The Best Macaroni Salad You'll Ever Make (Deli-style) | Food Wishes

Learn how to make a Macaroni Salad recipe! Visit foodwishes.blogspot.com/2015/0... for the ingredients, more information, and many, many more video recipes. I hope you enjoy these easy Macaroni Salad recipe!

[@foodwishes]

Check out the recipe: www.allrecipes.com/Recipe/244305/Chef-Johns-Classic-Macaroni-Salad/

[@kathyinwonderlandl.a.8934]

Food Wishes ooooo Thankyou! I’m betting that this is the recipe I’ve been after from when I worked at a Chinese restaurant in my youth. It was their Macaroni Salad I adored and I believe this is the one! Yay 😀

[@ElizabethT45]

I think Chef John and I may be around the same age based on his joke "you are the Tony! Toni! Toné! of your macaroni" man that is a throwback reference!!

[@barbaraswiftcoleman5089]

Thank you.

[@jbsavard1265]

way too much pepper!

[@marjoriemills2484]

Lillian Rapos

[@HK-ni6cn]

Hi I’m a 16 year old who’s always loved when my mom made this for me. I stayed home from school today and was in charge of making food, so I decided to make this for the first time! Your video and recipe link was very easy to follow and im so excited to see how it’s going to taste! It’s in the fridge right now absorbing together!

[@PatriotGamesROCKS]

Probably not.

[@CreativeCreatorCreates]

How did it turn out? :D

[@chakagomez8129]

its a great recipe to know how to throw together and impress your friends

[@HK-ni6cn]

@@CreativeCreatorCreates really good :D

[@CreativeCreatorCreates]

@@HK-ni6cn love it!

[@karinaschulz6799]

Your life is divided in: before this salad and after this salad. You will never be the same again!!!!!

[@jimalden9355]

So easy....so amazing! I made this last month for a family gathering and it was devoured! Making it again today for a visiting friend...last time accompanied Chef John's grilled sticky ribs (highly recommended), this time next to burgers and dogs. A delicious macaroni salad...no bells or whistles, just damn good!

[@minao8942]

I had to come on here 6 years after this video was made (it is 5/8/2022) just to say that I was in desperate need for a good macaroni recipe. I have followed other recipes and they just came out dry and heavy. So I was a little Leary to try yet another recipe that I found on social media. I searched KZbin and this recipe was the first to pop up. I liked the ingredients and I liked that the KZbinr explained in detail how to make this. I followed it to a T but it was a big party and I had to make it for 60 people so I simply doubled the ingredients. I have to say this macaroni was an absolute hit. I made 2.5 lbs of this macaroni salad and it was all gone! My picky daughter loved it, and some of the women were asking me for the recipe but I didnt want to give out my secret! Haha. Love loved this macaroni recipe. Hands down it will not disappoint. I promise!

[@beautifulrose8619]

I looked at two other videos and they use milk in dressing. this one did not. Just give them the recipe. You're not going to make a restaurant or sell it.

[@DoctorMangler]

I'm with you but it's another year and change later (4/19/2024), I just needed a good macaroni salad recipe! I recently had a coleslaw recipe, and it made me crave macaroni salad. I could not believe my eyes, the liquid portion of this macaroni recipe is 95% exactly my coleslaw liquid in nearly identical proportions, I even add the onion and carrot to the liquid first for easy mixing. He uses a tad more sugar and salt than the coleslaw. Anyway I can't wait to try this, I'm making it in a few minutes for dinner, and oddly I already know what it's going to taste like.

[@gardenjoy5223]

"It's true! They've done studies. Where? The Mayo Clinic." Love that kind of humor.

[@filipeilolahia4798]

his voice is annoying

[@ClashingWithThunder]

@@randomyoutubeuser8509 agreed

[@tweet-tweettweety9704]

Dad joke. lol

[@ClashingWithThunder]

@B Ball ? What type or question is that lmao.

[@ShanmathiNaiduVshanC]

Best dad joke.

[@Ajb897]

I followed your recipe exactly...tasted the mix before adding the macaroni...Oh No, I put too much vinegar😣 with some faith... placed in the fridge overnight, and this morning I have just tasted THE BEST MACARONI SALAD EVER!!!! AMAZING😋

[@vivianpowell1732]

I have found this recipe to be perfect just the way it is. I cook the elbow pasta in my microwave, in a large round glass Pyrex bowl that fits in the microwave. I add water and salt to the pasta until there's water two inches above the pasta. It cooks perfectly in 20 minutes, though I give it a stir every 5 minutes.

[@Rizzle878]

I’ve made this for a number of bbq’s now and it’s always a hit. Thank you, Chef John!

[@rosetta13k]

"You are the Tony, Toni, Tone of your macaroni"! Love it!

[@caliselect]

There is absolutely nothing "You" yourself can cook wrong! Your so on point and full of Deliciousness!

[@reshmeeramdin5669]

Watched the whole video just because i love the way you explained everything... its like listening a song...

[@darlabible1325]

Reshmee Ramdin; Maybe I’m just different, but that “singing” thing is like torture to me. “YES YES, I’ll tell you everything I know! JUST MAKE IT STTTTTOOOP! 😂🤣 He’s a nice fella’ tho’.🙂

[@tablescissors67]

It’s refreshing to listen to someone whose genuinely funny, but I’m really here bc these are solid recipes, with just the right amount of specific information and shots on how to make the food (vs showing off the cook). THANK YOU.

[@Stardusted1]

I made this today for the first time. I’ve been making macaroni salad for a long time. (I’m 66) it is FANTASTIC!! I followed your recipe to the Tee and my husband said he thought it was the best he’s ever eaten! Thank you for sharing! We will make this all the time now!

[@ManchesterUtdFan]

My lazy ass made this and it was delicious. I gotta convince myself to do it again tho.

[@Kingjamesbible161]

@man lol 😂

[@youarerightboss]

@Lisa Currier: maybe, just lucky.

[@verawallace9055]

You are like me, I love easy recipes, doesn't like the complicated ones, last time I try making the Jamaican Gizzarda, it was ok but not perfect, have to try it again

[@ualuuanie]

Did you cook the carrots or is it raw?

[@verawallace9055]

Do not cook the carrots, only the macaroni needs cooking, let it cool before adding the other ingredients

[@ao_qd]

That Mayo Clinic joke was GOLDEN! [APPLAUSE]!

[@beccal7440]

Oyez oyez oyez…. This recipe is outstanding!!! Totally different from other ordinary macaroni salad. The vinegar, jalapeño, and onion give it a really delightful kick!! Will keep this in my repertoire…. Thank you for sharing!

[@MetroLaniac]

Brilliant, thanks Chef John! I thought I made great macaroni salad already but I can tell even before I try that you have made my salad way better. Just brilliant. 👌

[@michelleguzmanphoto]

These videos are so entertaining....even if you are not planning on cooking anything. I find myself laughing at the video script/comments. So well done.

[@janefromtennessee]

Michelle G I love to hear him too. He's very good

[@ohbuddyiliketowatch]

Michelle G he is a gem.

[@carmelquinn6567]

Michelle G must try looks good

[@MNAZ480]

Just made this. Holy moly this is the best macaroni salad I've ever had in my life. Thank you Chef John!

[@whitneyS2011]

I did this and my salad tastes AMAZING!! The best I've ever made! Thank you so much!

[@kathihjelmstad5026]

Singing voice drives me crazy.

[@passion777able]

Anything will pass as delicious when you have nothing good to compare it with.

[@marrianner.1682]

I found this couple of years ago and absolutely LOVE it! Easy to make.....everybody loves it. Thanks Food Wishes.

[@traderjosie100]

I just love ❤️ Chef John- I go here first if I need a recipe and this recipe tops them all! Chef you explain things so well! Wow what a great cooking teacher

[@judidunham5037]

I use sweet pickle juice in place of the granulated sugar. Plus I chop sweet pickles into my salad. Other than that, just the same. 👍🏼

[@lynellethompson5521]

Dill pickle juice is better!! And just skip the sugar. But it is all what you grow up eating!!

[@1950steele]

Judi Dunham - I use relish and the juice.

[@danielclooney6248]

I like your suggestion, I'm diabetic and very anti-sugar in something like this.

[@pattyturpin9180]

Judi Dunham I like to use sweet pickle RELISH. Less chopping to do. And some tiny cubed cheddar cheese is good in it too! Thanks

[@anamneses28]

Yep! 👍🏼

[@LEdHeadW]

I've made this recipe many times, it's so good! It's a great base for experimenting too. Sometimes I add pickle juice and hard boiled egg, or salami or bacon or ham, or diced up cherry tomatoes and some balsamic with feta or fresh mozzarella and basil... Usually I just make it as shown, and it's always a hit at picnics or when I help my girlfriend meal prep. I love this recipe!

[@maryleung1425]

Exactly .... pasta salad is usually pretty forgiving .... u can add whatever to it like ....cooked white chicken breast ...cubes of ham...etc ....just dont overcook the pasta ....

[@mads855]

I was thinking of adding a bag of broccoli slaw to it too! Sounds good.

[@dsdsmitty2]

Yay finally a way to see Food Wishes without all the slow ads.

[@vecernicek2]

As a former postdoctoral researcher at Mayo Clinic, I approve this salad.

[@theresatyler4043]

lolol......!

[@pandabear153]

Oh for funny 😂 😂😂

[@dairuggerxvvoltesfifteen8756]

vecernicek2 Is this some kind of Mayonnaise joke?

[@tarob6673]

Ty I was looking for good reviews for whether I should make this

[@miha3698]

@@dairuggerxvvoltesfifteen8756 yes, mayoclinic is conducting medical research

[@turiddudegaetano8725]

Great. With summer almost here....this salad is the one...thanks chef John!

[@lisakrenn3306]

This is by far the best macaroni salad! Made some for dinner tonight. This is a keeper!

[@dulsonguillermo]

I probably already commented on this video, but I must again, this a family favorite, and today I'm making it again, it's just the perfect addition for a whole meal. Thank you so so much for sharing it. We love you chef John!! 💕 Happy Holidays!

[@lynnewolfe7965]

It's not every tv chef that can make me laugh out loud, but YOU can! (Mayo Clinic, hahahaha!) Love your blogs, and rave about you to everyone I know!

[@rosemarymurphy5767]

I made this and it was all gone nothing left over love it been making it every since just can’t get enough of it. Thank you

[@twveach]

Well John…. I’ve been following you for 14 years… first dish was the chicken Marsala…. Tomorrow is Mother’s Day!!! I’ve got the macaroni salad in the fridge doing it’s thing…I tested out one cheese blintz,,,(delish) and the quiche Lorraine starts in the morning!!! THANKYOU FOR GIVING MY FAMILY SUCH GREAT FOOD FOR SO SO LONG!!! NEVER STOP!!!! You’re doing it right!!!(one of the few)

[@PenguinCam]

As advertised, this was the best macaroni salad I've ever made. I love your channel and will try most of the recipes, I've already done the Philly cheesesteak sliders and they were terrific!

[@vegasrunaway]

LOVE your videos! Just enough humor to keep them interesting! Keep it up!

[@rudyvel]

I'm making this today as I do every holiday since I saw this video. I get soooo many compliments and some say the best they've ever had in their life!

[@alisiabroussard9776]

Literally my moms favorite pasta salad ever! She asks me to make this every thanksgiving and Christmas!

[@Dzbiq]

It's the third time I made this salad from this recipe and every time I'm really surprised how comforting and delicious it is, thank you Chef John!

[@jcaff6963]

Thanks, Chef, I just made this. Couldn't wait for overnight, so I waited 4 hours. Excellent. It will be even better when I add the water and mayo at the end. Tastier than the mac salad at my local store and a great deal cheaper too. Thanks, again, and Happy 4th to you and your family.

[@pjgonzalez923]

Made this for today’s potluck at work and wow! It got soooo many compliments 🥰 I’m very happy with it! I used less sugar and used rice vinegar instead of white vinegar. So good!

[@Marwaislief]

My all time favorite pastasalad! Made it many times and soon will make it again, family also really loves it.

[@1991alla]

I made this on the new years eve and it was sooo good.. every body loved it at the party and I would defenitly make it again for myself I'm craving it already. I used 2 Tbs of Dijon mustard but would put only 1 tbs to my taste next time . This is just a personnal preferance. Thank you Chef

[@nancyjohnson5810]

Just made this recipe 3 days ago and it's all gone. There is just my husband and I and we ate it all in 3 days! It is the first time I'd ever made macaroni salad and this is by far the best I'd ever tasted. I will be making it over and over that's for sure. For me what made it so great was the little green onions that was so tasty. Now that vinegar made it extra tangy and so next time I might try a little more sugar or my husband suggested doing the apple cider vinegar with the mother! So I may try that. Thank you so very much for sharing this recipe.

[@RayBros]

Making this for like the 5th+ time for work occasions, it's always a favorite. Thanks John!

[@pickeymcpickerson9141]

I made this for the first time about a month ago. Yum. My mom used to make what I thought was the best years ago, but omg, this one takes the cake! Going to make it again this weekend, just got back on to double check the process. Thanks Chef John!

[@Pinkette25]

i love how you explain so thoroughly!

[@ndeshichristine12jonas12]

Pinkette25 I love when u talk like someone drinking water.lol.

[@amyalvarez9304]

Haha🤣 he must be a gem!😏

[@heathernetto8938]

I tried your yummy salad, it was excellent, my family & friends just loved it....thank you so much for the recipe.

[@rachelvillarreal6243]

Thank you Chef John. I just want to say I have never been a macaroni salad person. Until I saw your recipe. The thought of it being spicy with the peppers used...my mouth was watering. I have made the salad 3 times so far and I as well as family and friends have said it's the best they have had. Me too of course! Wowie so delicious. Really love all your recipes. Made your chicken enchiladas a few times too. Family favorite too. Actually everything I try from you is Fabulous! Thank you🙂 We're is a cook book featuring You?

[@jumo004]

Every recipe I have ever borrowed from Chef John has turned out wonderful and this one is no exception. Some people now think that I can actually cook. The potato salad recipe is amazingly good also.

[@onetimelovely]

I saw dis video two days ago and I made it today. I allowed it to stay for 5 hours O M G! So gud my family loves it. Thanks for sharing

[@munomuftaax3730]

I wanna make some tomorrow 😁

[@ezrabrooks12]

Tricia/// I WANT'S ME SUM OF DIS TO!!!!! OH LORDY,IT IS GUD!!!!!

[@sayitneliz9540]

The ingredients please

[@tylanway5450]

GUD

[@double8tch215]

Oh Lort, Ize believe dis iz da bestest mack-roni sel-ed ize eva hat.

[@rosewild6020]

since I found your recepies i cant stop listening to you.I love your voice especially when it comes to enjoy.

[@rosewild6020]

your recepies are great but i hate that you keep me up all night. . many thanks

[@rosewild6020]

your amazing you explain it all so easy peasy

[@judyberends4586]

It doesn't sound good to me but I'd try it. No carrots ...

[@joseph-ow1hf]

I love this guys voice. Very friendly and comforting. Good solid recipe too.

[@robertmckeon297]

This recipe is a game changer. Comes out so good!!

[@loveyourneighbor9354]

I agree with you, cook completely for salads.

[@xEternalSlumberx]

I made this last night to let it sit overnight. I tried it today and it is without a doubt the best macaroni salad I've had. I did add a couple more tbsp of sugar though, 1/4 cup was perfect for my taste. The sauce was just enough to coat everything, unlike the stuff you get in the store that is like soup. I will definitely make this again.

[@chrism4841]

+xEternalSlumberx God I hate that the sauce ends up coating your mouth with the oiliness from the mayonaise.

[@nicciGT]

+AngeloLacrime could you taste the vinegar? I have never used vinegar in mine so I am worried it might be too strong.

[@xEternalSlumberx]

+nicolle n. I don't think it's an overwhelming vinegar flavor. It just tastes like you put pickled vegetables in it. You could possibly do half vinegar, half lemon juice.

[@laus7504]

+AngeloLacrime Thanks for sharing your experience with this recipe! I am guilty of enjoying that sweetness that is mixed into the macaroni salad I have to buy in the grocery store. I really appreciate that some kind person, such as yourself, let me know how it worked. Now I at least I know that can use 1/4 cup of sugar and still end up with delicious macaroni salad! Thanks!!

[@xEternalSlumberx]

+Laura S (laursaurus) No problem (: you just have to find what works for you. Taste as you go. If 1/4 cup still isn't to your liking, add a tbsp at a time until you're satisfied. Just be careful not to go too far because as it sits, the flavors come out more.

[@bobdavis1168]

Outstanding presentation !!! I love your sense of humor !!!

[@missava214]

This is my favorite macaroni salad recipe! Thank you so much for sharing. The sweetness is perfect!

[@hollywoodharriet13]

Dear Chef John. I made this macaroni salad the other day. Didn't have green onion or a poblano, but had all the rest. Was a little short on mayo too because it was the end of the jar, but it was enough. I got worried when I tasted the dressing as I was afraid it would be too salty even though I only used 1 tsp of salt, but it came out perfect and we like the kick it has from the jalapeno and the cayenne. This is sure to be a summer time staple around here. This is the first of your recipes I have made but watch many of your videos. Thanks.

[@Familiagz_]

I never made this or ate this before in my life and it’s looks delicious 😋 I’m going to make it and try it👍🏽

[@tressalee8770]

I've been coming back to this recipe for years because it's such a hit w my friends & family, thank u so much for sharing it!❤️❤️

[@dartagnantaft5918]

I just watched a lot of videos on making macaroni salad and I have to say your the only one who said don't rence the macaroni and what a differences that made. I like to say I followed your directions exactly, but I can't follow directions (ask any body) but the salad came out great. Thank you so much for a much needed tip. I really appreciate all the time and effort you put into your videos. Thanks again.

[@ghostlysorrow8682]

Love the voice, and because of that I'm gonna make this recipe.

[@moniquenewman4889]

OMG. Chef John I can't thank you enough for this video. I was wondering why my mac salad always turned out dry? However the diluting with vinegar is what made it creamy!

[@jasonbodden8816]

This was a real hit in my house. My mother and I really loved it. Thanks!

[@dagnymaximus9778]

This really is the best macaroni salad! My brother told me about it a year ago and I didn't try it. He mentioned it again a month or so ago and I finally decided to make it. Watching the video, I gotta say, I wasn't thinking it was going to be as good as he said- I was wrong--this really IS the best macaroni salad ever! I shared with my neighbor and they liked it so much they made it for 4th of July. Excellent recipe!!!

[@MandyWasHere]

Best freaking mac salad EVER!!!!!!! Every tip you gave just perfected the end product. My entire family loved it they want me to make it again. 10/10

[@Angel.M.Trinidad]

Love the language. Great poetic touch. Good technique.🇹🇹🇹🇹

[@tanana2070]

I made this salad yesterday for today, as directed. It was delicious!! And, yes it was very soupy last night, today, magically just right. I think the chopped jalapenos and the cayenne really made it. Lots of crunch too! Will definitely make it again and even take it to a potluck. It makes lots!

[@brettsimpson408]

Awesome video Chef John. I'll have to give this a try this summer!!!

[@cougarhunter33]

cayenne pepper - check freshly ground black pepper - check shaka shaka and/or tappa tappa - check rimshot pun - check your the boss joke - check double entendre - check Yep, the Food Wishes drinking game got me drunk again.

[@RuToob]

cougarhunter33 Damn. I missed the double entendre. I hate it when I do that.

[@courtneymcfarland8333]

Was it the tossing the salad part? Touching the macaroni?

[@acrophobe]

ahem, i think you mean freeessshhhly ground black pepper

[@parker3208]

Fabien Brunner As a matter of fact, it did pair very well with what we were smoking! 😁

[@MrAwawe]

You're

[@evepaludan7713]

The dressing recipe is also really good for homemade coleslaw. Thanks for the recipe!

[@shareqaazam9171]

Amazing recipe. I made this for our picnic and it was a great hit. For garnish I used a couple of table spoons of finely chopped dill.

[@hmlxur54]

I’m going to give it a try, it really looks delicious, thanks!

[@carlosdyer5868]

" the Mayo Clinic" hahahahehheh ! You got a laugh out of me. Even though it was corny it's all about timing. Thanks for making this fun to watch. I'm going to make this NOWwww !

[@kiatequila424]

My family loved it! Had to leave the some of hot stuff out, came out perfect the next day! Bring this to your family party’s you won’t be taking leftover home!

[@SuperSPatrick]

I just made this for the first time and it turned out amazing!

[@Forevertrue]

I agree on the sugar and the macaroni never under cook it! But I use American Mustard. Poblano is my favorite for most things. Thanks John another good one!

[@trixiegarcia9049]

Looks sooo yummy. I cant wait to make it. I learned a lot from your tips. Thank you. P.S. Thanks also for the funny dad jokes

[@catherineharris27]

Creamy, tangy and perfectly cooked mac pasta salad imp!!! Delicious 😋🤤!

[@Garapetsa]

I just made this. Now...I've made a good mac salad in my lifetime many time. Chef John, you really kicked it up a notch with the Cayenne. Thanks for the tips too. I normally throw in peas, but this time I stuck to your recipe. The only thing I changed was the onion. I soaked 1/2 cup chopped fine onion in white vinegar.. drained then threw in. This one is a 10 folks. Kudos to the chef!

[@jeanmcguire4262]

This was the best I have ever made. I think not rinsing and allowing it to cool was the secret. I also noticed more vinegar than I usually use but it's great tasting. Thank you for the great recipe.

[@ginascott6068]

Loved this video . You sound so cheerful , thank you Gina scott . England

[@taracontreras4652]

This is the BEST mac salad ever. I could eat this all the time. Thank you!!!

[@c.e.tomlin5376]

I just made this! It still needs to chill overnight, but I’ve tasted a bit after a couple hours and it’s already so good. Every Food Wishes recipe I try is a hit!

[@angel87921]

Your food and voice are my therapy to my end of the day office days. Oh how I love thee ❤

[@rubyandrews1337]

I made this for dinner... And OMG!!!! My family loved it!!! Thank you my fav chef ❤️

[@lovely_time1771]

Best I’ve ever had!! Thank you John

[@liatstillman]

Toni, Toni, Toni, has done it again. Can't wait to try this. Thank you!

[@ProfWattsU]

your technique fits with my Amish grandma's methodology -- so I'm totally on board here. PS she got kicked out for being too wild, so basically my role model idol and is right about everything.

[@bonnielist6411]

My mom saves a bit of the dressing (without the veggies) and adds it right before serving. Very creamy that way.

[@vivianpowell1732]

I double the liquid part of the dressing recipe (not the vegetables), then use half of that in the salad per the instructions, and save the other half if the salad needs a tablespoon or so of freshening the next morning, or if someone wants a little more dressing to add during the meal.

[@sadecadogan167]

@@vivianpowell1732 hunt bý

[@dairuggerxvvoltesfifteen8756]

Bonnie List Your mom and I are gonna get along just fine

[@dairuggerxvvoltesfifteen8756]

Scotty Scotty 😠 watchew say about her momma?!”

[@75julianne]

Great idea, thanks!

[@keepingit100integrity4]

Love this guy and his recipes

[@demip845]

This recipe is insanely good! And so simple. Thank you thank you thank you :)

[@stephanieortega1669]

You're the Tony Tony Tony of your macaroni ..love it

[@djohnson8578]

Stephanie Ortega girl Not Tony Toni Tone ! I wasn’t ready 😂😂😂

[@JenCarpeDiem]

Still my favourite macaroni salad, years after first finding and trying it. Thank you, Chef John!

[@rowenaestelle4018]

I made this last night and brought to our church for brunch.all church mate love it. Thank you for your sharing your recipe

[@carp68]

That is the best looking macaroni salad I have ever seen. ❤

[@ThatChocoChipCookie]

you are the tony tony tony of your macaroni - Chef John

[@11FBA11]

***** actually its tony, toni, tone....

[@MrAhmedUA]

got a management exam in hours going to sleep but you posted a new video must watch then :D

[@priscillajoseph765]

Although this recipe was made 3 yrs ago. I love it and your very useful tips. Thank Vhff John 👌

[@Atimoskisk]

This is the best macaroni salad I have ever made!! Thank you!!

[@trusarmor4957]

... the Mayo Clinic ..... you sir, are a Great Man!