The Controversial Rise of Polygamy in Indonesia

[@blamelessshameless1519]

The original views/ideas of polygamy is to help single mothers with kids, poor women who have no means for earning and in situations it would help the WOMEN, not for the sake of men alone. It was fair to say, Muslim men misinterpreted this fact and make it self serving purpose for their own rights to choose 'young unmarried/Virgin women'. It is far stir from original ideas of men helping and honouring women, it mostly lust nowadays.

[@Zerin666]

true these men now are pathetic.They cant marry just because they want to

[@nnn-v6w]

Azzylum SeekHer That kind of makes sense. Why can’t women in Islam doing polygamy??? Is it because they won’t know the father

[@blamelessshameless1519]

@@Zerin666 I agree with you there, but it takes two to tango...So many women pressured into marriage, by society and family feeling like they have to settle in hopes to get the fruitful divine gift from God and not be shun by other.

[@blamelessshameless1519]

@@nnn-v6wI am not well versed of what quran stated about women and polyandry, however, in biological stands point I can see that women would have a difficulty in determining who is the dad, as you mention, and yes relating it to religion, as long as the person is known as your biological dad, you can't marry him, but you still can marry your step father (if the ladies remarried/and the daughter is not raised by the stepdad; however not in case of polyandry so not sure*), in case he divorced your mother one day so theres different debate to talk about the "awrah/modesty" within the child with his other father. But technology can prevent this by paternity test, tho, to be honest how many people have money and time to do the testing, especially coming from not as advanced country right? Other biological factor that I can see is women can only reproduce/pregnant every 7-9 months, taking into account of pregnancy and only one sperm from "any of the partner" that getting conceived. In reproduction it is disadvantages for the other men to wait for the women baby to be born, and well to wait their time to be able to successfully fertilize with the woman. That's why, polyandry is not advisable. Social stand coming with how the men pay for the child support, which husband gonna pay for it, of let say she have two husband, and who gonna take the last name, etc in which can be very detrimental in the kids future. I am only saying in the context of reproduction and also in this situation marriage in Islam. Also if this dude on the story above saying women run by jealousy, it be the same with him as well if the story is flipped. LOL sorry for the long explanation.he person is known as your biological

[@blamelessshameless1519]

Also, the woman marriage according to islam, only the first husband is consider the real father, so it would mostly be disadvantages for the kids to be label illegitimate child, this is in accordance to shariah law. It would affect the kids throughout their life if they live in muslim countries from schooling to marriage especially "daughter" they need a dad/dad's families* in accordance to shariah as guidance during her marriage in most case.

[@naungthaw]

"If they allow me to have two husbands, I am in" 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 That sarcastic level is out of the world. You do you girl.

[@knowlegeisgr8]

It's not their fault then. Bcoz they r allowed to marry many why won't they?! Problem is with the system...not men.

[@salihabanu7953]

@@knowlegeisgr8 If the problem is with the system... then who will be her child's father amongst them.?

[@wisenubianpolygynyseekerwh5456]

isn't it funny how 99% of the people who bad mouth the truth don't have not one shred of proof.Very informative.

[@Jblah]

You can have more husbands i dont care. Make the other fools work while im the one making the babies and chill allday ROFL You dont want them beta kids LMAO

[@Jblah]

@daLi demo lmfao u treat wives like they are cattle. This is how your species will never evolve. LMAO

[@laurenkahre4785]

It’s disturbing that these women really believe they are more “emotional,” than men. If these men could control their emotions and urges they wouldn’t need polygamy. 🙄

[@ethan________]

Lauren Kahre Exactly. They try to justify that ‘would you rather have a polygamous relationship or have your man cheating on you’... assuming that every man will inevitably cheat on his wife. Of course men lust after other women but surprise surprise some men can actually control their urges and desires.

[@NinoGucciani]

Preach#FACTS

[@maazkhan3202]

Lol he laid out some pretty convincing logic. Polygamy forever.

[@maazkhan3202]

@Saleucami I understand but what guy doesn't wanna f*** multiple women lol?

[@maazkhan3202]

@@micheller8556 Thats only one website, check all the other ones

[@Gamb11t]

The brain washing is strong with this one.

[@rachelp9954]

tell me about it... i'm indonesian and my neighbours, ex-teacher, friend's parent and so many that i know are like this...

[@bortzborger1391]

@@rachelp9954 bruh me too,, and I usually dont accept things like this, i would probably going to hell lol

[@Noname-ni8qm]

@@rachelp9954 well ita national brainwashing obvious ,cus laws are ok with it so people get brainwashed with everyday

[@barbatvs8959]

The feminazi or the Muslims?

[@dimasp8340]

Please call CIA, this guy should be banned from this earth.

[@dolewhip3369]

Sounds like she was forced by her father.She said she she only had a high school education and her father wanted her to marry him. That’s sad I really don’t think she’s happy. It’s like she’s not really living her life but just along for the ride.

[@mermer1581]

Dole Whip if she was forced, they’re already going against Islam. You cannot practise forced marriage. Sometimes our fellow muslims confuse culture customs with religion.

[@NisCho754]

MerMer exactly well said!

[@spark300c]

@@mermer1581 well only get ploygamy in large number if its forced.

[@antonymichealraj8857]

@@mermer1581 what about the forced conversions to Islam in Pakistan and sub sequent marriage ?

[@OoiPaul]

Since she is new wife I guess there is plenty of rides. 😁😁

[@MysticMagickery]

p.s. the younger wife did not choose for herself, in her own words "Because i only had a highschool degree and a dad TOLD ME TO" how is that deciding herself? SO unfortunate most of these women really believe that they have to follow family permission to be granted heaven, it just doesnt work that way!! lemme over there please..WAKE THESE WOMEN UP TO THEIR POWER

[@sakurakou2009]

Most women in polygamous relationship do it for financial reasons , the man usually have lot of money and the girl are poor , so it win win situations for them , the girl family just wanted her to marry to rice guy so they can feel they done their part , while the girl may have just done what her family told her but if she did not marry him with her high school degree what kind life or work can she do , she will end up marrying someone in end and living in provity , so her family thought about all that before marrying her up to the richest guy to knock their door .

[@FlowtnWitWalden]

Yeah right, go and try, take someone along to document the point where they hack the head off your body.

[@FahadFSA]

Are you still living a sad life?

[@Jaywalker45]

She consented the marriage she was not forced the thing you are suffering from is Kepler's syndrome

[@mashaaloturkar6788]

1:33 The actual quote said by Muhammad is "The best amongst you are those who are best to their wives, for verily they are your partners and committed helpers". Not "the best men are the ones with the most wives".

[@sakurakou2009]

Polygamy did not start with islam , polygamy been in human history as long as human have existed , monogamy in other hand were the rare case .. only recently monogamy became romanticized but in anceint times even preislam polygamy existed look at anceint china , europe , africa , all had polygamy

[@zicob2536]

How wives did Muhammad have?

[@ttytexetr282]

@@zicob2536 the Prophet Saw only had one wife hadhrat Khadijah as. However throughout wars many women were left widowed with no support so that's why they were married many times. The ratio between man and women was very high. In Islam if a man has more than one wife he has to treat them equally otherwise he will be punished in the afterlife hence it's a rare practice these days.

[@goodsleepinghobbits5265]

@@sakurakou2009 Who cares if polygamy started long ago? It does not make it right. Long ago it was common to be uneducated, it was common to own slaves. Only idiots will justify idiotic and unjust practices/traditions.

[@mrm3611]

True, I read it too

[@Inochan91]

If jealousy is in a woman's nature and patience is rewarded, then why isn't it same for men? If they are attracted to more than one woman, which women are attracted to more than one man also, why don't they be loyal and be rewarded for that? surely, the man would become incredibly jealous too if his wife went off and married another man. Hypocrites.

[@barbatvs8959]

@@dewadattaa268 I prove Islam wrong in my channel, but I also prove atheists wrong including the most "powerful" atheist preachers: Richard Duhkins and Christless Bitchens. :-) I prove my religion right in my series exposing the satanic. You committed a hasty generalization fallacy.

[@user-fz8ot3qt8s]

lol exactly. this guy twist religion the way he want to satisfy his desire. i feel bad for his wives😔

[@plissdanzmoore9433]

Funny that she married a man whos name is literally riski

[@nan6962]

Lol😂😂😂😂 very risky indeed

[@TheHarmonice]

Riski means fortune in their language. So what your risky means is so not important to them. Leave them alone.

[@HN-kr1nf]

@@TheHarmonice it's a joke calm tf down.

[@TheHarmonice]

@@HN-kr1nf jokes doesnt need to offend anyone especially when it could lead to being racist. Respect other people and people will give that back to you, or dont even make joke when youre sucks at it. I'm done.

[@아미방탄소년단-w7v]

HAHAHAHAHAHAH I just realised now🤣 that's defo risky

[@Thomas-Bradley]

Watching this is cancerous. I cannot believe these people actually believe what they said.... 🤦🏻‍♂️

[@echoindigo4436]

Omg she said she can enter heaven through jealousy. Is she serious? Love is not jealous. That's truth.

[@thatchindogirl]

Echo Indigo trueeee 😭😫

[@XOceaNX]

She is trying to satisfy her conscience because deep inside she is not happy. Most Muslims dont do polygamy because it breeds jealousy and unfairness. It is only allowed for the sole purpose of helping women in need and not to marry out of sexual desire.

[@barbatvs8959]

Jealousy isn't wrong. Envy is wrong. Jealousy means wanting your possessions to be respected meaning no one steals them. If you are not jealous, you will not lock your door at night, and let thieves take your virginity if it didn't already perish.

[@barbatvs8959]

@@XOceaNX Feminazis are not happy as their divorce rate proves.

[@ailsa7471]

Jealousy is literally one of the biggest reason why you can go to hell in Islam

[@madinaazzahra3973]

As Indonesian, if I was on that gathering I can't even stand a minute without my blood being boiled inside me. I can't stand their logic smh

[@MegaBaddog]

are you disgusted about prophet Muhammad and his multiple wives?

[@BilalAhmed-yk3xs]

All the girls are speaking from emotions just like yourself

[@madinaazzahra3973]

@@MegaBaddog Prophet Muhammad SAW have his own logical reasons. He never had another wives while Khadijah RA still alive and he's not immediately re-married after Khadijah RA passed away. He's doing polygamy and marrying widows because their husbands are died in war and they need someone to protect them from any harms(I understand how these widows will be exposed to many kinds of harms, especially in old times when the logic of the people is not as progressive as modern times and the stigma about widows). For Aisyah RA case, I know she's still underage when Rasulullah SAW married her but he waited until Aisyah RA reach her adulthood to really start a family with her and never even touch her before that. Meanwhile in this video, everyone is BRAGGING about having multiples wives. These men treated their wives like a trophies they won on a competitions and bragging about how many wives they got so far. The more wives they got, the louder claps from another participant there. I mean, they just marrying young beautiful women not old widows where their husbands died in some accident. If they were following the Prophet ways, married those who were need their help like the old war widows that the Prophet married

[@madinaazzahra3973]

@@BilalAhmed-yk3xs are we? I'm not speaking with my emotions. I'm speaking with my logic. Even if I speak with my emotions, is that even change anything? Dude, did these men doing their polygamy and bragging about it like it's some achievement show-off are using their logic?

[@BilalAhmed-yk3xs]

@@madinaazzahra3973 I understand your angle sister, and the guy in the video is not denying his desire.. his being a man about it.. and he spoke to his partner about it and they both came to decision.. they are all very happy.

[@ursulagayatri5130]

Notice how he talks. It’s very manipulative. His choice of words made his ‘talk’ sound less of an argument and more of something based of facts. It’s a classic form of subtle brain washing. It’s insane

[@shabinashabbir3379]

Agreed

[@MegaBaddog]

about what? look at the state of modern western women and the decline of morality@@shabinashabbir3379

[@MegaBaddog]

I feel you , you are really ugly and living a harsh life without a man.

[@yoruwardevil]

Ben Shapiro in a nutshell

[@rayejohnson992]

@@MegaBaddog Why do men like you feel like it's an insult to a woman when she doesn't have a man? Who cares, men don't breathe life into women. Most women who have men are miserable or end up dead by the same "man" you think they need to survive. It's not that serious, most people do better alone.

[@magurosky-izumi9772]

Actually I'm indonesian, and.......... I resist this.

[@MysticMagickery]

its a womans fate? to feel jelousy? what about all the thousands of "MEN" who've commited crimes over the emotional response to their own relationships. This is why women are losing more of their power in holding their own mind, keeping TRUE to their own values because they have some F'ED up guy come in and "CONVINCE" her its ok for his SELFISH gain. men I REPEAT are not the only ones on mother earth to feel strong sexual desires and passions. IM a hella fine woman and deal with it daily, wanna know what i do, Aside from meditation and inner self work i work out as well, instead of lowering myself in such a vibration of acceptance to who can satisfy me. ill be a queen on my own no husband needed. but by the way if were labelled queens then why is it these beautiful queens cant take more than one man and TEACH him a few things.

[@stormlah]

YAWN

[@rightrightright4763]

Girl, easy. At least we can still go to Thailand and certain regions in China to convince our future husbands letting us getting sevral more other husbands.

[@yads2246]

If a woman got two husbands then when she gives birth to her child you don't know who the father is

[@amatulfulani6390]

@Hdye Hdhde uh, no. Most women eventually leave the relationship. Do you even live in the West?

[@amatulfulani6390]

@Hdye Hdhde well most men aren’t rich. We’re talking about the average men. Women are out earning men too.

[@weylandyutani9622]

I wonder how Riski would feel if someone treated his daughters like he treats his wives ?

[@baeziadraws]

Damm this interviewer is really good at asking the right questions; especially the last one when he talked about instaling "Islamic" programmes in his wives

[@x.t.5221]

He spoke as if his wives are robots that need to be installed programs

[@sadiaafsana1094]

How religious is this man, he was playing a musical instruments. He interprets everything with his mind, he is not a scholar even .

[@sarabakeer2066]

I'm so frustrated with him!

[@MCZack-hm3ge]

He literally used religion to justify his sins

[@tatakalsum864]

😂😂😂😂😂 new prophet..

[@thatchindogirl]

Sarcasm at its best

[@ailsa7471]

Lmao I showed this to my grandpa who is the neighborhood scholar and he cat even finish the video and he said I would rather have a heart attack again than hearing this man speak

[@designergrace_withgrace]

Human will forever twist and turn religious rules/quotes to suit their goal

[@ishigoku]

what you talking about ???? it is within the man s brain and dna to have more than one woman the oposite isnt true for woman if not then why is the west full of married people having affairs there 6 women to 1 man in the world and there is nothing wrong with polygamy only difference one takes responsability for it the other one from the west does it outside of mariage and live a secret life and keeps jumping from one misstress to another women say what a twisted kind but sure go along if the man fits and even if he is married n im talking about the west so keep your fake morals to your self n leave muslims live theire lives the way they see fit go fix your broken society full of lies you preffer the mysogyne western society that doesnt value the woman so much so that the man doesnt have the guts to take full responsability and deal with her as a wife no !!! of course mistress much better so u can trash her like a sorry ass trash bag once u done with your business what we muslims see with polygamy isnt what you guys see with playing around two complete different concept and by the way there are rules in islam to establish polygamy its not for anyone if you cant establish certain standard then one is enough the number 4 in islam did not come fron 1 but came as a limit from much mire than 4 back then and before islam was established many king in europe had many women and many men had multiple wives islam came n ruled as follow it is permissible for you to have 2 or 3 or 4 wives but if are scared or beeing unfair not equal to them then one is sucficient quran surat annissa ( women) verse 3 so please before talking what you know not go study a little then cone up with your theory that is stil totaly wrong and far from understanding what the muslims mean when talking polygamy

[@rominaconstenla5624]

@@ishigoku you don't know the women I know mate.

[@Antidote54]

If that's the case, then imagine those without religion. No boundaries at all.

[@ooo-kl2hy]

@@Antidote54 what do you mean by "no boundaries"?

[@soscarlet]

men*

[@MrTurtleThief]

He's literally using the term "program" to talk about his influence on his wives... yikes

[@Lex86515]

Polygamy rule 1- convince her she will go to heaven!

[@sakurakou2009]

Non women im polygamy relationship think they go to heaven , they do it cuz they poor and man is rich , so they accept the situation for financial reasons , even see rich woman in polygamous relationship , and if guy got poor ome day I think they will leave him , so they using him just as much he using him .

[@Lex86515]

@@sakurakou2009 True also.. it's a combination of factors

[@aminuaidara8601]

The joke is on u

[@kaqualyneee6575]

Long story short: Let's make cheating legitimate lmao

[@thatchindogirl]

Josephine Kristiansen 😂😫

[@MahijaSharmaDantu]

👏👏👏👌

[@diahraspadewi9872]

I WHEEZED

[@aletakibler4158]

7:00 she just realizes that he's so delusional no matter what she says to him it won't matter lmao

[@neokysuiam9538]

Polygamy still doesn’t guarantee that the husband won’t have other affairs..he definitely can’t marry all the women he might desire.

[@MegaBaddog]

does monogamy guarantee happiness?

[@shubhammeena5177]

@@MegaBaddog does polygamy?

[@MegaBaddog]

doesn't Hinduism allow polygamy, since your gods had multiple wives?@@shubhammeena5177

[@pkbaby1418]

@@MegaBaddog well it's also allows polyandry. But Hindu men can't have more than one wife except in Goa. It is illegal..

[@crazymultistan3091]

@@MegaBaddog no it doesn't.

[@red70506]

It's super easy for that ridiculous, selfish man to talk about jealousy since he doesn't have to deal with it. This is a cancer.

[@nweiioonn6007]

This disgust me so much, god only make adam and eve not adam, eve, olivia, and alice

[@thatchindogirl]

😭😫

[@thatchindogirl]

Yeah and adam and steve can't fall in love to each other too

[@sat9394]

@@ajengfebrian463 ofc, the one who create steve is notch

[@tarulieliza3255]

This cracked me up

[@alifahhika3168]

Lmao I miss this joke, I used to arguing like this with my acquaintance that want to do polygamy 🤣🤣🤣

[@Iam-me]

Disgust me 🤮. Interview the kids too. What will they say?

[@safirasnh]

I loved it when he stated the unfairness in between feminists and this so called polygamy acts and the interviewer just didn't give a shit 😂😂😂 i can feel the embarrassment of the man straight through this screen

[@Angela-tg3ol]

He didn’t get what he wanted 😂😂

[@adamatraore9219]

That dude got some brain washing skill that the CIA can use!!

[@bingbingbarracuda1887]

everything that came out of his mouth...... garbage. the part about power imbalance mentioned by the scholar is spot on. hope his wives watch this video and get properly educated. The dude literally manipulated them into thinking that it’s okay for him to cheAT

[@giftycustom5560]

They all consent and do it bases on regulation there, how is it called as cheat?

[@neilnelmar8007]

Power imbalance nonsence

[@TheFormActually]

Jealousy is the pure proof that it can never work and that there's is fundamentally something wrong with that concept : )

[@leusmaximusx]

the conclusion you state is wrong... jealousy exists even in non marriage

[@pb7199]

personally i don't think there's anything wrong with polygamy, if you have the ability to share your love with more than one person then by all means find someone who is like-minded and be happy being yourselves. however it seems that the women in these cases were either not consenting, or had to be coerced, it is not their wish to be polygamous and yet they were made to believe they must be in order to fulfill their duty as pious devotees. the relationship of the first family seemed very nice but the foundation of that relationship is built on a narrow interpretation of scripture, and i think that makes it deceitful. the idea that it is only okay for a man to feel an urge-- not even love for another woman, but a wish to be adulterous-- to be with another woman, that they believe in logic but use ungrounded reasoning, that the same people who use this reasoning will tout that their faith respects women the most but doesn't consider them capable of rational thought, is probably not the type of thought that any god would reward. the concept of polygamy is fine, it is the conditions it is practiced under that are not fine.

[@hyrunnisa997]

Yes exactly!!! This is spiritual and psychological abuse. Using religious scriptures to manipulate your spouse is wrong. Telling them what they have to believe is wrong! Forcing them to be polygamous when they originally didnt want to is wrong. I am Muslim and honestly I wouldn't mind being polygamous...as long as I can have a second partner too!! If not, then neither of us can. Both people need to consent.

[@childofolivares8754]

Yesssss. Yesssss. Thank you. I was thinking the same thing I just couldn't put it into words. But I have to add that I actually feel that the man in the video actually does love both of his wives. It's just that he tries to find ways to justify the way he did his family in a twisted way. I don't believe that he's a bad man for this. But it's totally wrong that he convinced his wives that they're more emotional or 'jealousy will grant you heaven'. I do believe that there were big issues with the way he did this. Like maybe he should have made sure that he didn't marry his first wife before being sure that she's ok with poligamy.

[@ashleyburbank3129]

agreed 100%

[@so-suyahassan3279]

If she refused and he fell into haram do u think it would feel better.. I dn't think so, and that's how the wife also thought too. It's more shameful to hear your husband sleeping around with other women rather do him the favor of getting him married a second time also there are women who need support out there with no husbands since the ratio of men to women aren't equal today so marrying more than one could hurt your first wife but it could be a life saving for another who has nowhere and no one to stand by and Allah knows best since He is the one who gave this RESPONSIBILITY to men who think they are manly enough and can do a good job. I dn't know why people are looking at it with all critisizm no woman right is violated here unless the man isn't carrying out his responsibilities out right. This man took full responsibility for these women. Where are the women who got impregnated by 'boyfriends' or 'one nightstands' and have to take responsibility of their kids on their own and all over sudden when the pregnancy gets out the child has no father it's as tho it condensed into her womb out of nowhere, that no longer seems wrong but those that are living the right way are condmed of being violeted and having no rights subhan Allah may Allah protect us all.

[@x.t.5221]

@@so-suyahassan3279 a man shouldn't be sleeping around when he has a wife. Polygamy shouldn't be use as an EXCUSE for men to SLEEP AROUND LEGALLY AND WITHOUT SHAME. it is NOT OKAY for a man to marry multiple wifes when it is just for the purpose of satisfying their own lust

[@Chalize]

This is so sad.

[@TheNeilDarby]

@@Woowxiwoo The point is that both those situations are sad, and neither are necessary for men to be happy. I mean, some men, but that's just catering to the lowest denominator in society. The point is that you shouldn't need to cheat or need polygamy.

[@TheNeilDarby]

@@Woowxiwoo And I would rather see neither. Which, believe it or not, is the reality in many places. The difference is cultural conditioning only.

[@Chalize]

@@Woowxiwoo You can tell that the second wife is unhappy about the whole situation. She seems like she joined a polygamy relationship for her family, and not her herself. Is so sad how some men take advantage of such situation. The look in her eyes makes me sad for her.

[@salmaoct]

@@Woowxiwoo i think I feel the same. Better be honest than cheating its more mental sickness

[@aminuaidara8601]

You prefer to see men going for prostitutes just like in the Western countries having one wife and a lot of prostitutes

[@jithu1211]

What if his wife wants to Marry 2 men ,Will this people allow that ! Then you will see the real face of this gentleman 😂

[@sakurachristineito6428]

The reporter shoulda asked him this question!

[@jithu1211]

Yeh . Exactly

[@mukiiis]

Stupid question

[@sakurachristineito6428]

@@mukiiis stupid question?? So only the man is allowed to fuck multiple wives?? Hahahah

[@jithu1211]

Sakura Christine Ito check out his name and you will understand 😀

[@pk-vs8vg]

Polygamy is not a bad practice until you give that right to both gender.

[@silverjuly9339]

21:30 and 21:54 says otherwise from your statement.

[@pk-vs8vg]

@@silverjuly9339 who said I am in favour of the ongoing practice? It's patriarchal!!

[@mukiiis]

You stupid! If a woman has multiple partners , she will be susceptible to STDs .

[@chromewontgetyouhome]

So a guy who sleeps with lots of different women is not susceptible to STD’s but a woman who sleeps with lots of different men is? Your logic makes no sense.

[@aleale6277]

Humans naturally form couples, this is due to biology: male-female birthrate of ~1:1 and the long pregnancy times. Islam is a fucked up cult, just like mormonism.

[@kritztalkreviews1437]

"Men are programmed to be attracted to more than one woman" Happily married couples all over the world: Are we jokes to you?

[@mylerwilson4879]

People who are asexual: Are we also a joke to you

[@Angela-tg3ol]

Homosexuals: are we also a joke to you?

[@alifahhika3168]

As a woman I have to be honest that I also attracted to more than one man at the same time lol, he just stupid 🤣

[@AznAfroMan513]

issues aside, the dude is damn good on the guitar

[@izzyy1680]

This guy clearly misinterpreted the reason for polygamy. It is to protect and help women who do not have a comfortable life, not to 'channel lust'. This is messed up even for me, a Muslimah.

[@notYisan]

this is wrong on so many levels, the husband is willfully ignorant and the wife is also stupid to accept such preposition.

[@usmanakhtar6110]

A few points to note. - Men cannot marry without their wives blessings. - Polygamy isn't something Muslims should be chasing actively if it isn't practical. And guess what .. it isn't in todays generation. - They MUST be just and equal to all their wives, this means time, finances and fairness - Consider all the sleeping around men do, the single mothers, fatherless children, sexually transmitted diseases, broken marriages due to adultery. This system holds them to account and keeps women's dignity intact. Remember there is NO compulsion for a woman to agree to this arrangement, it ain't for everyone.

[@blue-or7co]

Wives are brainwashed. No woman would ever be happy this way

[@blue-or7co]

Also the being equal concept is a good concept but it doesn't show good in practice.

[@theefaa]

@@blue-or7co Trust me, majority of Indonesian muslims (esp. women) do not agree or even practice it even though we don't condemn it.

[@sleepycowboy18]

Or you can not do adultery nor cheating? Why does it sounds like it's hard to not commit adultery smh, it's not that hard. Imo go ahead with polygamy/andry/amory, but them justifying it with religion is gross.

[@efmadscientist9184]

@@sleepycowboy18 however it's the part of religion, but it just advice. Depends on your desire you can hold 1 wife or not

[@nourahmad538]

This man made it seem very normal.. When he said "what's to lose?" I lost it😂 boy..What if it was the other way round..what if your wife had four husbands? and she was surprised that you didn't like it and she said "what's to lose?" oh boy... that would have been fun

[@sanchsai4431]

Education and common sense are two grossly different things I've learnt.

[@mars7935]

The interviewer is so beautiful

[@erinpilla]

Of course he'd advocate for it; he is RICH! Poor second wife had to marry him coz of that

[@littlebulb3538]

There is nothing wrong with polygamy but mind this, it is not about financial only,it is not about sex only,it is not about men only. It is about fairness with your family,how you treat them. How you take care of their feelings . How you take care of their needs spiritual and emotional. Most of the men who trully practice Islam will not be easily suave by poligamy. Because they know the responsibility that they have to bear. And how if they did wrong in teaching their child and wife,they will easily went to hell because of it. But mostly men use islam to have sex with multiple women. Just because they can. Please. From what i see in this vids,polygamy is just an excuse for them to have more wife. Sick mind. Prophets married more than one to save women from abused not because he want to have sex. In fact he loves his 1st wife so much that he cant remarried for a long time after his 1st wife dies.

[@silverjuly9339]

The Islamic Scholar at 21:02 said Islam supports monogamy.

[@fejobs150]

Tell this to the ones debating me in the comment, please. I'm not good at words.

[@littlebulb3538]

There is no use in debating this subject with someone who dont understand and never want to understand the really meanings behind polygamy. The one with green hijab (in vids) explains it better than me.

[@ZiFrenZie]

Nadeeya is My Name , "Prophets married more than one to save women from abused not because he want to have sex." Exactly!

[@nnn-v6w]

Nadeeya is My Name But you can’t truly treat them equally...

[@dinil5566]

If God created men to be attracted towards more than 1 women, *you should seriously reconsider your God* 🙄

[@AllThingsConsideredUK]

They're happy, you're the one commenting, maybe you should reconsider your personal beliefs

[@giftycustom5560]

Christian, judaism and hindu allow polygamy too isn't it? 😏

[@dinil5566]

@@AllThingsConsideredUK as far as I know, they are not happy. Atleast not the Muslim people i know of. May be in soudi Arabia.

[@dinil5566]

@@giftycustom5560 I don't think so. Atleast not Hinduism. Not like we are banned. We have no strict rules.

[@athiramanoj144]

Yeah that god is kind of manipulative

[@maryamkidwai2543]

Polygamy limited to 4 Need first wives free willed permission Only if equal tratment is possible which is kinda impossible nowadays. So its nit allowed. Only with free willed consent. Separate house for each woman. Not for lust. Only for children if first wife is barren and only with her permission or if first wife is insane or to protect the other woman in times of war and then onlg with free willed consent. So there. If it doesnt meet these conditions its a haraam relation and the husbands punishment will be great in this world and hereafter.

[@maryamz6691]

As an Indonesian Muslim I just want to say that these kinds if people are of the minority. As the person in the video mentioned 86% OPPOSE polygamy. God has permitted polygamy, but keep in mind the state of things at the time of Prophet Muhammad. It was a dangerous time for an unmarried woman. My personal belief is that polygamy should ONLY be practiced in order to protect the women, as a LAST RESORT. In this day and age, women are allowed to work and some even gain more money than the average man. That’s why I believe the practice is not necessary. It is a husband’s duty to curb his desires for other women periodt😤

[@maryamz6691]

We are now given the opportunity to become independent people, why the heck would anyone want to be someone’s second, third, or fourth wife? There are so many other things you can do to worship god and become a better Muslim.

[@warhead160]

I have heard of drugs being a problem in certain nations, including mine. But never thought Indonesia had such a problem. Then this guy happened.

[@sakurakou2009]

Polygamy was not invented by islam , it was already their before islam but was unlimited , so islam limited it only to up to four wives and their was rules to it that you must be just and treat them equally , and in quran said that even if you try you would not be just .

[@asavideos1857]

Your comment is so underrated! That's what I oftenly read!

[@98nabilahlolipop]

There.. Someone finally said it.

[@salmaoct]

I've ever read about this. And this is what I look for

[@sakurakou2009]

@Wasim Ahmed while polygamy is not 100% bad , like rather then man cheating on his wife he can take in another wife , rather then couple hiring sorgatte woman to carry their children in case of infertility and rather then guy divorcing his infertile wife he can marry another while keeping both , their many social problems that might be solved with limited polygamy and woman can get divorced if she not like it , so I think it ok . me personally I would not be able to tolerate polygamous relationship with my husband BUT I know their many women who not mind sharing their husband whether it be cuz they need husband support financially or ok cuz they have problems like infertility . about why mohammed married lot of women most those women where widows and divorced and some were alliances marrige , mohammed first wife khadeja was his love and only one he was married out of love , this just show us that marrige is not just about love and I agree with that many dont marry for love but life goes on. and quran clearly say if you cant do justice then marry only one , so where is the problem , quran words come before anything else even mohammed actions in his own private life

[@sakurakou2009]

@Wasim Ahmed you can ask muslim scholar on that , I personally dont care .. I am not muslim anymore but I have my own reasons .

[@ramizraza6344]

You should have asked if he will marry her daughter to a man already has a wife when grown up... ! I think he will not.. This is disgusting ! Its an old tradition during wars which must not exist now! I am muslim and i really disaprove with this shitty idea. It must stop !

[@nidanaeem3876]

the woman who believes that living a life full of jealousy is a direct ticket to heaven is going to be so disappointed when she becomes worm food

[@shahansindhi8141]

His second wi're talked like she wanted to kill him...

[@Oreo-vh7rk]

DRAMAAAAA

[@leanderbarreto6523]

Tribal religion meets modern world

[@liri8243]

If they accept polygamy then why not polyandry , that will be fair in my sense

[@so-suyahassan3279]

Woman's body can't be compared to a man's that's why.

[@liri8243]

@@so-suyahassan3279 hay I know what u mean and I agree . I don't support both polygamy and polyandry but it's not like it's not happening anywhere . What I mean is let the individual decide what they want don't choose for them . so I think they should legalize polyandry then it would be equal right for all although I know no one going to practice it . And here is some data from Wikipedia :- More recent studies have found more than 50 other societies practicing polyandry. Fraternal polyandry is practiced among Tibetans in Nepal, parts of China and part of northern India, in which two or more brothers are married to the same wife, with the wife having equal "sexual access" to them.

[@so-suyahassan3279]

@@liri8243 that's sick as ever and has lots of complications campared to polygamy and believe me or not men are creatures who easily get jealous over nothing when their women are even looked at by other men it's a war that's if he loves her but in their case it just seems sexual satisfaction and nothing more. These are facts that are scientifically proved and even ask any man who loves a woman if he could share her and hear their response but be careful not to get punched 🙄.

[@liri8243]

@@so-suyahassan3279 it's obvious , Regardless the gender no one can accept their dear ones to share with others so these concepts should not be acceptable for a better society . Bdw r u Indonesian ?

[@so-suyahassan3279]

@@liri8243 No I'm not but God gave this choice to men those who can afford the expenses and carry such responsibilities there are also a lot of other positives to it God knows best.

[@Angela-tg3ol]

“It’s a woman’s fate to feel jealousy” doesn’t a man feel jealous too?

[@ya6068]

Polygamy is like anti religious. To me it feels like the men just gave up fighting their urges and religion is about fighting urges (fighting the inner demons) also it doesn’t make any sense to be polygamy because god put roughly the same amount of woman and men on earth

[@abuqatada2389]

Wrong. Polygamy is part of Islam and we will continue to do it. Take your western ideologies and put it UP YOURS

[@immortaleternal5125]

There is no need/value for all the reasons/opinions/justifications. Polygyny is clearly declared optional in the Quran. Do it if you qualify and want to, don't if you don't. The prophet pbuh did it and some of his best companions did it, he didn't discourage anyone. Others also didn't want it, he also supported their decision, most notably his own daughter Fatima.

[@omegamelody6947]

I wonder if the wives will be fighting like those women in the harem of CDramas. Maybe I watch too much CDramas lels

[@alifahhika3168]

Yes usually they will be fighting or when their child is became a teenager and understands this they'll get depressed (bcuz I have friends like that)

[@samsamistorm]

this angers me to no end

[@maazkhan3202]

Lol

[@maazkhan3202]

@Asmeret ኣስመረት weak willed are those who have sex with anyone they want and then they never see that person again.

[@maazkhan3202]

@Asmeret ኣስመረት can you explain with better grammar pls.

[@maazkhan3202]

@Asmeret ኣስመረት So what do you believe the intent is.

[@yoursinfernally]

It is important to recognise though he is a Muslim with such practices, they’re ultimately HIS choices based on HIS perspective of the Islamic teachings. Religious scriptures are rarely literal in their interpretations. What one man chooses to take away from the faith does not get to speak for the entirety of Islam.

[@syahrulzhafrel1909]

If he said women use emotion.. then he used lust as thinking mechanism.. in religion if u can control your lust then you are the be most noble man. You're messed up to the core

[@b.h6087]

Didalam agama Islam mana mungkin seseorang yang boleh berbuat dosa berlaku adil melainkan manusia-manusia pilihan tuhan sperti para nabi dan rasul. Selain dari manusia pilihan tuhan, mereka hanya mementingkan nafsu semata-mata sebab itu mereka cenderung ke arah mahu memenuhi keperluan nafsu sendiri. Adalah satu kebodohan jika berpoligami atas dasar menambah umat kerana jelas dari hadis nabi mengatakan umat akhir zaman nanti bilangan nya ramai tapi hanya seperti buih-buih di lautan. Islam itu sudah sempurna dan kuat bukan dari kuantiti tapi kualiti.

[@wahyutyas9581]

👍👍👍👍👍

[@Angela-tg3ol]

18:02 absolute respect for the reporter for putting up with this guy

[@dimasp8340]

This video originally from Vice Indonesia and most of the people disagree with this guys. He had so many bad comment about him and cursing him being "the horny guy" lol

[@happyheartslee]

The explanation by the last lady in green is good. It provides perspective and reasoning.

[@EosMuse]

The only polygamy that I can accept is if the first wife was unable to conceive the husband child and they both come to this solution .... Like..... This is a nope for me...

[@arieswoman824]

If God didn't give you that, adoption is the route not marrying someone else. The assumption here is there is a problem with the woman not the man.

[@healtyme2194]

I think his choice of words has made the islamphobias more afraid

[@shabinashabbir3379]

I'm hurt. Deeply hurt by the way these women have been made to understand that their sexual urges are less and feeling jealous all the time is in woman's nature. And also that they are doing it for the sake of Allah who definitely would not want these women to be hurt and feel jealous.

[@meccathecowifecoach]

As I watch this video I observe a lot of cultural practices and ideals along with the religious meanings. I am a Muslim (American)Woman who practice polygyny and I am happy in my marriage and happy with my family structure. We are not brainwashed or oppressed or forced into practicing polygyny. This practice was something that has been here for ages so this is nothing new. I actually work with women who practice polygyny (and other women regardless of their marital status) with healing of the heart and making the best decisions within themselves to do what’s best for them (whatever that may be)

[@blackrose584]

Brainwashing at its finest

[@meccathecowifecoach]

Black Rose that is your option. To you be yours and to me be mines. Have a positive peace and productive day on purpose and with purpose 😊

[@niniksetiawan6034]

Lucky you for living in a country where women can choose freely.

[@ashtonharris8900]

As a Muslim, polygamy isn't a religious practice that grants you a pass to heaven or a practice that will make you a better Muslim it is something that is permissible meaning it is permitted but it's not necessarily a holy action, polygamy is only to be practiced if you treat each wife the same, same amount time together, same gifts etc. Also another thing is polygamy is meant to be used in times when there is a shortage of Muslim men for Muslim women to marry or to help women in poverty. And if a Muslim woman does not want her husband to be married to another woman while married to her they can put in the marriage contract that polygamy is not allowed in their marriage and if the man breaks that promise it would be extremely bad.

[@macrick]

The man is smart to separate his 2 wives in different houses.

[@mycrafts7207]

When she said listening to this makes me want to break my fast 😂😂😂😭

[@childofolivares8754]

Y'all know that this video is basically like advertising poligamy right? And like it'll most likely become more likable to people in Indonesia because he's doing a great job making it look good. I like how the journalist tries her best to understand what's going on and how everyone feels about this.

[@dandelionroots3308]

it's not. indonesian people who watch this video in vice indonesia are angry too

[@alifahhika3168]

@@dandelionroots3308 yes we're actually disgusted by that, you can tell if they had family vacation ppl around them will be disgusted, ilfeel or making fun of them when they leave

[@niniksetiawan6034]

Nah, I'm Indonesian and I think that man is doing a good job making himself sounds so stupid and ridiculous.

[@rennims4187]

"Daripada zinah lbh baik menikah lagi, dengan menikah lagi maka hasrat yg saya salurkan ke istri saya menjadi ibadah." OMG!!! Anda punya modal merangkai kata kata, sdh menikah kog msh punya hasrat ke wanita lain..

[@shaunduquette5992]

I wonder if these women have a proper education.

[@FlowtnWitWalden]

LOL, the music starting @7:01, I don't know who wrote it; But it was used in the K-Drama "Autumn in My Heart" (가을동화)!

[@choianam2656]

Yang janggal dr narasumber riski: 1. Dia tidak memberikan dalil (naqli atau aqli) 2. Sexual oriented topic 3. Latar belakang istri ke 2nya (yang mungkin bisa jadi bahan pertimbangan kenapa menikahinya) tidak dijelaskan 4. Terasa semua sudah disetting oleh riski dr awal Menurut saya😁

[@noorrahma2685]

As a Muslim, it is not about what our opinion is but what God has blessed us with. With that in mind, Allah SWT says that a man can get a second, third, fourth, etc. wife IF and only if he can support his second wife successfully and his current wife is happy, fulfilled, and satisfied. Sometimes a second wife is necessary in a situation where the first wife cannot conceive children. The problem with polygamy is not what Allah ordained on us and allowed us to do but it is the fact that Muslims do not follow their own religion and take it out of context. They make it into something that is a light decision that can be taken on, astigfirallah, when we see the example of Prophet Muhammad, PBUH, he had so many wives but the fact that he put them before himself never changed, how many husbands can acheive that? But they talk about taking on another wife and deny that in Islam marriage is a huge responsibility and the wife holds great value. May Allah guide us all

[@omegaman6193]

Everybody keeps talking about what god once.... dude never told me what he wanted.

[@privaterizk4936]

I know it's an old video and I don't think many people will read this. I don't like the idea of journalism in here. Shouldn't journalists be as netral as they can? Not saying I agree on polygamy and the video should put polygamy on fully positive side, tho. It's just report it in format of facts without putting her own opinion here. If she wants to talk about her opinion, it's different kind of video.

[@anais3580]

That man didn't understand the purpose of allowing polygamy. It is allowed (in Islam) because in many societies, a widow is often left without any ressources and can't work. So being a second wife is a way to escape this dragic fate. But that man married another woman only for lust and to avoid cheating, as if God didn't give him any self control. A wife is a partner, not a toy.

[@anais3580]

@@Guyanababoo217 I agree with you, he is not dishonnest about his reasons to have several wives. However, his reasons are not noble at all and they aren't pious according to Islam. Moreover, his wives may have agreed to be in this situation because of their upbringing. Indeed his second wife even said her father pressured her to. How is that "bitches running to rich men" or whatever ? Many women are taught to accept anything and to submit from a young age so they eventually find themselves in such a situation. And I would like to add I don't think I know better than anyone. I just gave my opinion on the fact that he explained his reasons with Islam, when his actions don't correspond with Islam's teachings.

[@hanak2159]

Quran said to the men only if you can keep justice you are allow to do polygamy. Also first wife's permision is important.

[@ashleyburbank3129]

I don't like how he says women are controlled by emotions I disagree but his family seems very happy so for that I will not judge him he has a very happy family don't we all want that. I'm not a hater of polygamy I actually am okay with it if done in a healthy way, I just feel like it should be equal women should be able to have multiple husbands if they can support them!

[@ashleyburbank3129]

Rusty Shacklevert nowadays they actually do make accurate DNA test especially if you have the DNA of the people in question that makes it a hundred percent guaranteed actually(and they have pretty cheap mail in ones that are just as accurate when you have everyone's DNA sample) or if they were that concerned about it they could switch off every month and use the calendar technique when trying to conceive! that way they could know who the father is 100% without a DNA test.

[@ashleyburbank3129]

Rusty Shacklevert K weird I'm not aroused during my period but I actually believe that. but assuming that sperm Can Only Live 5 days inside the vagina which is a fact and assuming that the woman doesn't have sex on her period which if it isn't long enough she can wait at least 7 days that would work 100%. am I about to do this now I'm happily married to one man, and if either of us cheated we would clearly divorce because we live a faithful marriage. but I'm just saying people make it seem like it's impossible to have the reverse kind of polygamous relationship but it's clearly not. there's a place in India on a mountain somewhere where land is so limited and these people have owned it for so long that they don't want to give it up or break up property which is owned by the men of a family. so when these men(brothers) get married they marry one woman and the brothers "share" her. they seem to have very harmonious families. also when you have everyone's DNA In question (both or multiple) DNA tests are 100% accurate.

[@ashleyburbank3129]

Rusty Shacklevert if you can't afford it you really can't afford polygamy, because there's a lot of people to support. also your statistics on DNA are wrong have you looked it up when you have everyone's DNA cuz it changes everything. I have worked in the medical field before and I do know this is true! also the comment I made about me and my husband wasn't saying that polygamy is a problem with that is cheating in a polygamous relationship to have sex with someone you're married too. I was explaining my different perspective and why I'm not someone who knows what it's like to live in one. though I do full heartedly believe it could easily work just as well the other way with women marrying multiple went men and there are examples where this works in other cultures that allow it.

[@ashleyburbank3129]

Rusty Shacklevert like I said I've worked in the medical field and I don't trust a single article I can find an article online anywhere that can say anything I wanted to but I trust STUDIES in large numbers, show me a few studies that show your theory and the actual studies; not an article based off a study the study it's self!

[@ashleyburbank3129]

Rusty Shacklevert simply use a credible search engine to search for studies everyone has access to Scientific and Medical studies

[@agungaryowicaksono6215]

The woman is too stunned to speak

[@violinstar5948]

His twisted logic is astounding

[@echoindigo4436]

Disgusting practice. Disgusting.

[@kyuiis]

I'm Muslim. Not in with Polygamy. It's a big yikes. I understand if your wife has passed and you re-marry, it's okay. Not with having 4 wives. But, Its still halal and if your perspectives differ, its alright.

[@abdulrahmanraheem423]

The bottom line is that polygamy is Halal, but if the women or man does not want to take part in that type of marriage then he or she can choose not to get involved in that type of arrangement. It is ironic that people will vote and fight for the rights of 2 men or 2 women to marry then look down on people that agree to marry more than one women? If you dont agree with polygamy dont get involved! But i dont think its right to point a finger at those people saying that it is not right and that the women are being tricked or manipulated.

[@missthis4140]

The way the Indonesians treat the indigenous people of West Papa New Guinea I hope they all end up under oppression those who oppress others deserve it. Good luck ladies😄. What goes around comes around. May you have many sons!

[@missthis4140]

@Asmeret ኣስመረት Why? Honestly if they weren't treating others like shit I'd say do what you do. It's their private lives. The tribe on that island speak the most languages in the world their racism is destroying their opportunity. Oh well you can't fix stupid. Some chicks like that freaky shit. That's on them. Why does everyone feel the need to beat the same drum? Sadly most asian country are homogeneous so yes this could spread like cancer. Diversity works people.

[@yiting7456]

Sry but wtf he said Islam treats women as noble beings and they need to be empowered through marriage. You do NOT need marriage or love to be empowered, you can be strong on ur own. And if they really are empowered through marriage, why can't they practice polygomy

[@nourahmad538]

I'm sorry mister, but it didn't take you years to convince your first wife to agree to have other wives along with her.. it took you years be able to suck out every bit of logic she had until she complied.

[@mrm3611]

That is not what god intended with allowing more than 1 wife, these people are confused. There are circumstances that is necessary, there are rules and terms that need to be fulfilled. Like if a wife can't have children or a homeless poor woman that need to be taken cared of.

[@prundina]

He’s being dismissive with the fact that the idea of love is unquantifiable. On itself, this justifies the fact that no man can be fair to their wives as not all the things provided can be quantified equally. And in Islam, men are ONLY allowed to marry more than one woman IF they can be fair to all wives. And for him to say that “God doesn’t requires us to feel equal love for all of our wives” is pure made up excuse cause I never read any Qur’an verse or Hadith that says exactly that.

[@MariaCau_Soares]

For me what makes you stand out for God is actually restraining yourself from cheating, and being faithful, to him and your family. Not trying to get another wife just so you can "cheat" freely.

[@Iswimandrun]

Hey just change purity to moral character and doing what you say. Then expand the practice to women to be able to do it too. Then try to remove power disparity between the genders wam bam thank you man I got no problem with it. This kind of life not for me to much drama plus to much Regimentation by social pressure.

[@scoopam_art]

The way these men treat women just as sexual objects is disgusting

[@pategustavo4392]

So, what do feminists have to say or do about this?

[@cooliipie]

They only have white people

[@rakkrisr123]

Trump is racist and immigrants are welcome, islam is the religion of peace 😂🙄😆

[@rajathe8339]

@@rakkrisr123 lol

[@rosannaberckley5515]

Feminist here, I really don't care what happens outside my country. Sad that attention hungry thots are importing this 3rd world scum though.

[@pategustavo4392]

@@rosannaberckley5515 so a useless feminist then, just like the majority

[@isaacyip1998]

If paedophilia can be accepted in Islam, I'm not really surprised they condone polygamy too

[@delitter]

... Install programs... Well thats just creepy.

[@musicclasical]

Ok but no one‘s talking about the reporter who was asked if she‘s single and looking for a husband inwhich she responded: if I can have 2 husbands, I‘m in!🤣🤣 u go girl!