The dark twist of ENHYPEN’s XO (Only If You Say Yes) | Explained

[@vernerkole5624]

Another great video. Thank you. One thing that struck me is that Chloe, if she is still alive, will be an old lady by now. The technology in the trailer and Niki's car in the MV both indicate the early1980s, which must be the time they were hanging out with Chloe. I don't think they experience time in the same way humans do. This is also hinted at in the webtoon. It may seem to them like only a short time has passed and they may not realise that most of Chloe's life will have passed since they hung out. This is another way that Chloe represents Engene. Engene will grow up while they remain digitally immortal and unchanged.

[@ullamolina2007]

Thank you for the existential crisis on this fine evening…

[@vernerkole5624]

@@ullamolina2007 You're welcome.

[@heeseungismymanz]

5:07 "and before he ends up pulling a regina george-" thats enough internet for me today

[@CasianaMagpantay]

How can you comment a time like that ? I wanna do it too 👌👌

[@heeseungismymanz]

@CasianaMagpantay you just type it out the exact time then once you post your comment it'll add your time stamp ^^

[@CasianaMagpantay]

@@heeseungismymanz Thxx 💗💗💗

[@heeseungismymanz]

@@CasianaMagpantay nppp

[@minholly949]

2:05 i'm crying hahhaa we love you fanboys!! once again, such a convincing theory! i love how so much details are explained and tied it back to the lore.

[@Praneelchauhan-mg1hi]

I'm a guy and i'm sobbing my god no representation for me :(

[@AwakeningWings]

At first, I thought this was an alternate timeline but this must have been before they met Sooha at the Riverfield school. Then I went back to thinking it seems like a different reality in their Dark Moon storyline. But it's really the prequel to Dark Moon. Because of the reincarnation thing in Dark Moon, it would make sense that they have different powers, it can be a different timeline. I wondered how many reincarnations they had until they got to the modern timeline. And there's the "Children of Vamfield. Where they were staying is called "Vamfield house," and they grew up with Ms. Marge, who is the caretaker/teacher of Selene/Sooha.

[@hibahsami4530]

Just like enhyphen's example. Us dedlulu girlies will never leave the fantasy world. No clue whose who, when did the powers swap (for "cinematic purposes " and what timeline it is.. 😂 this comeback is a banger i must say

[@Tina_xx7]

1:15 Omg this makes so much sense, I'm glad we have someone like you to help explain it for us❤️

[@fate.d]

here’s my long winded theory 🤩: so it’s been confirmed that the xo mv is a dream. if you look at the lyrics, you notice how they seem like what a knight would say to someone they serve. remember in their past life (blood of vargr), enhypen were vampire knights who served Selen. in my opinion, the xo mv is their past life memories blurring into their dreams. they can’t remember selen, they can’t remember what she looks like, but they can remember their feelings. i think the mv shows each of the boy’s dream if they won Rock Paper Scissors, but at the end it’s just a dream and they’re still waiting for selen / sooha to appear. additionally, jungwon can reverse time in dark moon but I think he lets ni-ki win Rock Paper Scissors because he’d rather sacrifice his own happiness so enhypen can all stay together. so in conclusion, jungwon dreams of sacrificing his own happiness to keep enhypen together, and at the same time the memories of his past life are blurring into his reality.

[@peace-s4f]

“k-drama level of romance” LMAO

[@m.i_myself_and_i_]

Didn't Jungwon confirm that what happens in the MV is just his imagination? I think I saw it on their MV reaction video, maybe I'm wrong, I have to see it again I just checked it and they say it was all a dream

[@puppyjakeu]

yes yes, he said it

[@Bangtan_she]

"YOU are the goddess of the song-" Me: in the corner blushing very well knowing that ain't happening...

[@vickiwilliams1228]

Thank 😂you, you always add more insight to my understanding. I don’t understand or maybe it doesn’t mean anything , the 6 vs 1 splits . Beginning Sunghoon wins and leaves six, six empty chairs and one full, Sunoo 6 butterflies and one bat, etc..

[@3mmaissad]

As always, your video is so explanatory and the theory makes a lot of sense :) i didn't think such a cute mv could be this sad ;--; i still love it tho :P thank you sm for this amazing video!!

[@Chloe-n1r]

Omg Chloe is gorgeous 1:37

[@fantasmaghoulical]

right like forget enhypen i want herrr🫣

[@en_ace_gene]

Your theories are always so accurate and detailed, love you

[@luanatassorocha6487]

The only thing I can say is GENIUS

[@MoaEngeneLuneRise]

I have been waiting for this thank you

[@bignochi842]

This is an amazing video!! Your take on how the mv is connected to the concept cinema was so interesting to watch!! Im curious to hear your thoughts on another very similar theory on Twitter because it addressed the mv separate from the concept trailer I believe. It basically talked about how ni-ki is actually the mastermind in this mv bc you can see the boys playing rock paper scissors at the start of the mv to confess to chloe. They throw up scissors and sunghoon throws up rock, so he wins. Then the mv flashes to how each member would confess to chloe in their imaginations. We can actually see in the mv a clip when Jake closes the fridge that he looks at the corner of the room, and there are 6 bats there watching him because they don’t want Jake to confess to Chloe. Then the mv flashes back to Jungwon, who was zoning out bc he along with the other members saw the future that sunghoon was going to win, so he along with all the other members throws up rock. However, ni-ki, knowing what all the members were thinking, throws up paper and wins. That’s why at the end of the mv, we see them and Chloe in the car where ni-ki imagined his confession to be, and they’re here bc ni-ki won the rock paper scissors by outsmarting everyone. That’s why the very last scene of ni-ki has him looking so smug. Or at least I think that’s how the theory goes. Again, I’m curious to hear your thoughts!! 💗💗 I love this video! Credits to hoonpillar on twt!!

[@c1mnrz]

4:20 I actually thought that the part where Sunghoon is laying with Heeseung is a reference to FEVER

[@jeyjey226]

Actually it's Jay laying next to Heeseung

[@Soobs-dece1211]

2:04 OMG TENKYU AHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

[@OlgaKrapivenko]

Thank you for the interesting and detailed analysis.🥰

[@kais.5892]

When it comes to their new powers… sometimes I think they are in a different timeline where the main girl is Chloe. But it is the Japanese version / MV’s of Enhypen. Maybe that’s why they have different powers in this timeline…I don’t know…but it does make sense that this story happened before they went to Riverfield (romance untold). Thank you for the video ❤

[@haewonniee42]

i don’t think so.. since children of vamfield is on the same timeline as the blood altar

[@abc-tu2cl]

it is said that vampires can use each other's powers so i think they can use various powers🤔

[@Chaconnenation]

Wow this really makes a lot sense! Now I'm thinking, what do you think can be next, in next album, this story seems tragic so tragic, dark selve theme or maybe another dream? Or maybe Sooha come back since Chloe is not with us?

[@monaraina9264]

Chloe is us !!! Engenes and in this album Chloe is not there with enhypen anymore and they couldn’t escape to riverfield with chloe (engenes) and they didn’t succeed there mission so basically the mv shows that they are stopping time again and again so they can hang out with Chloe for a longer time and she only comes out at the night when they stop time but in reality the last day of Chloe with them is totally full of dates and sunghoon confessed her and he was feeling nervous about doing it ALSO my theory SOOHA IN DARK BLOOD LOVES SUNGHOON AND SAID MY LOVE TO HIM but When heli like sooha and sooha like heli in the web toon so this is totally bizzare are and I don’t get it . Sooo if someone helpssss ❤❤❤

[@codemari]

same thoughts! all of the dreamy shots and time stops/reversing made me think that the mv was not reality and maybe alternate universes where Chloe is alive and whoever wins the rock paper scissors would date her

[@Bangtan_she]

5:15 Yeah, like we can know it really.... Great big brains..

[@ChiduPriya]

I was waiting for your ENHYPEN lore explanation video~

[@Wavingfly]

I was looking forward to this video!!! Thank you!!!!!! 😊

[@AwakeningWings]

And doesn't "Romance: Untold" remind you of something? The whole "truth untold" stuff going on with BTS. I think the letters on the word "UNTOLD" look like a key and a keyhole from a door. The other letters look like the inside of a lock.

[@cgage_01]

DON'T FORGET ABOUT SELENE, SHE IS ALSO A PART OF THE STORY. NONE THE LESS, THIS IS A GREAT VIDEO IN TANDEM WITH THAT WONDERFUL MINI MOVIE WE WATCHED. DOESN'T ONE OF THE BOYS CONTROL TIME? THEY CAN GO BACK AND FORTH IN TIME? WHAT I FOUND CURE IS WHEN JAKE IS ON THE FLOOR WITH THE FRIDGE OPEN, HE TURNS AND LOOKS AT SOMETHING BEHIND HIM, 6 LITTLE BATS HANGING UPSIDE DOWN, LOL. I THOUGHT THAT WAS IMPORTANT.

[@ivytowergirl207]

Beautiful explanation! Thank you.💞

[@aunaurrr]

I LOVE IT. Thank you for such a thorough explanation.

[@maitreyeebhowmick1468]

love your videos every time

[@Dinotsaurus_]

Lol 2:08 in love with this comment even though i am not a dude

[@wonwon_3812]

found this theory on ig! please read!! niki is a mastermind, what we saw in the beginning (sunghoon won by choosing rock and everyone else chose scissor) but niki took matters into his own hand, and made it his own fate. as we all know from the beginning, is that sunghoon won, which means he gets to confess to chloe/sooha. we have seen in the mv how everyone likes chloe/sooha. but it was actually how the rest of the members would confess if they won the rock paper scissors. it was not their present reality YET. we could see that nearing to the end, the scenes were sped up and jungwon was zooming out. when in the fact he was looking into the future of what would happen. but it wasnt only jungwon, everyone looked into the future. so basically in the round were sunghoon won was just imaginary (they looked into the future) where sunghoon chose rock. but when they actually played it, they all wanted to win over sunghoon who chose rock, so each of the other members knew they would win if they choose rock so they did exept niki who was smart and knew what the other members were thinking, chose paper to win! along the mv, niki,'s scene with chloe/sooha is on a car. thus, in the ending scene, we saw chloe/sooha in the car. he already confessed to her. and the mv ending with niki smirking cuz he successfully had what's supposed to be sunghoons fate to be his.!!

[@demariawhite3681]

Can you do a MV theory on Dreamcatcher’s Justice?

[@AwakeningWings]

Doesn't Jungwon wake up from the dream at the end of the music video? So when you mentioned the dream world it makes sense.

[@cami-rising]

Amazingggg can you also explain brought the heat back its so cofusing

[@igotpushed_]

Where did you find the storyboard?!

[@bookishtheories]

The artist posted it on Instagram! Search for Park Youseung

[@igotpushed_]

@@bookishtheories thank you!

[@puppyjakeu]

es q sus teorias y analisis son increibles

[@BbokAriWing]

Please do chk chk boom by skz 🙏

[@ewamacionga7475]

XOXO 😘KISS ME AND BITE ME,BESAME MUCHO😘 BLACK CAT🐱 AND TAKE ME TO YOUR DREAMS AND YOUR HEART(condition,only me😉). 🎵🎶💜🌃

[@Katiem2410]

Hey can you explain jimin who mv

[@afreakaboucher1316]

❤❤❤

[@Deb.Blakley.Rasmussen]

💜

[@elindayana8174]

Is it true that people don't like Sooha? Why? 😥

[@bookishtheories]

Yes it’s true! I’m not sure why, I guess a lot of fans see her as “competition”? 😅 I’ve read some comments about it but idk if there are other reasons

[@yumeng.xie16]

I think it started in the webtoon where Sooha found out the boys were vampires and freaked out (even though her behavior and hate for vampires were totally understandable due to her being accused). Then she made up the Heli after finding out the boys are good and there was a romantic scene between them (bite my neck moment). Because of that, the webtoon's comment section was filled with Sooha hate with "Sooha out" calling her a pick me. It could either be due to jealousy, or the fans weren't happy since Sooha apparently represents engenes

[@imnot_nukii]

@@bookishtheories not competition, they just think she acts really dramatic and pick-me, lol.. i honestly don't have that much of a problem with her

[@en_ace_gene]

​@@yumeng.xie16 how fictional character can be "pick me"😂😂

[@Sunghoon_penguinཐིཋྀ]

Dawg