA). It’s so powerful and she is amazing! 🙌

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

I love finding new music!!!! But if you want me to react to them its always better to Let me know on my community board: kzbin.info/door/Ud6f8IvYBlD7rz4cjOAMdAcommunity

[@matthewmcshane399]

Hi u should react to the musicals movie Anna and the apocalypse. Its both funny sacry and emotional. Start by reacting to the song Hollywood ending.

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

I would love to react to all the amazing artist and shows out there but with so many good options to choose from, I need your help making a decision by leaving ideas on my community board 🥰 Here’s the link 😁 kzbin.info/door/Ud6f8IvYBlD7rz4cjOAMdAcommunity

[@sashalaguelamusic]

the gasp at the end makes me cry every single time 😭

[@marissat.5504]

Omg you need to listen to guns and ships

[@mattschulte3578]

you should react to guns and ships

[@-blobfishpunk-9699]

~gasps at the same time as eliza~

[@Jackie-cw7qz]

Please do all of Hamilton songs 😄😄

[@mizukirye6324]

never fail to make me cry.

[@leahkkk]

You should do my shot or Alexander Hamilton

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

Should I react to that next??? 🤔 🤔 🤔 Let me know on my community board: kzbin.info/door/Ud6f8IvYBlD7rz4cjOAMdAcommunity

[@brisarodriguez4293]

CC Español please!!!

[@losfp]

I'd like to speak to Pippa Soo's manager please.

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

LOL to thank him?

[@losfp]

@@SongsFromASuitcase No I wish to make a complaint about her STABBING ME REPEATEDLY IN THE HEART EVERY TIME I LISTEN TO THIS DAMN SHOW.

[@kendallmondo8315]

IVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS WOOOOO

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

Hope you liked it!!!!

[@b_reaction_music3900]

👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

🥰

[@tityadoreess]

Still waiting for the reaction to One Last Time. Love you ❤❤

[@SongsFromASuitcase]

Should I react to that next??? 🤔 🤔 🤔 Let me know on my community board: kzbin.info/door/Ud6f8IvYBlD7rz4cjOAMdAcommunity

[@tityadoreess]

@@SongsFromASuitcase yes please 🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼

[@uhope765]

It is so, so beautiful 😍