The Future Of Palestine And Israel

[@fuckbankers]

There is no place for settler colonialism in the modern world.

[@greenmc8]

There never was.

[@davidradovsky5354]

Then the Arabs better get off my land.

[@QuilishWammy]

Yet, you pay taxes to a country that is spearheading the 'settler colonialism' all around the world 😉

[@MikeMW87]

yes there is

[@jenkscx3766]

@@MikeMW87explain yourself don’t just say the opposite

[@londontrotter7481]

What a beautiful soul Mr Pappe is

[@jake751]

A man of wise words 👏

[@gamingguy8595]

Yes jonathan greenblader will pappe is antisemitism lol what a joke.

[@JackAShepherd]

Pappe peed on my sofa!

[@AWSOM817]

There was Palestinian Jews before the Zionism and there always would be Palestinian Jews after.

[@LJones-tx6eg]

As long as they don't have synagogues and pay a religious tax and live as sub human...that is all that is allowed in Islam nations.

[@FaiezCader]

Palestinians are the original Jews who reverted to Islam and Christianity

[@TonyMidyett]

​@@FaiezCader*converted, not reverted

[@gamingguy8595]

Jews are forbidden to have land aka sovereignty state thats why God said u will be in exile. Neutrai karta already said that and they are jews.

[@FaiezCader]

@@TonyMidyett reverted if it's to do with Islam

[@retrofedora7061]

Indeed. i3roel is falling apart. Apartheid is unsustainable, oppression & military aggression are unacceptable. If i3roel keeps thinking they can commit warcrimes with impunity forever, their future will not end well.

[@andresrojas7924]

Israel is falling apart but not Gaza? 😂

[@naomideguyane]

IIS@@andresrojas7924 He is absolutely right! Israel IS falling apart economically! And many people are leaving! As Prof Pappé says : "the Zionist Project is falling apart."

[@bendyrland7213]

I just don't see how it's sustainable long term.

[@solinvictus5349]

​@@andresrojas7924Gaza could have been as successful as UAE if given the chance to exploit its natural resources and granted sovereignty on its lands.

[@eyedownload]

@@andresrojas7924 Already it is not going well. The first signs the bully veneer was peeling was when Israel bombed the Iranian Embassy to steer consequences away from their own agenda - but Iran was clever and played Israel to the tee (and cost them an estimated billion lol). The US then began wavering as they couldn't sacrifice their equilibrium with Iran in order to protect bases there, a little performative hand wringing by Jo about casualties was all he could muster and then more shipments of 2000 pound bombs, but all the same more distance is growing and nothing has gone well for Israel since. The atrocious number of slaughtered and maimed Palestinians does not mean any kind of victory. The Palestinians are RESOLVED to be free. Period. Israel will lose, and now, as an official pariah state.

[@MaryDeanDotCom]

You guys are performing a real service to humanity by looking to the future in this way. Michael Brooks is beaming with pride.

[@QuilishWammy]

They are performing a 'real service' to Israel, by convincing people to _vote for Biden_ .

[@virgil4marvolo5crowl]

If someone had the time to take a look at some of their videos way before oct 7th , they would have noticed the pure racism. Even within the society itself.

[@custybox1569]

Yes but these Zionists will keep pushing their propaganda. No hope in showing them facts. They're literally brainwashed.

[@jeffreywilheim5970]

Yes there's intense antisemitic racism in "Palestinian" society.

[@imjamesiam]

I’m starting to think that Israel is not the “good guy.”

[@oliveoil5789]

And you would be 💯 spot on. Simply residing in the Holy Land does not make a person “good”.

[@Brandon-ne3xz]

It's a tragedy that the world could not fix that issue yet. Even in 1948, Abdul Razek Azzam Pasha (Secretary-General of the League of Arab States) proposed to UN: "the only fair and just solution to the problem of Palestine is the creation of United State of Palestine based upon the democratic principles which will enable all its inhabitants to enjoy equality before the law, and which would guarantee to all minorities the safeguards provided for in all democratic constitutional States affording at the same time full protection and free access to Holy Places". Maybe we could replace "United State of Palestine" to " United State of Israel and Palestine" or "United State of Palestine and Israel". Why is nobody discussing about that idea? I can't blame the Arabs or Palestinians.

[@Brandon-ne3xz]

@@sh25098 No. League of Nations were replaced by the UN in 1946. UN divided the land by 45:55 to Palestine:Israel. But Israel did not respect that partition and keep grabbing more lands. In 1922, The League of Nations formalized the British rule in Palestine. The second clause of the British mandate document approved by the League of Nations, stipulated: “The British mandate shall be responsible for placing the country under conditions that will secure the establishment of the Jewish homeland.” It did not mention how much land and never gave the whole land to the Jewish people. Moreover, Palestinians were living in the area before the British mandate. And British are not the owner of Palestine and does not have the authority to expel Palestinians from their land or award Palestinian land to somebody else.

[@jewels11189]

Orthodox Jews are the good guy Zionist... are dangerous in many ways

[@Brandon-ne3xz]

@@sh25098 The Balford declaration did not specify the intended boundaries of Palestine. In 1921, Winston Churchill commented that not all of Palestine would become the Jewish National Home.

[@MichaelDurant-vz1bb]

Love + justice to one + all

[@frndlystrangr]

Empathy is not words. It's much deeper than that! At times, it's gut-wrenching because you feel what another person feels and is going through as if you are experiencing their pain and suffering. Netanyahu has no empathy, not even for the Israel hostages, let alone any of the hostages. He is the wrong leader for Israel!

[@AlmaNavas-y5i]

Totally agree, Netanyahu is a selfish man and he plays with Israel security and wellbeing with his neighbors The Palestians

[@maazkalim]

FINALLY...! 👍🏾👍🏾👍🏾 Somebody who realises what a hardwork `empathy`, instead of the.. ...Overrated, and autoneurotic trait of `sympathy` which idiot Ms Emma tried to regurgitate. Good on Mr Matt to reassert himself by pushing back on that! 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾

[@simonsteen-andersen3181]

Empathy is the real superpower and the driving force for tomorrow's big changes which will ensure that this atrocious injustice is brought to an end!

[@23ofSeptember]

Gaza and the Palestinians there and in the West Bank need security.

[@andresrojas7924]

Lol there's no security from islamists.

[@alexcampbell4297]

What are you on about?​@@nebwachamp

[@junebrilly5302]

​@@nebwachamptroll, Troll. TROLL ALERT

[@abubaytnighan6480]

@@nebwachampPale3tinians lived there long before islam

[@jake751]

​@@nebwachamp🥱🥱🥱

[@karlschmidt9573]

I used to report those Isreal tourism ads as "offensive" when we still saw them.

[@jake751]

Imagine anyone wanting to book a holiday in Israel now. It will be a pariah state forever.

[@52flyingbicycles]

It would be deeply ironic for them to still be running tourism ads. “Come to Israel despite the massive conflict in Gaza, it’s completely safe here… uh uh uh I mean every single person in Israel is at imminent risk of being nuked by Hamas and we need billions of dollars more weapons and unconditional diplomatic support! Yeah that’s right! But still come visit we need the money 😇”

[@Octoberfurst]

Funny that you said that. I was doing the same thing ever since the war on Gaza began! Every visit Israel ad I got I would report it as inappropriate.

[@TeamGxxS]

@@jake751 tourism is for the (poor people) who no longer matter. The ones who do matter are bidding on Israel's new beach front properties and offshore gas reserves.

[@Travisl400]

Name 3 differences between the establishment of israel and the establishment of austrailia, america and canada without refrencing any religous text? I asked this to a zionist and he was pretty stumped

[@andresrojas7924]

1. These three countries gained their independence by stopped being colonies of the British while Israel didn't gain their independence from anyone lol 2. Israel wasn't really a colony. They were immigrants that bought a bunch of land. In fact the Arabs born there (the people you call Palestinian) never owned more than 2% of the land. Arab investors owned like 10 times more than Arab born there (the ppl you call "palestinian"). For Israel to be a "colony" they should have answered to another country and that was never the case. 3. First limits came in with a partition. Nothing like the US, Australia or Canada. Seriously do you even think before talking? Plus if your point is that Israel is similar to the US or Australia are you trying to say Israel is an illegitimate country? Lmao

[@geraltrivia6148]

@@andresrojas7924 Sure dude, sure; Britain had nothing to do with Zionists 'moving' to Palestine. Israel doesn't celebrate Britain giving them Israel every May, and they certainly don't call it Independence Day. The Nakba and all of the massacres were just legitimate land purchases and the brand new Israeli government had no need whatsoever to immediately declare it illegal for the indigenous populace to sue or prosecute them for taking that land that the locals didn't even own any way. Palestinians who hold onto their house keys in the hopes of returning home, actually mean that they hope they can return their landlord's key to them one day. The Zionist movement never proposed to colonize the Middle East on behalf of Britain, never called itself a colony, and no Israeli spokesperson has ever admitted that Israel is following the colonialism playbook written by Britain, right down to it's handling of the indigenous 'problem' by dividing the populace onto shrinking reservations./s.

[@ZER0--]

@@andresrojas7924 Israel are losing, and losing badly.

[@andresrojas7924]

@@ZER0-- losing what? Does it look like they are losing? They have eliminated any hope for islamists to gain a millimeter of land beyond of what was Gaza at this pt. How are they losing?

[@uzaukee]

@@andresrojas7924 The Zionists immigrants were Europeans who colonized a land with intent to create a state for Jews in disregard of the people who were already there. Simply having "bought a bunch of land" did not give them the right to do that.

[@tylerhackner9731]

Free Palestine 🇵🇸

[@QuilishWammy]

You're barking up the wrong tree here. The Majority Report repeatedly tells people to _vote for Zionist Joe Biden_ 😉

[@dazzle1933]

From the Islmasits

[@tapioorankiaalto2457]

Anti-Semite! 😂

[@MikeMW87]

I notice you everywone my dear left wing islamofascist

[@blueheartless36]

​@@MikeMW87You can't even write a grammarly correct, complete sentence? lol

[@kami2099]

If Israel went away and they just make it Palestine and Jews lived there as citizens in peace...I will have no problem with that. I honestly don't believe that Israel has a right to exists. They have a right to exists just as stranger has a right to your home.

[@NickyRikki]

Well it exists now, like canada, Australia, Argentina, brazil, south africa etc.... if you dont think israel has a right to exist then that goes for all nations built on colonization. Tough peanuts. Its like arguing whether or not you want a baby to live after its been born. I am Israeli and will never accept being citizen under any other country. Never at the mercy of others again. I support a 2 state solution and keep my country jewish majority.

[@elisawhitman8526]

@@NickyRikki The idea that any country has “a right to exist” is… well, kinda silly. Countries don’t have rights. People do. That aside, your desire to live in a “majority Jewish” nation seems a lot like religious nationalism, or ethno-nationalism. It’s not much different than what the Nazis believed. They wanted their country to be “aryan” and Christian. That was bad, was it not? Moreover, the actions they took to achieve their goal included genocide… which is what the Israeli government & military are currently doing now. History’s greatest atrocities will keep happening over and over as long as people maintain the same toxic ideologies or belief systems that gave rise to them. (Edited to be shorter. My reply was way too damn long. 😅)

[@BamBamGT1]

@@elisawhitman8526 That's simply what indigenous peoples strive for, to have their own country on their ancestral lands. The Arabs are like the nazi's actually, The Arabs once conquered and colonized the Middle East and North Africa, so they feel they should have all that land. That's what this conflict has always been about, the Arab Blut und Boden. And Nazism actually opposed chistianity, they wanted to get rid of it eventually.

[@LJones-tx6eg]

No. Jews can not live with Islam/Arabs. Israel was formed in part because all arab nations in middle east and north africa expelled or killed their Jewish populations. Stop lying

[@LJones-tx6eg]

example: Iraq had 250,000 Jews but when Britain gave the country to Arabs, they expelled the Jews or killed them. There are now 14000 Jews in Iraq. Stop talking nonsense when you don't acknowledge any actual history.

[@_surreal99]

It's disgusting how Britain and Germany get to sit back and just spew garbage scripts when their role in this goes so much deeper.

[@megashot]

Sunaks got blood on his hands.

[@absolutelycitron1580]

Facts

[@willneverstop]

Okay what role do you think Germany and the UK should have right now

[@absolutelycitron1580]

@@willneverstop right now? Boycott divest and sanction 🇮🇱 shut down the embassies and cut off all aid

[@eoinc9511]

I’d love to hear the panels opinions on how every Israeli prime minister has changed their last names 👍

[@shiddykiddy-lp4dz]

Why?

[@eoinc9511]

@@shiddykiddy-lp4dz because it further highlights the Zionist tendency to hijack Judaism for its own purposes. It’s sham-legitimacy.

[@jake751]

​@@shiddykiddy-lp4dzwell why have they changed their last name? 🤔

[@JackAShepherd]

Look Man I'm not a Zionist but I find this notion that Israeli *culture* is fake -- that Israelis are just Europeans who lomged to colonize a brown territory -- to be offensive and historically inaccurate and, most importantly, counterproductive to the cause of Palestinian self-determination. The state of Israel has existed for several generations, so people legitimately *feel* Israeli; they don't speak Yiddish or Polish or Russian... They speak Hebrew. They had nowhere to go back to after the war -- they were not safe living alongside their former non-Jewish neighbors. You can say the Zionist project has failed and that Israel doesn't have the right to exist as an apartheid state *without* rewriting history and erasing a culture.

[@elisawhitman8526]

I’ve heard a lot of people say that Hmas’s goal on Oct. 7th was simply to take hostages & trade them for the release of the thousands of Palestinian hostages that Izrael had abducted, imprisoned, and tortured. But I wonder if Hmas knew that Izrael would respond exactly as it has. I wonder if Hmas knew that Izrael would respond with collective punishment and g-cide, and that this response would mark the beginning of the end of Zionism. I wonder if Hmas knew that the Izraeli government and military would respond by acting like monsters… and then the whole world would finally see them as such. If this was Hmas’s goal on Oct. 7th, then they succeeded. However, the cost of achieving this goal was incredibly high. Tens of thousands of civilians should NOT have to die in order to wake people up to the immorality of land-stealing and settler colonialism. Hundreds of thousands of people should NOT have to starve for the majority of the world to finally acknowledge the egregiousness of apartheid, occupation, oppression, displacement, and racism. (Apologies for the misspellings. They’re a deliberate attempt to avoid deletion.)

[@bendyrland7213]

They knew and they knew the time was now before the Saudis and Israelis normalized relations.

[@jamesquattrone]

So all the civilian death is Hamas’ fault. As many have said all along.

[@absolutelycitron1580]

​@@jamesquattronefault isn't just for one person or organization. At the end of the day, who pulls the triggers? Who drops the 💣s? It is messed up that hmas sacrifices their own civilians and if they intended this reaction then that's vicious but they're extremists, what do you expect? That doesn't make Is rael innocent

[@blueheartless36]

I don't think it's fair to blame Hamas for Israel's choices. Israel chose to be monsters. Hamas did some awful stuff, but their kill and torture count is wayyyyy below Israel and their power is much smaller than Israel. It's like a little kid kicking a bigger kid, then the bigger kid murdering the kickers family and pets in retaliation? It just goes too far. Completely beyond what was necessary. (And yes not the best comparison but it's all I had at the time.)

[@rgghjs9270]

​@@blueheartless36 its a good analogy. The only thing I would add - the bigger kid also has an even bigger, fully grown adult helping him with weapons

[@michaelj3414]

Bystanders become sympathizers. Sympathizers become active.

[@mrschwartzmc]

It's just a thought.

[@michaelj3414]

@@mrschwartzmc Spread the word.

[@yeasminchowdhury6090]

Long life Palestinian InshaAllaah 🇪🇭 😪

[@dalchurb]

Great discussion

[@oddjam]

I agree but I think we need to temper this optimism. Netanyahu and CO are at a place of no return, and that makes them even more reckless and unpredictable than normal. I'm worried things will escalate in ways we cannot imagine... and the horror that's happening now is already unimaginable.

[@absolutelycitron1580]

Fr, things are probably gonna go nuclear once the campaign to create a "greater Israel" begins. They have around 100 in their arsenal, and there are only a dozen or so large cities in between the Nile and the Euphrates

[@hiphopotamus69]

Their plan is definitely to keep this going until Trump is back in office. The Israel offensive hurting Biden at the polls is actually great Netanyahu because he wants want Trump in the white house.

[@jeffreywilheim5970]

Optimism isn't what any decent people feel contemplating the possible destruction of the only democracy in the Middle East.

[@absolutelycitron1580]

@@jeffreywilheim5970 they aren't a democracy buddy. Democracies let everyone vote.

[@zq_77]

I fully support what Ilan Pappe said. One democratic country from the river to the sea. Give it a new name so that no one fight over it. Call it Peaceland or Holyland or whatever. Anyone with a religious ideology such as the zionist movement or hamas have no place in this solution. People are guaranteed their freedom of worship and that's as far as the state should interfere in religious matters.

[@jeffreywilheim5970]

One state between the river and the sea: Israel, the eternal homeland of the Jewish people.

[@ohmanmom3641]

Great job ❤

[@karimaferras9083]

Thank you for the great coverage

[@DrXtoph]

Thanks for this very important coverage! Love your content!

[@ramisaffarini3233]

Thanks!

[@greenmc8]

I don’t see how Israelis can treat Palestinians as equals. They are beyond repair.

[@moj1338]

Yes, I agree. IsNotReal ruling class have kept their citizens ignorant by constantly lying to them, by constantly re-traumatizing them about WWII, and keeping them in fear. So, you are right, the IsNotRraelis are beyond repair.

[@junebrilly5302]

You proud of being a rascist bigot?

[@MelissaLeeNg]

FREE FREE PALESTINE!!

[@QuilishWammy]

You're commenting this on a channel that urges people to *keep voting for Zionist Joe Biden* 😉

[@airtale.p]

Palestinians refused a free palestine 4 times, they just want to kill all jews.

[@charlenegraham1923]

Too bad Branden, as usual, barely got a word in. He always brings new ideas and perspectives to the conversation and never repeats himself or what he's heard many times over elsewhere. That's extremely rare and his brilliance doesn't seem to be appreciated by his co-hosts.

[@warmperson2007]

I can't believe how an intelligent person like Ilan Pappe could seriously think that the one state possibility from the river to the sea with equal votes for all could work. It did not work in Lebanon, nor in Yugoslavia... How on earth could it work in Israel/Palestine. TWO STATES is the only solution !

[@writemeyers]

Thank you for this guys. Once again you've introduced us to important activists and scholars

[@wafaabdullah2172]

The USA and UK governments should never have envisioned a colonial mindset for Israel in a post-racial and pluralistic world. That was the original sin and the consequences are clear to everyone but especially clear to the international Courts. Israel's supporters seem to believe that they can revive colonialism in modern times but this only highlights the heart of retrogressive thinking that has swamped officialdom in the USA and the UK. It is as if the acute racism and barbarism of 19th century western colonialism was never enough. Pushing Israel into accepting a colonial role for itself in the Middle East is unconscionable and unforgivable.

[@jeffreywilheim5970]

As Jews are indigenous to the land of Israel, the USA and UK did not have a "colonial mindset" in supporting Israel. A people can't colonize its own land.

[@wafaabdullah2172]

@@jeffreywilheim5970 The Palestinians are also indigenous to the land so occupying their land and subjecting them to a system of Apartheid and ethnic cleansing would most definitely count as symptomatic of a colonial mindset.

[@wanderer977]

Ay papi!

[@Democratienow]

According to norman finkelstein i believe said recently more than 500thousands israelis dual citizens left israel since the war began, and finkelstein always has real data and facts ❤

[@junebrilly5302]

​@@sh25098yeah, if true are they heading for the illegal Settlements in the West Bank?

[@Snartfoodler]

​@@ArleeStarr what is your reasoning for asserting this though? the definition of "diasporic" absolutely fits when israel is the country you will be most likely to see mizrahi, sephardi, ashkenazi, ethiopians, all in a day. regardless of your feelings on it there is a huge diff between what you probably associate with jewish culture and all of the OTHER things it also includes. how do you think all these different groups formed. of course being jewish was not originated in the US and to say that would be someone's homeland inherently is pretty facetious considering my state has yet to even recognize our largest tribe diaspora is simply a way to assert that you are taking your culture with you somewhere that it was not present previously which if you pick up a history book i think it'll help you understand quickly why the term exists for a LOT of reasons lmao

[@lakunna991]

This conversation is EVERYTHING

[@emeraldkendell1577]

Find the Australian four year old's Birthday party. The child has cupcakes decorated with the Palestinian flag, the Kaffir & Abu Obieda. The 4 year old boy is dressed as his hero & the Bakery/ catering business is ' being looked into by the police '. Resistance is Lawful. As an Australian, 5th generation, non denominational Christian, I say Happy Birthday little one and I pray that he grows into a World exponentially more Truthful and just. So yesterday I was watching Jewish Rabbi's, not the Chabad variety, walking with the funeral multitudes in Iran to honour their President. There they live in peaceful coexistence. Australia has over recent decades given land title of more than 50% of the land mass to Indigenous Aboriginals, mining royalties on their land, National parks we pay to enter and seek permission, educational grants, dedicated institutions, housing, 40 Billion $ annually from the Federal Government, and for example, in my area there are 7 specialist Medical Centres catering to a population of 3,000 and I may not attend nor do I begrudge it. Reconciliation has been a several decades endeavour.

[@aquamatch]

Reconciliation, a beautiful word, nowadays...

[@BamBamGT1]

And in the Middle East the Arab colonizers have been in an ongoing conflict against the existence of an indigenous state for over a 100 years, quite the difference.

[@tumslucks9781]

​@@BamBamGT1 Arab colonisers?? The Palestinians are the descendants of the Canaanites who already inhabited the land long before the Hebrews arrived from Egypt during Exodus! It was the Palestinians who founded the city of Jerusalem which they called Urushalim after their God of dusk! Most 'Israelis' are Ashkenazi European colonizers who are NOT the descendants of the Biblical Israelites whatsoever so have no right to occupy Palestine. Now do you get it?? 🇵🇸 ✌️ 🇵🇸 ✌️ 🇵🇸 ✌️ 🇵🇸 ✌️ 🇵🇸 ✌️ 🇵🇸 ✌️ 🇵🇸

[@JackAShepherd]

Jews and Muslims live in peaceful coexistence in *IRAN*??? You named one dude who attended the president's funeral... How many other Jews do you think there are in Iran today? And what, pray tell, happened to the substantial minority of Persian Jews that lived there before the Revolution...???

[@AgitpropPsyop]

One state is the only choice… Anything else is more of what we already have

[@ebtisamzaidan7576]

Israel isn't only occupying Palestine they also occupy the US and UK governments.

[@ebtisamzaidan7576]

Israel isn't only occupying Palestine they also occupy the US and UK governments.

[@ebtisamzaidan7576]

Israel isn't only occupying Palestine they also occupy the US and UK governments.

[@andresrojas7924]

Lol that will not happen

[@MsZeitgeist85]

2 state solution > One state solution. The one state arguments are laughable.

[@tauseefhassan7796]

One law from the rivber to the sea. But lsrael is scared of 2 things: truth and justice - the 2 things that happen to make up the foundation of the Torah. “There is nothing Jewish about the Jewish state.”- Rabbi Yaakov Shapiro.

[@samih96]

Thanks! Love you guys I hope this video goes viral. I hope you can all visit my former family home one day in AlQuds in a Free Palestine.

[@tomking7367]

"The Palestinian Authority was “granted” the right to exercise sovereignty over its own maritime territory by the Oslo Accords in 1995. Four years later, following the findings of the offshore natural gas, the PA gave the international consortium BG a 25-year, 90% stake in a license to explore, develop any discovered fields, and install the required infrastructure. Since that time Israel has consistently blocked this development". Source- “Behind Israel’s ‘end game’ for Gaza: Theft of offshore gas reserves” By Betsey Piette. November 14, 2023 ... "Israel announced on Sunday ( October 29, 2023) that 12 licenses have been awarded to six companies, including British multinational oil and gas firm BP plc and Italian energy giant Eni, to explore and discover additional offshore natural gas fields". Source Times of Israel, by Sharon Wrobel Oct.29,2023 29 October 2023. Nothing to see here

[@tauseefhassan7796]

I think the US is interested in spending billions to level Gaza to control the billions in gas that Europe needs now that “not us” took care of nordstream. Hegemony is everything.

[@jessejordache1869]

You can see this playing out generationally. There's such a close correlation with someone's age and how they see Israel, which is inevitable given the increasing flow of information coming out of the occupied territories, as well as Israeli leadership stating baldly what the Labour government for years only hinted at. When Golda Meir said (I can't believe this is considered a great quote among Zionists): "There will not be peace until Palestinians love their own children more than they hate ours", she was basically painting Palestinians as subhuman. "Look, they don't even love their children". Fast-forward 50 years, and Golda Meir's modern counterpart will basically call Palestinians insects. That may work with the people who have grown up thinking "Palestini delenda est" (sorry for leaving it in Latin, but English really can't handle passive gerunds), but you're going to lose most people way before you reach that point.

[@catlyn777]

Great show! People are generally too self-centered and greedy. They don’t like to share, and they think their group/team is the best., has the correct beliefs.

The less you own the more you give...

[@haithamabdullah400]

You’re the true leaders of tomorrow’s good world on crippled one that colonialism created ❤️👏 you guys are heroes of humanity

[@TruthAlways_]

Great job guys ❤❤❤

[@DannyMannn]

Second ! I love your vids too!! Left is best

[@greggbisgrove7499]

Netanyahu is right when he said its like the holocaust he should look at Nazi filming of Warsaw ghetto uprising and there response.

[@kriminal7009]

I love the empathy/sympathy conversation. Who gets/receives empathy, who’s responsible for empathy, and what comes after empathizing are interesting questions. Many people, in microcosm and in society at large, struggle or refuse to empathize with any conceived “Other.” Some just cannot empathize with those who are different. A woman lead in a movie? Impossible. A mother and child starving in Gaza? No thanks. A homeless man on the street? Never should have quit his job. A Latino man missing his mother back in his home country? Unthinkable. Young black men being murdered by police? Never should have smoked weed two weeks ago.

[@AudioStream7]

We’re seeing the end of the Trumman Show

[@bendyrland7213]

A forced secular one state solution seems to be the only realistic solution that will bring peace over the long-term.

[@absolutelycitron1580]

Well said

[@52flyingbicycles]

You’d need some big senate-type check on pure majority unfortunately. Like I know the 60-vote threshold for anything to pass in the USA is garbage, but it would actually make sense in a place like Israel-Palestine to stop both sides from ripping each other apart in the first few decades following unification.

[@hiphopotamus69]

I don’t think a peaceful one state solution is possible at this point. There has been decades of violence and bad blood at this point that isn’t just gonna vanish overnight

[@absolutelycitron1580]

@@52flyingbicycles no. That is a racist way of thinking. White people are the minority in South Africa. Did they get "ripped apart" after apartheid fell?

[@andresrojas7924]

A forced one state solution? Lol Israel is a nuclear power capable of destroying the entire Middle East WITHOUT nukes lol man you guys are delusional. North Korea is a bankrupt country with no food and a handful of nukes and that's enough to keep anyone for forcing them to do anything and you think you can force Israel (a country that is technologically and scientifically more advanced than the entire region) to do something?

[@FoxSt3v3]

good shit guys

[@septima1789]

0:24 Did Brandon just reference Knocked Loose with that Poppy mention?

[@sntfrancisco31]

Ngl.... "i dont know why im in the habit of saying 'papi' " made me rise an eyebrow to recently engaged Emma lol. We MIGHT actually now why the habit is there lol.

[@adammsa5303]

. As they are above the internal laws, ICJ should sanction the ones who supply them by the bang and boom items....

[@FAILED00CREATION]

Still get loads of those visit israel adds on youtube in ireland funnily wnough

[@yeasminchowdhury6090]

Western some countries are two faces because Israeli government is killing women and children and older people Palestinian but they are silent where is the human rights for Palestinian people

[@subversivelysurreal3645]

There’s even BOOK BURNIG! WTF is wrong with Joe Biden?!

[@secularismpeace]

Peoples who said that Palestine is terrorist country -🤡🤡🤡🤡

[@wyleecoyotee4252]

They are

[@CFX992]

@@wyleecoyotee4252 Here comes the first clown

[@wyleecoyotee4252]

@CFX992 Are you Resorting to insulting people to try change their minds?

[@CFX992]

@@wyleecoyotee4252 I don't really care about changing your mind. Anyone who is pro Zionism at this stage is a lost cause.

[@notamurderer6226]

Well I’m pretty sure this war popped off with Hamas killing civilians and taking hostages

[@saberaahsan3287]

I love following your content it's a lifeline... After someone who has ran sessions on genocide in my policy equality and human rights training... Genocide is not hard to understand...Allport's scale of genocide. He was a Jewish psychologist in the 1950s who studied the Holocaust genocide occurs like this 1. anti-locution 2. avoidance second step including dehumanization 3. discrimination unfair treatment 4. physical attack which is what the mainstream doing now final step 5. elimination annihilation genocide. Press and western leadership rhetoric is part of the genocide. Society is made up of withdrawers, acquiescers or resistors. Press and certain leaders are championing genocide. The best thing we can do is work with the withdrawers to resist then we become more powerful and it's less likely that genocide can take place in the long term. So the real life examples in Palestine are the dehumanization, apartheid, the wall, children being imprisoned unjustly, bulldozing people's homes, olive groves, illegally building settlements, taking over people's homes and throwing them out and the violence in Gaza, destroying infrastructure, hospitals, universities, birth certificates historical proof of Palestinian heritage, sniper attacks, mass murder. In summary antilocution, avoidance, discrimination, physical attack, removal, annihilation = genocide

[@supermills03]

also the backlash to campus protest was only ever people saying "I feel unsafe" ok, well I'm sorry you feel that way, but that's a you problem. seeing signs that scare you doesn't mean those signs are illegal.

[@davidzieglmeier1020]

Maybe saying "Papi" is a freudian thing?

[@petedog9581]

David Ortiz is Big Papi. Emma is probably a long-tine Sox fan. He's a big black guy, so not Freudian. Lol.

[@LACYJEN1999]

Making you ,your opinions the most valuable is narcissism

[@amania9254]

👌Ilan Pappe ❤

[@mattnhormann]

Ilan "¡Ay, Papi!"

[@b.bigdaddy]

As a Palestinian, I love the fact that in all these videos discussion our situation, mainstream & alternative media barely bring us to talk about our experiences as a collective.. such a refreshing feeling of shut your pie hole and live with what we give you kinda vibe

[@absolutelycitron1580]

Owen Jones does platform actual Palestinians. He also has a good interview with a gentleman named Alon Mizrahi about the erasure of Arab culture among Arab Jews in Is rael

[@absolutelycitron1580]

Diana Buttu and Khalil Sayegh are the 2 most recent interviewees Mr. Jones has had on his program MR did have Nour Erakat on the program but that was 3 years ago...

[@b.bigdaddy]

@@absolutelycitron1580 I know.. but in comparison to the number of people who are not Palestinian, don't you think it is just odd they barely even bother ask who's Palestinian and wanna talk, subjectively or objectively?

[@absolutelycitron1580]

@@b.bigdaddy It is odd and low key racist. It's a form of white savior complex imo. A lot of people think talking about is just as good as talking with and it isn't

[@b.bigdaddy]

@@absolutelycitron1580 my point exactly. Thank you!

[@maticsmats]

Today I’ll make a nice salad with some chicken and parmesan cheese

[@jhern083]

"I'm not ya PAPI" my favorite quote from COPS

[@adammsa5303]

they can not operate by themselves, they need alliance. As they are above the internal laws, then the sanction should fall on alliance too...

[@Irene-im8xi]

60% of settlers on the West Bank have American/Israeli dual passports.

[@jeffreywilheim5970]

Even if that were true, none of them are going anywhere. Get used to it and grow the fuck up.

[@billybigwig1154]

Love the show. Left is best.

[@JNRJER]

Ilan Papi

[@Arizalia]

Singapore, with all the legit criticism you can have about that country aside, did a wonderful job in integration. They made an artificial integration system in which blocks of societies are mandatorily made up of different ethnic backgrounds so that every other neighbor is someone of a different race/ethnic background. It had its mishaps, of course, but if you contrast it with arguably strong failures in integration that have been made in Europe during the refugee crisis, or in England for example, or white flight in the US, the system implemented by Singapore was better at combating an otherwise impending division in its society because of its diversity by forcefully making them neighbors of each others. It will be difficult on the short term for a one-state solution to Palestinians and Israelis, especially when we look at the situation right now, but you'd be surprised how quick people (especially younger generations) get out of that bubble. Think about the civil rights movement and how black children had to ve taken to unsegregated schools by the army. Yes the inequality still exists, it didn't poof and disappear from existence in one snap of the finger, but to say the division today is the same as it was in the past is ridiculous.

[@absolutelycitron1580]

I'd rather follow South Africa's Australia's Costa Rica's or Cuba's model for integration Singapore is a literal dystopia

[@laracroft8420]

🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸

[@michaelwhite5455]

Hey Emma. It just clicked in my head. Miedas never mentions Gaza Ever. Never heard a word about it.

[@mozi3051]

Clinton too. Since this thing started i havent heard from that woman. Thank God

[@inrainbows1829]

And they cost Bragg a conviction by employing Cohen

[@earth_coin]

yeah they’re sadly just another cheerleading organization for the DNC

[@bendyrland7213]

They just talk about Trump 💯 of the time. Don't know how it would even come up in their reporting at this point.

[@absolutelycitron1580]

​@@mozi3051 I have! She said the protestors don't know anything about Is rael and should stfu

[@CandGoods]

based Ilan Pappe does it again!

[@Airbag15]

100%

[@adammsa5303]

they can not operate by themselves, they need alliance.. ICJ should sanction the ones who supply them by the bang and boom items....

[@anthonyrowland9072]

I got a 10/7 propaganda at during this. I let it play 30 seconds to fund the report.

[@anthonyrowland9072]

@@pranays I feel like there has to be a Sun Tzu quote somewhere... Also, I'm petty like that.

[@absolutelycitron1580]

Yall should get Nour Erakart or Diana Buttu on the program to discuss Or any Palesti nians tbh

[@daniel25083]

Yall gotta let Brandon talk and stop cutting him off

[@kray97]

One state - free for all - is the only solution.

[@lordvadertheleftie9703]

No mainstream media addresses this issue properly

[@jeffreywilheim5970]

Yes that's because mainstream media deal in facts, not antisemitic lies.

[@lordvadertheleftie9703]

@jeffreywilheim5970 Your accusations of antisemitism are meaningless. In fact we wear the badge of antisemitism with pride. Antisemitism is nothing to do with Jew's, it's a weapon used by zionists to shut down criticism of war crimes

[@anthonyrowland9072]

"Ill Papi" sounds hard tho...

[@jonathanmckeage8222]

The iron dome is far from perfect

[@notamurderer6226]

@@ArleeStarrthey don’t have hypersonic missiles

[@jonathanmckeage8222]

@@notamurderer6226 Iran does and that's the scary part because all the technology Iran has China Russia North Korea has too Iran may have stealth as well but we'll probably never know

[@notamurderer6226]

@@jonathanmckeage8222 they definitely don’t have hyper sonics but good thing America has not only finished testing on there hypersonic missiles but are also about down testing systems to fight against hypersonic missiles plus the Air Force which has planes that literally can’t be seen by radar while watching everything you do Iran isn’t a threat neither is Russia or china

[@fallond3165]

I recently found a video of him and Mehdi debating two zionist women (I’m sorry I don’t remember their names) if antizionism was antisemitism. Worth looking up. They polled the audience before and after

[@joeblow5505]

It's funny but really you are talking about the core principle of all abrahamic faiths here: Lev 19: 18 states clearly: לֹֽא־תִקֹּ֤ם וְלֹֽא־תִטֹּר֙ אֶת־בְּנֵ֣י עַמֶּ֔ךָ וְאָֽהַבְתָּ֥ לְרֵעֲךָ֖ כָּמ֑וֹךָ אֲנִ֖י יְהוָֽה .Simply put: love your neighbour as yourself. This basic core principle is what they reject. Their religious identity, is a tribal one that is based in exclusion of the other, not inclusion, principles or morals. But social dominance and tribalism at all cost. Republican Jesus also pretends Matthew 21-26 doesnt exist, or that the only time Jesus lost his shit and starting throwing tables was when people try to commercialise faith. Their religion is just an excuse for their bigotry to them and treating others as inferiors as divine.

[@Caroline-dy4fb]

this conversation is just a bunch of dorm room kids kvetching. Do you have any news or facts to share with your listeners?

[@randomuser6378]

With any luck, the entire place is turned into glass

[@petedog9581]

Emma is still fixated on Big Papi as she is probably a Sox fan. Lol.

[@50043211]

Damn, that Doha skyline is ugly as fuck.

[@gatorgityergranny]

get better lighting on that black guy. he disappears. i cannot see his lips moving. come on. it’s 2024.

[@ebrahim9583]

South African Muslim here. Good epsiode, such an overlooked talking point. Just 2 points from me. 1. The idea that Muslims have a hatred for Jews and secretly seek to annihilate them is untrue and unfounded historically and theologically. Isolated incidences aside; under the Islamic rulership for the last 1400 years, whether in Palestine or the Middle East, Jews and Christians lived relatively harmoniously, eve in Iran. Hence one finds the oldest Jewish and Christian synagogues and churches, and communities. Rabbinic scholars through history attest to this, to the degree that what is considered the Jewish Golden Age was under Muslim rule. This is not despite Islamic law, it’s because of it. When Umar, the 2nd Caliph conquered Jerusalem in 637 CE, he preserved the Church of the Sepulchre, and cleaned the Jewish Temple's site from the desecration it had suffered prior. He retained the Christian population and ordered the repatriation of exiled Jews to Jerusalem - And so too upon the reconquest from the Crusaders in 1187 CE, had Salah-al-din Ayyubi (Saladin) adhered to the same Islamic constitution. Muslims and Jews lived somewhat harmoniously through the Middle East, in Palestine as well, not despite Islam but because of Islam - religious minorities such as Jews and Christians are protected and even allowed self-governance - see the Constitution of Medina, the Assurance of Umar and the Pact of Umar - it’s a matter of Sharia law that non-Muslim inhabitants have rights, protection and even allowed self-governance according to their religion. 2. In Apartheid South Africa, ‘Swart Gevaar’ (Black Danger) was a common term used to create a perceived existential threat for South African ‘whites’. It was also commonly used as an electioneering tactic to galvanise British and Afrikaner voters. There were, of course, calls for the abolishment of South Africa by non-white liberation movements - even toying with a name change for the country, and battle cries of ‘One Settler, One Bullet’. The reality is that these were the motivating slogans of an oppressed people that were barely mustering an armed struggle. Once parties came to the table as equals, with reconciliation as an objective, these slogans became whispers as is often the case historically. So too with Zionist Israel and their Western supporters, once an ally of Apartheid South Africa, using the idea that the Palestinians are an existential threat to Jews and similarly straw-manning the protest slogans of their oppression in order to galvanise support for Zionist Israel, ironically based on the West’s own historical treatment of Jews. Hamas, portrayed as THE personification of this threat, has themselves clarified that it’s a fight against Zionism rather than Jews, and that they would disband should there be a withdrawal to 67 borders and Palestinian self-determination - let alone the idea that it be one land with all people.

[@richardcaves3601]

Long term, the solution lies in two factors: 1. International pressure on the Netenyahu regime, causing it to collapse, and the ringleaders rounded up for trial at the ICJ. 2. Israeli politics, where half to two-thirds oppose Netenyahu. If they can get their act together, and form a stable coalition to defeat the extremist right wing, then an Oslo Accords type solution is probable. Such a solution would have to acknowledge past wrongs from both sides, a return to the 1948 borders, compensation for ALL families, ON BOTH SIDES, who have been hurt and deprived of home and livelihood, and finally, an enforceable agreement to treat every single individual inhabitant in the area of Palestine/Israel strictly according to UDHR, with power of arrest and detention given to every citizen when they see or experience breaches of the UDHR, no matter whom or what station or status the offender - this includes police, military, politicians, religious, and security personnel. All overseen by an armed UN force, after all Israelis and Palestinians have turned in all their weapons. Penalty for keeping weapons - death.

[@BamBamGT1]

1949 borders (I assume that's what you mean, there are no 1948 borders) is never going to happen, and it's quite silly to expect that. Because those borders have nothing to do with "Palestine", nor does the status of occupation. The reason there are occupied territories, is as follows: Israel had no recognized territory and borders yet when it was attacked in 1948. That war ended in 1949 with Jordan and Egypt occupying what became the West Bank and Gaza strip (occupation simply means taking land beyond your recognized border) The UN only recognized Israel borders after that war. In other words, if the Arab states hadn't occupied it, the Gaza strp and West Bank would have been an integral part of Israel. So as a consequence when Israel removed Egypt and Jordan from those territories in 1967, they now also fell outside of Israel's territory, thus it remained seen as occupation. And that's the absurd situation the UN had managed to create: that every state involved was occupier of territory which didn't belong to any state.That's the actual status of these territories since may 15 1948, the day the British mandate ended: it's no man's land, doesn't belong to any state. So because e.g. Jordan occupied East Jerusalem before Israel was recognized, Israel should now split Jerusalem again, to give East Jerusalem to yet another state.. How on earth does that make any sense?

[@richardcaves3601]

@@BamBamGT1 incorrect! The 1948 borders are the ones set by the UN, and they are the internationally recognized ones. The rest is by virtue of conquest and occupation. Agreed the conflicts of 48, 67 & 72 were defensive to start with, but continual occupation after the truces were put in place, carries with it obligations. That occupied territory will be returned as soon as practicable. That the citizens of occupied territory will have their human rights respected fully by the occupier. Israel did none of these things and that puts them in the wrong, as is openly acknowledged by no lesser esteemed persons than Holocaust survivors. The right wing Netenyahu regime will fall; it's a matter of when, not if. You can face that fact now, and prepare. Or you will have it enforced upon you by your own citizens. This Gaza tragedy is the final act in an 80 year Zionist quest for a mythical dream, that takes no account of existing inhabitants of the territory. It ends very soon. Mostly because ordinary people know right from wrong, and together, just like the Nazis in Germany, evil loses.

[@BamBamGT1]

@@richardcaves3601 The UN set Israeli borders on may 11 1949, there are no 1948 borders... The 1949 green line or armistice line is the internationally recognized Israeli border. There is no territory to "return" as the territory doesn't belong to anyone.

[@richardcaves3601]

@@BamBamGT1 really, you do need to learn your history. The British turned the Palestine Mandate over to the UN in 1947. They conducted a survey against a background of Arab hostility. Those borders were agreed and voted on by the UN in full council. They are the legitimate ones! The only legitimate ones. You can fantasize all you want, but Zionism died with the invasion of Gaza. Ordinary people in every country on the world, the overwhelming majority of them, now know this. Between 60% and 75% of Israelis know this. Apart from the small minority of extremist right wing zealots holding together a fragile coalition of extremists, no-one in Israel believes in that hollow dream anymore. They all realise that Palestinians are the legitimate citizens, and they have to live with them in the future. That future has to start somewhere, and conquest in this day and age of the 21st century, doesn't cut the mustard. They know they have to make a lasting peace. That peace starts with acknowledging past wrongs and doing the right thing. The alternative is complete destruction of the Israeli state. Even the Palestinians don't want that, because they value Israeli industriousness and tenacity. It's only the stupidity of people holding onto attitudes like those you express, that prevents peace. You, mate, are "past your use by date". Adapt or die, is a quality that humanity has developed for survival. It's a quality you'd better learn quickly.

[@comments8742]

I would just disagree with the point that no American has had their home bombarded and, therefore, do not feel empathy for Palestinians. African Americans (US descendants of chattel slavery) were bombed out of their homes and social institutions in the Tulsa race massacre, part of the Red Summer of 1919. Might explain why there is more empathy toward Palestinians within the African American (ADOS) community.

[@claudemadrid4950]

Ilan Pappé is not "israeli leftist", Ilan Pappé is "historian". 🙂

[@CanadianSpiceKing]

Zionism does not translate 1-to-1 to American racial dynamics. It's not white versus brown; the Mizrahi are the most far-right ethnic group in Israel.

[@balisongguy8479]

Not to mention how many druze are loyal to Israel. It's wild that so many zionists say that Arabs don't want peace when it's so blatantly obvious that this wouldn't be a problem if Israel didn't treat Palestinians worse than literal dog shit, but that would only happen if Zionism wasn't rooted in colonialism

[@TooDarnEasy]

oof mehdi needs a better camera

[@absolutelycitron1580]

Not every country is like Spain, Germany or the USA. Not all people of the world are rac-ist like the way Europeans and their descendants are. Sure it exists outside of the European sphere but its not the same in most regions of the world

[@notamurderer6226]

It’s actually worse in most parts of the world like china some of the most racist people in the world

[@notamurderer6226]

@@ArleeStarrya if your fucking brain dead

[@antonroux6737]

The United States is not a signatory to the Rome Statute of the ICC and neither is Israel, or China or Iraq or Yemen, North Korea, Saudi Arabia, India, Indonesia, Ethiopia etc

[@andresrojas7924]

​@John-PaulHunt-wy7lfyou do know that international courts have zero power right? Their decisions are only turned into reality if both parties agree

[@j0j0dartiste21]

​@@andresrojas7924it would simply means that Netanyahu Will be a caged rat that can't travel to Europe.

[@yeasminchowdhury6090]

🇯🇴🇯🇴🇯🇴🇯🇴🇯🇴🇯🇴🇯🇴🇯🇴🇯🇴🇯🇴

[@haraldisdead]

Stop calling them "new" historians.