The Porsche Macan (S) is NOT worth your money. Here is why…

[@pandy7358]

I have owned various versions of the Macan - Turbo, GTS, S, Base and so on + a few hundred hours tracking them. I have had ZERO issues with them. The driving dynamics are fantastic (find one with PTV+). I have a small child and a dog - no problems with space. Buy a CPO vehicle or an extended warranty if it provides you piece of mind. Jump in, drive and enjoy. Some misinformation info in this video - including costs for various issues (timing chain bolts and transfer case). Yes- the SQ5 and the X3 M35/40i are also a great choice (i have owned both) BUT neither feels as special. Side note- cross shop the Alfa Stelvio if you prime target is chassis feel (its the best of the bunch). Drive them all and see what fits you best! Otherwise - great work on the video's! Drive what you enjoy!

[@qushu]

I bought a 2016 Macan S December 2021 and so far no problems... Next week I have an appointment at Porsche dealer to extend warranty by another 2 years... This fun will cost 2500€ together with the preliminary 111 Point inspection..... With my limited experience so far, I can recommend the car. It looks good, it makes you look good :) Don't sneeze in the car otherwise you may press on the throttle inadvertently and beam instantly... fast car... :)

[@donaldbillings1693]

40 years ago my first porsche was a 73 914, since then the wife & I have owned seven 911's. We just purchased a 2015 Macan S. Early impressions are awesome. It's powerful enough, and rides like a dream. She's very smooth and quiet. We got our Macan with 50K miles and we paid under 30K out the door. Haters are going to hate, opinions are like @ss holes everybody has one.

[@JetFire9]

Some people have two assholes. One is on their face.

[@DumindaA]

I embarked on a thorough exploration of top-tier SUVs in search of the perfect vehicle, meticulously test-driving models like the Cayenne, X5, X3, GLE, and GLC. However, my SVU automotive odyssey reached its pinnacle the moment I grasped the wheel of a Macan S - it was an instant infatuation. The Macan S transcends the typical SUV experience; with its dynamic handling and responsiveness, especially in Sport and Sport+ modes, it exudes a palpable sense of power and agility. What truly sets the Macan S apart is its ingenious design. Featuring larger rear tyres and smaller front tyres, it effortlessly embraces the curves of the road, particularly evident when navigating the winding paths of Mount Dandenong. Every twist and turn reaffirmed the value of my investment, as the Macan S delivered an unparalleled driving experience that exceeded every expectation.

[@kevinbrown7616]

@DumindaA: Thank you for writing this. I've been looking at exactly the same cars and to hear someone say this is what they chose is super helpful. I'm going to do the same thing. I think I will buy a slightly used one and get the extended warranty so I can save some money. I really excited to finally do this. Thanks again for your insight. KB

[@ImTHATguy...]

We rented a 2015 Macan S a couple of years ago on vacation, drove it for 4 days and loved it. I'm 6'3", my wife is 5'11" and my son is the same. We all fit just fine. We loved it so much we bought a 2018 GTS. The GTS sounds better than the S.

[@PeggyBrown-ui1wg]

It's DEFINITELY enough excitement for me... it's my first Porsche. I found myself going faster than I expected initially, but as with all cars; you learn ❤! The very first drive on a super highway, there was a car suddenly stopped around a bend.....was I ever glad for my Porsche RACING BREAKS! YES

[@JJPineda1114]

I have a 2017 Macan S bought new. I now have 76K mi. I have had BMW's, Audi x3, Volvo. The Macan S is the best of all. I use for cross country treks and for daily driving. I used it for a few years before I retired. I think it is a great car. Frankly , I don't see what the complaining is about. Will I get a 911 next? Probably yes.

[@cadreamdrives]

I'm very happy you're enjoying your Macan S! That's what matters! My Macan S was my 7th Porsche (I'm a big fan of the brand), but it just left me a little cold and uninspired. But we all have different tastes and I'm super glad you're loving your car!!!

[@joshuacalvinyoung]

I can respect your point of view. For me, being a new driver for 1 year standing, I’ve only owned a 2020 mustang eco boost before it got totaled in a hydroplaning accident. I’m a musician (jazz bassist) & I love the trunk space for my music gear. I prefer the mid size suv over the Cayenne size. I even have the same 2017 Macan S volcanic grey color, gotta admit if it’s not in sport mode it’s not as spirited a drive. I do love the sound of the exhaust with the windows down. Also when cruising around it’s a pretty comfy ride. Got mine used 2 months ago at 79k miles and has only had a coolant leak so far. Crossing my fingers for no TCC leak!! The repair was $1400 at dealership but for me there’s no price tag for putting a smile on your face. So far there’s been no other issues. Maybe as I get more experience I will feel differently in the future. Apples to oranges of course. Thanks again for your thorough review.

[@cadreamdrives]

I’m so happy you’re enjoying your Macan S! They are great cars in many ways - and they are drop dead gorgeous! For me, the Macan never really made my heart beat faster - but that’s just my experience, and I’m sure it makes a lot of people very happy! Congratulations on the entry into Porsche ownership. That’s a special feeling - and a fairly exclusive club to be a member of! I’ve been lucky enough to own quite a few Porsches, and my one recommendation would be to find a good non-dealer mechanic in your area. Your wallet will thank you immensely over time. There are several great online forums for Porsche owners (rennlist.com is one of the biggest) and people are generally great about recommending local mechanics there. Good luck with the Macan S going forward! (I still can’t drive by one without wondering if I maybe should get one again 😄)

[@joshuacalvinyoung]

@@cadreamdrives haha! Thank you for the info and I enjoy all your review videos. I appreciate the passion behind them. Will do those things, best regards. Cheers

[@2010hyundaielantra]

I got one as a loaner car surprisingly and it was pure agony. the car drives way slower than it's actually going, the steering wheel bruised my hands, the ac barely works, and the brakes are so good they suck. what I will give this car though is the handling was astronomical and it's very roomy for such a car, so don't shove it away, but keep in mind I would never buy one for myself.

[@AccurateEnglish]

I love the Macan. I rented it for a few days through the Porsche Drive app, and I discovered that the driver's seat is not comfortable. It caused me some back pain. That was the deal breaker for me. Too bad. It's a gorgeous car.

[@cadreamdrives]

That's such a bummer when that happens. I've had other cars where everything else was great, but I just couldn't get the seats to fit me. These days, seats tend to adjust in a million different directions, but I find that actually seems to make them more difficult to fit just right. Maybe I'm just weird that way :). In any case, thank you for watching and for your comment!

[@rustyme1122]

Doesn't matter what car I drive, I always have to use an additional lumbar pillow. I just took delivery of a 2022 Macan S with the basic 8 way seat. Toss in my lumbar pillow and I'm good to go. BTW, there are 3 seat choices in a Macan, 8 way, 14 way, 18 way.

[@METALGRAMMYS]

Good to know! Just sold my M4 last night and Macan was at the top of the list for me.

[@cadreamdrives]

@@METALGRAMMYS I'd say definitely go drive one. Your opinion may vary from mine. And if you can swing, look into the GTS or the Turbo. Those are completely different animals. The S level just isn't special enough, in my opinion.

[@alfredkc]

Test drove the new Gen 3 S with 14 way seats for half a day. Extremely comfortable. 18 way seats also felt nice in a Cayenne they had. Currently with my order I specced the 14 ways, as the leather on the 18 ways bolsters tend to wear prematurely. Not sure why you guys think it’s uncomfortable? Adjustability is great, and the seats are some of the most comfortable I’ve been in. But it rlly is just personal preference.

[@markmcinnis2526]

Bought a 2015 Macan Turbo new with NO options. No sunroof, no roof rails, no fancy painted keys, nothing. Just the sweet 400 BHP motor and PDK. Still loving it. Huge difference from the Macan S. Unfortunately, no longer available, but the GTS is close.

[@jdperalta84]

I have had a 2016 Macan S for about two years now and put about 40k miles on it and love it very much. I do have to admit though that when it was stock the power delivery did not impress me. Installed a Cobb tune and man did it transform the car. It will outperform a stock GTS model now and turbo lag is not noticable anymore. Also having the PSE option helps with the awesome sounds! The handling for the size of this car cannot be beat.

[@cadreamdrives]

I'm happy to hear your mods have brought the car more excitement! I'm still disappointed in my experience and sad that the car couldn't deliver what I expected. I still want one every time I see one on the road - but then I have to remind myself that I didn't really care for anything other than the looks :)

[@carsandcoldbrew6489]

@@cadreamdrives the newer models are a ton faster, so you should do another review on the S and GTS.

[@MultiGator78]

This guy deserves an Oscar for not laughing while he spewed out all the carefully contrived Macan hate. Be sure to subscribe!

[@llf4913]

Love my 2021 Macan S! And I drove BMWs before this.

[@zhaostephen5800]

I love my 17 macan s so much! Tech is behind its competitors; and maintenance cost is high! But it’s the best car I’ve had after owning a couple of Lexus, infiniti, and bmws.

[@cadreamdrives]

I'm very happy to hear you're enjoying your 17 Macan S. Mine obviously failed to excite me, but I know they are wildly popular, and it's great to hear that you love yours!

[@SAMMYJR00777]

​@@cadreamdrivesmehhh I wouldnt change my 928 gts to anything

[@af5235]

If you can afford it.....its well worth it...period.....if you are price sensitive, there are excellent alternatives almost as good....but .......

[@cadreamdrives]

I find my BMW X4 M40i to be a better car in almost every way - except for the exterior design. My Macan S was utterly uninspiring in comparisons. I love my Cayenne S, but the Macan was sadly not for me.

[@salimrandall]

I had a 2017 Macan S just like yours but no sunroof and black interior. I had it three years. Nice car but overpriced. I had multiple recalls and problems with it. The Porsche dealer was pompous and unprofessional during warranty service. It was too much of a headache so I traded it for a RC-F. Not to mention the Macan is build on a VW/Audi chassis. With a VW transmission not a true PDK from a 911. And Audi engines starting in 2018. I’ll save for a 911.

[@cadreamdrives]

I was really surprised with the Macan S. I love my Cayenne S, and I was very much looking forward to the Macan. But no matter how much I tried to like it, it just always left me feeling underwhelmed . I have another video on why I actually sold the car. My recall experience was not great either-.

[@alfredkc]

Hardly overpriced. An X3 M40i costs around £60k, GLC 43 from £56k. Macan S starts at £54k. My very heavily optioned order is at £68k (not locked in yet). Best value sports SUV imo.

[@amsterdamcreative]

I LOVE MY MACAN

[@PhilippStraub]

One of these guys who loves to talk things down. The glass is always half full Henrik. Life is much better with that pov;)

[@cadreamdrives]

Hi - I don't believe we've met. If we had, you'd likely know that I'm generally just about the most positive and optimistic person you can find. I fully subscribe to the glass always being half full - or in most cases, way more than that. However, sometimes there are things that just aren't objectively great. For me, that was the Macan S. Is it a good car? Absolutely. It's also wildly popular! But for me, the Macan S is a case of the Emperor's New Clothes. I love my Porsches (I still have two), but I also expect a lot from Porsche. And the Macan S just didn't deliver for me.

[@jinro_]

if spec'd with PASM + sport chrono + PSE the macan definitely livens up and isn't as docile as this example

[@brormonberg8945]

Always look forward to Henrik's points of view! He's an expert in this field. His presentations are entertaining, well crafted, and provide great information, all researched. This is an honest appraisal of a best selling, somewhat pricey, prestige SUV.

[@cadreamdrives]

Thank you very much, Bror! I appreciate you being a loyal viewer and your always kind and insightful feedback!

[@Truth2024]

Turbo solves many of your performance problems

[@Truth2024]

Flat 6 motor sport built a Porsche approved repairs solution for the timing chain cover issue it’s 50 bucks

[@ClintVickers]

If you have problems with the timing chain cover it’s not 8k they have changed the repair it’s right at $900

[@lordglencoe2194]

I managed to hold on to mine for 14 months hoping against hope it would somehow get better. But it didn't. So it went, along with a £20k loss in that time. I agree with most of this as I mentioned in another review of this car. It is a good car in many ways but it is NOT a sports car and it might have the build quality of a Porsche but it does not drive like one. It is by some way the worst car in the Porsche line up and sells here in the UK mainly on the Porsche name and its snob value in some eyes. It handles terribly - OK I had the diesel version (just as fast as the petrol equivalent but uses half the fuel) so it was even more nose heavy and lumbering. This car does not like changing direction. The gearbox is clunky and noisy from starting, the brakes are very "grabby" at low speed making it very hard to drive slowly in traffic say. The ride in Sport mode is like a steamroller. Porsche uses the profits from Macan to pay for Boxsters (told to me by a sales person at a dealer). And the sales service and servicing was terrible. That might just be Scotland though. Overall a real DUD. If you want an SUV (and I now realise I don't) buy the Audi instead. But really, don't. Just buy a BMW 5 series. It outclasses the Macan in every single aspect.

[@cadreamdrives]

Thank you so much for leaving this comment. A lot of people have been angry with me for posting this video, but the truth is, the Macan and Macan S just don't live up to their Porsche heritage. They are stunningly beautiful cars, and they are certainly nice cars. But they are not Porsche level cars in any other way.

[@lordglencoe2194]

@@cadreamdrives A lot of Porsche owners and those who "aspired" to be, thought I must be raving mad not to like the Macan. But having owned two excellent Boxsters, (both with actual Porsche flat-6 engines) and done some track driving in them, I know what Porsches can do. So when I was told this was the same, I fell for it. Stupidly I did not take a test drive (my local dealer ignored me) and instead drove 500 miles to collect the car from England. On the way home I was starting to get worried that maybe I had made a £45k mistake. Over time we came to the conclusion, as you did, that they are fantastically well made cars and a joy to sit in, but if you want something a bit more interesting to drive and justify that hefty price tag, it ain't a Macan. Yes I know some people love them. Like the lady who didn't get what the paddles on the wheel of her Panamera were for (now THAT is proper car). But objectively it was the second worse car I've ever driven, beaten only by my dad's 1980 Austin Allegro (you never got that in the US but it made a Pacer look positively desirable). You know what pissed me off the most? I wrote to Porsche's UK CEO and various others to point out to them that the Macan was degrading the Porsche name - not even a response. I reached the conclusion they simply don't care about drivers any more. Their model range is looking pretty dated - the only modern car they have is the Taycan and that is tanking. Macan and Cayenne are VW/Audi not far under the skin, Boxster/Cockster/911 are all much the same except for engine location, and all at least 25 years old. There seems to be nothing new in the pipeline other than ever more expensive rehashes of older models. Porsche is skating on very thin ice. Hence my return to classic BMWs - 5 and 3 series. Now have a 5 year old 335d X drive. 313 bhp and eats most Porsches before breakfast. Beautifully designed and made cars, drive stunningly well. About to do 4000 miles around Europe on decent roads. Can't wait.

[@leanidis300]

I just bought a 2020 Macon S, didn't do a ton of research on this model but hoping it's as much or more enjoyable then my MB GLC300 was. any tips or suggestions is appreciated...

[@stzw613]

floor it when you can.

[@yuraplus3]

Try Macan Turbo. That is the one to buy and keep forever... True Porsche

[@flatlandAutoSales]

I felt this, just bought a 2016 S. I was expecting more , well Porsche and a little less Soccer mom wanted a fancy badge. I like the car, but it's very boring. I don't think I'll have it very long, but it's always on to the next car

[@cadreamdrives]

Thank you for posting this! That was complexly my feeling as well. It was a very nice car - but there just wasn’t anything special about it - especially not in the performance area. I expected so much more based on my experiences with my previous Porsches.

[@flatlandAutoSales]

@CA Dream Drives I think I'm gonna trade mine for a 4tunner. Wife has a 06 with 330k miles. It needs nothing. I just had the oil changed and PDK oil changed. $1270. Ridiculous. It's just not worth the maintenance costs to me. Maybe if it was fast and super fun to drive

[@cadreamdrives]

@@flatlandAutoSales Wow - that’s crazy expensive! Did you take it to a Porsche dealer, or was this at an independent facility?

[@flatlandAutoSales]

@@cadreamdrives porsche dealer. It had a recall that needed done. It's coming up on spark plugs, $750, and they wanted like $300 for a cabin filter lmao

[@cadreamdrives]

@@flatlandAutoSales I would definitely find a good independent mechanic. Porsche dealer maintenance (and really all of the big three German dealers’ maintenance) is crazy expensive! Or, if you like tinkering, do the spark plugs yourself and out $$$ back in your own pocket!

[@ryanmatthew511]

These small SUVs are still Porsche, they were never meant to mimic a 911. Sporty design... for middle class. Thats what its for.

[@cadreamdrives]

I get that - I didn’t expect it to be a 911. But my old, 2012 Cayenne S has way more driving feel (and that thing is a truck) - and don’t get me started on my BMW X4 M40i. It blows the Macan S out of the water in every driving category. But the Macan sure is pretty!

[@JimmyXie]

Seeing your new upload is literally the highlight of my morning! Thanks for these insightful vids! I have so many things to say and ask about the Macan S. I’ve always been a fan of small performance-oriented crossovers, and the Macan was my dream car. I currently drive the Mazda CX-5 (with Turbo), and went to test drive the Macan S you had - same as you, I was very disappointed - literally agree with everything you said. I know that for the new model year, the S is the new GTS, and the GTS is the new Turbo. With the facelift, interior refresh, and the added power, would you say the new Mecan S is finally a proper Porsche now for the price? I am also looking at the CLC 43 and X3 M40i - very torn on which one I should set as my goal for the next a couple of years. How would you compare the three, in terms of handling and reliability? Thank you so so much!

[@cadreamdrives]

Thank you so much for your kind feedback - It means more than you can imagine! I have not yet driving the new '22 Macans, I like the way they look (but then again, looks were never the issue with the Macans!), and the interior updates are nice (but still fairly minor). I am very happy to see that they added a spot for your sunglasses / phone on the center console :). For me, the main issues were the overall blah-ness of pretty much everything that affects the driving experience. My Macan S never put a smile on my face and it never made me feel excited in any way. I'm going to guess that a slight bump in horsepower isn't going to change that much. My X4 M40i is magnitudes more fun and engaging (the X3 version should be the same) and a much better car for the money. I've also had a GLC300 Coupe, and that car surprised me with how much I liked it. I had the most base model you could get, so it wasn't exactly a performance car, but it felt luxurious and drove very well. I would definitely check out the the 43 version of that model before buying a Macan. I would also look into the Jaguars. The F-Pace and the new, facelifted E-Pace can offer tremendous experiences in the right configurations. And for something truly different, The Alfa Romeo Stelvio will likely make you smile all day long as well!

[@crisgarrido4436]

I also had a chance to test drive a ‘19 Macan S about three weeks ago. My expectations ran so high given all the positive online reviews. Well, test-drive day arrived and I really wanted to love the Macan. But in the end, it sadly didn’t speak to me. It was overall a pretty unexceptional ride, exactly the same way Henrik described it. It reminded a lot of an Audi Q5. For a Porsche, the car totally lacks excitement. The salesman informed me the ‘22 version would feel the same as far as its driving dynamics, just a bit more power (up about 35 HP). The next day it was a trip to the BMW dealer. I test drove a ‘21 BMW X3 M40i and did not look back. What a world of difference in terms of driving dynamics, throttle response, adaptive suspension that goes from very compliant to stiff based on your drive modes (very noticeable changes). Steering is exactly what I expected on a car for driving enthusiasts. Its technological features are better, as well as its rear seat/cargo space. It also has the ability to be tame, very compliant on rough roads and even more fuel efficient than the Macan. It makes a great daily driver. We got ours delivered just a few days ago and we’re totally stoked.

[@cadreamdrives]

Congratulations on your X3 M40i purchase! I LOVE our X4 M40i. As you mention, the driving experience is MUCH more fun and spirited,, when compared to the Macan S. Enjoy your new car!

[@JimmyXie]

@@cadreamdrives Thank you so much for the thoughtful response!!! I really appreciate you. And yes, I completely agree with the "overall blah-ness" you mentioned about the Macan S. All I could think about, after the test drive, was how amazing my CX-5 is and how I can get so much power for a lower price. I am definitely leaning towards the GLC 43, but will test drive the X3 M40i as well. Cheers!

[@JimmyXie]

@@crisgarrido4436 Congrats to you!!! Did you test drive the GLC 43 too?

[@HanNguyen-vb3eo]

He sounds like a typical car sellman

[@hwyfools]

Thanks for the video. Wife car shopping and Macan on the radar.

[@cadreamdrives]

Definitely test drive one. A lot of people LOVE them. The Macan failed to excite me, but it may be exactly what she’s looking for.

[@stevenmaron8546]

Did this guy go around sharp curves, for an suv it's way better than most cars. It never feels like you're going to lose it. It blows most trucks and suvs out of the water, they can't keep up

[@cadreamdrives]

The Macan S will do everything pretty decently. But that's exactly my issue. It's a Porsche - and an S model. It should do everything much more than decently. My BMW X4M40i is WAY more fun to drive - and faster as well.

[@GuitarsAndSynths]

Drove one and was not impressed. Horrible seats, uncomfortable ride, poor quality cheap interior, way overpriced. Meh, I like the Mercedes GLE AMG way more. That’s a far classier ride with performance and better looks. Only the 911 is decent and I hate the new body style and prices increases.

[@VickiKunkel]

OMG...the seats. SO uncomfortable for me--despite trying to adjust them every which way they can be adjusted. Dealer sales person told me this is a common complaint among small framed, thin people.

[@PLPOR]

What's an SUV that feels nimble to you?

[@stephengaribaldi1378]

it is an SUV not a 911 so in light of all the hating you've done I like it

[@Nord_Mann]

So aunt Edna passed away and you didn’t sell it in the end? Recall fixed?

[@cadreamdrives]

😀 Aunt Edna survived - but I did sell Macan right after I made this video. Porsche eventually started fixing the recalled cars, but not until long after I had sold mine.

[@darinlastonphd655]

MMMmmmmmm, Its a wonderful car but I think if your looking for a URUS, Its ok to buy the MACAN GTS. Nice video I guess I understand but for me this is an AWESOME car/suv.

[@tutunci]

sorry but why you did not buy a land rover evoque??? the gearbox it's completelly garbage , the engine light will show up for no reason even in a new car . i am currntly look for a used 2017-19 macan right yesterday the let me try 2 macan bothe too old for me. the firt (2014) has over 250000 kilometers but either engine and gearbox where great and car was fast and quick good suspension and perfect electronics. the second (2017) has 180000 chilometers and better then the first . the tirth car i try was a land rover revoque 2012 with only 23000 kilometers. as soon as i drive down the road the engina light come out . the gearbox has the first 2 gear so lung and sloppy the car was slow and fee so heavvy . the gearbox did not respond at all when i change the delay was about 2 seconds. a completelly disaster. what are you talking about??? macan it's the best middle range suv ever build. u are just payed to talk bad about it.

[@luxchhun1232]

There are much more advantages than disadvantages. Don’t be too serious ! Nothing is perfect ! There must be some things you are not happy about them. Just remember Porsche Macan is the best selling in Porsche Line up.

[@andresmattos7541]

My thought is that is awfully overpriced

[@micjakes1]

Forget speed and performance, is it reliable. A porsche that will run for 10 years with only oil changes?

[@cadreamdrives]

Well, I sold mine and it was a 2017, so it still had quite a while to go until 10 years! Overall, I have found my Porsches to generally be reliable - but almost all manufacturers and models have some kind of issues. Transfer Cases have plagued both the Cayenne and the Macans, but overall, my reliability experience has been positive.

[@masterbear888]

I Guess u should get a Lambo SUV in stead haha

[@King_king0]

By comparing to Cayenne and X4, you never mention what exactly this Macan S can’t give you? In your another video, you complained as well the recall (in fact you sound more like complaining the dealer instead of the car itself) … though you tried hard to sound fair!

[@cadreamdrives]

The Recall issue was 100% about Porsche and not really about the car itself, but the Macan S pretty much failed to put a smile on my face in any scenario (except, when looking at it). I found it to be a very average and boring car with zero driving excitement, and the cabin feel and quality was nowhere near what I have gotten in pretty much every other Porsche I have owned. I get that it’s their entry level model - it just isn’t worthy of the Porsche badge in my opinion.

[@andreipretorius92]

I’m also sure the M40i sounds a lot better. Every time you start it, you smile

[@cadreamdrives]

The Macan S did have a beautiful exhaust node - you just had to be outside the car to hear it... But few (stock) cars beat the M40i (before they started limiting the sound). They do indeed make you grin every time you drive one!

[@llf4913]

well you can go for the sound and only have power to two wheels or have the Macan and the superior handling. Definitely your choice.

[@cadreamdrives]

What are your thoughts on the Macan? Please do share!

[@robinpelletstovesuk9194]

It's a stylish family wagon SUV...you are asking tooooo much of it !!! its not a sports car is it! Go but an old C43 AMG wagon w202....or buy an old Cayenne GTS v8 and suffer the bad gas mileage

[@jimmannella2291]

This is pure click bait on your part. …..“Subscribe!” “Click below!”. … This is a Porsche small SUV and the reviews have been overwhelmingly positive. Were you expecting the “911” experience from this? It’s a f’n SUV just like your Cayenne but smaller. Yeah, I clicked on your bait infused headline and I’m dumber for it. JFC…

[@cadreamdrives]

Thank you for checking out the video! I’m sorry you felt it was “clickbait”. Everyone has their own opinion about the Macan S, and for me it fell short. Everything about it (except its looks) was just forgettable to me - and not up to the usual Porsche experience. I did not expect a 911 experience from this, but I expected some “Porscheness” - and there was none to be found. The interior was not up to usual Porsche standards, and the driving experience was very bland. It’s not a bad car - it’s just not worth the Porsche premium to me. The BMW X4M40i is infinitely more fun and sporty to drive, with an intoxicating exhaust note - and just a better car in every way - and that’s every bit as much of an SUV as the Macan is. Of course, all of this is just my opinion. Many people love their Macans, and that’s fantastic! For me, it just didn’t bring what I felt it should.

[@jimmannella2291]

@@cadreamdrives I’m sorry, you drive a Cayenne, correct? Tell me what “Porsche experience” you experience with the Cayenne as opposed to the Macan? Hell, explain what the “Porsche experience “ is lol.

[@kannon965]

Is this guy a douche or just kidding? 😂 this car is amazing and everyone generally agree it’s the best in class and drives amazing lol

[@timothydenyer7749]

buy a new one?

[@andreipretorius92]

I was between this and an X3 M40, went bmw route. Very happy with the decision, it’s no slouch either.

[@cadreamdrives]

The M40i has an awesome engine and exhaust. I love my X4 M40i. So much more fun than the Macan S.

[@donaldbanner2185]

BOTH Euro Crap!..................No Hybred.....REQUIRE PREMIUM ............Terrible gas mileage Horrendous Re- Sale HEADACHES!

[@petrudumitrasculuxuryart926]

Maserati Grecale locks better .

[@jeakim4152]

That ‘ s teue !

[@extremedrivr]

But is it really a Porsche?? Sure it has the looks and badging of a Porsche. But.. Underneath it still screams VW/Audi to me. Nice review!! But I like you have to say no for the reasons I mentioned.

[@robertdevoy3119]

They should install engines by Toyota, Mazda, or Honda. Problems solved.

[@VickiKunkel]

He he. I have a 2005 Toyota 4Runner that I have been HOPING would bite the bullet because I am bored with it--lthough it is still fun to drive. I'm the original owner, bought it new, and I have never put a dime into it over the past 19 years other than normal, regular maintenance. Can't kill a Toyota--at least not the older 4Runners.

[@TucsonDude]

Your little "boinks" are pretty annoying.

[@builtyankeegirl]

It's only boring when you're still that kid who asked dad for everything in life.