TDAS: What if Heather held onto the invincibility statue?

What if in season 5 of Total Drama, Heather pocketed her invincibility statue instead of hiding it?
Tier list: tiermaker.com/create/total-dr...

[@AutumnPlains]

Realistically they had to give Heather a weak elimination because she would have caught onto Mal way earlier than everyone else. Keep in mind she was the only one who saw Alejandro for who he was in season 3 so I don’t doubt for a minute she would have saw through Mal.

[@TotalDramaOwenandNoah]

She wasn't the only one, Noah figured him out too

[@AutumnPlains]

@@TotalDramaOwenandNoah yeah by farther into the game. Heather had him figured out upon seeing him leave the bus for the first time.

[@miizuq]

Noah did too, it Heather was first so I get ur point lmao.

[@AutumnPlains]

@@miizuq Yeah Bridgette, LeShawna, Noah, and Heather all knew him for what he was. Heather knew first and the others it happened during their elimination.

[@chickengangtoh4916]

⁠@@AutumnPlainsleshawna and Bridgette got out bc of him hun

[@justthinkingaboutthearmyofbees]

The fact Heather canonically got out before Sierra haunts me

[@havikrogers1801]

I know, I'm severally depressed by that.

[@domenicavallone28]

Heather is THE face of All Stars, the fact that she didn’t merge irl was a crime! Heather should have made it to at least episode 9. I would personally have her rank 5th or 4th tbh 😊😊

[@user-bd8rw2oh1l]

She winner and she didn't deserve this

[@TheSilliestGoose655]

I think 5th or 4th is a bit far but I still would like her take Cameron’s placement

[@galactic4012]

I'm actually ok with her being a pre merge boot, but the way the wrote her to get her eliminated, not so much but that's nothing new for all stars

[@GothicPurple]

so what you're saying is keeping the invisible statue = no million + no perfect boyfriend? Sounds like 9th place was a blessing in disguise. I do really like how you wrote this, though. Courtney doesn't ruin all her relationships, a mini zoey villain arc with mal is really cool, and duncan being mal's helper so should have actually happened in canon.

[@TDWonderer]

thank you kindly, all stars is a real piece of work but I tried my best.

[@bossome77777]

i like this what-if version alot more than canon all stars, as cameron gets out earlier and heather lasts farther

[@TheSilliestGoose655]

Nice video! Suggestions: S1; What if Geoff convinced the guys to not vote off Bridgette S2: What if LeShawna never fake-cried and got the spa-day S3: What if Ezekiel didnt drop the stick S4: What if Dawn found the real immunity idol S5: What if Courtney didnt make Lindsay push the cart (most likley Zoey would push instead)

[@TDWonderer]

solid suggestions! glad you gave you one for each seasons as there are definitely some seasons that I don't have many in mind for

[@yourmusicalnerd_Bridgette]

Maybe Duncan or Izzy wouldve gone on that first suggestion

[@TheSilliestGoose655]

@@yourmusicalnerd_Bridgette yeah, probably Izzy though

[@TheSilliestGoose655]

@@TDWonderer np!

[@rafaelconstantino9736]

​@@TDWondererhowdy, i have a suggestion that may be a weird one to do,don't know if it is a hard one but What if Mal took control over Mike from the start of the last season , could he beat the game ,since Zoey and him would never be a thing most likely? Another weird one if you did not like the first one ,What if Heather and Alejandro were a couple ( or just made an alliance ) from the start of either World Tour or All Stars? Really like the TD what ifs bro, keep going ✌🤘🤘🤘👍👌

[@sisterlemon789]

Dude, you are such a storyteller. I could sit and listen to these for days on end and not be bored. These feel like what would actually happen, complete with research into the characters. These are kinda like the "Marvel What If's" except for Total Drama and I love that kind of stuff. Thank you for making such fun Total Drama videos.

[@totaldramaturkey]

Heather deserved better in All-Stars!

[@darkishere233]

I guess she did have a lot of screen time in season 3 along with Alejandro

[@ashton-rb7qt]

​@@darkishere233fr

[@justarandomperson976]

Agreed!

[@highonsugar6273]

All of the og cast deserved better

[@donutmaxgaming9674]

Fun fact: None of the OG cast’s placements were their best yet. In fact, in Lindsay’s, Heather’s, Sierra’s, Duncan’s and Alejandro’s case, it was their worst yet. Only Courtney and Gwen didn’t do their worst due to the humiliating placements for Courtney in Island and Gwen in Action.

[@-cookiez-]

I'd like to see "What if Eva didn't drop her MP3 Player?" And "What if Cameron didn't betray Jo?" Or "What if Sadie didn't say 'Hold on I got this!'?" Or "What if Harold didn't rig the votes?"

[@TheGodIvy]

I can answer 2 of those for ya If Cameron didnt betray Jo, just replace Lightning with Jo for the rest of the episodes. Maybe Zoey would be 4th instead of Scott, but thatd be it And the Sadie one implies she wouldnt be the target, which i think she still would be, so nothing would change there

[@shellos31oeste72]

Can you do what if Leshawna was unbothered by the reward in TDA episode 8 and didn't make the whole fake acting with the tears? (And the reward goes to Duncan cause he is the other one who contributes to the win)

[@TDWonderer]

action is a season that i struggle HEAVILY finding more what if's for so this idea is a good one that will be probably be what my next action video is on

[@shellos31oeste72]

@@TDWonderer LEZZGOOOOO

[@ultra_5488]

​@@TDWonderer​ What if? Izzy accepted Chef's deal (Revealed on the first aftermath) Owen never came back as a mole Courtney participated from the start Courtney went with the Screaming Gaffers instead Gwen didnt vote herself off Gwen didn't break up with Trent Harold and Heather had an alliance (Riot on set)

[@jordancollins444]

A better one would be TDI’s elimination of leshawna

[@donutmaxgaming9674]

This season variation is actually really cool! I like the idea of Mal using more personalities for his own personal gain. Using Manitoba and Svetlana are essential, and maybe he can even try to use Vito when fighting the gophers. I’m not sure why he would use Chester, though…

[@poplioenquintacuenta]

Now i need a what if of the what if

[@TDWonderer]

what if.....

[@entymash]

Great video as always! Heather not making far felt so wrong to me considering she made the final 3 twice and even halfway through TDA. I don't mind her getting out pre-merge since she had enough screen time in the first 3 seasons but the execution of her elimination was just... well lazy. If I were to find a way to get Heather out, I'd make her work with Alejandro, make the others vote for Al just for him to play the idol so only his and Heather's vote to count. But obviously Al would want revenge on Heather and secretly vote for her and probably convince someone else to guarantee her boot. On the other hand, I do agree this season is so damn chaotic and it's no much to do, especially because in most scenarios the final 2 stays the same. I mean Mike and Zoey would've probably made the finale in ROTI as well if it wasn't for Scott and Lightning.

[@bossome77777]

sawig 🎉 22:02 iodaiopkeanq ss. xx o it❤dligg😅😅 😮trpmm. i w sa

[@carlospena4387]

all i want is a heather and gwen friendship arc 😭💖

[@AutumnPlains]

Their alliance in island against the boys was very sweet. Sad they never put them together like that again. Ironically enough, they work great together against a common goal.

[@lillrice27]

During heathers elim i thought he would make team amazon+alejandro vote scott out

[@AutumnPlains]

@@lillrice27 Hm? That comment didn’t read well. You’re saying during heathers elimination that Alejandro + Heather, Gwen, and Courtney would vote Scott?

[@lillrice27]

@@AutumnPlains yes meaning scott would be eliminated not heather

[@AutumnPlains]

@@lillrice27 Why would they vote Scott? :o

[@JujanGames]

The reason Mal was gunning for Cameron is simply because he’s the most observant one. Mal knows that Cameron was the first one to find out about Mike’s DID, so it’s safe to assume he’d be one of the first to catch on to Mal. If Cameron caught on, it would ruin Mal’s disguise and would probably send him packing instantly.

[@ElPsySneak]

Your rewrite was great and made sense from writing standpoint but god damn was Zoey even dumber than in original here 😭 Keep up the good work

[@TDWonderer]

yeahhhhhh, when I said at the end of the video that I didn't like that I was forced to continue storylines I didn't like. I was mostly talking about Duncan blowing up the mansion and Zoey being a big dumb dumb with Mal, the best I could do was try to make her hold herself more accountable for clearly letting her emotions take over reason, but still just not the happiest about how she acts.

[@Maw0]

@@TDWonderer Meh, to be fair, you're just going off an already horribly written season.

[@milanbeerepoot4260]

I have a world tour suggestion: What if team chris won in I See London?

[@TDWonderer]

this is a very common one that i get for suggestions and i'll definitely do it (just not sure when)

[@Lime0853]

Another world tour suggestion: what if gwen beat courtney in the tiebreaker

[@elitettelbach4247]

This is certainly an improvement on the real season, but it is very difficult to get past all of the absolutely frustrating parts of the canon.

[@TDWonderer]

yep, thats all stars for ya

[@kiabb8851]

I really love your what ifs! Theyre so fun and I like the stories you come up with! I especially love the choice of making Zoey be aware of Mal way earlier than in canon and that Scottney didn't break up

[@youraveragenickel2177]

Pretty enjoyable. I would agree that it's probably my least favorite what if of all the ones you've done, but it's still a lot better than canon All Stars. At least now I can better understand why Zoey would take Mike over everyone else and the writing acknowledges that it's actually kind of selfish of her to do so. Also, no reset button--yay! The finale was just far superior to the canon All Stars finale in general tbh. If this were the canon season, it'd still have its problems (Sierra and Duncan specifically) but at least it wouldn't be my least favorite.

[@TDWonderer]

thanks! very candid comment that I agree with. I wish I could completely fix all-stars in a what if but unfortunately there are just so many problems in all-stars that a single what if can't really fix it. I obviously still plan to do what ifs on all-stars but they will definitely be the videos that challenge my ability to fix shitty plotlines lol.

[@havikrogers1801]

​@TDWonderer Question, have you ever thought about combining two or more what if. For example, what if you combined both this video and let's say What If Duncan didn't explode a mansion to see what would happen?

[@TRBAK-47YM_TD]

5:33 you should of let Heather fight Leshanna it would be amazing

[@blueblood2354]

What if Beth won the Total drama World Tour Comeback Challenge

[@thieenoo6996]

This is actually one of my favorite video of yours

[@TDWonderer]

well, im glad that you liked it! (even if i didnt)

[@thieenoo6996]

@@TDWonderer well I really like All-Stars so that’s a factor 😅

[@iraflopera]

td wonderer upload WOO (sick ass birthday gift hell yeah ‼️‼️)

[@TDWonderer]

Happy Birthday!!!

[@limasquarterback]

what if katie and izzy diddn't swap teams :) please

[@TDWonderer]

don't worry, i've seen your other comments and that idea is currently on my list (but also not exactly sure when i'll do it, so don't get too excited)

[@elise6894]

11:00 I feel like she would’ve taken Gwen feeling like she could somehow convince her to help her. It’s shown the two of them can get along even in season 1 when they voted out Duncan

[@smorelove4017]

i love how much this changes! i love mike so this makes mal a better villain and TDAS a better season! i like all stars mainly because it has my favorite characters but this helps so much!

[@CrushAugust]

I agrre with what you said at the end. Most of the characters were done dirty. Makes me wonder what all stars could've been like if all the characters were consistent and well written. Great video btw!

[@TDWonderer]

thanks. yeah all stars is a straight shit show for many many reasons, and I could critique everything about all stars but its already been done a thousand times so i'll just leave it at: its annoying lol

[@user-ce4ql6cj2x]

Alternative title: What if heather wasn't dumb

[@Pokefan-ne8zm]

What if Courtney didn’t win the lawsuit in TDA

[@TDWonderer]

I've played around with this idea, the problem is that Courtney is the main villain of Action. I know that Justin is portrayed as the villain but he's really just a pre merge villain as his character becomes progressively less threatening with him just becoming obsessed with his looks. without Courtney, Action just kinda continues without any real antagonist except maybe Duncan. Obviously could work and am low on ideas for Action so isn't out of consideration.

[@Pokefan-ne8zm]

Ok thanks for responding

[@Sombil27]

You should do what if Eva, Noah, Tyler, Cody and Ezekiel were in action And what if Eva, Ezekiel, Justin and Trent were on World Tour

[@TDWonderer]

This is kinda of a problem im experiencing right now doing an TDI what if, is that in Island the cast is WAY too big. most of the pre merge is a fair amount of the cast just getting nothing to do because of cast size. and the cast sizes of Action and World Tour being smaller actually help the pacing a lot more and having more people would inevitable cause there to be floaters. I like the concept and one day might do it but its a real hassle to write for honestly

[@Nonya._.]

Suggestion for the upcoming video: In the wiki for total drama or his audition tape, idk which one it is I forgot- Ezekiel can speak up to 7 languages. so I think I’d be cool if you incorporated that in some way, but It’s fine if you don’t want to it’s just an interesting fact that was never expanded on 🤷‍♂️

[@Blueberry-wn5fc]

6:54 mother and father are looking at each other

[@Invtr23_]

Great Vid! What would happen if Harold didn’t rig the vote in Basic Straining?

[@someguydoingthings]

Harold would get eliminated, and Courtney would stay in for longer.

[@TDWonderer]

thanks! glad you like the video. that's a fairly common what if so i'll probably get around to doing it at some point

[@havikrogers1801]

NGL, I don't really like this one. I think Courtney would just be eliminated in the next episode. I think this works more as a short than anything (unless I'm messing something).

[@alliumrose6862]

​@@havikrogers1801your entirely right courtney would just have gone the next episode since the bass would still lose cause of lindsay's far more impressive win and heather cheatingwhich then brings us to the votes Duncan would vote bridgette since he is friends with both geoff and dj Courtney would basically have to vote bridgette now since that would be her only shot at staying Geoff would vote courtney since he likes bridgette and he wasn't gonna vote dj or duncan Bridgette would realise her only way of staying would be if she votes courtney so she does That leaves DJ as the swing vote and since he is and remains closer with geoff and bridgette throughout the series yah he votes courtney and courtney gets eliminated

[@ethanalgicosathlonchannel1110]

@@alliumrose6862I agree that Duncan would vote Bridgette since he has a close bond with everyone besides her, while Geoff and DJ would vote Courtney having a close bond to everyone besides her. Bridgette would either vote Duncan(since she doesn’t like him) or Courtney(knowing it’s either her or Courtney going) and Courtney would vote Geoff or DJ(since she doesn’t know either of them well, I’d say Geoff since he messed up the challenge) or Bridgette knowing it’s her or Bridgette going. The best case scenario for Courtney is a tie, but it’s a stretch to say that would happen. However, I think it IS possible that Courtney could score a point which would tie the challenge, so the bass winning the challenge is possible, but I think the most likely outcome is that the bass lose and Courtney gets voted out

[@amcuevas]

See, idk if they'd believe heather rigged the votes, at least not by literally replacing votes. Heather is mean and manipulative, but she's not a cheater. She even called out cheating a couple of times.

[@AutumnPlains]

Yeah she never cheats. She’s a fair player, just a manipulative one lol.

[@genderfluid_flower_boy]

I GENUINELY SPRINTED TO THIS VIDEO AS SOON AS I WATCHED HER HIDE IT… still not done but i’m liking it so far

[@craigsudol2657]

Hey got a sweet idea for you what if lashawna never tricked her team in tda

[@TDWonderer]

could you clarify more? im unclear of what moment you are talking about

[@craigsudol2657]

You know in the total drama action hospital episode where she fake cried too get the team reward now is it more clear

[@Beaches_Peaches]

I was actually surprised that she got out so early :(

[@elise6894]

11:18 Zoey also thought heather was really cool so that’s a pretty cool idea of heather although she was mean to Zoey in that episode of roti

[@arthuralexander1449]

24:16 i think Alejandro would actually win this one since he was the second best at eating during the pancake episode behind only Sam, if heate pancakes full of traps, rats a gross stuff(which is a bit weird, i guess all stars forgot eating challenges was one of Alejandro weakness) he wouldn't have much problem eating a normal ice cream.

[@dylanjohnson3346]

Still wouldve prefered courtney and scott final 2 but this was way better than the og

[@Althea19480]

(sorry am late)i love this video and it's actually better than the og btw i have a video idea(btw idk if a already said this😅) what if brick didn't get vote of instead vote lightning thx!

[@Alittlebitofeverythingoffical]

its so weird that one minute detail can change the entire shows timeline.

[@incognitocat78-jm4zt]

your voice is handsome no lie What if "hook line and screamer" was not a purge challenge?

[@TDWonderer]

no idea what you hear in my voice but thanks either way! at some point in the future (probably a while like at least a month) I plan on doing each season if every voting round was normal (no sole votes, no purge challenges, etc) and this idea would fall into that spectrum.

[@deadakus]

My only issue with this video is F5. I could easily see Alejandro being able to convince Courtney to vote Mike with the fact that Mike and Zoey are both strong competitors who will 100% be voting together. At best she'd have to face one of them in a tiebreaker which is definitely no guarantee. I think Mike goes there.

[@cs2222]

idk what u have done so here's a suggestion or few outta bordeisim & curiousity what if brick never swaped teams S4 what if tyler never saw duncan & gwen kissed S3 what if zeeke wasnt feral S3/S4/S5 what if cameron didnt actcidently kiss courtney S5 what if scott didnt hit mike with a shovel S5 what if duncan & courtney never swaped teams S5 what if duncan never quit in the starting S3 what if heather didnt make the allince w/lindsay & beth S1 what if lindsay never gave heather the chioce instead of giving heather the choice S1 what if courtneys violin never broke S1 what if heather never kissed trent S1 what if the aftermath show was never hosted S2/S3 what if blainley never came S3 what if justin never lost his charm S2 what if izzy never came back S2 thats all dudes peace

[@niewiem2419]

I love how all of your what ifs are better than the original storyline 😂. By the way I can't believe you managed to make all stars at least decent. If I will be honest this is the worst season which I hate but with your changes it's mu more likeable. First of all heather isn't that dumb, Courtney and gwen's friendship wasn't ruined and Alejandro was treated with much bigger respect than in original. It's mu better written and more i teresting than the original bullshit all stars was 😅

[@Supreme-AMVs]

Can you make, what if Noah played in the dodgeball challenge.

[@TheGodIvy]

You deleted your comment just to say the same thing again?

[@doritodragon9218]

Ridoncoulus Race(S7) What if the Vegans never lost the fossil?

[@TheGodIvy]

Why does that one matter, its a non-elimination episode

[@bossome77777]

@@TheGodIvy yeah and ridonculous what ifs are very hard to write

[@TheGodIvy]

@@bossome77777 it is but not impossible. From what ive done, Vegans and Genuises are very hard to eliminate, but this applies to other characters like Lindsay, DJ, Brick, and probably a lot others

[@doritodragon9218]

@@TheGodIvy But the next episode, they can get it together and actually win

[@TheGodIvy]

@@doritodragon9218 they did win the next episode, and got a stupid penalty to end up last. Please be more specific on what would actually change, because i fail to see why itd be different

[@justarandomperson976]

Hm well elimination wise nothing really changes i really loved this tho! The writing was great and Heather honestly deserved better i would of swapped her and Cameron’s places

[@TDWonderer]

thanks, glad you liked this!

[@twinberwolves4231]

What if Izzy and Sierra did not switch teams in World Tour?

[@Brendanthedachshund]

And then Chris would say it’s fake they always have another reason to eliminate them

[@Sam-tl4ho]

I dont think courtney will try again to "cheat" the challenge with the painting, knowing that the ice cream wasnt a great idea, but i cant think another way to get around that problem but maybe she would found another solution and get before zoe? Idk

[@Daansstuff-alt]

Tbh. Im fine with Heather being an early boot in canon All-Stars like. What really could they have done with her? They’ve done all they really could with her in the first 3 seasons. And with her being eliminated early we were able to get some solo Alejandro moments.

[@seanalailima5929]

Could you do What If Sam finished the pancakes or What If The Getting To Know You Trivia Game Challenge didn’t end in a tie?

[@EmilyQueenno12]

We still got a Zoke finale, we are losing 😭, Courtney and Scott were robbed of their win and heather was robbed of merge

[@AlexLovesArsenal]

I think I have a good idea for all stars, might be interesting! What if Courtney was eliminated instead of Lindsay

[@sillylittleinternetperson3932]

i like this channel

[@TDWonderer]

i like this comment

[@havikrogers1801]

​@TDWonderer I like this reply.

[@bentley7188]

S1 what if there was girls allies instad of boys S2 what if courtney was a full time villain S3 what alejandro got out in the final four S4 what jo was the main villain S5 what if sam made it far in all stars

[@havikrogers1801]

Tbh, I only think that the first and fifth one as the other three wouldn't work, whether because Jo and Courtney were already villains and the third one would be too short.

[@Maw0]

1st What is Beth and Lindsay weren't in an alliance with Heather? 2nd What if Trent wasn't obsessed with #9? 3rd What if Tyler didn't witness the Duncan and Gwen kiss? 4th What is Dakota didn't turn into a mutant? (She was just left gone after the 2nd episode) 5th What if Mal didn't exist? 6th What if Ella stopped singing after Chris warned her? RR What if Geoff and Brody didn't come back? Reboot What if Zee didn't try to eliminate Chris?

[@randommason7323]

That would of been a better story in my mind

[@user-yk5on3if1m]

Another title: How to make TDAS better?

[@IdkT-ky3mf]

And here’s another: what if Duncan never blew up the mansion

[@anchorsaway9500]

It may be your least favorite so far but it’s still an improvement over All Stars main story. Duncan’s “theirs a difference between being bad and being rotten” is perfect closure for Duncan’s arc in All Stars

[@nfornolanxy4782]

Good video, idk if this topic could work, but since Blaineley does say she was the original host in mind for World Tour, what if Blaineley hosted world tour could be interesting.

[@TheGodIvy]

I wanna do that one now, so ill start in the morning

[@TDWonderer]

interesting idea, difficult to tell how much it would really impact the season but still is a fun idea that I might try out

[@nfornolanxy4782]

@@TDWonderer Thank you! Your videos have been really good so far, so I’m sure it will be great!

[@IdkT-ky3mf]

Here’s a good one. What if B and or Dawn was able to prove Scott’s manipulations before they got vote out?

[@imjoker2823]

Future Idea- What if the team that won that week’s episode loss?

[@thebois6651]

What does that mean?

[@imjoker2823]

@@thebois6651 Example- The Killer Bass lost in episode 1, so what would happen and who would be eliminated if they won and The Screaming Gophers had to vote someone off

[@gowatchbonesprettyplease1038]

My suggestion is what if Harold didnt vote off Leshawna and instead voted Duncan in Action (which I still dont understand why he'd vote Leshawna, an ally, over something he already forgave her for..)

[@thebois6651]

Duncan plot armor

[@TDWonderer]

this idea is on my list for Action and I plan to do it at some point (just not sure when and kinda wanna give action a break for a bit)

[@MarxrileyAoki]

what if the Lindsay and Courtney rivalry went in-depth? This can be on either Action or All-Stars

[@christiankealey2932]

Question: Would Mal still go back to the hole to drop a boulder onto Heather only to get captured like in the original timeline

[@Benjamio]

Ideas (mostly related to Island) What if Heather was the one to convince Owen to give her half his bottles instead of gwen in the semi-final of Island? What if there was an invincibility statue in Island? What if Katie got eliminated but Sadie kept going and made it to the merge (or further)? Or Katie keeps going after Sadies elimination Ideas (mostly related to 2023 TDI) What if Raj & Wayne didnt get injured? What if Ripper got the immunity in the Egg finding challange? What if Julia got immunity in the final 4 challange? Ideas (mostly related to Action) p.s. i saw ur comment about trouble finding What if's for action so hopefully this helps What if Lindsay didn't vote herself? What if Leshawna's tape talking about the other contestants with her mom didn't get exposed? What if Sierra or/and Alejandro were in Action? Ideas (mostly related to World Tour) What if Sierra didn't blow up the Plane in the final 4 and Alejandro was voted out like he was supposed to be? What if Instead of Sierra or/and Alejandro Sadie & Katie or/and Eva were in WT? What if Alejandro didn't manipulate everyone with his Looks?

[@havikrogers1801]

What If Lindsay didn't vote herself already happen on the channel.

[@ethanalgicosathlonchannel1110]

Island: That makes the finale Owen vs Heather. That’s it. It doesn’t really make any major differences other than Heather making the finale of season 1 …in what universe does Sadie merge? You’d need to do a fair amount of rewriting to make that happen… 2023: Ripper winning the egg challenge means nothing since Wayne and Raj still get booted there because of their injury. The winner of that challenge didn’t matter at all World Tour: …in what universe would Alejandro not manipulate people with his looks?

[@grenadethrower6370]

What is Duncan never came back to tdwt

[@AestheticAlex]

final 6 i dont think it makes sense that gwen goes. i think zoey's bond with her was strong and it makes more sense that everyone just votes off scott. this is because zoey can talk to gwen and explain, and gwen would be happy to help zoey try and bring mike back. coutrney still upset over the kiss would join in. this or scott courtney and gwen all vote mal and he goes, alejandro would probably too in order the eliminate a threat. gwen is the least likely to be voted off during this round due to her position. not to mention if anything zoey would lie to mike/mal and blame what gwen said on courtney bc she doesnt like her and then gwen is alone and will rely on zoey!

[@kharihammon9784]

Pretty confusing but I think if Heather keeps her idol, Alejandro goes in her place, Villains more than likely win F9 & Sierra goes in 9th. Both Duncan & Cameron were auto elimiantions, Sierra didn’t make the merge so she has no say & I don’t see Heather fighting for their lives. She’ll probably be like "Less players, less competition" At the F6, Heather probably goes for either Gwen or Mike. She hated Gwen more than she did Courtney. I believe she just dislike Courtney, but just found her a threat more than anything. I could see a world where Mal pulls the stunts he did to Alejandro onto Heather since she did have a similar reputation. I think hilariously enough, if he sabotages Heather then he gets eliminated by her single vote. But then Courtney would go after Heather/Zoey since she made amends with Gwen & has a relationship with Scottney. I believe Heather goes after Scottney, but she would probably go at F5. So basically, not much happens. She would have the similar run that Alejandro did except she would get an extra life through an invincibility statue. As I said, Mal probably would do as he did to Alejandro to Heather, Heather would indirectly send herself home because Mal did have the chart so Heather has no leverage against Scott, Gwen & Courtney. Even if Heather tried to make a move earlier she wouldn’t because the F8/F7 rounds were non-eliminations. Also, her best bet would be eliminating Zoey & hoping Mal pulls out the chart at the F5 & even then, in canon version Zoey dusted Gwen/Courtney/Scott & Mal could possibly try sabotaging Heather’s chances. Edit: Heather would for sure use the chart against Courtney because she knows she’ll be 5th or 4th place otherwise. If Heather DOES have the chart, she probably is 3rd with Scott being the weakest in challenge, Zoey probably wins & takes Gwen to the end in Mal’s place.

[@ionut2751]

personally i dont belive alejandro would snitch on the fact heather had the statue also she told everyone about who alejandro was trying to vote and either way i dont see mike to get far if heather merges

[@Catvinity]

Here’s what I’m thinking: Heather might sabotage Gwen and Courtney, putting them at the same area as the raft. I think Courtney could stop Duncan from exploding the house.

[@DeadBedOfficial]

29:37 wouldn't work, as far as we know Duncan is in prison.

[@TDWonderer]

if you rewatch the finale episode when the balloons get blown into the sky, there are 8 balloons. 4 balloons were popped earlier (Alejandro, Heather, Cameron, Gwen) and 2 people were on the ground (Mike, Zoey) meaning if you add all that up you get the full cast of 14 people. also when the balloons are flying away the balloon on the right has a really similar outline to Duncan. so Duncan was there in the original which I do think is really weird how the show was able to get him out of prison for this but the numbers don't lie, so yeah

[@OsBo566]

6:29 duncan goes here, gwen and cour tney dislike him

[@princelandrycrusher]

I have a "What If" idea: what if all 24 contestants (4 teams) were in TDWT (which means little to no reward challenges and no Blaineley). :)

[@Maw0]

That would also mean no Aftermath.

[@ethanalgicosathlonchannel1110]

@@Maw0no?

[@raymondthefiregod5598]

Can you do "What if Ezekiel competed in All Stars instead of Alejandro"?

[@Nintenbhoy_]

Pretty good opinions Suggestions: What if the Trent heather kiss never happened What if Alejandro wasn’t in the robot and not in season 5 What if Ezekiel wasn’t sexist What if Lindsay’s elimination was fair What if the Gwen Duncan kiss never happened

[@thebois6651]

he doing the third one.

[@Bread771]

What if Lightning didn’t miscount the pieces/Jo kept the alliance with Lightning

[@TheGodIvy]

Would he not go home anyways? Even without the miscounting, who else would people vote for?

[@ElPsySneak]

@@TheGodIvy either heather or jo since they kept butting heads

[@Bread771]

@@TheGodIvy the villains were making pretty good time, I could see them winning. If they don’t win, then Jo probably still has her alliance with Lightning and her mini alliance with Duncan. I could see Jo campaigning for Heathers elimination

[@TheGodIvy]

@@Bread771 i only question this since if you want Jo to keep her allience, that would hafta be either in season 4 or a rewrite, not a "what if" video And we can already assume Jo and Heather wanted the other out, everyone else (presumably) just voted for Lightning. So while this isnt the best scenario, a better one to ask would be "what if the villians won that challenge" The premise of ones like these seem kinda lazy, and could only work with some very specific challenges (like the one in WT where Noah shouldve won, yet because Duncan was brought back, he didnt) but i think for here it could work since they were so close anyways

[@maxezzy1282]

If you count the number of peices that villain team got, there were eight peices found. Apparently Lighnting isn't the only one in All Stars who can't count

[@GusUrFavYT]

You should do what if Cody got kicked out for not singing

[@TDWonderer]

I mean in World Tour that singing rule gets broken by a lot of people, so it would be kinda weird if Cody got kicked and then other people who don't sing get away with it (because there is A LOT of other people that also don't sing in episodes and are fine).

[@user-ny4iz9un6b]

wasnt duncan instantly sent to jail after blowing up the house?

[@roselialeontoo]

i don't understand why al didn't use his statue. wtf. it was ignored.

[@alankarpiel4163]

I mean alejandro has over 160 iq , he is definitely smarter than Cameron

[@nameless2996]

Here's my thoughts on the first episode: Courtney is not stupid, and would not trust Alejandro to listen to her, so either she would toss a vote on Gweb, causing a 3-way tie breaker, or tossing a vote on Alejandro, resulting in a 3-2-1 vote with Alejandros being eliminated, and Heather's immunity being used. This way, Courtney has bothered Scott and Cameron in her pocket for the next vote (Cameron would probably be an unintentional bonus).

[@nameless2996]

I will now always refer to Gwen and Gweb because that's funnier

[@seanalailima5929]

Could you do a video on What if the RCVMP didn’t hunt down Izzy?

[@TDWonderer]

rewatching island currently, and Izzy is very much the vote out in that episode anyway because she gave the Killer Bass the idea to have DJ push the canoes back. I guess that could effect her returning at the merge since she was presumably living the island after her elimination which is what allowed her to come back. But to say that she wouldn't be brought back at the merge is a bit of a hard sell

[@seanalailima5929]

@@TDWonderer Maybe you could do a video on What If Izzy didn’t suggest the Bass to have someone paddle behind the boat.

[@havikrogers1801]

​@@seanalailima5929I would combine that with the other one.

[@ethanalgicosathlonchannel1110]

@@seanalailima5929she would’ve still been hunted down by the RCMP

[@havikrogers1801]

This was a pretty good what if rewrite. Thankful that Scott and Courtney stay a couple, Zoey learns about Mal ahead of time, and the Heather and Alejandro dynamic. Yeah, I'll say it's my least favorite so far but it's still really good and way better then the original All Stars.

[@Sam-tl4ho]

Finally someone who likes scott and courtney being a couple

[@veryokusername]

What if they didn't have the revote in season 7?

[@poplioenquintacuenta]

Priya and Bowie would get out in double elim and the finale would probly be Julia vs zee or elma

[@havikrogers1801]

I don't know if it would be a double elimination since there already was one two episodes beforehand. I would probably bet Zee votes Bowie just because that's who was in the bottom two with him, but yeah.

[@ethanalgicosathlonchannel1110]

Then there would be a split universe for what if Priya got out and what if Bowie got out just like in ‘TDWT: What If There Was A Tiebreaker?’ This is how I view it happening *Priya Path* 7th-Bowie 6th-Chase 5th-Millie 4th-Emma 3rd-Zee Winners: Priya/Julia *Bowie Path* 7th-Priya 6th-Chase 5th-Emma 4th-Julia 3rd-Zee Winners: Bowie/Millie

[@Yourbestieisabel]

What if Duncan never cheat on court

[@happylol6179]

Let’s see… what if Sammy didn’t used her twin switch trick?👀

[@TDWonderer]

i like it! already did a what if where Sammy got to shine so it could be fun to give Amy time to shine as a antagonist

[@someguydoingthings]

Didn't they say that Alejandro was out in a 5-1 vote? Heather convinced everyone to vote for Alejandro, and Alejandro voted for Heather, so if she held on, Alejandro would immediately get out.

[@havikrogers1801]

In this What-If, he goes over that Alejandro would tell Courtney about Heather's idol and her, Cameron, Scott, and Gwen vote Heather, Heather votes Alejandro, and Alejandro votes Cameron.

[@user-qn1vt9yu5d]

Alejandro would be illuminated instead of header you do not boots Cameron because Chris Alejandro was being illuminated. He never said anything about a time.

[@baileylynn5562]

What if Harold didn’t quit in WT and DJ went home in Japan instead?

[@baileylynn5562]

And maybe what if Dakota never flew back to the island in ROTI

[@ZoPoj]

6:25 nah no way they would chose Sierra without Cameron being there

[@havikrogers1801]

IDK, Sierra is very threatening in challenges.

[@angelriveralovehisfamily]

What if Zoey was smart 😂

[@mongface2059]

Im glad Alejandro won since if Heather or any of girl won that challenge theyd be in a hot tub with chris...that guy whos very verbal about his attraction to teenage girls

[@siddiqarizwan7718]

If Alejandro manipulated Gwen (romantically) my 2 fave characters

[@giorgiohernandez3266]

What if Courtney didn’t come back in S2

[@TDWonderer]

I don't hate the idea, the problem is that Courtney is the main villain of Action. I know that Justin is portrayed as the villain but he's really just a pre merge villain and falls flat come merge. So without Courtney, Action just kinda continues without any real antagonist except maybe Duncan. Obviously could work and am low on ideas for Action so isn't out of consideration.

[@FanOfAnimation]

Really good video, I honestly like this version better than the actual All Stars, even if I low key was hoping that Scott and Courtney somehow got the final 2. Here’s a minor one, but what if Eva didn’t drop her mp3 player?

[@ethanalgicosathlonchannel1110]

I wouldn’t say that’s minor-