Special Agent Lundy vs. The Bay Harbor Butcher 🔎 Dexter

[@Dustyplastic73]

Lundy figuring out that the Butcher had a law enforcement background is one of the biggest yet most believable and impressive leaps in logic I’ve seen from a character. Rather than make sense of the manifesto, Lundy recognizes its true purpose. Plus it was a great consequence of Dexter’s brazenness and carelessness.

[@lucyseverine9907]

@@rubenoteiza9261 I think it's perfectly reasonable. He recognised that the message contained specifically a lot of signals and hints that would appeal to cops trying to make sense of the mind of their target, but that there didn't actually seem to be a lot of agreement on what those hints *were*; and from that he concluded that the message was written with intent to muddy the waters. From that, you can get three reasons why this points to a Law Enforcement background; one, the suspect *knew* that this tactic would get the sort of confusion reaction they wanted, which means they have some understanding of how cops investigate. Not very much on its own, but combine it with, two, the fact that the suspect seems aware that the cops are getting closer and thus that they needed to throw them off somehow, a major change in their behavioural pattern up to this point. That points to the suspect having contact with the investigation to some degree, either directly or indirectly. Three, and most damningly, the subject knew *exactly* the sort of things to include in the manifesto to elicite that sort of reaction. This points to them thinking in a very similar manner as the investigators, and/or being very well versed in law enforcement experiences. To explain that last one, imagine that, say, you're a construction worker, and you read a novel in which a protagonist constructs a house from scratch. If you're actually intimately familiar with how to actually build houses, whether the AUTHOR of that novel is will likely be immediately apparent; their own level of experience, or lack there-of and their attempt to "fake it". Lundy is here observing the opposite in reverse; he's recognising that the author of the manifesto is familiar enough with a law enforcement mindset that they are able to actively 'forge' a narrative- several, in fact- that appeals to people who also have that mindset. Which means they're probably Law Enforcement themselves.

[@ACatNamedOrwell]

@@rubenoteiza9261he acknowledged blatantly to Dexter how he (the BHB) was able to consistently and convincingly and conveniently avoided cops at every turn. So he did in fact step outside that box and made an educated guess that he either is currently or has the background of law enforcement

[@kirbyis4ever]

​@@rubenoteiza9261 Who pissed in your cereal my guy?

[@kirbyis4ever]

@@rubenoteiza9261 Someone didn't just piss in your cereal, they must have shit in it lmao. "Leave me alone" okay tough kid 😆

[@iEcksy]

Yet he didn’t make the link that the Bay Harbor Butcher has a surgical cut on all the cheeks, some of the victims walked due to faulty blood work on an otherwise impeccable record of someone meticulous (as Doakes clearly was not in control of his emotions or surroundings and he would know someone with such compulsive traits craved control, including emotional; even if feigned and regulated to replicate others emotional patterns, still requires comprehensive control of your actions) then of course the biggest tell of all is that there was a blood analyst that was a suspect, and the trophies were literal blood slides. 🤦🏼‍♂️

[@elmagistradofk6286]

22:56 "Dextuh put your knife away Dextuh"

[@shehateTD]

holy crap mike walking up was so surprising

[@shehateTD]

he was such a good cop before he broke bad😔

[@Jonathan-xj9ny]

kid named Bay Harbour Butcher:

[@DizzyDaDon]

🤣🤣🤣

[@dongatello6969]

This is the moment Dexter and finger started kissing passionately

[@jimsty7550]

Damn, I forgot Mike Ehrmantraut worked the Bay Harbor Butcher case long before he met Gus Fring...

[@ninjaguyYT]

I didn't realize it was before. I assumed they added finger as an easter egg.

[@jimhalpert0]

The Office is connected to Dexter as there is a Sabre Printer in Dexter. Breaking Bad is connected to The Office as Jesse Pinkman shows up to sell some crystal to Creed. So either it is Mike or his twin brother.

[@kylesherlock3859]

@@jimhalpert0and also breaking bad is tied into walking dead, Darrell’s cousin or brother hung out with Jesse. So technically all 4 shows are connected, Dexter, walking dead, breaking bad and the office. Funny though that the manager of that office in Philly is also Saul lol

[@shakibali5766]

@@kylesherlock3859slipping jimmy did a lot during his sabbatical from law

[@Laserith-r8v]

Waltuh

[@OTHERVERSETCG]

I like how we are all here watching Dexter together years later

[@finlaytemple1744]

Catching up for the new season lol

[@eleegalz]

Bro comment so real

[@OTHERVERSETCG]

I grew up watching this show at it was the best of times

[@rashtra8253]

To relive nostalgia

[@TewnMacLean]

@@finlaytemple1744 theres another??

[@Ravensword01]

I like how Doakes is the one who turns the lights on, as if to foreshadow how Lundy shed light on his crimes as the Bay Harbor Butcher.

[@trollin702]

literally been looking for lundy clips for weeks and this comes up? 😂

[@Please_allow_me]

Bravo Vince

[@ghostaccountlmao]

LMAO

[@fabianhammer2864]

i will always remember that reveal, of arthur mitchell randomly calling someone a cunt, only for the camera to pan back and reveal doakes, saying surprise motherfucker.....they tried to replicate that, with travis calling little harrison a whore, but it just wasnt the same

[@randallflagg3700]

Kek

[@IamtheWalrus2]

I like the part where Dexter says ,”Say my name.” And Lundy says “The Bay Harbor Butcher” and Dexter goes ,”Youre god damn right”. ICONIC

[@basstian]

Skylerita shouting to her mum, telling her to 'shut up, shut up, shut up...' was priceless!

[@odatnarat14]

Vrabo bince masuka matata 👏👏👏👏

[@TimmyMcGowan]

A butcher opens up his bay and gets harbored and you think that of ME?!?

[@basstian]

@@TimmyMcGowan I am the one who cuts!

[@clownnightmare113]

Dexter telling Lundy to "Say it, out loud" and Lundy saying "Serial Killer" always sends a chill up my spine. #TeamDexter

[@Ihvnoname]

The way LaGuerta looks at Doakes...she always knew of his secret of being the Bay Harbor Butcher

[@fabianhammer2864]

dude, it was clearly miguel prado, who organized the doomsday sacrifice, of the barrell girls

[@longebane]

Actually I think DEB is the BHB

[@fabianhammer2864]

@@longebane i couldnt believe it, when her full birthname was revealed, as debay harbor butcher morgan

[@sprytnychomik]

Of course she did. It is she who made him this way, an innocent people killer.

[@endless_sands]

it was a bit obvious after he grabbed dexter and slammed him into the table. (unironically, i hate the fact they never mention this in the later seasons. It would've been 10/10 of an excuse for dexter to use. "doakes literally stalked me for weeks, then threw me to the ground in front of everyone. honestly he might've made me a victim if he wasn't caught" *this reinforces the already established idea that doakes wasn't in the best mental state, and places dexter as a possible victim (thus separating him from any possibility of being the BHB further)*

[@lorenzogaspero9758]

The fact that Doakes was the bay harbour butcher was so shocking to me!! Literally wtf, i tought it was Dexter all along!

[@fabianhammer2864]

Officer Ramos was clearly the Ice Day Surgeon, it was revealed when Brother Sam saved Barrel Girl No. 13, which was revealed to be trans harrison

[@leeham6230]

Honestly, that has to be a top ten anime twist.

[@dickfitswell3437]

Doaked wasnt the Bay Harbor Butcher. It was Deb.

[@eleegalz]

He wasn't 🤔 It wasn't Doakes

[@elcineaste]

@@eleegalz…did you not watch the show?

[@Gavin_Editsz]

Still can’t believe Doakes was the bay harbour butcher 💀

[@NJ-wb1cz]

By trying to frame Dexter he made Dexter's career as a youtuber really take off, so it all worked out in the end

[@Molon_Labe1776]

IKR Kinda makes since. He always mad.

[@jimsty7550]

The most common comment on every Bay Harbor Butcher video...

[@Sniperboy5551]

This is the most common comment on every single Dexter video, but it never fails to make me chuckle

[@ninjaguyYT]

Seriously? Were you paying attention even or were you playing Half Life 2 with the definitive edition mod while paying half attention to Dexter? Byney (Deggster's brother) was the Gay Harbor Butch.

[@Dull_Void]

Fun fact: the actor playing Lundy also starred in 'Criminal minds' as a serial killer with a body count as high as Dexter.

[@thebyrdcage8619]

Also played penny’s dad on the Big Bang theory. Dudes an awesome actor

[@zaftigkitty308]

and has an academy award for best original song!

[@uberhaxorzskelletor]

he also played wild bill in Deadwood

[@axe863]

​@@uberhaxorzskelletor he was also the voice actor for jaws

[@jodycwilliams]

Go watch him in The Duelists. It will change how you see movie fight choreography.

[@NJ-wb1cz]

I still can't believe The Lundy Butcher Bay was Special Harbor Agent

[@fabianhammer2864]

how bout quinn being the doomsday butcher and liddy just being a product of his schizophrenic mind?

[@Keebrev]

@@fabianhammer2864kind of reminds me how the whole show after season 2 is actually just a fever dream in Doakes mind as he’s blown to shreds

[@lostpathblog]

😂😂😂😂

[@RedMist97]

HAHAHAHA YOURE SO FUNNY 🫤

[@Kayconquers]

This has 666 likes I was gonna give it a like but I don’t wanna ruin it

[@davidharshman7645]

Dexter's excuse that being overworked let a murderer go free...most believable thing in the world.

[@rubenoteiza9261]

I have seen many videos of plane crashes and believe or not, at least some of them were provoked by overworked air controllers/pilots, people who had brutal working schedules.

[@Dinglehoppers779]

It's like they say, labour regulations are written in blood.

[@Doom_Slug]

​@@rubenoteiza9261That really bad train crash in Japan comes to mind

[@Christian-ml9sx]

Pretty sure there are more overworked workers than serial killers out there.

[@KennyEvans-yg7ej]

I love how it zoomed in on doakes face as he looks nervous as it foreshadows how he is the bay harbour butcher and he killed Dexter

[@fabianhammer2864]

doakes being the dark defender was a bit on the nose, though

[@DonMyrda]

Tired of these

[@Hershey1000]

@@DonMyrdaCool.

[@OhHeBustin]

Lol​@@fabianhammer2864

[@GiovanniMejiaSantana]

​@@DonMyrdahahah that makes it a lot better

[@keyproblems7590]

I love how Lundy thought it was Dexter until they found the blood slides in Doakes car. Even then, when LaGuerta tried to to prove Doakes innocent, he told her to find better evidence he can use. I think deep down Lundy knew it was Dexter

[@fabianhammer2864]

cant believe Travis Chase was the Dex Day Doomer, truly up there with Louis being in Isaac Sirkos Imagination, all along

[@Pmilum]

It's like L Vs Kira . L knows but can't prove it . And in the end L dies

[@thefrenchfieldnigga8078]

@keyproblems7590 " I think deep down Lundy knew it was Dexter " BINGO 🤝🤝

[@amartyaroy3754]

If deep down Lundy knew he wouldn't be able to bang Debra 😂

[@Asignuva]

I think Lundy knew it was Dexter as well

[@Zegin17]

It always felt like Lundy suspected Dexter more than Doakes, but all evidence pointed to Doakes so he had to believe it. Especially in season 4, it almost seemed like he was planning to use Dexter to take down Trinity and then use that to bust Dexter, but in the end, he died before he could.

[@rubenoteiza9261]

The possibilty that few if anyone has considered is that Lundy could have suspected that both Dexter and Doakes were working together and that their feud was only a cover and that they finally fought because one of them panicked and wanted out. That would explain to him why Doakes ran away with the slides. I dont know if serial killers work in teams but for Lundy this looked a lot like a vigilante job so couldnt discard a team of them. That is why he set up Dexter, to see his reaction when he would shove the slides in his face.

[@Zegin17]

@@rubenoteiza9261 Some serial killers have worked together in the past, but in those cases they are normally family or something like that; the main issue with that theory, is that Lundy was certain that it was only a single individual, he knew it was only one, so I doubt he would have suspected both Doakes and Dexter, I honestly think his True suspect was Dexter, and he probably also suspected a frame job, but without full proof, no way to convict; I also believe that he was planning to tell Debra before his death in season 4; the show loved to leave things for the audience to solve from time to time.

[@Maimonides19]

@@Zegin17killers definitely work in teams all the time - gangs, armies, etc. the only evidence pointing away from Doakes is that he might have been on special forces missions when some killings were happening - that might point to an accomplice. Hard to believe doakes would be innocent given all the evidence implicating him and his own suspicious behavior (storming out of interview,running away when arrest warrant was issued)

[@hindenburg1596]

​@@Zegin17 No

[@NJ-wb1cz]

​@@hindenburg1596 no

[@gasparcarlos13]

I can't believe how close they got with their suspicions about it being one of their own in the police department and when they found a rack full of blood slides they didn't think "oh the blood guy" lmaooooooooooooooooooooooooo

[@CannedPsycho-]

Well they found it in Doakes’ car and Doakes is 1: Very sus, 2: hiding evidence, and 3: avoiding the authorities.

[@youngmaster2072]

​@CannedPsycho- also Ex special forces assassin with multiple shootings on the job.......

[@mindfork]

"Actually it's two." "Actually it's two." "Uh oh." The delivery of that line kills me, pun absolutely intended.

[@TheUrionak]

Also how he starts slowly looking around with his eyes widening absolutely perfect

[@FurryWulfz]

It was smart of Dexter to manipulate lundy into believing he had done sloppy work, which threw him right off the butcher's trail in terms of Dexter, as the Butcher was extremely methodical down to the smallest detail.

[@dickfitswell3437]

Doakes was the Bay Harbor Butcher. You know that right?

[@llarmstrong783]

They really were making it look like Lundy suspected Dexter

[@ameliakyle7054]

and he did it in a believeable way, at first not wanting to admit he screwed up and finally admiting albeit with excuses, how he made such an error.

[@DeathHelper420]

Well everyone makes mistakes and will never be perfect, Dexter didn't know someone else who knew a lot of blood was Lundy himself and he is messy. He didn't do it on purpose for a cover up, he messed up

[@AndreCaine]

He did it so he would be released and killed by him.

[@felipeamado8615]

i cant believe mike Ehrmantraut was the bay harbor butcher

[@fabianhammer2864]

i cant believe ray speltzer sent masuka the barrel girl discs, crazy bastard

[@SL1CK_K7LLA]

This is Mike's twin brother

[@ConquestadorExplore]

Fun fact, this appearance in dexter happened before breaking bad season 1 even got released. Which means this is og mike

[@Multi18only]

Lundy was my favorite character on the show. He never felt like an antagonist even though he was the greatest threat in season 2.

[@1mclv]

I think Dexter would've accepted it if Lundy was the one that caught him.

[@gijane2cantwaittoseeyou203]

@@1mclv But certainly not Vince Masuka

[@Arto343434]

“There is no such thing as the perfect crime. Not in my experience anyway.” - Special Agent Frank Lundy before he ever had any experience with Dexter Morgan

[@anttitheinternetguy3213]

Tbh dexters crimes werent perfect, he just always managed to myddy the water from within their own circles. If he didnt work as an police officer he would have been caught

[@rubenoteiza9261]

Dexter had not one or two but three nemesis in S02: Doakes, Lundy and Lila. His genius mixed with his luck allowed him to play two of them against the third and so destroy the most lethal and powerful he ever had, Lundy. Without interference by Doakes there is 100% chances that Lundy would have gotten him.

[@reeapeerr]

Dexter was specifically trained by his foster father. Works out well

[@Guyvermectin]

Except he eventually made mistakes and got found out like Lundy mentioned

[@wologan1080]

Wasn't the Trinity Killer basically a perfect crime for Lundy since he really never caught him

[@william1238ify]

I always forget how funny Dexters internal thoughts were.

[@rdrrr]

The "oh no." is the funniest one. It's so understated

[@Eva-ed4ed]

This is one of those scenes when you can see that Dexter does indeed feel love; his first instinct after seeing a picture of his dead brother, the one he didn’t want to kill but had to, was to look at his sister to see if she was okay. Not his own feelings, his own weird sadness. His sister.

[@Eva-ed4ed]

@@rubenoteiza9261 I think you don’t understand my point. Dexter feels things, but doesn’t know how to recognise those feelings, and act upon them. He has been basically handicapped in terms of emotional intelligence because he genuinely believed he feels nothing, as his father told him. Dexter was a child with antisocial behaviour who got turned into a killer by his father. He is beyond normalcy because he is stuck in a wrongful understanding of who he is, and has been fucked up beyond recovery. That’s why he often acts as if he doesn’t care, and then when consequences come, he seems distraught or worried. My boy tried to kill himself when Deb died, but took him a 10 minute conversation with Bryan to decide wether he could kill Deb or not. He has emotional blindness.

[@endless_sands]

i mean.. honestly there's tons of moments even in the early seasons that point to dexter never being this "unfeeling killer" that his father inplanted in him. Like when he killed someone and showed it to harry, wanting to make him proud. imo if dexter got some actual therapy instead of being brought to an actual crime scene (which is mentioned in S8) and being taught some nonsense code about how to manage his "urges to kill" he could've totally been normal. a prime example of this is when the dark defender is shown (an in universe comic book character based on the bay harbor butcher) his first thought was to save his mom and brother. Dexter cares about the people close to him.

[@NJ-wb1cz]

​@@endless_sands I think this is more of a case of writers always writing bad guys this way because it's understandable to people. People genuinely can't relate to a psychopath, but the writers need the readers to relate to characters and those writers also don't understand psychopaths themselves. So they create a vision that they understand for others, one built on misconceptions and tropes, one that doesn't actually construct a real person but a vehicle to produce the same impressions a real person could've produced.

[@MrShisuto]

15:32 I'd like to think Dexter felt actual, genuine fear at this moment because of how smart Lundy was that he could see through his tricks.

[@cipcervantes15]

Lmao that “bullshit” was completely pure panic and denialism 😂 5:37

[@ClifordMosia-hf9zi]

Dexter releases a manifesto which consequently led to Lundy seeing through it , backfiring 101

[@catslino5037]

The blood samples payoff is one of the best twists in any show. Right up there with Don Héctor's chair or Ned Stark's bad haircut

[@rorybarber5076]

I remember being so fucking tense when watching Dexter be brought in. What a rush.

[@catslino5037]

​@@rorybarber5076 It was pure luck yet also totally justified within the story

[@clyde15]

I’m still on season 1, but knowing Doakes is the Bay Harbor Butcher really explains why he’s always so angry and cursing all the time.

[@_..Yuki._.]

Lundy: had these parts coming from 1 body. Dexter thinks: actually its 2. Lundy: Actually its 2. Dexter: uh oh.

[@aldobanuelos6614]

Bro we all saw the video what the fuck are you doing.

[@jazzyje5ter223]

Damn you got lazy didn’t even make the dialogue look like dialogue lmao

[@kiryodama3663]

It's like there's an odd echo around here... 😅

[@davidskrzypek2828]

Never understood that part. Did they imply the Butcher mixed body parts from 2 victims into the same garbage bags ?

[@marctm7614]

@@davidskrzypek2828 Some of the bags were ripped open and Dexter was shown to put a single person in multiple bags.

[@xvince2002]

Lundy knew. How could he not? Its the order of what happened. "What happens now?" from Dexter. "Seargent James Doakes." from Lundy. The repeat from dexter, questioning, the sigh of relief right after. The way they stand in a circle literally around him and he's the only one sitting. This was a semi-final test by Lundy to put Dexter in a semi-ambiguous situation to see if he crumbles. No proof, but suspicion. The way he says "Dexter, it'll keep Doakes at bay." You can just see it. When they greet and Dexter asks "Hows my favourite serial killer hunter?" All of it. He knew.

[@SolaceWhore]

Great point, but he did not say “favorite serial killer hunter” he said “favorite blood spatter analyst” But yes, he knew, and I’m sick of people saying he didn’t. They clearly need a lesson on what sub text is

[@luciusdebeers6176]

​​@@SolaceWhoreI'm sick of tired of "fans" trying to fit round pieces in square holes because of what they want to see themselves. Him knowing doesn't fit his character at all.

[@FoxxyCZ]

Always bugged me how no one notices that a big chunk of time was missing from the marina recordings, after Dexter deleted it.

[@HMan2828]

Unless someone else saw it before it was deleted, they would have no reason to suspect anything... The cameras are motion activated, they only record when the detect movement. Delete the file and there was just no movement at that time... Of course if they did forensics on the drive they would probably find the file and even restore it...

[@thebigivalbowlski]

I hate the fact how Agent Lundy died, it was so pointless. He was a great character. I loved his interactions with Dexters

[@HNHDebates]

yeah but his time was def up

[@thebigivalbowlski]

@@HNHDebates the actor contract or the character?

[@HNHDebates]

@@thebigivalbowlski character, his arc was already fulfilled basically

[@SolaceWhore]

I completely disagree. But to each their own Coming from him being one of my favorites in the show as well

[@ActivistTigers]

I like how ludy explaing doakes credits really explains doakes "surprise mfer" reaction when dexter caught him up in that dock yard. The abused professional assassin- "how tf is this lab geek grappling me?!"

[@NBHKLilK]

Can’t believe it’s all going to hopefully come full circle in Dexter resurrection

[@YoYo7_2_1]

🙏

[@Rupture28]

@@YoYo7_2_1🙏🙏🙏 prayers in chat

[@adamhououin]

If he does, the sentence "something left a hollow place inside" will have a new meaning after being shot by Harrison.

[@Hemskelol]

21:23 that moment when they found blood slides and didn't suspect the creepy blood guy

[@khrashingphantom9632]

Thank you for posting this! It is BEAUTIFULLY cut together and the quality is top notch. It’s good to gather with other Dexter fans and also kinda rewatch a series I really enjoyed (in the beginning). Lol. This was also my 1st show to ever “binge watch” on Netflix. The second was Breaking Bad. Lol. Thanks again.

[@TehFreakCA]

The way Debra got choked up when the Ice Truck Killer showed up on screen was great foreshadowing that she would get butchered by the bay harbor.

[@the___dude]

tf

[@antemarkic6988]

22:55 best crossover ever

[@odatnarat14]

Kid named bay harbor butcher:

[@mandm7878]

The fact Dexter uses blood slides in work is a big cauae for suspicion

[@distinguishedallureproduct879]

That alone should have gotten Dexter caught up, If Doakes was the Bay Harbour and his dad was a Butcher, and Doakes suffering from PTSD from Military time....why would he be so precise and almost OCD about how he cut up, disposed of, and sneaking, when Doakes was always a hot head, aggressive and messy

[@endless_sands]

oh no, it's much worse than you think. **the miami metro police do NOT use blood slides. At all. This is important in season 7.** this means the person would've had to have their own interest in blood, because doakes couldn't even theoretically have been doing it to put blame on dexter who he had been saying he didn't trust for a long time.

[@ocifer]

Lots of professions use blood slides, but it is at least circumstantial enough to look into

[@electroxexual]

You guys seem to think blood slides are some niche items that only few professionals use. You can just buy them from a shop and they are used by medical students.

[@kibbit1373]

12:27 how is that good when Lundy literally gave her the answer. That's like saying x + 10 = 15, him saying 5 + 10 and her being like ... x is 5!

[@funkyfranx]

I think it was tongue-in-cheek, he was congratulating her for her uncouth language rather than her deduction. He says _'very good,_ Officer Morgan,' in a (playfully) patronising, school teacher way

[@fbmfbmfbm]

The "Very Good" was said in a different kind of tone

[@gustavolopes5094]

Then she'd be wrong. In that example, x is not 120, it's 5.

[@kibbit1373]

@@gustavolopes5094 what? No one claimed x is 120?

[@gustavolopes5094]

@@kibbit1373 Yes you did. It's literally your last sentence. "... x is 5!", it isn't, it's 5.

[@phoqueme]

"You owe me a new Michelin mothafu..." 🤣🔥 Doakes was the best

[@soulsilvergaming4833]

Miami in the mid to late 2000s was a whole ass aesthetic. This show and burn notice were my favorites at 10-13 years old

[@retrobiggy]

I forgot how good season 2 was. Absolutely incredible.

[@rubenoteiza9261]

By far the most thrilling, during which Dexter actually had to fight for his life. In all other seasons, bar one, he could just retreat and let go, not in this one. Fighting with 3 enemies at once.

[@adrianmorin1053]

“Actually it’s two” ”actually it’s two” “Uh oh”😂

[@diamondexed5331]

I was crying laughing and didn’t see any comments about it

[@investlikeawarrior]

I'll never forget how intense the scene of Dexter in the hot seat. I've never felt that kinda anxiety while watching a show before.

[@AaronHarmon-k6w]

Thats the moment that Lindy became Heisenberg

[@romansweik]

Bravo Vince

[@JBRewind]

​@@romansweik Masuka?

[@Cognitive_Fun]

I love that if you edit Dexter out as much as possible it really does look like Doakes is the Bay Harbor Butcher

[@endless_sands]

i made a huge comment then accidentally refreshed the page, but yeah. to other people's perspective Doakes acts pretty violent and obsesses over dexter.

[@TacticalSocks]

Lundy figuring out the Butcher was involved within LE still remains one of the best moments I've ever seen in a series.

[@sarojandongol1482]

I didn't like how the season concluded with Lundy finding out who the Bar Harbor Butcher was. The show is called DEXTER. Dexter should've done more and contributed greatly for the find.

[@imthebestmayne122]

18:09 is one of the best scenes in the entire show

[@wraith1117]

Carradine, and I've seen him is some many other shows and characters, owned this Lundy bit like a champ. The Writing, and acting, made this character something special, to an already special show. Man oh man he delivered to this.

[@b.a.p.2731]

5:38 “bullsh**😳… I mean, REALLY🤓??” 😂😂

[@tudo_na_pratica]

Dexter got really shocked when he found out Doakes was the Bay Harbour Butcher 😂

[@francocruz75]

Lundy was one of my favorite characters he was the only one who was able to read dexters patterns like a book and call him on his shit in a logical and calm way. Doaks was awesome, too, but he kept getting in his own way with his emotional outburst.

[@OnTheShouldersOfGiants64]

I always felt like they should have found the Bay Harbor Butcher bodies later in the series. It would have been so awesome if every body they pulled up was a callback to a previous episode that the audience had seen and maybe even had a little flashback or Dexter doing an internal monolouge saying their name and remembering what they had done. It also would have allowed for Doakes and Dexter to play their cat and mouse game longer which was my favorite part of the show.

[@all9472]

1:05 oh....oh hes smart lol

[@jtrapp651]

uh oh

[@marty1459]

Surely Dexter's finger prints would have been all over that wooden box and blood slides.

[@alejandrosanchez6404]

Yeah they were but they made him in charge of it so he just took off the fingerprints from what I remember

[@rubenoteiza9261]

That was useless as evidence. First, the slides had been found in Doakes' car which at that moment had framed himself already by becoming a fugitive and anyway Dexter could have easily taken care of it: "Of course my FPs are all over! They are MY slides, I work with them! And every time I receive a batch I take them one by one and I inspect them closely to verify they are in good condition! Doakes stole them before I could use them" And that would have ended there.,

[@WingsOfHeartFailures]

What this guy said ^

[@DemonicRobots]

What the other guy said, and they found it in Doakes car and didn't think there were 2 people.

[@buhklao]

1:00 - 1:04 i recognize the scope sound from Halo anywhere

[@Whoisrem]

22:52 Mike lore

[@Caio-ow5tm]

lol

[@onlineidssuck]

Never knew he was in this. Lmao

[@Badartist888]

Back when the show was properly written. Realistic progress on the case. Everyone has their moments of smarts and adds to the narrative. All connected nicely.

[@minder01]

I am fully in the camp that Lundy knew but approved of what Dexter did.

[@Arto343434]

Potentially. I thought Dexter was pretty oblivious to be neatly organizing his forensic tools to a compulsive degree when he was with Lundy in the train car AS Lundy was profiling how the BHB was someone who was extremely careful and meticulous. There was more to that scene that helps your opinion. I’m not sure I believe Lundy knew, or if he was like Dexter in the sense that if there wasn’t clear evidence others had found on their own, he wasn’t going to divert the investigation towards Dexter if that’s who he suspected. He looked disappointed when Doakes turned up dead because I think in his heart of hearts he didn’t think Doakes was him, but Dexter. But the evidence pointed to Doakes and he wasn’t going to fight it.

[@Pat4ever.]

It's a nonsense theory and you didn't pay attention to the show/Lundy's character if you think this.

[@elrenegat61]

Are you stupid ? He wanted to catch him at all cost, couldn't you see ? The one that most probably knew was the one that took his retirement and was trying to discourage laguerta

[@elmagistradofk6286]

Of course he would let Doakes die just cause he thinks Dexter does a fine job

[@perrycarters3113]

@@Arto343434 Lundy simply, imo, did not have it in him to 'go rogue' with his theories by setting his sights on someone like Dexter and then simply not acting on it. Without the music, Dexter's narration or foreknowledge that Dexter was the BHB, those scenes probably look fairly normal, and we'd buy Lundy's explanation that he simply didn't like Masuka at face value. Lundy was thorough, insightful and intelligent but strictly by-the-book. If he suspected Dexter, it would have been laughably easy to get a GPS tap on Dexter's phone to figure out his comings and goings and pick up that he was in the Everglades at the cabin, and he never would have entertained a relationship with Debra. COULD he have looked the other way and helped LaGuerta get her evidence through and buried the phone call she had with Doakes? Yes, easily. But he is GENUINELY frustrated that she screwed up a chance to get potentially exonerating evidence for Doakes into the system. And sadly, eventually, the only legitimate evidence LaGuerta COULD provide came from a deeply unreliable source, and Doakes was never able to tell anyone his side of the story. The only one who could come to his defense was LaGuerta, and he gave her no information to work with. And despite his reservations due to LaGuerta's inadmissible evidence, he accepts the conclusion that Doakes was the BHB because, as he says, "The evidence is compelling. Overwhelming, in fact." And he simply, by the book, accepts the verdict and moves on with his life, chalking it up as a case where there was something he missed.

[@PhiLLyPhiLLz]

Truly epic writing and storytelling. I remember looking forward to new episodes. Dexter had me completely hooked.

[@The_Jim]

18:50 - “Explain it to us” 😂 why would rockstar serial killer hunter Frank Lundy need the blood spatter analyst to explain that these are trophies.

[@crispaz4180]

I guess he was expecting him to tell them about the extraction method or if they can be analized, not to tell them what they already knew

[@The_Jim]

@@crispaz4180 but all Dexter says is “trophies”, and Frank responds, “just as I thought”. This implies he was looking for confirmation.

[@gustavolopes5094]

​@@The_JimI thought of that too, but I came to the conclusion that Lundy was expecting to confirm it because he didn't know if they had any other function. If they could be used for anything besides trophies by the BHB.

[@lordkronos5470]

Dexter opens a mysterious box and when opened without hesitation, he passes his fingers through the slides. That was extremely suspicious. 😅

[@El_Crazyknight]

When Lundy is going over the cases with Dexter and shows he also knows about Blood analysis and you see Dexter basically in true fear and almost speechless trying to find a good believable excuse is just an epic moment in the series , at that point Dexter knew he was punching a bit above his weight at least for a moment.

[@mrautismo420]

23:27 girl better watch it before Gus pulls up

[@tango5275]

When Dexter said “uh oh” made me burst out laughing

[@pinacoleadas1912]

Honestly, I feel like this show did their plot lines backwards. I feel like revealing his brother as the ice truck killer and Dexter’s kills finally being discovered should’ve been saved for the final seasons, not the first two. This show really went out with a whimper in my opinion

[@greedojenkins9984]

Ya it was strange for a tv show to do that. Based off clips I thought the ITK would’ve been in the last season

[@rubenoteiza9261]

Now that you mention it that could have been arranged easily. The Ice Truck killer suddenly disappears, the kilings stops, no one knows why and then he reappears in the last season and what happened is that he had been caught and was from s02 to so7 in prison or in a mental hospital because he had been wrongly convicted of some unrelated crime or he had a nervous breakdown.

[@jonseon5952]

Book 1 was the Ice Truck Killer plot too just so you know

[@alexmartin3143]

Twice

[@shardj5151]

Once they found out that the bay harbour butcher was in law enforcement, isn't that the obvious time to hand the case over to the feds

[@jaesjmes5498]

I love his “uh oh” in the first scene lol, it just sounds so funny to me

[@abominablesnowman64]

Lmao Dex always looked so guilty I dont know how he wasnt caught on that alone.

[@courier6960]

I think it was him being an awkward “lab geek” combined with his nervousness being mistaken for shock when being told bad news. Not to bring down the mood, but for a real life comparison I remember watching a news report of a guy that murdered his female neighbor, at the time of the report he was acting like a friend of hers and that she was missing, but when the reporter told him the news that the police had just found the body he got visibly upset to the point of borderline crying and having to sit on the curb, in the moment it looked like he was grieving his friend, when in reality he was crying at the fact that he knew he was caught.

[@rubenoteiza9261]

If you judge and condemn people for looking guilty half of mankind would be behind bars.

[@_Cujo_]

@@courier6960 Stephen McDaniel. His interrogation footage is pretty creepy as well. He basically just sits stock still in the chair, not moving a muscle, for hours on end. The detectives can't get anything out of him longer than a yes or a no. Absolute tragedy what he did to her. They still don't know exactly why he did it but suspect it's cause she was moving out soon. Although, he was no Dexter. When they searched his room they found just mountains of evidence against him. He even had videos on his computer of him hiding and filming Lauren in her apartment the night he killed her so he wasn't getting out of anything. Plus they found a bunch of evidence of child related stuff, if you catch my drift. He's still rotting in jail, thank god.

[@mostlyneutral]

Yeah that person was an absolute creep. So sad for the woman. She was even being nice to him eventhough she thought him of a weirdo​@@_Cujo_

[@MrDCHun]

Lundy's relationship w/ Deb still creeps me out.

[@rdrrr]

Deb's character is so weird. Deb relationship drama is such a drag and the show would certainly be better without it

[@rubenoteiza9261]

I think what makes it even creepier is that there was absolutely zero chemistry between them. One of the (main) raisons viewers feel repelled at things like this is that one or both actors hate being there, I dont know about she but from the first moment I felt that Carradine couldn't wait for the love scenes to end and if you notice he doesn't act naturally, like a real lover, but always with a rather dumb smile in his face, which is the best he can do I guess.

[@SolaceWhore]

@@rubenoteiza9261yeah I straight just skipped the scenes, I wasn’t trying to watch all that lol

[@alexmartin3143]

A bit

[@briefcasefullofbacon7291]

This is truly the moment Doakes became the bay harbor butcher. Bravo Vince.

[@NoahBranch503]

Fed's investigating a police department 😂 Unions, lawyers and politicians would be coming out the wood work😂

[@dashuntas.m4045]

News media as well going on about “an attack on the police” 😂

[@notddead]

2:45 Dexter when he asks Agent Lundy if he also watches Talk Tuah

[@nicolevangellecom6405]

if looks could kill Agent Lundy would be dead at 3:33

[@jarusai9213]

0:10 is where you can see the bay harbor butcher

[@harrybaldino8955]

Yup their he is James

[@HermeticDawn17]

Suprise muthafucka !

[@SpaceBaked]

I thought she was the captain????

[@longebane]

Deb is the BHB

[@MrBoss-re6lp]

No, 0:13

[@JacketCK]

I still can't believe Lundy was the bay harbor butcher

[@fabianhammer2864]

it was so crazy, when it was revealed, that vince and hannah left miami, in the very same ice truck, that belonged to kyle mitchell, who was really louis, all along

[@jameshollister8294]

Not seeing dexter as a suspect is crazy

[@jlau9268]

Batman is the worst resemblance to Dexter to give cause one of his biggest traits is that he absolutely refuses to kill even the most derranged people.

[@rador3573]

Vigilantism nonetheless

[@jlau9268]

@@rador3573 That part is true.

[@drmidge]

2:46 say that again

[@romanticizingSolitude]

Talk tuah ya

[@yesusjoestar4333]

Oh no

[@Viberac]

GET OUT OF MY HEAD, GET OUT OF MY HEAD, GET OUT OF MY HEAD, GET OUT OF MY HEAD, GET OUT OF MY HEAD, GET OUT OF MY HEAD, GET OUT OF MY HEAD, GET OUT OF MY HEAD, GET OUT OF MY HEAD, GET OUT OF MY HEAD, GET OUT OF MY HEAD, GET OUT OF MY HEAD, GET OUT OF MY HEAD, GET OUT OF MY HEAD, GET OUT OF MY HEAD, GET OUT OF MY HEAD, GET OUT OF MY HEAD, GET OUT OF MY HEAD, GET OUT OF MY HEAD, GET OUT OF MY HEAD, GET OUT OF MY HEAD, GET OUT OF MY HEAD, GET OUT OF MY HEAD, GET OUT OF MY HEAD, GET OUT OF MY HEAD, GET OUT OF MY HEAD,

[@celestiangaming87]

Dude! Lundy knew Dexter was him! He was disappointed that he couldn't give a better explanation about the blood spatter. His step dad told him what Dexter was.

[@finlaytemple1744]

No

[@rubenoteiza9261]

Harry never met Lundy, for all we know, even if Mathews was his friend. In any case Lundy had no idea of Dexter's family story.

[@harcusrenover]

Lundy rock that hairstyle

[@salsa_2239]

Captain Mathew’s really did shut Lundy up😂

[@ianorndorff1436]

Thank you TikTok and KZbin for finally getting this show more recognition that it so badly deserves

[@albert-i2d4r]

22:52 Did not think I would find Mike Ehrmantraut here. What are you doing here?

[@mosestheartman4814]

lol same

[@tylergagnon4850]

11:45 no detective working with the FBI would doubt the validity of linguistics after the unabomber case

[@siah7590]

I can't believe Rita was the Doomsday Butcher

[@atarifan80]

“Bullsh…I mean, really??”😂😂

[@AlanElChato]

22:53 Holy Molly, Kid named Finger!

[@awesomeguy-rq8zw]

MIKE EHRMANTRAUT???

[@llarmstrong783]

He plays a cop really good

[@camron.w1841]

Genuinely had a heart attack when I saw him

[@schneir5]

I can't believe it took Deb so many seasons to figure out that Dexter was a serial killer. I figured it out by season three. I watched a lot of other police shows, though. 🤔

[@endless_sands]

ok wahlburg, relax with the "If I was on that plane with my kids, it wouldn't have went down like it did"

[@Death_InOne_Form]

H-he was a serial killer?

[@Drehirth]

I think he’s joking 😂

[@GenericVideoPlayer]

I mean, I figured out in the first episode of the show where dexter said ke was a serial killer and then serial killed someone, but yours is valid too

[@Harry-r9v]

They always implied Rockstar agent had a sense of Dexter as the butcher

[@newmoneymadeit]

Still can't believe Hank Schrader was the bay harbour butcher

[@emichels]

No matter who you are and what year it is, I will ALWAYS watch Dexter with you. I'm writing you in 2064.........

[@frostyy7845]

If only they fingerprinted those slides and the box

[@randallmcgrath9345]

"Heres whats gonna happen Dexter."-Mike (probably)

[@eggheadusa]

1:18 Don’t let the mob hear that

[@GabrielDonhauser]

9:20 dont know how masuka didnt see dexter's legs behind the chair xD

[@jptaylor74]

So Dexter has a boat in the harbor with the algae, works with blood in a lab, the trophies are lab slides with blood, is very meticulous and methodical...but they bought Doakes was the Bay Harbor Butch? Right.

[@ultrasuper1600]

Doakes had the slides and dipped out the country and went rogue. Lundy was onto Dex just couldn’t tie together. Mike ehrmantrout wanted the case closed asap

[@Masterfrodos]

Still can't believe that Nickacavo Avocado was the Bay Harbor Butcher