The History of Minecraft's Music - What Happened to C418?

New music from C418 has strangely been absent from new versions of Minecraft. Why is this the case? In this video, I will be explaining the history of Minecraft's soundtrack and what happened to C418.
Information Sources:
C418 Interview: • 10 Years of the Minecr...
DevGAMM 2015 C418 Panel: • Daniel Rosenfeld (C418...
Minecon 2012 C418 Panel: • Minecon 2012 - The Mus...
Join the SalC1 Discord Server: www.salc1.com/...

[@puzzLEGO]

let it sink in that C418 has probably made some of the most listened-to music ever, of all time

[@MrGlitchDogePE]

Verified KZbinr hehe

[@Omega-mf9kj]

@@lopanreturns7085 its sold more than tetris by like 130 million

[@TheBinklemNetwork]

Yeah. That didn't click until you said it.

[@BritishTrainspotting]

the thing I find sad is that most of the soundtracks he made for the game are no longer played in the game, alot of the alpha soundtracks aren't really heard anymore, or atleast have an extremely low chance of playing compared to the beta music and the new music coming with these new artists. Alpha is honestly the best soundtrack and I wish it played / played more in-game.

[@mlgcostted9015]

@@BritishTrainspotting ikr i hate Microsoft for removing everything good about Minecraft

[@optie5]

The fact that an entire generation could recognize these songs instantly is just incredible.

[@zpond3212]

Maybe even 2 generations mmm more like 1.5

[@user-tzzglsstle585e38]

@B O ꓭ Probably still gonna be big but a big buuuut will be that it's most definitely gonna be less endearing and people wouldn't get as attached to it compared to today, and the game will stand-out less.

[@Omar96149]

I’ll be ur 1k like 👍🏻

[@huhj963]

@B O ꓭ it would but you only feel the true minecraft experience when C418 music start to play. When you are chilling alone like you never did before, amaze by your shitty cobblestone house. But it doesnt matter because is your home and the sun is rising up for a new cubic day, maybe tomorrow you play minecraft with your friends, maybe not but you have something to build now that you end your house.

[@YourBoyfriend]

Yeah

[@The_Horizon]

C418 might need to bring his cat to the vet

[@deathpacito6]

Hello horizon

[@BottledPoe]

why?

[@pogerster7429]

true lmao

[@Clem2TheClemening]

@@BottledPoe Because it made Ghast sounds

[@crowneddiamond]

It's coughing up fireballs instead of hairballs

[@Laurel5544]

i played minecraft at my grandmother's in 2013. the music would play throughout her house for multiple hours every day. she still tells me almost 10 years later that it's one of her fondest memories of us at the house, and asked who the composer was because she liked it.

[@dinamita2870]

This is too wholesome😭❤️

[@realcartoongirl]

mean while my grand ma : AAAAAAAAA Aaaaaaa

[@pxnzers]

awwhh

[@Americas_91]

Me too I got introduced to games from Minecraft, I would play for hours at a time

[@corbinsbeats2540]

Im glad bro go visit ur grandma

[@mikesmit7496]

That man forged a entire community with his music. He will be remembered as the first and greatest music composer for Minecraft.

[@vgarzareyna]

Maybe not the greatest forever (it's difficult but possible that someone better comes some day), but definitely for being the absolute legend that gave character to this masterpiece of a game

[@gabrieldelatortilla1]

@@vgarzareyna forever the OG, father of our beloved Minecraft's soundtrack

[@z69b]

@@vgarzareyna his music holds infinitely more meaning than anything that will ever be made for minecraft

[@SplashLava986]

Sal you fricking gave me all my nostalgia memories back 2:25 why just why

[@gabrieldelatortilla1]

@@Bacon-Boys OK I'll watch your damn video, but if it's worse I stg

[@origamimasters5626]

Well guess what, C418 is getting to be a part of Billboard's music awards for Volume Alpha. I'm very happy to see that he finally gets an award for one of the greatest soundtracks of all time!

[@RealSekiroGamerz]

Really wow he deserves it alot

[@raffandbotnik]

what about volume beta??

[@RealSekiroGamerz]

@@raffandbotnik beta died

[@WreeperXD]

good

[@ser_igel]

sadly he didn't, but getting a nomination is also very good

[@StuffOfSonny]

I remember when Steve was added to Smash Bros, and I was really upset that none of C418's music made the cut. Then someone replied to one of my many pessimistic tweets saying he did not want his music to end up in the clutches of Nintendo's Copyright ID data base, so Smash Bros' lack of Iconic Minecraft Music made a whole lot more sense.

[@asprinjuice425]

At first I was like "Grr why can't we get Minecraft music in smash that sucks!" but now it makes perfect sense to me

[@Dakoya]

That makes actual perfect sense, a shame nonetheless. But arguably I’d say I’m not sure that C418 should be the one to make the soundtrack for the smash game. Rather anyone else from the mess that it is now. Organised and respected mess of course ;d

[@Moon_in_Flames]

The C in C418 stands for CHAD

[@MasterChaosL100]

This is why copyright laws need to be overhauled. To allow use of music without the unnecessary complexity of the current system. It's almost abusive...

[@dillonm913]

@@MasterChaosL100 almost?

[@NickJacobsMusic]

When the song came on at 2:30 i got teary eyed... these are the moments that made Minecraft Minecraft! The nostalgic feelings, all that came from C418! Without this music, it would never be the same!

[@nullenality]

Felt that too

[@mazush1681]

Just wanted to comment this lol

[@armlessdominik]

Exactly, i almost cried too.

[@DinoGooch]

Which song is it?

[@GItoKeG]

I felt that so much.

[@LukemoLegend]

I still listen just to the soundtracks he made to this day. And I love what he did. Minecraft would be different without C418.

[@nickermations3503]

Same

[@tnt_xxx_tntvods]

It most certainly would be different. Sad to see that he probably won't be making any more music for the game though :(

[@e_mine505]

Indeed

[@spaceguybob]

I also do. My top 2 albums of all time are alpha and beta

[@epicnothere]

Here after bots We're no strangers to love You know the rules and so do I A full commitment's what I'm thinking of You wouldn't get this from any other guy I just wanna tell you how I'm feeling Gotta make you understand Never gonna give you up Never gonna let you down Never gonna run around and desert you Never gonna make you cry Never gonna say goodbye Never gonna tell a lie and hurt you We've known each other for so long Your heart's been aching, but You're too shy to say it Inside, we both know what's been going on We know the game and we're gonna play it And if you ask me how I'm feeling Don't tell me you're too blind to see Never gonna give you up Never gonna let you down Never gonna run around and desert you Never gonna make you cry Never gonna say goodbye Never gonna tell a lie and hurt you Never gonna give you up Never gonna let you down Never gonna run around and desert you Never gonna make you cry Never gonna say goodbye Never gonna tell a lie and hurt you (Ooh, give you up) (Ooh, give you up) Never gonna give, never gonna give (Give you up) Never gonna give, never gonna give (Give you up) We've known each other for so long Your heart's been aching, but You're too shy to say it Inside, we both know what's been going on We know the game and we're gonna play it I just wanna tell you how I'm feeling Gotta make you understand Never gonna give you up Never gonna let you down Never gonna run around and desert you Never gonna make you cry Never gonna say goodbye Never gonna tell a lie and hurt you Never gonna give you up Never gonna let you down Never gonna run around and desert you Never gonna make you cry Never gonna say goodbye Never gonna tell a lie and hurt you Never gonna give you up Never gonna let you down Never gonna run around and desert you Never gonna make you cry Never gonna say goodbye Never gonna tell a lie and hurt you

[@psivewri]

I have so many memories of playing Minecraft Classic 11 years ago. The music was a big part of it :)

[@melonexist9070]

hi :D

[@surfision]

oh didn't expect you here. love ur vids!

[@GigantTech]

we need a mod to recreate it

[@oscarosullivan4513]

The one with birds chirping has a woodland feel

[@sak1b_c]

Oh hey psivewri didn't expect you here but hello

[@Supertimegamingify]

I'm glad that he (apparently) stood up for himself. He's still as great a composer as he was before, and his works still exist.

[@christopherdeguzman9083]

@@Bacon-Boys lmao

[@GAMMA_AF]

@@Bacon-Boys You will get zero traction from your shameless self promotion. Especially when you're shitting on the creator we all came here to see.

[@joshc7032]

@@GAMMA_AF I always report those comments for spam

[@GAMMA_AF]

@@joshc7032 Good idea 💡

[@yasterday5377]

There's a playlist on Spotify made by him that has all of his works that are posted on Spotify

[@MKP2W]

Man. He never made music before yet he has made tracks that I will never forget and always stir up intense nostalgia of my younger days and friends.

[@bramt2000]

Some people are just born with that talent, and good thing he shared it with us.

[@Jacob-sl6ur]

He made LOTS of music before Minecraft, I don't remember the exact amount of years but it's above five.

[@bluey_fan968]

I remember when I was 6 and I was playing Minecraft with my brother and we built a big house and a farm

[@skully_bonez]

He HAS made music before. I highly recommend checking out his other stuff, it’s really under-appreciated.

[@SirBenjiful]

He made loads of music before, not much of it is online. He also wrote a few videogame soundtracks before Minecraft, although they were very small hobby projects and he doesn't publish those anymore.

[@areakastudios6704]

C418's overall style has a charm that will never be replaced. Kind of random, but volume beta is actually my favorite album of all time.

[@mose918]

my favorite album too. ever. easily beats any other album

[@Hannah-rv8rb]

Same I have it on vinyl :)

[@enolp]

@@Hannah-rv8rb :O want

[@mr_confuse]

For me it's not only the music, which is minimalistic but interesting and progressive, it's the time of life I heard it and played the game. Back then I had so much less to worry about and would spend hours with friends playing Minecraft. Good times

[@dbvectra]

Just play volume beta at my funeral, thanks

[@houssemknf]

Microsoft doesn’t know that c418 is sitting on a legendary third album that could flip the internet upside down if it’s released.

[@King_WolfLIVE]

I would argue that C418 made minecraft and would actually bring more than the new artists. Not saying that the artists are bad mind you, just that when people hear the name C418, they instantly listen and enjoy. There isn't a single minecraft player who doesn't enjoy his music where as some people don't like pigstep, infinite amethyst etc

[@Flamme-Sanabi]

@@King_WolfLIVE I guess his stuff just has something that can touch everyone, while the newer stuff was made for a specific biom, with specific genres and stuff.

[@crazydragy4233]

@@Flamme-Sanabi A lot of new stuff sounds spacey to me. It captures some emotions minecraft might envoke but... it sounds more like a space game at time :(

[@TheAdvertisement]

@@King_WolfLIVE I'd argue you're putting him on a bit too high of a pedestal- there are certainly people who don't like C418's music.

[@XrayTheMyth23]

@@King_WolfLIVE almost everyone I know who plays MC hates the c418 music and plays without sound/Spotify. I do aswell but that's because I've heard it for thousands of hours at this point.

[@bjbrandon11]

No disrespect to the new composers, but damn I miss c418, his music is so impactful and still holds up after hundreds of hours listening

[@DBT1007]

Nostalgic, relaxing, epic, void, and still in game theme style.

[@potatoplayer922]

Same

[@IroAppe]

Who knows what's in that new album, that has apparently more tracks than Alpha and Beta. How impactful that would be. How much great Minecraft music we are missing. That's what worries me.

[@ActuallyNTiX]

C418's style just holds high. It can be imitated, but not replicated. This proves how masterful it really is. May Microsoft one day change their minds. Please, we all want to hear what's been bottled up.

[@wizardlizard524]

His music has a magic to it. So many people from many paths of life have played minecraft and heard those songs, so they mean something different to everybody. For me, they're emotional because those melodies remind me of some of the best times of my life. I can't thank minecraft and C418 enough for that.

[@1598hi]

We need a mod that fixes the music. Just c418 tracks and enough with the broken way the music plays now. Back to playing at random

[@shuvelstone1331]

Good for c418, he's not letting microsoft take control of any of his hard work, that's admirable. It is such a shame that he won't be back to make more of it though. That... hurts.

[@Thee_Jadex]

Exactly what i was thinking. Notch might have ocastrated the game but it never would have been the hit it was without c418, he deserves a much bigger stake in it but alas microsoft would never accept that.

[@Pixillnow]

I agree. Especially with the recent update Microsoft is getting way to far into Mojang’s business for there own good

[@gabrielcalda7033]

@@Pixillnow I think by this point microsoft completely controls mojang, if in the shadow

[@Pixillnow]

@@gabrielcalda7033 it starting to look like that

[@ilovebeatingwomen]

I wish notch never sold the game, like was it really that bad that he couldn't take it. He never thought of his team?

[@Sbeev]

Nothing against the new composers or their music but it's just never going to be the same as if it were still done by C418

[@niftylittlename]

i mean, yes, its not like the artists want their music to fall under somebody else's name. Lena wants their music to feel like it was made by Lena, and still be Minecraft, and the same with Kumi.

[@menooby2653]

It's good they kept it in biome specific areas, meaning C418 is still the main theme, and any new additions won't take away anything from it, only adding parallel

[@chasetamburo316]

Lena is so good tho ngl

[@パシャル]

very sad that the agreements didn’t work out for Dan, but his music stays iconic to the point that all the other composers just copy his style. the new music is alright but it will never be the same

[@gazehound]

It's not supposed to be the same. Like have you listened to pigstep

[@rykerporter1986]

C418's music really made the player fell relaxed, like nothing was rushed, like they could do what they want.

[@gabbyfielding649]

Exactly, it was perfect ❤️

[@alexandrashvydun8726]

i know right

[@darrenplayzbg5980]

@@alexandrashvydun8726 69 likes

[@ch26-z9w]

I think that's why it fit in with the game so well. it's very cozy

[@reapersexotics1129]

Listening to it over and over again made it annoying asf so I turned music off

[@johngaynor4363]

C418's music always felt melancholy, but in a good way. It brings back memories of playing with friends who have been offline for years. It's beautiful in its simplicity.

[@afekshelly4648]

I swear every time I hear the original soundtrack, I get hit with this nostalgia wave and mixed emotions, I get kinda sad that I wouldn't be able to play the game as a kid again. So many memories. I just wish to go back and play survival with my friends once more, this game really was my whole childhood

[@anonymous-3695]

you can always start a new world with new friends. im going to on this recent update :) i know its not quite the same. but with loved ones it can be.

[@afekshelly4648]

@@anonymous-3695 I do it sometimes, it just doesn't feel the same...

[@flawnski]

​@@afekshelly4648 man I feel you 100%. Know that you're not alone with this beautiful memories and let's reminisce together

[@afekshelly4648]

@@flawnski much love to you brother

[@DR_REDACTED]

Same i almost feel depressed i dont want to hear it. It brings too many good memorys in mind but after growing up my friend group grew a part. I still remeber how the 7 of us would always play minecraft...

[@TheChnecht]

that moment when the music kicked in during the mining literally gave me goose bumps. weird, how something so simple can trigger so much.

[@darvil82]

Same, I don't think any other song ever did this to me me when listening to it. Such an special soundtrack imo.

[@linasjesaias]

@bruh funny that sells their soul to microsoft for a quick buck. microsoft owes c418 everything for his impact and instead they just hire new shit artists

[@halflight8811]

same mate

[@Dakoya]

Its on a similar vain to me as the old runescape soundtracks. It transports you through melancholy and nostalgia into a emotional trip

[@irok1]

Yup

[@paullester3160]

C418 said on twitter a couple years he was almost done working on the third minecraft album which was said to be longer than the length of alpha and beta combined. I've been so excited for it ever since I heard the aquatic update's music. I hope I can listen to it one day

[@adamike9990]

Lets hope community make microsoft rethink their decisions about C418.

[@ExponentialCircle]

@@cykes5124 How's that superiority complex working out for you?

[@shrimpin4145]

@@ExponentialCircle is that really what you got out of that?

[@ExponentialCircle]

@@shrimpin4145 They literally end with "these people are not humans". It's a dime a dozen screed proclaiming how much better they are.

[@recursiveslacker7730]

@@ExponentialCircle I mean, corporations ARE like that.

[@lochlanbasile4964]

Its unfortunate that c418 is not with Minecraft anymore. He's undisputably a genius, and I can confidently say that his music, is Minecraft. Nobody can do it like him.

[@thelegacyofgaming2928]

Genius is a stretch, as making good music doesn't equal genius level intellect. But his music is awesome and gave Minecraft a soul.

[@lochlanbasile4964]

​@@thelegacyofgaming2928 musical genius. You happy Einstein?

[@xcaedes]

@@thelegacyofgaming2928 The word “Genius” get’s bent a lot these days. Better to use a different word to refer to it’s original meaning.

[@Zandercraft]

The MC music is so iconic... Wish we had more C418 music. Unfortunate we won't have more.

[@Flamingpaper0]

C418 is working on a new Minecraft album

[@holidayoreoreal]

@@Flamingpaper0 what?!?!??

[@CinnabarCereal]

@@Flamingpaper0 AYO?

[@marshpenny]

@@Flamingpaper0 he said he was a long time ago, he likely has completed it by now. but due to microsoft its likely not going to see the light of day

[@GammaZ]

YO MY NAME IS ZANDER

[@calebkoivisto5524]

I have to admit that C418's music was one of the reasons I loved Minecraft.

[@13_cmi]

When I turn on the music I only hear a few tracks from him. Not all of them like back when I played on the ps3 and ps4. They've replaced it with gross new music that I hate. I need to figure out how to bring back the old music. But I'm on mobile. So it's in a separate folder. Resource packs don't work.

[@Th3cosmic_]

@@13_cmi download a soundtrack on youtube and play it in the background, i found this problem too thats how i fixed

[@bedsidespace321]

@@13_cmi I agree, I don’t like the music much. People were saying they really liked Lena Raine’s music because of how well it depicted the nether, and of course Kumi Tanioka. But their music holds absolutely zero emotional value. But C418’s music, you can tell he poured his heart and soul into it. C418’s music will always be levels and levels above any average composer’s music because of this.

[@pacefactor]

C418 did the right thing to keep the rights to his iconic music, and perfectly demonstrates the glaring issues in the intellectual property space and how badly its abused by megacorporate conglomerates.

[@samfsrr]

well said

[@GabrielleTollerson]

soo true

[@Prof.Pwnalot]

Indeed so, especially since microsoft absorbs everything it touches.

[@Linus-nq2op]

Well said, this is the reason I just hate Microsoft.

[@Linus-nq2op]

@@Prof.Pwnalot They absorb it and do shit with it nobody wants 😂

[@FaeChild8478]

C418's Minecraft music is one of the few playlists where I can listen to it at anytime and it brings me back to a calm, and content state of being. It sounds good, it feels good, and makes for some lovely background ambience

[@Fizz134]

A legend made, a legacy never forgotten. A nostalgia trip in music. Music thats makes a grown man cry. Hearing mice on Venus years later makes me cry in nostalgia. Memories overflow me. Minecraft.

[@thediamondgamer8337]

Bruh this is all about C418 and Minecraft nostalgia not bots sending weird add born sites!! 💀🤬😠😡

[@ElioSWeiss]

i had the pleasure of meeting daniel rosenfeld when he was staying with a friend of mine. he was open about struggling with severe anxiety and the recognition he received after composing the soundtrack. i was much younger back then and my presence had overwhelmed him to the point that he almost didn't come to speak with me. i really do hope he's doing better now

[@Carcharodon]

Damn

[@stschannelt1476]

Wow that's unfortunate

[@Josuh]

😔

[@keeyust2457]

I wanna meet him, he's really a genius

[@SirPatrickStar302]

Storys that never happened #1

[@userwhom]

“Sweden” and “Minecraft” are the songs of my childhood. I have so many happy memories of playing with friends or by myself in survival which are scored by the songs made by C418.

[@streizz_yt7219]

true dude. He can still take those away with a snap of a finger showing his powers on microsoft and microsoft cant ddo anything but I hope that doesn't happen caz these songs are so cool in minecraft

[@itsv1p3r]

if i ever get Alzheimer's i want someone to bump those for me and ill probably recall my entire life just from awakening such a deep and primordial memory

[@youreallyareanidiot2751]

@@Bacon-Boys you have no subscribers Your just another bot

[@munchosrs]

Personally, I'm not a fan of the new soundtracks. But that could be due to the emotions that come to surface when I hear those classic MC soundtracks.. So bittersweet.

[@Starhiveart]

I just think it doesnt fit minecraft. I love lena raines work on celeste, but i dont like the songs at all on minecraft

[@rafhael636]

Except otherside and left bloon

[@cuppajoe2]

I actually really like them. But, they do NOT bring the same nostalgia that C418s tracks do. Not even close. They are objectively good soundtracks, but they are not C418s soundtracks.

[@lunathecutest6652]

I believe if Lena's music was there to begin with and c418 came after, everyone would be nostalgic towards her music.

[@randomality77]

@@lunathecutest6652 Exactly. At the moment, though I love Lena's music, I prefer C418's. But after 5 years or so, when the former's starts to become more nostalgic, I'll love them both equally.

[@Absolute_Zero7]

Honestly, when I heard at the end that C418 owned the rights to all his music, I was happy for him. If he was replaced by someone else, but lost the rights to all of the music he made, it would've been a tragic end. Otherwise, good for him!

[@RealSekiroGamerz]

True he's great

[@Walkingmango]

Yup

[@WreeperXD]

he still gets paid royalties and licensing fees so

[@brunnomenxa]

Like the opposite of what Notch did. He sold the game and all rights to Microsoft.

[@zackrose6261]

@@brunnomenxa TBF, C418 only got to keep rights to his music because Notch wasn't rich at the time of their deal. Him not wanting to sell his music isn't integrity or anything nice like that, just pride even though artists selling their music to game companies is a normal thing.

[@thegirthquake8574]

I'm 100% in support of C418 being in complete control of his music. It's HIS art. And he ultimately built the tear-inducing soundtracks of MC. MS shot themselves in the foot with not being willing to work with him.

[@A1lexander]

I think for Microsoft it's not a big problem to find new musicians, because money solves almost everything, but I agree that future minecraft soundtracks would be much better with C418

[@draftsky12]

@@A1lexander yeah i agree but its just not the same without C418 even if the other musicians they are working for are doing a good job

[@musicased9591]

He's the one who chose to not be willing to work with them. He had weird ass requests that didn't make sense for a music artist. He basically didn't want people to know he made the music while still having the rights to it, dude was literally retarded and fucked himself out of millions because he thought he was gonna be famous and didn't want to be when he already is.

[@inevitable48]

"Tear inducing" lol what

[@thegirthquake8574]

@@inevitable48 Mate, if you grew up with it, it has the potential to bring you to tears.

[@HenrikoMagnifico]

No one will ever be able to recapture the incredible melodies composed by C418

[@noahstrine8161]

You maybe right, but that's the nostalgia talking. Give it some time and even pigstep will be the same.

[@koonlord3541]

@@noahstrine8161 no, pigstep and the new music discs suck ass

[@lukasmaraula3329]

@@noahstrine8161 pigstep doesn't really bring that nostalgic kind of feel. The new tracks such as pigstep other side and all the ambient 1.16+ music is a vibe to say the least. But the reason why mc music is nostalgic is due to its simplicity, randomness and pure ambience just pushes the nostalgic vibe forward like aria math (my favourite) is made by only a couple of instruments. The new music being biome specific might be the reason why it doesn't pack the same punch as other tracks such as Sweden and mice on venus makes mundane tasks actually fun. I have to say tho lena and kumi really blew it away with the music.

[@golfcartlmao]

i genuinely think c418’s volume beta is one of the best albums of the 2010’s. i’m glad i can listen to it on spotify without the advertisement money going to the wrong people edit: probably should state that i haven’t listened to a lot of albums from the 2010’s. drunk by thundercat is solid all the way through and the first two death grips albums are a white guy staple but other than that i can’t confidently compare volume beta to its contemporaries

[@anesthetized7053]

c418 did the absolutely insane but ultimately smart move i think. im sure he got offered microsoft millions and he straight up said "i own my work". he probably lost a shit load of money but he kept his integrity and we will always love him for that, aswell as the amazing soundtrack he produced. im confident in saying minecraft would not be as popular as it is today without the miraculous influence of c418's music. gg, cant wait to see if he makes more music. ownership of the things you make is a powerful tool if you have the right audience.

[@Stevus12]

Also, If I'm correct on this, c418 is passively generating income simply because Minecraft still uses his music. since it isn't owned by microsoft. They are paying him either licensing fees or royalties to use the music. Which is probably why they didn't go forward with him as well, they have to fork over money to use it. I will say here though, I am not 100% sure about this and it's solely my interpretation of how I think the system works, I may be wrong with what I'm saying here.

[@daaljones9584]

Southpark tegrity meme

[@InfoByAC]

I mean I woulda made the money instead

[@johnsappleseed]

I don't think Microsoft would've gotten to the point of offering him millions, it already made sense for them to ditch C418 when clearly there were creators who'd sign away their content for much less. Sad but it is what it is.

[@umamifan]

@@johnsappleseed Yeah people like Lean Raine would gladly be bought out for way less than what could be offered to c418 simply because a lot of people want recognition, especially if it's a game like Minecraft. Barely anybody knew about Lena Raine until Celeste and Minecraft. It's just that popular and lucrative.

[@nothingiseverperfect]

I’m glad he owns the music and not some money hungry corporation. Minecraft wouldn’t be Minecraft with out him. Thank you C418 for all your work. We hope to hear your music in other games in the future!

[@darth3911]

I agree but i do know why Mojang/Microsoft started going to other musicians for those who don’t know the reason why it’s because if Mojang wanted to do a Minecraft collaboration with a different game they can’t legally put in the C418 music and even if C418 agreed to allow his music in collaborations the other game company would not want it in there game sense it’s not legally owned by Microsoft and that opens up the possibility of lawsuits.

[@spacecadet_01]

your pfp noooo

[@CoolMintMC]

@@darth3911 Funny you mention this, because this is EXACTLY what happened with Super Smash Bros. Ultimate & the music that was added. That being said, I think that they might've contacted C418, but perhaps he declined to allow the team to create a fitting remix, hence why we don't have any songs from Minecraft itself.

[@GamingDualities]

nice try to get boosted subs

[@SolliumTWO]

@A N G E L beta bot

[@deokureta108]

dam i just realized that i had been listening to C418 music for 8 years without thinking it was repetitive. truly a work of art imo.

[@slicky3397]

Same

[@channelname99192]

You have been stuck playing Minecraft for 8 years straight?

[@traicho_9259]

Now when i play 1.19 and hear the C418's music still in the game It would always make me tear up cause i know that there won't be more music from him. But even tho there won't be any new music from him, I'm still happy with the music he made and we can still listen to it.

[@MasterCube33]

I don’t his music will be in the game for much longer honestly. Every update you hear C418’s music in-game a lot less frequently. I think they’re slowly adding so much new music so they have an excuse to remove his music which would make sense from Microsoft’s perspective. I hope the fanbase really retaliates if this happens

[@SpankeeMyDankee]

When he said "I'm sure you have been in a situation where you were playing the game in silence, doing a mundane talk like digging a giant hole for your base, and then this comes on" I was literally anticipating Mice on Venus, and was waiting for the iconic music, and my body felt so happy hearing how nostalgic that concept was.

[@JShortsFR]

I’m proud of Daniel for sticking to his guns. His music is an art form, and deserves to be treated as such and not given the corporate bullcrap that fells many creatives in their pursuit. I’ll always have a soft spot for his work, and if you guys want more C418 music then, well, listen to his other stuff. His other albums, especially One, 148, and Dief, are some of his best works yet underrated since its not Minecraft, so go show some love. Edit: I was removing something for clarity and it took away my creator heart, fricc :( Edit 2: Excursions heccin rocks too, people keep commenting about it so I’ll add you should listen to that too!

[@alecmajor9]

One was never released as a vinyl, so tough luck there.

[@JShortsFR]

@@alecmajor9 Oof, you’re right. Must’ve saw a mock up of it someone did. I’ll edit my comment here, but One is a masterpiece. EDIT: FRICC IT TOOK AWAY MY HEART

[@alecmajor9]

Yep do wish there was a vinyl made, good luck on a sealed cd then?

[@JShortsFR]

@@alecmajor9 I got volume alpha and beta, unsealed because, while entirely a collectible item, I would enjoy them so much more playing the discs then letting them sit on a shelf. But yes, a CD would be great, I’d keep a One CD sealed for sure.

[@user-tzzglsstle585e38]

@@JShortsFR Ayo, a fellow Album 'One' Enjoyer, cheers

[@ShortHax]

Remember, somewhere out there in the world when man has put his last block, a kid has just put his first

[@regenpalkar4385]

LongHax

[@grilledwaffle]

when I read the very last part of this.... the video finished and the song ended... felt kinda nice

[@ocsanik502]

@@grilledwaffle Same

[@TheBinklemNetwork]

I forget the second half far too often.

[@bluetowel-reko]

Thats deep

[@juciy8599]

As long as C418’s music is still in the game I’m completely fine with it

[@YanSimiGamingi2]

bad news they removed 85% of the old music

[@abhmed]

​@@YanSimiGamingi2don't lie

[@ProsecutorValentine]

@@YanSimiGamingi2 If that was the case it would make it all over the gaming news reports and people would be complaining.

[@YanSimiGamingi2]

@@abhmed i dont. the chance of old music playing is 25 % 1.20 has more old music because only a few new tracks got added

[@vennax810]

Same bro

[@ubiquityxx]

C418’s work on the Cookie Clicker soundtrack is amazing. He has a Bandcamp page as well if you want more of his work.

[@Bentroen_]

Heck yeah! I bought the Steam version just for his music =)

[@Plututo]

FACTS, C418’s music works so well in cookie clicker

[@twilightwolfpiano]

Click is my favourite song in that album

[@theunluckyidiot]

wow just checked in on cookie clicker the game is so different now i gotta play sometime

[@BranchBruh]

@@twilightwolfpiano yes!

[@zachbernstein3804]

Let this sink in: his Alpha Volume (all the survival tracks) is getting a super prestigious award from Billboard. That music is up there with the diamond tracks released in our history.

[@Gusenichka925]

C418 music IS up there with diamond tracks

[@heftymagic4814]

mental illness pfp lmao

[@Tachy_Bunker]

Billboard awards is nothing else than popularity driven shows, it doesnt matter, what matters is that its goo music.

[@Gusenichka925]

@@Tachy_Bunker didnt even understand what you said

[@Tachy_Bunker]

@@Gusenichka925 billboard awards are not so focused on artistic views or the effort than the money they get from their choice

[@allyfelii]

The part where he says that when the music plays, doing a seemingly mundane task suddenly becomes more meaningful is what really got me. This is because this is very true. Whenever I played minecraft in the past, I turned off the music. But now, whenever I turn off the music it feels like a big part of what makes this game so special to me is missing.

[@britishneko3906]

yeah... especially when doing anything underground... the task feels more time consuming and is harder to accomplish... but when the song just pops in outa nowhere... all that tiredness goes away like my xp after grinding so hard on getting em

[@kimberlycarter369]

I’m a musician but, there is something about in game music that makes me immediately turn it off. Sadly this goes for Dan’s music as well. However, I do like to achieve/find the discs and play them in game.

[@leeccilee7605]

I like the feeling of loneliness the music gives me. Like I'm really all alone on a world and trying to build me a life there

[@slicky3397]

Same shit happened to me

[@Slynch25]

Always good to let your brain wander for a bit if you don't regularly do it.

[@nikolkapochcalova8405]

Whenever I hear a song from C418, I feel a weird emotion. I am not sad, not happy, not chill, not angry.. just.. nothing.. like pure nostalgia.

[@TautaS123]

Yes

[@sQuEeZyMaN13]

That is a very simplistic yet perfectly explained description of what it feels like to listen to the soundtrack.

[@sQuEeZyMaN13]

An emotion that does not yet have a name. “This song makes me ceefoureightious”

[@BingoGo2Space]

True. The new minecraft music are nice, but they just feel cheaper than the masterpiece we've got, much more cheaper.

[@caden5936]

It’s worth pointing out that he also made the music for the Steam version of Cookie Clicker, which came out this year, and it’s actually really good.

[@theseangle]

wait wha rly?

[@caden5936]

@@theseangle Yeah! You can listen to the soundtrack on pretty much all major music streaming platforms and see that C418 is the composer.

[@VlidOnTheLead]

oh!

[@Dakoya]

Cookie clicker is dang legendary. Worth having on your CV haha. Will check it out thank you!

[@marse5729]

Oh, I didn't know it was actually FOR cookie clicker. I just thought he made it because he really likes cookie clicker lol

[@12beesinatrenchcoat]

I just want to say that C418’s “Excursions” is one of my favorite albums ever and everyone should go listen to it. (And also C418 recently did some music for Cookie Clicker!)

[@brunoaleixo9828]

and your comment was stolen by a verified bot

[@cocobruh]

@@brunoaleixo9828 who... cares?

[@Pavalineox]

Excursions blows the Minecraft volume albums out of the water it's insane

[@niccy266]

My favorite album is 148, but I really love the songs on Excursions like Beton

[@IceFlanYT]

I like Figure 8 a bit too much

[@xXxKAMIKAZExXx]

C418 owning 100% of the rights to his own music it pretty awesome. Not everyone gets to have such control over their own productions.

[@Theunicorn2012]

C418 owning 100% of the rights to his own music it pretty awesome. Not everyone gets to have such control over their own producations.

[@spicydong317]

@@Theunicorn2012 what

[@MarcABrown-tt1fp]

@Spicy Dong Bots be botting haha.

[@largerootbeer2019]

C418 owning 100% of the rights to his own music it pretty awesome. Not everyone gets to have such control over their own productions.

[@localidiot4116]

@@largerootbeer2019 what

[@YeahImDylan]

man this takes me back, when i used to stay the night at my friend's house in 2014 we would play Minecraft, and c148 would come on and we would build big things like huge hotels, mansions, and we even made huge spiders and bugs. now i don't see them anymore because they have a life, having jobs and living at their own house. And this music reminds me of those memories.

[@poisonousiodine1769]

Just want to make it known that in-between and after Volume Alpha, Volume Beta, and the 1.13 singles, C418 never really disappeared. Its really anything but. Hes fairly active on twitter and still makes music (as far as I know). Hes made some absolutely incredible albums that have nothing to do with the Minecraft OST. If you want to check his stuff out Id recommend starting with Excursions and One.

[@adamtuico390]

Excursions is the shit all those tracks just make me feel something that no other music does for me

[@frodobaggins941]

Yes, but this video was in the context of Minecraft, not C418's other music.

[@yahirdoesbadvids]

He made music for cookie clicker pretty recently.

[@klefferhd]

In appriciation of C418: "May he alway randomly pop into our heads, and thus be never forgotten." A legend of our times, fallen to big corparations.

[@rocky-ie7li]

Minecraft isn't doing that bad tbh

[@muammar1895]

@@rocky-ie7li no

[@Gamer-pv2fv]

@@muammar1895 yes

[@muammar1895]

@@Gamer-pv2fv sure thing "gamer"

[@Gamer-pv2fv]

@@muammar1895 no

[@risingstar1309]

I personally think you’re spot on. This is precisely why I wasn’t happy when Microsoft acquired minecraft. I really don’t want Minecraft to feel corporate ya know

[@crazydragy4233]

Yup... Microsoft in general just kind of sucks. Not a surprise tho, since when do giant corporations have good business practises lol

[@Somethingaweful]

Unfortunately this seems common place same thing happened to two other legendary composers. Mick Gordon got screwed by Bethesda and Marti O’ Donnell got screwed by Activision.

[@infinitespace2520]

@@Somethingaweful Marty also hasn't been contacted by Microsoft

[@ScourJful]

@@Somethingaweful Eh, the Mick Gordon thing wasn't Bethesda's fault. Mick just never made all the songs he was supposed to on time, even though Bethesda gave him multiple delays. Trust me, Bethesda wanted Mick to do the soundtrack, but Mick didn't have that much interest it seems or just simply forgot. The fact that it came down to delaying the entire game just because it didn't have a soundtrack is indicative of Mick just doing the wrong thing. It's not black and white, but let's not act like Mick Gordon was innocent and betrayed when in reality he was given the full expenses and most leeway possible in the business just for him to not finish on time.

[@deletedkneecaps]

@Sasha Lemay java still feels good, bedrock is what’s disappointing

[@DanSolow]

C418 Stal disc is my favourite by far, so many times my character has woken up only for me to make him listen to that song while still getting pumped about the silly drops that song has, will never fail to make me happy. I miss you C418

[@armakeen3576]

C418's music will always be the best, his tracks make me so nostalgic

[@Dakoya]

The feeling of nostalgia should be something thought in schools ✨🦋

[@yaboycjm5581]

Lena Raine is outstanding I gotta say

[@TriflingToad]

C418 can make a song with good vibes, but Lena Raine can make a fuckin bop

[@caidenh04]

@@TriflingToad I think C418 tops Lena Raine imo

[@TriflingToad]

@@caidenh04 yeah for general music but not for music disks

[@kasnickijakub]

Im my opinion some music can/should be biome specific but most should stay as being random. I love just randomly hearing minecraft music while playing. I support the new artists as their music is phenomenal! I hope that mojang doesn't make too many biome/place specific music, but a few here and there isn't that bad.

[@nachoferrari240]

Yeah, the few biome specific music tracks makes those biomes feel more special

[@NebulatheZorua]

@@nachoferrari240 ^^ Terraria did it and their ost is.. REALLY good and fits the biomes, though Terraria has more obvious progression than Minecraft so that's probably why

[@joris4235]

Hahaha, no.. uhh no that’s just, oh Jesus, oh that’s just a bit cringe. Oh dear oh smithery smogs. That’s just ooh, terrible, no wonder you’re so silly

[@user-tzzglsstle585e38]

Meh, why change something that doesn't need to be changed.

[@HotboiEngineering]

I support him for trying to keep his masters. He's a real one for that.

[@nextosam.]

Meh, it's not an indie game anymore. It's definitely the right choice from mojang to have rights for the soundtrack

[@minoxiothethird]

@@nextosam. oh, really? which is why a record number of low people play minecraft, and why the majority of people still play on 1.7.10 and 1.8. it's the "right choice", for who though? barely anyone plays on the newer versions. go through public servers and you'll see just how dead the community actually is.

[@car_477]

@@minoxiothethird stop complaining

[@Slamm1nSalm0n]

​@@minoxiothethird Source: Dude, trust me

[@nextosam.]

@@minoxiothethird chill, man. 1.8 is great and all, but I'm talking about latest versions music, the Microsoft one. Having music they don't own is a whole lot of trouble they can afford to avoid. Plus in my, not unpopular, opinion, new releases are amazing, especially considering you get them for free

[@639hzEPD]

This is a very wholesome video. It’s so sad how the new composers have replaced C418. He is one of the greatest game composers ever.

[@norperz]

I urgently suggest everybody to give some of C418's music outside of minecraft a listen, everything is an absolute masterpiece. He wasn't just hired because he was in the right place at the right time, mainly because he has talent.

[@Xaaaach]

Oh yeah. I listen to Stal literally all the time. Such a good song.

[@user-tzzglsstle585e38]

@@Xaaaach You might wanna listen to his *other* albums and music as well, like One or Dief

[@honchokomodo]

Beton is a good starter

[@nelsonraley]

I’ve been saying this for years. Excursions is a masterpiece.

[@gray3589]

@A N G E L Intrested. Where can I hand one out in my garden to nurish my plants.

[@yoryapen]

Other artists may come, but C418's music has a special place in everyone's heart Dude made generations of gamers

[@soya9152]

C418's music makes me always play minecraft everytime, it also helps me sleep

[@lionhart1517]

I'll be honest, Microsoft should've just let C418 keep the rights to his music and let him keep working on Minecraft. It is truly sad, but I'm glad he is able to work on a new project. (Let's just hope Microsoft doesn't try and remove his music from Minecraft...)

[@CyanEight]

I would stop playing if C418’s music was removed

[@ミコ-たん]

Honestly, if microsoft removed C418's music, Minecraft wouldn't be Minecraft.

[@Turquoised]

I hope

[@TheJaguarthChannel]

They're slowly phasing out most of it. Reducing the chances of it playing with each update. Like how they're slowly phasing out (Java edition) in favor of Minecraft. Yes, Bedrock is sold as minecraft, but java edition is sold as an edition. Bedrock is the main character in the story now. Because unlike java edition, the xbox account has less rights than the old mojang accounts. It allows them to sell you skins, datapacks, worlds, ect. Opening up microtransactions in game. That's Microsoft for you, what once was free will no longer be. Slowly phase out Java, but promise they're not going to. They're just manipulating new players into abandoning it so that the OG minecrafters will just die out.

[@Number19MouseInBakedBeans]

@@TheJaguarthChannel ayo another og?

[@RickySama240]

Great video! Another great thing about C418 is that very soundtrack at "The End" area are slowed down compared to the overworld area. End soundtracks offer a sort of moment of solace allowing you to reflect upon your journey.. It definitely gives you the feels of how far you've come to fight the Ender Dragon. 😇🥰

[@alfredoooooooooooooooooooooooo]

I personally think that the biome-dependent music should also be played in other biomes, with less chance

[@nicknack125]

I agree, and also have non-biome specific music still play. My new base is is super deep down and I only ever get below y=0 music, to the point where I thought they removed the old stuff

[@D_benji373]

@@nicknack125 they should make it where you can disable biome specific music in the audio settings, like "Disable/Enable biome specific music?" or "play background music randomly?"

[@sexi_rexi4080]

They sould make that every song can be played in any biom but specific musics have biggaer chances of beeing played in specific bioms. I think this is a good middle ground

[@alfredoooooooooooooooooooooooo]

@@sexi_rexi4080 yeah thats basically what i commented but you made the idea better. thanks. thsi is what we need

[@larniieplayz6285]

Sure why not?

[@SkyeBerryJam]

I like the idea of biome specific music in this case, I'd never want each biome to have its own soundtrack, but a couple rare soundtracks for special areas like a flower field or mushroom biome or what they did in caves and clifs seems ok to me, almost like a little Easter egg for finding it

[@ineedpineapples]

Yeah cause as far as I could tell in game the other tracks still played in the meadow biomes and whatnot, it's just that the biome specific ones could *only* play in their own biome. I think it adds variety and a certain vibe to the biomes which is much needed. It's just a scaled down version of the nether and the end

[@Shyhalu]

Its not so much that - its that it was forced, not natural and certainly not built/well thought out.

[@Jesus-qv5sw]

Yes, or combining both.

[@steamingpileofspaghetti9755]

Yeah, but it gets really annoying if you actually want to live in that biome. That's why I'm ultimately against the non- random music. It's only nice the first few times you hear it.

[@Stryfe52]

@@steamingpileofspaghetti9755 can’t other tracks still be played in the biome though? It’s just that the biome’s unique track is only playable in that biome, and not other biomes.

[@AlonsoJoaquinComposer]

Im glad a big youtuber finally spoke of this, us composers tend to get screwed up a lot and there's not much we can do about it as our work goes unnoticed most of the time. Thanks Salc1!

[@shuvelstone1331]

Good luck with your music, my guy.

[@AlonsoJoaquinComposer]

@@shuvelstone1331 thanks!

[@Shyhalu]

If your work goes unnoticed, its not good. Stop signing bad deals and make better music.

[@yotsuba6352]

@@Shyhalu “If your work goes unnoticed, its not good”- What??

[@Shyhalu]

@@yotsuba6352 Are you illiterate? That was basic English.

[@kelownatechkid]

Tragic in a way but glorious in another. Best of luck to c418, his musical genius will live on forever!

[@Electric_Bagpipes]

The thing is, I _want_ it to work universally. Thats the thing about c418’s music, it works everywhere. Heck, why not just release the new Minecraft music volume as a standalone track without the name on it. As players we can just put it into the game ourselves.

[@d-zummyaldente6826]

YES this right here

[@KjelltheWolf]

Would be nice. The newer music always felt so.. different so... Modded... To wild. You know what i mean

[@aspenpaw0]

Sell us an album, which we install into the game with a mod or resource pack. Boom. Greatness achieved.

[@sheldonakintoye5480]

@@KjelltheWolf I've played with a few mods that add their own music and all I can say is that they new music doesn't personally give me those vibes.

[@KjelltheWolf]

@@sheldonakintoye5480 maybe It was the modpacks more than single mods. But on the other side. There are maaaannyyyy mods.

[@Odyssey_Central]

Wish they’d come to some sort of agreement. I’m still pained to this day that none of C418’s music made it into smash ultimate, likely due to this copyright situation.

[@casiooooooo]

I know I just want to hear mice in venus while playing steve

[@user-tzzglsstle585e38]

Most probably the same reason why his music is not on Smash, and it's a shame that C418 itself got shit for that instead of the companies and their lust to own everything...

[@darth3911]

@@user-tzzglsstle585e38 They don’t lust to own everything they lust for money and because of that they don’t want any risks of losing money such as lawsuits workers strikes slow production of products and so on.

[@bob450v4]

@@user-tzzglsstle585e38 it has nothing to do with money it would be cheaper to allow c418 to keep the copyright © it’s legal

[@TaylorLovelace]

I'm surprised you didn't mention Smash Bros. None of C418's tracks were included with the Minecraft DLC. There's a lot of speculation C418 refused to have his music in the game, and that's part of what pushed Microsoft to find new composers who'd outright sell the music rights.

[@Zacalacking]

it feels like mc is trying to distance themselves from c418

[@zealouswiz8789]

If Mojang had the choice, they'd absolutely put more c418 music in. However Microsoft is the issue, being a big company and all who wants to have ownership of the music before using it for anything since they don't wanna ask c418

[@Marshall.R]

To be fair, none of the tracks from the original Minecraft made it into the game whether they were composed by C418 or not so I doubt that has too much bearing on the situation

[@jonathandiaz5622]

To be fair I do remember Sakurai saying that since most of Minecraft’s iconic music(mostly c418’s work) is calm and relaxing, it wouldn’t fit within smash bros. Now if that is true, then it makes some sense, but then again I’m pretty sure that not all music in smash isn’t calm and relaxing.

[@darth3911]

@@zealouswiz8789 It’s not nearly just that but they also want complete ownership of everything in the game incase of a lawsuit for a example Herobrine used to be in the default Xbox skin packs but Microsoft removed it because according to them it was not owned by them sense they did not create the character sense Microsoft doesn’t own the music it’s also vary likely that other games will refuse to put the music in there games C418 is probably ok with it being played in Smash but you also have to remember Nintendo is a company also and sense they don’t have a agreement with C418 do they really want to risk having a lawsuit for using it? the answer is clearly no.

[@Matty002]

i remember trying minecraft when it was still 'new' and loving the music i started playing again earlier this year and the music was just.... fine. i miss early minecraft music

[@therustynovel7911]

When the soundtrack played back then, we appreciated the music. But when the soundtrack plays now, we appreciate the memories.

[@lucasc5622]

Wow so deep bro

[@SirAU]

It feels like I understood each and every word you said.

[@jacktheflash8478]

True

[@tomatosauce5775]

Even it never makes it in the game, I really hope that volume gamma would come out at some point.

[@reynerules]

We all miss C418. All the great songs, listening them for hours at a time. It’s really sad to see him go. Long live C418.

[@Dakoya]

He’s still there as he has been gone for a while. Only difference is that in place of some of his randomness, order and system came out

[@j.r.7339]

What are you talking about?! He has a ton of other Albums

[@TheBossua]

like the cookie clicker soundtrack on steam its pretty good tbh

[@user-tzzglsstle585e38]

@@j.r.7339 They meant he'll probably never make another Minecraft music, not the one that'll be heard in-game officially.

[@revalone3944]

minecraft is not minecraft without c418. i remember hearing the soundtrack coming out of a crappy tv speaker at my friends house in 2012. good times.

[@aidank68]

While Lena Raine's and Kumi's music are good, listening to some of C418's music still brings tears to my eyes sometimes.

[@Krotos]

same

[@puss404]

absolutely same

[@Pigness7]

every time C418's music comes on it gives me a feeling that I just cant describe, its nostalgic, kinda makes me sad a little bit, those good old days are gone now :(

[@Krotos]

+1

[@Dakoya]

Take in these feelings and let them power your intentions to make new everlasting memories ✨🦋

[@scense6934]

The human brain will romanticise the past. Wasn't as good as you think....

[@Dakoya]

@@scense6934 wasn’t as good as you “MIGHT” think. I don’t think it’s wrong to romanticise the past. For history is just the starting point of the future

[@scense6934]

@@Dakoya Im only saying people always say "The Good OLd DAys" just so they dont have to accept change

[@Flora_Dawn]

I prefer c418, his music honestly brings a warm and comforting feeling, even with all the mobs it’s ok. It feels like it pulls you from reality and into the game for you to just get lost in this little blocky world.

[@sharmasookarry408]

I agree it brings back memories of just mining in a cave and I get just random music that's beautiful and it almost makes me cry now

[@iambread2914]

@@sharmasookarry408 Cave music: Hey I heard you were having a good time

[@WreeperXD]

ye

[@erikr4325]

I strongly agree

[@3manonmusic435]

I just wanna state that even though the words like "billions of dollars" in this video, you managed to make this video feel relatively downscale, solely to focus on c418, who is a huge inspiration for my own work. Not only is he an inspiration in this video, but the story you managed to portray. Thank you. I will continue and thrive my own musical career.

[@chriswilliams-oh8yq]

I just hope Microsoft doesn't remove the music after adding enough disc's to warrant taking away tracks. I know it would not fly with the community, but Microsoft is greedy enough.

[@typicalmountainbiker]

I think that they may take it away in the Bedrock Edition but leave it in the Java Edition for much longer since a lot of the Java community will be much angrier about that than a lot of the Bedrock community

[@mrkirby8622]

@@typicalmountainbiker That'd be a huge parity issue between the 2 made on purpose. I don't think they'd split them again

[@Player-jh4ko]

@@mrkirby8622 Right

[@deltacat27]

Bruh no, the backlash against that would be insane and Microsoft knows it. They may be greedy, but they're not stupid.

[@mystic-malevolence]

Watch the "how to mod C418 music back into Minecraft" videos that would come out after that

[@thelionoob]

his music has a very unique feel to it. The simplicity and slight melancholy really fit the lonely and calm mood of Minecraft. The echoed piano that doesn't sound like it was recorded on a studio but rather feels like it's coming from someone's living room is my favorite. The new music is by no means bad, but gives off more adventure-y vibes rather tha c418's comforting and home-y tone.

[@BVSSIC]

@mechakid37 I think they're just as good.

[@saschabinder2570]

@@BVSSIC I dont think so. The old tunes just slap.

[@Sans-oc1ie]

With Lena you can hear every instrument and know what it is. C418 you had no idea how he made his sound.

[@therelaxingwonders]

Wet hands

[@FirebaII0]

@@saschabinder2570the have a comfort to them like if your mom or grandma or just someone you love chose to play the piano for you and no one except you

[@Yourname942]

C418 should have a Patreon and people should pay him to make "custom" music for Minecraft (like a mod) It's not the same without his music.

[@yasterday5377]

The custom music could be added as a modular resource pack, similar to how Vanilla Tweaks resource packs work

[@johnranut9151]

@@yasterday5377 wouldn’t be worth it for him, he is better off releasing his album on his own and then let the internet get its hands on it. Then it will do well without Minecraft haha

[@hannahdeards9652]

I mean, people on patreon can make BANK. Especially since he's a well known guy, he could make some serious money.

[@ThunderBlastvideo]

Well, there is a mod that allows you to add custom music to the game.... Just saying...

[@RealityRogue]

Patreon just doesn’t work for that formula. It would more likely be music commissions

[@edwardgamerx9061]

Something that I would personally like is a music selector, something similar to what Smash Brothers has. It could work as a toggle feature that allows you to enable, and if activated you can pick which songs play more often. Therefore people can choose to stay with the random/biome locked songs to play as they normally do, or however the player wants to.

[@Vaidiss]

C418 leaving is like a family member dying without you saying goodbye, we will all miss his music and creating our childhoods with music we never knew would be so nostalgic edit: ngl ever since c418's music played i can still imagine his name written on every world minecraft makes, from just being wood-stone-leaves and grass, to now having biomes, mountains, more wood types and beds

[@Ethaniel1999]

This makes me incredibly sad. When you showed beta with the music in the background it almost made me tear up a little. I love C418's music so much. I really think Kumi is better at getting the C418 feel than Lena. Ill be honest, there's really only two or three tracks I actually like that are by Lena but the others are mostly inoffensive.

[@rainingBrackets]

Yeah, while i like Pigstep and Otherside it certainly doesn't have the same feel as the iconic Mc music. Kumi's music fits seamlessly with C418's classic tracks

[@karmatical5837]

At the end, its not the same, its other thing. The music of new artists is good, this is a agreement, but the C418 music will not be replaced at all, cannot be recreated, this is not bad at all, will be 2 eras of minecraft in the soundtrack history. The Classic Minecraft Music - Include old disks, background musics and more The New Minecraft Music - new artists, disks, background musics and more

[@Trogloglation]

I don’t think Lena is trying to go for the same feel as C418 at all, which I am perfectly fine with. While I would also have been fine with keeping the music only to C418’s, I also feel like with how expansive and colourful Minecraft has gotten, keeping the OST to a single "colour" is kind of a missed opportunity. Please note that my point has nothing to do with making the tracks biome-specific. That’s an entirely different matter that isn’t really related to Lena and Kumi’s music.

[@JShortsFR]

I agree. I respect Lena Raine’s work, especially in Celeste, the emotion and feeling she puts into it warrants calling it art, but I just can’t get the Minecraft feel out of her music. To me, it just doesn’t fit in with the tone of the game. Kumi is a step in the right direction, I believe, and while it’s not the same as C418, it does feel more “‘Minecraft” than anything Lena has made so far. Again, love her work, it just doesn’t capture the feeling that C418’s music does for me.

[@user-tzzglsstle585e38]

@@rainingBrackets I don't mind the 2 new disc as much as the new overworld music, at least the disc is not supposed to replicate that game feeling of the game in general, the new 1.18 music though....

[@kaidoshun143]

I‘m glad he still owns his masterpieces

[@mrrandom5043]

Minecraft isn't Minecraft without C418 he's the guy wo made me fell in love with Minecraft only cause of his music i got peace in Minecraft eventhough Microsoft hires too costly or top composers but for us og players C418 will be the god of Minecraft music till eternity its sad seeing his legacy fade away but im happy that he gave us some beautiful memories we will never forget

[@sunvieightmaster88]

C418 is one of that person that had made many people's childhood amazing. Wish we would still get more musics from him.

[@lynxfyre-z3l]

Go listen to his other stuff, its just as good and even better than his work for minecraft

[@calebmufford2747]

C418 will forever hold a special place in players hearts. I'd love to see Daniel, and Lena, and Kumi all making music for minecraft. They are each amazing composers, and great music makes the game come alive!

[@zenseplayz3289]

Your profile pic with the music in the background is making me sad and happy at the same time

[@josephbostaph9773]

I’m actually sad...I grew up on this game and the music really made me “feel” when I played this game. C418 Deserves every bit of recognition for Creating millions of happy memories. I just hate to see him almost pushed aside....Well that’s what it feels like anyway.

[@S0ME_GUY]

Go listen to his actual music, Minecraft isn't his only work

[@CarlosAM1]

@@S0ME_GUY To all people who are willing to do this, may I heavily recommend his excursions album and dief albums. They are as good if not better than most minecraft songs

[@josephtung5280]

hello fellow joseph

[@aletlee179]

@@CarlosAM1 "ONE" Album is a masterpiece especially the last song "Tsuki no Koibumi" a collaboration with Laura Shigihara

[@CarlosAM1]

@@aletlee179 also good, but I personally prefer Excursions overall

[@ThreadBareHope1234]

I noticed that, too. That the music is location specific. I was building in a savanna a while ago and heard the same two songs on repeat, and with sadness, I had to turn off the music before it got annoying.

[@masterdeetectiv9520]

Uhm theres no location specific tracks for the savannah biome. Do you know which track it was

[@ThreadBareHope1234]

@@masterdeetectiv9520 One More Day (Overworld)

[@masterdeetectiv9520]

@@ThreadBareHope1234 well it plays everywhere in the world, so maybe you just got unlucky

[@ThreadBareHope1234]

@@masterdeetectiv9520 Probably

[@jakobr_]

Huge respect to Daniel for owning his creations and keeping them available for everyone to enjoy. Props to the new composers, too, for doing their best to emulate the “Minecraft music style”.

Sal's video production quality has really gotten better over the years - amazing video :)

[@SalC1]

Good to hear! Always trying to improve with every video.

[@bonkmaykr]

This

[@idontknowwhatimdoinghelp8078]

Ew sub botter

[@graphic.by.eli2]

@@SalC1 lit

@@idontknowwhatimdoinghelp8078 how am i a sub botter? LOL

[@zelda1420]

When I first started Minecraft, I was young, and didn't know that C418 was the composer of Minecraft's music. When I saw "-C418" at the end of each music disc, I thought, maybe that's the kind of disc the music is in, or something like that. His name was so deeply embedded into the game, that I never even gave it a second thought. When Pigstep came out, and didn't say C418, but said Lena Raine, I was quite surprised. I had heard Lena's name before, from Celeste's soundtrack, and it took me just a bit longer to realize all C418 did for Minecraft, and for us.

[@RealSekiroGamerz]

He's our memory maker bro we need him back in Minecraft

[@TheGalacticPenguin]

same

[@NorthernLaw_]

It's pretty disappointing seeing the outcome of this. While it's normal for game studios to buy music and then own 100% of it, they should make an exception for C418. Give him the money he deserves, you can afford it, and let him keep ownership of his music while still licensing it for use in Minecraft. Would not only be giving C418 what he wants, but giving the players what they want, not to mention the huge PR boost. The only downside is losing a few million, which is pennies for Microsoft, and then the problem of other composers wanting to also add their music and own it which won't be possible or current composers already in the game trying to do the same. I hope one day Microsoft realizes they made a mistake and they go back on this. The good thing is thanks to mods, we can still put C418s new music and any music we want for that matter in the game.

[@ghostperson2455]

Im really going to miss C418's music, I think given the resources from Microsoft he could have gone so much farther and made Minecraft possibly even more immersive and deep. I really hope someday he can make another Minecraft song, even if it was only one. Thx for the likes boys

[@JustA.Person]

Well, big companies are terrible. They probably gave him an ultimatum that he had to give them all rights to his music or something else he didn't agree with. It's understandable that he'd want to keep ownership of his own music. And yes it's really sad and I wish there was another way but I'd prefer him not to do something he wouldn't like.

[@CHKNSkratch]

Step 1. Get c418 to release that finished album Step 2. Make resource pack with the new songs Step 3. Profit

[@lunecker]

2:14 that moment right here, when the music kicked in, plus the commentary, made a huge smile on my face and i almost got tears in my eyes. That was insanely on point and combined with a huge wave of nostalgia made me almost cry. Damn, I love this game so much

[@dragonman0372]

i just started crying when i herd it

[@heftymagic4814]

fascist flag lmao

[@cy3rtronn_360]

What's the title of that music?? I can't find it.

[@N4SCARfaN]

@@cy3rtronn_360 Mice on Venus

[@Threat_LvL]

when its getting dark and starts raining... damn i love this game

[@primtones]

C418 sounds inspired by Kraftwerk's early stuff, especially "Morgenspaziergang" from 1974's Autobahn has the same calm ambient piano soundscape. The soft analogue synth is also from the Kraftwerk sound palette. And they're all German too.