The Descriptions of Jahannam #8: The Eternality of Heaven & Hell (& Ibn Taymiyyah’s Views)

Intro - Surah Ale Imran, Verse 185:
لُّ نَفْسٍ ذَائِقَةُ الْمَوْتِ ۗ وَإِنَّمَا تُوَفَّوْنَ أُجُورَكُمْ يَوْمَ الْقِيَامَةِ ۖ فَمَنْ زُحْزِحَ عَنِ النَّارِ وَأُدْخِلَ الْجَنَّةَ فَقَدْ فَازَ ۗ وَمَا الْحَيَاةُ الدُّنْيَا إِلَّا مَتَاعُ الْغُرُورِ
Translation:
Every soul will taste death, and you will only be given your [full] compensation on the Day of Resurrection. So he who is drawn away from the Fire and admitted to Paradise has attained [his desire]. And what is the life of this world except the delusion of enjoyment.
Please LIKE, COMMENT, & SHARE!
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Credits:
Intro Reciter: Qari Sajjad Gul
Outro Nasheed:
Link: tiny.cc/outro2
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi - Official Social Media Pages
Facebook: yasirqadhi
Instagram: yasir.qadhi
Twitter: yasirQadhi
Snapchat: snapchat.com/add/yasir.qadhi
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
© Shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi - Official KZbin Channel

[@imranamalik8216]

I just live the way when sheikh goes to his tangents. really this man has soooooo much knowledge that it just gush out. may Allah bless him.

[@adnanahmed9044]

Sheikh ul tangent qadhi. Lol

[@shienm635]

MashaALLAH

[@sadiaabdullaimuhammed8470]

Ameen

[@15afshan]

Alhamdulillah

[@mishkatahmadchowdhury1513]

@@15afshan Amiin

[@rayhanhkhan]

If we had to buy a moment in Jannah with a lifetime of misery, it would still be an amazing deal! And if we had to go through just a moment in hell to be able to enjoy our while life on this Earth to the fullest, it would be a horrible price to pay. No matter what we go through we cannot possibly earn Jannah through our own deeds. Jannah is way more valuable than all of your good deeds and efforts. It is only out of Allah's infinite Rahmah that we can hope to get into Jannah. We don't even want to be in Jahannam for a second! We cannot even imagine what its like! The least punishment in Jahannam is worse than the worst pain you have ever experienced! Jannah is worth all the hardship we go through and more! Be ambitious! Give it your best! Don't settle for less! Be patient! Allah is with the patient! May Allah strengthen us and grant us Jannat-ul-firdaus! ❤️

[@bellah09]

@Cheers To nothing Yeah after some few years max sadly.... haters can wait!

[@RK-si4ln]

Words of wisdom.

[@bellah09]

@Cheers To nothing Yeah I did ... But he also said word by word is Allah's speech...When u study Qirat history you will understand what he meant... trust me!.. this people that refute him don't hv the knowledge to present their case ...I advice you and myself just concentrate on yourself..Are u a good Muslim?? coz at the end of the day you will stand alone in front of Allah on the day of Judgement!.. May Allah forgive us all

[@bellah09]

@Cheers To nothing You left your religion ??...inalillahi waina ileyhi rajiun...why??...You really don't love yoursel!..You failed the test wallahi

[@bellah09]

@Cheers To nothing How do you deal with stress ..problems...who do you turn to... Are u happy now!...Just do tauba and go back to your Religion please !...You will never hv peace..You hv failed the test thats what it means

[@o_o-037]

May Allah forgive all of our past, present, and future sins, Ameen.

[@typingwithonib8622]

Ameen.

[@QasimAli-bc2vc]

Aameen

[@bellah09]

Am so glad Jannah is forever and ever and ever... was getting worried I hv a looooonnng ...endless list of things that I wish for 🙂.May Allah grant us the highest place in jannah!

[@mouhamadoutaffa5064]

Ameen dear sister

[@parkerflop]

ameen

[@Revival321]

Aameen

[@dilekbasar4673]

Amen!🤲🏼

[@emiribric4294]

fire!

[@dubkaxaaji9698]

Jazakallah what a wonderful series may Allah SWT make jannah our final abode inshaAllah. May Allah safe us from hell fire Amiin ya Allah..

[@idrismobarik8718]

It’s best that allah has made this point ambiguous people tend to try and squeeze through small openings when they wanna follow desires

[@kmir224]

absolutely phenomenal video... i'm gonna have to watch it again. love watching videos on topics in which a plethora of opinions along w/ their associated reasoning are presented in a concise, digestible, and highly informative manner

[@sairanazsufian7237]

Subhan Allah....... may Allah bless u

[@gadgetseco9864]

This speaker is amazing and my favorite. he explain things in befitting manner. May ALLAH grant us all PARADISE.

[@ByChoiceMuslim]

Very good discussion on the eternality of Jahannam. I have been eagerly waiting for this discussion since you started the Jahannam series. Ibn Taymiyya's position is very unique and intriguing.

[@tiktokasylum5186]

Unique isn’t a good thing as a scholar it means out of the ijma

[@Kimeikus]

@@tiktokasylum5186 It’s not good or bad. It’s just different.

[@stadiamak692]

It's the correct opinion

[@sabanaaz9222]

SubhanAllah beautiful lecture Shaykh has so much knowledge MashaAllah

[@AhmadJZaigham]

Ma Sha Allah, Jazak Allah Khair Sheikh Yasir

[@shyro1316]

Waiting inshallah, just love this series may Allah reward you.

[@logicalrealistic3139]

ASSALLAMUALAIKUM WARAHMATULLAHI WABARAKATUH SHEIKH DR YASIR QADHI Greetings from Malaysia 🇲🇾... I embraced Islam after watching your videos 5 yrs ago.. I have learnt so much & much more to learn. I am always so motivated and inspired with your lessons... May you be always protected. May you be blessed with good health, happiness and infinite success. May you be given Jannatul-Firdaus Aamiin Aamiin Aamiin Ya Rabbal Alamin 🤲 JAZAKALLAHU KHAYRAN

[@truthseeker185]

Such beautiful educational process. Love it.

[@malinakinnarath1091]

May Allah reward you shaykh Ameen

[@abuyasin9278]

Barak Allah feek Shiekh Yasir. This series has been so useful and enlightening. The subject of ibn Taymiyah extremely controversial and probably over our heads since our understanding of him or any other Muslim scholar so limited in this day and age. Good food for thought that I don't think is correct and side with camp that says only Allah knows, but believe jahannam to be eternal. Shaytain deserves eternal punishment for what he's done to us since the time of Adam AS. He deserves no mercy.

[@shiyanahaikal2561]

May Allah give you jannethul firthouse shayk .U have plenty of knowledge

[@afubu1255]

MaashaALLAH to you..

[@skyslimit3746]

Jazhakallahu khair sheikh.

[@mkansar1]

Masha Allah, great series as always Dr Yasir Qadhi. My 10 year old daughter asked me the question of eternality of Jahannam and it's punishment. Very difficult to explain. So if explain the second position, I think it will give comfort to her. Really like the academic discussion rather than our old school emotional talk what we were listening when we were young. May Allah bless us as the inhabitants of Jannah, Al Firdous

[@rasmaansari8435]

JazakAllah Khair shaykh

[@bakary333]

May Allah forgive us all ameen

[@readwithsani3781]

Just love the recitation at the start❤

[@rush19463]

Mashaa Allah

[@fathimashanaz4412]

Assalamu alaikkum Jazakallah khair Sheikh

[@pq2552]

Allama Iqbal♥️♥️ the man who felt the pain of the ummah so strongly that his words, to this day can move you to feel that pain. The love drips from his words for Allah and His messanger pbuh. The man who taught me how to talk to Allah without formalities, the man who was one of the biggest reasons I am free today! Jazakallah♥️ you are my hero, and I look foreward to the day I will get to see you in Jannah In Sha Allah in the company of your beloved Prophet (pbuh)♥️♥️

[@theimprovist4158]

Jazakallah khair Sheick, much love

[@azraa7110]

Salaam from Nottingham Uk

[@mishkatahmadchowdhury1513]

Subhanallah Alhamdulillah La ilaha illallahu Allahu Akbar🌸 La hawala wa la quwwata illa billah🌸 Subhanallahi Wa Bihamdihi Subhanallahil Azim🌸 Sallallahu Ala Rasulihi Wa Sallam🌸

[@usmanhannan5675]

In Taimiyyah's analysis is definitely food for thought, and your analysis on Yajuj and Majuj is also food for thought, so long our ummah in general wakes up and learns to churn some vigorous thoughts. Without being apologetic and being on the watch for critics' harsh labeling, I wish you could expand on these ideas more rigorously and unabashedly moving forward.

[@imadshammaa]

Excellent lecture, Jazak Allah Khair أَلَا يَعْلَمُ مَنْ خَلَقَ وَهُوَ اللَّطِيفُ الْخَبِيرُ Should He not know,- He that created? and He is the One that understands the finest mysteries (and) is well-acquainted (with them).

[@Ahmed-vw3iw]

Brother , as a revert will my parents go to hell eternally? They don't follow any religion and hence don't associate any partners. They are good to me and fine with me being a muslim.. I am constantly disturbed of the fact of them landing up in hell as anyone would do. Allah swt declared his Mercy overcomes his anger, so would it make sense for eternal punishment. Even a mother or father would not punish their children for eternity if they have caused them lot of harm and troubled them no matter how angry they are, that too in a unimaginably terrible place like hell. As a muslim if I enter jannah InshaAllah, can I be at peace with my self seeing my own family suffering in eternity? I know those who reject Allah swt deserved to be punished badly , however Allah punishing them eternally doesn't seem to match the quality of His Mercy..and why would Allah say in Quran unless he wills for hell.

[@greaseTalk]

The topic presented by Dr Yasir is a... Very advanced one, and requires several bits of knowledge pieced together. I hear what Ibn Teymmiya (RTA) is saying. It's not necessarily a concrete belief, but rather a presentation of something POSSIBLE, which is consistent with our Islamic knowledge of Allah. As for me personally, I will take the verses of the Quran at face value. ME PERSONALLY, I'm not even a student of knowledge, just a Muslim trying to find his way

[@AyshaKhanam]

Hi may Allah bless you

[@RijHetWijst]

Interesting, I am an Ashari myself but I think thst Ibn taymiyyah made great points. But if there is an ijma then you should stick with the ijma. If there is really no ijma then he had made great points rahimahullah

[@shahmir342]

Assalamualaikum Sheikh! I'm a big fan of your work, and I pray for the acceptance of your Jihad. I wanted to point out that the Ayat has a missing Kaf in the description. Keep up the good work Inn Shaa Allah

[@shifeq9770]

I believe position of ibn taymyya makes sense, Allah is not obliged to keep hell forever, Its His wish, His mercy prevails over wrath, it will exist as long as Allah wills. Allah knows best.

[@mohamedbinishaq3169]

It makes sense but Allah never said that disbeliever will go to heaven and he did say they will be in hell forever but added the word as your lord wills so who knows what will happen to them it doesn't effect us we want jannah al firdous let's keep our goals high and push our selves a litttle more inshallah

[@aliwaqar6004]

wa alaykumasssalam wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuh

[@tarrazzz]

I believe Ibn Taymiyyah was right as I always remember what Allah says, "My Mercy Prevails Over My Wrath! "

[@mrperfect9291]

Allah has forbidden injustice to himself

[@mrperfect9291]

Only mercy in this life and after that either reward or punishment

[@alib7489]

33:55 Sheikh shows a great sense of humour Mashaa Allah. These refutation kids are becoming so silly they deserve to be mocked!

[@fahimrahman6658]

It would be very helpful if the quranic verse numbers are shown in subtitles or included in the description section.

[@Kimeikus]

I remember you also brought up a narration about Hell eating itself and how certain pathways are opened so that Hell has more room to breathe. It could be that there’s a self-destruction or after certain ages.

[@dhuss14]

I hope so

[@SpaceCadetIsabella]

On this topic... it shouldn't be something that a Muslim dwells over. Our focus should be on Jannah. Spending the equivalent of one second, one day, one week or one million years in Jahannam is never something that a Muslim wants to experience. The difference of opinion on whether Jahannam is for eternity seems irrelevant - this is a topic that a person should say "Allah (swt) knows best" and leave it at that. Also - In the lecture it was stated that the opinion of Jahannam not being for eternity might save a person's Iman - however it could also do the opposite (i.e. a sinful person may continue to be sinful because they believe their sins are too much and that person may have a false 'sense of security' because shaitan whispers to them that even if they are sent to Jahannam, Jahannam will eventually cease so in the end their punishment will stop. Hence they can continue being sinful and not make changes in their life. Shaitan will use anything to deceive people so talking about this topic doesn't seem helpful. Allah (swt) knows best.

[@SpaceCadetIsabella]

@Najma Khan but if this notion is not true then a person would be led into thinking it is when it is not, hence it's better to say "Allah (swt) knows best" and leave it there. An anti-islamist person will come up with all sorts of reasons why Islam is "like this and not like that" but they are anti-Islam, hence anti Allah (swt) hence, anti prophet Muhammad (saw)... this is not someone that needs to be appeased. An anti-islamist person will most likely say that any person going to Hell proves Allah (swt) is not merciful and so on and so forth. We don't question Allah's (swt) mercy so why question his wrath when he gave mankind all that we have and generations upon generation of people have completely and totally disrespected Allah (swt) and mankind has been given warning after warning. Islam and the Qur’an teaches us how abundant the mercy of Allah (swt) is and even then we have no real comprehension of it. It really is clear. If a person chooses to focus on "this doesn't make Allah (swt) merciful and that doesn't make Allah (swt) merciful", it's deception (either by themselves or by shaitan) because Allah (swt) is The Most Merciful. A person only needs to read the Qur’an to see this and the Qur’an is readily available.

[@parkerflop]

@Najma Khan I don't care if they find it problematic, fear of eternal hell forced me to discover that Islam was true and so it helped me. Also the ayat are clear its forever

[@nonameddog]

This is well said

[@muslimtorchbearer6146]

Read Sura HUD chapter 11 verse 108. The same thing also applies to Jannah. Jannah can also be temporary and cease to exist if Allah wants. Verily Allah can do whatever he intends to do. So bringing up the verse 107 to somewhat claim that Jahannam is temporary and Jahannam itself will cease to exist after a period of time is totally and foolishly out of context. Because this same thing can also be applied to Jannah. May Allah have mercy on our beloved Shaykh Ibn Taymiah. May Allah also have mercy on us. May Allah give us guidance and bless us with beneficial knowledge. Allahuma Amin

[@muslimtorchbearer6146]

It is strange that a group of scholars are of the view that Hell will cease to exist, based on false arguments which go against what is indicated by the Qur’aan and Sunnah, and they misinterpreted the meanings of the Qur’aan and Sunnah and said that the words “dwell therein forever” mean for as long as it exists. How can this be correct? If they are to dwell therein forever, that means that Hell itself must last forever, as they will be in it. If a person is to dwell in some place forever, then the place where he will be must last forever as well, because if that place will cease to exist then he cannot dwell forever. The verse is very clear, and the arguments which go against the text are to be rejected. This difference of opinion which was narrated from a few scholars is to be rejected, because it goes against the clear text which every believer must believe in. Whoever goes against it because of some argument that he comes up with may be excused before Allaah. But whoever studies the texts of the Qur’aan and Sunnah will know that the view that Hell will last forever is the truth which cannot be ignored Collected from islamqa.info

[@parkerflop]

@@muslimtorchbearer6146 yeah those arguments are false. there are plenty of ayat saying disbelievers wont be allowed to die or allowed the torment to lighten on them or be brought out of hell or ever forgiven and He describes their torment as adhaabal khuld and their place as daaralkhul

[@tanveer5655]

There is still a difference. After Allah swt saying whatever he intends, he adds an everlasting giving without end, when describing jannah. But that isn't the case with jahannum. The description of jahnnam rnds with whatever your lord wills.

[@abdel-qudus1143]

Jakaza Allah. I add as a conclusion what the Imam Anas Lala wrote in his good article on this subject (found on a the site maison-islam) : « Neither Ibn Taymiyya nor Ibn ul-Qayyim said that the Fire of Gehenna will have an end: Ibn Taymiyya contented himself with recounting 2 opinions, and showing that the second opinion remains different from that of Jahm ibn Safwân. Ibn ul-Qayyim, for his part, clearly expressed a tawaqquf. It would be very unfair for us to start assigning them something different from what they actually said. » (His article is very long and clearly detail on this subject for those who can read arabic)

[@lightspeed2014]

I just wish to be saved from Jahannam, may Allah forgive us All

[@mouhamadoutaffa5064]

Mashaa Allah "refutations can hold until I finish quoting"😂 😂...no refutations insha Allah 🤗

[@rameezahamed]

That's why he is special in taking up things diplomatically

[@TheMiz_0]

The number of jannah being 39 and jahannam 38. Allah does not make mistakes or contradictions. Although it may serve many things but is definitely proof Allah's mercy over extends his anger. Same as Gates of hell And Gates of jannah

[@abdulazizmaulvi3602]

Had I al Arwaah has been translated into urdu by Khurshud Anwar Nadwi and is published in Hydrabad I ndua...

[@learnAnythingCool]

Salam alaykum sheik, pls I want to ask a question that caused a little issue in my community. I watched all your videos especially on the end time, so you mentioned in the first video of life in barzakh that pharaoh is of father and son pair, pls is there an evidence that I can use to prove this to others. Jazakallahu khairan

[@Kimeikus]

There is an interesting verse where the disbelievers ask Allah if there is a way out. He tells them why they ended up in hell and then says that the judgment only belongs to Him without mentioning that they will be there forever.

[@parkerflop]

The Quran also says hell itself is eternal not just its inhabitants. So "it" will be forever فَذُوقُوا بِمَا نَسِيتُمْ لِقَاءَ يَوْمِكُمْ هَٰذَا إِنَّا نَسِينَاكُمْ ۖ وَذُوقُوا عَذَابَ الْخُلْدِ بِمَا كُنتُمْ تَعْمَلُونَ So taste [punishment] because you forgot the meeting of this, your Day; indeed, We have [accordingly] forgotten you. And taste the punishment of eternity for what you used to do." ذَٰلِكَ جَزَاءُ أَعْدَاءِ اللَّهِ النَّارُ ۖ لَهُمْ فِيهَا دَارُ الْخُلْدِ ۖ جَزَاءً بِمَا كَانُوا بِآيَاتِنَا يَجْحَدُونَ That is the recompense of the enemies of Allah - the Fire. For them therein is the home of eternity as recompense for what they, of Our verses, were rejecting.

[@windowview8240]

I believe Ibn Arabi held that opinion too

[@aktcdc]

25:20 is where the topic of ibn Taymiyya starts

[@ihdinashirotolmustaqiim4741]

Jazakallah khoir

[@mrperfect9291]

Allah has forbidden injustice to himself

[@Gamafoi1]

Dr yasir Qadhi please I have question about Wahed Investment,I watch all your videos about it and I didn’t get my answer,please how can I get contact with you

[@nufailanoon]

*Copy his email from his Facebook and than send a message from gmail* That is what I do

[@Gamafoi1]

@@nufailanoon thank u brother

[@bennymuhammad2988]

👍👌✌️

[@BI10000]

Could someone please tell me the name of the Quran reciter in the beginning of the video? If u do and i listen more u get hasanat inshallah 😊😊

[@neohybridkai]

It's in the description, qari is Sajjad Gul

[@KASERQARNashaytaan]

IF jahnam is not eternal -> so firawn for example will eventually leave jahnam? -> if so, where to? jannah? or araaf? Obviously this is a very deep issue

[@wanderingsoul2758]

What is ibn al qayyims book is called

[@stoneraristotle683]

I think Shaikh al Islam understood that torchering people for eternity contradict with notion the all merciful God. How can God claims to love humans more than 100 mothers yet condemns them in hell for forever ? Punishment for the sake of punishment without giving people opportunity or hope for reforms is torchering of worst kind. Anyone with emphaty will understand why Shaikh al Islam had this position. But as Qur'an explicitly mentioned that hell is eternal so he could not openly disagree with. Yet it's very brave of Ibn e Taimiya to say this even in Hush Hush voice.

[@dhuss14]

It seems if I get past one hurdle on my life, in terms of extremely depressing thoughts, there is a new wave, if you like, of demotivation and sadness, and right now, it is the eternal nature of Hell. How can I be expected to believe, with my limited knowledge that Allah is indeed the most merciful if he will cause people to be eternally humiliated, burnt, tortured, mocked and immersed in regret and grief, no matter what they have done. Yes, there is no denial from me that there are people who deserve punishment and justice should be served for the people who have been oppressed, yes evil individuals who have done evil things do exist, no doubt, but eternal, never ending punishment seems like a whole, different level of cruelty. By the way, there is no doubt in my mind, apart from the pathetic, unimportant 'waswas' that Islam is the truth from Allah, too many things just seem to 'click', I believe this to be the truth, which is a reason as to why I cannot possibly justify or understand eternal hell. Allah can see me typing this, so Allah please, forgive me for saying this, but I would really love there to be justice, but not eternal humiliation and regret.

[@Abdullah21038]

​@@dhuss14but your critera for judging what an appropriate punishment is appears to have no proof, its just a claim, like how different moral groups have their own criterions for judging what is a worthy punishment, even if you emotionally feel resistant, at least with reason it can be pretty easily established that this is at least logically possible in being totally aligned with Justice, the issue with us is that perhaps Without realising it we conflate justice with well being or justice as resulting in our overall benefit when in truth justice can and has required negative emotions, the eternality of the experience of pain in varying forms, what makes someone worthy of it, it is a life lived in unjustified misguidance and with no belief although the sahabah have said that Allah could put all in Jannah or all in a Hell and it wouldn't contradict his Justice, Mercy is not something identical to Justice, any mercy or wrath shown is in the scope of what justice allows, but the degree of mercy or wrath shown is optional and not necessary and there is no contradiction in reason for this, If I said I think there's a contradiction between a wrathful Lord and him offering me Jannah, you would reply well Allah isn't compelled neither obliged to only be wrathful in fact he has other attributes such as mercy which makes possible something eternally merciful in nature such as Jannah, the criterion to judge the worthiness of a crime is known to Allah and can simply be this that living a life of unjustified evil, disbelief and shirk is by its very nature worthy of eternality of Hell though it wouldn't contradict his Justice to take it out for he has this permissibility and Authority to do so, what I am simply trying to establish is that in reason there is no contradiction in this, also saying his Mercy prevails over His Wrath can be interpreted with regards to His Patience and Mercy he shows in the Dunya restraining His Wrath and even in the hereafter by him not exercising as much wrath as he could and excericing more mercy than he is obliged by whats Just

[@mrperfect9291]

Both are eternal and punishment also be eternal

[@maganhassan2627]

MashaAllah again great lecture I love how you go into detail like saying tangents it's interesting In the end only Allah decides who goes to jannah & jahannam & if he decides to bring people out from jahannam he can he has the power Anyways I am a little confused by that verse from surah hud what does Allah mean when he says people will remain in jahannam as long as there are the heavens & earth just that part of the verse if you can answer sheikh or any knowledgable person of Islam can instead??

[@mrperfect9291]

They go into jahannam before judgement day or otherwise

[@mrperfect9291]

See hell is eternal and surah hud is talking about the day of judgement day after that the inhabitants remain there in forever

[@maganhassan2627]

@@mrperfect9291 so people could go straight to jahannum before day of judgement after they die or is this after judgement day? Still confused sorry

[@mrperfect9291]

@@maganhassan2627 who are Rebel will go to hell directly

[@mrperfect9291]

I abuse Allah by bad and ugly words despite knowing Allah is true god would not I deserve eternal torment

[@danh4435]

So maybe they will be punished for so long that it will feel like eternity?

[@tiktokasylum5186]

What should one face who commits a crime against a eternal one?

[@techutopiareviews]

A CLARIFICATION and CORRECTION: Ibn Taymiyya and Ibn Qayyim did NOT say that Hell is temporar. That was a slander against them. In their own books they always say its eternal. Ibn taymyiya: Dar at taarud, volume 2, page 358: وقال أهل الإسلام جميعاً: ليس للجنة والنار آخر، وإنهما لا تزالان باقيتين، وكذلك أهل الجنة لا يزالون في الجنة يتنعمون، وأهل النار في النار يعذبون، ليس لذلك آخر And all the people of Islam said: There is no end to Heaven and Hell, and they are still there. Likewise, the people of Paradise are still enjoying in Paradise, and the people of Hell are in Hell being tormented, and there is no end to that Ibn Taymiyya also says in his books (مجموع الفتاوى)) (18/307)؛ ((بيان تلبيس الجهمية)) (1/581 ‏وقد اتفق سلف الأمة وأئمتها وسائر أهل السنة والجماعة على أن من المخلوقات ما لا يعدم ولا ينفى بالكلية، كالجنة والنار والعرش The salaf and its imams and ahlu sunnah wal jamaah agree, that some creation like the Arsh, jannah, and Hell will never cease to exist Ibn Taymiyya authored a book refuting those who claim that Hell is temporar The book is called: الرد على من قال بفناء الجنة والنار There is no evidence that Ibn Taymiyya hold that view. Assuming he did, he obviously retracted it, since in every single book he says that Hell is eternal like Paradise The scholar Ibn Hazm wrote a book where he gathered issues where there is ijmaa' (consensus) of Islamic scholars. Ibn Taymiyya wrote a commentary on it and he criticised some mistakes of Ibn Hazm, because there actually was a difference of opinion in some issues. But, ibn Hazm claims there is consensus that Hell is eternal and Ibn Taymiyya NEVER critices Ibn Hazm for that. So, Ibn Taymiyya clearly did believe that Hell is eternal, like all other Islamic scholars. This is why u should learn Islam from Islamic scholars, NOT from western academics

[@dhuss14]

You're a Najdi coper. You're coping. It's okay, relax. Najdi parrot 🦜

[@techutopiareviews]

@@dhuss14 poor u

[@Maxwell_V]

​@@techutopiareviews can you please give me the book name or pdf link so we can read further ? Also yea I agree, Islam should be learnt by books of Prophet PBUH (hadith) first, then by the companions and their students and then early scholars and fiqh. Recent generation can have a slight modification in opinions due to modern era or otherwise- however we should not believe everything and should definitely verify InshaAllah

[@Pain-jw3uu]

I just read the book of Ibn al Qayyim. It's exactly like if not more than what sheikh Yasir said. You just coping bro

[@djibrilr6s]

​@@dhuss14answering well written arguments with proofs by insulting the person May Allah forgive you

[@danishbro3777]

Ibn Al-Qayyim does not mention "Allah alaa kulli shayin qadeer", rather he says that his opinion end with Allahs words: إن ربك فعال لما يريد Allah certainly does what He wants to (roughly translated).

[@hammadallana3606]

Shaykh, with all due respect please also let us know where Allah SWT will put those people of hell fire? Is there any place other than Jannat and Jahannum? Where the children of non-believers will be destined to? Please reply here, thank you in advance.

[@zxiyo5857]

Why would the children of disbelievers go to Hell?

[@zxiyo5857]

@@musti12312 Someone is free of sin till puberty so them going to hell makes no sense. 2. Pretty sure theres a verse that says some1 will only enter hell when he himself knows he deserves it.

[@adoontiialle8270]

To be honest i like the opinion of ibnu tiamiyah that janahham is not eternal becouse allahs mercy will always overcome Allah’s anger. And Allah know best.

[@MohamedMohamed-vy6xe]

So are we just going to ignore all the verses where Allah says it's forever? May Allah have mercy on ibn taymiyah but he is wrong on this one

[@imranamalik8216]

my question is that when hell will perish then why we struggle so much to achieve jannah. why to strive?

[@rayhanhkhan]

If we had to buy a moment in Jannah with a lifetime of misery, it would still be an amazing deal! And if we had to go through just a moment in hell to be able to enjoy our while life on this Earth to the fullest, it would be a horrible price to pay. No matter what we go through we cannot possibly earn Jannah through our own deeds. Jannah is way more valuable than all of your good deeds and efforts. It is only out of Allah's infinite Rahmah that we can hope to get into Jannah. We don't even want to be in Jahannam for a second! We cannot even imagine what its like! The least punishment in Jahannam is worse than the worst pain you have ever experienced! Jannah is worth all the hardship we go through and more! Be ambitious! Give it your best! Don't settle for less! Be patient! Allah is with the patient! May Allah strengthen us and grant us Jannat-ul-firdaus! ❤️

[@parkerflop]

@Mohamed Ismail theres infinite difference between that and fearing hell forever, which is what Allah clearly warns of

[@tiktokasylum5186]

@@furqan2485 those minor scholars clearly contradicted the clear cut statement of Allah...

[@maganhassan2627]

I'm curious & want to clarify so it's possible if I end up in jahannam I can leave it in sha Allah especially if Allah is merciful to me?? I hear the hadith how Allah frees the people of jahannam during Ramadan so does that mean it's possible for people to not stay in jahannam forever technically?? You gave the verses yourself where if Allah wills he can remove people from jahannam I pray to Allah I don't end up in jahannam ameen!

[@rianamohamed300]

If u are Muslim, u do not enter the main jahannam. U are on the perifories of jahannam. But focus on jannah, and ask for the highest of it. Allah swt is Ghafoorur Raheem and with sincere tauba n supplication, and doing good, by His grace u can enter the highest jannah ameen.

[@zxiyo5857]

@@rianamohamed300 can u explain further about “perifories” ? Tyvm

[@rianamohamed300]

@@zxiyo5857 watch the series, he explains it so well. The sheikh says that muslims do not enter the main jahannam, they are on the outskirts of jahannam. Also, pls do not be depressed, find ur purpose in life n u will be happy, or at least content.

[@zxiyo5857]

@@rianamohamed300 Ty for the answer. I found my purpose in life already :)

[@mohammednihad3529]

@@zxiyo5857 good for you man wish you the best inshallah 💯💯

[@24xv555]

Refutations can wait after hahaha

[@Adrian-yf1zg]

The truth is humans can not understand eternality, nor do we fully comprehend time. Geological timescales are hard to understand, cosmic timescales are even harder to imagine... Let alone forever and ever.... If a time limit was given for hell, it would be rendered useless when compared to eternality. For example everything would be considered insignifcant if punishment for a crime was a million years in fire but if they were to put in heaven for eternality after that time.... It would not serve as a warning as humans will look at things relatively ... A million years are just a tiny spec when compared to eternality..... There is great wisdom in not figjting hard for the ibn al qayyim position... As people will not heed the warnings and slack.... As they will have more emphasis on HOPE rather than FEAR

[@saracentiano]

@Cheers To nothing Hey you mannerless indecent human being. Stop calling YQ stupid. You are even less significant than a mosquito when it comes to his knowledge. Go and learn adab and manners. Is the way you talk about elders in your family?

[@ahmedsattar1359]

He is doing a good job i just hope he doesn't say anything about Saudi Arabia otherwise no umrah or hajj. Bannnnnn

[@tiktokasylum5186]

Lol 😂

[@harissohail8122]

16:05

[@ABDULRHEEM-kr1kr]

Convey message of Islam to all people of the world and to everyone who will come also convey message of Islam to all world leaders

[@tiktokasylum5186]

Yes those who deny Allah and associate partners with him will be in hell fire eternal because the one they committed a crime against us eternal... what punishment should someone who murders a child face? 5 years 10 years ext. ask yourself what punishment should someone who commits a crime against Allah face?

[@mokkaddesali6466]

The title of lecture is misleading. There is absolutely nothing about Jannah.Topics as where Jahnaam is permanent or not is redundant.

[@mouhamadoutaffa5064]

If there is no a permanent hell Where will the devil ( Ibleess) go?

[@bellah09]

Interesting Q?...I guess He won't exist anymore with his minions...lucky guy!

[@mouhamadoutaffa5064]

@@bellah09 yes and Allah knows best

[@AlMadzhar]

One of the consequence of this opinion that Jahannam may end is that its inhabitants will cease to exist as well. Can't back this with evidence right now, but I read this somewhere most probably the Here after series by Shaykh Sulayman al Ashqar published by Darus Salam. Again not sure though.

[@mohamedbinishaq3169]

Only Allah knows and Allah is gonna be fair with them

[@smurfanb348]

brace yourselves for the refutations lol

[@adnanahmed9044]

10:43 its jahannam

[@sulaimanahmed6566]

shaykul islam yasir qadhi

[@Ephesians--zs6pv]

who wants to have a debate?

[@mohamedbinishaq3169]

About what

[@sirsanitynow6157]

This is a lot of math

[@abdellahafkir]

It is well known that this opinion of Ibn Taymiyya is not authenticated. The same is to be said about Ibn Qayyim. رحمهما الله. That’s something that Yasir Qadhi misses, you call out opinions but don’t explain the authenticity of the chain... ⛓

[@asadbaig2105]

He literally mentioned how Salafis try to claim the chain is inauthentic but how all of that is complete and utter nonsense. Watch the video next time lol. The only people who deny that ibn Taymiyyah held this view are Salafis trying to whitewash history.

[@TechBoxHD1]

@@asadbaig2105 how do you know it’s complete and utter nonsense? But regardless even it isnt, there are various places where he states the hellfire is eternal. As yasir qadhi stated it is not a definitive position of his either and ibn qayyim stated Allah knows best in one his works. Maybe you should rewatch this video. P.s I’m not a Wahhabi/salafi

[@dhuss14]

Crybaby Salafi. The camera of the Ummah. Cope.

[@nabezadehs]

No one touched on the view of Allama Muhammed iqbal, it makes me wonder where did this guy get this ideas about jannah and jahannam existing only on our minds. Tbh its left me curious and confused, I want to know more about this

[@saracentiano]

@@furqan2485 Sorry to ask but genuine question. What did Allama Iqbal believe? I respect and admire him but his is not an aalim per se right?

[@saracentiano]

@@furqan2485 That was Dr Israr Ahmed bro. Thank you so much. Interesting.