Style Theory: Makeup Brands Are STEALING Your Money!

[@伏見猿比古-k8c]

"But didn't you already retire?" Matpat: yesn't.

[@Zhizhan69]

If you ask me has matpat retired: Yes yes Yes yes Yes yes yes Yes yes Yes yes yes yes Yes yes Yes yes yes yes Yes yes Yes yes yes yes Yes yes Yes yes yes yes Yes yes Yes Yes yes yes yes Yes yes Yes Yes Yes yes yes yes Yes yes Yes Yes Yes yes yes yes Yes yes Yes Yes Yes yes yes yes Yes yes Yes Yes Yes yes yes yes Yes yes Yes Yes Yes yes yes yes Yes yes Yes

[@betka5791]

@@Zhizhan69try again, maybe make it smaller

[@XzTS-Roostro]

>>"But you already retired from hosting" >"Yes; but what about second retirement?"

[@Adezk]

@@Zhizhan69 B

[@Firemaster27]

If Santi wasn’t on his food theory road trip, he DEFINITELY would have been on this episode 💀

[@OriSnori]

Sounds like the Santi Collab days are gone if he's moving

[@shandalikechandelier]

Yeah, Santi is always a real one, lol!

[@ray_is_a_menace]

Yeah, Santi would've taken Josie's (mannequin) place

[@StuartGelin]

​@@OriSnoriyeah I think the santi move is over and we're seeing the episodes from the trip, but we probably won't see much more collab since they're not in the same city anymore

[@ItisJasmine27]

Yea I agree with you!

[@JayKwell]

22:32 Matt has apparently not learned anything from Safiya’s franken videos if he thought this would be easy

[@thedoctorsjenny5143]

Yeah I’m pretty sure she also taught us the whole taking out the ring trick from lip products first I swear I saw her do that in a Franken video

[@victoriaconway1]

​@@thedoctorsjenny5143you did see that

[@Victoria-_]

Fr 😂😂

[@KM-nu7vj]

Problem with this math: something can be way overpriced, understate the grams but still have deceptive packaging, and it looks like it has this huge increase in "money saved". A better version would be taking the total price divided by the usable grams, to get the price per gram to compare. This truly shows how losing product (or gaining) can affect the price by weight, without having the overpriced items just look better because they cost more per gram to begin with.

[@DarlingsOrgans]

True, didn't think about it like that

[@jasmine_1375]

I fully agree since in general most liquid eyeshadow are more pigmented than the powders. So you'd get more use from them but it would show as "less product" if you were just weighing it.

[@jadedhula]

The problem with this whole experiment is that it didn't do a control before any of these rediculous "let's dump everything into a container to see what happens" scenarios.

[@jadedhula]

Also, just because the container is bigger than the amount inside, it doesn't mean that you're getting ripped off.

[@darladay4766]

Right, and amount of product changes per use

[@eirik5324]

24:57 that plastic ring isn't trying to scam us guys 😭 its there to secure the product, without the liquid lipstick comes out, if u take it out and close it like that the content leaks :/

[@asmozinho]

I was thinking about that 😭

[@ElysV135]

Same goes for Milani blush. Thicker packaging is caused by the different manufacturing process of baked cosmetic items, it's not to fool us there is more product.

[@diamondinmyeye6160]

Yep, project panners know to use it until you get no more with it, then ply it out to scrape the full thing out.

[@ecstasycheese7390]

Yo Style Theory fact-check please?

[@EmpiireanDemon]

she mentioned that lol

[@hathorthecow7146]

The lack of comparing different brands of the same shape makes me doubt whether it's the shape of the packaging or the brand being more honest about their products.

[@reaganteator6426]

maybe they could do a follow up episode where they compare different brands, but they kept the brand the same bc changing 2 variables in an experiment makes the results less accurate.

[@rhoward295]

Exactly! They need to compare different brands with the same delivery method and packaging!

[@KM-nu7vj]

Yeah, there was a lot misleading here. like using the original price to turn into an amount "saved" or "lost". When that price could vary widely by brands, and as you mentioned, whether they err upwards or downwards on grams is also variable. Plus, the exact same product from the same brand might vary in grams based on the standard deviation they allow.

[@hathorthecow7146]

@@KM-nu7vj that and it also relies in the price point being reasonable for the quality of the formula not just the quantity. I'd far rather get a tenth the product of something that works for my skin than something cheap but cakey.

[@KM-nu7vj]

@@hathorthecow7146 exactly! I get what they were going for here, but it felt too oversimplified. Which I'm sure they have to do, for a youtube video and not an actual scientific study. I feel like the Theory channels have done better at controlling for certain variables before though

[@Brianna.barlow]

Fun fact: I’ve been taking these things out of my lipstick for years bc of how much more product I get. I wait till it’s nearly empty. Saved me lots of money.

[@HumbleWooper]

Yep, and a pair of needle-nosed pliers generally works way better than trying to lever it with a pen.

[@marcelraisbeck6104]

20:27 for folks that couldn't hear, she cries and says, "I'm sorry, I'm gonna need a minute. I feel so betrayed."

[@Gooonda]

Saw someone suggest this and we neeed to see it: Is it dangerous to drive with a claw clip?

[@ymca_unscrambled]

Or heels! Or other forms of hats! (I can’t wear my cowboy hat in the car either)

[@NotSoBossGamer2002]

It's dangerous if you get into an accident, especially if the claw clip is plastic because the force from your head slamming against the seat can cause the clip to shatter and get lodged in your head

[@KimG-uw6qv]

@@NotSoBossGamer2002this!!! My mom is a nurse and the stories that she tells me about car accidents and girls who had their claw clips in their hair is scary

[@heatherholzhaus7013]

Yes, I know some nurses that will remove them immediately before driving home. They've pulled enough shrapnel out of heads to know

[@misspanda456]

Yusss

[@Debraka]

I feel the felt-tip eyeliner was done very wrong. The force put upon the tip in testing was WAY more than we use when applying the product to our eyes. The destruction of the tip, and subsequent inability to get any more of the product out, is not a 1:1 comparison to the actual use of the product. I'm not saying there's no waste...waste is automatic with all make-up products...but this test was not a fair one, in my opinion.

[@EmpressCirce]

Super agree, plus she doesn't seem to know you're supposed to pull the tip out with tweezers and turn it around when it gets dry.

[@gooses78]

I had the exact same thought about the felt tip eyeliner experiment. Of course the tip will be ruined when you scrub it around on a piece of paper, that's not how it's meant to be used.

[@sablemoreno5095]

​@EmpressCirce huh. Didnt know that. I dont use makeup often but i have a few laying around (mainly family who uses them) that were just complaining about it drying out. Ill have to check if they can be flipped

[@agata2787]

I know this is kinda a fun theory, but the methodology is all wrong. Some of the products have their packaging a certain way because of their consistency, or to avoid it drying out. Product of a different consistency in the same packaging would give a different result, so testing only one is a fun experiment, but introducing the results like they were conclusive is misleading.

[@alveolate]

yea it's pretty obvious that those felt tip stuff are not meant to be drained from full to empty in one go. clearly, all that vigorous action would accelerate product loss too. the idea is there, but the methodology is far from rigorous enough.

[@charlieeveredy1756]

This is actually the same problem I have with her closet video, she draws conclusions too early and too definitively for it to be a theory. I feel like there's a lack of objectiveness in these videos. I have nothing against Amy and I like the topics she chooses for videos, I'm just not feeling great about how she goes about them.

[@monsterrahadewbaja]

The way I scrambled to find my remote to watch this on TV is unholy. We love you, AMY, and this is on the behalf of all style theorist

[@eoljjangiee]

Plastic stoppers are meant to 1) dispense the right amount of product on the applicator and 2) prevent the product from spilling out accidentally. I disagree that they’re a cheat or trick. You can take them off once you reach the bottom of the bottle to get some last product.

[@Sinbertus]

I wonder, it would be easier if you used this strategy: get two of the same product, empty one, clear it well and make sure no product is left inside, and measure the weight of both, and finally, basic math, full product - empty container = final weight of the product, and then measure again with almost empty containers to see the weight of wasted makeup.

[@ralexandra1058]

Can be done with just one of the product, rather than two- to eliminate fill discrepancies across batches. 1-weigh when new to get total package weight. 2-remove all product into a new container…. 3-weigh the container containing what’s not accessible… 4-then thoroughly clean out old container.. 5- finally reweigh packaging to get base package weight. That’s how the beauty breakdown does it.

[@user-em8fq2ev4b]

Gaining money by buying makeup - Amy 2024 If that isn't girl math, I don't know what is

[@KM-nu7vj]

yeah... as a mathematician, some of the "math" here definitely bothered me 😅 a wee bit misleading

[@per-c8229]

Yeah my math wasn't mathing, I'll love to see the recits on how they calculated, it sounded to me that they have some sorth of baseline for each product and the x%+ or x%- is obtained compared to that baseline but I can't be sure.

[@kitkitcat268]

​@@per-c8229 it's the amount listed on the packaging of each product

[@thisisnotausernameXD]

​@@per-c8229The baseline is the quantity listed on the packaging. I'm guessing there is actually extra in some products, more than the listed weight, volume, etc. It could be to compensate for wastage but I don't know. It would definitely be interesting to see the math though.

[@badgyal845]

30:30 NOOOooo 😭😭😭I only joked in my mind when I heard about the auction on the other channels that what if the morph suit was included

[@LyricAndCompany]

@@badgyal845 the way that it's currently the cheapest thing available lol

[@verona8420]

Follow-up video idea: find out if trial/travel size makeup products have more value than their full size counterparts! and which ones have the MOST, of course

[@piercedsiren]

I use a pump foundation, and yes there is loss, but when the pump doesn't pick up any more product, I just take out the pump and just deal with the bottle itself. Usually get a little more out that way.

[@Bananova-slupka]

Not to mention how much more hygienic it is

[@DomyTheMad420]

9:35 i'm usually the last person to give a company the benefit of the doubt but: using glass containers to contain your 'luxury branded' product has been proven to convey a sense of class/luxury compared to the generic plastic bottle. Yes it costs more to produce and sell, but don't worry that what the markup is for :) never attribute to malice what could be explained by branding & advertisements 101 xD

[@ElianaMCP]

I also feel like most products are less likely to strongly stick to the glass than to the plastic bottle

[@RTC-xl6fr]

Also heavier packaging feels more luxurious to consumers. It’s not necessarily malice, but the user experience

[@mysteriousunicorn4658]

I’d love to see you have Safiya Nygard on to do some Makeup Math/Science collabs too!! That would be so cool!!! Omg!!

[@jessicazaytsoff1494]

I was wondering why they didn't consult Safiya! I guess because it would be a shorter video.

[@afeatherinthewind]

yesssss I feel like Safiya and Amy would be fantastic in a vid together

[@codekt]

6:32 “ I didn’t expect us to gain money… “ GIRL MATHHHHHH

[@jessicabowles8663]

came here to say this

[@Mad_Bun]

This doesn’t take into account pigmentation, some products may be worth it even if u get less product out because you can use less per day.

[@RoseCentaur1916]

Question: With the stick products, blush, lip, concealer... why not just add a paint/lip brush to get that bit of product out of the container (which would work like the other tools) and onto your face? Professional make up artists use brushes like that. Heck to use my liquid liner I use a paintbrush because it gives me better control for a cat eye. 💜

[@One_Winged_Warrior]

The loose powder container, when you get towards the end with the last bit not coming out, take a tweezer and stick its between wheres its tightly fit between the container and the filter part to force it out - works like a charm

[@brandinichole2490]

I use the nyx mineral powder and you can take out the filter thingie when you get low and use every speck of powder lol

[@emko24]

12:48 for the Maybelline Age Rewind, I just rip the sponge tip off and take product out on the back of my hand and then apply with a brush. Also, by Canadian regulations, the amount written on the packaging has to be the actual amount that a consumer can use up. So the layer that is left over at the bottom of the container is actually a little bit of extra product. Unless they change the packaging between US and Canadian market, I would presume that the same applies to stuff you would get down there. The more you know~

[@AhhhSukeSuke]

Makeup is a scammmm. Who uses up a $60+ makeup product in 3 mths, or powder products in 6 mths???? We're upsold robber prices for product sizes that we cannot use up before expiry 😂

[@CottonCandySharks]

Very true

[@jamesuthmann940]

At 28:02 Amy's "No pumps!" came across just like Edna Mode's "No capes!" from "The Incredibles".

[@DomyTheMad420]

i'm still coming to terms with the massive shift and boost to Her whole style; lusher and more amazing hair, a lovely set of face make up, and the wardrobe improvements oh my god like before you were fine and i adored your style but now jeez your make up and costume department deserve credit!! (altho i have a feeling it's also partly her own input)

[@emilyobrzut9290]

I want a part 2 of this now. (Not that I even wear makeup. It's mostly because I'm a bit invested in this theory) ❤

[@september3569]

Mat being on the gtlives still was like my saving grace. Mat you better show up on occasion you will be missed!

[@zaidshakeel7435]

Theory idea does expensive mean better in clothing

[@supernova582]

It all depends on if it's better quality or just overpriced brand names. There are certain brands with better quality and brands that are just luxury so this would be a great theory

[@MartiganzYT]

Okay, this one is interesting and now I am curious 😂

[@SimonWoodburyForget]

@@supernova582 I think the question here is whether the quality ingredient are actually that expensive or not.

[@hvbg]

​@@SimonWoodburyForget it's not just the fabric that makes high quality clothes expensive, it's also the sewing techniques applied. The biggest difference between actual high quality clothes and just branded clothes is the sewing, since cheap fabrics can still make decent clothing if the sewing itself is high quality

[@hvbg]

​@@MartiganzYT it depends on the brand and the sewing techniques applied when the clothing was put together. The difference between clothes that are expensive because of high quality and clothes that are expensive because of the branding is the sewing, since cheap fabrics can be made into decent clothes if the sewing itself well made

[@imamejmg]

Another tip for making make up easier and getting more out of it if it comes in a tube and you can’t get any more out of the top go to a cheap place and get little plastic containers cut the bottom off the tube and put whatever is left in the plastic container you’ll probably get a couple days out of it

[@aylaheidelberg4299]

Not me about to cry when Matt said he wanted to pay it forward 😭

[@theRealSara]

Yall should talk to the Lipstick Leabians! They are makeup and packaging gurus!

[@PumpkinPeach83]

i know its just a "fun" video but a lot of the "testing" was so inaccurate. the eyeliner annoyed me the most. The "misshapen point"? We aint scrubbing it over paper towel! i dont think the measurements were accurate either. take it with pinch of salt.

[@yesac100]

Oooh, definitely want that part 2

[@BeautifulShaving]

Omg, I loved this & it gave me serious flashbacks to a channel called"Makeup Break-up" a duo of Aussie ladies who'd do this same kind of makeup & packaging testing (and that oh so fun makeup math). Would love to see a part 2 to this video! Thank you for this very interesting & enlightening video about makeup lost in packaging. ❤❤❤

[@sambeawesome]

Though I don't really use makeup, as an artist who DOES paint, I'd personally aim for any plastic tubes that I can cut open, haha. Works great for watercolors, could get you a bit extra makeup too ;)

[@angelicagtle]

Hey Amy, I think you'd like a series called The Makeup Breakup by Beauty News, they do exactly this but for specific products and see if you're getting the amount of product you're paying for! They measure liquid foundation and concealer by volume using measuring cylinders!

[@Kitty_Girl_Candi]

11:32 Instant age eraser? More like instant money eraser am I right? No? Nobody? Okay I'll stop

[@marissah1868]

The shimmer eyeshadow probably would be a better choice it tends to be softer then the matte shades.

[@toomanyopinions8353]

Amy you should invest in one of those teeny tiny makeup spatulas, it’ll make getting the man up out of bottles when they’re almost out way easier!

[@tarroc_FaB]

28:23 YESSS PLEASE!!!!!!!!!

[@raygonzales2208]

I know there's a budget to this. But a larger sample size for each item would make for some more accurate results. Multiple of each individual item

[@acciobook8053]

Why would you use the listed weight as opposed to measuring it yourself? Shouldn’t you measure it yourself so that you can get a more precise number, also accounting for any inaccuracy in your methods by standardizing them more?

[@deirenne]

Because you don't weigh the packaging before buying the product. When you're comparing prices per unit of product, you compare them by the listed weight.

[@livelaughlove669]

@@deirennebecause some brands might list the weight/volume of their product alone and others try to be tricky and list the product and bottle together. That might be able to explain why some products gave you twice as much while others barely gave you half of the product.

[@AuntBA]

Love this video! One thing I want to note about some lipstick tubes that twist is that some designs will not let you twist them back down once you extend them up (so waste occurs when you try to put the make up away after applying it).

[@makethelifesimple]

3:03 face powder is supposed to be use on a greasy face for his full capacity. Using a mannequin can’t absorb the powder

[@Nels1957]

Thank you for this I get so mad when I have to buy new foundation earlier than I should because my foundation will not come out when it’s towards the bottom

[@Royal-breeze]

Not me gonna be using this as a guide when I finally throw out my 5 year old expired makeup XD

[@rosbindadolmo]

We been lied to nooooo.

[@thepowerfulmusic8572]

The little plastic stopper that causes the vacuum on the liquid products is there to make sure it doesn’t leak and the wand it’s self gets really mess with out it so it’s there for a reason and you can usually get the out with some pliers once it’s at the end of the

[@linnhuman]

I know this isn't about hair buuut your hair looks incredible!!!

[@willreese7114]

Pt 2 pls! It's great to learn more about makeup, since I had little knowledge of it, and it's one of the reasons I followed the channel

[@KohakuAmber22]

Now I'd like to see the number of uses for each product compared to the price you calculated for the amount of product you actually get.

[@rpggirl017]

Thank you for this episode! I would DEFINITELY love to see another episode comparing what companies are being the most honest.

[@lekiscool]

I don’t wear makeup but I’m here to see the deceptive packaging.

[@ateh6150]

I don't wear makeup, but I love the math. Looking forward to more insights on how to avoid being scammed by big corporations. 😅

[@orinb8654]

I'm going to save this for when I get a girlfriend so that way I can get her the best make-up with scientific evidence instead of popularity. Thanks for telling me how much of a sham L'Oreal is, I've seen so many ads for it.

[@keilanisummer5613]

PLEASE GO THROUGH ALL THE BRANDS!!! I love watching you judge productssssssss

[@LadyLocket]

It would have been interesting if they used cosmetic silicone or metal spatulas. This would have made getting most of the product out so much easier to get a true base amount reading. It would have been interesting to see how much the applicator not just the packaging causes product wastage.

[@SmallM4A1]

Yo, im so sorry, but I literally couldn't focus on the content. Your hair is literally a magnet for eyes. All I'm tryna say is w hair

[@mr.owlgaming893]

I have theory for y'all idk you'll even see it, but can licking a cut help it heal? I know there's white blood cells in spit that can help you heal but would it make your cut heal faster?

[@mumenRhyder]

There's so much bacteria and viruses in our mouths, i feel like it's more likely you'll get an infection rather than prevent one

[@johnlittle8045]

Could we get a series of "how to" episodes focused on dressing and styling like character archetypes? -How to dress like a pirate -How to dress like an anime protagonist (inspired by Erika Ishii in Smartypants (and other things)) -How to dress like a superhero -How to dress like a ninja -How to dress like my D&D characters -How to dress like a K-Pop Star Stuff that focuses on capturing the essence of the styles that these things embody even if you're not literally wearing the clothes for them (to invoke Seinfeld, what if you wanna be a pirate but don't want a puffy shirt and just want to wear what you buy off the rack)

[@Fazkrueger]

There's a Style Theory episode discussing witches modernizing their sense of fashion.

[@edwardtdm123]

Poor Amy, it must have felt like a chore to empty all of the makeup products. 💄

[@joshweinbergjw]

My name is Josie look mom I’m in a video 2:29

[@christinegraham2579]

🤣🤣🤣

[@OmaBiszantz]

Lovely

[@jacklomas4218]

I'm still saying with the theory channels it'd be nice to see Matpat do one theory per year or even a couple here and there. It's up to him completely of course and hey he deserves a break. He's such an integral part of the theory channels. Up to him though.

[@gooses78]

I'd love to see a follow up video with more data points. Maybe including ways to get some of the last of the product out of a nearly empty container, such as using a lipstick brush to truly finish off the last of a lipstick.

[@ninin117]

if yall got the budget for it you should do a high-end version and compare them. or a skincare version.

[@angelatana7560]

23:45 , fun fact: your only suposed to do 2 clicks to get the product and too many clicks will make it fall of the stick and stick to your lips.

[@harpurr53]

AAAMMYYYY, i love your wavy hair!!! i wonder if it will get even curlier as you continue to leave the straightener alone? it looks amazing, and thank you for this helpful episode

[@anamelendez3668]

YESSS do a part two Amy🙏🙏🙏I’m always struggling with getting all my lip product out and constantly rebuying!!

[@Bakerygo]

My heart hurts when I see her hit the containers next to the analytical scale. Rip scale.

[@looneytoon76]

New tools for the makeup table pliers and a scraper knife

[@TheAllSeeingEye2468]

Squeeze tube is the way to go except when it comes to lotion. For some dumb reason they don't use the same science for toothpaste tubes when it comes to lotion

[@merilinmachado]

My god! This was the most eye opening video from theory so far! Thanks Amy ❤ and sorry for all the frustrating bottles 😂

[@DomyTheMad420]

11:05 it's an open little secret in the production industry that you usually can't get everything out of containers (using cost effective methods). you'll find in this general case of applied simple physics that if you extend all the way to the bottom, there is a rather high chance of NO product going through. Instead of the higher % you wanted, you just created a fatal flaw that's often encountered in cheapo products ;) maybe you guys should hire someone with engineering in their background :D

[@RTC-xl6fr]

I’m a fan but this was hard to sit through. It was so frustrating how she was trying to get the make up from most of the products but ESPECIALLY the eyeliner. No human is going to apply it like she did by basically stabbing the tissue. Of course it would affect how it would dispense make up. No one thought that something must have been off that this ONE product would make you lost ~90% of the listed weight?? A way higher variance than all others?? A high schooler would know better. Also the stopper on liquid lipsticks HAS A PURPOSE. I think she got too frustrated at how long this took to film so she took shortcuts.

[@stinky5530]

Miss ma'am, please make part 2 Your efforts weren't wasted and I'm so glad you did this video because it was needed

[@oliviakostick9639]

Idk how any of the stuff is lying when it tells you how much product it has. I see your equation, but idk how they can lie about 1.6oz if that's how much product they put it. However, I do think it's interesting to see how feasible it is to actually be able to use all of it. Totally agree with other comments I've seen about the piece in many liquid lip products; it's just too messy and unusable without it so you have to sacrifice space for the product. Pricing is usually adjusted to compensate for this. Would love to see you do another video and see a wider range of brands. The Subtle Makeup stack would be neat to test.

[@luckymangoes9934]

Amy always asks the kind of questions that I have NEVER thought of and then after watching Style Theory I always wonder why I never thought of them. Thank you Style Theory!! ❤❤

[@thecontentcreator2513]

30:08 Mat Pat we respect you 👏 You are awesome 🎉Although we will miss, now that you will be leaving KZbin 😢 But at least with a lasting impact, that will help many children's dreams & wishes to come true 😌 Truely, Matthew Patrick, MatPat is just So , Honourable, Remarkable & Awesome!😊🎉♥ 31:09 Thank you for everything MatPat ♥ And for the one final video for us . We appreciate & honor you ♥💫😊😉🎉 Se Ya on the GTLive 😊😉♥💫🎉 Honestly, may this man be blessed for all eternity ♥💫🌟

[@kittikatastrophe5011]

When my round pressed powder gets to the point of being a nearly unusable circle around the edge i smash it up with the back of a makeup brush and finish the rest as a loose powder 😅😂

[@JNouveau]

The mortar and pestle method

[@8FCA8]

As an avid makeup user (and thus buyer) this is a game changing episode and would love a part 2.

[@SamuelaKelia]

Never expected Amy to go crazy bc of makeup math and Matt auctioning his stuff

[@Thusenite]

Style Theory maybe be my favorite out of the 4, i dont really mind my appearance that much but i really like watching (maybe i like the way the information is presented?)

[@Whimorbood]

Thats why a great tip from makeup artists is to make a beauty blender slightly damp so the liquid foundation doesnt soak in as much (i just use clean fingertips as an application method which also works)

[@froggy_buggie]

I am buying Maybelline concealer with that sponge applicator and I just throw that sponge bit away 😅

[@90855jkj]

Omg , they way you looked so tired by the end! I hope this video goes viral. You deserve it!

[@alicegant2327]

Great video! I have never been a makeup or style person but I am always intrigued by the science and experiment involved in the theory ( and motivated to better my image to gain confidence) If there would be a part two, to weigh ml, a pycnometer would have been useful as it is used often to get a density for the product used. Weighing the product before use, after use, and after being washed clean and dry would show the weight of the bottle which in turn would tell the true weight of the product before and after use more accurately. The analytical balance is usually closed while weighing because the air and container used ( if not tare off ) adds unnecessary variables to the weight.

[@imL25]

Okay so i use the maybelline eraser concealer BUT i always take out the applicator sponge and use my own sponge so there is not as much product waste , but the pruduct left INSIDE the container.... yikes

[@milasharma7553]

The sanity meter had me cackling.

[@surcutieyukii5946]

I dislike this already because instead of weighing the full liquid product, washing it out then measuring the empty container, looking at the difference could've easily gotten a much more accurate result

[@SkuikiMigu]

Yes Amy, please do it by brand. Thank you!

[@Richforce1]

What these companies should look into for containers is the possibility that like CGPgrey says "hexagons are the bestagons."

[@Kazz1187]

I feel like the editing on this episode hits better than usual

[@lyvvv23]

The little ring is called the stopper in liquid bottles (like lip glosses), those are there to prevent it from leaking everywhere

[@julianapicone4358]

As an Ulta employee, the About Face foundation is my absolute FAVORITE! It provides a natural, dewy finish that's buildable if u know hoe to layer it with powder. I like this one more than Fenty!

[@catlady6532]

Makeup expires. Too much product in the same container can oxidize or go bad fast for many reasons. Smaller amounts is better.

[@Octogeek94]

I love how you are airing out big makeup’s stained laundry. Can we test the stacked makeup? I know that those are normally a round tray that is a combination of powder and puddy. I thought it would be great travel option. So a travel makeup episode. Also I would love to test all the brands to see who’s worth their salt.

[@monicathorpe-ub3nh]

I just started watching this and I have to say this is already the type of videos you should be making! We actually want to know stuff like this when it comes to makeup and stuff! Please keep making educational your videos like this!!! But like someone already said, can you go more in depth? Like multiples of each size and shape so there's more collective data to make a thesis!