The mind-boggling Key and Ring Puzzle!!

[@RadElNew]

Takes a big man to upload an experience like this. Respect

[@majortom8990]

It's always the simple things. Good analogy to life. Look both ways.

[@raffaelepiccini3405]

This would have never worked on me, I'm always confused about which way a thread should go, so i always end up trying both ways lol

[@anastasiacline6159]

@@Vintage4815 except if the object your tightening/loosening is on the opposite side of the object you're working on or underneath and you're reaching around, then it becomes a mind twister. I actually had to learn it through my engineering course using the right hand rule. Imagine an arrow painted on your thumb and fingers pointing towards your nails. Grasp the bolt or screw (whatever will be moving) by curling your fingers around it and point your thumb like you're giving a thumbs up 👍 if you rotate the moving screw or bolt in the direction your fingers are pointing it will thread on/off in the direction your thumb is pointing. For left handed screws you just use your left hand to get the same method. Probably why they're called left handed screws.

[@Nidht]

@@anastasiacline6159 That's a great method! Reminds me of how you determine magnetic field lines based on current. For bicycle pedal threading, it's mirrored. That way the left pedal doesn't unthread while you cycle! The rule here is to imagine the direction the wheels would rotate. To tighten, rotate the pedal threading in the direction the wheel would roll when moving forward, regardless of the side you're standing on, and the reverse to loosen.

[@drewt.4353]

Same

[@Sinsanatis]

@@Vintage4815 “anticlockwise” huh...

[@davidmoody7450]

Same. If it dont move one way try the other. I saw the pic of the video an I was hummm something has to unscrew.

[@sonofriggnarok9320]

I'm a little upset that's all it was.

[@technodrome]

The solution ended up being what I thought it would be, but I was hoping there was some crazy trick.

[@operastudio1238]

Last Slice of Pizza same here. I was picturing there was some spring loaded “compress and turn” mechanism... but no. 😇

[@chamcham123]

I thought maybe the rivet in the front was a button.

[@יונתןספיר-ח5ט]

Same here bro

[@copperguy1209]

Easy

[@ritchards]

So the solution was... sinister.

[@BosmanHa]

😂😂It was indeed

[@fawful9992]

"Truth had gone truth had gone and truth had gone. Ah now truth is asleep in the darkness of the sinister hand." -Zero

[@jbrisby]

And a little gauche.

[@justinwhite2725]

Literally.

[@CR-iz1od]

I was routing for a internal lock driven by the spinning parts, I'm disappointed

[@DanielGarcia-ir8oe]

That's not even a puzzle. Its just a dismantling. Its like the person trying to break through an iron door and it wasn't locked

[@bigpoppabotch3523]

No it's actually pretty clever, the only solution is to do something no one would be likely to try.

[@thaitea1833]

Yepp exactly.. This is no puzle at all.. Same as if u dont know how to open a bottle.. All u need just rotate the top of bottle, then you ready to drink...

[@klausstock8020]

@@bigpoppabotch3523 Actually, I faced a puzzle like this, just in form of a screw and a nut (right-handed, as usual, but spot welded so the nut could not be removed) and a hidden left-handed thread in the screw's head. I got to the idea of a left-handed thread being hidden somewhere pretty fast (I have some experience with gas hoses which have left-handed threads so you cannot use your water installation material for gas), but I had injured my hand a few days ago, so I couldn't apply enough force to unscrew it. The guy who gave me the puzzle had actually said that no significant force would be needed to solve it, but he had no idea how insignificant the force was I could apply. So I ended up screwing around for several minutes...well - not screwing - screwing around - even though I had guessed the solution pretty early. Of course, my prior gas installation knowledge helped.

[@unknownx8164]

It could be a puzzle if there are another things you need to do before you actually solve it. In this case it's not even so much of a puzzle.

[@bigpoppabotch3523]

@@klausstock8020 I don't know man, your response has an appropriate amount of periods for its length, but still reads like a run-on sentence. I just don't know how to feel about what you wrote...

[@DDragon1226]

Sometimes, the best way to trick the clever is that there is no trick at all. It's a mind trap.

[@EliasMcCloud]

LOL your selfdisappointed reaction is the Best 😂

[@Mr.Puzzle]

🤗

[@kellynevada4844]

5:20 i hope it saves some of your time. Remembering you have only 24 hours a day dont waate it.

[@lilwhoadie8405]

I hate waateing time

[@onyxlily2230]

Thank you

[@bhupendrapatel9807]

Thanks

[@DexterCreations]

Thankyou.hehe

[@chununanunan4040]

knew it would be one of those damn detachables...

[@hadzhere]

Being left-handed and always screwing things the wrong way...I would have solved it instantly...haha

[@Mr.Puzzle]

🤣👌

[@ThisPeasant]

Same i woud accidently solve in in like 1min

[@tsb_creation_offical8696]

time waste!!!!!!

[@jayfredrickson8632]

I never remember which way to turn so I would have been trying both ways.

[@sentientcomet]

Same here lol

[@beaconofwierd1883]

Probably the most dissapointing puzzle I’ve seen. Looks very intriguing and promises a lot with it’s design, but then just farts out a screw. Everyone who liked this comment thinks that AndrewWithEase is the loser in the so called ”Debate” bellow.

[@gaiamission7200]

No! Thats its beauty the simplicity of something a master would struggle with its so goddamn elegant just swapping thread directions to throw off any conventional attempt, my first thought when i saw it was "hidden screw" but with it being a left handed thread i would've sooner cut the thing in two than actually figure it out, anyone can make a difficult puzzle few can do so with a single change

[@frogs1341]

@@ChaosLord5129 hey kid. If you disagree with someone, state why. Calling them names isn’t going to help. It just makes *you* look like the idiot.

[@Luminoxie]

@@gaiamission7200 I agree, sometimes the best solution is the easiest one. Overthinking it can make it more difficult on yourself.

[@bunathan2485]

@@ChaosLord5129 your on the internet.

[@ultrasparrow]

@@ChaosLord5129 calm tf down holy shit 🤣 you on that roid rage

[@vangildermichael1767]

That puzzle is a good life lesson. That you should not take anything as a given. Always examine each node completely. Forwards and backwards.

[@tamirerez2547]

Your honesty is very convincing, very impressive!! Not many people can simply say "I don't know" when they don't know... I happy you did it!!! You deserve it!!

[@AlucardNoir]

There is this thing called the Mathematics Olympiad. I heard of these guys that were a year or two younger then me back in high school who went to it and qualified for it. When they got back, in their final year they had to take a series of test - similar to the SAT's in the US. They failed the tests because they thought they looked to easy and spent the whole two hours trying to find out what the "real" problems were.

[@ThePallidor]

This is exactly why IQ tests don't work for the highest IQ people. They're good as a basic filter around the average, but they can't tell you if someone is a supergenius.

[@nundata]

of course that never happened-i went to math talents highschool and most people i know went to olympics. they all killed all sat and similar shit. if its easy they solve it - they never think question has a trick part but they look for solution. they just finish any of those tests in ten minutes and leave

[@jurgenhoke3393]

Genial, weil im Grunde so einfach. Mittlerweile vermutet man ja gerade in den Metall-Puzzles einen hochkomplizierten inneren Mechanismus (versteckte magnetische Widerstände und so Sachen). Aber da muss man erst mal drauf kommen, eine Schraube rechtsrum aufzudrehen :-)

[@Mr.Puzzle]

Absolut 👍

[@danielleking262]

I'll be honest, I would've tried both directions because there's no way the key can come off unless one of the ends unscrews, so you know it HAS to come off in some way, lol

[@goodwillhart]

Does the end still screw off if the other rotating bits are screwed up tight? Also, any idea what the brass bit was about?

[@Mac_Omegaly]

As a dyslexic I turn screws both ways to figure out which way it would work, because both directions are the same to me. Lol

[@joratto2833]

Dyslexic people can’t tell left from right??

[@Mac_Omegaly]

@@joratto2833 summery: That is just one symptom of dyslexia. Dyslexia is a wide ranged definition for a brain nerve condition that can be manifested in a number of ways. And ussally to get the official diagnosis is to have something like 10 of the 37 possible manifestations. So you could have 3 people diagnosed with dyslexia but have completely different symptoms. There are also things that overlap with dyslexia but are more likely related to other more specific conditions. But yes, generally dyslexic people have confusion on in areas involving order, direction, and identifying patterns. I had problems swapping "b" and "d" when hand writting. I can point right and think "right" but say "left". I have problems with solving arithmetic in my head and swap numbers around. (Especially 3 and 7 for some odd reason.) And problems holding detailed instructions in my head in the right order. (So if you spell out a word 7 letters or longer I most likely won't be able to figure out that word.) And the previously mentioned spelling issues. *(esspecally in double letters and silent letters) Now, I have learned ways to cope with some of these issues but it is still frustrating when my brain knows to say one thing and my mouth says the other. When there are two options that are opposites (like ) I can't remember the lable for them. I hold up my hands and look for the letter L for my left hand, but they are both "L"'s to my mind *(for like 20 seconds before I think how I would write the letter.) So just like that clockwise and counterclockwise are clear different concepts but I can't recall the lable for which one will tighten or loosen the screw. *(maybe it also didn't help I had a backwards watch in middle school because I could read time faster if it was backwards.) Now there are a few different ways you can have dyslexia, including hitting your head before you are an adult. And there are cases of a girl in England that hit her head this way, got dyslexia which made everything look upside down and backwards, and struggled with it for 3 years before hitting her head again, and getting cured. You can get it from a chemical imbalance in your infant years. And there are still mysterious cases that defy explination. But if you still struggle with dyslexia as an adult, there is nothing that can be further done beyond the exercises you were most likely taught in school to help bypass areas you struggle in. Now certain kinds of Dyslexia have an advantage. Since we have to think outside the box to solve common struggles, most Dyslexic adults are able to deal with certain kinds of events better then those who have never had much of a struggle through their school life. And some of the greatest inventions have been created by dyslexic minds. *(a fun topic to search yourself.)

[@joratto2833]

@@Mac_Omegaly Thanks so much for the detailed reply! Totally fascinating. Like many people, I imagine, I always thought dyslexia was only about the “lexia” stuff, but of course it makes perfect sense that the abnormalities that would lead to reading trouble would also affect other forms of pattern recognition/distinction. It’s especially interesting that you say you can point right, think “right”, and yet still say “left”. If you don’t mind me asking, how?? Is it in any way related to split-brain syndrome, which renders the speech centre of the brain unable to communicate with other parts?

[@Mac_Omegaly]

@@joratto2833 I would have to dig up and research more what the exsact differance is. And not all dyslexics have this particular issue, but my guess is that certain binary data is swapped like a flipped lens in a telescope with my issue. While the split brain issue would be more like a dirty lens in the telescope. (At least that's how the differance was explained to me.) The right and left sides of the brain are importaint to have good communication with each other. But Dyslexia can sometimes effect only one side of a person's brain. One might guess that a person could have both problems. But I am no expert and don't personally know much on this subject. And the only reason I know a bit about it, is because I have the issue and wrote a paper on Dyslexia about 15 years ago. So my knowledge is a bit old on the subject. The human brain and the nervous system is a wonder on many levels. And there is a lot of things we still have to learn about them, and will still learn about long into the future.

[@callumbillington8395]

How can you not retain such information..? Hold out your hand, I'm 50% sure it's your right hand you lifted, you dig? It's black/white, up/down, yes/no two options 🤷‍♂️ I don't mean to be rude but how do you fair in everyday life if you can't retain such info..? 🤔

[@TheVaperMan]

It would be helpful if you checked out the availability of the puzzle you are showing with the web sites you post. Only found one place that is offering the Key & Ring puzzle and it’s out of stock!

[@BenieTheDragon]

I thought it would be one of those "align the notches" puzzle, since the back and front of the key can be rotated. The solution blew me away.

[@HowRandomIsRandom]

Same here. I was trying to find some correlation between the teeth of the key and the rotations.

[@davidhelsem8794]

@@HowRandomIsRandom that is why they are there; to throw you off.

[@trickyricky2903]

Thank you for being honest and posting the genuine first attempt, I think it might have been tempting to reshoot it and show yourself get the easy (when you know how) solution right away. The genuine attempt is much more entertaining!

[@smg97791]

How can this be considered a puzzle? “Puzzles” like this are just gimmicks. Doesn’t require any thought, just knowing where the trick component is.

[@practicalintuition4030]

Make your own puzzles, bro. If you really feel that way go for it.

[@eustacehendrix9659]

Figuring out where that trick component is already requires a lot of thought. To "puzzle" is to confuse so it did it's job as far as the definition is concerned. Puzzles mostly rely on gimmicks so your argument is stupid.

[@ibieiniid4240]

5:45 lmao as he's telling us there's no other way but right handed in his mind, trying to screw it back in right handed

[@Ved_Vatts]

Thank you! 7 mins were saved

[@markfisher7962]

Yes, I noticed he was unscrewing it when he was trying to start the threads.

[@TheElrondo]

Was fun to watch! Sadly it's a real easy solution after finding the lefthanded thread. There should be some more stages and it would be great puzzle.

[@lifetake3103]

yea it goes from unsolved to solved in one step. And overall not a lot of mechanical thinking having to be done

[@sixchiensblancs]

I agree, although not easy, it is too easy, if you know what I mean.

[@WgWilliams]

One time I got a new fan and tried for 10 minutes to screw the bolt in to fix the fan blade to the base. Not thinking about it being threaded left so when the blade spins it does not loosen, I almost broke it forcing it to thread righthanded. I was cussing at it the whole time until I realized my mistake.

[@stevebuddy567]

@@WgWilliams a simple glance at the threads should tell you instantly! always suspect left hand threads on something that rotates... like the lug nuts on the driver's side on my 1972 Fargo truck.. no joke lol

[@kellyrickard3833]

I love seeing your first attempt

[@Mr.Puzzle]

Thanks, I did not like it myself. Fail! 😊 Part of the game. :)

[@kellyrickard3833]

@@Mr.Puzzle no you did great!! I loved your frustration it was cute

[@kylen6430]

My favorite part was when he tried to put it back on, he still turned it the wrong way at first

[@kyleguajardo]

Overthinking, the bane of Mr. Puzzle's formidable mind. :) I like this puzzle, it is well made and just fun.

[@arbov169]

sometimes being too "smart" is hinderance.

[@paulsangiorgio3093]

jeeboy25 1 TL;DR what you see is most certainly proficiency, but maybe not quite intelligence. i disagree, being smart includes creative problem solving/ innovative thinking. Being experienced with common puzzle mechanics doesn’t fully indicate intelligence for me but rather shows a type of professionalism that comes with experience only. On the other hand I think treating every puzzle with the same orders of procedure and then using what is commonly called “outside the box” thinking when I run out of practiced “tricks” is what I try to use to determine my next move.

[@hrishikeshkashyap3715]

@@paulsangiorgio3093 ... No offense, but as long as Mr Puzzle continues to entertain us, your beliefs don't bother any of us.

[@NumbBloodHound0]

Being smart is having knowledge, being wise is knowing when you need the knowledge and when you dont.

[@sapelesteve]

I just knew that there had to be a twist to that puzzle. Glad that you figured it out.......... :)

[@pepperonipizza8200]

Puzzle was so easy, Mr. Puzzle needed to make his own obstacles for more video.

[@tiagorodrigues6962]

The kEY to solving this puzzle appeared at the moment where you'd think "SCREW this puzzle"

[@YOURS1]

What part makes it a puzzle? Stupid part i guess!

[@IRISHKENZO]

Lol, that's great, a lot of people including myself would of never thought of turning it left, always righty tightly lefty loosely. On another note, I'm making it a habit to watch the ads all the way through for the you tubers who really put effort into a video for our amusement, Mr puzzle you really uped your game over the last six or so months with your up loads and it's greatly appreciated, so thank you and keep up the great work. It's worth a few minutes to watch an ad if it means you'll make out. Can't wait for the next puzzle.

[@Mr.Puzzle]

Thanks a lot! I think an add is considered being watched by KZbin after 5 seconds. 👍

[@babayagx]

I just love how he says "mister puzzle" everytime

[@alexisheart428]

I dont know if i would of done it quicker or not but i defiantly would of over thought it just like you did.

[@robnelson1574]

The always charming and fun to watch Mr.Puzzle has worked on too many complicated puzzles and almost over-thought the key.

[@reggiep75]

Hahaha that is simple but shrewd!! With most nations having a high density of right handed people, the thought of turning something left handed totally skips the mind and the misdirection of having numerous moving parts only makes people stray from the solution until a moving part is determined to be functional or a distraction. I approve this puzzle as a left-hander and had thought it may have been more difficult but it was smart to go with left handed threading.

[@terryv]

Really quite clever in its simplicity.

[@maranatha1115]

The first puzzle I solved before you!! 😂🙌🏽

[@Mr.Puzzle]

Well done!

[@WhatAboutTheBee]

Is a left handed thread really a puzzle? I usually don't guess the correct answer but in this case, my guess was left handed thread, right away. I'd rate it a 0.1 on a scale of 1 to 5. Brave of you to post your puzzlement of such an obvious answer.

[@marrellray]

Nice puzzle for display...when he did the close up, I saw it coming. I work with mechanics and figured it was a left handed thread trick to it.

[@glanni]

It's so good looking!

[@NDPuzzles]

Haha, amazing! these puzzles are definitelly MADE for engineers. I wouldn have totally failed at this one myself ;) how does somebody even dare to think about a left-handed thread?

[@y2a1979]

Anyone who ever used oxy-fuel welding equipment would probably think of it, also, since one of the hoses always has a reverse thread so that you can't accidentally put them on the wrong tanks. :)

[@Dr.K.Wette_BE]

😆Nice one ! I would have solved it immediately, because I always turn screw the wrong way first... 🙄

[@LordNest66]

This is beautiful puzzle. Nobody would have thought it was a left handed screw.

[@KeZaRo0o]

So you were too smart to solve this puzzle quickly, how ironic? it's very sneaky and technical puzzle, I like it.

[@Vggincidently]

The left handed thread AND the distracting oversized ring AND the notches on the 🔑 so many avenues. Great Puzzle.

[@Zentron]

Looks nice, but I realised how to solve it before the spoiler break.

[@linaklimova560]

It was very fan, thanks 😂

[@ottarkraemer9001]

Wonderful to see that even you can get stumped by a level 2 puzzle. ;) This principle is borrowed directly from another iteration of the exact same key-ring puzzle from some other manufacturer, though. I have seen it many times at magic conventions.

[@MrHarpless]

Well that was fun! Keep them coming!

[@jaredharris1970]

If someone said I’ll give u a grand if you can get this ring off this key the first thing I’d think of is to look for weaknesses in the metal put in a vice and wack with hammer lol

[@sapphirelight748]

Love the first attempt solves

[@Rhomeme]

Great video like all the rest. It is hard on the ego when you are bested by something simple. Especially when it is public. Love these kind of puzzles, elegant, simple, intuitively obvious but not immediately apparent, so easy it is hard. I have a left handed thread screw puzzle and it is a beautiful thing. Equally as much fun watching someone attempt to solve as solving myself. As a machinist I am dealing with mechanical connections and mating fits constantly, threads being the most common, so for me it was a no-brainer. Keep on puzzling!

[@brianallen9810]

Mr. Puzzle is puzzled. I can't wait till Puzzlemaster carries it.

[@mork6668]

Actually, this time my intuition was right, and it was solved the way I was thinking :)

[@fk319fk]

These are the puzzles I like for my guests to play with when they come around. They are simple and easy but require a "trick". There are a few red-hearings which I also like.

[@JFomo]

Lol this is one of those puzzles where a child would have solved in a minute wheres as i probably would have ended up angle grinding the key in half 🤣

[@Mr.Puzzle]

Oh yes! I just got an idea for a nice episode! 😁

[@KetansaCreatesArt]

Same thing happened to me with a camera. The on/off switch of the camera broke in the middle of documenting my project material. We decided to remove the screw cap on the switch and turn it on internally. At the site in a small town, every one came to help me unscrew the cap. A crowd gathered around me on the street. No one could do it. Then at my hotel room I tried to unscrew it in the tightening direction, and it came off smoothly. 😑

[@lezhaosicne6387]

big facepalm right there

[@f1awsy]

thats a genius level puzzle. perfectly simple making it impossibly difficult.

[@hayessquared5662]

You could say that Mr. Puzzle got.... Puzzled 😎

[@mrpuneet1]

LEFT HANDED THREAD TAKES THE LEAD

[@kyleguajardo]

Damn it English language...

[@davidhelsem8794]

Now, it's a horse race.

[@stinkingfishguitars1362]

Nice editing with the spoiler break but I just preferred the simple black screen

[@luispalma6917]

The sneaky left handed thread! Only the sand puzzle can be more difficult. 10 minutes was fast, i would take 10 days.

[@Morishintaru]

Great looking puzzle, funny that you couldn't figure it out for that long :D

[@Name-js5uq]

That was really really good... I loved it a lot.its great to see you struggle once in a while.

[@TheDBZCollector]

At 3:18. I might have figured it out. Time to find out

[@BrandonMcBadass]

Which parts the key?

[@theywhoplaysgames6513]

For these type of physical puzzles something has to be removed or disconnected in order for a solution to even be yielded. But if that piece were not removable, it would have truly been impossible for the bronze ring to be removed simply by attempting to slide it off the key's edges.

[@NiNja10Doh]

I would absolutely love to have that puzzle, I'm left-handed and I thought that was really cool.

[@oblivionfade]

This is probably one of the most ingeniously simple puzzles I've ever seen in my life. ALL IT TAKES IS FOR YOU TO TURN BACKWARDS BUT NO ONE DOES IT.

[@EduardoWeidmanBarijan]

What a beautiful puzzle for a simple solution. Hey, nice spoiler break song! It makes everyone happy.

[@sid_._._xxdd]

How did the ring get inside?

[@mireksoja9063]

If unscrewing the tip didn't work, the last resort that would not damage the ring would probably be to try to apply the thermal expansion of the metal.

[@Eitner100]

Great fun the way you explain the tricks. Thank you!

[@superhunk1989]

This puzzle is easy, but it has great details.

[@longbow6416]

Used to right hand loosen. Laughs in 14x1 lefthand ak barrel threads :) You're a joy to listen to! Keep it up!

[@stefanf922]

My first thought would be rubbing the copper ring in the shaft maybe to generate an electro magnetic current.

[@Mepholar]

Those cut away panning shots are great.!Made me excited for the spoiler break.

[@robertmeadows1657]

You're such a delightful fella.

[@larryeifler2994]

The flush handle on a toilet is left-threaded. Also, the fan blades on my fan are attached with a left-threaded attachment. Are left-side bicycle cranks left-threaded?

[@bakedspade]

This was hilarious. Love this channel.

[@andrewwhited]

Nice production on this one

[@debdottir]

That was great! I thought 2+ different parts had to be aligned.

[@MYZS]

Ayyy been a while, welcome back

[@raz0229]

03:17 This is how I spend all day solving a puzzle!

[@Ciaolo]

This is so clever!!

[@EricPetersen2922]

Nice looking puzzle! Beautiful. Looking forward to more videos. Great production quality.

[@michaelwarlow4398]

Excellent video thankyou :-)

[@Beano_z]

Very amusing, great job, hahaha!

[@staysharp1476]

I got a story for you. A co-worker of mine was training to become a Doctor and i see her at Lunch trying to solve a patient case she was given for a task. She was telling me she couldn't get her head wrapped around it and the solution was so simple i answered it within 2 mins. Lesson learned here is not to over smart things all the time, some answers just need a touch of Logic.

[@JoshuaKennedy321]

I am surprised that the solution was almost exactly what I expected.

[@micks9580]

A Professor tasked his students to design/build an undefeatable door lock without having the key to open said door. The winner built a mock-up of his room only visible thru the peep hole. He "built" a giant screw that wedged against the door and any movement tightening the hold. The entire time the door was unlocked, and the screw and mock-up was just a fugazi. The easiest solution is sometimes to try the basics. Turn the knob.

[@a.m.kabdullahalkhzalah3896]

Nice puzzle

[@justinvzu01]

Left handed threading doesn't exist, it's called reverse threading. Left handed people have no issue with normal screws, being one myself I can confirm.

[@TheDBZCollector]

I was wrong. I thought somehow the unlocking part shortened so you could slide the ring over

[@nevamind68t23]

You did well Arnie, I wasn't even close 😭

[@trdi]

I don't think I would solve this one even after seeing the solution now.

[@reicherruschach3727]

This is truly a paradox of a puzzle. The most difficult puzzle was infact so, because the solution was so simple nobody would have guessed it

[@Robin-ve2lb]

3 mins in and you are losing your mind

[@SparkieGoth]

I actually wondered if it would have an unusual way of unscrewing it that wasn't I.immediately obvious. Pleased to have been proven right. They key itself is quite Steampunk actually. I would probably wear it as a necklace if I had one like it. Great work as always, Mr Puzzle. 👍I never tire of your vids.

[@Mr.Puzzle]

Well observed and thanks!