THE PROBLEMS WITH BEING AN HONEST REACTION CHANNEL

[@METALBIRB]

Thanks for watching and listening guys

[@TankTheTech]

Solid video, man. I think stuff like this really needs to be talked about for people to hear because a lot of the time, this is stuff only fellow content creators or reactors truly understand until it's talked about. I agree with pretty much everything you said, and have experience a lot of it. HOWEVER. I have been really harsh about a band on a reaction and they still said "thank you" and then had em on for an interview, so ya never know. 😂

[@Laros82]

That's awesome I'd be interested to know what band that was. They got my respect

[@galacticriminalx]

You're not wrong. Honesty can really hurt ur views, engagement and shareability. Too many hot takes and u can really spoil returning viewership. I'm so glad that I stopped caring about the algorithm and whether or not a video did well VERY early on, AND never grew any aspirations to benefit monetarily from youtube. I just have fun and do what I want and pride myself ALSO as being an honest channel. It's just a shame that picking the most popular tunes and pandering or straight up FAKING a positive opinion is what pushes music react content to the front

[@thawolf5921]

Facts GC! Big names like A&P, Rolling Stones, and other magazines just pandered for yeaaaars. We need brutal honesty.

[@soulreaperamvgmv6416]

I value the responses you and Metalbirb give with the videos/songs you guys review. I was personally stoked that you reviewed the new Dragoncorpse song. I was the person that created the AMV for Blood and Stones, and I loved what you said. Not an exact quote but “even without the AMV the song was amazing” I loved working with the band in order to give them something for viewers to watch as they listened to their new song. I really hope they gain more traction and they do truly start a new sub-genre.

[@galacticriminalx]

@@soulreaperamvgmv6416 🤘😈🤘

[@w4tt58]

I like punk rock mbas videos. And he doesn't give a fuck and makes fun of everyone even people like me and I love it.

[@METALBIRB]

I also respect the fact that you try to find bangers and just share the good tunes cause you don’t want to dislike a song. But if you do you’ll say it’s not for you or something

[@SpaceTacoTV]

As you touched on, people aren't really interested in the reactors thoughts. They just want to see someone else be as excited about the band as they are. Probably some sort of human psychological effect at play. Anyway, I like your channel because you're the opposite of that. Keep doing what you're doing!

[@humanthenarrator]

For me it's both. It's like listening to your favourite music with a friend, but I do stay for the review

[@humanthenarrator]

And yeah, the reviews are great

[@jasonlovesmusicreacting882]

@@humanthenarrator Yeah, as long as the substance is there. I really find Anthony Fantano to be overly obnoxious at times when it comes to what he likes to dunk on while simultaneously praising overly average to God awful mainstream garbage. I know he’s not a reactor either but as far as reviewers go…

[@humanthenarrator]

@@jasonlovesmusicreacting882 Yes, I was mainly talking about Metalbirb tho, I just dindn't make that obvious enough

[@mmf-rules]

More when you are in a band, and you really want to know what's happening with the song in your audience, it's more honestly between artist/bands and fanbase, more transparency

[@OldSkuleNerd]

100% agree with you I have gotten the back lash but much more people appreciate me being real with them… my immediate views have taken a hit cause I don’t do just hype videos but the steady growth of people who would rather enjoy someone who is honest

[@notpc3070]

I may not agree with a reactor, but I won't down vote them for it. People have to remember that it's just one person's opinion, and I'm sure you know what they say about opinions. Props for staying true to yourself.

[@OhrionReacts]

Keep staying true dude 🤘🔥 so glad you stick to your true self. Mad respect and that's why I love your content. Great video Metalbirb 🤘 KZbin is a mental game for sure 😖

[@PreciousLettuce]

hello, ohrion

[@OhrionReacts]

@@PreciousLettuce lettucccce!

[@VioPLayable]

Yeah, I really enjoy watching reactors vibe to a band as much as I vibe to a band, but I also enjoy someone expressing honest thoughts. You've never been disrespectful in your videos EVER and you provide a safe place for discussion. That's respectable, really

[@FYMPRODUCTIONSMEDIA]

Great video bro. You have to be one of the most honest out here along with ohrion & richard janvrin. I also love how you can go so deep into the technical stuff...whereas im like "Yeah pure filth - love it haha"

[@danielspencer4564]

This is why I've stayed with you since the almost beginning. There's no bullshit with you and you give actual insight into why you like or dislike something. And the community you've built shows that as well

[@ptbempire]

This my friend is why I subbed because you aren't afraid of speaking your mind. I enjoy showcasing other bands that people don't know hoping that others will be discovering something new.

[@adecakaship2486]

I am the same my man, I know I'm late, but yeah. I just commented on another reaction channel and I was kind of really transparant in a negative way about my thoughts regarding the band's song. I was really respectful tho. They replied to my comment in the best of ways. I'm happy some bands can take criticism. I always mention that I understand why a band might do this and that, but that it doesn't appeal to my personal tastes. Anyway, you're my king reactor birby. /kiss

[@Thewingestofdings]

Mans what sucks is that sometimes I go to like a video and I have an error in my brain and suddenly it’s pressing the dislike button and then I panic and quickly hit the like button lol worries me a lot. Like oh no they hate me now

[@user-ke3dg4yd1u]

I LOVE the addition of pros and cons and your opinion! Keep it up man, makes you unique and interesting

[@CaptainBangief]

I dont always agree with your opinions on songs and bands. But I would rather watch an honest critical reaction than a fake enthusiastic one.

[@chrizszx]

Keep being honest dude!

[@johnnykooks4096]

Dude you spit so much heat in this video my phone caught on fire.

[@viktor821]

Big difference being a react channel and a critic/review channel

[@theBOSpaladin101]

Your commentary and reviews of the songs when you listen to them, whether good or bad, is the main reason why I love your channel. It's so boring just watching a plain reaction to something without adding anything to the discussion.

[@alexst3232]

I can say that I agree with you on the CJ video. I personally loved the song but the criticisms are valid and I agree with most of it, even though I am the type of person that sees CJ on a track and will instantly love it. Honesty is why I come back here and it gives deeper insight and meaning to music hearing your thoughts. Keep being you Birb!

[@MY1BLACKCAT]

i am suspicious of all reaction reviewers - they all seem to be clearly being used by record company to hype their artist - like the reaction people getting perks sent to them and it looks like they are getting things like getting live concert access and things like that. I am getting more and more like not watching anymore reaction videos . theyre just pointless

[@Sasfoot]

Honest reactions are great. Pantera is my favorite band but I'm not a big fan of The Great Southern Trendkill. I've had other people tell me I'm not a real fan but not every album for a band as awesome as Pantera was gonna be a complete banger like CFH, VDOP, and FBD.

[@TheDoctorPhreak]

100% agree bro. I remember when tallah dropped thier debut album I found this pod cast who absolutely hated them but I found some insight from it and saw that yeah there are some tonal things that they could change to be better.

[@xMeme_X_Lordx]

Hot take. I loathe the Metallica fanbase.

[@jasonlovesmusicreacting882]

I do too.

[@austinsomogyi9051]

As a Metallica fan I agree

[@mattilindstrom]

Don't ever stop being honest to yourself. As a Nightwish fan I'm sorry for the things the fans have done to you or others. Mostly I find the fanbase being reasonable and understanding, voting and leaving a comment if you find anything enjoyable in the song. Otherwise my impression is that we'll just stay silent. Carry on and like or hate songs, according to your own taste.

[@theglanconer6463]

Always be honest. That's it. Never ever pander. Concerning Eskimo Cowboy. I hated their name change. Groveling at the feet of the woke crowd. They've become part of the problem. Definitely not Ricky Gervais. Got quite a lot of hate for it (but much more support). But to be honest. 85% positive is bad ? (have you ever been at school ?) 8,5 ! Wicked. Anyhow always be honest, stay true & *ck the haters & the herd (but never criticize the Pogues or you will get it :) That said I love Nightwish, Floor is brilliant but if you don't like it, it's ok (of course). Never knew we were toxic.

[@GAYKEEPDEEZNUTZ]

The cult like fan response to the cj song is just creepy as fuck. Everyone instantly becomes an advocate for the integrity of a dude they don’t even know and have never met. It’s just so cringe because the song is mid as fuck lol and there’s legitimately reason why and yet no real critique matters to fanboys. It’s okay to like the song but it’s also okay not too. They don’t get that.

[@TheDjentleman77]

You be you man. 🤘🏻 I appreciate honesty all day every day. I would never dislike a video just because the reactor in question didn’t like the song that I absolutely love. Also, the world would be such a boring place if everyone had the same opinion. Keep on rollin! 🔥🤙🏻

[@malefikgamer5446]

It all comes down to your integrity. I honestly think that bands will respect your honest opinion MUCH more if you actually stick to your values and don't just produce an echo chamber and pander to your audience. So stick to your guns and don't ever cave in just for views your audience will appreciate the honesty and I think the bands will as well.

[@jadecasssie]

As a creator I am often challenged with making content that is 'popular' or that will sell. I was told my page/website would not be successful because I refuse to pander. It's hard. I could easily lie, or make stuff I don't really care about, or talk about all the same artists everyone else does. Instead I'd rather promote smaller/DIY/underground artists and bands that I actually know and want to see succeed. While I understand You have to play the game and do what the algorithms demand in order to be on top but I'm content with being part of something bigger than that.

[@LasTortugasAzules]

The CJ Mccreery stans are definitely out in full force on that Immortal Disfigurement song. They're all over every reaction channel, screeching about how he's 100% innocent and the greatest deathcore vocalist of all time. If you don't just mindlessly praise the song, they attack But hey, toxic people attract toxic fanboys I guess

[@LasTortugasAzules]

@Freddy Rugerlol, see the stans are still out

[@chrisp.14]

Having an honest opinion which doesn't go along with the majority is always running the gauntlet alwasy was hard. I am on the interwebs since 1999 now, and already, in the mIRC chats and in the first forums, it was not easy not to give a fuck about other peoples' opinion. It always was the same wherever it was. I also wrote music reviews online from 2003 to 2017, same story. The good thing about being a youtuber, twitcher etc is that you are the boss of yourself. You can still ignore the comments and just think: Okay, just let em talk. In forums, bulletin boards and for example facebook groups, this really sucks a lot. Let's say it this way: Even though always staying respectful and polite and always explaining your views, no matter how subjective they were, I even got banned from forums and groups. Just by having opinions. Just because you don't fit with the others. Just because you say what you think about a certain piece of art. It just repeats itself, just on different platforms.

[@ArsRegnandi]

Maybe we bark at the wrong tree. If a video does have 85% likes and 15% dislikes, then in a sane mind this is still a very positive ratio. "Yes, but KZbin algorith...". Yep, there is the problem.

[@coretaku]

Your honesty is easily why I subscribed. Oh, and the fact that you, and MetalBabe are big fans of Spiritbox of course. Lol.

[@randommetalhead7]

i think it's mostly the way you talk that triggers people. you have a big voice and you're honest about shit. i can relate to that cause alot of people got pissed at me for simply just wanting to have a normal conversation with them lol. maybe try to slightly tune down the tone of your voice if you want less people to take offense of literally anything you might say in the future. personal advice from another honest dude with a big voice who also triggers people by accident. :)

[@naz88-36]

the truth will always win in the end..

[@jasonmarshall7572]

Is Nightwish fan base or Army dislike you?. I'm a Nightwish fan but yet i don't see any reason to hate you? And i've seen Nightwish reactors just sitting their laughing it off and taking the piss and i felt they didn't even try from the start it was like hey chose a group we can take the piss oh how about this one. Any way it's your channel and you have the right to run it anyway you want to and if somebody doesn't like what you say they can just unsubscribe and leave. I'm sure your opinions are based on your knowledge and experience and it maybe bias based on your taste or not? But that's you and people should just learn to respect that. Good for you for being open. Thank you.

[@justinvarieur4411]

Ngl I really only watch reaction videos as an excuse to listen to a song I like over and over again 😂 but I definitely agree with what you're saying

[@LasTortugasAzules]

It's brutal that being honest hurts your channel, but just know that those of us who subscribe really appreciate it I only watch two reaction channels, and the reason you're one of them is that you actually give pros and cons, and tell us how you truly feel about a song. I'm use Nik Nocturnal as an example. He seems like a great guy and is fun to watch, but I don't watch his reactions because everything he says about the songs he reacts to is positive. And just listening to constant praise for every song that comes out gets boring very quickly You're unique in that you give us your honest thoughts, and I hope that never changes

[@UtmostAxe]

this was a really good video. I especially agree with your part about the pandering and using Electric Callboy as an example was a fantastic comparison. my highest video so far is an electric callboy reaction and it's just bc if you have a positive reaction to them it's a goldmine

[@rupbhatt]

Important video. To be very frank, I am yet to watch your video on Spaceman as that song didn't do anything for me and sounded like a cover band of EC, so skipped reaction videos of it.

[@andyohil7465]

it's absolutely right to be honest. If someone doesn't like a band/song, then of course they can say so. But since it is a reaction channel, please give reasons. But what must also be allowed as a viewer of the channel is, of course, criticism on the part of the viewer - be it of the band/song or of the channel/channel operator. That's nothing reprehensible.

[@djomla9999]

Were the dislikes on CJ song because of CJ controversy or because you didn't love the song? Or both...

[@BigDenk]

Good point tbh. I would say cause he didn't love the song but yea could be either

[@DenyThisFlesh]

I appreciate the honesty from you and any other channel that gives their real opinion instead of just riding the hype train.

[@InteractionImplants]

Just a thought. You mentioned people often form an opinion based of a video title and will thumbs down unpopularly critical headlines. I personally wouldn't mind if you were more cryptic with the video titles for songs that you had heavy constructive criticism for. I don't really consider the titles much myself, and I enjoy the surprise of what your opinion actually is. As a side note, when you feature lesser known bands on the channel, that's always a sign that it's music worth checking out. I appreciate that.

[@joedavies6364]

"Criticism is so much more valuable than pandering"...this is SO true. Today I had a presentation at University. The tutor asked my fellow students to give feedback and they all said "Yeah it was good, well done" As soon as it came to the Tutor, they gave me sooooooo many worthwhile criticisms that will help me grow for the future. Pandering literally gets you nowhere

[@juansnowgaming]

People went in on me for my Cj reaction.

[@patbateman8116]

Imo your honesty is so refreshing as opposed to certain channels just pulling weird faces and “liking” everything for views. Also even though I might not agree with all your takes, your lack of bias and just love for music in general just makes me want to watch every video you put out even if you don’t like something from a band I love haha. Keep up the great work man 🤟

[@dylan_monument]

Loving that you’re expanding the channel past just reactions dude! Keep it up!

[@chrism2964]

This is entirely on KZbin, not the fans. The fans are fans, its short for fanatics, so Duh.. The problem is KZbins algorithms, completely, 100%, totally. Same with copyright strikes, same with the god awful search.

[@zwhtan]

This should get many++ thumbs-up. I hate the fact that even when I know exactly what I'm looking for I can't find it on KZbin, but I get 100 recommendations for something that I glanced at in passing and have no real interest in.

[@sbueller1987]

Your hair is fucking awesome!

[@Kotsoros37]

I agree its important to be honest imo people don't always have to agree with each other. You keep saying CJs apology video but he never made an apology video it was a statement defending himself to accusations that some people even apologized to lying about. Also I never downvote I usually just comment, music is subjective, I do agree that sometimes when the tone of the video headline is bad and I know i like the song it can be a turnoff to watch sometimes so I just usually ignore it unless I'm in the mood lol

[@shspurs1342]

Loads of reactors take it to the limit. I.E pretend to love everything they react/listen to. Which obvious isn’t possible.

[@thunderwatch8463]

Look man, I use to watch a lot of reaction content. These days there are only a few reaction channels that I still watch because most of them are just too fake and you start to see through it eventually. You've always come off as an honest, genuinely cool dude. I don't always share your opinions, but people can disagree on things (especially music), it's no big deal. Keep being yourself and doing what you're doing.

[@jasonlovesmusicreacting882]

I’m honest too but certainly don’t have an amazing set up yet lol if I reach 500 subscribers then maybe I’ll start to put some investment into that.

[@mattlupu152]

This was a good video to watch and I like how it gives an inside look at how things really are. I never liked the dislike/like function on social media as it has so many negative consequences. It is silly that because 10% of people don't agree it causes problems. The one problem I have with the video is naming bands fans as toxic. The point of the video could be made without this and seems sort of vindictive and toxic in its own right. It puts a negative and confrontational feeling out that really doesn't lend itself to productive discourse.

[@METALBIRB]

Fair enough about the bands! But I can't speak for everyone but I avoid certain fanbases after being critical with their music and Nightwish is a prime example. I received death threats from the fans and I even gave them a second shot months later, only for them to still attack me in the comments. So why bother making videos for them when I can make videos for other bands?

[@adityapillai2157]

Honest critical reactions which I might even disagree with >>>> Biased fake reactions

[@jacobwalters]

I enjoy watching your reactions because they feel more genuine and not scripted. I enjoy agreeing and disagreeing with you, I think Electric Callboy recently has been sounding repetitive, I believe Immortal Disfigurement was mid, I love having discussions. I can't ever join the streams due to work, but I like to listen to others' opinions since I have no friends to talk to irl. Please remain honest and forget those haters.

[@richardseeley6311]

Sure the channels who have less authentic reactions or pander to audiences and bands might be more popular now but I believe staying true to yourself and being real with your videos will benefit you more in the long run. It also makes your channel more fun as a viewer imo because I never know what you’ll like or dislike about a song. This is why you’re my favorite reaction channel man!

[@duradrian1]

Man this topic gets my blood boiling hard. There is NO value in dishonest reactions (which are the majority). Imma say this again, not as a hater, but as someone who really enjoys Nik's content other than the reactions. It's clear that Nik kinda "leads the game" in terms of popularity of metal reactions and networking, having the opportunity to be close and create things with people who many of us would call "idols". But I get so sick with it, cause all of this is built over a culture of pleasing others just for the show. It's so empty and superficial. You get many views, you get to talk to bands and people you admire, but as a result of what? As a result of videos full of vague opinions, bad memes and "catch phrases" that portray the same excitement over everything. It's obviously just here to be there and create engagement, it adds nothing to the discussion. The videos are made trying to be as optimistic as possible, being ultra superficial (cause "GOD FORBID if I go too deep on my thoughts about this people may not like what I say"), a fake excitement is portrayed and people watch it pretending they believe (I think its like some mental masterbation, like seeing someone pretending they love a song you like). It wouldn't bother me if this wasn't the "pinnacle" of metal reactions, what bothers me is knowing that success, networking and engagement is primarily being built around vague "just for show" content, and not with meaningful discussions.

[@jasonlovesmusicreacting882]

The thing I don’t understand is you have people like Finn McKenty who is way more unfiltered with his opinions but when it comes to Architects and literally any band at the top in terms of popularity he’ll kiss their ass then write off bands like Northlane and ERRA as “Architectscore”. And he’ll still get the views. Is it because he’s older and people enjoy the gatekeeping crap or are they disliking a lot of his videos? I don’t currently have a laptop so can’t see dislike ratio btw.

[@thunderwatch8463]

The thing is, I can guarantee you that if Northlane and Erra were as popular as Architects, Finn would be singing their praises in every other video. I like the guy and enjoy his content, but he's got a lot of stupid opinions and seems to think popular=objectively good. Oh, there is no way some of his videos don't get disliked into oblivion 🤣🤣🤣

[@jasonlovesmusicreacting882]

@ThunderWatch846 Yeah, I know. Just for me it’s come to the point where I don’t even want to watch his content anymore lol

[@jasonlovesmusicreacting882]

@The Coin Has A Say yessir

[@gamesinfinity98]

I love Tool and also love you too :)

[@savageplanet8299]

Totally agree with everything you said. I don't comment on your videos often, but I have to say that your honesty is what made me hit the subscribe button. I think it was actually after watching a video of you disliking a song that I liked. I love honesty. It's so transparent to me when these reaction channels are fake and just absolutely love everything they hear. That's not natural. No one likes everything. It really does come off as pandering and a gigantic waste of my time. It's so much more rewarding when you finally do see an honest reaction to a song or band that you like, and they like it as well. That's some true solidarity that I can get behind. Anyway, keep being you, and above all else, keep being honest, no matter the consequences.

[@joshgrillo6115]

I like the criticism whether I agree or not, I always watch your reaction videos regardless. Great content!

[@Cornchps827]

When I first saw a reaction video about the music I like/interested in. There was the one british hardcore guy and noticed quickly maybe 6 videos in that he says the EXACT same positive things. after I noticed that I couldn’t watch him ever again. Fake ass videos

[@Harv72b]

We live in a world where a _lot_ of people treat their opinions as facts and treat those who agree with them as providing evidence for their "facts", marking anybody who disagrees or even qualifies their agreement as "wrong". I could go on forever about how we got here & why, but nobody wants a comment that takes longer to get through than the video its posted on. 😄 Also, KZbin's algorithm is a flat out joke. I understand why content creators have to take it into account, I just wish KZbin itself would actually attempt to improve it.

[@jasonlovesmusicreacting882]

Don’t worry, I wrote an essay too. I’ll still never get the algorithm. Sometimes my KZbin shorts do better but lately my Tik Toks have been doing so much better…

[@OldheadMike]

Don’t read the comments on my CJ video

[@shanefoleyyyyy]

Couldn't agree more on your perspectives. One of the realist reaction channels out there. Much love metalbirb ❤

[@zerozeeros]

As I said on the CJ video I don't mind criticism of the song it was more your take on him. It was super unfair

[@DillSkin]

I dislike reaction channels that just say they like everything. I like your taste and ACTUAL ‘breakdown’ of the song instead of just reacting. I find I actually learn things from you which I why I watch

[@karl00l]

Real 1 MR.BIRB!

[@toyotaecw]

This is the only reaction channel I’m subscribed to. Our tastes aren’t the same but the content is quality. Keep up the good work🤘

[@jasonlovesmusicreacting882]

I see how it is!!! Lol

[@zwhtan]

Even though I don't agree with your every thought (why should I?), I'm subscribing *because of this video. I don't think I've ever downvoted a reactor. If someone is pretentious and inexplicably opinionated, i just go elsewhere. Trolls on the other hand get severely downvoted (and generally aren't worth a comment).

[@hunterwilliams8490]

So i appreciate honest channels. Follow a lot of good ones, Finn McKenty, and Intergalactic Criminal are two of my favorite. I think a) bands look at these for constructive criticism (erra interviewed with Finn after the backlash the fan base gave him for a reaction of one of their songs) b) sparks conversation and debates that I think is healthy. Not everybody has to agree on everything. There are too many sheep now a days. I hate the channels that pander, but I also hate channels that make non constructive comments and trash bands. I can also agree with toxic fanbases, I’m a huge Korn fan, and can say that the fanbase can be very toxic. I really like your channel because it’s real, I love the pros and cons section and often agree with what you say.

[@devdirty3191]

You should check out the new track from A Wake In Providence

[@rc88tcb]

I kind of realized with this video that you might be the most honest reactor I watch. Its a tremendous thing! Keep it up.

[@JohnnyRychous]

I agree 100 percent about your criticism stance. Growth comes from discussion and feedback. I find it incredibly boring when someone just says “I like it”. Sure, that’s fine and I understand people don’t like to discuss but I’m in the area where I enjoy discussion and I like to hear “the why”. I’ve been a fan of your channel FOR YOU. Not for what you can do for me as a subscriber. You most definitely are a real one…and I appreciate the shit outta you! 👊😂

[@ramiroquiroga2949]

Your genuine personality is what I keep coming back for. Being honest and genuine shouldn’t hurt you. That’s just not fair man. Much love to you and keep being you.

[@drewoo_]

Hey man always love the content but I don’t comment much. For what it’s worth, I say double down and TRY to have a discussion even with the toxic fan bases. If it becomes an argument then stop, but a discussion is a 2-way street! I appreciate this video and I don’t want you to waste your time, but you can’t say you want a discussion without challenging opposing opinions. Anyway I’m here for the content either way. Thanks, birb🤘

[@padtron7679]

This is why you’re the only reaction channel I’m subbed to, love your honesty. Can’t stand the circle jerk

[@McYates24]

maintaining your loyal subscribers like me would be staying true to yourself of course, all the phony generic reactors that don't actually analyze what they hear are boring and i think it'll pay off to have your subs being real ones that geniunely like your content and will more regularly return longer... i would think. Keep it real bruv.

[@icanmakeeverythingilovedie9861]

If you want to be truly popular, getting views/likes in the reaction side of things, then metal isn't the way to do it. It's pop and rap, unless it's like Ronnie or (again) EC. Fake or not, those songs/artists just inherently bring in more views. There's zero, comparatively speaking, relevant reaction channels based around metal. That alone says you're doing this because you enjoy it, not the money. I think the issue with some of them, and I say this as a big fan of your channel, but you lack consistency with some of your takes. You enjoy To The Hellfire despite it sounding like every song on Immortal with a weird breakdown (the only reason it went as viral as it did), but flip the switch when CJ/ID sound like Lorna Shore/Will? You don't want Copy-and-Paste music (from the Allt video), and yet you want Dayseeker to be more copy-and-paste? You say you don't gravitate toward heavy music, but you seem way harsher toward slower songs (MIW's Masterpiece, for example) than anything super heavy (BoS/WCAR, for example) or using batshit time signatures regardless of how generic it may or may not be. But everyone has their own tastes, so that's just a whatever thing to me.

[@ScreenSpidah]

You know what to do, Metalbirb. You're better than pandering, and you know it! Since day 1, you've been brutally honest (about songs I adored, too) and I appreciate you for it. That's why I'm a true fan of yours, and not just a passing spectator: "ah, just another reactor." Nah, this is metalbirb, he's in my inner circle 🤞

[@MoonOfSatan]

I only watch a few reaction channels (including yours) and every one of them tells it like it is.

[@rwood0011]

The thing is people watch reaction videos of bands / songs they like or love and in today's world they feed us information that we agree with so when we get hit with opinions we do not agree with then we handle it poorly. There is no such thing as discussion anymore. It is either you agree with me, or you are a shitty person with shitty ideas.

[@scottb.4472]

Unfortunately I think a lot of the talkit's a lot of the toxic fans you're referring to are actually a big minority however sometimes their voices are the loudest and they stand out............. It's true in life if you go to a restaurant and you really love it you might not even say anything if you hate it you'll tell anyone who's willing to listen........ I think the fans are wrong sometimes for defending their band or their singer to the ends of the Earth but I also think sometimes the reactors are wrong because they don't give the band enough time to fully evaluate who they really are..........

[@alleninfinity6730]

If you don't have something nice to say, say nothing at all. Isn't that basic etiquette? I would not react to bands or artists I do not like or respect. That isn't being dishonest, that is simply enjoying the artists that you appreciate. I mean some people like trolls and some people like the negative attention as much or more than the positive attention. Reactors and reactions are all based upon opinions, your opinion or Tank's are simply that and you should not state things as facts, unless you have evidence. If I see someone react to Floor or Nightwish and say, they are talented, just not my cup of tea, fine with that, but a person that just spews negativity I see as a person trolling. For instance, Band Maid, Babymetal, or Love Bites, not my cup of tea, they are all very talented, but I would not react to them. I don't have to pander to them for clicks or be an a**hole and run them down, because they are obviously all talented, just not for me. What is dishonest about that? What many reactors do though they will find bands, like the ones I just mentioned or Nightwish/Floor, get lots of likes and subs, then disregard them when it is convenient. Likes and subs go to some folks heads and they believe they are more than just a regular person with an opinion.

[@baotrangia3981]

Hard agree on the reddit thing, I said that I didn't like an south park episode that people like and got downvoted with no replies. I really like the way you do in depth analysis after the music unlike most reaction channels that just give generic comments. And especially because you don't pause in the middle of the song. When I watch a reaction for a song I like I want to know their actual reactions towards the song and why/what makes them like/not like it and not just praise comments. Toxic people are gonna be toxic people need to learn to ignore them. I know this is a lot of rambling about stuff that was already said in the vid I just wanted to write down my opinions

[@vogel2280]

NW Army brutal? I can't help but wonder what you said 🤣🤣 Also I can't imagine anyone saying there is anything wrong with Nightwish. 🤣🤣 Keep real man! I rather hear someone say they are too far over the top or the start of Storytime sucks (which I will never admit) then to be listing to some bad actor pretending they find everything Floor does is 100% fantastic (which is true) and Annette is equally good (which is a lie).

[@randymarple9830]

The 2 NW reactions are still viewable on Mb's KZbin channel. You can view them and see. I only found Nightwish 16 months ago so I had never seen them. A little surprised that NW was on the top of his list. Most likely because some of the hardcore fans were angry about the sexually negative comment by his lady. The commenters jumped pretty hard on her. And he jumped back, which is what we guys do. He did seem to like Romantacide, but his side glance, and seeing she still didn't like the vocals, well, he backed off....and never reacted to another Nightwish song. Happy wife, happy life.

[@pmasher]

@@randymarple9830 Yea. 2 songs 3 years ago hardly gives enough exposure to call the fans toxic, especially all this time later. Ah well. It is what it is.

[@METALBIRB]

@@pmasher dealing with death threats and racism which I received is pretty toxic. I’ve had a few other reactor friends that have issues with Nightwish fans. It’s the general consensus amongst us reactors. And the fact that Nightwish fans are triggered in this video when I barely talked about them is proving my entire point.

[@vogel2280]

@@METALBIRB Interesting reaction... You mention NW, so you show up in my daily query and I watch you video. You say you want comments, I give you one. Appearently I misinterpreted...

[@alleninfinity6730]

@@vogel2280 Maybe he only wants comments which pander to his beliefs and opinions? Is he being toxic?

[@nazman465]

You, hard core, and Nik noc are the only metal reaction channels that I keep coming back to, mainly because of the honesty. Keep up the amazing work dude 🤘🤘

[@nazman465]

You all have great personalities as well

[@VasKurtas]

Through the whole video I actually thought about Nik as exactly the person who Metalbirb was talking about. Looks like he's friend with every band, streaming with everyone. Like, does he even have negative reactions? Not saying that I don't like his content, his channel is fun, but that is just what came to my mind...

[@nazman465]

@@VasKurtas he might be exaggerating his reactions but there are absolutely times where he said he didn't like a song. Check out his Architects - Dying Is Absolutely Safe / Flight Without Feathers reaction. Those are a few I can remember off the top of my head.

[@jasonlovesmusicreacting882]

@@VasKurtas Yeah, TooLitMafia is like that too.

[@soulreaperamvgmv6416]

Stay honest and to hell with what anybody else thinks. Reaction videos are about the bands themselves and the content they release. They are getting YOUR feedback. Honest and raw feedback is what’s going to help a band grow and become better. That’s why I value channels like yours.

[@alexinferno727]

What seems to be lost today is the nuance of opinion. There really is no right or wrong view because everyone's tastes are different. So now, when someone sees a somewhat negative reaction to something they enjoy, they feel personally attacked, and immediately go on the defensive. It's a shame that you can't just share your point of view on something that you are passionate about without being punished for it. Just keep doing what you're doing, because you are one of the best on here. I never want to see you be discouraged.

[@WeaselFromNorth]

Metalbirb, i don't wanna look like I'm kissing ass or something, but you are one of my favourite reactors. I like your approach and honesty. Kinda like Nik Nok's reactions and Lost in Vegas. Watch them from time to time, but your videos I've watch pretty much always. Keep doing what you doing man. You are cool.

[@DillSkin]

If I was in a band I’d love to hear your criticisms otherwise I’d never get better

[@chazhartwayne6493]

13:40 So here's the deal with me, I RARELY if ever comment because.. Idk, I don't feel like I can add something of value to a discussion or video in general but when I watch a Video, I make sure to watch it to the end and give a like or dislike.

[@sharchik916]

Love all of this man. Can't wait for you totally roast our new album 😅 it's different...

[@vitaminme4203]

I enjoy how much of an honest reviewer you are and it's why I've stopped watching other channels. Certain one seems like a cool dude and all but damn he became such a sell out

[@questioneverything5595]

The problem is when you're based

[@METALBIRB]

Yeah and it happens man. I do admit when I’m based but it can happen

[@questioneverything5595]

@@METALBIRB other than the based cj video I've always loved your channel

[@questioneverything5595]

@@METALBIRB not going to quit watching your content because we disagree on one artist though.

[@Mrzachpain]

I literally cant give this vid a like!? Wtf?

[@andimatt7232]

I think that's why the reaction scene got a lot of bad rep because many - not you - are just reacting because of the views. It's really sad, I think we don't need 100000 channels with 1 blend opinion so I do appreciate your honesty.

[@marcel021065]

Its clickbait week??? Why do you make a video, talking abouth beeing honnest but use NightWish name as clickbait to get vieuws??

[@marcel021065]

@@user-nx6md1yl5c no, looks like Tank, same video same story

[@TankTheTech]

@@marcel021065 Except my video was 100% related to talking about Nightwish, and his contained about 0.5% Nightwish, but sure.

[@METALBIRB]

@@TankTheTech they’re literally proving the points I made in this vid. Let them feed the algorithm lol

[@marcel021065]

@@METALBIRB let me be helping youre aloritme, atleast i am not alone thinking you make youre video come up bij using clickbait, using the band names.. but keep reacting, nothing against youre reactions,