The ancient humans who wiped out 90% of Europeans - David Reich

[@DwarkeshPatel]

A bit more context: The Corded Ware (named after their corded pottery) is another pre-historic culture living in northern continental Europe. So much of what we thought we knew about human history is turning out to be wrong, from the ‘Out of Africa’ theory to the evolution of language, and this is all thanks to the research from David Reich’s lab. David goes into a lot more detail in the full interview these cultures, as well how they interact with the Beakers, another group. Really fascinating stuff.

[@glennhall8665]

@@scottloar Ah, ok. Thank you for the correction, Scott. (I’ve deleted my comment).

[@KatholikoPharorah]

😂 nice try but if the "corded ware" lived over 1 million years ago before homo-ercetus left then possibly but still homo-ercetus brain activities are identical to modern homosapiens which was 2x higher than the others. They research the brain activities, as well as vocal cords a Homo-Neanderthal had high pitched voices we have lower vocal cords and higher brain activities from homo-ercetus. While the size of our brain is almost identical to Homo-Neanderthals.

[@johningham1880]

Interacting with The Beakers generally just involves saying “Meep”

[@donmac7780]

We are not really built to contemplate deep time. You are comparing 5000, 20,000, and 200,000 year time scales.

[@david0aloha]

​@@donmac7780I wouldn't say we're not built to contemplate "deep time"/long periods of time. We can contemplate it. But it really takes diligent contemplation rather than just intuition, because our intuition is weak over long timescales. Thankfully, human brains allow us to be more diligent and logical. It's just hard and we're prone to introducing bias when we let our intuition take over. Our intuition is better geared for the day to day, social relations, etc than long timescales.

[@serfandterf]

Absorbed and taken is such a polite way to describe what happened

[@Grimhorn]

It's nature. It's terrifying to imagine but that's the most basic law of the land haha, I think it's dangerous to imagine that we're that much different from our ancestors all those years ago just because we've got centralized bureaucracies & courts of law.

[@cromemako83]

Human history shows this over and over again - death of native Y chromosomes and almost complete disappearance of X native. War is evil as heck - murder and rape are what hairless humans apes do.

[@imperson7005]

​@@Grimhornit's ignorant to mistake human intention like nature, whatever "nature" is.

[@willfeen]

it’s likewise ignorant to assume “human nature” in archaic AND modern populations that were/are H. sapiens + NEANDERTHALENSIS, as studies demonstrated a “sociopathy” gene in Neanderthals. The current social/political/military dominance of H. sapiens + neanderthalensis descendants seems to explain the brutality of colonialism and imperialism, high suicide/mass shooting rates in the imperialist societies, and popularity of brute worldviews such as “social darwinism.” I think that what most people of the dominant social group perceive as “human nature” is actually, and quite literally, “neanderthal nature”

[@willfeen]

⁠@@Grimhorn people who have pure H. sapiens more recently in their ancestral line (like, in the last 20,000 years) (post-Neanderthal extinction) really are different from “our”ancestors, though. In some ways. See my other comment

[@grondhero]

This is a prime example of why I hate shorts, especially when it's taken from a full video. This is more vague than clarifying.

[@dewilew2137]

Then watch the full video. That’s the point of shorts. To entice you to watch the long-form video.

[@the-philosopher7219]

​@@dewilew2137you r correct but what I see is he only watches shorts 😂

[@thebexflex1048]

Don’t watch shorts or have the person arrested who us forcing you against your will 😂

[@sawdustcrypto3987]

Agree. This clip makes no sense on its own. It didn't tantalize me to go watch the full thing, it just annoyed me

[@brandonfoley7519]

KZbin should get rid of shorts

[@user-dh5bo1wn7p]

Who else watched this whole short and took away nothing

[@juliebrown1394]

😂

[@rubymargaritais5657]

👆🏿

[@idfk8L]

Exactly. Like what is bro yapping about? Quit lollygagging with my time.

[@lifestorieshappens]

Yep, I was left so confused

[@SandStormXII]

Thought was just me

[@TomGhoulerie]

“Absorbed and taken” wow, I’ve never heard such a polite way of describing kidnapping and SA.

[@lancesims8627]

Man you dont wanna know about the comanches then my dude

[@TranscendentaLobo27]

@@lancesims8627No! All the Native Americans were gentle and peaceful until we showed up and made them violent… right? /s 😏

[@Yotrymp]

Man you dont wanna know about all of history and what a lack of fitness allows

[@defendfreedom1390]

Not necessarily

[@disontago5729]

Makes you think how you got that small percentage of Neanderthal DNA

[@centerfield6339]

Newsflash: human settling includes women. Stop the presses.

[@michaelpettersson4919]

Are we sure they identify as females? 😉

[@dr.bright3081]

@@michaelpettersson4919LOL!

[@marcuspolo9106]

Obviously,you are not taught u like females,your body let's you know,that's the male explanation,very male biased and its completely unnatural to not want females

[@michellecollins290]

😂for both

[@curiositycloset2359]

Yeah, was kind of funny when he said "we had a confirmation bias that the expansion was male led", then said "the DNA shows it was male led".

[@Gismotronics]

One take away from the full interview is that David honestly pointed out that there is so much we simply don't know about the way modern Humans evolved from earlier separate Human sub groups. It made me think that the old phrase, 'Missing link' is a huge understatement.

[@nikolaiv1138]

I'll add that every region of the world where bipeds lived had the potential of creating multitudes of races. I do not believe in the basic groupings one sees on forms created by modern governments to attempt basic categorization for political purposes. It's not possible to fully know the exact ethnogenesis of any group, but isolation, migration, etc., have nonetheless created many distinct groups on earth, though the agenda in the Western educational system often likes to call all of this a "social construct." Whether they are to be called races or ethnic groups, the hardware (AKA DNA) is at the core of the differences, and visible to the eye, unless, of course, modern globalization starts swirling people around at hyperdrive speeds. A real unnecessary process, might I add.

[@Gismotronics]

@@nikolaiv1138 - I think we're on the same page re. Globalist Agendas, etc. I have heard that that White Europeans have a high level of DNA commonality with a few surprising non-White groups such as the people in the north of India and some ethnically distinct black groups in Africa. Over millions of years, civilisations and cultures rise and fall. If we look at the birth rate in 'The West', it's well below replacement/maintenance rate and falling fast. This is because of Societal change, which is indeed greatly influenced by Globalist propaganda but also a dramatically reducing sperm rate (although that is not just limited to Westerners). Bit of a simplification but only Africa has a birth rate well above the replacement/maintenance rate at this point in history. Demographically speaking, sad to say, White Europeans are on their way out and it's very hard to see anything that could turn that around. So, perhaps the point is that Humanity is always in a state of flux but in the short time frame of our lifetimes, we think our culture and society is permanent but, clearly, over a long time scale, it isn't and won't be. Of course, while we are alive, we should strive to look after our own as Humans have always done but, sooner or later, some other 'tribe' takes over - usually because civilisations run out of steam and degenerate - internal decay. Other tribes enter over time and easily take over. 'Decline and fall'.

[@baronandbaronessvonwolf4618]

Maybe Read The Orthodox Bible you find the answer Then making up nonsense

[@DavidBritton-nl1wv]

@@baronandbaronessvonwolf4618 Yeah, that's always the first place I go when I want scientific knowledge./s

[@elram2649]

​@@baronandbaronessvonwolf4618 Correct! 😎👌

[@usaturnuranus]

Hide yo kids. Hide yo wife!

[@Culpeppered]

N hide yo husbands!!!

[@maam-yj8ph]

You don't have to come or confess. We're not looking for you.

[@Enmanuel_V6]

@@Culpepperedcus they R****** everybody out here

[@catherinemerrill5511]

Funniest comment ever!

[@fancyfree8228]

We’re gonna find you

[@jc2rico]

Ty, not only did I just regress(literally felt it happen) but I’ve also lost all minute of life.

[@emh8604]

Listening to this man passionately discuss something with great interest. I basically shut down about halfway through this and don't know what just happened.

[@Optim40]

This is what you call "Professional Simping." Unbelievable right now. I just cant.

[@quequea]

😂😂😂

[@nicoleraheem1195]

😂😅 Relatable

[@Jen-Inspired]

Me too! I got to the end of the video and was like "wooow! But what did he even say?"

[@pr9039]

One ancient tribe of warriors who murdered their way through most of the Steppes met up with another ancient tribe of warriors who slaughtered them then enslaved and raped their women.

[@RARA64HUNNID]

think the phrase he was looking for was *”R_p’d & Pillaged”*

[@dideetahu4907]

I just replied to someone's comment with this exact line😂

[@fajaradi1223]

How about "traded", tho unwillingly

[@Yousef-lb4ip]

@@fajaradi1223today that’s called "kidnapping"

[@HELLISHHANDZ]

​@fajaradi1223 i perfer forcefully courted

[@potatomagnet7070]

@@johnnysilverhand1733 this comment has no relation to what the op comment said

[@mostsacredstories]

WTF do they mean? Nomads travel as entire communities. It's not "male or female" driven, its community driven.

[@SP-qi8ur]

Well, they mean precisely that… i.e. the spread of certain genes was carried out mostly by one gender

[@Edmund18021988]

In many mammal species, it's common for a group of males to leave the tribe and try their luck elsewhere. From elephants to whales, The males are often kicked out even.

[@badaoe3stratsonly130]

When traveling through territory they know, they travel as a group. Yes. But the Mongol and Hunnic modus operandi was to use semi self sufficient groups of mounted riders as a vanguard force. You send in scouts before the main group goes in. That's been true from the greeks to the modern day. If you don't know what the hell is ahead. You send up a few people first. So if there's a danger, like thin ice or some dude waiting with a bow. You don't lose the whole group.

[@LS-xs7sg]

He simply means that the males of the tribe had first dibs on the native women for a time. Presumably because the native men were killed, enslaved or subjugated. They probably practiced polygamy or concubinage. It sounds like over time the corded ware people put up enough of a fight to start taking yamamya women. They probably adopted then new technologies

[@dab0331]

When conquering men take multiple wives they'll have one wife from their culture and all the extras from the tribe they slaughtered.

[@AJxxxxxxxx]

The scholars way of describing Rape and pillaging in a conquest

[@ramonessikbar5719]

with asmile

[@Ozone814]

Absorb and take…that’s a polite way of putting it

[@carloko08]

that "man" look like a gay one and obviously is a dammed woke, is their way to mask the reality in something politically correct

[@zachkent2575]

Not the term that would be used if the Europeans had been doing the expanding

[@Sebastianator01]

Lol seriously tamed way is saying it. Nobody says that about the Incas, Aztecs, or Mayans when they did it. I wonder why they make it sound so polite ?

[@Threezi04]

​@@zachkent2575 The Yamnaya are literally ancestral to modern Europeans and originated in Europe 💀

[@jemiinou]

@zachkent2575 Did you watch the video or do you want to feel like a victim for 5 seconds on the internet?

[@AniketanPelletier]

either this was edited or Dr Reich is seriously simplifying the facts, in a way that really obfuscated and disrupts people’s understanding. No, there was not a “90%” population replacement - there was about a 40% admixture on average of Yamnaya DNA, peaking at 55% in Norwegians and as little as 7% in Sardinia. There was a 90% replacement of Britain’s population by a population that was 50% Yamnaya at most, and a 90% replacement of the male lineages in Spain. Basically, Yamnayans killed most pre-Yamnaya males in Europe, but they bred extensively with the local women.

[@DwarkeshPatel]

It is a bit edited! He says 50-90% in the full interview. It's super hard to fit all the complexity from his interview into a 60 seconds. Dr. Reich was extremely careful not to overstate his conclusions. We're doing our best to keep things accurate, coherent, and entertaining

[@sciencefliestothemoon2305]

​@@DwarkeshPatelit is entertaining enough, more important to keep it accurate. Otherwise it means invocating the spirit of Rogan. 😅

[@user-yt3xd2jl6d]

Genetic data of the "pure" Iberians, without North African mixture, are 60% Anatolian Farmers, 29% Yamnaya, 11% Western Hunter Gatherers

[@elmexo4375]

You could still wipe put 90% of them if the natives are more populous than the yamnaya and those statistics would remain true.

[@kaushikvsmaniyan]

Story of humanity's existence till today

[@Bbydunn28]

I read somewhere that the yamnaya brought smallpox from the cattle they brought, and it wiped out the neolithic farmers who had no immunity.

[@goofguy316]

He also spoke of that as well in the podcast. Disease played an important role. It was present during the European contact with the New World, and existed in the past as well.

[@brandonrandall3861]

Cowpox and smallpox are related so it's logical evolution.

[@mtman2]

​@@brandonrandall3861 Likely not in being merely similar

[@lufsolitaire5351]

The domestication of cows is also where we got Tuberculosis from as well.

[@reddixiecrat]

I think you’re thinking of Black Plague which is believed to be the cause of the Neolithic decline

[@Dewan0529]

Genghis Khan be like “Hold My Drinking Bowl”

[@bee6684]

😂😂😂Brilliant 😂😂😂

[@voskresenie-]

except this was way more significant than Genghis Khan's conquest, at least relative to population

[@cacao1312]

Everyone owes everyone reparations

[@jason4275]

Europe can start, the scramble for Africa AKA Europe invasion of Africa, WW1 in Africa 1890

[@Peter-sl6mf]

So the rich nations have to compensate the poor nations for their lack of ability. Let's find a scape goat colonialism And slavery by white people. I never hear about Japanese colonialism and slavery of 100.000s of white men or millions of asians

[@willfeen]

No

[@cacao1312]

@@willfeen yup and Arabs owe the most since they created the first and largest slave trade in the history of the world they actually kidnapped people from multiple continents and castrated millions of men that killed around 50% in the process and kidnapped millions of women for sex slaves they kidnapped people for slavery since Islam doesn't allow for followers of Islam to be enslaved

[@deusvult7947]

Yes. Pay up N

[@redtube8667]

I bet the first cavalrymen felt like war gods and everyone who saw them were absolutely terrified

[@alejandrop.s.3942]

Apparently that happened in America and helpt the conquistadores to gain momentum.

[@redtube8667]

@@alejandrop.s.3942 that didn't happen in the Americas. The Natives fully understood the Europeans were humans.

[@WWLinkMasterX]

@@redtube8667 Humans who could talk to antler-less elk and bend them to their will.

[@redtube8667]

@@WWLinkMasterX the Native Americans weren't stupid and understood how to domesticate animals. Just say you're racist and move on.

[@elliottbaker201]

Big dogs ​@@WWLinkMasterX

[@aantonparra]

Aren't these guys what is more commonly known as the indoeuropean invasions of Europe?

[@user-yt3xd2jl6d]

Yeah

[@IslandersFan100]

Proper term is Aryan (who were the Celts, Finnics, Germanics and Slavs)

[@aantonparra]

@@IslandersFan100 I see we are getting onto something 😏

[@BoredSquirell]

The term Indo-Europan fell out of fashion, first because it's also the name of a language family, second because the "Yamnaya" were a well defined culture and most expansionist out of several related groups

[@kc4276]

​@@IslandersFan100 No it's not. It was the Indo-Iranians who used that term for themselves. This 'theory' died along with your leader in 1945.

[@marcbow]

Imagine how terrifying it would be to just suddenly be in the presence of these ancient, incredibly hard human ancestors. There was absolutely no fucking around back then, you fuck around you better be strong and skilled enough to survive.

[@intermilan9731]

Not exactly. It probably isn't exactly like Hollywood. Remember a lot of these people peacefully immigrated to India and simply settled down all the way to the borders of Burma. Some fought. But most of it was peaceful immigration. Fighting would be mostly in southern Russian regions as there were other similar tribes competing and not being docile.

[@archelon111]

​@@intermilan9731Buddy it was so much worse than Hollywood they have skeletons with weapon damage to prove it

[@jhor729]

Weren't they short and shortlived relatively uneducated?

[@MateuszMisztela]

​@@jhor729No

[@XX-ew8cr]

they were probably like 5' 2" and had rickets

[@duncanmacduff559]

The extended video has its comments turned off. Cant help but wonder why.

[@bigdeal6852]

Is it because it's 🐂💩 ? 🤣🤣

[@piterpraker3399]

Probably because it's all horse shit. Mendelian genetics, mutation, and natural selection does not explain the origins of humanity, let alone life - and we've known that since at least 1953 as per Darwin's own explanation of the critical pitfalls of his theory. These people can't let go. They've spent too much personal time and money, built too many institutions, and taken on too many students to continue their blunder. They do not like the implications of the impossibility of life, and a "natural" world which is anything but.

[@carloko08]

2030 agenda

[@TheBooban]

Sounds like modern history.

[@benjamincarnes9117]

They don’t want people correcting their bs history they are trying to rewrite

[@SuperSoundtracksEX]

Sounds like i’m getting reparations.

[@gabe1277]

Why

[@alexnowicki286]

@@gabe1277bc bro

[@dogbert52]

Suing putin? Good luck with that

[@nicolasolton]

For what?

[@GSXK4]

I demand reparations from myself.

[@NamaRauqos04595]

Having observed the comments, it seems fair to say that youtube shorts are a detriment to spreading information.

[@dewilew2137]

Isn’t the point of shorts to entice you to watch the full video? I’d say it served its purpose.

[@imitationpitaya]

@@dewilew2137sure, but there are topics complicated enough that you can’t boil it down to 60 second short. And without being precise, all it does is contribute to misinformation

[@fabolvaskarika7940]

@@imitationpitayapeople who know the facts still can spread misinformation. Putin not a stupid man and still spread around the world with his enablers, including western politicians, journalists misinformations. They make believe people the the white is black and the black is white. Did you know for example that in Springfield Haitian migrants eat pets. 45 saw on tely! 😂

[@gsnail8189]

Unless one knows how to put things together in a nutshell clear and bright😚

[@gsnail8189]

@@dewilew2137 so sexy

[@elizabethjarrett8473]

FASCINATING.....I've never heard of the Yamnaya. Thank you for sharing this !!!

[@NoelleBenedite]

🎉🎉🎉. qu' est ce que le yamnaya s'il vous plaît ??? 🎉🎉🎉. Merci pour votre réponse. 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉😊

[@AmmaSoelberg]

I feel like this is what you hear when you're having a stroke

[@Jeizych]

😂😂😂😂

[@DIABOLICAL-6]

Propably.

[@Machoman50ta]

@@Jeizychwell it’s all made up anyways just an educated guess they try to feed like a new religion called science 😂

[@kazzaclev]

😂

[@jackgrant9301]

Its a bit like trying to watch tv while youre tripping on mushrooms. I should know, ive done a lot of hallucinogens.......watched tv a few times too

[@richb2229]

Tribal warfare in ancient native people…how unexpected.

[@aflaz171]

Exactly!

[@aflaz171]

Exactly!

[@usmcmustang2972]

It's still going on today ... One tribe dyes their hair blue and puts nose rings in random parts of their bodies and shake their fist at God... While other tribes get jobs, own businesses, manufacture and produce things and honor and thank God for their blessings. These two tribes are always at war with each other.. and their tribal chieftans today are struggling to see which tribe will prevail ... Of the blue hairs win, there will be no one to feed them. If the workers win, they are just forced to continue to feed the blue hairs ... So I ask ... "What's it worth to continue?" 🤔

[@ComeMoonandStar.]

​@@usmcmustang2972This comment doesn't sound biased at all.

[@keagantaylor5070]

@@usmcmustang2972 The chief keef says if you eat a blue crayon you become one in the night. Spooky

[@Voodoo_Robot]

It's so funny how nobody in the comments understood what he said.

[@clarkvaughan]

That's why I'm reading comments. At first, I thought the women went off on their own, then I thought they got left behind. Now I think they all just got molested, or 'absorbed'. I'll watch the full video.

[@hyperdrivecollections6460]

I’m with you! I worry about the effects of KZbin shorts consumption over, say a decade. My fear is that bite-sized, non-contextualized, unverified content will erode factual data. Human history could potentially be wiped away, supplanted by misleading 15 second opinions driven by “likes” It’s a rather horrifying conundrum

[@glowinthedarkzombie]

​@@hyperdrivecollections6460 exactly and its not an accident. Each generation ends up smarter than the last but governments, for generations have tried so hard to dumb us down and kill off the best, brightest of us. You can tell it really backfired with a large fraction of millennials and gen Z, as we were the first to notice the patterns and rapidly spread the truth like never before (thanks internet) no wonder the government wants you to focus on why social media is BAD AND EVIL and not the fact that most of them want to fVck our children.

[@EncroachingShadow-og1td]

@@Voodoo_Robot Yeah, they are probably aren’t even aware that they aren’t even indo-european genetically but mainly descended from those conquered and assimilated farmer peoples preceding the yamnayan invasion. The funniest ones are that looking down upon them. They are literally looking down on their own ancestors lmao.

[@usmcmustang2972]

These headlines shorts, are what create more and more dumbed down democrats.. especially when it comes to history, religion, science or politics .. Things that leftists usually ignore completely, but claim to be experts in.

[@ibbygirl1417]

🥺 Those poor women.

[@TheDirtyWork]

Colonialism is violent. Poor kids and women in Gaza!

[@Sjattuh]

​@@TheDirtyWorkindeed... I agree with you, it is sad for them. Just like those poor women and children when they attacked Israel from Gaza, for no reason and that's how this all started, by just walking into Israel and started killing at random. Then kidnapped a few hundred at random.... Imagine Mexican cartels did this to the USA and then the USA invaded Mexico to whipe out said cartels and the whole world starts to turn against the USA for doing that.... Or if instead, after the invasion, random killing, and subsequent kidnapping of hundreds, your president decided to do nothing... Ppl in this world are such sheep they just stop looking at the facts and join he group that shouts the loudest. I'm so happy for all the poor women and children in Israel that Trump won your election, and only for that, because he will simply say to Hamas to leave Israel alone or else he will just bomb whole of Gaza into a sinkhole.

[@SerenaSeyamer]

@@Sjattuhyou’re very kind, the way you normalise Palestinian children getting murdered in hospitals, the way civilians get gunned down while waving a white flag and how Palestinian women get raped by the idf. Your humanity is showing, I’m sure you’re ancestors and children will be very proud of your disgusting heart

[@TheDirtyWork]

@@Sjattuh I will pray for your soul. Your heart is in a very dark place. I know my history and I know my ancient history. Israel is not innocent. And men who lead nations into violence -well,their souls will answer for that eternally,over and over again. And blind humans, slave to their egos, will probably continue their greedy self destruction. Always blaming, always destroying. Men excel at that. Wake up

[@TheDirtyWork]

@@Sjattuh cut the crap, please.

[@BaltimoresBerzerker]

This little clip is going to confuse ppl who are unacquainted with prehistoric European genetics and cultural complexes. Modern European ethnicities have their own unique admixtures of Yamnaya steppe, Ancient Anatolian Farmers, and indigenous hunter gathers of various types (Eastern, western, caucus). Some are mostly one or the other, such as Sardinians are mostly Ancient European Farmer. I recommend dedicated videos from Survive the Jive, Fortress of Lugh, etc for layman to get an understanding. For African history fans, a similar thing happened with them during the Bantu expansion...just no horses and wagons.

[@IndorilTheGreat]

Hey just a heads up, StJ and FoL are both bigoted.

[@heiliger_sturm]

African history? Didn’t know that existed.

[@VanaeCavae]

Indian genetic history has something similar and yet different admixture. Indian have varying degrees of admixtures from Veddoid indigenous hunter gathers, Ancient Zagrosian Farmers and Yamnaya Steppe Pastoralists.

[@BaltimoresBerzerker]

@IndorilTheGreat loving your cultural and ethnic heritage isn't bigotry. Even so, they both cite sources out the wazoo. The history, genetics, etc that they cover are factual. STJ has gotten things wrong like twice and proceeded to correct himself publicly. You may not like them, their spiritual beliefs, or their ancestral background, but they're not misinforming anyone regarding history and genetics.

[@ikeafanatic1749]

Asia used to have a huge chariot culture. Now they have a huge car culture... who invented the automobile? A german guy did, and his invention was enabled by the English's industrial revolution. The automobile also enabled women's suffrage as it gave them the freedom and mobility to organize. Starting revolutionary innovation is our speciality. We need other people to make our inventions/systems better. And when you make a system for the first time, nobody really has an idea of what they are doing. Look at London's subway system, it was the first subway system, but they had no idea what they were doing and made horrible decisions that had unforeseen long-term consequences. The first farmers and their civilizations were crappy... but their work would form the foundation of God in various religions and creation myths. In genesis, God creates the earth with farming concepts like the weekday, signs, seasons, etc... although that one is probably based on the Zagros farmers in the levant whose prized crop was the fig tree... the forbidden tree in Eden... because if you ate too many fruits, it wouldn't propagate.

[@lexx5313]

"Sir, this is a Wendy's drive through"

[@ArpanDe]

What is blud waffling about🙏🏻😭

[@ZsomborGyökös]

top comment..

[@avantigabourel7384]

😂

[@robertchiarizia9463]

@@lexx5313 in that case, coukd I have a Biggie bag with the large fries and a small chocolate frosty. Mahalo.

[@robertchiarizia9463]

@@ArpanDe Blood Eagle

[@TifaseLSSTLK]

That was the politest way to say grape or SA

[@comenowletusreasontogether1337]

Sort of like abortion.

[@AnuragShende-jj2dx]

​@@comenowletusreasontogether1337Sort of like Christianity.

[@spencerstevens2175]

He probably works at a university. He's been totally neutered by the insanity there

[@pedrofreitas4262]

@@AnuragShende-jj2dx ?

[@KristenSlice]

Uh, the word you're using didn't even exist until 1150.

[@BeautyKeren]

Nothing is free in the kingdom of darkness! You go round in circles! No peace! Just confusion! The Devil will always demand something back! he is the father of Lies! This story teaches us to love Jesus and have a personal Relationship with Him! Love Him and Submit to His Will. Seek First the Kingdom of God and all these things shall be added unto you..

[@nigelkhan1969]

The history of our ancient ancestors is always quite intriguing to learn. Whether good or bad it's our history and we can't change the past.

[@toddoliver1205]

Tell that to American democrats

[@davidmartinez688]

@@toddoliver1205 tell that to Lost Cause and Trumper conservatives too

[@toddoliver1205]

@@davidmartinez688 no that’s the lazy lying left that tried to kill off millions but it didn’t work.

[@Aromatic.Bleach]

how about you both shut up? so sick of political sh**

[@theflamingeagle572]

Tell that to all of the United States

[@Jtbrahh]

"Wiped out" is misleading. Europeans are the product of Indo-Europeans and early european farmers, who are a mix of anatolian farmers and European hunter gatherers.

[@BoredSquirell]

In the full video he actually makes the point that the Indo-Europan invasion was more violent than previously thought.

[@StuStevens-rn7rb]

Anatoly - weight lifter extrodonaire. 🤔😯👍😎

[@KhrisJenkins]

​@@BoredSquirell of course look at the r and murder of current Europeans invasion from an outside group is never pretty

[@Gold_Silver.]

@@BoredSquirellto be fair, if u go into anything u thought was fairly violent in history, it normally leans slaughtering/pillaging for gold & silver.

[@astha77]

There were no Arabian farmers back then.

[@AxiomApe]

Time is definitely a theme here. We see not one, but two separate drum kits. Drums, as we know are what helps keeps time in a song…tempo..rhythm.. so much imagery here.

[@LS-xs7sg]

This is a bit out there but in a lot of early folklore the fairies, leprechauns, brownies etc are described as short & darker than humans. They wore green clothes etc. they steal babies and put their own babies in their place. They are more connected with nature and are afraid of iron. It might apply more to the arrival of the Neolithic farmers than the indo europeans but couldn’t these stories be an echo of a defeated people who were small and dark who fled to the woods as they could not stand against iron weapons. Dwindled in number, inbred and stole babies etc. it is all very George r Martin “children of the forest” I know but you have to wonder how subsequent generations made sense of their defeated enemies

[@michaelcaffery5038]

It is a bit fanciful but I too have wondered if some of the tales of legendary creatures are a memory carried in stories of Neanderthals/Denisovens with who we co-existed, and bred with, for a long time. Maybe as little as 24,000 years ago in the Iberian peninsula. These stories often have an element of regret and guilt over their passing. Perhaps Homo Sapiens thought something like "although we had our differences it's a shame they are gone". Just unprovable speculation I know.

[@LS-xs7sg]

@@michaelcaffery5038 You also have to factor in the weirdness of ancient beliefs where magic was just taken for granted in lots of cases. There wasnt this hard conceptual line westerners have between the physical provable world and the imaginary. And we are much more used to human difference than people probably where in the past. We find it weird that the catholic church had debates about whether native americans counted as human so I dont find it that implausible that neolithic farmers would develop a narrative to explain a strange dwindling people in the woods. It is my understanding that in britain there was a resurgence of the hunter gatherer dna through the maternal line after the initial neolithic invasion so there was also mixing going on. If you look at the Irish Pagan stories about fomorians or the aesir vs vanir of norse mythology you can see interesting possibilities.

[@Elfrida-ls2mo]

Read and Learn Real GBUK History if YT does not D It The Wall Wildlings Children of the Forests were the Picts The First Native Brits The Picts were Tiny and Very Dark Still African Looking when They first Ruled GBUK and all it's Islands including the Island later Called Ireland The Native Brit Picts bred with the Friendly Viking for Thousands of Years The Friendly Vikings were always bringing lost Homeless people to the Friendly Picts including Different Types of Orient People over a Thousand years Apart Just over a Century before the Romans invaded the Vikings Brought the Celts in Massive Numbers the Celts even Came in their Own Ships some believe they were the Spartan Army who Left Greece after A Fight with their own People who had Teamed up with The Turks which was insane the Spartan Army and Spartan men refused to turn Gay and Hate Women Which the Majority of Greeks still were at this Time Like Alexander the Great who was born In Macedonia brought up in Greece to be king Alex Was No Bio he was Gay dont believe the BS Especially Blaming his Mum who never saw her Son again After he was most likely an Infant and Certainly not over the age of 7 The Celts or Spartans bred with the Native Picts However the 1st and 2nd Gen of Celts or Spartans Betrayed the Native Picts and Took over not by War Many of the Young liked the Celtic or Spartan Ways however the Celts or Spartans had back stabbed The Picts who had given them a Home and Maybe saved their life and for the First time in GBUK History Two Tribes were Created in GBUK The Picts could easily have taken the Celts Spartans However this would have meant Killing some of their Children Grand Children Family When the Shocked Viking Came to ask What they Could do The Picts Chieftains King told the Vikings There is Nothing we can do the Celts? Have Played their hand Well When the Romans invaded Both British Tribes Joined up together to Fight the Romans and Nearly Won Sadly Both Tribes Realised the Romans had an Endless Supply of Soldiers from all over the World not Just Europe The Mostly Pict Tribe with the Rightful Native Chieftains Royals King to GBUK Fled to the North of GBUK Largest Island which at this Time in History was Frozen with Ice and Snow most of the Year this Area would later be Called Scotland and the Mostly Native Pict Tribe would be Called The Scots who would go Down In History as the Only Tribe in Europe not to be Defeated by the Romans The Romans hated the Now Native Pict Mix Brit Scots as They had not only Shamed the Romans the Romans Could never Claim to have Conquered GBUK and All GBUK Islands including the Island now Called Ireland as the now Named Scots had the Rightful Native Pict Chieftains Royals and King of GBUK and Still Controlled Nearly all GBUK Islands And A Massive Part of GBUK Land much Larger than where the Wall is today it was only a Decade before Rome Fell that the Romans Finally managed to Push the native Pict mix Brits the Scots Back with the Help of Thousands of Extra Soldiers sent from Rome and Sadly the Slaves of England Wales Ireland Even Then when the Romans built their Wall it was still Many Miles inside today's England The Romans were so Ashamed and Angry they Told the Rest of their Controlled World this Wall is the End of the World Although the Now named English Welsh Irish had been Slaves under the Romans for many Centuries the Now named Scots never stopped Trying to Rescue their Other Kin Sadly this got Harder as time went By as the now Named English Welsh Irish lost their Native Languages of GBUK Islands Also their Roman Masters did a Good Job of Brain Washing their Slaves telling them they had always Been Slaves and the People Beyond the Wall were not Human Their is A Lot more to Tell and I am Missing out a Lot the Romans RC Church Pagan French RC Germans all Hated the Native Picts mix Brits now named Scots because they Never Stopped Fighting every invader to their Lands and Islands Regardless of their Religion The Romans The RC Church The French Pagans The German RCs and their Familys who now Control GBUK Today All Tried to wipe out the History of the Picts Destroying Graves And Shockingly even today Have tried to wipe out the Picts from History No GBUK History in Schools talk about the Picts who were and are the First Native Brits They Few things the Evil 1s and all their Puppets say about the Picts is mostly Lies Lately The Evil 1s in GBUK have Tried to Wipe out the Picts with their Fake Political BS DNA Kits telling Scots they had No Pict DNA not knowing many Scots still know a Lot of GBUK Real History and their Family's were Native Pict When Some Threatened to dig up some of their Family's Graves the Few ones Left These Fake DNA kit owners told them Sorry er yes you do have some Pict or Scot Although with saying Scot they were still trying to get away with not saying Pict The Welsh and Irish nearly Two Thousand years Later were allowed to Go to Scotland to learn some of the Old GBUK Languages from the Scots Who unbelievable were banned From Speaking it What the Welsh and Irish still never got the Language the Scots now Spoke was a Mix of all the old Pict Viking Languages from all UK Islands mixed with Celt and a Few Words from Other Races When Men From Donegal in Ireland were sent to work in the HighLands of Scotland they were Shocked to find the Highlanders including Tiny Dark High spirited Women Talked their Mix Native Pict Celt Languages which no one in Ireland Spoke The men From Donegal were more Shocked when all the Highlanders Massive Fair or Red and Tiny and Dark said Welcome Home it's been a Long Time

[@FrostyGerardo-kr7xs]

It has happened before with the hobbits,Skraelings/viking mix and Native Americans gigants

[@sam12587]

It’s a valid theory. I read a few years ago signs of a small Hobbit like people somewhere. I’m really starting to think that the old tales are actually of varieties of humans that bred out into the sands of time.

[@craigthomas7920]

Watched 3 minutes and took away that the culture with the best weapons expanded . No different today.

[@AgnesCongdon-xk8hr]

In Ireland there were poets who expanded upon historical events. 1 event was about these people who had a prophet tell them they would eventually travel westward to the farthest lands. Many groups followed the prophet's directions. One group was in Espanola for 14 generations, before the king of the group took many youths to Egypt to let them learn trades. When the youths completed their apprenticeships and were well seasoned they returned to Spain and taught the next generations who traveled on to Ireland and lands beyond. At the time the Atlantic sea levels were lower and travel between European kingdoms, England, Ireland and other islands was a matter of walking or using carts. There were several migrations of these peoples from the Steeps of 🌏 Asia to Europe and 🌍 Africa. Some later generations went to European lands and westward to the islands 🏝 of the American Continents. Many may have stayed behind and enjoyed wars with their own cousins like every other kingdom and neighboring lands or islands. We haven't changed behaviors and life goals ever. 😮 Thanks for mentioning the matter. I have been waiting to use that tiny bit of information for over 20 years. 😊

[@desmondmurray5160]

England isn't an island.

[@runningwaters787]

​@@desmondmurray5160 other islands

[@LGrian]

@@desmondmurray5160more accurate to say England isn’t the entirety of the island on which it exists.

[@desmondmurray5160]

@@LGrian Which means it's not an island, neither are Wales and Scotland.

[@LS-mp7co]

@@desmondmurray5160 Dear Desmond....everyone else got exactly what the posting individual meant except for you. You decided to split hairs and try to make the posting individual look uneducated. Which says more about your character than I can say while staying polite. Grow up.

[@mindblowing3202]

"According to genetic evidence, it is likely that Northern Slavic people are the most direct descendants of Proto-Indo-Europeans. Yamna culture, which is associated with the Proto-IE language…"

[@Feanor1169]

I love how the illustrator gave the first guy psychotic, crazy eyes.

[@ZorroTomas94]

😂😂😂😂

[@rebekah1216]

The Akhal-Teke horse breed came from this region. It’s an important part of the historical background that validates a lot of tales.

[@In-Gall_Tegidda_n_Tesemt]

The Akhal-Teke is a beautiful horse… it’s coat absolutely glimmers in the sun, it’s my second favorite after the Prezwalski horse which dates back 20,000 years…

[@Grungeuncle]

Sorry but wrong, Akhal Teke is very young and one of the relatively new speicies bred by Turcomans. Akhal Teke only has 1 single maternal ancestery from Yamnaya Horses. Maybe you're thinking of Marwari horse? But again both are much more of BMAC and / or Sintashta ancestry horses rather than Yamnaya.

[@zomberkay]

Teke is ours lmao😂

[@juanitascott9367]

I love this breed. The shiny, satiny look of their coats is amazingly beautiful ❤

[@genuscorvid]

​@@zomberkayPan turk larper

[@xtramail4909]

The idea that the Yamnaya wiped out 90% of Europe is an oversimplification and not supported by current archaeological or genetic evidence. They contributed to the genetic makeup of Europeans but they entered genetics through complex interactions rather than outright replacement.

[@ikeafanatic1749]

Were the Yamanya hawt :o

[@Alejojojo6]

I'm from Iberia. For example, I have U5b which is a maternal mitocondrial DNA from Ice Age European hunter-gatherers (20 000-12 000) while on my paternal side I have the R1b-M269 haplogroup from the Yamnaya (around 5000 years ago)... and here it has been proven that they used local neolithic sites that were holy for the neolithics to bury yamnaya. That is cultural mixing.

[@Gismotronics]

I really enjoyed his full interview. Very interesting.

[@RandmUser9]

Please find your info on this stuff elsewhere

[@bliss9595]

It’s weird the Yamnaya name stuck in the West. Yamnaya is a conjugated adjective in the Russian language, which means “of the pit”, as in “pit archaeological culture” Because they dug a lot of pits for burials, as opposed to others who burned corpses or made above-ground burial piles.

[@drakethesnek6429]

They're also called kurgan people.

[@drakethesnek6429]

@thatonedude6247 ya I know, but the yamnaya people are also sometimes referred to as the kurgan people.

[@themadmanwithapen]

Yes. They’re named after their burial practices. They were discovered in Russia and named by Russian anthropologists so their name is Russian. The people themselves did not call themselves Yamnaya.

[@CharlesCowart-x2w]

Yamnaya just had a badass ring to it.

[@IslandersFan100]

It’s a attempt at historical revisionism to wipe out the Aryans, these people were Aryans, who are most genetically similar to modern Irish

[@RO-B96]

💯 thank you for being so raw & authentic. I’m 27 and feel so lost in life and only have one person that actually understands me. I’ve been back & fourth for years feeling guilty about cutting people off but it’s more draining keeping them.

[@jennifer9325]

Your idols will inevitably fail you. They cannot save you. This includes relationships,family, education , money etc..Jesus is the way the truth and the life. He will never fail or forsake you. That's His promise to you. He sacrifices himself for you. Love and seek him as your top priority . Because He loved you first despite your sins, weaknesses and failings. He alone can save you from slavery to self and sin.

[@ChuckHae]

It's funny how he talks so confidently about something that may have or may not have existed 5000+ years ago 😂😂😂

[@tiltil9442]

I like how yo confidently try to swipe left on academic research. lofl

[@extraditori6604]

bro is that type of ppl who think earth is flat cuz they didn't see it being a ball

[@TheChuckfuc]

There's only 2 ways we know that something happened in history: 1st eye witness testimony. 2nd, archeological evidence. All these stories that are told is just a hypothesis. That's why we study Rome so much, because they wrote a lot in great detail and left a lot of artifacts behind to study.

[@RaffleRaffle]

Bro (you) graduated from a McDonald's bathroom

[@k.3050]

have you ever heard about the scholarly and academic field of archeology? As you know, they have refined methodology, both using natural science, with c-14 dating, radiocarbon dating, dendrochronology, stratigraphy, obsidian hydration, fission track dating, thermoluminescence testing. as well as DNA analysis and sequencing with methods such as PCR and restriction fragment length polymorphism. You know organic material can easily be analysed with these methods, you can also analyse bones from bodies, you can analyse tools people used and infer their production techniques. You can track population change and transversal with DNA analysis and so on...

[@ianmacfarlane1241]

Amazing that the footage is colour - I thought it'd be black and white.

[@demsrchildabusers7959]

That's how you know it's fake. The World didn't start getting colors until the 20th century.

[@Kalafinwë]

Interesting that coloured footage was developped in 1902, nearly two decades after the first ever footage in the late 1880s. After that it only developped, leading to televised colouration.

[@jimjensen1096]

Good one!

[@edheldude]

The corded ware actually had clay cameras, possibly the first ones in prehistory.

[@kaviyap5171]

Please post videos regularly, my fav channel❤

[@sarahs8371]

I can relate to what you are sayibg because ive been talking to JWs and Mormons, being as kind as possible and humble while standing for free grace. For me its a struggle to be loving in a way that doesn't offend them while being firm. I almost feel like a coward when I try to not offend others which conflicts with my feeling of wanting to be gentle yet wanting to speak the truth.

[@constantine5]

Yamnaya bro lookin like Techno Viking.

[@chuck_machine]

Awesome, bro. Never forget TechoViking!!

[@arminiusdergrosse]

And don't forget the Corded Ware warrior made to look like he came from the Bronx or the South Side of Chicago for "The Narrative's™" sake.

[@billclemons5593]

LMFAOOOOOO OH SHIT!

[@ThunderSen]

Dude I think you have piece of hair on the screen. I cant get it from my side. Can you get it for me?

[@Ong.s_Jukebox]

histories of ancient humans are really cool.

[@falconking9091]

Casually talking about genocide

[@charleshash4919]

Like in Gaza and Sudan today?

[@intelligencecube6752]

Genocide is surprisingly common in Humans throughout history. Indo-European expansions killed off the natives in Europe, Turkic Expansions in the Steppe killed off the Indo-European Nomads, Chinese Expansions killed off / assimilated the native peoples all around them (which is a Chinese tradition that continues to this day 👀) Austronesians killed off the group of people who we know now as the “Negrito’s”, and the Bantu peoples in Africa genocided almost the entirety of Sub-Saharan Africa and populated it themselves. These facts are uncomfortable, but nonetheless true. Genocide is just something that Humans do throughout time and space when they can.

[@robertchiarizia9463]

@@charleshash4919those who refuse to learn from history will become history. ☠️❄️🤡☠️

[@financialfirepower5513]

@@intelligencecube6752 Indo-Aryan.. lol

[@EmperorBEternal]

​@@intelligencecube6752And the BLACK Moors that controlled and civilized and dominated Europeans

[@FayreeenAarow]

Very interesting would like to know more. Thank you.

[@Me_Caveman]

We are very prideful to believe everyone who came before us were less intelligent. I'd guess they were too.

[@ants7279]

Yeah that's why the history channel still tells us that humans didn't build the pyramids.

[@seasonedbeefs]

Yeah just go to the history museums. When you look at the jewellery from 5000 plus years ago you realise how sophisticated they were. Today we might have literacy but our ancestors were the most capable and advanced type in history. They got us here. Socialism makes it worse.

[@Loopez-o3u]

And we have gobegli tepi an stone hange's we are growing less intelligent,

[@annannya1356]

its a result of ignorance, we didnt know any better. we have information that dates back only a few thousand years, which is prob tempered as well, because winners create their legacy and destroy the rest

[@ants7279]

@annannya1356 For real,remember when the Spanish toor down the Aztec capital it was said that they had the largest Pyramid in the wolrd I've been to Egypt and I'm telling you I was pretty disappointed it was nice but I hoped it would be bigger just imagen if they kept the city would have been awesome,altho I'm curious how easy it was to destroy the pyramids brick by brick maybe it's easier to brake down than to build.

[@Mr-hv2xv]

Seems like an educated guess rather than fact tbh

[@LordWoodlouse]

Some things we know (the genetic analysis is factual) but what that means is down to interpretation. Basically like any science. It's a bunch of facts we have to tie together and figure out what they mean.

[@BoredSquirell]

We can't really know facts, the people back then didn't have writing and couldn't document what actually happened. Educated guess is the best we can do

[@MiguelGarcia-vj7oo]

​@@LordWoodlouse genetic science is not conclusive..... We are still limited by our technology which is why it's still expanding.....

[@Potatosalad5-sg9yr]

Yeah that's what he literally said

[@Your-Least-Favorite-Stranger]

​​@@MiguelGarcia-vj7ooThats how science works. We throw every tool we have at our disposal at the problem until it seems like something fits; over time we refine the method and realize "Oh, that wasnt the full story. We were sorta there but not quite", then some time later we get some single previously unknown piece that utterly upends the previous conclusions and changes the entire picture but we have the benefit of the last 20ish years that helped us recognize this piece of data for what it is. Its a process of continually improving our methods to get the best answers possible; you're right until you're not, then you keep an open mind and repeat the process.

[@apurvakmr]

History of human beings is truly fascinating

[@Cody_Benoun]

The guys face at the very beginning just screams "Tf you say to me?"

[@desperatefortuneproduction3296]

I love the 'DNA double helix' in the bas relief image with the horse and cart!!😊

[@BaltimoresBerzerker]

Is that a real archeological piece?

[@desperatefortuneproduction3296]

@@BaltimoresBerzerker My guess is that the piece is probably real but the 'double helix'' resemblance to DNA is coincidental.

[@jamesjameson2244]

Its illustrated in many ancient works of art around the globe and its not a coincidence. Mainstream archeology is willfully blind to the obvious fact that theres a huge section of human history thats been forgotten or lost and the timeline of history is wildly different than currently believed. Take from that what you may.

[@reportedstolen3603]

@@desperatefortuneproduction3296so you don’t know lol.. just say that

[@daviddickey9832]

He was very uncomfortable and uncertain when he said that, I wonder what was going on.

[@paparuda1968]

Maybe because he’s fabricating hogwash! Cucuteni Culture and Vinca Culture are much older around Balkan and Carpatian Mountains and towards the northern Black Sea!

[@BoredSquirell]

Historians abhore giving absolute statements. As well as using loaded terms like "gen*ocide" or even "violent conquest, enslavement"

[@carloko08]

@@BoredSquirell former "profesors" are just woke activist

[@RandmUser9]

@@BoredSquirell Especially the ones of his kind

[@haha__hihi]

@@RandmUser9 you mean the educated one? :)

[@73elephants]

I like the corded ware pottery that has cords that look like like strands of DNA!

[@Hypnopotimus27]

Or a piece of rope or twine? It’s not possible that they understood DNA.

[@terruwuism]

​@@Hypnopotimus27 yeah you can't see DNA it is way too small and submerged in a goopy homogeneous mess even

[@michaelhauser6440]

@Hypnopotimus27 No but we have these things imprinted in our subconscious. Kinda like how a scientist gets an inkling for something outta “nowhere” and then experiments and does research to prove it or disprove it

[@73elephants]

@@Hypnopotimus27 I mentioned them because they look so much like DNA strands, they can't be actual examples of corded ware pottery, which is not so ornate.

[@73elephants]

@@michaelhauser6440 We don't have DNA "imprinted in our conscious", and corded ware pottery is not that sophisticated.

[@vessagroker98]

I'm from germany and there was a documentery about a german woman who fell for a romance scammer from Nigeria, they even flew her down to Nigeria and she met the scammer in person. A few months later the team met her again and she told them that she continued to send money, because she still wasn't a 100 % convinced that it's REALLY a scam 😅😅😅😅

[@ModernDayRenaissanceMan]

Having already known this story I understood all of this already. Basically the women wore gold on them & were considered important. The Corded Ware people for SOME reason either saw this as wierd or magic or attractive or valuable etc. The Yamnaya people used women to mate with each other within their own culture. So basically when they got wiped out the only thing that survived from them was the women. They must have been so good, so rich, so wealthy, so powerful, so smart, so attractive, that the other cultures let themselves be lead by the Yamnaya women. Thats truly odd. We don't really see that in many other places. They would take one from Yamnaya, & keep her in their town & raise her like a Queen. Then marry her to their enemy for peace. The cycle continued even though she wasnt related to them

[@theyeking7023]

More likely that the kurgan hypothesis is a load of rubbish

[@intermilan9731]

The yamnya also weren't blonde Aryans. The corded ware people were the pure blonde ones.

[@m.t.443]

What's more fascinating is that we look at these ancient cultures, the rape and pillaging, and it's not mentioned that this is exactly what other mammals do when taking over areas. Lions, wolves, and many many more across the animal Kingdom use this tactic to keep their blood lines going. It's horrible and not very nice to think on, but it's another reason to remember that even today we are no better than other animals. At our base our instinct is to survive and thrive, at any cost. Reading about how humans evolved culturally and how different beliefs sprang out from that is always so interesting

[@ThePinkPantha21]

Yes, yet human beings are created differently to evolve differently. I really don't think we are meant to remain the same. But yes, the survival mechanism is strong and overcomes all critical thinking and awareness. Obviously our survival needs have evolved or we would still ........? It's nuanced.

[@sabsain2399]

Not you trying to justify men r/ping women lmfao

[@namedrop721]

Your conclusion that we are no better than animals is weird, given that we are able to refrain from war crimes

[@jsmithy643]

​​@@namedrop721 Your understanding of morals, and what is "right or wrong" is entirely based off of the culture you grew up in. It has no basis in instincts or biology. If your culture values conquest and raiding, then you would think that those things are ok. Plus, you are separated from these people by thousands of years. They grew up in a different time, a different place, and a diffrent world.

[@shaktimishra9710]

It's in human nature

[@mattcernjavic9999]

When he mentioned the domestication of the horse, it looked like a DNA strand at the top and bottom of the horse and wagon.

[@youteacher78]

That's because it is. It's just a fancy animation for this show.

[@BaltimoresBerzerker]

Is it a real cultural artifact??

[@idamcneill8005]

No. Drawing for video or book..​

[@saltypete3549]

For fcks sake I got excited for nothing xD

[@reportedstolen3603]

@@youteacher78seriously this was not a genuine artifact? Misleading publication

[@judithcampbell1705]

Thank you 💛. The only thing I got out of this was that they tamed horses and made corded pottery.

[@A-RJ]

Ahh.. this mystery was keeping me up at night but now i can finally sleep

[@Darvit_Nu]

I love learning about historical tribes! ❤ I'm so incredibly happy to find your channel tonight. Liked &subscribed with all notifications on! 😊

[@user-vr8zs3ei7n]

I love that crazy eyed Yamaha guy. You are just wandering the plains and you walk up on that dude. You know you are screwed.

[@intermilan9731]

He would most likely most look like one of those Bollywood actors. Albeit culturally different ofcourse with different mannerisms.

[@Shadowcat561]

​@@intermilan9731He look more like Dwayne Johnson to me

[@OliveDNorth]

You're right, it thickness that determines whether an ounce can be sent with a stamp. It's not just weight. It has to be under ¼" thick. Learned this when my brother was mailing CDs for church. Had a little gadget from the post office to gauge thickness.

[@EmisoraRadioPatio]

There were very few Yamnaya women who invaded Europe with the men, though. It was very much indeed one-sided, with male Yamnaya DNA spreading across Europe.

[@the_kimchi_kommandant2603]

Where did all the women go?

[@EmisoraRadioPatio]

@@the_kimchi_kommandant2603 Most remained in the steppe. I recall reading only 15% of those who left the steppe were women.

[@sivaratnamasabaratnam8946]

When robbers,raiders are all male like Rogue lions & elephants

[@sivaratnamasabaratnam8946]

​@@the_kimchi_kommandant2603Most men migrate if their chances are not met ,they group up with other or either banished

[@cosmicbodyguards4285]

“My mom’s ancestors are direct Yamnaya lineage yada yada me me, I, I, myself because me, I” -some random person in the KZbin comments

[@dirtyduval9258]

So true lol

[@elsvaughn7959]

Don't make fun of my great great great great great great great great great great great great great great great great great great great great great great great great great great great Grandmother. They're a REAL culture and we're finally getting some awareness

[@cosmicbodyguards4285]

@elsvaughn7959 😂😂

[@cosmicbodyguards4285]

@elsvaughn7959 I will say tho that I visited Boston & Salem & the surrounding area of Massachusetts & maybe Vermont in 2018 & it awakened my passion for history. I started my genealogy after that & found out my 7x great grandfather was a captain or colonel & knew George Washington personally because they were both from Virginia which was amazing to find out. And just knowing he played a larger role in the rebel army to gain independence from the British. I saw a picture of his gravestone & it just made me feel really connected to my ancestry. His brother too, don’t remember his name was in the group who founded Kentucky. People get very carried away tho imo

[@elsvaughn7959]

@@cosmicbodyguards4285 one's heritage can be a huge part of ur character. On my mom's side, we're related to ulysses s. grant, and on my father's side, Alexander Hamilton. On his side, we're welsh, and a great-x 250yrs- uncle of mine was an Earl of Carmarthyn. I think it's super important to know where you come from- like you said. This comment is just making fun of the ppl who lie about EVERYTHING and are related to anyone mentioned lol

[@causticchameleon7861]

My mitochondria dna haplogroup is connected to the Corded Ware people. My haplogroup W3a is a young haplogroup only going back to that time.

[@asharzaminanwarzamin9151]

Fascinating.

[@alejandrop.s.3942]

Mine is from the chimp's royalty.

[@-_YouMayFind_-]

My maternal is J2a1a and my paternal is G-Z37368 and both came out of East Africa. The groups itself are newer but still go back further back then the G-Z37368 number itself. Because the G-Z37368 does come from a male with haplogroup A that lived in East Africa 270.000 yeard ago. The G-Z37368 excists for 14000 years

[@intermilan9731]

You must have blonde hair gene.

[@causticchameleon7861]

@@intermilan9731 probably since my sister and daughter both have blondish hair. I, on the other hand, had dark brown with red highlights before I went almost completely gray.

[@michael.forkert]

_To believe that Mumbo Jumbo you have to be very fond of being bamboozled._

[@edheldude]

Bazinga.

[@your_favorite_chode_merchant]

Just like religious people

[@Firguy_the_Foot_Fetishist]

Eekum Bokum

[@AB-hh4hm]

Oompa loompa

[@mayfalltribe4747]

Oh ok. Glad we have a real expert here. Please do educate us sir.

[@jamesirmert]

Inasmuch as the Yamnaya were certainly a Warlike Aristocracy everywhere they went, it's almost certain because of that demonstrable fact everywhere else that they did not intentionally attempt to wipe out the previous inhabitants of Europe. It's most likely that what happened was what followed when their mixed descendants came to the New World. Diseases which those people had no immunity to did most of the work. And the rest was done by nearly unending violence due to fear of it. Everywhere else that the Yamnaya and their descendants went, they would wage war but only to the point of implanting themselves as a Warrior Elite and Aristocracy.

[@RamZar50]

Yamnaya expanding West into Europe and Corded Ware expanding East into the Eurasian Steppes and becoming the Sintashta which gave us fortified metallurgical industrial centers, horse chariots and spoked wheels. Are the Sintashta a mixture of Yamnaya and Corded Ware? Sintashta expanded south from the southern tip of the Ural Mountains as the Aryans and Indo-European languages into Central Asia, Northwestern India and Iran. In Iran they were the Achaemenids and Parthians.

[@user-yt3xd2jl6d]

Sintasha was closely related to Corded Ware, both Cored Ware and Sintasha had a mixture of Central European Farmers, Globular Amphora. The composition of Yamnaya is 50% CHG and 50% EHG, the composition of Sintashta is 33% EHG,36% CHG,19% Anatolian,12% WHG.

[@user-yt3xd2jl6d]

In Central Asia Sintasha gave rise to Andronovo and mixed with BMAC, BMAC culture was largely composed of Anatolian and Iranian Farmers, with a minor Hunter Gatherer component from Western Siberia. Later cultures such as Yaz were largely derived from Andronovo and BMAC. Populations such as present day Tajiks and Yaghnobis are 57% Andronovo (similar to Sintasha) and 43% BMAC derived. These Proto IndoIranian people migrated to South Asia and contributed significantly to the ancestry of present day India.

[@sachinpotdar7798]

​@@user-yt3xd2jl6dno one is indo Iranian

[@ikeafanatic1749]

Asia had a huge chariot culture. Now it has a huge car culture. It's funny how inventions spread. The German invention of the automobile made horses and chariots obsolete. And that invention was only possible because of the industrial revolution. What rules the world is not humans, but their creations.

[@le13579]

Go Partians!

[@Tourmaline200]

Jean Auel really did do a lot of research when writing the Earths Children series in my youth (this dates me) I'm always impressed when her extrapolations are in line with or vary from the research done since her very fictional stories were written.

[@2.thePoint]

Domestication of horses was much earlier than 5300 years. The Egyptians, Sindhu(Harappan, Mohenjodaro, Gangetic civilizations), Mesopotamians had done it much earlier

[@era6519]

source : I farted

[@araceli2827]

The first signs of horse domestication-pottery containing traces of mares' milk and horse teeth with telltale wear from a riding bit-come from the Botai hunter-gatherers who lived in what is now Kazakhstan from about 3700 B.C.E. to 3100 B.C.E.

[@mscreationworks5787]

The DNA study of the skeletal remains found at the Harappan site of Rakhigarhi, Haryana, shows no trace of Steppe pastoralists genetic , indicating that Aryan were never present during Indus valley civilization Time period . This proven that IVC people does not have known Indo European language spoken by Steppe pastoralists. Dr . Niraj Rai, who is the head of the ancient DNA laboratory at Lucknow’s Birbal Sahni Institute of Palaeosciences, did the DNA study.

[@krishgaming9080]

​@@mscreationworks5787hapologroup u existed in India and Europe and the prime marker of white skin

[@rocketrabble6737]

The egyptians, very likely, did not have horses until a thousand years later. Sumerians were earlier but their earliest chariots were pulled by asses or other equids. Kazakhstan appears to be the earliest place for domestication.

[@graceyacho]

😮😮😮😮 My shoes 👟 were stolen from my front porch/door when I lived in Kirkland…crazy..my neighbors told me it was a redhead individual. Sad that he did that, that was supposed to be our little apartment on the lake and money 💰 would have flowed in. Thank G-d I moved 8 states away.

[@remnant1018]

So basically, they did what every group of warriors did (R&P)?

[@thiagocastrodias2]

So If I got It right, the Yamnaia moved near the territories of the Corded Ware people, who in turn kidnapped their women. Because of that, the Yamnaia men ventured deeper into Europe. Which I guess would give us another Netflix series. Nice background music, by the way.

[@strnbrg59]

Europe in our time is undergoing a population replacement just as thoroughgoing.

[@PaddyDogg]

Wish these programs would keep the actors accurate, I doubt corded ware people looked like modern African Americans

[@user-yt3xd2jl6d]

They did not look anything like African Americans, but according to analysis they did show pigmentation between olive and light brown, the facial features were very European, but they were not what we would call today White Caucasian, and 3/4 of the same with Yamnaya, the Yamnaya also had a darker pigmentation more similar to Southern Europeans or Mediterraneans but with a greater amount of blond hair alleles. On the other hand, the Amphora Globular culture of Central Europe, if it had a very light pigmentation and had blond hair, like current Northern Europeans, but their facial features were more graceful, having facial features more similar to the Mediterraneans of Europe and the Middle East, the Yamnaya and Corded Ware had very robust faces.

[@user-yt3xd2jl6d]

The Western Hunter Gatherers were Western Eurasians, like Arabs or North Africans, this means that their facial features were very distinct, but it is true that they had different skin tones to modern Europeans (although variables depending on the region), the humans who introduced the light skin of the SLC24A5 gene, were the Anatolian Farmers, coming from Greece and Turkey, due to founder effect or perhaps selection, they became even lighter, Amphora Globular from Central Europe are the first individuals with North European pigmentation, although with more Mediterranean facial features, this pigmentation was absorbed by Corded Ware, and it spread it throughout Northern Europe, Yamnaya also contributed since they had a high density of blond alleles although their pigmentation was not so light.

[@ohlangeni]

​@@user-yt3xd2jl6d Indigenous North Africans are the people that Westerners call "Sub-Saharans". Africans of the E1b1 yDNA haplogroup (now dominating most of Africa) originate in North Africa. Modern North Africans descend from Greeks, Phoenicians, Romans, Iberians, Vandals, Arabs and native Africans (historically labelled Berber/Barbarian by Eurasians). Modern Egyptians are more Cyrene (Cyrenaica) Greek and Macedoanian, Syrians (who made up majority of Ptolemic soldiers), Arab, Circassian, Cuman and Kurdish and Kipchak Turks. Sudan is more Arab than Egypt genetically. Arab genes peak at 18% among Egyptians, but 60% among Sudanese.

[@tredeen97]

Lol you see a person with tropical phenotype and automatically think African American lol expand your knowledge

[@EncroachingShadow-og1td]

@@user-yt3xd2jl6d Also I have to add that yamnayans didn’t had that much blonde alleles. Strangely, blonde hair percentages started to rise only after yamnayans migrated. So yamnayans also weren’t blonde haired and they look nothing like modern europeans.

[@kevinkevinkevin1909]

Keep this simple, Asian conquerors were coming to Europe before Huns, Mongole, etc...

[@eastbow6053]

we are basically related to asians maybe stop blaming europeans for sl..very since they were also victims

[@danzoom]

​@@eastbow6053 everyone had sІаvеs, but western european states in 15-19 centuries cranked it up to 11

[@danzoom]

"Europe" wouldn't exist without Yamnaya culture. You are speaking their language.

[@eastbow6053]

@@danzoom everyone was evil bruh but huwhites were more evil Is that what you are saying here. God you people try so hard to hate an other race, there is a word for it Btw half of africa was already enslaved by the other half if you wanna talk about numbers, also 1 million europeans were kidnapped from europe from 15 to 18 century and sold as slavea to the barbary slave trade

[@ADUAquascaping]

​@@danzoomNo, you're talking as if you know how slaves were treated 5000 years ago 😂

[@marinashtash1822]

If KZbin shorts had quizes people would be failing faithfully: What was the first nomadic group to domesticate horses called? A. Corded Ware B. Yamnaya C. Caspian People Selecting D. Yamaha 😂😂

[@kadbenson7540]

The Dothraki grinding nations into dust as always

[@taipan8021]

How can a Human say what actually happened thousands of years ago, but can't get the last hundreds of years accurate?

[@ThePalmettoProletarian]

That’s literally every ancient society lol. “Men lead and take women to other places mate and have children and continue the cycle. Like wtf? Is this supposed to be some stunning discovery?

[@ransomgamemaster2943]

that pretty much what thought

[@ThePalmettoProletarian]

@@ransomgamemaster2943 I watched it twice and didn’t understand what the big deal was lol

[@ValidPointsMade]

Was so interested in the beginning. By the end was wondering who cares and what benefit is there to knowing any of this?

[@AustinDDishes]

Fascinating but also sticks to my brain with all the adhesiveness of a 10-day-old Band-Aid

[@nickkings7881]

I think they're seriously underestimating the mind of women in those situations to have power you have to think of the Celts where women had almost equal power the Mongols were the only people of the steps where you might say it was a patriarchy but every other people like this it's pretty even

[@squamish4244]

Research shows that male researchers have a bias towards studying male evolution. So it's male this, male that. They just took over and raped everyone. Yet how the hell does that explain why we are not basically super-patriarchies like chimps? Or the power of the evolution of female choice in mates millions of years ago to quickly change things? Or how massive agricultural societies are way more patriarchal than small tribal ones as a general rule, the societies that existed right up until the ice melted since forever? That wiring did not suddenly go away. Dammit! Maybe it was beyond the scope of his interview, but I keep seeing this pattern over and over. One researcher said a lot of these guys are "closet macho hunters of the steppes".

[@PoetofHateSpeech]

Lol no

[@disapearingboi]

Unfortunately women did not have 'almost equal' power in Celtic societies. Under Gaelic law, women could not own land or cattle. They could own their own house but not the land they lived on. A widowed woman was treated as an unmarried woman - she got none of her husbands possessions which returned to his clan. The matriarch of a clan could veto the men's decisions which did give her a lot of influence. However women were still living in a very patriarchal society.

[@PoetofHateSpeech]

@@disapearingboi Sounds like a good system to me

[@toddhellyar4167]

​@PoetofHateSpeech It is exactly why society is failing today. A slow downward spiral because women are not biologically driven to lead their people or family. The reason for a small fraction of men ruling was competition amongst men (also biologically driven) and women were not kept at bay because of their lesser strength but more because of what it is to be a woman is different and complimentary to what it is to be a man. This is why single mother households result in vastly worse outcomes for children and the reason why the developed world is at a crisis point (China also).

[@vitalismed]

This guy can delete my comments all he wants. I’ll say it again - bull sheed. How easy to exploit people who don’t know anything for themselves.

[@MrLee-cy1pw]

The corded ware came after the Yamnaya migration. They were a result of Yamnaya mingling with the neolithic cultures found in Europe at the time. Also, the 90% population disruption only happened in England.

[@Cyd98]

How did they get across the English Channel? I’m a little confused, these guys conquered all the way across Europe crossed the English Channel and slaughtered 90% of the population ? That’s absurd

[@Joyride37]

@@Cyd98are you aware that these people could make boats and sail?

[@adventussaxonum448]

​@@Cyd98 Certainly better sailors than Napoleon or Adolf. 😅

[@Cyd98]

@@Joyride37 yes I’m aware that they could make small rafts that hopefully made it to where they wanted to go. Suddenly these horse masters of the plains are master shipwrights and sailors as well? On top of being logistical geniuses to sustain a near complete slaughter of the British isles. Interesting

[@Cyd98]

@@adventussaxonum448 apparently, though I think they had stiffer competition

[@TIGERZY2K]

Yamana nomads might have formed Bactrian Empire around 3000 BC

[@highonlife341]

absorb????? What a weird fucking way to say rape and kidnap

[@sebastianchmielewski6281]

Not necessarily, maybe just marriages arranged as part of alliance or trade agreement. Women usually refuse to raise and abandon children coming from rape.

[@highonlife341]

@@sebastianchmielewski6281 I will not take your word for it, you clearly have no fucking idea what you're talking about

[@ginnoji.]

Rape from 5000 ago is perceived different than what it is now.

[@highonlife341]

@@ginnoji. Speak for yourself

[@anthonylombardo1261]

Help! Help! Im being absorbed! Majin Buu is that you?

[@apexprecitech]

For those who know Sanskrit, the word "yamnaya" will sound familiar. This is a taddhitanta of the noun "Yamuna". Yamnaya literally means "those of the Yamuna region". The European historians will never take this angle since the very thought that an Indian army ransacked Europe , eliminated its male population and took all their woman will not go well with the eurocentric world view.

[@ushirokaito8846]

Yamnaya comes from Russian and it means the pit

[@gabriellecollier8127]

I literally did not grasp what he was saying. "It was very both sexes." ???? Did anyone ever think that when one country occupies another, it's populated just by men and the women don't migrate????

[@SchmulKrieger]

Yes, pretty much that. A lot of warrior units, young and unmarried took land, killed most of the males and then took their women as their own wives. That is even described by Muslim scholars of how to practice with non Muslim women and their men, which is kill the men and take their women.

[@mateoleon524]

The fact that we know about those people is insane

[@drakethesnek6429]

Yamnaya and corded-ware people are actually the same people. They simply arrived in europe at different times.

[@boguslav9502]

Not at all, corded ware has more r1a and yamnaya r1b. So two male lineages and different cultures and even languages. Corded ware goes on to create most of eastern Europe as we know it today, travel back into Eurasia, and eventually settle in the middle east and India. Yamnaya goes through northern Africa and enters Europe again through modern day Spain. Their audna is also different

[@drakethesnek6429]

@boguslav9502 interesting 🤔 I read different somewhere, but I could be wrong.

[@subhodipbanerjee6699]

​@@boguslav9502R1b is not found in India, however R1a1 is indeed present.

[@boguslav9502]

@@subhodipbanerjee6699 thank you for the point! I made a huge mistake literally swapping the groups by accident.

[@naturbursche5540]

@@boguslav9502 Haplogroups may diverge from village to village. Look at recent groups like Erzya and Udmurt you basically got "Yamnaya" and "Sintashta" or whatever, the one have more "R1a" the other more "R1b". You know what I mean. Back then everybody had one civilization... at least after the steppe invaders made it so and became the new nobility from Europe over the Near East to China. Already that R1b and R1a must have a common ancestor speaks for itself. Western and Eastern Europe and the predominant genetics always influenced each other. Probably since the times we were apemen or aliens or something.