The OFFICIAL Monster Hunter Game Tier List

[@nibelsnarf5977]

I want to make it clear that I LOVE every monster hunter game yes even including rise despite what I said about it

[@joni3368]

1 year later? haha nice

[@nibelsnarf5977]

@@joni3368 many people are finding this video now through my other tier list video and I don’t feel like dealing with “rise/world are actually good games” like I don’t think that either…

[@joni3368]

@@nibelsnarf5977 that makes sense, I just watched it for the first time as well xd, great vid btw

[@nibelsnarf5977]

@@joni3368 thanks I appreciate it

[@koalamusicfrfr]

NOOOO PLEASE I HATE EGG QUESTS!!!!

[@zytche6466]

There's a little bit of tier list in your nostalgia

[@marstastatur783]

World in c tier.... With all the endemic life, all the Hidden mechanics and the guiding Lands..... Wow..

[@yadielrosado8012]

World was literally what made mh saga mainstream

[@johankhamaruddin3775]

grinding lands... but yes

[@egoygoy7542]

I mean world is really on easy MH game specially the items where you can carry everything.

[@marstastatur783]

@@egoygoy7542 i think its Just a more modern way. Its easy for sure, yes. But i think that shouldnt be a that Bad Thing. I mean its still Harder than rise 😂

[@egoygoy7542]

@@marstastatur783 its not bad just easy. It is still enjoyable. But just think how hard World/iceborne would be if the item inventory are limited to what you can carry trough out the whole quest especially if you played it for the first time.

[@pickcollins9910]

“Apparantly your hunter doesn’t feel anything” Buddy if you thought drinking a cold glass of water was the miracle cure to standing in a boiling volcano, I don’t think there was ever any hope for you

[@hisoka6272]

Yeah the complaint about cold and hot drinks not being in the game had to be a genuine lobotomized take. I can accept most of the other stuff but some monster hunter fans really complain that they got rid of antiquated mechanics and added quality of life. “It only takes 1 time to mine ore deposits vs 3” REALLY YOURE MAD ABOUT THAT?

[@mikehemraj9240]

It's a valid point. It would be a nice addition if they hadn't made all of those quality-of-life decisions mashed into one game. Cool drinks & hot drinks did serve the purpose of making you better prepared for each hunt, or else you'd be punished by constantly decreasing health or stamina. The ore thing makes it much less rewarding to actually get the things you need. It's much less earned in this game. @@hisoka6272

[@chadliterutherford9198]

​@hisoka6272 Yeah the game needs to be even more streamlined in fact, every upgrade should require only 1 monster part any part, mega potions should be infinite just like pickaxes, and hunters should spawn right next to monster ! Anyone who thinks gathering or preparing for a hunt is clearly a rose tinted nostalgia baby cause everone knows " New Product Must Consoom and get excited for next Product "

[@ryu-bx6wo]

@@chadliterutherford9198 So you want to grind mining nodes 3x as slow just because ''gathering is part of the game'' LMAO

[@kiamehrgh3081]

​​@@chadliterutherford9198you know hitting circle 3 times instead of 1 isn't really ganna add anything to the game and i like the old monster hunter games but like this just saves time and thats it

[@Xile165]

This is absolutely the most biased and nostalgia based tier list i have ever seen in my entire life. But you like Nibelsnarf so it’s acceptable.

[@stine4132]

@NickReilly-iv6jg I think XX is the best game out there, but Iceborne is the most polished game, with the best graphics, mechanics, and some really fucking good fights. The Iceborne endgame fights are the absolute best monhun's ever had, especially Fatalis and Alatreon. You're Nostalgia baiting yourself so hard. Speaking as someone who's played every single game since childhood, the early games are not that good. The only one who stands the test of time is 4U, and that's not really early

[@stine4132]

@NickReilly-iv6jg Yes just like XX had too much "insistence" on styles, and rise had too much insistence on wirebugs. I'm not even going to humor you with a response. Maybe check to see which Monhun game old and new players continue to go back to. If Iceborn was the gimmicky trash you call it, people would be playing the Old Games more than It. Your entire message reads like you being trash If you call Fatalis' attacks unavoidable

[@darosai1797]

​@NickReilly-iv6jgit amazes me how much of a "selected elite" mindset most of the MH players have, it's just stupid. Doesn't matter how good or bad you are, in the end it's just a stupid game, let people enjoy what game they want and don't be an idiot just like most of the Dark Souls community are, that's just childish mentality, my God.

[@gektoast4968]

@NickReilly-iv6jgas you said before, cope

[@asura8971]

aint readin allat dumbass@NickReilly-iv6jg

[@reachcole514]

Just started playing Rise on console and the fast progression is actually allowing me to experiment more with different weapons instead of only using the hammer and nothing but the hammer because all my time and materials are focused on perfecting my hammer builds.

[@StBg-yt2ez]

a men of culture

[@Bringingmoneyback]

Just letting you know if you're playing on Xbox. There's a huge problem with hitboxes so if you feel like the game starts getting really sketchy, it is

[@Ryx211]

Bro just got the skill issues

[@coolman9020]

@@Bringingmoneybackyou just have a skill issue ngl

[@Seafor-v4l]

Rise has very good accessibility imo. You can pick up and play it pretty easily, which makes it a good way to ease into the high difficulty that most other MH games present.

[@johankhamaruddin3775]

They hated the annoying wind dragon so much they mass murdered them to make a tower out of their skin? Honestly, quite relatable.

[@The_medicine_frog]

And built an entire dragon frankenstine's monster out of their dead bodies with the explicit purpose of killing other dragons.

[@silverlightning4995]

@@The_medicine_frog im not 100% sure but i thought something like that happened in MH lore with their first civilization.

[@The_medicine_frog]

@@silverlightning4995 Equal dragon weapon baby

[@absolutionone]

@@The_medicine_frog It isn't actually canon, but damn I sure do wish it was. The EDW is such a cool concept.

[@quack-tastictictac1630]

@@absolutiononeIt doesn’t have to be canon for Capcom to add it in a MH game. I mean, look at Frontier Z monsters. I think the Equal Dragon Weapon has a chance to pop up somewhere in a MH game… I hope.

[@MrErdtree]

Most reasonable tier list when he ranks monsters, most biased tier list when he ranks the games. Legend.

[@Werkvuur]

This is literally nostalgia in video form, lmao

[@r.k845]

Rise is pretty bad though

[@NoctisCantet]

​@@r.k845 I wouldn't say rise is bad but it's not necessarily the best of monster hunter games but it's definitely still a pretty decent good game in general

[@devilbananalol2800]

@@r.k845 low IQ take tbf

[@koolaidmansam8yearsago273]

@@r.k845 you are just being biased lol. theres nothing wrong with changing the formula a bit here and there.

[@jcc4543]

​@@koolaidmansam8yearsago273 true these old players does not like changes and likes to say sht like a karen and those old games were not played much just looking at twitch world and rise got lots of players.

[@macaroninaegi5169]

Thank you Nibelsnarf, the sheer power of your facts made me realize that enjoying MHW:I was actually wrong, so everytime I play it I make sure to kick myself in the balls so that I can associate the action of playing it with pain That or I just enter a Behemoth fight, why did you make this, capcom? Why?

[@nibelsnarf5977]

Have fun with that…

[@seaweed9092]

I think hunting ancient leshen can simulate being kicked in the balls pretty well

[@alderwield9636]

Made me chuckle, ngl

[@Voroniirijeglaz]

​@@seaweed9092 killing solo and no add-ons

[@VadeInSpiritu]

Some of the endgame stuff really annoyed me as a solo player. Fatalis solo is actually a challenge. Kulve taroth sucked. Safi though finally forced me to play online a little bit which was actually fun but I still don’t like relying on randos

[@marvinmoeller3170]

As someone who played every Mh game, I liked mh iceborne the most, every quest felt like an adventure, gameplay and graphics were the best in the series and some of the fight like Altreon and Behemoth were so hard alone that I absoulty loved them.

[@OHIO10182]

frrrrr❤❤❤❤

[@PacmanLickThisGuysAs]

mhw/ib gang

[@andipajeroking]

You dont play mh for graphics. You play it for the story and for the masochistic difficulty. Unfortunately world is very bad at that. The world design is awesome, but it s not enough. 3 will one of the legendary mh there.

[@dawas5370]

@@andipajerokingthe “story” you’re talking about is just rinse and repeat: Village in trouble? We come and save 🎉😊❤. MHWI: Research and learning/discovering new locales,fauna, and many other things

[@stine4132]

@@andipajeroking There isnt a single MH game with a good story, no one plays monhun for the stories, what are you on about bro 😭

[@barritop6679]

Gen ult should be S tier. No Giant snake and demon dragon BUT you have a MANTIS DRIVING A GUNDAM!!!!!!!!!!

[@jackkrell4238]

Also, ROCKET POWERED ELDER DRAGON!!!!

[@OrgBrent]

@@Ew-wth HAHAHAHA No.

[@nextgencombodrop378]

Gundam? Or Zoids? 😅🤔

[@uppermoon5gyokko655]

I don't think Athal Ka was 4U​@@Ew-wth

[@yeahboah307]

Don't let bro cook again

[@DemonicX-vg3vp]

He burnt the damn salad man 😭

[@Dememenic]

I don't particularly agree with your placement with Iceborne, but everything else is fair so I'll give you that. Imo Iceborne deserves to atleast be in B tier.

[@hanafitian8692]

Yeah, agree with you.. For me MHW and MHWI is kinda new way presentation of MH Game, give me so much fun, and the story it self, even though kinda bad because its the story about the handler, and you just kinda second character in this game, but I enjoy being the part of story. To be honest it was sad to kill spiky boy after what actually he did to the environment, but the fight is fun, best flag monster if i say. For me one thing that makes MHW bad is the Handler that always says "we" in this game, others than that, i think the game deserve at least B or A tier. Oh, and MHR, its so bad, its not MH game, maybe if the title not MH its a good game, but because its MH game, its bad. The only thing i like just the dog palamute, thats it.

[@godzillaking-rf2eq]

@@hanafitian8692 agreed, MHR just doesnt feel like monster hunter honestly. Tbh MHW was my first MH game so im a bit biased, but it really stands out in the best way possible being how well the monsters act in their enviroment and with eachother.

[@apexzora4423]

@@godzillaking-rf2eq rise does have the mh feel wth. It has the best combat too while iceborne has the worst one (yes, iceborne and not world)

[@Elyakel]

@@apexzora4423 Hello clutch claw and mantle who break the rhythm of the battle :D Hello spam Roar,Tremor and wind :D

[@MILDMONSTER1234]

@@apexzora4423 I’ll take mantles over the wire bugs anyday of the week and I hate mantles

[@Dumb-Comment]

I played all the MH games, and World is definitely in S+ I have never been so excited to play with such a large amount of players online with no loading screens in between fights on the map. The world building was exciting, it's new it's fresh it isn't about a village in danger, it was about research and gaining knowledge

[@borzoilover4156]

I've only played world but ive seen playthroughs of GU and stuff and they did such an incredible job making monsters feel even more like animals mhw genuinely feels like a living breathing world rather than just: Kill the monsters

[@sergioalej.9564]

Sorry old mans but mh world reboot. Is a C tier -3/10 AND zzz cuz the game Is too Easy AND u need to Advance too fast just for enter the real challenges. So ure progressing like a snail just for the cinemátics and world was the true reason for the mh rise sunbreak remake playstyle with too much tutorial

[@OGXenos]

@@sergioalej.9564 I don't think you could be less coherent if you tried.

[@sergioalej.9564]

@@OGXenos ok old Man. Mh world C tier. Too Easy for veteran players AND too much tutorial. AND then mh rise was released. Childish game just for being too easy

[@sahave5042]

⁠​⁠@@sergioalej.9564Did you play monster hunter before you were born because your iq maxed out when you were 6

[@OMGYOUARER8GHT]

Welp i guess we never get a true objective tier list because most vets only view Old gens with nostalgia goggles,meanwhile new players mostly only notice flaws of Old gens

[@chadliterutherford9198]

Cope nostalgia goggles don't exist, people still paying Old Gen in 2024

[@OMGYOUARER8GHT]

@@chadliterutherford9198 that just make their points even objective.Because new gens isn't as 'difficult' with old gens. And Capcom don't really care about those players

[@Arjeee]

Wow surprisingly small channel love the content

[@nibelsnarf5977]

Thanks I appreciate it

[@keisukebaji282]

MH TRI one of the top tier storyline , Underwater combat ,Lagiagod , Pickle Rex ,Readable text speech, 1st mh game that I played... My perfect entrance to the Monster Hunter franchise. Fucking nostalgia hits hard!!

[@peterduprey7286]

I fucking love rise. I love hinoa and minoto. I even love rampage. I love fioraine. I love Malzeno and crimson glow Valstrax. I love gaismagorm. I love wirebugs and switch skills. And the weapon I’ve been using for 11 years now, the switch axe, peaked in Sunbreak.

[@nobodyknowswhoo8995]

Freedom Unite and Tri is beyond S tier for me tbh, I had a blast with these two and I teared up when I first fought Glavenus and Nargacuga in MHW.

[@JohnTaylor-ed4eb]

replaying 3U again on a emulator. gotta say it feels like a classic MH experience. i defiantly miss the QOL changes in the new titles but its its just not classic enough

[@izsubs316]

Never thought I would meet nibblesnarf, I liked your fight in 3U

[@chopin31415]

As soon as you put tri as the best monster hunter ever and complimented water combat, you gained a like

[@downhill1222]

Never could play rise but since it came to consoles I have actually really enjoyed it

[@alleycat4642]

finally someone who understands the fact that mhtri is the best mh I MISS CHACHA AND KAYAMBA SO MUCH LIKE I NEED TO REPLAY

[@Adiansyah1514]

I like the underwater combat.. the swimming animation just top tier👌

[@MrDnbForLife]

100% agree with this list, had me worried with the thumbnail!

[@nuggie4huggie23pp]

To counter some of your points about rise, 1. We know we’re the monsters are thanks to our owls if I remember correctly and 2. The concept of hot and cold drinks never made sense. I love that you references us not feeling anything standing next to lava as if a cup of ice water is gonna change that😂

[@luckybison67]

To counter your argument, nibelsnarf speaks facts, he is above you and the world revolves around him. Your mere opinion doesnt matter

[@Walond-pac]

@@luckybison67 '='

[@Threat_LvL]

yeah and still its just too rushed. i get it, you cant made a slow paced game like the first ones in this times and yeah its cool and nice to know where u have to go or not having to abandon a quest because you forgot a silly white/red drink. but running around with "fog of war" and just exploring or looking up to wave at the baloon to get at least for a moment the location was just awesome. i always loved the moments when you set a trap right under the monster and he was like "nah im getting the fuck out lol" ....and you couldnt get your trap back. but never get me wrong. i fking love rise/world. i play this genre since 2010 and all i want is the old fatalis armor back hehe

[@taroko3721]

Imagine not liking hot and cold drinks

[@nuggie4huggie23pp]

@@taroko3721 I never said I didn’t.

[@evolburd5768]

This dude is high on nostalgia.

[@dds4585]

he’s right. i only disagree with rise

[@HazardousCanine0620]

​@dds4585 I second that! World's co-op needing to watch cutscenes before your friends could join felt tedious. Also, there's only so many times I can put up with the handlers bullshit and hear "HEY PARTNER" before I want to deck her lights out. Honestly if I had a dollar for everytime she's almost gotten herself killed I could buy myself lunch.

[@redmonkey2518]

Playing 3U back in the day was so good! 3U is an easy S tier and the WiiU community online was great! I miss the shitty gamepad mic no one ever used and I miss it’s one of a kind comradery between fellow hunters! Best Monster Hunter game ever created

[@yobro6053]

Still mad 4u didn’t release on the wii u 😢

[@critanalysis9546]

Wow this was a surprisingly great video! It’s a shame so many creative and funny mh channels like this one have such a small following, oh well at least you have a new subscriber and I hope to see more videos like this! 👍

[@nibelsnarf5977]

Thanks I appreciate it a lot

[@aloofi_]

generations ultimate has nibelsnarf, so objectively it belongs in S

[@SuperSky951]

I have a question for Nibelsnarf even after all this time, do you prefer fighting a Gravios or a Tigrex?

[@nibelsnarf5977]

If variants/ sub species count than molten tigrex by far. If it’s between normal gravios and tigrex than definitely tigrex.

[@liricl6978]

Gotta love the first set of subtitles reading "nipple sniff"

[@QuicksliceFilms]

MHW and MHWI are my only introduction to the series. I must say, the story was very lackluster. And the dragging cutscenes being unskippable can make coop a bit of a nightmare. Either way I love the game, the progression feels rewarding for the time required. Lot's of monster variety and weapon variety as well keeps you busy. Even catching some of the rare wildlife as pets to show off in your home. Beautiful looking game with a lot of content!

[@DragonsRocks017]

While I do love world the weapon variety is actually the worst in the series by FAR you should really give some of the other games a visit but note that world and rise added a ton of quality of life improvements and made the world itself much more fleshed out

[@ColetheFlame01]

yeah I'll just say what someone else in a video said more or less: "The game is grindy, but the grind itself is actually fun." Every land doesn't feel like it was catered to arena style boss fights, they all feel unique, alive, and flexible. every monster has a unique way of fighting and how to respond to you hiding. most will try to sniff you out but occasionally others will run and not take their chances. the thrill of having to learn and research these creatures made finding them even funner as you could learn their weaknesses and then prove it in the field. tracking them down, despite people complaining about it taking too long, makes a ton of sense. you are in their turf, you do not know the lands anywhere nearly as well as they do. the pacing is also slow, but fair, low rank expeditions have less monsters overall cause the high rank ones would eat a new player up for breakfast and possibly make them quit for good from raging. I could go on about how well I think MHW is. I legit did not ever want to play a MH game cause I thought it was a terrible series and hated how it looked and the way it seemed to play. World defied all that in the best possible ways and I'm now obsessed with the game.

[@joesheridan9451]

Story has always sucked in MH, closest they came to a good story was 4 and it was still nothing special at all. Some games like GU they didn’t even bother pretending it had a story lol

[@prehistorickyle]

⁠@@DragonsRocks017 yo no offense but that’s a straight up lie weapon variety the worst in the series? That’s delusional mh1 only had 7 weapons types with only 17 large monsters

[@DragonsRocks017]

@@prehistorickyle bro go look at all them same bone and metal weapons with only a bit of difference you're straight BLIIIIND 😂

[@kenshovenir5097]

Holy shit i didnt expect you to have 296 subs so fxking underrated channel

[@nibelsnarf5977]

Thanks I appreciate it

[@The_real_Arthur]

Never let this guy cook again

[@zbrahbobov1350]

Monster Hunter is like Pokemon but instead of forcing the animals to murder each other in illegal pit fights you do the dirty work by yourself like a real man.

[@nibelsnarf5977]

That makes sense since they’re both my favorite video game franchises… I guess I like killing monsters

[@Geym1account]

Mhp3rd is my nostalgia machine being my first game but MHGU is MOST DEFINITELY the best of MH series

[@Harv-E]

I hope this video blows up my dude. I planned on making a video similar to this a while back but dropped it cause I can't speak for shit in a funny way. Can't wait to see people's reaction on this one.

[@nibelsnarf5977]

Thanks I appreciate it. You should just go for it I’m sure the video would be good.

[@djgrizzly9353]

My favorite thing about Tri is the Ceadus fight. The theme compared with the fact that you fight him in the ruins of cities he's destroyed just fills you with this "Oh shit, we're next" and like you're the last hope for Moga Village. Monster Hunter is never direct with their writing, but if you read between the lines, god DAMN is it juicy

[@Threat_LvL]

bro the sound that the old pokke village grandma made just hit me like PTSD fucking good times... sadly i couldnt play mhfu online

[@TheBakaPotato]

I'm a bit late but subscribing for the excellent comedic timing alone.

[@IV_Boi]

Nargacuga has been always been my favorite monster

[@SirCrabthe1st]

"You go from killing a velociraptor, to FUCKING GOD." ayo

[@johnross5098]

This is probably the tier list I agree the most with.

[@norwayrules3446]

I am sorry for the crimes I have committed against Nibelsnarf for his armour.

[@joekheem3834]

imagine a remaster of 3u 😍

[@saltyluigi4011]

Thank you Mister Nibelsnarf, nice video.

[@bl00dsplatt3redeverywhere]

Nostalgia screamed loudly in this Tier list

[@SharkPivo]

Oh well, can't argue with OFFICIAL tier list. Facts are set in stone now

[@Vayne_Solidor]

I agree on many of these. 3U is definitely S tier. 4U I give high A tier. XX A tier. Iceborne C tier. Rise probably high B tier with Sunbreak.

[@Vayne_Solidor]

Oh, have to add: Frontier S tier. Shantien is my fav monster.

[@SadMoribund]

L Take on Iceborne, 4U is S.

[@MILDMONSTER1234]

@@SadMoribund 4u has the worst balancing outside of Rise

[@RiffingWithSanti]

I actually liked rise because of the fast pace it has. When you work you don’t have enough time to appreciate all of the different mechanics MHW has, so it was a breath of fresh air.

[@erenattacktitan4964]

Rise is the second mh game that I've played (the first being world). As for now, it's my favourite mh game (well, I haven't played a lot) because that made be give a second chance to the series. World was too big for me, and the monsters were taking a long time to be beaten, while a kinda of chaotic environment was created for me. I didn't know what to do, and the game wasn't beginner friendly. I stopped playing the game, and had the intention to never play another mh game. But then, rise came out. Rise is a more relaxing experience, a more controlled environment. It was actually manageable for a beginner like me

[@defaultdan7923]

wow we had similar experiences. when you feel like you’re done with rise, definitely go back to complete world and try out ice borne, it’s really good imo

[@erenattacktitan4964]

@@defaultdan7923 yeah, that's what I was planning on doing

[@kanerussell8304]

The issue is that it doesn't feel like a monster hunter game. I'm glad new players like the speed and accessibility but it is a bit of a turn off to their core, existing fan base who came to love the series for it's slower, more difficult gameplay with longer fights.

[@Chris-ls1ub]

lol, so you suck. mhw was my first game too and i loved the struggle and the way i got so much better at it later on

[@erenattacktitan4964]

@@Chris-ls1ub I didn't want to struggle. I just wanted to relax with fighting some monsters. If I want struggle I will play fromsoft games. Plus, it's not only the "struggle", I also should hunt the monster in a giant map, finding its footprints and so on. I have a limited free time, I can't waste 5 hours for a hunt

[@pokeytrev]

Finally someone who gets it.

[@grahamcrackers5645]

God tier channel and video. Most objective and based Monster Hunter video I've ever seen.

[@nibelsnarf5977]

Thanks I appreciate it

[@MrBomb-nn9ds]

This was supposed to be the objectively correct tier list not the objectively Incorrect one

[@bookfish]

Honestly I just adore Rise's fast pace. Nowadays I don't have the time to sit down and play a game for half a day and do little to no progress in it. Rise was the first monster hunter where I didn't looked up guides for building armorsets, because building a single peace of armor doesn't take days of grinding the same monster. You can farm stuff really fast and if something doesn't works out, then I'm like "meh whatever" and don't feel bad, that I grinded, maybe a day in worst case, for an armor I'll never use again. It lets me to experiment much more, with the builds and even the weapons I use. And I think that sometimes a vastly different style is needed to put things in perspective and help you to appreciate the other games in the series. Edit: Typos.

[@halos7727]

@10:41 it's not because of that It's because the cahoot (the owl companion) tracks mobsters from the sky and relays the info to the hunter

[@vlwhiteonyx]

Been playing MH since I was child and I consider World as the peak MH. It's like a love letter to old players and a fresh welcome to new ones. It made MH mainstream and got the recognition It deserves as Elden Ring did to the Soul games even if Bloodborne or Sekiro were the really good ones. The quality, the capture rewards than just killing, those huge non-load maps that Rise got inspired, the natural feeling of the weapons, the Monsters interacting with anything and you can actually interact with, etc. I will be there hunting on Astera and Seliana with new and old hunters until my journey makes me ship to the Next World.

[@massgrave]

I expected 4U in S tier, objectively is one of the best MH games if not the best one. Finally Im seeing World ranked low, was a great game but too overrated for me. This thanks to the people who never played other MH games, and the ones who think that graphics are essential to make a “good” game. As for now Im really enjoying Rise, and Im liking it more than World.

[@JechtZone]

Dude all the things you say is so true. Being a player from day one this hits so hard. Lol great video dude.

[@juanburgueno3274]

The intro alone deserves a like

[@TerribleJhoe]

Dos in S tier and Rise in trash tier made my day. Sir you earned a like.

[@aleksis007]

First 30 secs and i'm already pressing like lmao

[@superxtreme7338]

Tri at the top of S tier. Now that's an objective list :)

[@Ballsinyaface_89]

TOP TIER EDITING!!!!

[@Godskxn]

TRI WAS GO GOOD BRO PLEASE BRING BACK UNDERWATER COMBAT. Dude the fear of realizing the monsters followed you underwater and now you have to clunkily fight back in a zone you arent used is awesome, like so awesome, people really dont understand how terrifying it is to have to fight out of your environment with limited movement.

[@agni2051]

MHF2 was my first MH and I feel like the IB hate, while warranted in some ways (clutch claw lmao), completely disregards the massive scale the game was brought to. No loading between areas, turf wars, the sieges, sos flares, the environments (except AF), Fatalis etc. This was a good af video, but idk. As a lifetime hunter myself, I find the bashing of IB among my fellow old hunters crazy. That game (on PC) was a gift.

[@nibelsnarf5977]

I don’t hate any monster hunter game I think all are amazing I have countless hours in MWIB and it did bring in good addition to the series. This list was more of I think these games are better than that one but they’re all good.

[@bennyrayson297]

"U go from taking down a Veloceraptor to fucking God". Pause

[@asteranightshade2981]

World and Tri are the best, objectively. World has the best combat and visuals, Tri is just badass. Other than those two I actually agree with most of these rankings

[@wyld3137]

I’ll move World to a strong B or entry A for trying to keep things fresh and pulling new players. The same changes they made kept me from putting World next to 4U and tri. Besides that im okay with the list.

[@m3anmug]

Why would someone want to click something 3 times instead of once? I would rather a game respect my time.

[@PhriekshoTV]

>Tri in S Tier Based af Underwater combat was great and people just couldn't get good. Also 3U gave us G Rank Purple Ludroth armor, my favorite in the entire series based on skills, alone

[@drkreuzer670]

I skipped to the end, just so i can see how many MH games there are, and... im gonna need a bigger storage, to harvest all of the creatures

[@im_skrunkly]

rise is either peoples favorite or least favorite. i think sunbreak adds enough content to justify the pacing, but if you're ranking it as a monster hunter game, a D makes a lot of sense. good video.

[@bluerhyno2710]

"Bring frontier back" hell yes. Shantien and all the other elder dragons have my favorite designs in the series even if some people think they’re “whacky”. I wish I could fight them

[@carnwennann]

I doubted this video's quality and credibility till you put Dos and Tri/3U in S tier. You really do speak nothing but pure facts... except for when you called the switchaxe the best weapon in the series. It's second best. ... Now if you excuse me, I'm going to quietly watch every video you've uploaded and everything you'll upload in the future because I think you're funny.

[@nibelsnarf5977]

Thanks I appreciate it a lot

[@TheNoMoreGamer]

Hell yeah homie 3U bros rise up! I’m the psycho who bought a Wii U for MH3U. Best MH experiences ever

[@blazeedge1631]

Never been so glad that a thumbnail was clickbait.

[@jihanrayyan7997]

In monster hunter rise,i got killed by a magnamalo so much that i said "enough is enough" and killed like 20 magnamalo in the next 4 hours

[@DopeyDopes]

I agree, the lack of preparation and easier gathering killed most of the immersion. Sadly we cant return to mh2.

[@nibelsnarf5977]

Hopefully they remake old mh games including dos

[@alyeva457]

why would you want to wait an arbitrary amount of time holding down the a button for no reason, I wouldn't call that immersive just a waste of time

[@OGXenos]

mmmmyes, the game that nearly killed the series, perfect, more of that please

[@Benri05]

​@@OGXenosrose tinted glasses are one hell of a drug, I love the old MH games too but letting the series die just for the sake of nostalgia is quite selfish.

[@GagAl-]

​@@Benri05speak literal facts

[@SawnikTheHedghog]

The fact that theres a C and D tier......

[@jeronym894]

I would put iceborn in A. Why ? Because It hase a beautiful living world, an excellent endaga with the best fights such as Fatalis. And negative things don't bother me with the game.

[@greenbone9556]

You prolly havent tried the other series or even grow up with mh.

[@jeronym894]

@@greenbone9556 I played mh4u, and I think it's on the same level as MHWI and some things has even better.

[@Antwonn2002]

I agree with you, world and iceborne are revolutionary for the franchise. They introduced big beautiful open zones, rolling backwards, and moving while healing, turf wars. And the game felt soooo alive. The siege system wasn't perfect but it made the game feel so alive. Live events, title updates this games multi-player felt so fresh and amazing. Whether or not people enjoyed this game they can't deny that iceborne evolved monster hunter. I guess the problem with the devs is that they tried to take what was good about iceborne, but rushed it and made it too flashy. Which is what created rise, took was good about iceborne but kinda messed it up adding the wire bug. Iceborne is a great game and I think people are a little too biased. 3u and 4u are S tier still 😁.

[@shutup1037]

@@Antwonn2002 they are different team too between rise and world.

[@Antwonn2002]

@@shutup1037 I know

[@shoto_slayer9997]

icerbone and rise tier c and d XDDD what u smoke buddy i want some

[@Alane056]

God tier video deserves 1,000,000 views

[@jorgenamnum6481]

bros brain logged off after MHGU, like yeah you point out the same issues we all see with this gens game but those issues at most is what drop it from S tier to A tier, B for rise if your mean like that but C and D? straight to jail.

[@XsyrusX12345]

If I learned something in regard to Monster Hunter, then it's to stay away as FAR as possible from the Monster Hunter Community. It's full of trashy nostalgia fans and elitists. And this comment section just proves me right. I will keep enjoying my trashy, grindy, clutch clawy MonHun Iceborn to the fullest and I HOPE that Wilds will not cater to any nostalgia troglodytes out there in the slightest. Let it be World, but times two. And for the love of god, please keep the Clutch Claw. Just to piss off nostalgia idiots, but more importantly because it's an awesome and fun mechanic.

[@Suckle-Buckle]

I, Diablos from monster hunter approve this message

[@tylercafe1260]

I think World has the best endgame. I got into MH back in MH:FU on PSP and played them ever since. Endgame just never quite made sense to me and as much as I understand the appeal of older armor abilities it's quite jarring to think the final monsters armors don't really matter all that much besides a few pieces. Then you're pretty much relying heavily on RNG to get charms you wanted because of how much obnoxious different kinds they allow. Making "finishing a set" feel like a fucking miracle rather than an intended goal. It's so satisfying coming back to World and seeing my complete sets. Then I turn on MH:Generations for nostalgia and end up back on the Sakura Method for those damn charms despite doing every single quest already 😭 Basically older MH is RNG city and as much as I love those games I'm loving the new direction. Sales numbers don't lie. Older titles feel like getting upgrades was a plus to clearing the quests rather than the intended goal. World it feels like that IS the goal. No wonder no one got into the games back then. It was literally trying it's hardest to not give you good gear. I finally get a game where I'm loving the beginning pacing and everyone complains about the very changes that helped this series explode into Capcoms best seller. Criticism's like that need to align with reality. That sad reality is the older games just weren't doing it. Also it's crazy to think majority of the series was on objectively shitty hardware. The fucking Wii while we were on 360 and PS3s. Jesus fucking christ. It more or less skipped an entire hardware generation. I'm actually getting Kingdom Hearts levels of flashbacks on trying to play this series. It's so all over the place.

[@trustyrat8632]

Finishing a set in world is so much worse tho. You don’t need a perfect talisman in the old games but you need decorations in worldborne. Making them rng sucked. And the power creep making everything except fatalis and some alatreon and at velk pieces also wasn’t very good

[@CheckMark1999]

Me to

[@cheese6191]

@@trustyrat8632 genuinely my 1 problem with world and iceborne is how theres 2 good armors endgame. i think its more fun in a game to be able to have a variety of armors to choose from with different playstyles while none are just obeselete from the others,

[@gejsalociN]

there is no mh close to world, world is just greatness

[@jweesm4287]

I always hate the long grind in the monster hunter games I don't know why people hate rise

[@yamchayaku]

This 100%

[@invertbrid]

Well u prob quite minority then as most MH players enjoy grinding, especially ones in older ganes

[@SylvisNuvara]

people hate rise because removing the need to actually fight monsters and work together with people removes the core fantasy of monster hunter. Rise isn't a monster hunter game- it's an arcade fighting game. In rise, you have complete control over essentially every situation in combat due to wirebugs. That's not monster hunter.

[@caharademise]

9:42 play mhw again, you didn't get it. Then redo the video thanks.

[@ssdragunov2986]

Blasphemy List this is what this list is.

[@cristianfuentes-nydel1607]

Just here to point that in MHRise, you know where the monsters are because your little owl helps you track them. I assume that you have never feed the little fella, and never pet it too :c

[@DarkDoughnutsVids]

Brave of you to assume he actually plays the newer games Or does anything more than skim through them for the sake of making videos

[@rithalos]

Wow bro, cybershell vibes in this video, welldone!

[@nibelsnarf5977]

Thanks I appreciate it

[@Spilzu]

bro I just realized today that they purposely made the monsters in Rise super fast to make up for the wirebug and dogs (literally can't remember what the dogs are called). I tried great sword in both 4U and Rise, and that's when it hit me just how jerky and quick the Rise monsters are. The heavy weapons just don't feel as good as the light ones in Rise. Haven't played Sunbreak but hopefully the monsters are better

[@waltuh2412]

Cap, gs still goes hard

[@Spilzu]

@@waltuh2412 true true I've gotten way better at the game since writing that comment. It still plays differently than the old games but if all the weapons do

[@j.s.t.6515]

Finally someone that isn't afraid to admit that they are 100% totally and objectively correct. I wish everyone could be like that so we could have 100% accurate debates and discussions. God bless you.

[@buuthepowerfull]

Honestly, Rise is one of my favorites. I like that is streamlines the game a bit. Some of the functions in the oG stuff was cool and immersive, but some people just wanna get out there and fight the big lizard! (Me I wanna fight the big lizard). All and all I agree with your points, but I still love it. However I really with they brought back Playable Palicos. Say what you want about that function, I loved it.

[@Shiny_Charizardia]

MHS and MHS2: Cries in forgotten

[@4blasphemy]

Honestly very good video, didnt expect it to be this good, a lot of things are very true except i would put freedom and P3rd a tier higher, but i am biased towards them sooo Oh and dos was a very good point, i would go as far as to say it needs to be even higher, as you said, that is the closest monster hunter ever gotten to what 1 was aiming for, i dont know if you saw but there is a 3 hour review/overlook of it and it is VERY good, would for sure recommend if you havent seen it

[@nibelsnarf5977]

Thanks I appreciate it a lot