This Cruel Killer Murdered THREE to Hide His Dark Secret | Mike Bullinger

Nadja Medley and her daughter, Payton, were excited to be moving into a new house in Idaho with Nadja's boyfriend, Mike Bullinger. Only one problem, Mike was already married. When his two worlds collided he did the unthinkable, and vanished into the woods.
Twitter► / that_chapter
Instagram► / that_chapter
Patreon► / thatchapter
Sources►pastebin.com/g...
For business enquires please email [e-mail]

[@mikeykay1898]

Nearly fell out of my stool when you mentioned Cian McLaughlin. Cian was a good friend of mine, I miss him. Thank you for mentioning his case in this video. His case kind of got overshadowed by the Gabby Petito case because it was the same time and same place, so really, I appreciate it. Great video as always. See ya in the next one.

[@Ali-kb8gr]

Sorry for your loss Mikey. ❤

[@jaymimcbride5846]

So very sad! Sorry for you and his family!!!

[@amazingsupergirl7125]

How long had he lived there? Surely as a ski instructor he knew about the mountain lions, bears, poisonous snake maybe wolves or coyotes and NOT to bushwhack. I think most missing people go off trail, get turned around, and never find their way out. Even the most seasoned hikers have been found 10 ft. off trail or a matter of half a mile from a river. I used to hike in the Ozark Mountains, which runs halfway up the central part of America. We went off trail only once and even tied ribbons yo mark the way back. What a joke! Everything looks different coming back and the only way that could’ve worked is if I’d put ribbons every three feet. We only walked about five minutes off but it took hours to find the trail. So you can imagine how militant I am about staying on trail no matter what cool thing I want to go explore. I think that happened to your friend. Also, it’s too easy to get lost if you’re still hiking after 5:00 pm. The trees block all sunlight and it suddenly goes dark and cold. Definitely one of these happened to Mike. He doesn’t seem like the kind of man who could survive in the mountains for five years. Hopefully a mountain lion got him. 🇺🇸 🇮🇪 ❤️🤟🏻

[@B3Band]

Actually, it pronounced "Cian"

[@melpomenesnightmare7291]

@@amazingsupergirl7125 I’m sorry, but wth?

[@kindtimetraveler]

Saw it coming. ☹️ The second Mike said he was a pilot, I thought “Second family. Guy’s already married, & they’re his second family.” Very sad.

[@slimkt]

Man, if he is alive and out there, anybody that isn’t aware of this case could’ve bumped into this guy or casually talked to him and just thought, “What a sweet old man.” Not an ounce of knowledge that he’s a murderer. Gives me the heebie jeebies.

[@Trenchcoat3]

lol this. My mom always acts like every elderly person is just a sweet old man/woman, and I'm over here like mom, you have literally know idea who they could have been in their life. Rapist, murderer, pedo. You have no idea! She's also a bit too friendly with the homeless, I've been attacked before so it really makes me nervous how overly trusting she is at times.

[@goldkhw]

So, he did all this when he was old. Imagine what he was doing as a young boy and as his age increased. This was not something new. He has always been this way inclined. There's a crowd out there; damaged, harmed, and hurt by him. He had a family somewhere once. They know what he's like. A fiend.

[@rebeccagable9629]

Fiend is right! The perfect word.

[@ParasiteEvel]

@@Dakota.Brodeur or not.

[@katymcginn4644]

@@rebeccagable9629 😒 TRULY A MONSTER! SO MUCH EVIL 😈 😢

[@wildcambium]

People like this creep DO leave am absolute wake of wreckage in their wake. Thankfully I was at least alive after my encounter with one of these Human Hurricanes, although it has taken YEARS to put my life back together. I hope a freaking bear made a meal of him. While alive.

[@leahflower9924]

Wow all these marriages and relationships that he gets involved in and then he's in some weird love triangle ok but God forbid he could leave that girl he played father figure to out of his murder plan

[@whosTage]

Its honestly insane how some people work , there is people who has been living in hell all their lives and wouldn’t hurt a fly and people who ”had/has” it all that can kill people and ruin peoples lives including theirs , i dont know if this is the case here but to think that your loved one can kill your family without any real reason will forever be impossible to understand.

[@MaisyMimi]

You can tell these people a little if you learn narcissistic red flags. They do follow a scarily similar pattern in relationships. They don’t feel, they fake.

[@scottbuck9348]

Ya I always shake my head when I see a rapper/gang banger in a music video flexing stacks of cash while sitting on a rolls Royce or Bugatti and then the following week I’ll see his mug shot on the news for a drive by shooting or an ops murder. Like is life that bad that you need to go around shooting people? I’m over here working two jobs and 70 hours a week busting my 🏀’s off and sure I have bad days but most of them are pretty good! Even on my worse day, I’m not going to pack some heat, nor consider shooting anyone!!!

[@greglandry926]

Pop out I I’m o pop hi

[@harrydemkee3580]

Agreed, this guy was obviously a dirt bag but made it to 60 and wasn’t violent and then commits a triple homicide? I’ve always been amazed how some people can just flip and become a monster. Even seeking out her friends and asking about her whereabouts I assume in an effort to create an alibi? I guess the answer is there is no answer and some people can go through an entire life and then just kill their loved one after getting outed in a lie, scary to consider

[@maramarxx2431]

@@MaisyMimi yes, a lifelong acting. And so, they look for no Therapy, wish they were counseled And took the advise.

[@heathernikki5734]

Payton seems like such a kind soul in her KZbin videos, that girl would have contributed to society and to the people lucky enough to meet her. Her KZbin videos make me tear up, she was so innocent and sweet. What a SOB!!!!! I wish her father had not died :(

[@VioletJoy]

💔😥💔

[@yagesh287]

Kids who have not even lived their lives make me super sad. RIP Payton.

[@thecelt4807]

100% agreed very sad very sad

[@morgan8274]

I know!! I don’t condone killing Nadia but it makes sense because he was having an affair with her but to kill her daughter as well!? What a loser

[@ginger3884]

She was. I was friends with her in middle school before she died. She was the most kindhearted girl I knew.

[@Indifferent_Taco]

Nadja was a dear friend of mine. She and Payton had the kindest souls, Nadja was a badass! Until this day I can’t believe what happened to them. She was so happy and excited to move to the farm. Also for the wife of this POS and the dogs… a true tragedy.

[@AwfulDog1]

So unfortunate that the nicest people can have such awful things happen to them. I am sure Nadja appreciated your friendship.

[@Indifferent_Taco]

@@AwfulDog1 Thank you for your kind words. Yeah, it’s hard to come to terms when tragedy strikes good people in the most senseless way.

[@UrrmmWut...]

My deceased husband's name is Mike and he used to answer the phone with "you're on the mic with mike" and then instead of goodbye he'd say "Mike out" lol and everytime you say Mike out it makes me smile. I miss him so much. 😔 love your videos tho!! Always makes my day when I see a new 1😊

[@AwfulDog1]

Bereavement is so painful. Xx

[@cynthiahusband106]

Love you mike , tragic story 3 women dead and no justice for them.

[@bulma463]

This is so sweet 💜

[@UrrmmWut...]

@@bulma463 thank you 😊 he was a great man.

[@ibrahim_khalilx]

Watching murder videos make your day

[@FlameFlickers]

I suspect he was the beneficiary of a life insurance policy in his wife's name and his plan was for her to have an "accident" before she moved to the new house but then she messed it up when she made the surprise visit and he panicked. I also suspect it's likely he'd already left a second car at the park so he could make an escape as soon as he abandoned his wife's car. He would have known it would take authorities a long time to search the park and that they'd probably eventually just assume he's dead and been eaten by the wild animals.

[@hexadecimal7300]

Yes I think the same.

[@hollybottoms5512]

I saw this covered by someone else, all I gotta say is Mike makes every story so much more interesting, even without photos or clips I could literally listen to Mike talk all day & whatever he covers is so much more interesting then someone else doing the same story!

[@peppermintpetty6766]

THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU!!! I’m so glad you’re covering this case!!! It definitely needs more attention. RIP Nadja, Peyton, and Cheryl.

[@ThatChapter]

It’s insane

[@Wings_of_foam]

Lol, calm down.

[@Braham_the_Terror]

@@Wings_of_foam mind your business

[@P9rkour90]

They never found the man to this day??!! Noooo

[@peppermintpetty6766]

@@ThatChapter It really is. You did a fantastic job as always.

[@reneesantiago6496]

My brother was found dead in a shed just 3 weeks ago. It was a drug OD and he was starting to decompose. This episode hits hard just due to the bodies in a shed.

[@terribongers2465]

🤗 So sorry for the loss of your brother

[@Rschu]

I’m so sorry for your loss Renee. I can’t begin to imagine the devastation. Please take care of yourself the best you can ❤️‍🩹

[@quickchris10]

So hard/sad! Like suicide, there's nothing anyone can do for another's mental illness. They have to get help to change themselves. I deal w/this w/my bro as well.

[@kebaj]

Truly sorry about the loss of your brother. Praying for you and your family.

[@emy4314]

Im verry sorry for you lost ♡

[@EpicGigglez]

I know the family who use to live in the front of that ally that lead to this house. I use to live in the subdivision across the street if you google map it. Crazy this happened in my own backyard but so cool that your covering this. Idaho doesn't have a lot of solved crimes honestly. Im from salmon,ID where disappearances are more common and the river takes life. Thank you for covering this 😁

[@amazingsupergirl7125]

Yeah I think they either went off trail or animals got them

[@lah67]

i'm from north central. i hope he got eaten by a grizzly or a pack of wolves or a mountain lion. the odds are pretty good down there.

[@maramarxx2431]

So close And so far somehow, how curious. What a pity, And the feeling these family tragedies leave behind

[@emeraldblue5291]

He's done 2 stories recently about my hometown in rural Ohio. The population of the entire county that includes both towns is roughly 15k. I never even heard of 1 of the stories. Mike is the best!

[@bishyeahbish3758]

You really should learn how to spell properly; *not ally -> alley *not your -> you're 🤦🏼‍♂️ c'mon man 🤦🏼‍♂️

[@slantera]

Thanks for the update, Mike. I had been wondering about this case very recently. I used to be Facebook friends with Nadja and after I found out what had happened to her, I would routinely check her page to see if there were any updates about Bullinger (was he found/captured). It's sad that there hasn't been any closure, but I am glad that you did this video in hopes that Bullinger is found... Dead or alive.

[@fatherofmimes4236]

Hey You!! The world would be much better if we all had Mike's punctuality!! Thanks for the hard work and giving it a GOO!!

[@barneyronnie]

That's the truth, although when I was young, being on time was the rule, rather than the exception. (1960s and 1970s)

[@richarddobson5035]

@@barneyronnie That's what every punctual person tells themselves. People have always been late and people have always been on time. Just depends on the person. A study of ancient and classical societies shows the same.

[@Swansong321]

The most reliable thing in my life just now!❤😂

[@JME1186]

@@richarddobson5035 thank you. The “back in my days” crowd comes around every generation since the beginning of time. Confirmation bias or something similar, I’d say

[@barneyronnie]

@@richarddobson5035Thanks. This old fool appreciates you taking time to set me straight. Perhaps you can refer me to the 'study' that you cited. Well, the company that I worked at had time clocks and strict attendance policies. Thus, employees were on time with few exceptions. I think that you may be referring to other events and activities.

[@thejudgmentalcat]

Why did he allow both "families" to become involved with the same house? Makes no sense. Thanks Mike! ❤️

[@rubyharris4422]

I agree. Generally people living 2 lives do all they can to keep them separate not bring them together! Wondering if he planned to bump the wife off to start a new life but them all finding out about each other as they did changed his plan?

[@Rottiezucco1]

My gut says he was going to kill his current wife to live with the girlfriend. Notice nobody asked about her being missing for the 10 days. Her showing up before he could do it, put him in a spot and he most likely felt he needed to kill them all.

[@kathleenmckenna4004]

hmmm....maybe he wanted to get rid of both, so he could start fresh, and set up the meeting. Or maybe the girlfriend showed up in time to witness the first murder and had to be eliminated too.

[@hawleyclan9496]

Or maybe he had a third lady somewhere else and decided to downsize his herd and keep the other lady, instead?

[@Jason-lw7tk]

I love watching your stories. You’re so entertaining and funny while dealing with such dark material. Keep up the good work…cuz I love ya :)

[@kevindean1327]

He is a funny fker!!! I like when he says "well look at you" now I say that to my dog.

[@MartaWomack]

Terrifying to think of this guy still out there somewhere, trying to take advantage of the next people unfortunate enough to make his acquaintance! Reprehensible monster seriously needs to be locked up in a cage so he can't do it again! Thanks Mike for all your efforts.

[@pearlwhite3009]

I think that hike in the Grand Tetons did Mike in, and that's just fine. We don't need sociopaths preying on innocent victims. Thanks for the great storytelling! :))

[@amazingsupergirl7125]

I bet he was frying up bacon over the campfire when a bear caught wind of it.

[@whoisharo4689]

yeah, i dont think hes alive. unless hes in another country.

[@chickenlittle5095]

@@amazingsupergirl7125 we can hope.

[@heathernikki5734]

Oh I hope so

[@maramarxx2431]

@@heathernikki5734 yes! And those 'vigilantes', and nosy people spent their time preventing these family tragedies. So often, there must be some kind of preventing them.. a social problem

[@RightsForZombies]

This story is so senseless and tragic. This need never have happened.

[@WobblesandBean]

Welcome to mormons.

[@Autumnpearly]

@@WobblesandBean what?? 🤣 this isn’t a common thing among Mormons.

[@maryleiacunningham2545]

Hi Mike! I’m all the way up in Iqaluit, Nunavut, Canada, and have been checking in all day for your latest episode. I’m putting it on while I do dishes. You have quite the following up here in the Arctic! Keep up the great work!😊

[@LittleSeasonist]

Definitely a highlight of every week Mike! Much love, good to see you're doing well

[@malirocs2483]

I see that I'm not the only one that anxiously awaits Mike's new videos each week. I don't know why but I just like him so much! Keep doing your thing and giving it a go!

[@dopestylzfunknut483]

I love the line “ they found all the goblins that did all the bad things to little kids but did not find mike” or something close to that effect!? Hilarious

[@littleshell2748]

Man I'm so proud to see your numbers!! I remember when we were at 5 subscribers I knew you were going to grow quickly ❤️🥰

[@evahanson7681]

Todays a terrible day for me (my dad's been gone 25 years today) so a Mike upload is EXACTLY what I needed. Thank you, sir! We love you!

[@FK-lq8zf]

Hang in there 🙂

[@jamierupert7563]

I had the same thing 2 weeks ago. It was 25 yrs for my father too so I know EXACTLY what you mean. Here's to having a better day knowing you're not alone (and neither am I).

[@evahanson7681]

@@jamierupert7563 sending you all the love. It's surreal to think it's been THAT long. 💔

[@laurabustos6560]

Oh crap, as soon as I saw her video of her back yard I remembered this case. So incredibly sad!

[@pugachevskobra5636]

I have a homegirl who went though a similar situation a few years ago. She had been engaged to a guy who not only was married with children but was actively staying with his wife and kids at the same time he was proposing to my friend. His secret double life went on for about a year; my friend was suspicious due to a few events that took place and one day the guy’s wife contacted her with the truth, saying that she was deceived as well. The guy got mad and first attempted to gaslight her into thinking she was paranoid and hallucinating and then he pulled the “I’ll harm myself if you continue to be angry with me for betraying you and my wife and kids” card which spun things out of control really.

[@Ams_5590]

Awesome to spread awareness on this case, hope he is found and pays for his horrendous actions 😡😤

[@NikkiC777]

Wow! He hasn't even been found yet!? I haven't watched that far yet. Yikes 😬

[@rocketta.chique5761]

Let’s think for a second about this though: Sociopaths are famously stupid because of the size of their egos. They’re arrogant enough to think they can survive anything- eg, Mike entering the frozen wilds with nothing, not even water, proper clothing or shelter. I’m an avid outdoorsman (well, woman) and I survived a relationship with a psychopath. I personally would gamble a lot of money on him being dead as a doornail, ESPECIALLY in the Grand Tetons. Was camping in the area myself last week. I would guess he suffered frostbite, paranoia and dehydration till his last moments.

[@rocketta.chique5761]

That being said: if he’s out there, we can find him. Someone should post this video on Reddit to get the pot stirring, given its track record of solving mysteries. What about researching recent John Does in Canada? Or accessing facial recognition software? Someone smarter than me (and with more time) can solve this if he’s still on this earth, I’m sure of it

[@meredith2803]

@@rocketta.chique5761 yeah that’s what I’m thinking. They over reach, I think he’s probably dead. Anything could have happened to him out there. Elements, animal attack, broken bones. He was completely unprepared, but his arrogance probably made him think “Yeah, I’ve got this”. Still would be great to find something though, to know one way or the other.

[@LowKey_izildura]

@@rocketta.chique5761 I would hope he suffered all of that, but I vote - c: the psycho coward killed himself at the end of his rope

[@martieflagg4671]

Hi Mike! Thanks for all the work you put into your stories! Hugs!

[@Razok90]

It's always a great day when That Chapter uploads a new video.

[@jenniferh8148]

I think this might be the most senseless case you've covered. Not that there's ever good reason for murdering anyone but c'mon, how much of a POS do you have to be to kill a girl that calls you "daddy" because you got caught cheating?!

[@lea88pu]

People who like their material things and illusions more then other people. 😑😔

[@Kanetsugi]

:(

[@LB-gz3ke]

There just wasn't any reason to kill any of them. If he got caught out in his lie, as is supposed here, he just as easily could have said addios to all three of them and left. Think about it. They are all standing in that little house screaming at him. His reaction was to get a gun and shut them up. A wiser man would have just said, I can't deal with this right now. Then he leaves, cleans out the bank account before wife can even get her bearings, and leaves town. She can't immediately set the law on him, what law has he broken? By the time she is trying to take him to court for alimony, he could have legally gone anywhere in the world to start over.

[@QueenBeeBeautyXO]

Hey Mike, can you please keep us posted of any updates on this case? You are my number 1. Favorite channel on KZbin. And you take care of yourself too because we love ya too 😘🥰🇺🇲

[@Ronin4614]

He could even be watching this video thinking “ I should a, would a, could a “…… I agree that suicide is pretty unlikely given this guy’s history of psychopathy. I wish the LEO community all the best in finding this guy. Thank you, Mike; see ya in the next one.

[@Dyealilbit]

Love your channel and I hope these other TC channels covering OPEN missing persons cases (fresh ones at that), and spinning their wild theories, don’t ruin it for you REAL TC channels!! xoxo

[@robynjones2807]

Perfect timing Mike! Thanks 😊 love your videos xx

[@colleens1878]

Can't imagine what they went through at the end That poor woman and her daughter 😢 💔 I had heard of this didn't realize he was never caught I think his wife is right he planted the vehicle and is living somewhere with his new family hope he gets caught

[@peppermintpetty6766]

He deceived two women who only lived 15 minutes apart. I’m sure he’s found someone else now.

[@WatchTashi]

I have to wonder if he/they had been there before and he had a bug out/new identity bag buried somewhere? He was a pilot, wouldn't be difficult for him to flee anywhere in the world, if he had the right identity and credentials to fly. I hope they find him, or even pieces of him, soon.

[@LiveFreeOrDie2A]

With this guy, I find the most likely scenario to be that he had a relationship with (at least) one more woman, probably strictly online, and more recently started up. He seems like he would have a catfish on the back burner for if/when he needed to pull the plug on his double life entirely and start over. He stays in the National Park long enough to grow a beard, drop some weight, and be harder to recognize off a wanted poster. He calls up his lonely, desperate, and submissive middle-aged prey to come and pick him up using a burner phone- and lets her know he’s ready to commit and take their relationship to the next level. He wants to move in with and start his life over with her…

[@TheNuckinFoob]

I remember hearing about this case a little while ago. The whole thing is pure insanity!

[@JamiLeigh77]

Mike, we’ve given it lots of gooos so far. I have watched you mature (😂) and change, and grow so much over the years! I just hope you know how truly special you are, and I just absolutely adore you 🥰 thank you for always delivering the devastating true crime in true Mike fashion🤩

[@thebluehotel426]

It's amazing how people like Mike can come across as so genuine and apparently never slip up.

[@kittystetson6737]

The worst part is he COMPLETELY blends in- I see at least 10-15 men that look similar to him on a daily.

[@bphlebotomist67]

I love that if you are having a shite day, you can watch a video by Mike and when he says, because I love you. It just makes you feel a little bit better ☺☺

[@Wtfplsstfu]

Hearing "lets give it a goo" always reminds me im in for atleast 20mins of terrible awesomeness. Thanks mike ☺️

[@joannahaywood1366]

Thank you Mike again your delivery is flawless and comical. Extremely talented. I can imagine hours and hours goes into making the final edit.

[@Tam0de]

I wonder, does Mike receive assistance from a few trusted people with regards to the day-to-day operation of this channel? Or is he some sort of a one-man-army? Just thinking about all the research, writing & editing that goes into each video --- that's a lot of work for one person.

[@deertbahg7797]

he has a twin brother named Michel that helps him with everything no im just joking man lol

[@plutomaxwell]

@@deertbahg7797 naw I heard that too, Michael likes to compete for employee of the month!

[@PiXie232]

Nope.. all by himself!! He’s one talented guy!!

[@bokjuuu]

KZbin is his job, 9 or so videos in last month would mean he worked couple of dozen hours. Where rest of the world needs to work 160+ monthly. If he needs an assistant i mean ....

[@dcase84]

@@bokjuuu So you think you can pull together 9 videos a month in 24 hours? Good luck

[@psychoticpsycho7665]

Another excellent job, thank you for your time and dedication to this awesome channel.👍

[@tiffanyelguezabal1212]

I grew up around here and it’s crazy because you gave us a lot more information than what was on the news. Just makes me sad.

[@ambersnow2855]

i am so thankful you have got these videos on here..i am very entertained and i find it super interesting..thank you so much for being a fact finding truth seeker :P xoxoxo

[@BiffTech05]

This is just baffling, wth was his end goal with moving his mistress and her daughter into a house his wife was moving into as well?

[@-._.-KRiS-._.-]

I live in Boise. I hadn't heard about this case, unless this is the one where the husband decapitated his wife and put her head in the back of his pickup truck then got into a traffic accident, killing a mother and her child. Also, no one-not a single person-is ever excited to move to Caldwell.

[@MaeveLaRenarde]

You should look into Alison Botha, Mike. A horrific true crime story with a small twist.

[@dirkdiggler2430]

He had help to cross that park and escape the authorities. Someone was already waiting for him in the park with the proper gear and equipment to cross that park and exit it through a different route.

[@TheGhostOfFredZeppelin]

I like how Mike just subtly flexes his inside connections to secretive government agencies within the US when he casually drops the "They found sasquatch", knowing full well that his cover as a "goofy youtuber" is strong enough that no one will take it seriously.

[@primesspct2]

wow this cold calculating murderer is still out there preying..!

[@shannonhinton3907]

Thanks for the video

[@skeeskrrrr9073]

Hey I’m from Ogden, Utah! Weiiird when you hear where you live in one of these types of videos!!

[@mjcurtiss]

Honestly Mike, I believe Utah is the new Florida, or at least a state that doesn't get any attention for the level of Violence that occurs there? It doesn't matter if it's under the guise of a relationship, religion or some MLM Scheme, there's is a ton of violence in Utah Sir Tit for Tat it's right up there with Florida, Georgia and the Carolina's. Colorado gets a shout out as well Love Your Show God Bless 🙏 Michael Curtis

[@PK-hx3tj]

Love your videos and SOH. Keep em coming

[@butchgrant7569]

Another teaser. MIKE! Ok. Time to keep our eyes and ears open on this coward. Thanx our friend. God bless.

[@SmokingCzar]

Justice and closure are not just for family - it is for all of society that we get justice and closure from a criminal act.

[@michaels.330]

Mike's two realities collided and exploded. In his mind there was no way other proceed.

[@chelscara]

Murdered 3 + a small pet shop. This is already gruesome, I can’t imagine walking into this crime scene

[@crossropemademedoit]

Love you too Mike. Keep the videos coming.

[@88jackiepinto]

Hey Mike. I might just be your biggest fan this part of the world - coming all the way from sunny Malaysia. A new fan who stumbled upon *That Chapter* fairly recently only. I do Crave your weekly videos which are totally awesome. Plus you're super hilarious and that truly makes my day! Wondering if you could cover "The Pike County Massacre" sometime in your videos - if you haven't yet. Thanks! 😊

[@OURWORLD4EVER]

Breaks my heart what he did to these poor women. I hope to god he is found soon and punished. He might have found an other victim while at the park and left in her car. Either way, truly sad for the ladies and his future victims.

[@gachacaspa]

It's crazy to think all 3 woman died from the exact same gunshot wound. Usually you would expect individual gunshot wounds.

[@LeslieRae]

I tell you… Can’t trust anyone in this world any longer…. Probably why I don’t venture too far from home without people I trust… how have we allowed our world to go so sideways?!!

[@FknNefFy]

Took 11 days to contact the owner… great police work

[@melissaclark6578]

He may have made his way to Canada then Alaska. Alaska is one place where people go to drop off the grid.

[@dpclaas]

He too is Mike Out".. Mike you are hilarious. Terrible story...but the writing on the wall was everywhere...

[@lisaleonard9874]

WE ALL ❤️💙💚💛 YOU TOO MIKE

[@clairew5812]

is it weird i had a nightmare where in a moment i was really scared, mike suddenly appeared in a car, flung the door open and was like “what are you waiting for? lets give it a goooooo” he is such calming vibes LOOL

[@annettehellingrath8288]

This reminded me of the time I went to surprise a boyfriend, something I had never done before and found his house lit up like a Christmas tree and surrounded by cars - he was having a party. A party I knew nothing about. Turns out he was there with his future fiancé. By the way, their marriage didn't last, she probably got the same sort of surprise one day. My step sister was married with three children when she found out her husband had another house, another woman and a daughter with her. This sort of thing happens more often than we think.

[@SilentHillSimp]

Stuff like this is why I refuse to ever be in a relationship. So despicable to do this kind of thing to another human being.

[@TheHikeChoseMe]

thats men for ya

[@sonofamachinegun8568]

It's almost like people weren't meant to be married...

[@dbax3500]

It absolutely does. My dad was married to my mom for 28 years and in 2019 we found out he had bought a house with another woman, and had been bringing my young autistic brother around her for 2 years. After my mom decided to divorce him he killed himself. So much betrayal and so many broken hearts. And I’ll always still want my dad. But I wonder if he was still around would things be even worse now. What on Earth makes people so heartless?

[@xmiunax4385]

Dunno if its just me but i assume this is happening all the time 🤷‍♀️

[@aftonrae4038]

It is so confusing to me that these people think that being a labeled a murderer is somehow better than being labeled as an adulterer or divorcee?!?!?!

[@tamarah2274]

Especially when some of these ppl have already been divorced before. It’s just an excuse imo

[@Swansong321]

He didn't think that..everything just came to a head and unravelled

[@georgiakent363]

GIRL!!! I know right!?!?!?!

[@jesusisminenow]

it's those strong christian values

[@tamarah2274]

@@jesusisminenow that ain’t any Christianity I know

[@armynurseshark]

Met my stepfather when I was around this poor girl’s age. He had quite a wild past and was still hella wild when he met my mom, who had never been around anyone like him in her whole life. I also had two younger brothers. She brought this man into our house without really knowing him all that well & I will be forever grateful that he really DID treat me like a daughter. He was in my life for 40 years, ups and downs like everyone has, but I was ALWAYS his daughter of whom he was so proud. My heart breaks for this poor girl.

[@Trenchcoat3]

That's wonderful, I'm happy things turned out well for you guys

[@carolynhoechst4053]

I’m glad you feel good about your stepdad! Sounds like a good and loving heart he had beneath that hella wildness!

[@ekbanks]

So you mean to tell me he NEVER played with your little cat or ass??

[@Gaby-fb7gh]

That's fantastic and heart warming.

[@janinestraats2811]

Glad you had a positive experience with your mom's men she brought through the house; mine wasn't as pleasant; so disgusting and just divide up the whole family

[@Strype13]

Seems pretty reasonable to assume that his plan was probably to kill his wife, at some point, before they reached the date that they planned on moving into the new house together. But, for whatever reason, he was struggling with the process and kept putting it off until... eventually... it was too late... and she surprised him by showing up at the property completely unexpectedly. So, ultimately, his plan to try and get away with one murder while sailing off into the sunset with his new family instantly and inconveniently morphed into murdering both his wife and his new family and sailing off into the sunset... alone... as a wanted psychopathic fugitive. You know when parents teach their children that one lie will turn into many lies until you're inevitably buried in so many lies that it's impossible to lie your way out? This feels like a prime example of that lesson.

[@TekkorGJC]

Yep I agree 100%. He could of broke up with the girl-friend at anytime and been clear. Once he moved them into the new house the plan was clearly to get rid of his wife. He just seems to have not been able to sort it before something went wrong which was he wife surprise visit. He was trying to play it both ways as long as he could.

[@Strype13]

@@TekkorGJC Exactly!

[@user-rx4jg8lq7h]

Oh that makes sense! Thanks for spelling it out for me, haha, I was really puzzled about this one! :)

[@Strype13]

@@user-rx4jg8lq7h No problem! Merely speculation, though. 👍

[@quickchris10]

Yeah, he always planned to ``disappear'' her; but being a sociopath, couldn't conceive of people caring enough to request a welfare check.

[@Forviewing]

Mrs baker was my 5th grade teacher..... :( She was such an amazing human being. We were all devastated when we found out this happened to her. She didn’t deserve it. 🥺

[@HollhouseVanHouten]

Thank you for taking the time and using your platform to mention Cian McLaughlin. My sister lived with Cian before he went over to Wyoming. He’s extremely missed.

[@sookie.smooth]

It’s sad to hear Cian’s story, somehow intertwined. I’m sorry for how it must feel. Do you think that this murderous jerk ran across him, freaked out thinking that he was law enforcement on his tail, and ended his life?

[@beachbunny7256]

Mike's the man!!

[@danceyrselfkleen]

No one cares, Cruella Deville.

[@FlameFlickers]

@@danceyrselfkleen Very poor trolling, must try harder for the little bit of attention you crave to make your sad little life seem interesting..

[@AwfulDog1]

No because there was about four years in between the two cases.

[@sharonbland3843]

This happened to my sister-in-law's friend. She was married to a man called Tony, for 12 years and they had one son. He used to go away on work-related business, or so she thought. It turned out he had another life with 2 children and neither knew about the other. It He passed away from a heart attack, and it was only at the funeral that these two women learned the truth. Can you imagine the shock of turning up at your husband's funeral only to find he had another family with 2 kids?

[@Aliese11]

I dated a man for two years and didn't know he was living with another woman in Las Vegas for 5 years. When I found out I called her and let her know and she kicked him out.

[@rebeccagable9629]

@@Aliese11 Good for you...

[@leanie5234]

When Covid hit, my husband "had to move in" with his elderly father (who was 94 and honestly needed home help). Actually, the "moving in" part was more my idea, as between work, getting his dad breakfast and then getting him dinner every day, we barely saw each other for any quality time anyway...he would get home at about 9 pm and fall asleep in a chair only to rise again at 6 to drive back to his father's to provide the requisite breakfast sandwich. At some point, this turned into his opportunity to start sleeping with the slut in his garage band. I only found out by accident after it had been going on for about 2 years (of course, since he still denied everything, I have no idea when it really started). I wonder what he has told the slut ?

[@emvitt]

Jesus! 😱

[@audreydaleski1067]

I've never been against background checks before marriage. You don't trust these person then? Who cares, especially when you have kids.

[@brendaredmond4678]

Hey Mike. Just in time. I just finished my housework, got a tall glass of lemonade and I get to sit down and listen to the best storyteller on KZbin.

[@ThatChapter]

Glad to hear it Brenda, hope you enjoy!

[@oisforoxygen]

Lol, same!

[@redneckshaman3099]

I prefer making love to black chicks, and Mexicans ❤️

[@lorettascott5477]

Haha same here but made sweet tea@ 😋 ☺ 😊

[@lisahinton9682]

@@lorettascott5477 Do you have diabetes yet? 🤣😅🙃

[@NickellaElla]

🕊Nadja, Peyton & Cheryl🕊 It was lovely getting to hear Mike say “three” and “third” several times.

[@seapup2247]

My favorite is when the says "turdieth" 😆

[@sparkytuttle2966]

I'm sorry do you mean turd? Lol! Love it.

[@jeanimarein317]

No! Never give in to the “th”, Mike! Stay true to you!

[@NickellaElla]

@@jeanimarein317 😅I love the way he pronounces th words! I just spelled them out so people knew exactly what I was talking about😄

[@WhattEvery]

This is how some people react to shock. Beating about the bush and not about the massacre in the story.

[@FunFails]

I, too, think he's alive and probably exited the park at a different end. The fact that he was a pilot who flawlessly kept up a double life with both his families living 15 minutes apart gives off an impression of reasonable intelligence, so I believe he went into the park with a clear plan to get people off his tracks, and I believe it worked.

[@wadesaxton6079]

I worked with Mike as a pilot, he didn’t have it together enough to pull that off. His happy place was the mountains, usually running a mule train on a hunting trip. I think he hiked in deep and committed suicide.

[@pretorious700]

That's not proof of intelligence, it confirms psychopathy. There's a huge difference.

[@lyricalstyles]

Hes dead

[@katymcginn4644]

@@wadesaxton6079 😒 LET'S HOPE THAT IS WHAT HE DID! SUCH A MONSTER 😪

[@thecelt4807]

100%

[@sapphicdreamer]

My wife was friends with Nadia and Payton. We called for a well fair check. This was the hardest video for me to watch. I love your channel Mike. But this was hard... Nadia and Payton were wonderful people and they didnt deserve this. Their spirit is at rest. My wife misses them and this is heart breaking. May they forever rest in Peace.

[@BeeaReyoU.]

My condolences. I while back I saw a video about this case on EWU's channel and this was the first case to legitimately make me cry. They ended the video I mentioned with a video of Payton she recorded shortly before she was murdered. In it she sounded wise beyond her years and the message itself is heartbreaking considering what would happen shortly after. May they rest in peace. I really hope justice is served for them.

[@natsarimthings3147]

You are both good people. Nadja and Payton are blessed to have you as their friends. Very few will care to call for a welfare check. I'm sorry for your loss.

[@maggiebrooks2550]

😢 I'm sorry sweetheart. 😞 I'm sure that is difficult to watch when you knew them.

[@jakoclown4175]

Its welfare

[@SlightlyUsedRubberDuck]

@@jakoclown4175 look at his name bro no way he’s serious 😂

[@crystalairgood9845]

You have a 5 years on KZbin anniversary coming up!! Congratulations on all you have accomplished Mike! Looking forward to many more stories and years.

[@TheNuckinFoob]

19:20 This seems like it was very planned. He could've easily staged a bunch of supplies somewhere deep in the park. That way all the sightings would indicate he likely died and they'd just kinda stop looking. That or, like you said, he left the park and is living another life. He could've easily staged another vehicle somewhere in the park that no one knew about and that's what he left in so no one has a clue what to look for. Either way, he's f*ckin' gone and based on his ability to string along 2 separate lives for years without either of them knowing its highly likely he's already setup somewhere else doing his thing. He's definitely a slippery f*cker.

[@saltushachalmers]

I agree with you. Such people are egocentrical. They control everything and everybody. Will not be surprised there are some other victims out there already. He's the most disgusting type of narcissistic perverts.

[@sunnycloud]

You’ve got a point, he could have staged all this to change the detectives investigation plans’ direction

[@workingonmyroar7944]

But how does one disappear? How??

[@skandababy]

There is no way on Earth the he EVER thought that they would stop looking for him. So...no.

[@TheNuckinFoob]

@@workingonmyroar7944 You change your name to one that's either made up or stolen from someone that died a long time ago. The stolen identities that tend to be used most successfully are those of children that died 90+ years ago. The other method is steal the identity of someone that died young but would be around the sane age as you.

[@AwfulDog1]

This story is almost identical to what happened to me and my daughters, right down to the man being a pilot and ten yrs divorced and us all moving to isolated farmland…same ages etc. luckily for us it has been living happily ever after with are rescue animals ( 3 dogs too, a cat etc). I really feel for the poor women esp as they are all hoping to have a wonderful new life.

[@emy4314]

Im happy that you have a good life

[@laratheplanespotter]

That Chapter Tuesday!! Yay! Great to see ye Mike! Have a wonderful week everyone! And get ready, this one is wild! So let’s goo shall?

[@kimmoran4437]

Giving it a goo right now! ☺️🇮🇪

[@ThatChapter]

Thanks for being here Lara!

[@Aeye424]

I literally just brewed a coffee and sat down.. 👍

[@210anac]

@@Aeye424 mmm coffee

[@laratheplanespotter]

@@Aeye424 great choice! Enjoy!

[@benjywalsh]

Ah man this case is such a sad one. I watched a show that covered the case it's truly heartbreaking.... especially how happy they all were and especially Peyton's vlogs. They both seem so awesome people and it breaks my heart what they thought was happiness and a new life became the end😢

[@mikesanders8621]

Which show was this? Coz I immediately recognised the footage but I have no idea where I would have seen it

[@sjeabee5345]

Yeah I was wondering if this was a reupload cause I seem to remember this case, but I do watch multiple true crim channels. Mike is one of my top fave tho ❤️

[@barneyronnie]

@@sjeabee5345 He better be your favorite !

[@hatake1990]

@@barneyronnie ORRR ELSE!!😤😤😋😆

[@nickyblue4866]

Was it from the EWU channel...? They have a good video on this case.

[@EOP02]

Mike, would you kindly look into the recent events over the weekend in Saskatchewan? 10 dead 18 injured and a killer presently at large. Your the only channel I'd ask to cover this story. As always, Love from way up North

[@ThatChapter]

I definitely will be!

[@maddyb7917]

As a fellow Canadian, I to am defintely looking forward to coverage on this case!!

[@GGiblet]

So glad you will be covering it!🙌

[@jordanmercier3616]

@@ThatChapter sakatchejam, Canada.

[@jordanmercier3616]

Howd I not hear about this lol. I gotta google things now.

[@justginab]

I was listening thinking he hasn’t killed himself, if he’s a sociopath his ego wouldn’t have let him, then you said it.. I suppose the elements could have got him, but yea I think he’s living the life somewhere. Poor women. No justice in the world !! 😓

[@LeeDee5]

My heart breaks for all the women especially young Payton. You can tell what she really wanted in life was a father. And now when she believed she had a father in her life again that cared about her he goes and does this...

[@ginger3884]

She was a wonderful girl. We weren’t best friends but she was always such a sweet soul dude. I’m blown away that 1m people know this story now.

[@Looshington]

Unfortunately I already recognize this sick bastard from the thumbnail, but I am absolutely sticking around to see how YOU tell this story!:) Thanks for all the amazing and consistent content!

[@ThatChapter]

Appreciate that Nick!

[@Mike--Oxmall]

Hey don't talk about Mike like that.

[@thatracingguy5694]

@@Mike--Oxmall Mike sticking up for Mike

[@cinderellapumpkin8993]

"They found goblins that are responsible for all the missing people in national parks..." love the humor. Love the music, the familiar intro, use of pics and videos, lively presentation, the geography lesson, etc...good stuff! Yay to Tuesdays and Fridays!

[@vance4262]

I'm not particularly into the whole deboonking culture in general tbh, but at least Mike can be counted on to keep things classy and charming. It's all about how you present things. Usually I'd rather hang out with a "tinfoil hat" person rather than a person who says "tinfoil hat" unironically, but I don't mind shitting on either one/both as long as it's done tastefully and in fun. Genuine debunking with facts and logic (epic 🅱️en 🅱️apiro style) is fine, being a DEBOOOONKER is not. Mike always does it right. I adore that fine gentleman.

[@jokesonyou1373]

Tuesday & Friday medication days?

[@norman1741]

I feel so sad that together with these poor women he also killed the animals. That's horrible, truly heartbreaking

[@killernp1317]

I never got into this true crime stuff until I found Mike and this channel. I can’t stop watching these. I think this is my favorite KZbin channel! Thanks for the great storytelling and thanks for not glorifying these punks as much as showing what trash they are

[@Autumnpearly]

I’ve never seen one true crime creator on here glorifying murderers so not sure who you’re seeing do that but it’s not a normal occurrence.

[@combatepistemologist8382]

He has a unique and interesting presentation style. I initially thought he was a Canadian, what with the Toronto "aboot" and the Newfoundland "tree".

[@christianchickpeajesussaves]

He's funny in a unique and refreshing way. 😌

[@TheVioletBunny]

@@Autumnpearly disturbian does sort of I can’t stand that guy. He exploits victims

[@rebelwithoutaclue9387]

He really does do a good job making these stories palatable and entertaining! Try Mr. Ballen too! He has a somewhat similar vibe. His older missing 411 stuff is awesome!

[@clmclachlan]

I have to hand it to Mike his tone has been consistently caring and upbeat for such a long time. The subject matter, I have to say, wears me out and I have to take a break from humanity's inhumanity on the regular. Don't know how he does it, but this is the only true crime channel I have the stomach for, on account of Mike's compassion for the victims and his humor. Sure and ye've kissed the Blarney Stone, Mike. You weave a good cloth from some terrible yarn.

[@Sorchia56]

Aye, that he does! Brilliantly.

[@genellecampbell5378]

THIS comment should be pinned!! Yes! To everything you said! Yes!

[@Stopstaring101]

It’s his paycheck friend! He’s going to do what he has to do to earn it, including keeping humorous and upbeat.

[@genellecampbell5378]

@@Stopstaring101 you have half of that, because there are many content creators that make their paycheck without being upbeat and humorous, they can be downright garbage people and get rich. That's why we appreciate Mike the way he is. 🥰

[@Stopstaring101]

@@genellecampbell5378 Never said I didn’t appreciate him… I just stated a fact

[@danieltosh9710]

As a father this terrifies me... the thought of me being gone and something horrible happening to my wife and kids... so sad

[@nikkiejones4606]

Omgosh I feel so sad for these poor woman and the animals, how could he do this!!! There are some very evil people in this wicked world! Mike please update us if you find out any more on where this monster is! Thanks for sharing yet again another true crime with us all! See you on the next one! Xx

[@amazingsupergirl7125]

Especially Peyton. How could he hurt that sweet, sweet girl?

[@pakde8002]

How could he do this? One at a time. C'mon, it's ahow about horrible, egotistical, scheming murderers; no happy endings here😖

[@BariumCobaltNitrog3n]

Why do you like stories about evil, wicked monsters that kill innocent people without blinking an eye if you feel so bad when people get murdered? You know all Mike's stories are about murder, kidnapping rape and torture.

[@TCHARRISON1]

I think the moral of this story is........IF IT SOUNDS TOO GOOD TO BE TRUE, THEN IT PROBABLY IS! I mean, how often does a great bloke come along and offer you and your kid a beautiful home with horses and animals and everything your heart desires? the answer to that is......NEVER! because the chances of that happening are so remote that you would have to be suspicious if it was to happen to you. Maybe i'm just over-cautious, but I can smell a rat a hundred miles away. Anyway, it was a very sad ending and what he did to the three people and all those animals, killing them the way he did, well that is incomprehensible. I think when he realised he couldn't keep up the facade and it was all getting too difficult juggling the two women and the daughter, he took the cowards way out. He so easily could have explained to them that the deal was off and he wanted out. He had nothing to lose by giving them the boot, they could have all just got on with their lives as they had before they met.

[@lyricberlin]

well after being in a relationship for two years, I guess she thought it was progressing...