Elden Ring Lore - Sir Gideon Ofnir, The All Assuming

[@gabez95]

Gideon should wear a Santa suit tonight and call himself the All-Giving

[@jacobberry5138]

… with a bucket of KFC.

[@spacecowboy5486]

Santa Loux, chieftain of the north pole The ever brilliant Jingle mask Fia, the christmas tree companion The loathsome coal eater AND SIR GIDEON OFNIR, THE ALL GIVING

[@AirSoftFattyIsMyDaddy]

Only to Christians tho...

[@ozsun9736]

He definitely gave his all on that albunaric village!

[@jacobberry5138]

@@AirSoftFattyIsMyDaddy Yes. Everyone can have their own thing, but you can join in without being Christian. To be honest, Christmas has more pagan roots than being about Jesus Christ. I hope you have a Merry Christmas!

[@bmg6229]

Gideon was extremely powerful, and extremely knowledgeable His mistakes were assuming he knew better than us, and that he was still more powerful than us

[@matthewmclean9607]

I wouldn’t say he’s powerful. I’m on ng+ 8 and I can one shot him 😂

[@mushroomsrcool1449]

@@matthewmclean9607 he THOUGHT he was more powerful, more smart, more knowledgeable.

[@C_The_Guy]

hes powerful, and hes fast, but precision beats power, and timing beats speed.

[@Psilo-gn1sx]

I think what Gideon witnessed wasn't Marika's will, it was Radagon's. We don't know much about Marika, except that she had active machinations against the GW. "Preserving the Order and having Tarnished struggle for eternity" seems a lot more like Radagon's deal.

[@square-table-gaming]

Assuming he didn't know the truth about Marika and Radagon this would make sense!

[@pixelty7458]

@@square-table-gaming it would seem like he did not know since even goldmask could not fathom why radagon was named as the one god along with marika until you discover it. so it seems like he is also under that lie

[@mlmii1933]

The issue that I have with assuming Gid (who is shown to be a competent scholar and spy master throughout the game) is simply wrong about Marika's plans is that there are two potential motives for Marika and both can be interpreted where Gid is 'mostly right'. Maraki's motivation is to be 'eternal' ... in this case Gid is completely right as in order to be truly and forever immortal the realm has to stay in its present state, the Greater Will can't be allowed the opportunity to announce any more potential heirs and the Tarnished by and large play a destabilizing role to prevent anyone from gaining the throne. ... In this case Gid's only mistake is not understanding the plot armor being the PC in a video game provides the Tarnished of No Renown. Marika's motivation is to strike a blow against the Greater Will itself by having the Tarnish slay her and truly destroying the Elden Ring and its cycles of Gods and Divine Trees. ... In this case Gid's mistake is assuming that a God can not truly be slain, although he is only partially wrong given that in the two cases where Maraki is truly slain the the Elden Ring isn't restored another God takes her place, either Ranni or the Frenzy Flame.

[@petercselik5674]

​@@mlmii1933 I think its the last one. I do believe Marika secretly want change. Anything than the enternal existence. She show rebellion against the greater will and seems as ling as the player seems bringing change to the world she willign to keep it alive by the grace. Even if the player go with the frenzy flame she dont mind and that's the only case when she can see the player intention. Every other ending is the players decision so if the player eventually decide to restore the golden order and set the greater will back on top is something she couldn't predict and for her that's considered as a bad ending.

[@amebchen]

One thing everyone ignores is his sheer wrist strength to weild that mace at 90 degrees to his body while holding it at the grip when there's like 1,2m metal pole that ends up with a hand holding something that looks heavy and he just handles it like a toothpick. That's why he's so badass.

[@whatsnewbois9814]

His conection to Seluvis is interesting; they seem to have been working together at some point, at the albenauric village there is a Omenkiller at the end that we can fight with Nepheli (similar Omenkiller that we can find possesed in Seluvis hidden lab), one puppet in particular paints a clearer picture: Dolores the sleeping Arrow a Roumdtablehold member that was a Crititc/friend to Gideon. It was because of her that Seluvis and Gideon went both their seperate ways...

[@square-table-gaming]

We talk about her in the 3rd episode of the tarnished files, super interesting character. I honestly wonder if selivus is the reason Gideon knows to look in the albinauric village for the haligtree medallion. There's a strong theory about selivus being a puppet of pidia's that's worth exploring.

[@King_WhiteWolf]

@@square-table-gaming Speaking of that theory, you are almost certainly aware of this already, but just in case you're not, SmoughTown did a whole video exploring this theory at great length. It's called "Is Seluvis Pidia's Puppet?". It could probably serve as an invaluable piece of content in your research of the subject.

[@Cman04092]

​@@King_WhiteWolf while i like the theory for fun reasons, i don't beleive it. People say when selevus dies so does pida, but pida dies after selevus, at least for me. I even watched pida die while rocking selevus's armor for kicks. I think it more likey that they're just friends, but pida couldn't control puppets anymore once selevus bites the big one.

[@maximedaunis8292]

​@@Cman04092But what about their voice?

[@darklordauron]

I think if Ofnir became Elden Lord, he would bring about an age of unending "perfection." A hell on earth where everything is known and anything that steps out of line is destroyed. Every grain of sand, every flap of a wing, every stone and beat of a heart, would play out according to what Ofnir knows/demands-to-be.

[@azathoth2067]

He would become odin

[@sevenclovers7]

The chaos of order as it were

[@TheDoomsdayzoner]

The only mistake Gideon has made is making the enemy of us. We felled Radahn, Mohg, Malenia, Renalla, Morgott, Rykard, Maliketh - what hope did he had?! He saw what we did to all of them through his Scarabs. He stole their incantations and spells. Yet he never bothered to think for a moment: "If that Tarnished so easily felled Demigods, should I really be opposing them?! This Tarnished slayed Dragons, Gargoyles, Dragonkin, and even godlike creatures like Rune Bears of the Mountaintop. There is no way to oppose this thing without sacrificing one's life." But alas, his hubris has proven to be his downfall.

[@HoldMyBong]

Edited with more spelling mistakes is crazy

[@High-Overlord-Snarffie-Pug]

I like that he's the last enemy before the end, and that the one thing he doesn't believe to be possible is the only thing that happens in game that he doesn't get to see and know.

[@jackirish9022]

Or he saw something so terrifying that he was desperate to stop you as they say stare into the abyss and the abyss stares back

[@colorgreen8728]

Gideon was the almost all knowing, yes, but he had wisdom. Wisdom would not let a town be slaughtered, wisdom would not go against the most powerful tarnished he’s probably ever seen, wisdom may have figured out the true feeling of marika

[@just70hq]

Almost definitely the strongest tarnished he’s met

[@lmSheep]

You mean he didnt have wisdom lol?

[@Floww57]

I like to think before he fought us he was going to steal the Elden ring but then him and Godfrey awkwardly just looked at each other before he ran away at just the right time for us to show up

[@puncherofbread]

Overall good video on Gideon although info have a slightly different interpretation of him as a villain. I see Gideon as a man trying to be a true monster and failing because he can never rid himself entirely of his humanity. When you get Seluvis' potion, Gideon will have corresponding dialogue about the potion, opting that you give it to him and just lie to Seluvis. Sure this could just be him screwing over Seluvis but he'll still give you the option even after he disowned Nepheli. I always interpreted that to mean that even after disowning her Gideon still cares about her to some degree. It could also be why he disowned her, because he was attached to her and didn't want someone who he cared about to know what he'd done. He even acknowledges you if you finish Nepheli's quests. That's why he keeps Ensha around is because Ensha doesn't ask questions or even talk. I also theorize that Gideon also knew long before the end that a tarnished could never become Elden Lord but still chose to try anyway.

[@theblocksays]

It always kinda cracked me up how his helmet made him look like a Nazgul with ears carved onto the bottom rim.

[@jeniskindof]

The first time I met him my first thought was not to trust him. i mean who else has a Jojo villain guarding him?

[@amorphisbrito9937]

When I first ever fought Gideon I was soo shocked and it came to me as a surprise because of how helpful I thought he was when I was first playing as he was giving me those rewards for giving him info. I then later realized in my next play thru after going to get the secret medallion what he had done. I do believe if he became elden lord he would go mad with power

[@Nightwalker170]

As for how Gideon came to lead the Round Table, we gain some insite after felling our second demi-god. The finger crone at the round table tells us that she's not ever seen so many runes together, not since "Young Gideon". This implies that in his younger days he claimed at least two runes, as well as leadership of the round table. I've always wondered though.. Which runes did he hold, and how did he lose them?

[@square-table-gaming]

They were likely runes from long dead demigods

[@AotO_DJ]

Sir Gideon has some pretty accurate parallels with Odin, the All knowing.

[@movespammerguyteam7colors]

Based on his combat encounter dialogue it makes it seem that he attempted to connect with the goddess of the Golden Order. Though there are technically 3 entities housed in the one divine body, which makes me think that he connected with the mind of Radagon who was more inclined to preserve and maintain the world versus Marika who wanted to reset or reforge the world. If it was me I would try multiple times to communicate before doing anything drastic like actively becoming a hostile guard to ward off everything.

[@coreyvortez866]

That okina fight at the beginning was legit

[@CrashCriesSometimes]

I think Gideon saw Marikas wish for a Tarnished to slay a god (which is why she tasked the blacksmith with crafting a weapon to do so). Gideon learning that this is what Marika wants, shudders in fear thinking it is impossible (i know it in my bones, a tarnished cannot kill a god) thus assuming that her will is for the tarniahed to suffer for eternity attempting to complete an impossible task.

[@colorgreen8728]

Gideon understood the golden order more than enough to know that power was everything, and so he amassed it. His own adoptive daughter used to this end, Henricus sacrificed, all for his goals

[@ckenshin3841]

Each of the Tarnished in the opening represent a different attainable ending. All except Gideon, however in a different perspective, Gideon who wished to have everyone struggle into eternity actually alludes to new game plus

[@maniacalmurderer4123]

I wish Gideon got a unique moveset as a boss, similar to how Blaidd and Melina have unique move sets and abilities as player type characters. Would’ve made his boss fight a little more exciting rather then it being a stagger contest with a overleveled mage. His lore and significance in the story are a lot more interesting then It was first let on. He deserved something neat like that.

[@theblocksays]

Surprising they didn't have him play differently in later playthrough +s where he starts using summons against you too, but it's always the ones you have leveled up yourself the most.

[@diegoidepersia]

@@theblocksays gideon the all spamming with a mimic tear

[@CsStrez]

Melina is a reskinned Black Knife Assassin. Just makes her connection to Marika even clearer.

[@theblocksays]

@@diegoidepersia Certainly be a way to punish players who relied on that too much, now you fight TWO Gideons LOL.

[@hola0759]

@@diegoidepersia Na lets let him summom a drganon like rennala.

[@rrm1903]

The moment I saw Gideon reading books in his chamber, offering demigod lore, I just had an aha moment that this guy is what Miyazaki sees the average FS lore scholar out there! It's probably wrong but I still like it.

[@square-table-gaming]

Nah, it's totally intentional, we all chase our tails and get it wrong, just like Gideon hahahaha

[@rrm1903]

@@square-table-gaming on a more serious note, who is the God we slay in the final fight? Radagon (as a representation of Marika) or the Elden Beast?

[@square-table-gaming]

@@rrm1903 Elden beast

[@rrm1903]

@@square-table-gaming so now that probably answers a question I've had: what Gideon figured that made him so hesitant? He somehow learned that we had to kill EB. Which according to Hewg is precisely what Marika intended, but yet again Gideon says Marika doesn't want us to... This is pointless isn't it? I'll never get a grasp on this game.

[@daniellewis4371]

@@rrm1903 I think that's what Radagon wants. Marika wants the tarnished to succeed in killing the elden beast and Radagon wants the opposite with gideon misinterpretting Radagon's will as Marika's.

[@Cyclops3161]

Not to nitpick your work (as it is always superb) But Old Albus is the Albinauric in the village that gives you the first part of the medallion to the Haligtree, not Pidia, who is the Albinauric who takes care of Seluvis' puppets in Caria Manor

[@square-table-gaming]

Oh God you're right. HUGE oversight. Thankfully a fairly unintrusive edit.

[@kevinmiller7408]

One thing about Nepheli, if you do the Kenneth Haight quest line, Gideon will thank you for looking out for his daughter the next time you talk to him. So while he does cast her aside when she's no longer useful to him, he seems to actually care about her to some extent.

[@DaxterL]

No that sounds like some manipulator shit he's saying to appear as if he cares. You don't cast out a family member because they disagree with slaughter and then pretend like you care for them. Just no. Ofnir doesn't have a caring bone in his body. By any means necessary, people are expandable. But of course he'll change the tune of his song to better his demeanor.

[@kevinmiller7408]

@@DaxterL Sure that's possible, but she's not there to hear it so it would be kind of pointless. And honestly, a dude disowning his adoptive daughter is like the least messed up thing going on in the lands between.

[@SophiaLilithUwU]

Iunno to me it came off as him thanking us for giving her something to do so she stops sulking in the roundtable. He even apologises to the tarnished on behalf of nepheli, because he thinks she's a burden to us as much as she was to him, so i don't think "care" is the rght word for the feelings he has for her.

[@partigianoliberal]

He then says "Sorry. For the time you had to waste". He's just an asshole

[@mikeock4924]

Knowing gideon this is some subtle way of saying "thanks, dickhead"

[@TiberiusRex182]

Sir gideon got off’d near the end of my fucking journey

[@Lila_S.]

Great video about one of the most enigmatic characters of ER. One of my favourite theories about him is the one that scarabs all over are actually his spies and that's how he knows everything. Apparently eyes on scarabs are the same as Eye Surcoat insignia. Really fun theory that fits him. GRRM loves this type of character- Masters of Whispers- with similar networks of spies: Varys, Littlefinger, Lariys Strong and of course, Bloodraven.

[@themadgamer1217]

The scarabs seem to be working for him, gathering up the ashes of war from fallen warriors throughout the lands between - the eye motif on their thorax seems to link them back to him. Has that already been talked about?

[@square-table-gaming]

Another lore channel has talked about this theory but I need more convincing, as every scarab has a different symbol, only one of them truly looks like the eye from Gideon's surcoat

[@themadgamer1217]

@@square-table-gaming really? I’ve never noticed that. I’ll look closer the next time I’m scrambling to smush one - or I might just have some common sense and use a monocular. 😂

[@HellFlame705]

after all this time, I still wonder what he saw when he looked inside Queen Marika's mind, or was it her mind that he peeked inside to begin with. Gideon is a bastard by all means but I still think he is the most note worthy tarnished aside from the player.

[@travelerofabyssrium14]

“Ofnir” is one of few names that Odin the “All-Father” uses when he travel Midgard. And Odin is also famous for being a “Knowledge Seeker”. The man literally hanged himself to gather knowledge stored in Yggrasil. So either that is a very clever details, or Gideon Ofnir is “bloody wannabe”.

[@cobrabear6497]

Gideon Ofnir reminds of Odin for Gow:Ragnarok. They both are known as "all knowing". Theyre both manipulative so they can get what they need, and they'll cast aside anyone who doesnt serve their purpose like they dont matter.

[@jeffreylu3626]

gideon literally sees me holding ever great rune and thought he stood a chance against me

[@Norinia]

2:45 Until you remember the term “Pearl Clutching.” Then his tantrum at the end makes a *ton* of sense. XD

[@DN-yv3gq]

I like how the Hold is initially full of NPCs, but by Liurnia it's just about empty

[@ianwilborn3728]

I always thought the bottom of his helmet is a beard to give it a wizard vibe and I just realized it's ears

[@Mistercodmobilefan8378]

I'm loving this channel so much of elden ring lore!! Every time i go and fight Gideon Ofnir i wonder what did Gideon ofnir read and saw that made him shuddered in fear to try and stop us to become the elden lord? Like what was queen marika's plans for us?? I hope the dlc of elden ring can explain it to us

[@leoornstein3963]

Gideon Ofnir the all coping.

[@ramageep]

I don't think we ever kill a god in elden ring, despite what the pop-up in game says, the Elden Beast was described as a more of an emissary the Outer Will sent to the lands between. The outer gods might not have a physical form, therefore cant be killed by a simple tarnished, but who knows

[@tonyogar6936]

Beautifully put together.. Thanks.

[@terminasitor769]

To me it’s so funny whenever I meet him in the end because I usually kill him before he finishes speaking.

[@Shinkiro47]

I never realized the demi gods Gideon couldnt locate were the 2 demi gods that were contacted by outer gods [Formless mother and Rot] and the last one knew how to starve off any outside influences. Its safe to say without us the Tarnished, he was never going to locate them.

[@wilburforce8046]

You know for being the all knowing he sure didn’t know a whole lot about the actual lore in elden ring. Man actually missed the whole Marika vs Greater will conflcit caused the shattering.

[@bananer87382]

I like to interpret his final word; “I know in my bones, a Tarnished cannot become a lord…” as the All-Knowing, in his last moments abandons what he knows, and chooses to go with what he feels to be true. As if he can’t accept that his endless pursuit of knowledge isn’t enough to grant him the title of Elden Lord, and that he can’t accept a newbie tarnished is to be Elden Lord instead of him.

[@AegisKHAOS]

Of all the things to learn about this man, I am thankful that Gideon LOOOOOVES to talk.

[@ImarBenIsrael]

What if Gideon in some way is a metaphor to us as a community searching for the lore and piecing things together? Think about it a bit 🤔

[@square-table-gaming]

Love that concept

[@cloroxusthestainlessone4324]

Ensha jumping the gun is like killing the merchants for their bell bearings

[@xRickAstleyx]

thats the dung eater. he runs around doing depraved and violent stuff for little to no apparent reason. his ending is pointlessly destructive and he does nothing but ruin everyones lives. hes the real player character

[@EverTM]

Gideon would start with the Pendant in DS1

[@Unclaimed_Username]

The only time I work with gideon is to get the bewitching branch blueprint for my bard. Charming enemies is super useful since they got rid of the rapport spell.

[@kalebstuart3083]

That flip over Gideon's Rancor was fresh as fuck.

[@square-table-gaming]

I honestly believe that unique ash of war is one of the most stylish attacks in the entire game

[@Mop890]

Great video, it's cool to see someone tackle Gideon. I haven't seen many videos about him at all

[@SquatchViking]

As much of an ass as Gideon is, one detail I do love about his boss fight is how his moveset changes depending on what you've done before fighting him. If you kill Mohg before fighting him, he gets Bloodboon added to his list of spells. If you kill Malenia before fighting him, he'll also get Scarlet Aeonia! One has to wonder if this is the same thing with him being able to cast Rykard's Rancor, since that is also a spell specific to killing him

[@NiceLittleWolfie]

Did anyone else think the eyes around Sir Gideon's tomb in the opening were a nod to Bloodborne? They're correlated with hidden knowledge in that game.

[@Bigboy_smooth]

Whit if Gideon glimpsed the greater will and saw what it wanted instead of queen marika. It would make sense that the greater will wants the tarnished to struggle instead of queen marika

[@FiftySpeckledRiceFan]

If he had more drip, he'd be Sir Gideon Ofnir, the All-Sowing.

[@gagemullis313]

I am curious as to who gave him the title of "Sir" as this implies he has been Knighted, but by whom?

[@tossapat027]

Funny detail Pearl on Scepter is Eyes of Full-Grown Fallingstar Beast ,Astel Kin

[@robertsoto5713]

Great video been waiting for this . Thanks appreciate your hard work.

[@tedp9945]

Just love the irony that he ended up becoming Gideon the all ignorant

[@WheatDos]

Sir Gideon Ófnir, The All-Fucker!! (Ófnir is a name of Odin in norse mythology)

[@MinimusMaximus]

Everybody once or twice felt like Gideon before taking an exam.

[@hystericbunny76]

Amazing vid man, I appreciate it. He is kinda meme. but he has a good part on the story.

[@Writh811]

I was gonna type a few sentence about how Gideon is actually weak and he realizes it and that's why he tries to pretend the goal is not to be Elden Lord but I realized that is a waste of everyone's time because it isn't the reason. Gideon is there to stall us. The junk he says in the final fight, he is trying to keep us from going to the Erdtree. He's desperate for us to give up or at least just wait a little longer. Why you ask? Well consider what is pretty much on the other side of Gideon... Godfrey. Godfrey emerged and Gideon like a good little puppy followed him out of the Roundtable Hold to the Erdtree. Gideon either offered to wait or was commanded to do so to forestall any who would interrupt Godfrey's reunion with Marika in the Erdtree. If you think I'm wrong consider these absolute facts. Gideon gives us a lot of lip service before he does anything in the fight (in fiction and in real life from the school yard to the terrible fields of war long windedness is a stall tactic). There is no one between Gideon and Godfrey. Godfrey is closer to the Erdtree than Gideon. Meaning Godfrey would have to go through Gideon or got there before him. So Gideon either saw him and stopped where he was or was commanded by Godfrey when they arrived together. While weighing those also note that Gideon was posing and waiting. Consider what would have happened if Gideon could win against us or we listen to him and give up. What's the next logical thing that happens in the sequence of events with Godfrey pretty much right at the entrance of the tree? I'm not saying he served Godfrey the whole time, but I think when Godfrey showed up Gideon saw the writing on the wall.

[@SophiaLilithUwU]

honestly, i doubt godfrey would have commanded gideon to stall any tarnished claimants. Godfrey was probably itching for a good fight when he came back to the lands between. Gideon probably just figured that's he'd have to fight both the tarnished player and godfrey for the throne and chose us first, because i did not believe we were stronger than godfrey at this point.

[@Writh811]

@@SophiaLilithUwU Because he is a great warrior who enjoys a battle does not mean he lacks a sense of priority nor the advisory command of Serosh. The world is on the brink of ending I doubt he is thinking about tossing hands for fun especially with the Elden Ring 20 feet away. As weak sauce as Gideon is, and knowns he is, there is no way he genuinely believed he was gonna fight us off and then fight Godfrey. If anything Gideon would have tried to trick us into working together since we are already listening to him. He'd have us go double team Godfrey and then he'd just stab us in the back. Not to mention, Godfrey was right at the door with it's last barrier removed it wouldn't make sense for Gideon (second closest contender to the door) to turn around stand in a pose and wait, give a discouraging speech, and pick a fight with 3rd place. The only reason Godfrey gives us any attention is because we killed his son.

[@SophiaLilithUwU]

@@Writh811 Before the battle against godfrey, morgotts body turns into guidance of grace and points godfrey directly to us. So even if the path into the erdtree is open, it seems important for godfreys personal journey to duke it out with us, after all he could just get up and enter the elden ring to have his audience with marika. So honestly the "we are not important to godfrey" doesnt fly with me. He even acknowledges how "long and hard" we fought. He clearly respects us. Godfrey believes a crown is earned with strenght. It's inconceivable to me that he would ignore the other most powerful competitors and make the race for the elden ring a race of speed and time where he wins by the technicality of "i touched it first" rather than by a test of strength and battle prowess.

[@Writh811]

@@SophiaLilithUwU I don't think we are gonna convince each other at this point lol. I would just say, yeah we were important because we killed his son and no other reason. His fight with us has nothing to do with the Elden Ring, we murdered his little boy (Serosh roars the tears Godfrey won't shed in that cutscene) and the last act of Morgott was to point the finger at his killer. Godfrey's talks of how long and hard we fought is vaguely applied, he attributes the struggle of all tarnished to the one before him. Any tarnished that walked up at that point could be assumed to have fought long and hard since they are there. Godfrey has no reason/way to know we personally fought long and hard. But he does know we fought and killed his boy. If we are so important to him beyond that what was going to be his next action if we didn't show up and events were allowed to proceed. Even if we were alive, quit the quest, and were just farting around in Jarberg after lighting the tree up. The logical answer is just walk into the Erdtree because that is what is most important at the moment. Otherwise if he was such no-think-battle-lord why hasn't he been stomping around the Lands Between until the end? What demi-gods did he bring low to get there? As far as we know Godfrey was still in the regular world beyond the fog until somehow the world became aware the Erdtree was burning and he courted a fight he knew he could lose just to show up in time to still have a say in the next Era. Weirdly there aren't very many answers beyond this one that don't make him look like he wasn't hiding in the cupboard until the thorns on the Erdtree were cleared. Which would not be very Godfrey by either of our definitions. I hope you had/have a happy holiday!

[@felatioable]

I only wish he was a tougher boss fight

[@AC-hj9tv]

Ofnir reminds me of Fafnir, which makes me crack up thinking about Fapnir

[@Sikraj]

I just noticed that isn't a beard that is sculpted into his helmet, but actually dozens of ears

[@axrye800]

Loved this take on Gideon

[@_nick.._.liachnis]

I like Gideon Ofnir's ties to Odin Norse mythology. The both employ spies in the form of NPC's (or ravens) to gather all knowledge. Both are ruthless and quite capable in all forms of magic, making them formidable opponents. That said, Ofnir is another name for "Odin" from mythology.

[@boneman-calciumenjoyer8290]

"Sir Gideon Ofnir - the somewhat knowledgeable" is what I call em. He does know a few things, just don't know how he got the title of all-knowing.

[@minerman60101]

I feel like Gideon Ofnir is going to get more content in the DLC where you can actually ally with him. I feel like there should be some way for him to, given enough knowledge, not fall into the despair and actually comprehend the truth of Marika. Your character helping him acquire knowledge has no effect on his actions, and separately there is no game ending for getting all of the great runes; it doesn't even matter which ones you get so long as you get the two to enter Leyndell plus Morgott's. This leads me to believe that if you can get Miquella's Great Rune in the DLC, that you'd be able to have a Gideon Ofnir All Great Runes ending. (Maybe also extract Ranni's Great Rune from the moon)

[@CorvoThan]

as someone big into fanfiction i cant help but see in him a lot of the typical self-insert character

[@fishafresh91]

I always wondered why if he knew everything why he thought he could beat us after knowing we defeated all these previous Demi gods moments before

[@Kryptnyt]

If Gideon knows that when the game ends, when you stop playing Elden Ring, the Lands Between and beyond cease to exist; does this makes his final act a martyrdom rather than a betrayal? He knew that he couldn't kill a god, not even you.

[@Andyconda14]

Gideon and vyke were closest to becoming lord I think but both seemed to lose there resolve somewhere down the road

[@Ganonduff]

I think Gideon also likely used the bugs that give heals and MP since they have his symbol on them

[@sampaio]

Fantastic, your best analysis, deserved more views

[@square-table-gaming]

Much appreciated!

[@wolfiemuse]

MERRY CHRISTMAS ZACH AND PAT AND MICKI!!

[@square-table-gaming]

Merry Christmas Wolfie, thanks for being a fan!

[@puzzleheaded6195]

Gideon’s Lore in a Nutshell F I N D T H E A L B I N A U R I C W O M A N

[@cross-eyedhollow]

Damn that thumbnail. Dude's coping harddd. Also, loving the Gideon slander in the comments. Stupid Gideon. I never liked him from the start.

[@topcat59]

I still find it hilarious that he thinks he can stop the giga chad player, also you didn’t put enough points in to vigor.🐱

[@square-table-gaming]

old character haha, also I've got to swap point around a lot in order to be able to cast the correct spells for each video

[@Z3kyTw0]

This channel deserves 100k Subs! its that good!

[@square-table-gaming]

Maybe one day!

[@nothanks9503]

Sir Gityone the Make-you-find-our-for-him knowing

[@aaronwinrock8164]

To struggle is to live, what meaning could be found a life eternal a perfect order? Continue in the face of adversity, grow and evolve. In Light, Dark, Life, Death, Heat, Cold, Order and Chaos we find our truest selves.

[@johncooney3940]

As I always say... Assumptions can be deadly

[@dbearded130]

Superb work as usual 👏

[@happysuds1856]

In Leda’s dialogue in Enir Ilim “his Eminence”…is she talking about Gideon?

[@D.boys6t9]

I feel like elden ring has SO much more to offer. They could add whole new missions and endings and we wouldn’t re start the game just to expirience it

[@brendanmuller7301]

There's a whole cut quest for malenia, vyke, benharl, and even miquella

[@kaiserdetectivegolden2735]

@@brendanmuller7301 malenia missions turned out later to be millicent missions others yes they got cut

[@iateabagelonce]

Is there something to Gideon being called the "all-hearing" by other characters? Especially by characters who hate him - instead of the "all-knowing." So he hears all, but doesn't understand or actually KNOW all. He just THINKS he does because he thinks hearing "hearsay" or reading books is enough. If all you can do is "hear" perfectly, you can still be lied to, or people can still sneak by you by being silent. Even though Gideon also has an eye motif, he doesn't seem to see very well at all in the end, besides what he reads in books, lol.

[@square-table-gaming]

The "all-hearing" is Ensha, Gideon's spy. This is loosely confirmed by the finger keeper who mentions the all-hearing leading the attack on the albinauric village. While Gideon gave the order, Ensha led the attack.

[@galacticpookachus6780]

I'd like to note that, Gideon dies fully believing to be all-knowing he never sees you become Elden Lord. His last words are his beliefs, and he leaves the world believing that You are destined to fail in your quest to kill god, that he still knows better than you, even in death, however he is wrong.

[@DogDudeRulez]

it might be a good idea to keep in mind what a god is in elden ring, because in the game its almost like aliens showed up and became the worlds new god, with how bing the upheaval was with the old gods and religion

[@zigtavius5071]

Hey there! New to the channel but I was a fast sub! Keep up the great content, you put out really good stuff and hope it reaches even more people 💪

[@square-table-gaming]

Thank you! Always excited to hear from new viewers

[@TotalBlackoutPainting]

Another excellent video!

[@ZetaMoolah]

Gideon, the All Knowing Sega Saturn Zealot

[@DukeofDusk]

I do believe he is responsible for the state of alberich if I'm reading his armour right

[@holyspear26]

I can’t help but think it was Dolores or Vyke. But it’s been a very long time since I came to that conclusion and don’t remember why.

[@ZKForbiddenParadise]

Sir gideon is basically elden ring's odin

[@purplebugfoot456]

I wonder if Melana is Marika's daughter in the same way that Millicent is Malenia's daughter.

[@greenpeace4246]

My gut feeling is telling me that he is the one who sends Ensha to assassinate me at the Round Table Hold.

[@bjm6104]

Merry Christmas

[@square-table-gaming]

Happy holidays!

[@5TailFox]

I call him Sir Gideon Ofnir: The Biggest Loser.

[@MarcusJGrey]

@6:35 he left behind Pidia? The albinauric hidden away in the Carian fortress? Thought that was Albus that Ensha attacked and couldn't find because he was hiding as a pot.

[@square-table-gaming]

It was! Oversight on our end. We made an edit to address this but KZbin takes forever to post edits.

[@MarcusJGrey]

@@square-table-gaming No prob, thought it was me for a second! Its insane how much these games have going on in them. I'm still watching lore vids on Bloodbourne, I have no doubt that I'll be watching lore vids on Elden Ring for years to come as well!

[@MarcusJGrey]

@square-table-gaming looks like you've got these garbage bots trying to impersonate you.

[@square-table-gaming]

@@MarcusJGrey thanks for the heads up. Keeps happening. Thankfully you can block them from the channel and it'll wipe all of those comments

[@dolphinboi-playmonsterranc9668]

Sir Gideon Ofnir, the Bald GOING "I'M NOT GOING BALD!"

[@MrMedia-ce4qt]

Can’t wait to slay him