The ONLY Time Darth Vader Fought Darth Maul - Star Wars Legends

[@ritz373]

Sidious definitely knew. If he did not orchestrate it beforehand, he would have sensed Maul. I think that Vader knew that too, hence the second of hesitation before following his master. That second was him remembering that he had nothing else in the galaxy left to live for, so he might as well continue trudging along behind the master he despised and distrusted

[@tstreb66]

Knowing Palpatine, he always had a backup plan even if he could forsee the future.

[@NillaShotz10]

This doesnt exist its fake. Darth maul and vader are on different timelines didnt know eachother existed

[@rjserr]

Darth Maul only died like two years before A New Hope, watch Rebels.​@@NillaShotz10

[@jrose6048]

@@NillaShotz10watch rebels, they were aware of each other but didnt fight each other. And maul probably knew vader was anakin or had an idea at least.

[@JarOfGreed]

Maul was aware of sidious plan to make Anakin his final apprentice so I'm sure he was capable of putting two and two together.

[@dngrouscrgo]

“Wait, aren’t you that guy who tried to run me down on your scooter when I was 10?”

[@thefknscarecrow]

(Because last second he sensed the powerful force in him)

[@davepegington9066]

​@@thefknscarecrow No

[@UFC_fanatic31]

Not gonna lie “what could you hate enough to beat me?” “Myself” is such a great line, and would be amazing in a movie or show

[@fortunecookie4080]

it describes vader perfectly in just 1 question. truly perfect

[@Hiipower23]

This used to be one of my favorite stories back in the day glad you brought it back up

[@ritz373]

ahhh, Legends. gone but never forgotten. real Star Wars

[@RetneysHolocron]

Its not gone, they still publish Legends books and you can read them at any time 👍

[@pjusttheletterpreally.noth2995]

​@RetneysHolocron If they still publish them... WHY do they not make them canon again?!

[@123ultramaster]

@@pjusttheletterpreally.noth2995 Just think about it like a Multiverse like Marvel stuff then dont care about "canon" its just different timelines :d

[@derekscanlan4641]

It's garbage like this story that caused The Mouse to de-canonise it all. Vader's characterisation is all wrong and the way he wins the fight is ridiculously implausible

[@Devil70090]

Please tell where do you guys read legends continuity?

[@anessamer]

Truly an insane duel. Thank you for making a video about it.

[@NateIsCorrupt]

Legends continuity is so good. Maybe we will get more of it one day.

[@nightwingman666]

I remember reading this comic long ago. And it makes sense to the Sith hate equals strength and after all Vader had done killing the Jedi, killing Padme, his self loathing was as effective if not more as Maul’s hate for everything else.

[@jeffs7764]

what is the name of this comic ?

[@krugg2798]

So Anakin got to duel Maul after all......

[@h20dies]

No, Vader did.

[@daph0307]

Same shit. ​@@h20dies

[@karlylove9791]

Wrong buttface. Anakin is not Vader.

[@thefknscarecrow]

​@@h20dies Anakin was always Vader. You just didn't pay enough attention. There's also deleted scenes you know. Movie archive has a 5 1/2 hours version of episode 3

[@USMC-es4yy]

If it was just anakin without the vader suit to hold him back it wouldn't of even lasted that long.Anakin used his rage during battle even before becoming vader which made him even better.

[@AshtonHooseria]

Awesome video Retney! I really like how Darth Maul and Vader fought it was really cool.

[@starwarssith66]

This is my dream project to see in live action or animated man! 🔥 video as always

[@soyevquirsefron990]

Star Trek redshirts have a better survival rate than stormtroopers. Either go with Vader and get killed by Vader or go separately and get killed off screen

[@simplyskrypt3914]

I will say this Vader, knowing what he himself went through and survived [on Mustafar] by tapping into the dark side, should not be THAT shocked about Maul surviving as well

[@Jiambo]

Thankfully this isn't cannon because it is stupid. Vader would have force slammed Maul over and over again until he was no more than a pile of gore on the floor while interrogating him "You are part of the rebel alliance and a traitor! CONFESS!" _bonk_ "Where are the death star plans?"

[@lordsknight4516]

I see you don't really know anything about Star Wars!

[@korytoombs886]

Vadar is very weak, he gets beat by almost everyone.

[@lordsknight4516]

Name one strong Jedi that Vader has beaten? All the Jedi knights he has killed were weak, the strong ones he would lose to, I have been watching Star wars and reading the books since before you were Born!

[@korrenthereaper4357]

Vadar molested everyone though.

[@Blindsyde5762]

So Vader being mostly machine actually made him strong enough to defeat Maul.

[@LastChanceWOR]

Maul was cool asf tho ngl

[@srujan00]

I don't even think Darth Vader (after getting the suit) was a good saber duelist. Sure, he beat Luke in ESB, but Luke was an inexperienced kid. He beat 60-70 year old Obi Wan in ANH, but Obi whooped him in the Obi Wan series, and obviously beat him before on Mustafar. In Rogue One, no one else had a saber. Luke kicked Vader's ass in ROTJ - some deleted parts early on in the fight show Luke getting several solid hits in.

[@jedijudoka]

If you’re only going by on screen performance then that’s a logical conclusion, but in novelizations, books, and comics, it’s said and demonstrated that he’s one of the all time greatest. Probably amongst the likes of bane, Malgus, maul, etc

[@thecorvus100]

Calling Vader “skywalker” was the exact second he lost.

[@UnoDoseMedia]

If Vader knew or had even an iota of knowledge that there was a way to get people to come back from the dead then he would be infatuated with it,in an attempt to make Padme come back to life like Darth Sidious had promised to show Anakin SO long ago. Does anyone else believe this to be true? So I think it is a bit fetching of the writers to create a story like this.

[@SM-xc4rl]

"and if there are this ways, why dont you resurrect padme?" *ignites lightsaber*

[@marioyungblood]

your Commentary is Awesome!! #Vader #Jedi #DarthMaul #Skywalker

[@KealanRobert]

The Vader comics are some of the greatest ever

[@karlschipul9753]

what? Vader was like, 9 when Maul got killed by Obi Wan. Maul would have chopped Anakin's head off easily at that stage.

[@PforPwned]

Yeah I don’t get it. I understand how qui gon dying led obi wan to fail anakin but as far as a duel? I’m pretty sure maul was dead before anakin even held his first lightsaber. So confused

[@DBWave94]

@@PforPwned Maul died at the hands of Obi-Wan on Tatooine far after their first duel on Naboo. He had a fully cybernetic lower torso and legs at that point. I think you missed Rebels.

[@ethanharrison336]

Hold the fuck up. DARTH MILENNIAL

[@o-shawnspecific80]

He went to the dark side after seeing every show, video game and movie from his childhood horribly rebooted.

[@willtill6544]

Next up is Darth Genalpha, hailing from the planet Ohiosis, bringing terror through the galaxy with his fanum army, every attempt on his life has been thwarted by his elite personal guard: the Inskibiders. He learned everything he knew from his master Darth Liberal, but Genalpha got the better of Liberal, as his gyat was a higher level than Liberal's, cementing his position as the strongest of the dark lords of the sith.

[@QgramPlus]

This doesn't top the time Darth Vader fought Darth Maul in Lego Star Wars: The empire strikes out. That was pretty awesome! Don't take my word for it. Just ask Darth Maul. Awesomest star wars moment 😂

[@cam2designs]

Legends are best…

[@williamgriffin3447]

"What could you hate enough to defeat me?" "Myself..."

[@sarrjel]

They should do this in an animation. Get the guy who voices Darth Maul and James Earl Jones and do a DC type animation. Oh wait Lucasfilm is headed with Kathleen Kennedy. Never mind, she’ll just screw it up by having Rey suddenly appear in and beat them both because she’s great.

[@duramirez]

Love these stories, they add soo much MEAT to the characters.

[@nicholasdickens2801]

Such a great story.

[@DutchDread]

4:50 Somehow Darth Maul returned.

[@yitschaqyasharahla4347]

We desperately need a Vader and Sidious movie or series

[@ContemporaryCompendium]

No we don't.

[@ritz373]

@@ContemporaryCompendium not until Disney are gone, at least

[@yitschaqyasharahla4347]

@@ritz373 F Disney

[@danman6431]

It’s called starwars episode 1-6

[@atilax6452]

Cant. They are white guys.

[@jurassicsteph]

There's still hope for this to happen in canon

[@ChildePC]

Wow... he hated himself... never considered that

[@actionkato2133]

It's really the basis of the Vader character. Vader's self loathing and self hate is what he drew on for his power. Basically most sith draw from hate and anger outwardly. Vader's hate and anger came from within

[@stephinshepard5067]

Vader almost lost too

[@delraydad7516]

Only someone who know absolutely nothing about fighting would script the following line: "Maul was considered one of the greatest swordsmen/duelist." In order to be considered one of the greatest if not THE greatest, must have fought more than practice. This is one of the most overused hypes Star Wars implements. It cheapens the meaning.

[@michaelgarcia8602]

I have this Comic. I found it to be very very cool to see 2 Sith Lord go 1 on 1 to The Deaths.

[@davidb9284]

What comic is it?

[@raidenn6266]

​@davidb9284 Star wars tales #9

[@davidb9284]

@@raidenn6266 great 👍🏻

[@michaelgarcia8602]

@@davidb9284 Star Wars Tales of Jedi.

[@michaelgarcia8602]

@@raidenn6266 I believe that it.

[@Delicious1922]

I wish they would have fought on film. I bet it was a duel of the ages

[@bryankennedy2257]

Crazy machine more than man....

[@zenchiefengineer]

They had some hella ways to keep anyone from copying the plans of the death star.

[@kdawg717]

This was way more entertaining than Acolyte

[@austinfuller8323]

One of the most iconic rematches in Star Wars lore and nobody (masses that dont read the SW extended Universe media) has ever heard of it... Also another point, them saying Darth Maul was "resurrected" is not accurate(at least if your basing his story off accurate verified Star Wars canon). Maul didnt die when he was cut in half, using his force powers to stop bleeding out, he then eventually set out: fusing together cyberneticly with mechanical prosthetic legs, then rehabilitating himself through training to become the agile swordsman he once was. Just a prime example of Sith propaganda, spreading lies and enciting fear and suspense through anyone who will hear it and latch on to the darkness, confusion, and fear that clearly feeds the Dark side of the force.

[@natryan8547]

This is AFTER OLD ben kenobi KILLED maul. Not when young obi wan kenobi cut him in half

[@austinfuller8323]

@@natryan8547 ok that really makes sense then haha. Listen to me above trying to sound based n shit. Im a pretty heavy dabbler in extended SW Lore but by no means a expert. I was obv more or less refereing the clone wars "Darth Maul and Savage Oppress Arc" as you could probably catch onto. But any and all info is appreciated always even in the form of correction.... And look on the bright side, Nobody was Expecting "Old Uncle Ben-Kenobi": Obi Wan to turn Maul into Sith Brand Gorilla Glue™

[@danman6431]

This is more of a what if comic

[@RetneysHolocron]

No, Star Wars Tales is part of the overall EU continuity!

[@danman6431]

@@RetneysHolocron Clonewars season 1-6 are also cannon so this contradicts that.

[@RetneysHolocron]

@@danman6431 That's cause CW contradicts like the entire EU 💀 From what I understand, that's why a lot of Legends fans have beef with it

[@danman6431]

@@RetneysHolocron it is true and technically cannon. Also there is another comic where maul comes back and fights obi wan on tattooine.

[@scottsharp3356]

Is it still possible to continue writing legends books or did Disney end that too? I know what I’d write about.

[@snoozeflu]

Vader doesn't believe Sidious at the end there.

[@kevin-2.1]

How could he be walking, after being impaled by his own saber?

[@raidenn6266]

I mean, are you surprised Vader has insane endurance feats?

[@kevin-2.1]

@@raidenn6266 well I know he survive being burnt alive, so maybe he used the force to heal?

[@raidenn6266]

​@kevinkeenan6785 Probably not on the spot, he did it later I do recall he tried to use the force several times to cure his burns and lungs, but never was able to heal them fully

[@kevin-2.1]

@@raidenn6266 Probably because he would have to use hatred to heal. But if he doesn’t hate then the whole procedure will undo itself.

[@raidenn6266]

@@kevin-2.1 In shadows of the empire (legends novel set between ESB and Rotj), Vader focused on his hatred and was able to breathe without mechanical aid, until he started thinking about Luke and the emotions broke his focus

[@simplyskrypt3914]

Random question Did dooku know that sidious was palpatine? Would sidious actually trust him with that information in AotC, knowing he's still technically in the jedi order? Even by the time of RotS, sure he expects anakin to finish him, but imagine anakin doesnt, they capture dooku and he starts talking... I guess he does look over at palpatine like "wait did you just betray me?" So i guess by that point he had to know, but i wonder when exactly he found out. If he did before he left the jedi order, damn, that is one hell of a ballsy move by Palpati e

[@darthlt4630]

Yes he knew everything

[@simplyskrypt3914]

@@darthlt4630 even before the clone wars? Damn. Like i said. Ballsy

[@RetneysHolocron]

Yes, Dooku knew Palpatine was Sidious

[@Chris-bv1bk]

​@@simplyskrypt3914Dooku literally tells Kenobi that Palps is sidious in AOTC lol "What if I told you that the Republic was now under the control of a dark lord of the Sith?" Obi Wan didn't believe him because "the jedi would sense it." To me it's one of the most significant moments of the fall of the Jedi/Republic because it perfectly highlights what they'd become. Arrogant. They believed that they were too wise and strong for the Sith to ever rise again.

[@cutegok]

continue trudging along behind the master he despised

[@bryantclay7212]

Vader would immediately regret the killing of these acolytes because he would want to resurrected padme

[@LordRazer3]

...so how many times has Maul been killed now? I'm at 3

[@gitgud1018]

Did Vader stab himself through his actual torso with his organs or did he stab himself through a completely machine part of his torso? I thought his whole torso was still in tact and there was just some machinery embedded? If he did stab through his actual torso, wow, he survived that shit.

[@RetneysHolocron]

Vader's torso was still organic. But he did have some tubes and wires that went into his chest so he could breathe and stuff!

[@KryptekRex]

It was all apart of the Will of ‘The Force’. SIDIOUS, just as Satan, only in control of the temporal plane of existence. The temporal worlds. Through ‘the Force’ we will always be redeemable.

[@JeffWhite-z7y]

Well maul only recent had vision of vader right before order 66, didnt know sll along, did know about plans of the clone srmy tho

[@shanebristow1955]

Everything maul said to vader is facts 😂

[@kevinvassago]

I have this comic, absolutely love it too. But how do we know it takes place 0 BBY?? Where is the year stated in the comic? Or is it in like an old reference book

[@RetneysHolocron]

We assume it’s 0 BBY because they are searching for the stolen Death Star plans from A New Hope

[@kevinvassago]

@RetneysHolocron OK cool. Ty👍

[@matthewtjeerdsma2549]

0BBY? Darn. I'd heard a bit about this story before, and assumed it was how Vader programmed PROXY with Maul's image and fighting style. Oh well. Still a cool story.

[@kevinvassago]

@matthewtjeerdsma2549 it's such a dope comic. I have a feeling in future content we're gunna see maul fight Vader too. The way he was so frightened by him in Rebels, and how he knew he couldn't defeat Vader alone. It sounded as if he fought Vader b4. That doesn't sound like something Filoni would just not address. It may take awhile, but I bet we'll see it eventually

[@SraMacaco]

@@RetneysHolocronCould you please give me details on where I can find this? I’m pretty new to the material outside of the movies. Thank you!

[@fastcarsnfreedom5407]

So did Sidious know? & want to be there when Mall won & killed em all off b4 they could say anything to Vader?

[@viiixiv8538]

Comic vader always looks surprised

[@benjaminvalenti1242]

Yes I have this dark horse comic

[@atrain2345]

The plot armor is crazy , I don't believe robotic vader can match the speed of maul , maul should win this fight 10 outta 10 times ,

[@shanebristow1955]

Skill will always beat speed not to mention vader was like triple the strength in force

[@schishne7546]

Darth Maul somehow returned...

[@aGoodHunter]

Maul were more sith than Vader

[@zaterranwraith7596]

Damn thats epic

[@shenaniganskywalker518]

Should be the plot of Rogue II

[@CrimFuryX]

Yoshimitsu Skywalker

[@Perch_Master_Nick]

I enjoyed the story. 👍🏼

[@domissavvy]

No way Vader beats Maul ever.

[@Jo-vc5gb]

Maul in rebels feared Darth Vader. I think it's clear that Vader is a much more powerful Sith than maul could ever have hoped to be.

[@domissavvy]

@@Jo-vc5gb Vader's one handed, slow, stiff as a board, can't even turn his head. It makes no sense that he would ever beat Maul, buuut I didn't make star wars so what do i know 😅

[@isymfs]

I like how you polled me here

[@RetneysHolocron]

Dude thanks for actually coming from the poll 🙏

[@yusrashah1173]

rip maul again

[@matthewmann8969]

This comic was never Canon even in the original Legends Canonization same with the Old Wounds one were Old Ben Kenobi fought Spider Legged Maul in the day time on Tatooine they were still fun stories though yeah.

[@RetneysHolocron]

Star Wars Tales was canon to the overall EU. The only comic that wasn’t considered canon was the “Infinites” series

[@matthewmann8969]

​@@RetneysHolocronEven if so this was not TPM Maul but a more powerful and skilled clone that had lots of prep time and environmental advantages and favoritism from the dark ones which is why he did do well against Vader on even footing Vader would of easily won yeah.

[@GeneFOX70]

​​@@matthewmann8969writer of the comic has stated multiple times that the resurrected/clone Maul is equal in power and skill to himself from TPM and that both he and Vader used their full power against each other. kzbin.info/www/bejne/a3jXh4x9p7dpa6csi=gSHZkUt01earrmGV

[@matthewmann8969]

​@@GeneFOX70Let's say that is true it should be noted that this Maul had a environmental advantage over Vader with Vaders fears of lava, magma, and volcanoes as well as the dark prophets favoring Maul giving him a motivational boost plus the fight was more on there physical abilities, unarmed combat, and lightsaber skills plus Vader was still not fully used to his suit yet on equal ground and with just force powers then Vader would of won plus Maul had lots of prep time that Vader did not for this fight plus lots of use of don moch yeah.

[@monkadelic13]

maul has been clapped so many times youd think he would be in mexico or a clinic- he got clapped TWICE by anakins padawan

[@jeffs7764]

what the name of this comic

[@RetneysHolocron]

It's from the Dark Horse Star Wars Tales series

[@iLoveMiIfs]

They where kind of right they knew Vader wasn’t completely gone

[@quickhallsshow576]

Nah bro, if this was a canon fight, Vader would dominate maul

[@stevemarce1988]

Bravo 👏🏽

[@elibridgers2781]

Is the same Maul who would later be reintroduced in The Clone Wars, or is he a different Maul altogether?

[@youuglymess]

The Clone Wars happened before Anakin became Vader,on top of that,This Maul is a mere clone

[@Finfection]

I know your comment is 3 months old, but I don't see a reply. This story was written before Maul was brought back in the clone wars show. This story is basically a non-canon story even when trying to fit it into the legends/EU continuity.

[@elibridgers2781]

@@Finfection I know this was written before he returned in The Clone Wars, but when I looked at his page in the Legends continuity on Wookiepedia, I picked up that he died in 0 BBY.

[@Finfection]

@@elibridgers2781 That's why legends is so messy. Even though it says he died in 0 BBY, if you scroll down that page you'll see that there was also a post-ROTJ story in Legends where Luke encounters Maul because his brain was kept alive in a bacta tank. Both these stories are from Star Wars tales in the early 2000s and they operated under the idea that Maul had been dead since TPM with no true explanation of how he comes back. Trying to make sense of it isn't worth the headache. lol

[@sydneysmith1521]

Wasn't Anakin a little boy at the time of Maul's death? I am not convinced Maul survived getting his spine severed by a lightsaber.

[@RJoelDOrr]

You may not be convinced but it’s cannon…. And he used the force to keep himself alive also can’t really assume the anatomy of a Zabrak is the same as a human. Finally it’s a fictional series so they can write the story they want. 🤷

[@Lily_Hasson666]

Yes he was he was around 9 years old when maul got killed by obi wan

[@Honda-wf6qj]

INSANE......😮

[@briancc2100]

I love starwars and you are a super dork

[@TobyTBD]

Is Legends apart of the cannon of Star Wars?

[@RetneysHolocron]

No, Legends is the previous continuity! The new canon was established in 2014

[@ProphetOfDoubt]

Man Anakin. Your story just keeps getting sadder

[@jakeb8838]

Do more longer videos like this. Your other videos are too short

[@RetneysHolocron]

I don’t worry about runtime when making a video. I just focus on telling the story and sharing info. I don’t like when creators pad their runtime and make the videos longer on purpose

[@jakeb8838]

@@RetneysHolocron ok I get it. I still enjoy your videos and they’re amazing. Keep up the great work!

[@RetneysHolocron]

Thanks so much dude 🙏

[@delraydad7516]

How could they fight? Maul was cut in half and fell down a thousand foot drop.

[@Zeus-fv1io]

so vadar isn't interested in bringing people back to life? you know the whole reason why he went to the dark side.

[@SuperKokssssss]

Is it cannon?

[@RetneysHolocron]

No, this is Legends

[@eddherring4972]

Rule of 2?

[@CompanyHaze]

People don't realize there is most a very difference on the dark side❤

[@bigjohncasey2641]

So much better than Disney garbage

[@Insomniac_Hart]

Theres no such things as legends. Its just Disney fucking things up.

[@CallOfDutyMenace]

But Maul Fought Anakin a few times so Vader did fight him kinda

[@KING-tz6lo]

Maul better

[@JohnMichniak]

Disney has all of these stories but continue to churn out garbage. Incredible

[@ciscoe007]

Wait a second? Maul was killed by Obi Wan again in animation. What is canon?

[@Finfection]

This is an old story that was released years before Maul even returned in the clone wars show. This was basically never a canon story even for legends.

[@joshuahchristenbury7371]

Darth maul died before Darth vadar was alive

[@RetneysHolocron]

Bro didn't watch Clone Wars or Rebels

[@respektetoutlavi714]

So before Disney hijacked Star Wars & made up terrible Imagine-less fake stories to 💩 on the epic actual stories…

[@biscuitoliva1984]

Disney sucks I miss the expanded universe lol.

[@davidb9284]

What comic is this from?

[@RetneysHolocron]

Star Wars Tales Issue 9

[@nathanielroberts3451]

🙏🏿❤️❤️🙏🏿

[@nomore2226]

Who cares? Star wars sucks. It's become a joke. Let the corpse rot. Even 4 5 6 and 1 2 3 have become garbage..... because it all just leads to disney

[@brianstrutter1501]

Except he didn't

[@malcolmcouturier6993]

Shouldnt Vader be significantly better than Maul?

[@user-iu1ru1qz7u]

For sure, this is the typical stupid writing where they purposely weaken a character to create a conflict to overcome. It's like you're superman is always an idiot who somehow gets into trouble, yet when he's the bad guy they show that he's actually invincible. Big letdown whenever "writers" do this.

[@JM-db8ez]

Darth Vader never fought "Darth" Maul.

[@DoomRay666]

@@JM-db8ez in the comics they did