The Incredible Depth of BTS Black Swan | BTS Music Explained

  Рет қаралды 5,767

Andrew Berg

Andrew Berg

Күн бұрын

Пікірлер: 121
@Kourinthia
@Kourinthia 2 жыл бұрын
In classical rhetoric (like Socrates and Cicero) the three part repitition is called tricolon. It's used not just for emphasis but to "hook" your brain and create a memory. The human brain is conditioned to pick up on repitition but only after it recognizes it as such. Twice is weird, thrice is repitition. "Black Swan" is really good at doing this musically, both lyrically and instrumentally, but less total repitition and more of a variation on theme.
@pambarab5506
@pambarab5506 2 жыл бұрын
Good one, Andrew! All of the art projects that BTS were funding came out first, so the art film came out in Jan 2020, the album came out in Feb 2020, and the MV came out in March 2020, and it was a surprise that we didn't expect. I love the differences in the art film and the MV. They have totally different tones and feelings, besides the music itself. I loved the deep dive into it, I always learn so much from your lectures!
@AndrewBergSax
@AndrewBergSax 2 жыл бұрын
Oh I can only imagine what it would have been like to be ARMY at that time!! And I'm so happy you liked the video 😊
@sunshinesam6399
@sunshinesam6399 2 жыл бұрын
@@AndrewBergSax very chaotic. It was panic all over because the mv just dropped with no warning
@vikzytoria
@vikzytoria 2 жыл бұрын
​@@AndrewBergSax omg I remember being on like day 3 of comeback streaming with no sleep...it was super early morning, I can't remember the exact hour, but I had JUST told my friend I needed sleep. Then BAM, Black Swan dropped and when I tell you we were shocked, confused, souls ascended....And even as a surprise, the views were INSANE. It was pretty cool considering one meaning of Black Swan is something that is unforeseen and unpredictable. GENIUSES
@itmfiddler
@itmfiddler 2 жыл бұрын
Wow. This was brilliant and I totally see how your theory fits. I don’t know if it’s what BTS was thinking when they did black swan, but I hope so because it is a beautiful theory. I was once a dancer, a musician, and a martial artist. It was all that was good in my life. When I lost them, due to medical reasons, it was, and remains, a painful death. Martha Graham’s quote has always spoken to me because of it. When I’ve listened to this song before, and it’s a tough one emotionally, I never saw beyond that top level story. Thank you for opening my eyes to what more it could be, maybe now I can enjoy this beautiful song from a different perspective without the pain. Your videos diving deep into the BTS songs are wonderful, thank you for them.
@ejentabi
@ejentabi 2 жыл бұрын
Very good points. Provided their original plan was after releasing MOS7, World Tour, then started their chapter 2. Although it turned out something else, but the more I relisten this album, the more that I felt they are preparing ARMY to accept the fact that it is time to let them move on and to try individuals' projects. Black Swan was indeed their master peice, but the whole album is still amazing which I always find something new day by day listening (especially with a good headphone.
@MarinaEariel
@MarinaEariel 2 жыл бұрын
Black Swan to me sounds now like "we're getting into this feeling as a group, we need to pause and see inside ourselves before we lose the passion completely"
@imajinallthepurple
@imajinallthepurple 2 жыл бұрын
You honestly never seize to impress me, Andrew, with the way you're always able to convey your vast knowledge and continuosly prove just how brilliant the guys are. This video was just one big wauw for me. I absolutely love your new approach. 💜😲👍💜
@AndrewBergSax
@AndrewBergSax 2 жыл бұрын
Thank you so much, I'm really glad you enjoyed it!! 💜
@drop-of-poison.007
@drop-of-poison.007 2 жыл бұрын
Fantastic analysis! I love your channel, very interesting content 💜
@bt6248
@bt6248 2 жыл бұрын
Black Swan---a work of art about losing passion and inspiration for art. This one hits harder post-Festa, when RM expressed his "just keep swimming" turmoil after MOTS7. So much food for thought in your analysis, Andrew. Thank you! (Also at 7:50, yes, it works. Any excuse to include Run BTS clips.)
@AndrewBergSax
@AndrewBergSax 2 жыл бұрын
Thank you!! When I was trying to think of a clip that worked for counterpoint, I just about lost it when I thought of this screaming 😂
@bt6248
@bt6248 2 жыл бұрын
@@AndrewBergSax I wonder if you'll be able to make a musical application for flying yoga. Here's hoping!
@AndrewBergSax
@AndrewBergSax 2 жыл бұрын
Flying yoga?!
@bt6248
@bt6248 2 жыл бұрын
👀
@alaska1538
@alaska1538 2 жыл бұрын
I thoroughly enjoyed this video! Made me see all those little artistic points I would have missed otherwise. Blackswan is definitely one of those songs with great musical quality and depth , a real validation of BTS' success and talent 💜
@MariaChavez-ey5sr
@MariaChavez-ey5sr 2 жыл бұрын
What a thoughtful interpretation and I really enjoyed this especially the clips like Jimin “I’m so lovely” as an example.
@cesmariano2969
@cesmariano2969 2 жыл бұрын
Ah! OMG!!! Andrew, this explanation/breakdown is so unique and yet I think it is the most correct or at least it caught all the details surrounding this song and its MVs and versions. And you put all those details in a basket and voila! It makes sense! This is one of my favorite BTS songs but I have always found myself wondering why it feels so close and relatable to me, me who is neither a musician nor a dancer or any other type of artist whatsoever. Although I do understand that it can refer to passion for anything for that matter. But as it turns out, it is actually relatable to anyone. And it's not just the lyrics, it's the actual music. It's because the theme is actually referring to a person, any person... and his/her/their persona, shadow and ego. I have always thought that Black Swan mostly delves into the realm of the shadow (based on its placement/position in the album and its "dark" theme). But, oh wow! This is the missing layer I never thought I was looking for. There truly are so many levels of understanding BTS' music. It reminds me of how you and a couple of other musician reaction channels explained why Lie is such a good piece of music and how clever it is. It's like having night-vision goggles, you'll only see things if you are equipped with the tools/means to see them. Thank you for sharing that with us. From now on I'm trusting you as my night-vision goggles. Borahae! :)
@AndrewBergSax
@AndrewBergSax 2 жыл бұрын
I am so excited to be night-vision goggles!!! 😀 it's so fun for me to make these videos because although you are just experiencing my theories, I've been delving deeper into them for a couple weeks and I just keep finding more things to pile on. This is so fun for me. Hahaha
@dharshere
@dharshere 2 жыл бұрын
I relate to that too and I'm so thankful for creators like Andrew for equipping us to take in bts content in whole different but still incredibly amazing perspective!
@lizzysmom8899
@lizzysmom8899 2 жыл бұрын
Here comes a long one... This is my interpretation of the choreography of the art film. I believe the dancers in black represent the shadow of the main dancer. At first, they are controlling him, almost abusing him. Then, he begins to fight the shadow, trying to break free, but they hold him back, imprisoning him. You can almost see him thinking that, if he could just escape from the shadow, he could fly (succeed/be happy). However, once he breaks free he finds he still cannot fly. In the discordant section, I see his movements as struggling to fly and not understanding why he can't. After he goes down, he encounters the shadow once again but this time, he takes control/accepts the shadow. That's when the shadow begins following his movements. After this acceptance and control of the shadow he once again tries to fly, and the shadow actually helps him to fly. He is whole and can finally be free. There are 2 parts of the lyrics that I interpret differently. To me, Do your thang is all the people around them telling them to keep doing what has made them successful, but What's my thang is them struggling with a loss of purpose. The other lyric is Film it now. BTS is constantly surrounded by cameras. Someone is recording everything, even as they fall apart inside. It's like they're saying that they don't even have privacy in their darkest moments. Someone is always watching. "I'm dying inside, but sure, make sure you get it on film." I think this reflects their frustration with stardom, the loss of their inner selves. Anyway, thanks for reading this, if you got this far...
@smrutishikharath3025
@smrutishikharath3025 2 жыл бұрын
When you said that the second "do your thang" is like a cry for help, I literally cried... I'm going through that phase right now although I'm not an artist, but I can exactly feel the meaning behind the song so much than ever before and thank you so much for posting this today I was literally thinking about this song today.... I needed this today..... The first death they're talking about is soooo painful I had no idea.....
@AndrewBergSax
@AndrewBergSax 2 жыл бұрын
😭😭 I'm so sorry you're going through a rough time, but I really hope you're able to find the solution that's best for you 💜
@kyce7too
@kyce7too 2 жыл бұрын
I love your insight to Black Swan, love how you were able to connect the 2 MVs and to tell the difference between them. I got another layer to this amazing masterpiece. Your in-depth analysis of the song is really great. I appreciate the song more and your explanations make it easier for us to understand. Love the BTS Music Explained series. Great job Andrew!
@almostpsych
@almostpsych 2 жыл бұрын
I really really like this kind of video essay tying together what's happening musically and metaphorically in the song. It's really engaging.
@deliaconny
@deliaconny 2 жыл бұрын
Oh okay! I have to say i never thought more about representations of persona/ego within the song Black Swan, since i just sorted it into the shadow section of everything. But... your theory and explanation does sound rather convincing. And, it's also the first main song in the "shadow" section of the MOTS:7 album (excluding intro/interlude/outro here), thus right at the change from Persona to Shadow. anyway, thank you for giving us your insights into some more of the details going on in this song (or two different versions of this song)! 💜 🥕 CFA
@_btsarmyjenn9420
@_btsarmyjenn9420 2 жыл бұрын
I love your breakdowns! 💜
@dreamzbts6585
@dreamzbts6585 2 жыл бұрын
I want add 1 more observation, from what we have understood from 2022 Festa, MOTS 7 in which Black Swan appears was supposed to be last phase of their chapter 1 That is SO interesting because the way I see it, this song can be interpreted as the studio version being them hitting that point as an artist where they feel lost(hence so much darkness in the mv) and them finding their path as Chapter 2(hence more light in the orchestral version) also the orchestral version ends with the protagonist flying while other dancers support them, I'm interpreting this as, though in chapter 2 BTS individual members will be taking off to fly, the other members will support one another EDIT: To add to 13:47, when the track released for the 1st time Armys were not able tell apart who is singing which part & I feel it was intentionally done to mix their voices to sound like ONE polished voice
@cyndilou8182
@cyndilou8182 2 жыл бұрын
Andrew, I always love your perspective on the BTS songs and music. Being a “new” ARMY just fallen down the rabbit hole, you have a pretty good grasp on the music and thoughts behind them. The GUYS would be proud of your videos. They never just put out a song without a lot of thought into each of them and you caught on quickly to that. Plus you are surrounded by some great ARMY that are never afraid to share with you. Keep the videos coming, I love them. Borahae 💜💜💜💜💜
@AngelaSealana
@AngelaSealana 2 жыл бұрын
Bro, you just blew my mind with that last assertion. I'm impressed! How did you do that!!?!? And why did you do this to my after my therapy session?? 🤣😅 Wow.
@AndrewBergSax
@AndrewBergSax 2 жыл бұрын
Hahaha this is the epiphany I had that one day where I finally found the idea for the video. It's so fun thinking of these things 😀
@noirmvs15
@noirmvs15 2 жыл бұрын
Thank you for this explanation of Black Swan. Such a masterpiece from BTS
@vikzytoria
@vikzytoria 2 жыл бұрын
Black Swan is on my Top 5 ever and it is the first song that my elderly dad just fell in love with. This was a great, and even, very emotional breakdown (ha pun). It is so sorrowful to imagine losing a love like that. BUT. Can you imagine having something in your life that you live and breathe and love so much that you feel your life would end if you lost it? such passion. sigh
@rafaelsmith5737
@rafaelsmith5737 2 жыл бұрын
I think the transition from the line "do your thang" to "what's my thang?" Is talking about the loss of passion Feels like an artist who's very passionate to draw every single day, and days turned into years and it keeps repeating, till his passion turned dull to the point we're the artist ask "why do I draw?" As an artist the thought of that is really scary, like you already know that you will lose all your passion like how you encounter your first death It's suffocating and at the same time it's killing you slowly So when the line say "film me now, film me now" I think it means to capture every moment before the time where you'll lose your "thang"
@rafaelsmith5737
@rafaelsmith5737 10 ай бұрын
BTS is like an artist that painstakingly draw masterpieces every single day, they work day and night just to make those masterpiece perfect as possible however their works barely has any attention cause people can't even begin to understand it, but never gave up cause they think one day people will start to realize how great those pieces were However, one day a disaster struck and everyone was devastated, so the artist tried to draw the simplest doodle to cheer everyone up but that doodle that he drew half heartedly with not much effort became the highlight of his career instead The simplest doodle got him so much attention and so much profit compared to the masterpieces that he painstakingly draw from the past that he doesn't know to react Cause It's like all his hardwork from before were like a joke So he felt conflicted, but then decided to draw another one, hoping it could win an award in a particular drawing competition as a gift for his fans before he has to leave but to no avail So he decided to just draw one last one in purpose to cheer everyone up Though those doodles got him easy money, he wasn't happy cause it felt like he betrayed himself and the people who liked his previous works from before
@donitapolk9413
@donitapolk9413 2 жыл бұрын
ANDREEEEEWWWWWW!! #nailonthehead I love this deep dive and it ALL makes sense. #repetitivefingersnaps An amazingly awesome explanation! 💜
@AndrewBergSax
@AndrewBergSax 2 жыл бұрын
Hahahaha thank you so much!
@skybluepink998
@skybluepink998 2 жыл бұрын
Wow Andrew===your outdoing yourself. Completely fascinating and I feel like I am learning things about music all along the way.
@AndrewBergSax
@AndrewBergSax 2 жыл бұрын
Thank you so much!!
@Jakeein
@Jakeein 2 жыл бұрын
What an excellent explanation of Black Swan. Your breakdown opened my eyes to a different way of looking at the song. Keep these types of videos coming.
@AndrewBergSax
@AndrewBergSax 2 жыл бұрын
Thank you so much! I'm really glad you enjoyed it 💜
@VAngel876
@VAngel876 2 жыл бұрын
Another great analysis of the music of BTS. Thank you for working so hard on this content and helping us understand the music and how it fits with the lyrics.
@debhouckscraftycottage
@debhouckscraftycottage 2 жыл бұрын
This was great. I had a thought, not so deep as you went, and that is that the timing (early 2020) was when BTS were considering how they should move forward as a group (which we didn't know at that time). They pushed off their "break" to do solo works and such until the pandemic just about ended in order to help ARMY through it, and put out more uplifting songs. However, they were struggling personally as "What's My Thang" indicates. I think in one of their lives they even mentioned that they were considering taking this "break" (Ha! Not a break really) a while ago, but couldn't. Anyway, I do think BTS was really having a hard time figuring out where to go as a group from that point forward and the song is fitting. It's a masterpiece really and was my introduction to BTS. Never looked back. I hope that all made sense.
@minrand2
@minrand2 2 жыл бұрын
Wow 💜💜💜it does make sense especially if BTS was preparing all of us for a change. However, the change that happened was not what they expected since English lyrics and a song blowing up(just like its name) and the catching me in its net. The world needed this detour before they were able to do ‘their thing’. The time is now 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
@cayothega1454
@cayothega1454 2 жыл бұрын
Whoa! Andrew, this time you went beyond depths! I was amazed by your analysis all along! So great!
@kaylyndunbar6414
@kaylyndunbar6414 2 жыл бұрын
Andrew, WOW, that's all I can say. The analogy of the 3 components of the orchestral, studio music's and the lyrics just blew my mind...it clicked in my head. I love watching certain reactors when they delve into BTS songs, you are the first I think I've seen that breaks down the actual music though. Well done! I am no way musical technical or otherwise. I only know what I like. You've helped to broaden my perceptions greatly. Thank you!!
@greneet
@greneet 2 жыл бұрын
Got SUPER excited when I got the notification that you had done another Music Explained and couldn't wait to get home to watch. You do such an amazing job and I hope you enjoy doing these. I can see your confidence and a growing personal strength. I truly look forward to these, I may not be a musician but I am a musical nerd...a BTS nerd, ha! I'm glad you are one too. Please keep doing these as long as you get an enjoyment from them, because you are giving a lot of yourself to do them. Thank you for that too.
@AndrewBergSax
@AndrewBergSax 2 жыл бұрын
Oh I love these even more than the reactions! Haha I feel like this is my true KZbin calling 😂
@sjm5750
@sjm5750 2 жыл бұрын
Wow!!! I love this reaction video. I have seen this MV over 100 times. I never caught the fact that the white outfit is never seen after the wings scene. This might be my most favorite reaction from you. Thank you so much for this! Great analysis.
@AndrewBergSax
@AndrewBergSax 2 жыл бұрын
Thank you so much, I really appreciate it!! 💜
@sjm5750
@sjm5750 2 жыл бұрын
@@AndrewBergSax I didn’t specifically mention this in my initial comments but I really like you how you analyzed Persona, Shadow and Ego in the song. That is incredible, college paper worthy analysis 😂.
@AndrewBergSax
@AndrewBergSax 2 жыл бұрын
Thank you! Honestly it blew my mind when I first had the theory and the more I researched, the more excited I got about talking about all of it. Especially with the ego. I didn't even consider that at first until I just happened to read the part about how it stands at the junction between the two worlds. That was a really exciting day for me. Hahaha
@sjm5750
@sjm5750 2 жыл бұрын
@@AndrewBergSax I got so excited about your video I posted it on my Facebook wall as a public posting for any and all to see. Then I also shared it with my local BTS group chapter. Then shared it with an ARMY friend over the phone. I too was 🤯.
@AndrewBergSax
@AndrewBergSax 2 жыл бұрын
That's so nice of you!!! I appreciate that so much and I'm really so glad you enjoyed it 😊
@MariaClara_x
@MariaClara_x 2 жыл бұрын
I loved the persona, shadow and ego theory!!
@AndrewBergSax
@AndrewBergSax 2 жыл бұрын
Thank you! I was so excited when I thought about it!
@VictryAngel619
@VictryAngel619 2 жыл бұрын
This series of videos just gets better and better. Black Swan was my gateway into BTS so I was really looking forward to this breakdown and you absolutely did not disappoint! 💜
@AndrewBergSax
@AndrewBergSax 2 жыл бұрын
Thank you so much, I really appreciate that!! 💜
@christinen9104
@christinen9104 2 жыл бұрын
This was an amazing analysis…loved it! 💜
@c-dragon4286
@c-dragon4286 2 жыл бұрын
Wow! That was a really cool analysis, thank you.
@keciaandthepurpleheart2961
@keciaandthepurpleheart2961 2 жыл бұрын
Black Swan is probably my favorite BTS song. If someone reacts to it, I watch. Andrew, this was the BEST Black Swan reaction ever! I will never listen to the song quite the same way again, and that is a beautiful thang. Thank you for taking the time to look this closely at the song.
@princesamarulina
@princesamarulina 2 жыл бұрын
Yes, you are finally as crazy as all of us, and presenting your own theories with quotes, WELCOME!!! I loved your analysis and your interpretation. The nerd passion that you show in this video is awesome (I don't know if you could see the hashtag "BTSnerd" the past days!). A dancer who reacted to both videos noticed something else: in the orchestra version, the main character is finally free and flies, while in the performance that they (BTS) do, they end exactly at the same position as the beginning, and it could mean (I'm overanalyzing now the dancer's words) that doubt, that potential death (Suga sings how he is in his studio and will never fall again, but... he is still needing to work in music, and what if his heart doesn't beat anymore? Also, it ends with the "what's my thing?"). Thinking about how they were ending their chapter 1 with this disc (it was their idea before the pandemic and the cancelled tour), and how the characters in the BU are pushed to look for the Map of the Soul (and it means the individuation; in the case of BTS members, they exploring themselves as solo artists), I think that it would be really interesting to think of BTS' persona doubting about which path would follow, and their shadow... maybe... like "but I want to be an artist, not just an idol" -yes, I'm pushing you again to analyze Idol-. Well, sorry, my many words show you that you were really accurate and concise. Congratulations, and thank you very much.
@AndrewBergSax
@AndrewBergSax 2 жыл бұрын
Ohhhhh that's really interesting!! And I have seen the BTSnerd hashing! Also Idol may be kind of soon 👀
@dharshere
@dharshere 2 жыл бұрын
I'm an army and I absolutely love reading theories on bts content but your little nerd rant here is driving me insane with thoughts🤯 Seriously I need to check the comments sections more often! I'm finding gems today 🤩😲 Ok bye I 💜 You
@rkivemagic
@rkivemagic 2 жыл бұрын
i already thought that black swan was an absolute masterpiece but seeing the lyrics and hearing the song from a musician's perspective made me love and appreciate this work of art even more, this song is beyond beautiful and the message is so much deeper than it seems! your explanation was very detailed and interesting, it helped me understand the song in a deeper way and realize how many important details i missed in the lyrics, beat, rap and vocals and music video, it all makes a lot of sense now. black swan is truly a brilliant song, both versions are amazing!💜 very good video!
@reyyy8882
@reyyy8882 2 жыл бұрын
Loved loved loved loved this!!!
@n.w.3863
@n.w.3863 2 жыл бұрын
Thanks for the great and informative analysis! Black Swan is my favorite song and now that I have better and deeper understanding for it I love it even more. Thanks again for the great video ☺💜.
@henwenwendy7368
@henwenwendy7368 2 жыл бұрын
Very interesting, Andrew! Thank you!
@spreadlove4094
@spreadlove4094 2 жыл бұрын
Love this video!!!!!!
@lollipop2900
@lollipop2900 2 жыл бұрын
Mr Berg! Best music teacher ever 😊
@AndrewBergSax
@AndrewBergSax 2 жыл бұрын
🤩 thank you!!!
@alnilamorionis5994
@alnilamorionis5994 2 жыл бұрын
Ooooohhh! That's very interesting. It aligns with the analysis done by Bookish Theories, but it's really cool to see how the musical aspect of it ties together across the two videos. Thank you!
@shannonnevermindgirl2479
@shannonnevermindgirl2479 2 жыл бұрын
Oh awesome...it would be so cool if BTS could see this!
@lalaking7974
@lalaking7974 2 жыл бұрын
I loved the breaking down the differences in the "Persona" and "Shadow" videos (as well as your thoughts on the role of the vocals!) I had heard about the video with the dance troupe but hadn't seen it. After watching you analyze it, I immediately watched it along with watching the versions I'd already seen. I LOVE content creators the bring different perspectives on BTS and help us to see/hear even MORE new, brilliant things.
@Rabbitwarren_7
@Rabbitwarren_7 2 жыл бұрын
Andrew, you have such a brilliant way of explaining music so that people can understand. I bet you are the most amazing music teacher. Black Swan is one of my ultimate favorite BTS songs so thank you for doing this, I loved it💜
@AndrewBergSax
@AndrewBergSax 2 жыл бұрын
💜
@threesubeh
@threesubeh 2 жыл бұрын
Excellent video Andrew 💜
@sichengbestboy9667
@sichengbestboy9667 2 жыл бұрын
I love this!! thank you ^^
@mandeefarley1399
@mandeefarley1399 2 жыл бұрын
Dude, you just blew my mind. The lyrics are the Ego?!! 🤯
@AndrewBergSax
@AndrewBergSax 2 жыл бұрын
🤯
@mccallumha1
@mccallumha1 2 жыл бұрын
Really good, Andrew. Black Swan is a really special one and I think you nailed its power. Loving these analyses!
@cynthiaperez2232
@cynthiaperez2232 2 жыл бұрын
Andrew, I was so anxious when I saw this video in my feed, just knew I would have to set some uninterrupted time aside for you -- so that's why I'm late getting to it. Genius. Just genius. Your theory makes absolutely perfect sense. Sent shivers down my spine. How does BTS/Big Hit keep doing this to us?!! I love this and am going to save it to watch later as well.
@ladymystyque
@ladymystyque 2 жыл бұрын
Thank you so much for this analysis. I love seeing this and peeling back the layers of this song that is my personal favorite of theirs. and understanding more about the melody and how it reflects both the dance and the lyrics and it works together to create such a complex meaning. I have a lot of songs that are favorites but something about this one just captures me. I still vividly rememer how hard this song impacted me when it dropped. I cried on first listen and though i have listened too many times to it by now it still catches me by surprise sometimes.
@erinblunt8183
@erinblunt8183 2 жыл бұрын
Fabulous Andrew. 👌🏻 a brilliantly thought provoking analysis.
@gretchend6823
@gretchend6823 2 жыл бұрын
Great video. As always, love your descriptions of the music but your pulling it all together at the end with the persona, shadow and finally the ego really caught my attention. Very interesting! 💜
@penchychan
@penchychan 2 жыл бұрын
Andrew, for real. You just blew my mind with that last section 🤯 It never crossed my mind! Please keep doing this series!! I am learning so much from you! Borahae! 💜💜💜💜
@AndrewBergSax
@AndrewBergSax 2 жыл бұрын
Thank you so much!!
@minitwink16
@minitwink16 2 жыл бұрын
Thanks Andrew. Once again, this was beautiful. I love music and with BTS I'm beginning to see so much colour in music. Your explanation is like the zoom in on those colours. Thank you.
@akankshayadav28
@akankshayadav28 2 жыл бұрын
You just gained a new subscriber because I've been an army since 2016 and your videos just keep reminding me why I fell in love with them in the first place.... This video was specially really good 💜💜💜
@boraheart613
@boraheart613 2 жыл бұрын
That was amazing Andrew! While watching, I imagine you teaching this in your class 🥰
@JLisme
@JLisme 2 жыл бұрын
Niiice! Also, yes, your amazing vocals helped... And were amusing. Jimin also did a good job of showing an example. 🤭
@karinacasco1895
@karinacasco1895 2 жыл бұрын
I love your reaction and explanation . When the art film was released I was so exited with it 🖤💜🖤💜
@mae__
@mae__ 2 жыл бұрын
Super interesting! I could write so many things so just thank you for that quality breakdown otherwise it's gonna be too long!! That theory at the end: persona- studio Ego- vocals Shadow- orchestral Definitely stands, it would make sense! Good one
@MariaClara_x
@MariaClara_x 2 жыл бұрын
Na moral, aplaudindo de pé esse vídeo 👏👏👏👏💜
@KaterynaM_UA
@KaterynaM_UA 2 жыл бұрын
wow, what an interesting way to look at it! Loved hearing your thoughts, I have no idea idea if it was meant to be like that originally but it definitely makes sense to me!!
@amyoconnell3936
@amyoconnell3936 Жыл бұрын
My life has been crazy lately, so I am only seeing this now. What a fantastic analysis! The editing with the overlays of the multiple video and audio tracks really made what you were saying very clear. I totally buy your ego theory, btw.
@gardengirl1020
@gardengirl1020 2 жыл бұрын
👏👏👏💜💜💜🤟Thank you
@raspberrytaegi
@raspberrytaegi Жыл бұрын
such a thoughtful and beautiful analysis!
@dsherwood3889
@dsherwood3889 2 жыл бұрын
To me the violins represent an ever increasing anxiety that takes over while trying to "do my thing" replacing the passion that has gone or is dwindling. I live with anxiety and low emotional affect so I deal with this all the time. When I find something that I enjoy or become curious about it is inevitable that one day maybe weeks or years later, that joy or curiosity goes away and I'm left with anxiety while doing the thing I used to enjoy doing. This may not be what they meant but it's what connected to me while listening to the song. Also I always put pressure on my self to "Do your thing" but I don't know "What's my thing , what's my thing?" because it always changes and there's long phases where there is no interest in anything. Anyway I'm new to BTS, 56 yrs old and really love this song.
@namastan5580
@namastan5580 2 жыл бұрын
WOW! 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
@sjm5750
@sjm5750 2 жыл бұрын
Wohoo! I finally got the answer right. I’ve been wrong for the past several weeks.
@dharshere
@dharshere 2 жыл бұрын
Black swan is one of my absolute favorites off bts and that's from me with no musical knowledge so knowing even a little bit of a musical perspective into it fascinates and amazes me and now I can see the or better, hear the song in a different and enhanced light(or sound lol 😂) Thank you!
@alexa5958
@alexa5958 2 жыл бұрын
Yes! I guessed right! 💜🎉
@AndrewBergSax
@AndrewBergSax 2 жыл бұрын
Woooo!!! Not many people have been getting them right recently 😂
@rkivemagic
@rkivemagic 2 жыл бұрын
not black swan related but the 4th anniversary of namjoon's mixtape "mono" is coming and i'd really love it if you react to it! mono is an incredibly beautiful album!💗
@Kourinthia
@Kourinthia 2 жыл бұрын
Moonchild is my comfort song. "Mono" was the album I found during COVID and really needed to hear when I did. I would love to see Andrew do this!
@DarkWing494
@DarkWing494 2 жыл бұрын
Well either you are right or you would make an excellent conspiracy theorists 🤣. I'm convinced either way this is the best music theory I have ever seen👍
@AndrewBergSax
@AndrewBergSax 2 жыл бұрын
Hahahahaha I'll take it! 😂
@shellyperry1810
@shellyperry1810 2 жыл бұрын
Fantastic
@AndrewBergSax
@AndrewBergSax 2 жыл бұрын
Thank you so much!
@MariaClara_x
@MariaClara_x 2 жыл бұрын
YAAAAAAAY
@AndrewBergSax
@AndrewBergSax 2 жыл бұрын
Hahahaha I love that you commented before even watching 😂
@MariaClara_x
@MariaClara_x 2 жыл бұрын
I was excited to watch!
@MariaClara_x
@MariaClara_x 2 жыл бұрын
I had to finish a meeting, I’m watching now. Super cool video!! I love your deep analyses!! Just would turn your voice a bit up comparing to the song :)
@dreamgloww6650
@dreamgloww6650 5 ай бұрын
i miss you guys! hope everything"s ok
@purplejin0913
@purplejin0913 2 жыл бұрын
深入淺出❤❤❤
@bpc0077
@bpc0077 2 жыл бұрын
Andrew...can i ask a popular question...why does bts didnt win the grammy??. Or this one: if u can be a panel , what song and why wld u vote.. I really like how much u appreciate bts' songs that i am appalled why they havent got one ..i mean, what else cld be the reason ?
@vivianmso
@vivianmso 2 жыл бұрын
💜
Why Musicians LOVE Jimin's 'Lie' | BTS Music Explained
13:10
Andrew Berg
Рет қаралды 20 М.
兔子姐姐最终逃走了吗?#小丑#兔子警官#家庭
00:58
小蚂蚁和小宇宙
Рет қаралды 14 МЛН
Миллионер | 2 - серия
16:04
Million Show
Рет қаралды 1,8 МЛН
Smart Sigma Kid #funny #sigma
00:14
CRAZY GREAPA
Рет қаралды 88 МЛН
I listened to nothing but BTS for a week
19:45
Relly Moorer
Рет қаралды 363 М.
hilarious things bts say
11:56
TaeZa
Рет қаралды 210 М.
SO MUCH HYPE! BTS - MMA 2016 Reaction | Down the BTS Rabbit Hole
21:22